Minutes from AG (formerly WCAG) WG meetings

This page shows minutes of the Accessibility Guidelines Working Group. Minutes for task forces are available from their respective pages. Minutes for all groups working on WCAG 3 are available from WCAG 3 Minutes.

Minutes | Topics | Resolutions

Display information about these minutes

Showing minutes for channel(s):

Resolutions reflect general consensus of participants present in a meeting. They are not formal decisions of the group. Refer to the Decisions page for formal decisions. Context for each resolution is available via its link into the minutes.

27 February 2024: Structure with Examples https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tpgJaoIHC4IywvFkfXrfa8mEcSlEtAP-P0_46vNqynY/edit#heading=h.vc6kiqsxgozk - Explore options 2 and 3 for structure in the first subgroup and report back
13 February 2024: Outcome Language https://github.com/w3c/wcag3/discussions/49 - We will proceed with the "Technical Statement" for our first round of outcome work
16 January 2024: ACT-Rules Format 1.1 FPWD https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/3616 - Accept the updates to ACT Rules format 1.1
29 August 2023: WCAG 3 Issues - We will adopt the approach outlined in the document "Resolving WCAG 3 FPWD issues", closing them in favour new issues/discussions in the new repo
29 August 2023: Question 1 - Understanding for Contrast does not call out Color Blindness #2033 (take 3) - Accept PR 3284 to address issue 2033
29 August 2023: Question 2 - Update PDF techniques #3354 - accept amended PR 3354 to address updating PDF techniques.
29 August 2023: Question 3 - Use of Color Understanding doc: add note concerning same color case #3286 - Accept amended PR 3286 to address issue 1467
29 August 2023: Question 3 - Use of Color Understanding doc: add note concerning same color case #3286 - Accept PR 3277 to address issue 3187
22 August 2023: Question 1 - Understanding doc for 1.2.9 mentions video #1836 - Accept PR 1837 to address issue 1836.
22 August 2023: Question 2 - Non-text Contrast - Figure on background changes #2494 - Accept PR 2574 to address issue 2494
22 August 2023: Question 4 - Suggested improvement to Understanding 2.2.1: Timing Adjustable #1814 - Accept amended PR 3281 to address issue 1814.
25 July 2023: Question 1 - Success Criterion 1.4.10 Reflow - Accept amended SC 1.4.10 Reflow for WCAG2ICT wide review
25 July 2023: Question 2 - Success Criterion 1.4.11 Non-text Contrast - Accept SC 1.4.11 Non-text Contrast for WCAG2ICT wide review
25 July 2023: Question 3 - Success Criterion 2.5.1 Pointer Gestures - Accept SC 2.5.1 Pointer Gestures for WCAG2ICT wide review
25 July 2023: Question 4 - Success Criterion 4.1.3 Status Messages - Accept glossary term "style property" for WCAG2ICT wide review
25 July 2023: Question 5 - Glossary term: style property - Accept glossary term "style property" for WCAG2ICT wide review
25 July 2023: Question 6 - Glossary terms: "set of Web pages" and associated "set of" terms - Accept amended glossary terms "set of web pages" and associated "set of terms" for WCAG2ICT wide review
25 July 2023: Question 7 - Success Criterion 2.5.8 Target Size (Minimum) - Accept SC 2.5.8 Target Size (Minimum) for WCAG2ICT wide review and ask for comments and recommendations.
25 July 2023: WCAG2ICT Now what? - Take WCAG2ICT to pre-cfc, followed by CFC
27 June 2023: Question 3 - Separate techniques for Target Size #3231 - Accept amended PR 3231 to address issue 2433 and review in list
27 June 2023: Question 4 - Adding brief descriptions for all WCAG 2.0 A and AA requirements, understanding docs - Accept amended PR 3219 to add brief descriptions for all WCAG 2.0 A and AA requirements and review in list
20 June 2023: WCAG 2.x backlog issues https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag2x-backlog1/results - Agree with using the W3C decision policy
20 June 2023: Is visited link color a failure of Use of Color? #905 - Accept PR 3222 with Bruce's editorial change, adjustment to clarify the difference between visited and unvisited links and file more issues if needed
13 June 2023: Keep a custom decision policy or use the standard W3C approach - Further explore moving to the default W3C process next week
13 June 2023: Keep a custom decision policy or use the standard W3C approach - Further explore moving to the default W3C process next week
13 June 2023: C42 good for 2.5.5, not as example for 2.5.8 Target Size (Minimum) #2433 - Separate PR#3231 into two techniques and bring back for review.
13 June 2023: Add 'In brief' section at start of 2.1 SCs #3191 - Publish without the key beneficiaries, with the editorial changes suggested in the survey. Keep existing wording on "enlarging". Put in ticket to improve understanding document to include small viewports and other clarification. Revisit briefs with EO in the future.
23 May 2023: Does Target Size (Minimum) result in widespread failure of common dataviz? #3091 - Accept PR 3188 without change to limited motor control, create issues for 1) zoom recommendation and 2) one to discuss all functional needs across all issues in WCAG 2.2
23 May 2023: Accessible authentication - consider other phrase than one time password #3180 - Accept PR 3185 without Patrick's suggested edits, readdress additional edits outside of meeting as a new issue.
23 May 2023: Focus Not Obscured (Enhanced) should permit opaque overlays #3193 - Merge PR 3194 and PR 3195 with edits discussed in meeting and circulate by email for 2nd review.
23 May 2023: Clarification on 3.1.2 Language of Parts #297 - add code example, change content to "phrases, passages, and in some cases, words" and close issue. Open separate issue for examples
23 May 2023: 2.2.6: Timeouts - reference to compliance #421 - Accept PR 501. If someone finds a non-US example, please create new PR
23 May 2023: What is part of accname for Label in Name? #2302 #2276 - Continue to work on PR #2725 with Wilco and ACT's input
23 May 2023: Focus being set to the first interactive element in a dialog #2241 - Accept PR #2306, leave suggested change out
16 May 2023: Failure technique for Focus-not-obscured - Accept failure technique with edits discussed in meeting and come back with update to cover the other SC
16 May 2023: Does 2.4.12 Focus not obscured encourage a keyboard anti-pattern #2809 - Accept PR 3163 and open new issue on lightbox and on substituting pointers.
16 May 2023: Changes/corrections to 1.4.3 and 1.4.6 understanding #3020 - Accept PR 3020 with a change to use a link to images of text instead of wording around required and open an issue about the challenges on contrast
16 May 2023: Inactive components in 1.4.3 & 1.4.6 Understanding #481 - Accept PR 3020 but open an issue examining inactive, disabled, and not available.
16 May 2023: 2.5.3 Label in Name - aria-hidden on part of visual label #2302 - Accept PR 2725 but request review from ACT before merging.
16 May 2023: Updating landmark techniques - Accept PRs 2435, 2338, 1269. Alastair will email update to list for additional review
2 May 2023: WCAG 3 Editor and Working Drafts https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/working_draft_23/ - Approve moving the editor's draft content to the Working Draft
2 May 2023: WCAG 3 Editor and Working Drafts https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/working_draft_23/ - Approve moving the editor's draft content to the Working Draft
2 May 2023: 2.4.11 Focus Appearance exception doesn't match explanation #3016 - Address concern in #3016 in the understanding document
2 May 2023: Accessible Authentication failure techniques #1916 - Accept PR 2990 with comments addressed including resolving password inconsistency and circulate to group via email
25 April 2023: Adding references to cognitive SC - Accept PR 3146
25 April 2023: For 1.4.13 Content on Hover or Focus, note at bottom of Intent section should be moved up #3129 - Update the note and move to below the SC text
25 April 2023: 2.4.12 Focus not Obscured (Minimum) and user opened / controlled content #2751 - Accept PR #3083, Note 2 is updated by the text above
11 April 2023: WCAG2ICT Second Content Review Survey - Accept WCAG2ICT Content
11 April 2023: Does anyone have an issue with Moving Focus Visible back to AA? - Moving Focus Visible back to AA
11 April 2023: Add '(Minimum)' to the name of SC 3.3.8 Accessible Authentication #3087 - Add '(Minimum)' to the name of SC 3.3.8 Accessible Authentication #3087 to “Accessible Authentication (Minimum)”
11 April 2023: Programmatically Determined example describes outdated direct parsing of markup #3001 - Update the understanding document and bring proposal back to group. for Issue #3001
11 April 2023: Focus obscured understanding updates #3074 - Accept #3074 with slight wording changes
11 April 2023: Alignment of structure/wording of Target Size SCs #3086 - Resurvey this with the new wording and addressing the concern raised by Wilco regarding expanding the exception
11 April 2023: "Very similar" examples are actually "exactly the same" #2692 - Accept PR 3131
4 April 2023: WCAG 3 Review of revised conformance section survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG3_conformance_March_23/ - Accept that we are presenting pieces without a 'integrated whole', in order to further discussion with stakeholders.
4 April 2023: WCAG 3 Review of revised conformance section survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG3_conformance_March_23/ - Accept that we are presenting pieces without a 'integrated whole', in order to further discussion with stakeholders.
21 February 2023: Removing all guidelines but exemplars - Remove all guidelines except exemplars
21 February 2023: Removing all guidelines but exemplars - Use Clear Language and Error Prevention as examplars, and add in a more common exemplar if there is time and people to work on it. We will revisit how best to get the targeted public review on conformance including equity.
21 February 2023: Google - Success Criterion 2.5.8 Target Size Minimum (AA) #2704 - Accept #2972 as amended above
21 February 2023: Google - Success Criterion 2.5.8 Target Size Minimum (AA) #2704 - Accept changes to #2704
21 February 2023: Definition of target offset returns wrong results #2973 - Alastair to update and send to email list for final review. If no objections, approve closing issue #2973
21 February 2023: Target offset can be determined only with complicated mathematical methods #2974 - Accept #2974
21 February 2023: 2.5.8 Target Size (Minimum) is ambiguous for non-rectangular targets #2803 - Accept #2803 with skewed example removed and as amended. Wilco's issue will be addressed later.
21 February 2023: Private Access Tokens will impact whether or not Captchas will be needed to be done #2524 - Accept #2524
7 February 2023: agenda+ WCAG 3 Review Test Section Editor’s Draft Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/updated_editor_draft/ - Agree to move the Testing section to "developmental", with an editorial update for the conditions examples and a new editor's note to allow exploration of multiple measures in addition
7 February 2023: agenda+ WCAG 3 Review Test Section Editor’s Draft Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/updated_editor_draft/ - Agree to move the Testing section to "developmental", with an editorial update for the conditions examples and a new editor's note to allow exploration of multiple measures in addition
7 February 2023: 2.4.11 text-decoration as focus indication for links #2679 - Approve PR 2772, and closing issue 2679
7 February 2023: Google - Success Criterion 2.4.11 Focus Appearance (Level AA) #2706 - Agree with the response for #2706
7 February 2023: Google - Success Criterion 3.3.7 Accessible Authentication (Level AA) #2707 - Agree PR 2811 and close #2707
7 February 2023: Google - Success Criterion 3.3.8 Accessible Authentication (Level AAA) #2708 - Agree to accept response to #2708
7 February 2023: Success Criterion 3.2.6 Consistent Help (Level A) #2709 - Agree to response for #2709
7 February 2023: Success Criterion 2.4.12 Focus Not Obscured (Level AA) #2710 - Agree to response for ##2710
7 February 2023: Google - Success Criterion 2.4.13 Focus Not Obscured (Level AAA) #2711 - Accept response for #2711
7 February 2023: Accessible Authentication disallows Security questions #2733 - Accept response to #2733
31 January 2023: Success Criterion 2.5.7 Dragging Movements (Level AA) #2705 - Accept PR #2705 with edits to address Wilco and Gundala’s comments
31 January 2023: Add "entirely" to Example 2.4.12: Focus Not obscured #2423 - Accept PR 2802 with edits discussed in meeting
31 January 2023: Accessibility vs Security again #2702 - Accept PR 2702 with a clarification that this SC does not include an essential security exception.
31 January 2023: Privacy considerations for redundant entry #2615 - Accept PR 2615
31 January 2023: Accessible Authentication needs better techniques #1916 - Accept PR #2920 with the addition of step 2 about pasting
31 January 2023: Last Benefit 3.2.6: Consistent Help not for this SC #2413 - Accept PR 2919 and circle back about chatbot
31 January 2023: Adding an "in brief" at the start of SCs - Add “in brief” section at the start of SC with specific content will be reviewed in the future. Style to stand out in the future. Add quotes under benefits section and link to WAI resource
17 January 2023: Assertions https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/assertions-jan-12/ - Limit the documentation required to information about the assertion itself. Recommend that organizations maintain documentation on the assertions.
17 January 2023: Level Assertions Apply - Bronze level would be where most 'outcome' based requirements will go, but we are not ruling out some assertions going at bronze level
10 January 2023: Question 1 - New Rule: HTML page title is descriptive - Accept amended rule "HTML page title is descriptive
29 November 2022: Initial equity group report (15 minutes) - group will continue to work for another 4 meetings and outbrief AGWG
8 November 2022: Fall and Winter breaks https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/winter_break_22/results - Meet November 22 and 29th
8 November 2022: CSUN meeting https://www.csun.edu/cod/conference/sessions/ - Hold a hybrid meeting at CSUN on Monday March 13th
25 October 2022: PR to Decision policy - Add PR 2739 with revisions and slight rewording of first sentence
27 September 2022: Issue Severity Survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/issue-severity-post-tpac/ - Accept PR 661 (addition to the guidelines), with Gundula's additional point
27 September 2022: Issue Severity Survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/issue-severity-post-tpac/ - Accept PR 656, for the updates to methods, but removing the updates to the Requirements document
27 September 2022: ACT Survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/act-agwg-sept-2022b/ - Accept new rule - Object element rendering non-text content has non-empty accessible name
27 September 2022: Line height in style attributes is not !important - Accept rule "Line height in style attributes is not !important", ACT will look at the titles of all similar rules.
27 September 2022: New Rule: HTML graphics contain no text - Revisit 'expectations' section on this rule.
27 September 2022: Meta element has no refresh delay - Accept new rule - Meta element has no refresh delay
27 September 2022: Accept new rule - Meta viewport allows for zoom
27 September 2022: Element with aria-hidden has no content in sequential focus navigation - Accept new rule - Element with aria-hidden has no content in sequential focus navigation. Add example for svgs inside of links.
2 August 2022: Add "Evaluating Procedures" Proposal into testing section (replacing procedures) as Exploratory - Add as exploratory but bring it back in 3 weeks with updates to terminology and the editor's note
12 July 2022: Preferred starting point - The sub-group will draft initial text for the editor's draft for each proposal (separately).
7 June 2022: WCAG 3 Placeholder for User Agents and AT https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/accessibility_supported_placeholder/results - Placeholder. We will be exploring this topic in future drafts. If you have input, please [chairs will figure this out]
7 June 2022: WCAG 3 Placeholder for User Agents and AT https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/accessibility_supported_placeholder/results - Add Placeholder text for User agents and AT
7 June 2022: New rule: SVG element with explicit role has non-empty accessible name - Accept new rule: SVG element with explicit role has non-empty accessible name
7 June 2022: New Rule: headers attribute specified on a cell refers to cells in the same table element - accept New Rule: headers attribute specified on a cell refers to cells in the same table element but add new example per Mary Jo's comment and run by Mary Jo and Gregg
7 June 2022: Update Approved ACT Rules - Accept Update Approved ACT Rules with Wilco's edits to fix Mary Jo's editorial concerns
7 June 2022: Does a Technique G219 example fail Pointer Gestures? #2248 - Accept PR 2356
7 June 2022: Dragging Movements needs some attention #1917 - accept Continuing with Dragging and update the understanding document to include that it is not widely supported by operating systems but when it is, that can be used to meet this.
31 May 2022: Removing guideline details and support materials - Approve, as amended today, the Maturity table, the editor's note process, and removing guideline details and support materials
31 May 2022: WCAG 2.2 Focus appearance https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-focus-appearance-enhanced2/ - Approve the ACT Test Tools & Methodology Matrix, with some editorial changes to be applied (links and focus-handling)
31 May 2022: Separate WCAG Rules from Other ACT Rules - Separate WCAG Rules from Other ACT Rules, we will come back to the pre-amble / text explanations.
31 May 2022: Separate WCAG Rules from Other ACT Rules - Update ACT Rules Common Input Aspects
31 May 2022: Re-structure of bullets - Change "Except when" to "Exceptions"
31 May 2022: Re-structure of bullets - Change "can" to "may" in the last sentence
31 May 2022: Re-structure of bullets - Accept the structure update to focus appearance demonstrated in https://raw.githack.com/w3c/wcag/focus-appearance-structure/understanding/22/focus-appearance.html
31 May 2022: Re-structure of bullets - Move the last paragraph to above the exceptions.
24 May 2022: Question 1 - Approval to add testing section to editor's draft as exploratory - Approve adding testing section to editor's draft as exploratory with suggested changes or concerns in a note.
24 May 2022: Question 1 - Update Focus Appearance Enhanced and split Focus Not Obscured #2365 - Remove the last bullet of the exception because the 2px thickness makes it redundant
24 May 2022: Question 1 - Update Focus Appearance Enhanced and split Focus Not Obscured #2365 - Do not have an AAA version for this SC
17 May 2022: Page break locators - Understanding doc scope update #2350 - Accept updated understanding per PR 2366 with GN's correction
17 May 2022: Are online word processing and slide applications in scope #2274 - Accept response, Alastair will wrap it up at the end of the thread.
17 May 2022: Multiple overlapping elements interact oddly with offset #2159 - Accept the response and changes but trop the “Targets other than A and B…” Change the sentence to “sizes of these targets differ.”
17 May 2022: Resolving 'common' objects #2386 - No change to current wording from this proposal. Anyone who has proposed alternate wording, submit against issue for consideration.
17 May 2022: Resolving 'common' objects #2386 - Approve PR 2386 to remove the word Common
17 May 2022: Update Focus Appearance Enhanced and split Focus Not Obscured #2365 https://usercontent.irccloud-cdn.com/file/Y7Y2K3Bt/image.png - Approve splitting apart the SC, resolutions on details to follow
17 May 2022: Update Focus Appearance Enhanced and split Focus Not Obscured #2365 https://usercontent.irccloud-cdn.com/file/Y7Y2K3Bt/image.png - Leave in the exceptions
17 May 2022: Update Focus Appearance Enhanced and split Focus Not Obscured #2365 https://usercontent.irccloud-cdn.com/file/Y7Y2K3Bt/image.png - Change the first bullet to "Encloses the visual presentation of the user interface component and is no thinner than 2 CSS pixels".
3 May 2022: Question 1 - Adjacent contrast - Accept normative change of PR 2341 to address issue 2333.
3 May 2022: Question 3 - Bounding box for separated links #2323 - Update the normative change to the SC, do not accept the changes to definition
3 May 2022: Question 1 - SC2.4.13 Page break locators technique #1226 - Accept amended PR 2130 to address issue 1226.
3 May 2022: Question 2 - Are CSS break-before/after indicators page break locators? #2259 - reject the proposed definition change
26 April 2022: Should we leave in critical errors? - Remove ratings, critical errors, and scorings. Add editor's note similar to Critical errors was introduced as a concept in the FPWD. Although it not currently included, AGWG intends to re-asses this concept in the future.
26 April 2022: Should we leave in critical errors? - Remove ratings, critical errors, and scorings. Add editor's note similar to Critical errors was introduced as a concept in the FPWD. Although it not currently included, AGWG intends to re-asses this concept in the future.
26 April 2022: What are outstanding questions on the new approach? - Accept new questions in the survey, accept editorial content from the survey, add an outstanding question of whether to use "test" or "evaluation", add a question of "How tolerant are we of we of subjective tests and Should any test be not objective?
26 April 2022: Pursue or remove - We will try one last time but if no quick consensus next week, we will drop for 2.2
26 April 2022: bounding box defintion - GN will create an issue for the bounding box definition
26 April 2022: Against adjacent colors - Accept the understanding document update and survey Adjacent Colors, normative change of word "instead", and exception language (assuming we haven't surveyed them recently, if surveyed recently it will move to an issue)
19 April 2022: Out-of-viewport content #2204 - Accept response https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/2204#issuecomment-1096984939
19 April 2022: Updated understanding document for "encloses" - Approve the change to use "Encloses" and "adjacent colors" in the SC text.
19 April 2022: Updated understanding document for "encloses" - Approve the proposed update for "Minimum bounding box" definition.
19 April 2022: Updated understanding document for "encloses" - Include the proposed note on using declared values, on line 44 of the diff.
12 April 2022: Question 2 - Replace "encompasses" with "encloses" - Replace "encompasses" with "encloses" for Focus Appearance
5 April 2022: Risk of not pursuing WCAG 3 - Continue working on WCAG 3
29 March 2022: WCAG 2.2 Visual Controls https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-visible-controls/ - Accept response and PR
22 March 2022: User Interface Component (UIC) measure as visual basis - Accept the visual display of the UIC as part of the assessment for Focus Appearance, with 1 objection that visual is not the correct approach
22 March 2022: User Interface Component (UIC) measure as visual basis - Accept the visual display of the UIC as part of the assessment for Focus Appearance
22 March 2022: Note on sub-components / active descendants - Add Wilco's text previously discussed into the SC text
22 March 2022: Not including the 1px perimiter metric - Add the 1px perimeter metric to the exception
22 March 2022: Definition of Encompasses - Accept shorter definition with 1 objection and a concern about handling focus on the whole page
8 March 2022: ACT Update (Wilco) - Approve the ACT update to go to CFC if there are no objections via email
8 March 2022: WCAG 3 Requirements Survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG3_requirements/ - Alastair will refine the question and pose the updated question to the group for later review.
8 March 2022: Question 2 - Revising true/false statement - Review existing PR and review proposed response later.
1 March 2022: WCAG 3 Protocols and Scoping Next Steps https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1b5xHQWBzoYdKp7BfPgIUBCpz-yaDOx_kSq_HlQxcFh0/ - Group agrees to explore this direction, working on the next steps from the presentation
1 March 2022: Examples provided are not enough #1443 - Accept PR 2200
1 March 2022: Explicitly say that this mechanism is visible #2072 - Accept response to #2072
22 February 2022: Focus appearance and User-agents, again - Move forward with SC with an exception in the principle of "The focus indicator and its background color are determined by the user agent and are not modified by the author." or "The focus indicator is defined by the user-agent and cannot be adjusted by the author."
15 February 2022: 1. Status Level Names - Accept status level names
15 February 2022: 1. Status Level Names - Accept the levels assigned to the working draft
8 February 2022: Question 1 - 2.1 Readable - Discuss the intent, and revisit a response later.
8 February 2022: Question 2 - 2.2 Measurable Guidance - Suggest update as drafted in IRC and bring proposal back to Silver for wordsmithing in that taskforce.
8 February 2022: Question 1 - Change of context definition - Accept PR 1765 as an errata to alter the "Change of Context" definition
8 February 2022: Question 2 - Visible Controls clarifications and a user-agent example #1905 - Accept amended response to address issue 1905
1 February 2022: Conflicting Goals #484 - Change repsonse to language at 11:20, detlev to add his comment to github issue
1 February 2022: Introduction: Explain how to solve Issue #41 - accept amended PR and revisit larger issue after Jake has proposed wording
1 February 2022: Recommended viewport size for testing? #1829 - Approve revised wording from 23 after the hour.
25 January 2022: WCAG 3 Requirements https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG3_requirements/ - Accept amended PR #586
25 January 2022: Scope of Guidelines #326 - Accept Rachael's response to address issue 326
18 January 2022: Question 1 - 380 - Question on Clear Words Revised - Accept amended response to address issue 380, and tag with input-for-future-version
18 January 2022: Question 2 - 169 - Consider "accessible name" instead of "alternative text" - Accept Alastair's response to address issue 169 and send back to the team working on text alternatives for additional review
18 January 2022: Question 2 - 169 - Consider "accessible name" instead of "alternative text" - Accept Alastair's response to address issue 169 and send back to the team working on text alternatives for additional review
18 January 2022: Question 3 - 257- Meaningful Text Alternatives - Return the issue to the team working on the response, and consider an adjective, and consider separating requirements.
18 January 2022: Question 4 - 457 - ITI Comments on flexible conformance - Accept amended responses to address issue 457, and tag issue as input-for-refinement
18 January 2022: Question 4 - 457 - ITI Comments on flexible conformance - Accept amended responses to address issue 457, and tag issue as input-for-refinement
18 January 2022: Size basis for focus-appearance - Carry on with the current approach, focused on 'component', tweaking the SC text to make clearer the basis for size.
11 January 2022: Announcements and Reminders - revisit this when we move into CR or 3 months, whichever comes first
11 January 2022: Announcements and Reminders - revisit this when we move into CR or 3 months, whichever comes first
11 January 2022: Focus Appearance complexity #1842 - Accept note as ammende and survey AWK's suggestion with last bullet back in next week
4 January 2022: Question 1 - 256 - Clear Words vs Plain Language - Accept the amended response to address issue 256
4 January 2022: Question 2 - 359 - Measuring words question - Accept the amended response to address issue 359
4 January 2022: Question 1 - “Conformance Criterion” instead of “Conformance Requirement” used in the WCAG 2.1 Glossary #1758 - Address issue 1758 by amending and updating PR for WCAG 2.2 and include an errata in 2.1
4 January 2022: Question 2 - Incomplete/no techniques #1813 - Accept PR 2131 to address issue 1813
4 January 2022: Question 3 - Problems with WCAG 2.0 Flash Definition #553 - Accept amended PR 2127 to address issue 553 and 585
21 December 2021: WCAG 2.2 Page break navigation (Q1 only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-page-break-nav/ - Accept PR 2160 to address issue 2155, there will still be conversations regarding keeping or dropping this sc.
21 December 2021: Question 1 - Focus appearance and user-agents - Carry on with the SC as it is and provide guidance in understandings that browsers can fulfill the SC if you test it, with 1 objection requesting including a default indication. C
21 December 2021: Question 1 - Focus appearance and user-agents - Carry on with the SC as it is and provide guidance in understandings that browsers can fulfill the SC if you test it, with 1 objection requesting including a default focus indicator.
21 December 2021: Question 2 - Using target-area as the basis for size metrics - We love Wilco
21 December 2021: Question 3 - Insufficient requirement for focus indication via enlargement #1858 - Accept amended response from Alastair and David to address issue 1858.
7 December 2021: Review Writing Testable WCAG 3.0 Outcomes Survey - AGWG approves amended Writing Testable WCAG 3.0 Outcomes for internal use
7 December 2021: Question 1 - Form field has non-empty accessible name - Accept publishing "Form field has non-empty accessible name"
7 December 2021: Question 2 - Attribute has valid value - Accept "Attribute has valid value"
7 December 2021: Question 2 - Attribute has valid value - Accept "Attribute has valid value"
7 December 2021: Question 3 - Element marked as decorative is not exposed - Accept amended "Element marked as decorative is not exposed"
7 December 2021: Question 4 - Letter spacing in style attributes is not important - Accept "Letter spacing in style attributes is not important"
7 December 2021: Question 5 - Word spacing in style attributes is not important - Accept "Word spacing in style attributes is not important"
3 December 2021: Dragging Movements needs some attention #1917 - Carry on with SC
3 December 2021: Adobe Comment on 2.5.7 Dragging Movements #1886 - Accept PR 1961 as amended by the text above
3 December 2021: Is keyboard functionality acceptable if an on-screen keyboard can be used. #1978 - Accept PR 2009
3 December 2021: Exception for web content used by the author but generated by the user agent? #1977 - Agreed response to #1977
3 December 2021: Does the Definition of "Dragging Movements" Intentionally Limit the Scope to Moving Objects/Items? #1560 - Accept the amened PR, knowing that the document will be further reviewed soon.
3 December 2021: Exceptions seems like free form paths rather than dragging #1979 - Remove the example from the understanding document.
3 December 2021: Further guidance on 2-factor independent methods #1965 - accept PR as amended by survey comments
3 December 2021: Google feedback #1890 - Accept the response to 1890 and update the definition as amended
3 December 2021: Page break navigation https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-page-break-nav/results - accept PR 1226 as is
3 December 2021: Overly prescriptive? #2026 - Accept response and add a link to the word “mechanism” in the SC and plan epub requirements discussion for 3.0
3 December 2021: Update page-break-navigation.html #2094 - Accept response, revisit the word “page” as used in this SC with Epub contribution or add a note to clarify what page means here.
3 December 2021: Update page-break-navigation.html #2094 - Accept PR with amendments as discussed
3 December 2021: Visible controls re-write - accepting this PR And including suggestions on how and where as part of understanding but not requiring it
3 December 2021: The first exception is difficult to understand #1760 - Accept response
3 December 2021: Subjective judgement is needed #1877 - accept response
3 December 2021: Understanding doc updates - Accept PR
3 December 2021: Controls that require scrolling to reach #1875 - Accept PR
3 December 2021: Clarify "available for the user to select." #1973 - Accept PR as ammended
3 December 2021: Remove explanation of help mechanisms #1881 - Accept PR as amended in survey
3 December 2021: Clarify situations where some pages in set provide no help #1972 - Accept PR
3 December 2021: Questions to resolve for consistent testing #2068 - Accept PR but keep question of SC text open until we look at other PRs
3 December 2021: Wording is perhaps confusing #2098 - accept PR 2145 as amended to close Issue 2098 and 1693
30 November 2021: Request to change web to digital in Abstract - Reject PR and send response as amended; then explore clarifying web based technology (possibly with W3C) and apply it throughout
30 November 2021: Name Change #1871 - Accept response with Mike Gower's amendment
30 November 2021: Using "should" in the Understanding doc is confusing #1874 - Accept PR and discuss wording choices further in a future meeting.
30 November 2021: Google feedback #1894 - Accept PR and response as amended.
30 November 2021: Adding diagrams that make the reality/consequences of target offset clearer #1848 - Accept the PR with the removal of last part of 103 (see survey) and Todd will take a last look at optimizing the experience between alt text and fig caption content.
30 November 2021: Dragging Movements needs some attention #1917 - Accept PR but add issue to give this PR more attention including the challenges that Mgower raises.
23 November 2021: Request to add a target increase in level of effort - Don't add to requirements document but schedule a conversation about the holistic cost of WCAG 3 after we make more progress (add to WCAG 3 schedule after conformance decisions for future discussion)
23 November 2021: Common Input Aspects note - Accept note as ammended
23 November 2021: Element with lang attribute has valid language tag - approve publishing Element with lang attribute has valid language tag
23 November 2021: Element with lang attribute has valid language tag - approve publishing Element with lang attribute has valid language tag
23 November 2021: Further Examples Required #1872 - Accept PR and response for 1872 as ammended
23 November 2021: Align Target Size (min) with Target Size (enh) #1721 - Accept PR for #1721
23 November 2021: Is "24 by 24 CSS pixels” reasonable? #1831 - accept response to 1831 as amended
23 November 2021: Minimum Component Size #1870 - Accept response to #1870 as ammended, and follow up on spacing issues raised by Abi
16 November 2021: Does the Silver scope covers closed systems / kiosk UIs? - Respond with "WCAG 3.0 could be useful for the web-based portion of closed systems that utilize web technologies, but it would not tackle issues around the physical aspects or user-agents of those systems."
16 November 2021: Backwards Compatibility Question - adopt updated response https://github.com/w3c/silver/issues/424#issuecomment-966166500
16 November 2021: Target Size addition of user agent and equivalent exceptions #1993 - Use proposed wording, add to understanding, and create an issue to explore the use of "not modified by author"
16 November 2021: Issue 1976 and same PR - The function can be acheived through a different control on the same page that has an area of at least 24 by 24 CSS pixels;
9 November 2021: Process approval survey - placeholder content will require WG approval, to be sought asynchronously, and any content that does not get asynch approval will be discussed. Chairs take an action to bring back asynchronous options with feedback from COGA so the working group can select an option for asynchronous decision making
9 November 2021: Process approval survey - Try out adding all levels of content to editor's draft using working group agreement (asynchronous for placeholder if possible, survey+meeting for placeholder when needed and for all other levels) and to the working draft using working group agreement+CFC , with full level markings and warnings and then revisit this in a few months to see how its working. We will explore filtering within the editor's draft as part of this
9 November 2021: Difficult to understand meaning #1840 - Rework to address concerns raised outside of meeting and resurvey
9 November 2021: Confirmation on navigation menus #1845 - Accept ammended response (Gregg's suggestion added)
2 November 2021: Use of the word “state” is not sufficiently consistent #2049 - Adopt the revised wording "Contrast: The area has a contrast ratio of at least 3:1 between the colors when the component is focused and when not focused
2 November 2021: Focus indicators for large editing areas #2017 - Adopt PR with slight addition to be made by Mike to explain insertion point
2 November 2021: Exception may not align with understanding text #1980 - Accept PR 1990 and adjust other areas as needed
26 October 2021: Whether to require working group agreement to add placeholder content - placeholder content will require WG approval, to be sought asynchronously, and any content that does not get asynch approval will be discussed. Chairs take an action to bring back asynchronous options with feedback from COGA so the working group can select an option for asynchronous decision making
19 October 2021: What is a complex shape? #2050 - Accept revised wording and add circular focus examples to understand doc
19 October 2021: Focus indicators for large editing areas #2017 - Agree that we don't think this is an issue but need additional text around defining UI component
19 October 2021: Focus appearance should be in Perceivable - Leave focus appearnance operable
19 October 2021: Focus appearance should be in Perceivable - Leave focus appearance in operable
19 October 2021: Focus appearance should be in Perceivable - Leave focus appearance in operable
19 October 2021: Need more info on adjacent contrast #1929 - Accept the updates in PR2060 and 2097
12 October 2021: Question 1 - Inline elements that wrap over multiple lines #1328 - Accept PR 2040 to address issue #1328 and consider a failure technique in the future
21 September 2021: WCAG 2.2 Accessible Authentication (Q1-2) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-accessibile-auth/results - Accept the updates to AA and AAA SC and understanding documents for Accessible Authentication as in PR 2046
21 September 2021: Note for WCAG 2.2 - Accept Alastair's proposed text.
21 September 2021: Update Technique G195 procedure #1931 - Accept technique update with Patrick's edits and changing the color from red to another color
21 September 2021: Make clearer the method of calculating the minimum area #1883 - Accept the response
21 September 2021: Sizing impresise and fairly complicated #1718 - accept the proposed response and keep "perimeter"
14 September 2021: Question 1 - Recognizing common objects path forward - to propose a AA level SC that allows for recognizing common ob
14 September 2021: Question 1 - Google feedback - Accept amended response to address issue 1896.
7 September 2021: WCAG 2.2 focus-appearance: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-focus-appearance-enhanced2/results - to accept the proposed updates with suggested edits and address substantive issues in new SC
7 September 2021: Confusing wording due to unconventional state requirement #1859 - Accept proposed response and PR
7 September 2021: 4. Gradient Focus Indicators #1861 - Accept proposed response to #1861
7 September 2021: 2. Understanding document updates - Accept PR2000
31 August 2021: Merge AGWG and Silver after delivery of WCAG 2.2 - Approve merging groups after WCAG 2.2 moves to horizontal review (Additional details to be worked out including how to handle the community group, how to address ATAG and UAAG content within the charter and WCAG 3 process, and meeting schedules)
24 August 2021: Approach to publishing WCAG 3 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/approach/results - adopt Proposed steps: 1. Publish the current work (new guideline plus user generated comment, and explainer and note) in September. 2. One (or more) goal-based milestones related to conformance and some critical mass of draft guidelines/outcomes.
17 August 2021: Error Prevention guideline and associated methods - Move amended Error Prevention Guideline to CFC for addition to the next update of WCAG 3.
17 August 2021: Editors Note about Approach - Slip next WCAG 3 heartbeat to mid-September.
17 August 2021: Question 1 - Consistent Help note doesn't make sense to me #1924 - Accepted as amended
17 August 2021: Question 2 - Success Criterion 3.2.6 Consistent Help (A) #1892 - Accept amended PR 1968 and response to address issue 1892.
17 August 2021: Question 2 - Ensuring single transactions (from the user's perspective) are covered #1880 - Accept amended option 1 and PR 1992, scope in 3rd party providers
17 August 2021: Question 3 - Does redundant entry require saving PII? #1843 - Accept Alastair's response to address issue 1843
17 August 2021: Question 1 - Are pages with print CSS that includes page breaks excepted? #1868 - Accept response to issue 1868
17 August 2021: Question 2 - Is EPUB Web Content? #1869 - Accept amended PR 1994 to address issue 1869
17 August 2021: Question 3 - Google feedback - Accept amended proposed response to address issue 1869
17 August 2021: Question 4 - What is and is not programmatically determined #1969 - Accept amended PR 1995 to address issue 1969
10 August 2021: CSUN meeting (survey, 5 minutes) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/csun_2022/results - probably no, reevaluate in December
10 August 2021: Glossary Definition of User Generated Content - Move the amended User Generated Content section to CFC for addition in the next update of WCAG 3.
10 August 2021: Glossary Definition of User Generated Content - Accept: The publisher in this definition is the owner of the website providing content, not the owner of a paid platform used for website creation.
10 August 2021: Glossary Definition of User Generated Content - Accept sending amended glossary definition with editors note to CFC for inclusion in the next version of WCAG 3
3 August 2021: Explainer note https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/2021-07-Explainer-Note/ - Move the modified WCAG3 Explainer to CFC for addition to the next update of WCAG3 as a first draft of what will be a Working Group Note, including a yet to be agreed upon note calling out the various moving parts.
3 August 2021: Question 1 - Minimum Area clarification #1806 - Accept PR 1966 to address issue 1806
3 August 2021: Question 2 - Browser default focus indicators #1854 - Accept Alastair's response to address issue 1854
3 August 2021: Question 3 - Gradient Backgrounds #1862 - Accept update to PR 1967 and response to address issue 1862
3 August 2021: Question 1 - Consistent Help note doesn't make sense to me #1924 - Leave the note and update the understanding document
27 July 2021: Error Methods Prevention Guideline - Move the Guideline to CFC after the link is fixed, placeholders are added, and "Outcome:" is added to template.
27 July 2021: Approval to move ACT/Silver Method Proposal to CFC - Move the proposed ACT structure (not content) to CFC for use going forward [12:01]
27 July 2021: Approval to move ACT/Silver Method Proposal to CFC - Move the proposed ACT structure (not content) to CFC for use going forward [12:01]
27 July 2021: "the value of spacing" confusing wording #1852 - Accept PR 1853
27 July 2021: Adobe Comment #1889 - Accept as amended
27 July 2021: User-agent components that can't be styled #1904 - Accept as amended<strong>Necessary:</strong> A particular presentation of the target is essential or is legally required for the information being conveyed;</li>
20 July 2021: Question 1 - Adobe Comment on 3.3.7 Accessible Authentication #1885 - Accept updated response to address issue 1885
20 July 2021: Question 2 - Add requirement / control to "show password" for end-users #1912 - Accept amended PR 1940 to address issue 1912
20 July 2021: Question 3 - Ensuring copy-paste is not blocked #1878 - Accept PR 1960 to address issue 1878
20 July 2021: Question 1 - Undefined term to define a term, and needs to clarify #1927 - Accept amended PR 1962 to address issue 1927
13 July 2021: Concerns about 3rd party - For next heartbeat publication, concentrate on user generated content only. Discuss how authoring tools can prompt or fix. Save paid content and services for further discussion. Name "User generated" vs "End user generated" to be decided in the future.
13 July 2021: Concerns about 3rd party - For next heartbeat publication, concentrate on user generated content only. Discuss how authoring tools can prompt or fix. Save paid content and services for further discussion. Name "User generated" vs "End user generated" to be decided in the future. Reference IRC chat for conversation.
13 July 2021: "single pointer" definition not quite accurate? #749 - Accept PR 809
13 July 2021: 'Headings' are enough to pass 2.4.1: Bypass Blocks #1712 - Accept PR 1946
13 July 2021: is it acceptable to only support niche, propriety, OS specific, and potentially inaccessible methods? #1899 - Accept revised response https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/1899#issuecomment-866716764
13 July 2021: Are system-level tests out of scope? Are PINs and Passwords synonymous? #1900 - Accept https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/1900#issuecomment-861909232 and https://github.com/w3c/wcag/pull/1909/files
13 July 2021: supporting copy-paste, example with memorable information, and specific characters #1901 - accept response https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/1901#issuecomment-868693998
13 July 2021: Clarification on USB-based 2FA #1903 - Accept response https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/1903#issuecomment-868707632
6 July 2021: Question 2 - Do the 'Dynamic Examples' satisfy WCAG 1.4.11? #1670 - Accept PR 1672 to address issue 1670
6 July 2021: Question 1 - confusion about "paste" #1855 - accept amended PR 1898 to address issue 1855
6 July 2021: Question 2 - Other Methods #1879 - Accept response to address issue 1879
29 June 2021: "Changes of color" applied to motion definition #1535 - Motion animation does not include changes in an element's color, blurring or opacity, where the change does not alter the perceived size, shape, or position of the object.
29 June 2021: "Changes of color" applied to motion definition #1535 - Motion animation does not include changes in an element's color, blurring, or opacity where the change does not alter the perceived size, shape, or position of the object.
29 June 2021: "Changes of color" applied to motion definition #1535 - Update both
29 June 2021: Carousels fail 2.2.1: Timing Adjustable? #1658 - Amended PR 1688 to address Issue 1658.
22 June 2021: Question 2 - Can text buttons fail 1.1.1 and 3.3.2? #985 - Accept amended PR 1568 to address issue 985
8 June 2021: Reporting in 3.0 discussion - Gather more tests, etc then revisit in1-2 months to see if a subgroup can work on it
1 June 2021: Question 1 - 1. Target size understanding review #1770 - Accept amended PR 1770.
1 June 2021: Question 1 - 1. Target size understanding review #1770 - Accept amended PR 1770
1 June 2021: Question 1 - 1. Target size understanding review #1770 - Accept the draft response for issue #930
1 June 2021: Question 1 - 1. Target size understanding review #1770 - Accept Rain's amended draft response for issue #930
1 June 2021: Question 3 - Update benefits of 2.5.1 pointer gestures #747 - Accept PR 1569 to address issue 747
1 June 2021: Question 4 - Text spacing: does it require compatibility with one or all methods? #975 - Accept amended PR 1687 to address issue 975
25 May 2021: Question 1 - Text spacing, "setting all of the following" to "any" (NORMATIVE) #930 - The intent of the SC was to set all 4 simultaneously. We will not change, and we will review the proposed response at a later date.
11 May 2021: Continue next steps and WCAG 3.0 discussion - Work through headings as a group and then figure out next steps
11 May 2021: Errata on contrast variable https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG22-Misc-items/ - Accept amended PR 1780 to address issues 1213 and 360
4 May 2021: WCAG 3.0 topics survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Follow-on-topics/ (60 min) - Use the WCAG 3 FPWD scope to views and processes and better define both.
29 April 2021: Testing objectivity - For WCAG 3, testing will aim to improve intertester reliability and will work on testing to determine this
29 April 2021: Which tests to include in conformance - For WCAG 3, testing will aim to improve intertester reliability and will work on testing to measure this
29 April 2021: Session 3 - Conformance - We support a simpler on ramp below bronze that is not conformance, and will explore this further later
29 April 2021: Session 3 - Conformance - The maturity model may be published as a separate document.
27 April 2021: 264 - Accept the updated responses & PR
27 April 2021: New technique for new contrast formula (threshold value) #1213 - Create (proposed) editorial errata that updates value, update G18 to include new value (for WCAG 2.0/1/2) with note that says "Prior to May 2021 there was a different value..."
27 April 2021: Understanding 1.4.3 and 1.4.6 should refer to 1.4.11 #1261 - Accept PR and close issue
20 April 2021: #507 Email: Siteimprove Comments on WCAG 3.0 Draft (1 - The proposal fundamentally alters the way in which WCAG is tested) - Close 495, Leave 507 open, close 510 and 458 to either a milestone or ovearching issue to track
20 April 2021: WCAG 2.2 Redundent entry (Q1 only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-redundant-entry-updates/results - Move forward with concept of version 2
20 April 2021: WCAG 2.2 Redundent entry (Q1 only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-redundant-entry-updates/results - adjust the language to Except when with bulleted list
20 April 2021: Target size (Q1) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-target-spacing-issues/results - Accept this updated understanding. Create a new PR with an additional map example using pins, additional measurement example, Rain and Michael's suggested edits and creating an issue on maps as an exception for future discussion
13 April 2021: WCAG 2.x issues https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG22-Misc-items/ - Reject this PR and explore other solutions, perhaps an errata
13 April 2021: WCAG 2.x issues https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG22-Misc-items/ - Reject this PR and explore other solutions, perhaps an errata
13 April 2021: Decision Policy - Move Decision Policy to CFC with proposed removals
6 April 2021: Focus appearance survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-focus-appearance-updates/results - Accept the amended updates to the SC Text and understanding document for Focus Appearance
6 April 2021: The math is difficult to understand and explain #1439 - Accept the proposed response to address issue #1439
6 April 2021: Target size/spacing (Q1 only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-target-spacing-issues/results - Agree with the updated and amended SC text for Pointer Target Spacing
30 March 2021: WCAG 2.2 Target size/spacing (Q1 only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-target-spacing-issues/results - Use "target offset" and work on definition via email list for next week
30 March 2021: Fixed reference points https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-fixed-ref-points-updates/results - Accept MG's suggestion to change title to "Page Break Navigation", and to update response accordingly
30 March 2021: Tal Persona - Use TAL's name and no pronouns for TAL, and to not create a pronoun statement.
16 March 2021: Focus appearance enh https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-focus-appearance-enhanced/results - Accept amended PR 1623 to facilitate Focus Appearance Enhanced more closely matching the AA version.
16 March 2021: Focus appearance enh https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-focus-appearance-enhanced/results - Accept amended PR 1623 to facilitate Focus Appearance Enhanced more closely matching the AA version.
16 March 2021: Dragging update https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-dragging-issues/results - Accept amended PR 1649 to update the cross reference of Dragging / gestures
16 March 2021: Visible controls https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/hidden-controls-12-2020/results - Accept amended PR 1648 to update the examples for visible controls
9 March 2021: Member driven agenda additions - Adjust meeting to add introducation and announcements, no more than 5 minutes
9 March 2021: AG Decision policy update https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ag-decision-policy-update2/results - Rework this content and bring back.
9 March 2021: Renaming Findable Help - Change name to Consistent Help
9 March 2021: Make changes to SC text - Accept proposed wording: For each web page within a set of web pages that provides one or more of following ways of finding help, access to at least one form of help is included in the same relative order on each page
9 March 2021: Findable Help - Goal of Criterion Ambiguous #1435 - Accept response and pull request with discussed revisions
9 March 2021: Responding to Issue 1148 clarifying questions and suggestions - Accept the response along with text from mgower
9 March 2021: Adding exception for continuous regions - Accept adding a note instead of an exception. Wording above.
9 March 2021: Add exception for equivalent functions - Do not include an exception for equialent functions but address in understanding
9 March 2021: Add exception for equivalent functions - Do not include an exception for equialent functions but address in understanding
9 March 2021: Changing the name of the SC - Rename the new SC to Target Size (Minimum); Rename 2.5.5 Target Size (Enhanced)
9 March 2021: Changing the name of the SC - Rename the new SC to Target Size (Minimum); Rename 2.5.5 Target Size (Enhanced)
2 March 2021: Updated SC text for closing issues (revised again) - Accept the amended update and response to address issues 1361, 1381, 1384, 1433 and 1444 and create a new issue for sliders
2 March 2021: Rewording Findable Help to address scoping questions - Agree with Bruce's amended rewording to address issues 1436 and 1367
2 March 2021: Re-name the SC? - Keep the name the same
2 March 2021: Google feedback #1453 - Accept amended PR 1639 to address the suggestions, and accept the response to address issue 1453
2 March 2021: Adjust process definition example - Accept PR 1640 and response to address issue 1453
2 March 2021: Re-entry and security #1346 and #1431 - Accept the proposed response to address issues 1346 and 1431
23 February 2021: Updated SC text for closing issues - Merge changes, bring back with new understanding doc updates, prior to CFC
23 February 2021: Minimum pointer clearance needs better empirical backing #1445 - Accept the amended response to address issue #1445
23 February 2021: Google feedback #1456 - Accept amended draft response to address issue #1456
23 February 2021: Re-entry and security #1346 and #1431 - Leave SC text as it is
16 February 2021: Question 2 - Google feedback #1451 - Accept amended draft response and PR 1624 to address issue 1451.
16 February 2021: Question 3 - Suggest including the first note AAA as well. #1405 - Accept PR 1625 to address issue 1405
16 February 2021: Question 4 - C41 does not fulfil SC 2.4.12 #1306 - Accept PR 1626 to address issue 1306
16 February 2021: Question 5 - Update G195 - Accept PR 1627 to update technique G195
16 February 2021: Question 1 - The term "minimum focus indicator area" is confusing #1544 - Reject PR 1628, leave SC and modify the understanding document, to be reviewed in call later.
16 February 2021: Question 1 - Change "Operated" to "Achieved" - Accept Michael Gower's recommended change of "Operated" to "Achieved", and create issue that requests erratum for 2.5.1.
16 February 2021: Question 2 - Dragging and its reference to single pointer #1225 (take 2) - Accept draft response and PR 1636 to address issue 1225, and Sarah Horton will provide new PR with additional improvements.
9 February 2021: Dragging and its reference to single pointer #1225 - Keep the definition as is, amend PR to update understanding, and draft new response.
9 February 2021: Dragging - essential example #1336 - accept ""There may be cases where a dragging movement is essential, for example, drawing a free-form figure, or playing a game where the aim is to follow a particular path as accurately as possible."
9 February 2021: Google feedback on dragging #1454 - Accept draft response to address issue 1454.
9 February 2021: WCAG 2.2 Accessible authentication (Q1 only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-accesssible-auth-updates/results - Accept PR 1611 and response to address issue 1256 with the sentences swapped
9 February 2021: WCAG 2.2 Visible controls (Q1 only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/hidden-controls-12-2020/results - Add a sentence clarifying that the other SC apply and Rain will craft updates for issue 1455 and team will review in a subsequent call.
9 February 2021: UPDATED: Google feedback on Fixed Reference Points #1449 - Accept response and work on understanding and page break locator terminology
9 February 2021: "on the same page" #1302 - Accept previous resolution as solution to this issue.
2 February 2021: Silver requirements updates survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/2020-01-silver-requirements-update/results - Take Detlev's proposal back, request comment from people who requested the change.
2 February 2021: AG decision policy update https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ag-decision-policy-update/results - Update policy again, return soon
2 February 2021: Visible controls https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/hidden-controls-12-2020/results - Accept the new text from the mailing list
2 February 2021: Using 'controls' in the SC text again - No change
2 February 2021: Update to the note - Use "User interface components can be available through other visible components such as sub-menus, edit buttons, tabs, or thumbnails of media."
2 February 2021: Fixed Reference Point wrap up https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-fixed-ref-points-updates/results - Accept new text
26 January 2021: Question 1 - Redundant entry, term "step" is ambiguous #1345 - Update PR 1597 and update draft response to remove "step" to address issue #1345
26 January 2021: Question 2 - Comment from IBM: Redundant Entry needs to be more tightly scoped in the SC language - Accept PR 1487 to address issue #1410
26 January 2021: Question 3 - 3.3.8: Redundant entry - session term #1335 - Accept Alastair's response to address issue #1335
26 January 2021: Question 4. Redundant entry - Accept amended response to address issue #1446
26 January 2021: Question 1 - New version: Visible Controls - Accept amended SC change and note using the word "component" uniformly.
19 January 2021: Updating the size metric - Accept change to minimum area
19 January 2021: Must a focus indicator always be displayed? #1387 - Continue with wording in Focus Appearance that addresses sticky footer
19 January 2021: Understanding 2.4.11 minimum area - focused/unfocused? #1552 - Accept PR 1577
19 January 2021: 2.4.11 Unobscured bullet will fail the common chatboxes widgets #1502 - Accept the response for #1502
19 January 2021: Adjacent contrast and unobscured clauses #1399 - Accept the response for #1399
19 January 2021: Adjacent contrast and unobscured clauses #1399 - Accept the response for #1399
19 January 2021: A point for the Understanding doc #1227 - Accept PR 1579
5 January 2021: WCAG 3.0 objection update Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/2020-12-editorsnote/ - Accept the proposed Editor's note in WCAG 3 FPWD on inclusion
5 January 2021: Notable Contributions Section and Editor's Note - Accept the amended "Notable Contributions Section and Editor's Note"
5 January 2021: Question 1 - Updates to G183 remove the focus step in the procedure - Accept the response and amended PR and close issues 1118 and 1272
5 January 2021: Question 2 - Clarity for 1.3.3: Sensory Characteristics needed #1532 - Accept Alastair's amended update to second example in PR 1571
5 January 2021: Question 1 - Some suggested editorial changes for clarity Issue #1462 - Accept Alastair's proposed response to issue #1462
5 January 2021: Question 2 - Does this SC really apply to "single page" web applications? #1427 - Accept Alastair's proposed response to issue #1427
15 December 2020: Use of color & contrast survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-color-updates/results - Create new issue to fix the gap in Example 1 which does not fully support screenreader users
15 December 2020: Use of color & contrast survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-color-updates/results - Accept PR 767 to address issues #750 and #1532
15 December 2020: Note and benefits contradict each other in 1.4.1 #1032 - Accept PR 1500 to address issues #1032, #1076 and #1370
8 December 2020: December 22nd Meeting - Last meeting of 2020 is on the 15th, 1st meeting 2021 is Jan 5th.
1 December 2020: Response to #1437 - Accept the suggested response from Scha14 to address issue #1437
1 December 2020: Response to #1367 about "Set of Web Pages" - Update response to issue #1367 and include additional examples in understanding docs, and review in a subsequent meeting.
1 December 2020: Question 4 - Response to #1434 - Accept the amended suggested response from Alastair to address issue #1434
1 December 2020: Question 5 - Response to #1394 - Accept the amended suggested response from Alastair to address issue #1394
1 December 2020: Question 6 - Understanding update to address #1347 and #1368 - Accept the amended suggested response from Alastair, and update PR #1538 to address issues #1347 and #1368
1 December 2020: Question 7 - Group of changes together #1242 - Follow up with Guy Hickling on the amended proposed text, and disregard PR.
1 December 2020: New formulation of the SC text - Accept Michael Gower's amended update to the SC text, with additional note per David MacDonald
24 November 2020: Focus appearance (question 1 only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-focus-appearance-updates/ - Accept PR.
10 November 2020: Question 1 - Add mechanism text #1418 - Accept the suggested text available in PR 1505 to address issue #1418.
10 November 2020: Question 2 - Accessible Authentication #1318 - Accept Alastair's modified draft response to issue #1318
10 November 2020: Question 3 - Clarify whether copy/paste is a cognitive function test #1359 - Accept the accepted change in PR 1419 to address issue #1359
10 November 2020: Question 4 - Far too fundamentally restrictive for a Level A #1364 - Accept Alastair's draft response to issue #1364
10 November 2020: Question 5 - Concerns and clarifications #1470 - Accept Alastair's draft response to issue #1470
10 November 2020: Question 6 - Conflict with legal and contractual obligations #1430 - Accept Alastair's draft response to issue #1430
10 November 2020: Question 7 - Feedback from Google #1452 - Accept Alastair's draft response to issue #1452 and accept PR 1508.
10 November 2020: Question 1 - Must a focus indicator always be displayed? #1387 - Review and return with a modified response for the group to review.
10 November 2020: Question 2 - Consider distance between component and indicator #1382 - Accept Detlev's amended draft response to issue #1382
10 November 2020: Question 3 - Does a change of background pass Focus Appearance (Minimum) #1278 - Accept amended PR 1495 to address issue #1278
10 November 2020: Question 4 - Example 2 for G195 is too inaccurate #1305 - Update the second example to include visuals and review later.
10 November 2020: Question 5 - UPDATED: Exception for the default focus indicator? #1341 - Add the proposed text to the understanding document to address issue 1341.
10 November 2020: Question 6 - Example calculations do not account for corners #1324 - Accept amended PR 1498 to address issue #1324
10 November 2020: Question 7 - Understanding rewording suggestions #1501 - Review Michael Gower's changes to PR 1501 next meeting
3 November 2020: Focus-appearance and Non-text-contrast relationship #1490 - Accept the SC update as amended, and the understanding document update.
3 November 2020: Focus: should indicator be unique? #1383 - Agree with updated response
3 November 2020: Contrast for aliased pixels #1348 - Accept update #1493
3 November 2020: Non-modal dialogues and Unobscured #1352 - Accept update as ammended
27 October 2020: Dragging Movements (1st question only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-dragging-issues/results - Approve the changes for issue #1316
27 October 2020: Pointer Target Size (1st question only) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-target-spacing-issues/results - Use Andrew's suggested response: The definition of target is: "region of the display that will accept a pointer action, such as the interactive area of a user interface component". If a label and the input form one target and if user-agents support making the label clickable as a mechanism to take an action on a user interface component, then the label's area can contribute to the target size.
20 October 2020: Dragging on mobile apps #1307 - Accept Detlev's response to 1307 with modifications
20 October 2020: Adding the word "Pointer" to "2.5.7 Dragging" #1397 - Approve changing title to Dragging Movements.
20 October 2020: Cross-reference Dragging and Pointer Gestures in Understanding #1316 - Accept PR 133416 to address 1316
20 October 2020: Relationship/overlap between 2.1's "Pointer Gestures" and 2.2's "Dragging" #1398 - Accept PR 1423 to address Issue #1398 with Alastair's modifications
20 October 2020: Updated proposal for "Target Size" - Continue working and review later.
13 October 2020: Silver scoring survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag3_Scoring/ - Include existing scoring example in FPWD with to be determined and approved framing
29 September 2020: Question 4 - Button has non-empty accessible name - Rule has been approved for publishing
29 September 2020: Question 1 - HTML page has non-empty title - Rule has been approved for publishing
29 September 2020: Question 2 - Image has non-empty accessible name - Rule has been approved for publishing
29 September 2020: Question 3 - Link has non-empty accessible name - Rule has been approved for publishing with amendments
29 September 2020: Question 5 - Form control has non-empty accessible name - Rule has been approved for publishing
29 September 2020: Question 6 - Meta viewport does not prevent zoom - Rule has been approved for publishing
29 September 2020: Question 6 - Meta viewport does not prevent zoom - Rule has been approved for publishing
29 September 2020: Moving Silver Requirements to a group note - Approved to move Silver Requirements to a group note
29 September 2020: Location of Examples of Silver Scoring - Improve content and include as a separate document referenced by draft or by announcement. Will be reviewed by group.
29 September 2020: Normative / informative discussion - Accept Michael's changes to use of non-normative.
22 September 2020: Change "must" to "is" in the SC text #1280 - accept pull request 1408
22 September 2020: Clarify exceptions in definition #1310 - Accept amended pull request 1411, close issue 1343 and incorporate feedback from 1344
22 September 2020: Understanding flow #1313 - Accept amended pull request 1412
22 September 2020: Confusing example: properly marked up email and password #1363 - Accept pull request 1415
22 September 2020: Clarify whether copy/paste is a cognitive function test #1359 - Do not accept the PR, propose a new understanding update, allowing for copy/paste.
22 September 2020: Include each step in an authentication process #1358 - Accept pull request 1414
22 September 2020: Does this include CAPTCHAs? #1256 - Accept amended pull request 1407 and we will update the understanding doc instead.
15 September 2020: Question 1 - Revised MVP - Reduce MVP to 5 guidelines, 3 of which will have how-to's, future guidelines will be complete in future drafts
15 September 2020: Question 1 - Revised MVP - Reduce MVP to 5 guidelines, 3 of which will have how-to's, future guidelines will be complete in future drafts
15 September 2020: Question 4 - Introduction - Discussion incorporated into new draft and brought back for review.
15 September 2020: Question 5 - Structure of these guidelines - Discussion incorporated into new draft and brought back for review.
15 September 2020: Question 6 - Normative requirements - Discussion incorporated into new draft and brought back for review.
15 September 2020: Question 7 - Guidelines (Not linked content) - Discussion incorporated into new draft and brought back for review.
8 September 2020: Changing the option term - Accept option 1 of AWK's amended language for PR #1356
8 September 2020: Same relative order term #1230 - Agree with proposed response
8 September 2020: Is one option enough? #1235 - revise response for later review
8 September 2020: Available or provided? #1232 - Use AWK's proposed wording to respond
8 September 2020: What is self-help? #1229 - Use Alastair's proposed response "Help content provided by the author"?
8 September 2020: Being responsible for content #1303 - Accept PR #1366 and additionally Rachael's proposed amendment to the response
8 September 2020: re-review Is one option enough? #1235 - Accept Sukriti's amended response
8 September 2020: re-review Is one option enough? #1235 - Accept Sukriti's amended response
8 September 2020: Understanding note gives the wrong rationale? #1362 - Accept PR 1379
8 September 2020: Pointer Target Spacing - target size #1311 - Accept proposed response
8 September 2020: Overlapping Spacing #1312 & #1361 - Put AGWG team together to continue review and craft a proposal.
25 August 2020: Could autocomplete meet the redundant entry SC? #1194 - Accept new line to understanding document of redundant entry to address issue 1194.
25 August 2020: When information previously entered has been saved #1239 - Accept Alastair's response to the issue.
25 August 2020: Are redundant resumes/curriculum vitae in online job applications a failure? #1293 - Accept Sukriti's new line to understanding document of redundant entry to address issue 1293.
25 August 2020: Add mobility use case #1276 - Accept new line to understanding document of redundant entry to address issue 1276.
25 August 2020: Unobscured: request to raise requirement #1271 #1304 - Accept the proposed alternative answer for issues 1271 and 1304.
25 August 2020: Not fully obscured wording (Normative) #1291 - Accept the recommended changes to address issue 1291.
25 August 2020: Add example of 8px side border #1279 - Accept the recommended changes to address issue 1279.
25 August 2020: Possible grammatical error in UIC definition #1296 - Accept the change with quotes to the terms for user interface components to address issue 1296.
25 August 2020: How should 2.4.11 / 2.4.12 be applied to inline elements that wrap over multiple lines? #1328 - Accept the changes to the understanding of focus appearance to address issue 1328.
18 August 2020: Representative Sampling - Include note on representative sampling in draft recognizing it will come back to this group for further review.
18 August 2020: Testing Editors Note - Use edited wording for Testing note and work on "rubrics and scales"
18 August 2020: Depreciation - Including a date stamp, no depreciation, add editor's note
11 August 2020: Discussion on Representative Sampling - Move topic to back of queue
11 August 2020: Scope & Definitions - We won't be weighting guidelines by disability for the FPWD
4 August 2020: Review and approve response to Issue 1156 "Loophole in SC2.4.11 allows almost invisible focus indicators" - Approve respose, but instead of a note, the understanding document will be updated to reflect commentary currently in note, and present to group for later review and approval.
4 August 2020: Dragging movement glossary definition: Deleting reference to intermediate point - Accept new definition for Dragging movement: "an operation where the pointer engages with an element on the down event and the element (or a representation of its position) follows the pointer"
4 August 2020: Clarity on Understanding 1.4.11 regarding hue #868 - Accept response and update the caption to figure 7 as above.
4 August 2020: exception for logos (1.4.3, 1.4.11) #902 - accept Alastair's proposed response and close issue 902
4 August 2020: Meet 1.3.5 via name attributes mapping to schema.org? #935 - Accept response and update understanding document for later review, close issue 935.
4 August 2020: Cross behavior between focus and hover (1.4.13) #1196 - Amend response based on either hover or focus applying, and review amended response later.
4 August 2020: SC 1.3.5 fields with correct autocomplete inside form with autocomplete="off" #1197 - Accept amended proposed response and close 1197.
4 August 2020: Removing application as a landmark from ARIA11 #780 - Approve pull request and close issue 780.
4 August 2020: Remove misleading/incorrect statement from 1.4.11 understanding #1058 - Accept proposed response and close 1058.
4 August 2020: Changes to examples in Understanding 1.4.11 #1065 - Accept proposed change and close 1065.
4 August 2020: Removing Flash Techniques #1142 - Agreed to remove flash techniques from WCAG 2.1 and WCAG 2.2, close #1142.
4 August 2020: Update link-purpose-in-context.html #1164 - Continue conversation for proposed response to 1164 at a later date.
28 July 2020: question 1 - SC 1.3.5 Technique "Use type attribute on fields in simple login forms"? #504 - Accept response to question #1.
28 July 2020: question 2 - labelled navigation landmarks should be added to sufficient techniques for 2.4.4 #619 - Accept Detlev's response.
28 July 2020: question 3 - 1.4.11 hover state clarification #849 - Accept Laura's response.
28 July 2020: question 4 - Clarity on 1.4.11 as it applies to "Cards" #856 - accept response and ammended. Defer evaluating changing understanding document.
21 July 2020: Revisit reflow question: Include 'down to' or not - Consensus is to not change "at" to "down to", and to review possible research and date for a later version.
21 July 2020: Question 1 - Adding fstorr's updates - border note in focus-visible-enhanced - Accept MG's proposed changes to focus-visible-enhanced.
21 July 2020: Question 2 - Focus appearance rewording of bullet 2 #1212 - accept Alastair's proposed text change for question 2.
21 July 2020: Question 3 - Review and approve response to Issue 1156 "Loophole in SC2.4.11 allows almost invisible focus indicators" - Leave Issue 1156 "Loophole in SC2.4.11 allows almost invisible focus indicators" open and revisit next week with revised text
21 July 2020: Question 4 - Review and approve response to GitHub issue 1067 "2.4.11 Focus Visible (Enhanced) Remove F78 and F55" - Accept response to GitHub issue 1067 "2.4.11 Focus Visible (Enhanced) Remove F78 and F55"
21 July 2020: Question 5 - Review and approve response to GitHub Issue 1049 Language of 1.4.10/Reflow exception seems broader than intended - Accept response to GitHub Issue 1049 Language of 1.4.10/Reflow exception seems broader than intended
21 July 2020: Question 6 - Update to reflow exception - Accept first sentence as amended and second paragraph in the question response.
21 July 2020: Question 7 - Dragging movement glossary definition: Deleting reference to intermediate point - review and address next week.
14 July 2020: Updates to touch target spacing https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Pointer-target-spacing-update/results - accept changes and publish pointer target spacing as amended
14 July 2020: Focus visible SC at AAA - Include the new AAA version of focus visible in WCAG 2.2
14 July 2020: Naming the focus visible criteria - Accept option 4 for naming.
7 July 2020: ACT rules integration review https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/2020-07-ACT/results - Move forward with integrating ACT Rules into WCAG Materials with changes discussed today
30 June 2020: Note that we'll be versioning the informative documents - Implement versioning for informative documents.
30 June 2020: Add 'unobscure' bullet - Add the bullet "Unobscured: The item with focus is not entirely hidden by author-created content" and add understanding content (tbd).
30 June 2020: Add an AAA version? - agree to work on an AAA version of 2.4.11
30 June 2020: 3. Do we try to mitigate the tricky examples? - answer wtih proposed response, including a comment that we will update the understanding document.
30 June 2020: 3. Do we try to mitigate the tricky examples? - answer wtih proposed response, including a comment that we will update the understanding document.
30 June 2020: 4. Change "border" to "perimiter" - No change of "border" to "perimiter", we will review some draft changes to understanding.
30 June 2020: 4. Change "border" to "perimiter" - No change of "border" to "perimiter", we will review some draft changes to understanding.
30 June 2020: 1. Expand 1.4.10 to apply 'down to' instead of 'at' 320px (#698) - agree to explore ways to add "down to"
30 June 2020: 2. Level(s) for 1.4.10 Reflow #1050 - Unresolved, continue next week.
23 June 2020: Making Content Usable Wide Review https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/content-usable-June-17/results - Publish "Making Content Usable" for wide review.
23 June 2020: Add Findable help to WCAG 2.2 draft https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/findable-help-finalisation/results - "Add Findable Help" is ready for CFC and wide review
23 June 2020: Add another size metric - Add the metric with an editors note to point out the need for feedback on the values, for public review.
23 June 2020: Matching the start of 2.4.7 - Re-introduce the following text "When a User Interface Component displays a visible keyboard focus, all of the following are true:"
16 June 2020: Update to Redundant entry - move forward with original text with link to process and steps undefined
16 June 2020: Proposed definition of "inactive" - To add the definition of Inactive in this week's survey, including the three Notes listed in the survey results, and the change of 'visible' to 'present' as a normative definition in WCAG 2.2
16 June 2020: Add another size metric - Keep open and try other wording.
9 June 2020: Focus visible update - level of 2.4.7 in WCAG 2.2 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/focus-visible-enh-issues2/ (1st question only) - Move 2.4.7 to A and add the new SC?
9 June 2020: Question 1 - Errata/clarification of 2.2.1 Timing Adjustable extension - PR not accepted, leave open for new option
9 June 2020: Question 2 - Formatting of Exceptions - Close GitHub issue.
9 June 2020: Question 3 - Add clarification of "inactive" to user interface component glossary definition - Andrew to work on "inactive" definition.
2 June 2020: Redesign of support materials https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/redesign-requirements/ - Leave open
2 June 2020: COGA Usage re-review https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/2020-05-content-usable/results/ - Ready for CFC after today's edits are made
2 June 2020: Sticky headers/footers violation of SC 2.4.7 - A sticky footer/header which temporarily obscures the focus indicator does NOT cause a failure of 2.4.7
2 June 2020: Understanding addition about mode of operation - Accept new text as amended
26 May 2020: Conformance Challenges Update https://www.w3.org/TR/accessibility-conformance-challenges/ - New survey to act as CFC to close Thursday with todays changes
19 May 2020: Focus visible updates https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/focus-visible-enh-issues2/ - Chairs will create a simpler survey to review changes
19 May 2020: Understanding addition about mode of operation - Leave open
12 May 2020: WCAG 2.2 Visual Indicators, last week (really) to agree SC text https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Visual_indicators/results - Defer, not ready for WCAG 2.2
12 May 2020: Sticky headers/footers violation of SC 2.4.7 - Find some examples, leave open
12 May 2020: Focus visible not required whilst element focused - Accept response
5 May 2020: Discuss results for COGA content usable note https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/2020-04-content-usable/ - Continue to review the content of Content Usable
5 May 2020: WCAG 2.2 Visual Indicators, last week to agree SC text https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Visual_indicators/ - leave open
5 May 2020: WCAG 2.2 Focus indicator (enh) issues https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/focus-visible-enh-issues1/ - adoption Option 3 for more refinement
28 April 2020: Silver FPWD MVP discussion https://docs.google.com/document/d/1tQHgVFaJYS1WWs9BKucZxWboMNVuclvdNqnQuzPbWwY/ - This document is sufficient to define what is in the FPWD
28 April 2020: WCAG 2.2 Finding help - https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/findable-help/ - Accept SC into working draft
21 April 2020: Finding help https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/findable-help/results - leave ope ... leave open
14 April 2020: Survey Results for AGWG/Silver meeting times https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/2020-04-silverpoll/results - Re-work, re-word survey
14 April 2020: Public Working Draft of 2.2 and standing consent to publish - To do CFC to the larger group for standing consent for WCAG 2.2 draft publication
14 April 2020: Public Working Draft of 2.2 and standing consent to publish - A CfC to larger group for standing consent for WCAG 2.2. draft publication
14 April 2020: Conformance challenges re-review https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Conformance-Challenges-FPWD3/ - publish the conformance challenges doc as a FPWD
14 April 2020: WCAG 2.2 Touch target spacing (Adjustment to errata): https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/target-spacing/ - Move the SC forward to public review. Remove the exception and add note about the exception.
25 March 2020: Touch target spacing - Accept Touch Target Spacing pending technique creation
25 March 2020: WCAG 2.2 Error Correction (was Confirm before submission): https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-confirm-before-submission/ - Accept Error Correction as Amended (pending editorial updates)
25 March 2020: WCAG 2.2 Fixed reference points: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/page-break-nav/ - Include accessible page location in 2.2. draft
24 March 2020: Custom interactions: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Custom_interactions/results - Defer this SC
24 March 2020: Dragging: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-dragging/results - Include in the WCAG 2.2 draft, after understanding & techniques reviewed
24 March 2020: Touch target spacing: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/target-spacing/results - Leave open
3 March 2020: Publishing ACT Rules https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/93339/PublishACTRules/results - Publish Rule "Image button has accessible name" as amended
3 March 2020: HTML Page LANG is valid https://act-rules.github.io/rules/bf051a - Publish rule "HTML page LANG is valid" as amended
3 March 2020: HTML lang and XML lang match - Publish "HTML lang and XML lang match" and "HTML page has LANG attribute"
3 March 2020: ID attribute value is unique - Not to publish until discussion about 4.1.1 is resolved for WCAG 2.2
18 February 2020: WCAG 2.2 Information in steps https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/info-in-steps/results - Accept Success Criteria pending technique
18 February 2020: WCAG 2.2 Fixed Reference Points https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/page-break-nav/results - Leave open to address techniques
18 February 2020: WCAG 2.2 Dragging https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-dragging/results - Leave open
18 February 2020: WCAG 2.2 Confirmation before submission https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-confirm-before-submission/results - leave open
11 February 2020: WCAG 2.2 hidden controls https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/silver-naming/results - Leave open, but almost ready
4 February 2020: Silver naming - Accepting New Name for Silver
4 February 2020: WCAG 2.2 Findable help: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/findable-help/ - Leave open
21 January 2020: Important controls (re-review) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/essential-controls/ - leave open
14 January 2020: ACT TF Work Statement https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ACTTF_New_WorkStatement/results - Accepted and run CFC
14 January 2020: Adding a research aspect to SC requirements https://github.com/w3c/wcag/pull/1006 - Accepted as amended
14 January 2020: WCAG 2.2 Accessible Authentication (re-review) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/accessible-auth/results - SC Text is ready for external review, need to finalize understanding and build techniques to get this SC into the editor's draft.
14 January 2020: WCAG 2.2 Important controls (re-review) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/essential-controls/results - Leave open
17 December 2019: WCAG 2.2 Confirmation before submission (2nd week). https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/wcag22-confirm-before-submission/results - leave open
17 December 2019: WCAG 2.2 Visual indicators https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Visual_indicators/results - Leave open
17 December 2019: WCAG 2.2 Custom interactions https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Custom_interactions/results - Leave open
10 December 2019: Non-text contrast update https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ntc-updates-dec-2019/results - Publish PR 931 as amended
29 October 2019: ACT survey on new rule https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ACT-Rules_Oct2019/results - The rule with the iframe change as discussed will be published Thursday and further comments will be routed through the taskforce for updates. ... Accept as ammended for publication
29 October 2019: WCAG 2.2 Criteria review – Icon Description https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/icon-desc-acceptance/results - Leave open
22 October 2019: WCAG 2.2 Criteria review – Focus Visible (Enhanced) (2nd week) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/focus-vis-enh-acceptance/results - Resolved to include in the WCAG 2.2 editors draft.
22 October 2019: WCAG 2.2 Criteria review – Essential controls. (2nd week) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/essential-controls/results - put on hold
15 October 2019: WCAG 2.2 Criteria review – Focus Visible (Enhanced) (2nd week) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/focus-vis-enh-acceptance/results - leave open
1 October 2019: Failure technique for 1.3.5 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/MiscItems09022019/results - Accept pull request 890 as ammended on call
19 September 2019: Custom Interactions - More work will be required on this SC.
19 September 2019: Page break navigation - continue working on page break navigation
19 September 2019: Page Break Locators - Continue working on page break locators
19 September 2019: Information In Steps - Leave Open
19 September 2019: Information in steps - Looking for additional use cases.
19 September 2019: Visible Labels - Review questions, update document.
19 September 2019: Orientation (Enhanced) - Compare to previous understanding update, bring that and the SC back for consideration
19 September 2019: Dragging - Need more examples, need to think about the questions.
18 September 2019: Silver topics - Accept conformance model noting Jemma's Condition
10 September 2019: Small errata for 1.4.10 reflow https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/SeptemberErrata/ - Accept erratum as proposed
10 September 2019: 1.3.5 failure - Do not accept 1.3.5 failure technique as proposed
10 September 2019: Failure for 2.5.1 - accepted as amended.
10 September 2019: Failure for 2.5.4 - accepted as amended
3 September 2019: Adding exceptions to F40, F41, F54, F58, and (new) F95 - Accept Pull Request #879.
3 September 2019: Failure of Success Criteria 1.4.12 due to clipped or overlapped content when text spacing is adjusted - Accept 881 Failure of Success Criteria 1.4.12 due to clipped or overlapped content when text spacing is adjusted
27 August 2019: 1. Failure of Success Criterion 4.1.3: Status Messages #853 - Accepted as amended.
20 August 2019: WCAG 2.1 Techniques and Understanding survey (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AGWG_T_U_Aug2019/) - leave open
20 August 2019: Errata, glossary definition for "images of text" #264 - Clarify in Understanding doc 143. Reject pull request 777.
20 August 2019: Failure of Success Criterion 4.1.3: Status Messages #853 - leave open ... and put on survey for next week!
20 August 2019: Updating Understanding 1.4.11 Text Spacing #860 - accepted as amended
20 August 2019: Adding extra paragraph to F94 for issue 854 #863 - accepted as amended
13 August 2019: Updating Understanding 1.3.3 Sensory Characteristics #767 - Accept PR 767 ammended to keep F26
13 August 2019: Errata, Motion actuation #733 - On hold pending further comments
13 August 2019: Errata, glossary definition for "images of text" #264 - On hold pending comments from people dis-agreeing.
13 August 2019: Updating pause-stop-hide-understanding #778 - Accept PR 778
13 August 2019: DHTML roadmap techniques? #289 - Accept PR 779
13 August 2019: Updating an example for buttons. #813 - Accept PR 813
6 August 2019: WCAG 2.1 Techniques and Understanding survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AGWG_T_U_Aug2019/ - Accept questions 3 to 5 as unanimously agreed
6 August 2019: Motion actuation failure technique - On hold
6 August 2019: Second item on survey - Accept PR 843 as amended
30 July 2019: Holiday calls - no calls September 24th, December 24th, and December 31st.
30 July 2019: Updates to WCAG 2.1 SCs in 2.2 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/updating-wcag2-requirements2/results - WG agrees that updating SC is a possible option. But no decision was made on updated on SC 1.4.10 at this time.
30 July 2019: Technique remap or turn off character key shortcuts - Accepted as proposed.
30 July 2019: Must the visible label of site logos be in the accName #722 - Leave open
30 July 2019: h57, h58 and xml:lang - Accepted as amended.
30 July 2019: F63 shouldn't indicate use of preceding heading to meet 2.4.4 #819 - Accepted as proposed.
30 July 2019: Non-text contast - Adjacent colors and example clarifications. #681 - accepted as proposed.
30 July 2019: Errata, add advice to Large scale (text) > Note 1 in the glossary #228 - Reject PR so that this is not an errata, but rather put the change in the Understanding document
30 July 2019: Must the visible label of site logos be in the accName #722 - Accept as amended
30 July 2019: Updating Understanding 1.3.3 Sensory Characteristics #767 - Leave open
30 July 2019: H80 Example 3 needs updating #233 - Accept as amended
23 July 2019: Failure of 2.5.2 - Publish PR 815 as ammended
23 July 2019: G131 Test Procedure - Accept Jake’s suggestion as amended and create a pull request
23 July 2019: 3. Are Reflow, Text Size and Orientation cumulative? #391 - Accept the proposed response to 391
23 July 2019: Change to normative text of 1.4.12: at least > up to #637 - leave open
23 July 2019: Expand 1.4.10 to apply 'down to' instead of 'at' #698 - Leave open pending survey.
23 July 2019: ARIA in HTML conformance to conform WCAG ? #717 - Accept q 6 and 7 as proposed.
16 July 2019: Updating WCAG 2.x requirements: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/updating-wcag2-requirements/results - Choose Option 2 for focus visible SC
16 July 2019: Control Orientation - Approve Tech Control Orientation as amended
16 July 2019: Tech Failure Doorslam - Accept Tech Failure Doorslam
16 July 2019: Providing a control slider that offers single point activation - Accept PR 760 Providing a control slider that offers single point activation
9 July 2019: Technique - Content on focus or hover - accepted as amended pending changes to use of popup.
9 July 2019: Technique - Failure of character key shortcuts - accepted as amended
9 July 2019: Technique - Two color focus indicator #583 - Accepted as amended
9 July 2019: Issues resolution https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/issues-2019-07/ - Accept numbers 1, 2, and 4 as proposed.
9 July 2019: Is H33 still valid #305 - Accept response to #305 and leave H33 in place
9 July 2019: G131 Test Procedure #339 - Leave G131 open
25 June 2019: Charter discussion - WG agrees to update the charter to include Silver but not including REC and to use that draft as the Wide Review Charter draft
25 June 2019: Technique - Tech Control Orientation - Leave open Tech control orientation
25 June 2019: Technique - Tech Failure Doorslam - Leave open Tech Failure Doorslam
18 June 2019: WCAG 2.2 requirements - Accept requirments document as ammended
18 June 2019: accessible authentication - Continue with the Accessible Authentication SC
18 June 2019: Touch Target Spacing - There are questions about the testability that need further work
18 June 2019: WCAG 2.1 Techniques, 1st question only. https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Techniques-June-2019/results - Accepted as amended
18 June 2019: WCAG 2.x issue resolutions, 1-5 only https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Tech_Und_survey/ - Accept as amended.
18 June 2019: Public comment: Security implications of autocomplete - Accept PR as amended
18 June 2019: 3. SC note and understanding update: Orientation (Issue 416 / PR 724) - Accept PR 724
18 June 2019: Public comment: Adding weight/typeface to the contrast test (Issue 665) - Accept proposed response
18 June 2019: Public comment: Maximum contrast (Issue 675) - Accept response to 675
11 June 2019: WCAG 2.1 Techniques survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Techniques-June-2019/results - Approve PR 714 as amended
11 June 2019: Two color focus indicator #583 - Leave open
4 June 2019: Path Based Gestures - the approach is agreed-upon and it will be written up
4 June 2019: Understanding update: Reflow doc referencing 1.4.4 (PR 715) - accept pull requests 715
4 June 2019: Motion Actuation (PR 693) - accept PR 693
4 June 2019: Non-text contrast (PR 701) - accept PR 701
4 June 2019: Should non-drafted techniques be included? - Michael Cooper to compile a list of the techniques that were deleted.
4 June 2019: Bypass blocks (PR 721) - Accept PR 721
28 May 2019: Pointers gestures clarification path base gestures. - The WG intended that path-based gestures in 2.5.1 does not include gestures that only depend on the start and end points.
21 May 2019: WCAG 2.1 techniques overview - Complete 2.1 techniques before TPAC
21 May 2019: New technique: Failure technique for 2.5.6 Concurrent Input Mechanisms (PR 690) - Leave open pending Mike Gower and Patrick working on comments
21 May 2019: New technique: Using native controls to ensure up events (PR 726) - Accept PR 726 as amended
14 May 2019: Failuretechniques for input mechanisms - leave open pending updates
14 May 2019: New technique: Using native controls to ensure up events (PR 726) - Leave open pending updates.
14 May 2019: Understanding update: Pointer Gestures clarity (PR 714 / 725) - Leave open pending updates
14 May 2019: Understanding update: Content on Hover or Focus (Issue 605) - Accept pull request 73 as ammended
7 May 2019: Silver requirements update - WG is happy with the updated to the silver requirements and we will do a CFC
7 May 2019: Pull Request 649: General techniques for label in name - Accept as amended from survey responses.
7 May 2019: Pull Request 531: Semantically identifying a font icon with role="img" - Accept pending edits form the survey as well as the additions to the second paragraph from the call.
30 April 2019: 522: Pointer Gestures: clarity on path-based language in Understanding document - Except respons and create PR
30 April 2019: Issue 687: Non-text contrast - Adjacent colors and example clarifications. - Remove " or selecting a close button" from the Understanding document, create a PR and then post the official response
30 April 2019: Pull request 658 - Accept pull request 672 ... Accept pull request 702
23 April 2019: Design Principles - Accept Design Principles as amended, pending changes we've discussed
23 April 2019: Requirements - Accept requirements as amended
23 April 2019: Requirements - Accept requirements as amended, send to CFC. Some concerns noted.
9 April 2019: New Technique for Device Motion Actuation - Leave open.
9 April 2019: Issues resolutions - Accept issues 638, 652, 660, 671, and 678 as unanimous.
9 April 2019: New Techniques for Label in Name - separate techniques
2 April 2019: TPAC 2019 (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AGWG_TPAC_2019/results) - WG will meet at TPAC
26 March 2019: Issues survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/technique-approvals9/results | - Accept items 1 3 4 and 5 as proposed due to unanimous concent.
26 March 2019: Issues survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/technique-approvals9/results | - Accept proposed response to issue 593.
26 March 2019: Issues survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/technique-approvals9/results | - Accept pull request 664.
11 March 2019: Design Principle 1 - Jeanne/Shawn to clarify “intersectional” and think about a glossary.
11 March 2019: Design Principle 2 - Overall agreed on the design principle itself. But need to make the including statement more inclusive.
11 March 2019: DESIGN PRINCIPLE 3 - accepted
11 March 2019: Design 4 - Move (later) to requirements.
11 March 2019: Design Principle 5 - In agreement this is a good thing to have. More points to consider in how you would measure if this were a requirement, but it is a principle.
11 March 2019: Design Principle 6 (moving to creation process for the guidelines) - We have agreement that this is an important principle. There is room for clarification.
11 March 2019: Design Principal 7 - We have agreement on this principle, with possible wording tweaks
11 March 2019: Design Principle 8 - We are in agreement, with the caveat to not let data-driven process exclude minority groups of people with disabilities
11 March 2019: Additional principles - The Silver group will discuss a new Design Principle
11 March 2019: Requirement 1 - Silver will check in with the group to make sure that additions to this requirement are incorporated.
11 March 2019: Flexible structure - Shift in focus of framing from structure to maintenance model so we can include process and terms for inclusion
11 March 2019: Multiple ways to display - Largely agreed, but we have notes of what to change
11 March 2019: Technology neutral - agreed with some minor wording changes
11 March 2019: Readability/Usability - Language needs to be tweaked to clarify scope and working with experts in plain language for how we would measure success
11 March 2019: Regulatory Environment - Agreed on the main purpose, but have to work through some solid discussions
5 March 2019: Issue Survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/technique-approvals8/results (#4 only) - Accept as amended pending changes described on the call
5 March 2019: F3 - Andrew will investigate Pull Request 120
26 February 2019: Issue 538 - Accept response as proposed.
26 February 2019: Issue 538 - Accepting items 5-8.
26 February 2019: New Technique: Boundary contrast - Accept as amended.
26 February 2019: New Technique: Boundary contrast - Accepted as amended.
19 February 2019: Issue 619 - leave open
19 February 2019: Issue 618: definition of presentation in SC 1.3.1 - accepted as proposed
19 February 2019: Issue 613: 1.3.4 Orientation - applicability to native apps - accepted as proposed
19 February 2019: Issue 612: Fixes to WCAG 2.1 Understanding 2.4.6 and 3.3.2 - accepting as amended with Rachels change
19 February 2019: Issue 599: Is using the track element to provide audio descriptions sufficient? (Was "Retire H96?") - accepting as proposed
19 February 2019: ERRATA – Issue 582: 1.4.13 Content on Hover or Focus - hoverable requirement, clarification of point "persistent" - Alastair and Andrew will add response on basis of Mike Gower's response
19 February 2019: Issue 581: Misleading info in "Understanding 2.4.4: Link Purpose (In Context)" - accept as proposed
12 February 2019: Errata Links to Understanding docs - Accept Issue 595
12 February 2019: Errata Better Link Text - Accept response for issue 608
12 February 2019: Issue 540 - Accept Issue 540
12 February 2019: Issue 602 - Accept Issue 540 ... Accept Issue 602
12 February 2019: Issue 538 - Leave open Issue 538
12 February 2019: Issue 165 - Accept pull request 604
12 February 2019: Retire H96 - Keep H96 ammended by note
12 February 2019: Feedback on approach to Issue 610 - accept PR 606 as erratum, as amended
5 February 2019: Errata - Update Content on Hover or Focus - Leave open. Mike will work on understanding doc.
5 February 2019: Remove technique: H4: Creating a logical tab order... - Remove H4
5 February 2019: Issue 544 on Autocomplete - Accepted as amended.
29 January 2019: Issue 568 - Accept pull request 568
29 January 2019: Issue 568 - Accept pull request 575
29 January 2019: Technique in 584 - Leave open
29 January 2019: Technique in pull request 455 - Publish as amended.
22 January 2019: Issue 567 - Labels of inactive inputs - accepted as proposed
22 January 2019: Issue 538 - modal on load failure - Leave open
22 January 2019: Issue 400 - SC 1.4.11 contrast on hover included or not - accepted a proposed
15 January 2019: Understanding update Non-text Contrast - Accepted as amended pending final edits by Alastair
15 January 2019: Technique Border Contrast - Leave Open
8 January 2019: AccName update - CfC accepted without objection, publish PR 555
8 January 2019: Technique Reduce Motion - Accept as amended ... Accept PR 556
18 December 2018: Understanding non-text contrast update - SC 1.4.11 does not require differentiation inside the component between states
18 December 2018: Failure due to locking the orientation to landscape or portrait view - Accept pull request 545
18 December 2018: Technique for reducing motion/sc 2.3.3 - Leave pull request for reducing motion open
11 December 2018: Understanding Update Non-Text COntrast - Leave open and send email to list for thoughts on feedback
11 December 2018: Technique Icon Contrast - Accepted as amended pending image change
27 November 2018: Technique: Ensure the "accessible name" includes the visible text - Address comments in the survey.
27 November 2018: Technique: Using CSS width, max-width and flexbox to fit labels and inputs - Accept Issue 456 as ammended
27 November 2018: Ensuring that drag-and-drop actions can be cancelled - Accepted as proposed.
27 November 2018: Technique: Failure due to "accessible name" not containing the visible label text - Keep open
27 November 2018: Technique: Failure of Success Criterion 1.4.13 due to content shown on hover or focus not being hoverable - Accepted as amended
27 November 2018: Failure due to "accessible name" - Accepted as amended
20 November 2018: Type attribute for purpose - Input type is not sufficient for identifying purpose, understanding document to be updated
20 November 2018: Bad link in G158 Edit - Remove link from G158
20 November 2018: Understanding update Non text contrast, clarifying active state - Accept pull request 530.
13 November 2018: Technique for media queries for sticky elements - Accept pull request 389 as amende ... Accept pull request 389 as amended
13 November 2018: Tech spacing override - To publish 386 as amended
13 November 2018: Technique fitting images viewport - Accept pull request 494 as amended
13 November 2018: Technique fitting images viewport - Accept pull request 495 subject to future discussion
6 November 2018: TPAC update: https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/Write_up_from_TPAC_2018 - Chairs will codify editor requirements and publish them
6 November 2018: TPAC update: https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/Write_up_from_TPAC_2018 - Chairs will finish any minor edits and routed the CFC for the decision policy.:
22 October 2018: Process Update Discussion - Incorporate the feedback from today into another iteration of the AGWG process comments
16 October 2018: PR 516 - Editorial, Editors will resolve
16 October 2018: PR 515 - accepted as proposed
9 October 2018: Understanding text-spacing, stylish to stylus update - Publish PR487 ... Publish PR487
9 October 2018: Technique: wrapping long URLs for reflow - Publish PR486 as amended
9 October 2018: Technique: wrapping long URLs for reflow - Publish PR486 as amended
9 October 2018: Technique: media queries for sticky elements - Leave open, finalize next time.
9 October 2018: Technique: failure for hover / focus content not dismissable - leave open and detlev will think about improving procedure or convert to success technique.
2 October 2018: Pointer Gestures - accept PR484 as amended
2 October 2018: Tech using role log - accept PR435 as amended
25 September 2018: Technique F87 - Accepted as amended
25 September 2018: updated technique example for SCR29 - accepted changes to SCR29 as proposed
25 September 2018: https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/460 (an editorial errata?) - accepted proposal two as editworial errata on principle three
4 September 2018: Techniques and Understanding updates survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/TechniquesforApproval/ - except for publication PR387 as amended
4 September 2018: Using CSS Flexbox to reflow - publish PR388 as amended
4 September 2018: Failure of viewport units, is ready - publish PR417 as amended
4 September 2018: Understanding Text Spacing: Removed fixed text example. - publish PR385 as amended
28 August 2018: Autocomplete - Publish the autocomplete technique as amended
21 August 2018: Update to 1.3.5 Understanding doc, Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/TechniquesforApproval/results - publish understanding 135 after removing related resources comment and fixing the error Mike Gower identified
7 August 2018: Techniques needing work/review - Pull request 431 has more than 5 approvals and will be decided next meeting.
31 July 2018: Marking WCAG 1.0 Obsolete. - Michael will check with Judy and we will send the CFC after that about whether to obsolete WCAG 1.0
31 July 2018: Reviewing open issues - https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/433 - Leave open for input from LVTF and COGA.
31 July 2018: Reviewing open issues - https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/433 - leave open for input from LVTF and COGA
31 July 2018: Reviewing open issues - https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/425 - Leave open and JF to investigate and update Understanding.
31 July 2018: Reviewing open issues - https://github.com/w3c/wcag/issues/420 - Accept issue 420 as editorial errata
24 July 2018: Errata update - MC will run the list by the group as a CFC
17 July 2018: Drag and Drop in Pointer SC - Accept proposed response and pull request 379.
5 June 2018: Techniques & Understanding docs process - No more Thursday calls are planned.
5 June 2018: Issue resolution: 913 & 914 (Non-text contrast understanding doc) - accept proposed response for 914
31 May 2018: Understanding changes and CFC - Editor's to included note in 1.4.11 if language changes, and also to try to reach consensus on changes beforehand (thus eliminating the need for the note)
29 May 2018: Publishing Understanding - Accept change to 1.4.11 Non-text contrast in order to better reflect the intent of the WG, and propose change to W3M.
29 May 2018: Publishing Understanding - send out CFC for publication of understanding documents with the rec
24 May 2018: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Understanding_Updates5/results - Accepted as proposed
24 May 2018: Issue 903 Abstract - accept edited version posted at by AWK at 11:45am central time
22 May 2018: Understanding Orientation - accept pull request 922 as amended
22 May 2018: Non-text contrast - accept Pull Request 924 subject to updating graphical examples
22 May 2018: CHanges to understanding timeouts - Accept pull request 925 as ammended.
22 May 2018: Identify Purpose - accept pull request 929 as ammended.
17 May 2018: Understanding Orientation - Accepted PR 922 as ammended by the comments
15 May 2018: Changes to Understanding Concurrent Input Mechanisms - Accepted as amended
15 May 2018: Changes to Understanding Concurrent Input Mechanisms - Accepted Concurrent Input Mechanisms and merge 915 as amended
15 May 2018: Changes to Understanding Orientation - Accept pull request 916 as amended (Orientation) with the understanding that further edits are needed for the "functionality" question
15 May 2018: Motion Actuation - Accept pull request #917
15 May 2018: Status Messages - Accept pull request #918 as amended
10 May 2018: Changes to Understanding Text spacing - Accept pull request 905 as amended.
10 May 2018: Changes to Understanding Content on Hover or Focus - Accept pull request 906 as amended.
10 May 2018: Understanding Animation from Interactions - Accept pull request 907 as amended
10 May 2018: Changes to Understanding Character Key Shortcuts - Accept implementing the changes discussed and not withdrawing the pull request
10 May 2018: Understanding Target Size - Accept pull request 908 as amended
10 May 2018: Understanding Pointer Gestures - Accept pull request 909 as amended
8 May 2018: Changes to Understanding conformance - Merge pull request 543
8 May 2018: Changes to Understanding conformance #2 - Leave open.
8 May 2018: Changes to Understanding conformance #2 - Accept pull request.
8 May 2018: Changes to Understanding conformance #2 - to accept pull request
8 May 2018: Changes to Understanding conformance #2 - Accept pull request
8 May 2018: Understanding Label and Name - Merge pull request 897
8 May 2018: Understanding conformance #2 - merge PR 545
3 May 2018: Issue 850 (https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/850) - Kathy and Jon and David (mike gower offered to review) will take a crack at understanding changes for the group.
12 April 2018: Issue 773 - Accept response to 773 as proposed
12 April 2018: SC reorg - Accept proposal with ammendment to move character key shortcuts to 2.1
12 April 2018: SC reorg - Working group approves leaving some or all of the SC in place if there are deemed to be too many changes by the director for the transition.
12 April 2018: Edits to Intro - Accept changes to introduction as ammended
12 April 2018: Edits to Intro - Move to PR with contingencies
10 April 2018: Survey on At Risk items: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AtRiskItems/results - Do not take the CR ¨at risk¨ action to remove SC 1.3.5
10 April 2018: At risk SC 1.4.11 Non-text Contrast - Do not take the CR at risk action to remove SC 1.4.11
10 April 2018: At risk SC 1.4.11 Non-text Contrast - Do not take the CR at risk action to remove SC 2.2.7
10 April 2018: Issues survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/CloseCRIssues/results - Accept all comment responses in survey as proposed
3 April 2018: 839 - Accept response for 754 and use for 839 also
3 April 2018: 836 - 844 accepted as proposed.
3 April 2018: 827 - Accepted as amended
3 April 2018: 827 - 829 proposed response accepted as proposed
20 March 2018: 808 - follow up with Steve about proposed response and report back
20 March 2018: 805 - defer issue to silver, clarify definition in 143, 146, 1411 Understanding.
20 March 2018: 763 - note that is in 251 should also be used in 252. and change Pointer Gestures to Pointer Inputs in both SC
20 March 2018: 778 - Accept response as amended in https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/778#issuecomment-374672047
20 March 2018: Non-text contrast - accept Glenda's edit to 1.4.11 understanding https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/blob/non-text-contrast/understanding/21/non-text-contrast.html
20 March 2018: Issue 772 - label issue 772 for future understanding work.
20 March 2018: 803 - working group decides to move the list into an appendix of wcag 2.1 unless that change contravenes cr status.
20 March 2018: 806 - add "and physical reactions" and corresponding change to the GL text language "or physical reactions" and adding 2.2.7 Animation from Interactions to GL 2.3 providing this does not contravene CR.
19 March 2018: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/753 - Accepted as proposed
19 March 2018: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/753 - Accepted as proposed - Issue #754 - with AWK edits
19 March 2018: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/753 - Accepted as proposed - Issue #753
19 March 2018: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/753 - Leave Open - Issue #753 - for review by Chris McM, Patrick
19 March 2018: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/753 - Leave Open - Issue #753 - for review by Chris McM, Patrick
19 March 2018: issue 765 - Change SC title to Status Messages, and follow up with commenter about changes
19 March 2018: issue 765 - Change SC Title to Status Message (including loading) and follow up with commenter about response - Issue #765
13 March 2018: Possibly moving 1.3.4 https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/768 - CFC for not moving 1.3.4
13 March 2018: Possibly moving 3.2.6 https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/802 - Move 3.2.6 to 4.1.3 (CFC)
13 March 2018: Understanding Pointer Cancellation - https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Clearing_Understanding/#wbsq13 - Merge Pointer Cancellations into editors draft.
13 March 2018: Understanding Motion Actuation - https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Clearing_Understanding/#wbsq16 - leave open
13 March 2018: Understanding Concurrent Input Mechanisms - https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Clearing_Understanding/#wbsq14 - Leave open
13 March 2018: Understanding Character Key Shortcuts - https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Clearing_Understanding/#wbsq9 - Leave open.
13 March 2018: Understanding Non-text Contrast - https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Clearing_Understanding/#wbsq4 - Merge into editors draft.
8 March 2018: comment on reflow https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/757 - 757 will become the official response
13 February 2018: Survey for ACT TF: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ACT_draft_review2018/ - Permission to publish draft of rules format and updated demo rules site.
13 February 2018: 761 - Accepted as proposed
13 February 2018: 760 - Accept as amended
13 February 2018: 759 - Accept response as amended
13 February 2018: 758 - Accept response as amended
13 February 2018: 756 - Accept response as amended
6 February 2018: Issue 745 - https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/745 - Accepted as proposed.
6 February 2018: Issue 744 - https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/744 - Accept as amended
6 February 2018: Issue 746 - https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/746 - Accept as amended. Includes link back.
6 February 2018: Issue 747 - https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/747 - Accepted as amended.
6 February 2018: Issue 733 - https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/733 - Accepted as amended
23 January 2018: Wrapping up CFCs - mark the following SC “at risk” animations, non-text contrast and identify common purpose
16 January 2018: Target Size Proposals - leave open Target size.
16 January 2018: Graphics Contrast - Leave open
16 January 2018: Text spacing - Accepted as ammended with exception language
16 January 2018: reflow - Leave open
16 January 2018: pointer gestures - Reissue CFC with updated definition
11 January 2018: Reflow survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_issues_reflow/results - accept response to Issue 589 as proposed
10 January 2018: issue 296 & 315 glossary items - not modifying definitions
10 January 2018: Issue 620 - leave open
10 January 2018: issue 622 - accept as amended "Ensure that device sensor inputs are not a barrier for users"
10 January 2018: 631 - Send option 2 out to CFC.
9 January 2018: Issue 408 - Accepted as amended
9 January 2018: Issue 520 - Leave open.
9 January 2018: Issue 605 - Accepted as amended
9 January 2018: Issue 656 - Accepted as proposed
9 January 2018: Issue 656 - accepted as amended
2 January 2018: 150 - accept 150 response
2 January 2018: 619 - accept 619 as amended
2 January 2018: 620 - Accept 619 with additional edits.
2 January 2018: 620 - leave 620 -22 open
2 January 2018: 630 - accept 630 as amended
2 January 2018: 631 - Leave open, will get back to it later
2 January 2018: 624 - Leave open pending JF edits.
2 January 2018: Comment about needing an identifier for common control concepts - Add an identifer for each common purpose
21 December 2017: Interruptions (minimum): https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/interruptions-minimum-review/results - No consensus
21 December 2017: Accessible Authentication: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Accessible-authentication-review/results - Accept as amended at AAA
21 December 2017: Contextual information: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Contextual_Information_review/results - Accepted as amended at https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/1-3-5_Revision
21 December 2017: Animation from Interactions: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/animation_from_interaction_review/results - Accepted as amended at ##:36 by Alastair
19 December 2017: Interruptions (minimum): https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/interruptions-minimum-review/results - Leave open
19 December 2017: Accessible Authentication: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Accessible-authentication-review/results - Leave open
14 December 2017: Contextual information: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Contextual_Information_review/results - Leave open
14 December 2017: Resolving issues: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_issues_1/ - Accept 602, 608, 616, 617, 618 as proposed
14 December 2017: 601 - Accepted as amended.
14 December 2017: 609 - 609 accepted as amended
14 December 2017: Animation from Interactions: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/animation_from_interaction_review/results - Leave open, Alastair will propose amended text
7 December 2017: Understanding Document Work - Publish Dec 7 Wide Review Working Draft and Understanding
30 November 2017: accidental activation (https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/pull/595) - Accepted for CFC as proposed in pull request 595
30 November 2017: Content on Hover or Focus (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ContentHoverFocus_20171109/results) - accept for CFC based on pull request #569
30 November 2017: Common Input Control Purposes - leave open pending comments to list by 1130 tomorrow
30 November 2017: Device Sensors (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_device_sensors/results) - accepted as amended above for Device Sensor
29 November 2017: Purpose of Controls https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_purpose_of_controls/results - WG agrees that list should be NORMATIVE!
29 November 2017: Purpose of Controls https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_purpose_of_controls/results - to spend 5 minutes tomorrow to finish this SC
28 November 2017: Change of Content https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/Comment_Summary_3-2-7 - Leave open for more work
28 November 2017: Target Size (AA) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_target_size/results - Accepted as amended at https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/index.php?title=WCAG_2.1/targets&oldid=8767#Alternative_Wording
28 November 2017: Target Size (AA) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_target_size/results - Open issue for implementation follow up
28 November 2017: accepting comment responses for Target size - Accept responses to comments for Target Size at https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/WCAG_2.1/targets#Comment_responses as proposed
28 November 2017: AAA Target size - Accept AAA as amended
28 November 2017: AAA Target size - leave open
27 November 2017: Device Sensors https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_device_sensors/results - leave open
27 November 2017: adapting text https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/Comment_Summary_1-4-13 - Accept SC text as proposed https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/Comment_Summary_1-4-13 and comment responses as proposed
27 November 2017: Accidental Activation https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/Comment_Summary_2-5-2 - leave open
27 November 2017: Change of Content https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/Comment_Summary_3-2-7 - Leave open
21 November 2017: Target Size https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_target_size/results - leave open
21 November 2017: Purpose of Controls - Accept SC in principle
21 November 2017: Purpose of Controls - Leave Open
20 November 2017: Content on Hover and Focus https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ContentHoverFocus_20171109/results (40 minutes) - Leave open
20 November 2017: Orientation (20 minutes) - Accept SC language as amended.
20 November 2017: Pointer Gestures https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_pointer_gestures/results (20 minutes) - SC language accepted as amended.
20 November 2017: Target Size https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_target_size/results (40 minutes) - Leave open.
17 November 2017: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolving_pointer_gestures/results - SC accepted as amended and put to CFC
17 November 2017: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resoling_orientation/results - Accept comment responses to 2.5.1
17 November 2017: Orientation SC - Accept SC text as proposed.
17 November 2017: Orientation SC - Accept responses to issues.
16 November 2017: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Resolving_Timeouts/results - No consensus
15 November 2017: Graphics Contrast and UI Component Contrast: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Graphics_and_UI_Contrast20171109/results - Add definition for state “a dynamic property expressing characteristics of a user interface component that may change in response to user action or automated processes. States do not affect the nature of the component, but represent data associated with the component or user interaction possibilities. Examples include focus, hover, select, press, check, and expand/collapse”
15 November 2017: Graphics Contrast and UI Component Contrast: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Graphics_and_UI_Contrast20171109/results - Add definition for state “a dynamic property expressing characteristics of a user interface component that may change in response to user action or automated processes. States do not affect the nature of the component, but represent data associated with the component or user interaction possibilities. Examples include focus, hover, select, press, check, visited/unvisited, and expand/collapse
14 November 2017: Zoom Content: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ZoomContent_20171109/results - SC criteria accepted as is, with 1 objection
14 November 2017: Responses to comments https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ZoomContent_20171109/results - Accept proposed responses to survey as ammended.
14 November 2017: Graphics contrast - Leave Open, discuss tomorrow. Issue around borders, most can live with 3:1
14 November 2017: Graphics contrast - 3:1 ratio has been accepted.
7 November 2017: Interruptions Minimum - We leave Interruptions Minimum open
7 November 2017: Character Key Shortcuts - accept comments and amend understanding document per issue #451
7 November 2017: concurrent SC - Move Concurrent input to AAA
7 November 2017: concurrent SC - Accepted as amended
7 November 2017: concurrent SC - Accepted for next draft https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/wiki/WCAG_2.1/targets
6 November 2017: Exit criteria - Accepted by the group
6 November 2017: Label in accessible name - Response to 557 accepted and posted
2 November 2017: Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Misc_Oct31/results (only #3 on Candidate exit criteria) - leave open
2 November 2017: TPAC Decisions - Decision can be made at TPAC. We will group items with consideration to schedules, and do CFCs for spec changes
31 October 2017: Problem with Technique G131 - Defer for a later time
31 October 2017: Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Oct_31_2017/ (#1 and #5) - accept as amended
31 October 2017: Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Misc_Oct31/results - Accept as amended https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/w3c-wai-gl/2017OctDec/0283.html (Lisa objection)
31 October 2017: Conforming alternatve versions need labels - Handle through changes in understanding
31 October 2017: Candidate Rec Exit Criteria - Leave open talk about on Thursday.
26 October 2017: The rewrite of label in name needs images of text #484 - Leave open
26 October 2017: Response to Comment on 2.4.12 Accessible Name #477 - Accept items 2 and 4 as proposed
26 October 2017: 3. Suggested Grammar fix on User Interface components SC #513 - Accepted as proposed.
24 October 2017: Response to 327 - Leave open. SteveR and MikeG will review and report back.
24 October 2017: survey item 7, proposed response to changing handles on SC - accept response as ammended
24 October 2017: question 8 from survey, proposed response - leave open, AKW and AC will work
19 October 2017: Response to comment on 2.4.11 Character Key Shortcuts #501 - leave open until Tuesday so JF and James can discuss and find a solution
19 October 2017: UIC Contrast - Leave UIC Contrast discussion for TPAC
19 October 2017: Commit for Need an "AND" rather than "OR" in Purpose of controls #405 - Accept as proposed. Will ssend out CFC on this!
17 October 2017: Changes to Understanding document structure? - Benefits to now be a sibling of Intent
17 October 2017: SC Orientation Text: Locking is not the accessibility problem #509 - Accepted Content is operable in all display orientations supported by the user agent, except where display orientation is essential.
17 October 2017: Response to comment on Mitsue-Links Accessibility Dept. C 3.2.7 Change of Content: Avoid using the term "control" #506 - Accept David’s 2 edits.
10 October 2017: Implementation process (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG21_impl/) - this was already surveyed but people wanted more time. - Leave open
10 October 2017: in graphics contrast - Alastair and Jason to wordsmith and send to list
10 October 2017: in graphics contrast - Leave open Alex and Alastair to clarify.
10 October 2017: in graphics contrast - Leave open Alex and Alastair to clarify.
10 October 2017: in graphics contrast - leave open, discuss 'essential' later
5 October 2017: Survey on Essential cases: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/essential_breakout/ - Accept 2,4,5,7,9
5 October 2017: Survey on Essential cases: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/essential_breakout/ - resolution to accept "In accessible authentication" as amended
5 October 2017: CONTENT on hover or Focus - leave open
3 October 2017: Requirement for PDF to Interactive - Accepted as proposed in github survey
3 October 2017: 4. And/or in SC2.2.7 Accessible Authentication #325 - Leave open until Lisa S available for discussion
3 October 2017: Success Criterion 3.2.7 Change of Content #365 - Proposed definition for Programatic Notification to go to CFC
3 October 2017: In Graphics Contrast - Leave open and come back on Thursday
3 October 2017: AGWG Work Items progress check in and sign-ups: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22AGWG+Work+item%22 - John Foliot to update the pull request
3 October 2017: AGWG Work Items progress check in and sign-ups: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22AGWG+Work+item%22 - Rachael to take on issue 403
3 October 2017: AGWG Work Items progress check in and sign-ups: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22AGWG+Work+item%22 - Jake Abma to take on issue 307
3 October 2017: AGWG Work Items progress check in and sign-ups: https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22AGWG+Work+item%22 - Assign both 211 and 302 to John Foliot, with Andy Heath assisting on 302 and John Kirkwood assisting with 211
28 September 2017: PR for: Sync Accessible Name SC language with existing WCAG terminology #371 - Accepted as amended
28 September 2017: PR for:Use of "essential" #372 and comment #333 - Accepted #393
28 September 2017: PR for: Correct all uses of Essential - Leave open
28 September 2017: Use of the term 'easily available' https://github.com/w3c/wcag21/issues/373 (with Lisa) - leave open
26 September 2017: SC Numbering - Accept Michael's proposal on WCAG 2.1 numbering and IDs
26 September 2017: Resolving Issues Survey (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/resolvingissues1/results) - Issues 154, 375, 157, 153 accepted as proposed
26 September 2017: Issue 379 - Accept as proposed, Issue 379
26 September 2017: Issue 373 - One or more concrete proposals needed for issue 373 - A mechanism is easily available
19 September 2017: Survey on SC ordering: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG21_sort_order/results - leaving open
19 September 2017: Merging SC - set a goal that we want to avoid merging but not take it off the table entirely. case by case - file issue for specific mergings.
12 September 2017: 1) New SCs - To Merge or not to merge? Survey https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/SC_merge/ - Leave this open. Needs more discussion.
12 September 2017: 2) Implementation testing process - (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG21_impl/). - Leave this open. Will discuss after more have answered the survey next week.
29 August 2017: ACT Rules Format draft publication survey - Publish the ACT Rules Format 1.0 second draft and three examples rules
22 August 2017: Printing – Issue 76 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/extra_sc/results#xmatf1 - SC to be tided up and definition written and CFC to follow
22 August 2017: Animation – Issue 18 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/extra_sc/results#xanim - Accepted to editors draft at AAA
22 August 2017: Device sensors - Issue 67 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC10 - Device sensors accepted to editors draft
22 August 2017: Undo - Issue 38 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC3 - Undo not accepted into editors draft.
22 August 2017: Issue 41 Plain Language - Undo not accept plain language into editors draft.
17 August 2017: Pointer Gestures Issue 61 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC7 - accepted as amended
17 August 2017: Metadata - Issue 82 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xsc12 - Accepted as proposed.
17 August 2017: Pointer inputs with additional sensors - Issue 66 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC9 - Defer for later consideration in WCAG 2.2 or later
17 August 2017: Printing Issue 76 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/extra_sc/results#xmatf1 - leave open for more discussion
15 August 2017: Timeouts - Issue 14 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC1 - Accepted to editors draft with the addition of a note on user consent and editors note
15 August 2017: Personalization - Issue 6 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC13 - Accepted as amended with MCs mc2 branch.
10 August 2017: Personalization - issue 6 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC13 - Accepted as proposed for the AA Personalization item, with an objection from Alex.
10 August 2017: Personalization - issue 6 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC13 - presonalization AAA accepted
10 August 2017: Personalization - issue 6 https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC13 - Popup Visibility accepted for CFC
8 August 2017: meeting time (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/mastiempo/results) - Extend the calls starting Thursday August 10. Split scribing for long call. ... Extend the calls starting Thursday August 10th. Split scribing for long call.
8 August 2017: Concurrent Input Mechanisms (https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Final_prelockdown_set/results#xSC8) - Accept as amended.
3 August 2017: Plain Language: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/sc_august2017 (only item 2) - No consensus yet.
1 August 2017: Popup - Leave open. Alex to work with Steve on new wording.
1 August 2017: pointer gestures - leave open resurvey
25 July 2017: Personalization https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/LatestPersonalization/results - Partially clean up definitions and bring back next week.
25 July 2017: Target size https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/target_size/results - Keep the AAA version of target size
25 July 2017: Target size https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/target_size/results - Accept AA version with editors note about exception for groups of links
25 July 2017: Confirm Important Information https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/confirm-impt-info/results - Continue work on transaction definition and scope
18 July 2017: Adapting Text: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AdaptingTextJuly6/results - Accept to editor's draft. CFC to follow
18 July 2017: Conformance changes: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/62-63-71-conformance/results - Accept version posted by AWK at 12:02. Also create an issue for clarifications to be made in understanding document.
13 July 2017: Undo : https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/COGA_undo/results - Leave open for further edits from Lisa, Mike and Alastair
11 July 2017: Resolving Issues 62/63/71: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Issues64-67-68/results - pursue approach on modification to conformace section
11 July 2017: Adapting Text (continued): https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AdaptingTextJuly6/results - leave open
11 July 2017: Personalization - leave open
6 July 2017: Adapting Text: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AdaptingTextJuly6/ - leave open UNDO
6 July 2017: Adapting Text: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AdaptingTextJuly6/ - Adapting Text accepted into editors draft
29 June 2017: Concurrent Input Mechanisms (cont) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/MATFSC_june/results#xnew1 - send back to Mobile task force for better examples
29 June 2017: Support personalisation (minimum) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/COGA_new/results - leave this one open
27 June 2017: Concurrent Input Mechanisms https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/MATFSC_june/results#xnew1 - Leave Open
27 June 2017: Support personalization (minimum) https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/COGA_new/results#xq4 - Leave open
22 June 2017: 1. Speech Input / Accessibility Name #68 - success criteria Accessible Name accepted for editors draft with minor editorial changes (i.e., removing the note)
20 June 2017: Device Sensors/User Interface Component Contrast (Minimum): https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Top3_18Apr2017/results - Device Sensors - Accept this SC into editors draft and include an Editor note to say that the preference of the group is to alter an existing SC rather than add a new one.
20 June 2017: User Interface Component Contrast - Accepted User Interface Component Contrast (Minimum) #10 into editors draft.
20 June 2017: Accessible Authentication: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/COGA_Auth/results - Accepted into Working draft accessible authentication #23
15 June 2017: Accessible Authentication: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/COGA_Auth/results - Leave open
8 June 2017: Orientation: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/MATF_orientation/ - Put Orientation SC into the next editor's draft
6 June 2017: AGWG summer schedule https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AWAG_summer_2017/results - We do not have consensus to publish new WCAG 2.0 edited recommendation
6 June 2017: AGWG summer schedule https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AWAG_summer_2017/results - Accepted as proposed “Approval process for Understanding documents”
6 June 2017: AGWG summer schedule https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AWAG_summer_2017/results - Accepted as proposed, with need for futher clarifications in understanding doc
6 June 2017: AGWG summer schedule https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/AWAG_summer_2017/results - leave this open
30 May 2017: change of content: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/SCreview_May_17/results#xq10 - The working group has accepted this SC for inclusion in the Editor's draft
25 May 2017: Resize Content: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ResizeContent-issue77/ - Leave open, alastair to work on edits
25 May 2017: Resize Content: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ResizeContent-issue77/ - Leave open.
23 May 2017: Supplementary document(s) survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG21_supp/ - the working group has agreed to publishing supplemental guidance in 1 document that is non-normative
23 May 2017: Target Size: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/SCreview_May_17/#wbsq4 - Target Size proposal accepted
18 May 2017: 1.3.3/1.4.1 - go for CFC
18 May 2017: Resize Content: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ResizeContent-issue77/results - Leave open
18 May 2017: Target Size: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/SCreview_May_17/#wbsq4 - Leave open
16 May 2017: Resize Content: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/ResizeContent-issue77/results - Leave open
16 May 2017: Plain Language: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/plainLanguage-min-Issue30/ - leave open
16 May 2017: Target Size: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/SCreview_May_17/#wbsq4 - Leave open
9 May 2017: Resize content #77 CFC - Removing Resize Content #77
4 May 2017: Timeouts: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Timeouts_Issue14/results - Leave open while final adjustments are made. See issues.
4 May 2017: Minimize user errors: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/minimize-user-errors-13/results - Leave open
4 May 2017: Single Key Shortcut Alternative: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Top3_18Apr2017/#wbssc - Leave Open
2 May 2017: Single Key Shortcut Alternative: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/Top3_18Apr2017/results#xsc - Leave Open
2 May 2017: Timeouts: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/minimize-user-errors-13/results - Leave Open
25 April 2017: Suggestion to change SC review schedule to make it easier. - Success criteria will be released every two weeks
25 April 2017: SC managers and comments - overview of process. - Success criteria will be released every two weeks
18 April 2017: Accessible Authentication: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/SCs_April_11/#wbsq10 - leave open
13 April 2017: Adapting Text options discussion - Group to review options for split SC on the list
11 April 2017: TPAC F2F - AG meeting will be happening at TPAC
11 April 2017: SC Review - accept Accidental Activation ... Accept Accidental Activation SC
11 April 2017: Support Personalization - go back to COGA for reviewing comments and further work
11 April 2017: Adapting text options - Needs more discussion.
6 April 2017: Target size - Working group will resurvey this item language proposal
6 April 2017: Adapting Text - Options for Adapting Text to be surveyed
4 April 2017: Adapting Text - Needs more work.
28 March 2017: User Interface Component Contrast (Minimum) - Leave open, with final contrast ratio to be determined next week.
21 March 2017: adapting text - No consensus yet
7 March 2017: Linearization - Take up Linearization next week.
21 February 2017: FPWD Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/WCAG21FWPD/ - Publish as FPWD
14 February 2017: SC Proposal: Graphics Contrast (Issue 9) - Accept pull request into editor's draft
14 February 2017: SC Proposal: Interruptions (minimum) (Issue 47) - Accept pull request into editor's draft
7 February 2017: Testing Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/testing20170207/results - User testing is not a required part of a manual testing process for WCAG test criteria.
7 February 2017: Testing Survey: https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35422/testing20170207/results - WG agrees that SC should have a high degree of confidence of inter-rater reliability, approximated by the expectation that 8 of 10 experts in a area would agree.

Minutes