Bug List

This is an archived snapshot of W3C's public bugzilla bug tracker, decommissioned in April 2019. Please see the home page for more details.

This archived bug list includes all the bugs for the product or component specified, including bugs that have been resolved.

Mon Apr 1 2019 03:39:04 UTC

Hide Search Description

Component: pre-LC1 HTML5 spec (editor: Ian Hickson)
Product: HTML WG

2547 bugs found. <

ID	Product	Comp	Assignee	Status	Resolution	Summary	Opened	Changed
5729	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	test issue	2008-06-06	2010-10-04
5744	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	CLOS	WONT	Improved Fragment Identifiers	2008-06-13	2011-01-26
5749	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	test IGNORE ME	2008-06-14	2010-10-04
5750	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	another test IGNORE ME	2008-06-14	2010-10-04
5751	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	IGNORE ME (sorry for noise...)	2008-06-14	2010-10-04
5752	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	CLOS	WONT	Parsing should be specified for future updates	2008-06-14	2010-10-04
5753	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	parsing issues with legacy UAs	2008-06-14	2010-10-04
5754	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	List elements content model issues	2008-06-14	2010-10-04
5756	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Need interactive UA norms for exposing (non-displayed) HTML document data	2008-06-14	2010-10-04
5757	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	MediaElement features are needed on OBJECT element	2008-06-14	2010-10-04
5759	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Newly introduced void elements are not mentioned in "Writing HTML Documents" section	2008-06-15	2010-10-04
5766	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	priority request: reply to outline e-mail	2008-06-17	2010-10-04
5768	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	content sniffing should be allowed on link elements with a relationship type of icon	2008-06-18	2010-10-04
5769	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	HTMLMediaElement.currentLoop readonly?	2008-06-18	2010-10-04
5773	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Authors need more control over handling of linked resources	2008-06-19	2010-10-04
5777	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	referencing subordinate text or asides should be through an alternate attribute	2008-06-20	2010-10-04
5787	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Rename "script that will execute as soon as the parser resumes"	2008-06-23	2010-10-04
5792	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	li/dd/dt end tag in body when no corresponding elt on stack	2008-06-24	2010-10-04
5793	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Cross-reference "as if"	2008-06-24	2010-10-04
5796	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<li><div><p><li> no longer matches IE	2008-06-24	2010-10-04
5798	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Deferring end tag eating to after head gives weird errors	2008-06-24	2010-10-04
5801	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Conformance rules for xmlns unintuitively different for HTML and foreign content	2008-06-25	2010-10-04
5802	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	No mention of %uXXXX escapes	2008-06-25	2010-10-04
5803	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	CLOS	FIXE	HTML5 serialization is not compatible with XSLT	2008-06-25	2010-10-04
5807	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	User Agent display of title attribute content not defined	2008-06-26	2010-10-04
5808	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Define a way to coerce HTML5 parser output to an XML 1.0 4th ed. + Namespaces 1.0 infoset	2008-06-26	2010-10-04
5809	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Mitigate data loss when conforming documents are coerced to XML 1.0	2008-06-26	2010-10-04
5814	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	WebIDL: Resolve the callback issue	2008-06-27	2010-10-04
5815	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	foreignObject in the SVG namespace should be scoping	2008-06-27	2010-10-04
5820	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Work on WebSockets	2008-06-28	2010-10-04
5821	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	RESO	NEED	meta/@scheme missing	2008-06-29	2010-10-04
5822	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	CLOS	FIXE	The headers attribute should be able to reference a td	2008-06-30	2010-10-04
5823	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	Scope allowable on a td	2008-06-30	2010-10-04
5830	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Work on video	2008-07-03	2010-10-04
5831	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	WebIDL: mark up constructors in IDL	2008-07-03	2010-10-04
5833	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Work on standalone apps ideas	2008-07-04	2010-10-04
5834	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<area alt=""> has no author-level conformance requirement	2008-07-04	2010-10-04
5835	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	no apparent mechanism for applying a caption to a fieldset	2008-07-05	2010-10-04
5836	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	Syntax section allows <ins><p></ins>	2008-07-06	2010-10-04
5837	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Rename CDATA block state to CDATA section state	2008-07-06	2010-10-04
5839	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Work on Worker Threads	2008-07-07	2010-10-04
5846	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Accessing Object Parameters from an Embedded SVG	2008-07-09	2010-10-04
5848	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Write the "fetching" section	2008-07-09	2010-10-04
5850	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	JS global object	2008-07-10	2010-10-04
5856	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	height/width DOM attributes in combination with display:none	2008-07-11	2010-10-04
5858	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Case marked as fragment when it can occur at other times	2008-07-11	2010-10-04
5859	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Spec doesn't handle unknown schemes	2008-07-12	2010-10-04
5863	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Tokeniser: "Bogus comment" state unclear	2008-07-13	2010-10-04
5866	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	SVG in HTML	2008-07-14	2010-10-04
5881	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Make tokeniser data states headers visible in table of contents	2008-07-18	2010-10-04
5883	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	data: URLs	2008-07-21	2010-10-04
5895	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Require attributes on <embed> and data-* attributes to be lowercase	2008-07-24	2010-10-04
5897	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Make &ohm; and &angst; expand to their NFC equivalents	2008-07-25	2010-10-04
5898	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Don't convert attributes to lowercase for localName/nodeName	2008-07-25	2010-10-04
5899	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Allow uppercase "CHARSET=" in legacy encoding decl	2008-07-25	2010-10-04
5909	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Need a solution for replaceable properties	2008-07-29	2010-10-04
5927	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	WF2: HTMLInputElement need some improvements	2008-08-04	2010-10-04
5933	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	<video muted> issues	2008-08-06	2010-10-04
5936	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Offline cache syntax section needs an example	2008-08-07	2010-10-04
5937	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	make cache manifest syntax more extensible	2008-08-07	2010-10-04
5941	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	<video>.width/height should have default values defined	2008-08-07	2010-10-04
5944	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Unclear wording, section 8.2.3.1	2008-08-09	2010-10-04
5946	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	execCommand('insertHTML') should throw in xml	2008-08-10	2010-10-04
5963	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Editorial: xrefs in media event summary table	2008-08-13	2010-10-04
5964	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	getting width/height on <embed>, <iframe>, <object> and <video>	2008-08-13	2010-10-04
5974	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Language tag sameness should probably be ASCII case-insensitive	2008-08-19	2010-10-04
5979	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	unclear whether new Audio(url) should throw	2008-08-21	2010-10-04
5989	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	alt=""	2008-08-26	2010-10-04
5990	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	SVG in HTML	2008-08-26	2010-10-04
5991	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	workers	2008-08-26	2010-10-04
5994	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add note in syntax section	2008-08-26	2010-10-04
5997	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Define script execution for XHTML5	2008-08-28	2010-10-04
6032	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Serializing a doctype with invalid public id	2008-09-07	2010-10-04
6033	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Forms section	2008-09-07	2010-10-04
6034	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Process <video> feedback	2008-09-07	2010-10-04
6035	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Process appcache feedback	2008-09-07	2010-10-04
6036	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	HTMLCollection.namedItem() should look for non-HTML elements	2008-09-07	2010-10-04
6037	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Elaborate on Web compat characteristics of task queue interaction	2008-09-08	2010-10-04
6038	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"noframes", "script", "style", "title" in 'after head' mode pop prematurely	2008-09-08	2010-10-04
6052	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Should propagate uncaught exceptions from workers to their owner	2008-09-10	2010-10-04
6057	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	in the audio portion of the spec, at the end of 4.7.8.0 it mentions "If the src argument is present..." but the example given calls it the argument 'url'	2008-09-12	2010-10-04
6097	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	[rendering] <body background> is a URL attribute?	2008-09-19	2010-10-04
6098	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	input type=foo as an element-level section	2008-09-19	2010-10-04
6099	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Process notification feedback	2008-09-19	2010-10-04
6100	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Process postMessage feedback	2008-09-19	2010-10-04
6101	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	media elements - ready states - events should be async	2008-09-20	2010-10-04
6102	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Please do not break applet element in HTML 5	2008-09-21	2010-10-04
6103	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	video section editorial issues	2008-09-22	2010-10-04
6104	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	<video> and <audio> should prevent cross-origin media loads	2008-09-22	2010-10-04
6127	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	Deal with origin details in WebSocket and postMessage feedback	2008-09-30	2010-10-04
6132	HTML WG	pre-LC1	w3c	CLOS	FIXE	[sniffing] No whitespace before "<!DOCTYPE HTML" in content sniffing	2008-10-01	2010-10-04
6134	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Run-on sentence in HTML5 spec	2008-10-04	2010-10-04
6143	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Linkify "pending external script"	2008-10-08	2010-10-04
6145	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Label content model should allow <label for=a><input id=a>	2008-10-08	2010-10-04
6153	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Process <eventsource> feedback	2008-10-10	2010-10-04
6176	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Process WebSocket feedback	2008-10-21	2010-10-04
6177	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Process Workers feedback	2008-10-21	2010-10-04
6181	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Process table feedback (including headers='" issue)	2008-10-23	2010-10-04
6182	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	WebIDL - strokeStyle and fillStyle should be of type 'any' not 'DOMObject'	2008-10-23	2010-10-04
6213	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Noscript content model with script allows fragment parse errors	2008-11-10	2010-10-04
6214	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	insertRow without arguments	2008-11-10	2010-10-04
6216	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	<script> in <select>	2008-11-11	2010-10-04
6236	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	scroll bar placement in frames	2008-11-19	2010-10-04
6253	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	<input> bookkeeping aren't consistent	2008-11-27	2010-10-04
6254	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	xref errors in the <input> summary table	2008-11-27	2010-10-04
6256	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Mutation event behavior on document.open() unspecified	2008-11-29	2010-10-04
6257	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Please specify document.write()-safe points in the parse	2008-11-29	2010-10-04
6258	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Changing the encoding doesn't cover non-idempotent navigation	2008-11-29	2010-10-04
6263	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	document.onreadystatechange	2008-12-03	2010-10-04
6293	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	specify that the value attribute on <input type=url> must be an absolute URL	2008-12-10	2010-10-04
6294	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Date microsyntax defines incorrect range for month and day fields	2008-12-10	2010-10-04
6300	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	[references] reference RFC 5322 instead of RFC 2822	2008-12-11	2010-10-04
6336	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	XSLT-compat doctype only allowed for use by XSLT	2008-12-30	2010-10-04
6339	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Define how to deal with onload, ononline, and other document/window-level events	2008-12-31	2010-10-04
6349	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Rewrite the entire script processing model again	2009-01-05	2010-10-04
6350	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Port examples from WF2 to HTML5	2009-01-05	2010-10-04
6351	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Add event handler attributes for all events defined in HTML5	2009-01-05	2010-10-04
6352	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Port acknowledgements from WF2 to HTML5	2009-01-05	2010-10-04
6353	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	play() and pause() don't throw	2009-01-05	2010-10-04
6356	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	00:99:00 is a valid time string	2009-01-05	2010-10-04
6357	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	<script> start tag parsing	2009-01-05	2010-10-04
6370	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Float exponent part unclear about length of sequence	2009-01-06	2010-10-04
6389	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Avoid double parse error on EOF in DOCTYPE state	2009-01-13	2010-10-04
6390	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Add a note about reaching after head state and the fragment mode	2009-01-13	2010-10-04
6423	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Names of confidence flag states inconsistent	2009-01-14	2010-10-04
6434	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	plugins inside fallback content shouldn't be instantiated	2009-01-14	2010-10-04
6437	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	document.location should update when the browsing context is navigated without the Document changing	2009-01-15	2010-10-04
6438	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Error in step 9.4 of the internal algorithm for scanning and assigning header cells	2009-01-15	2010-10-04
6439	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	<area> should stringify href (like <a>)	2009-01-15	2010-10-04
6440	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	To which elements applies the formatBlock command?	2009-01-15	2010-10-04
6457	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	registerContentHandler() and sniffing	2009-01-20	2010-10-04
6460	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Handle onerror feedback for Workers	2009-01-21	2010-10-04
6461	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Fix the definition of "Origin" for Documents from javascript: URLs	2009-01-21	2010-10-04
6462	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Self-reference and cyclic references in headers=''	2009-01-21	2010-10-04
6464	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Support meta refresh with quotes	2009-01-21	2010-10-04
6474	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Event handler DOM attributes on HTMLDocument	2009-01-27	2010-10-04
6475	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	DUPL	Missing event handler attributes	2009-01-27	2010-10-04
6476	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	cross-origin media element loads and progress events	2009-01-27	2010-10-04
6477	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	HTMLInputElement.width and height	2009-01-27	2010-10-04
6490	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Event handler attributes should ignore event's interface	2009-01-29	2010-10-04
6491	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<textarea wrap=off> not supported	2009-01-29	2010-10-17
6493	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Use encoding of POSTing document for POST response if meta prescan fails	2009-01-29	2010-10-04
6494	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Make the requiredness about alt more obvious	2009-01-29	2010-10-04
6497	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Examples using title="" with line breaks	2009-01-29	2010-10-04
6507	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Paragraphs section doesn't list all transparent elements	2009-01-30	2010-10-04
6508	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	XHTML doctype without system identifier	2009-01-30	2010-10-04
6515	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	the body element event handler attributes and missing Window object	2009-02-02	2010-10-04
6516	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	obsolete attributes on HTMLDocument assume there is a body element	2009-02-02	2010-10-04
6529	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	value DOM attribute for input element in File Upload state	2009-02-04	2010-10-04
6536	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Time element examples should be in the context of a goal-oriented microformat use case	2009-02-06	2010-10-04
6543	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Mint a new element for figure captions	2009-02-09	2010-10-04
6544	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Allow width=0 on <img> and <iframe>	2009-02-09	2010-10-04
6556	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	When parsing legacy color returns an error	2009-02-11	2010-10-04
6562	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Define parsing quirks	2009-02-12	2010-10-04
6563	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Specify if innerHTML setting should use the quirkiness of the document	2009-02-12	2010-10-04
6585	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Rendering: <marquee bgcolor>	2009-02-16	2010-10-04
6586	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Zero margin quirk not quite right	2009-02-16	2010-10-04
6590	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	character encoding mapping needs to be used for form submission too	2009-02-17	2010-10-04
6608	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	please undeprecate <center> for older browsers	2009-02-22	2010-10-04
6609	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	negative keywords-not meta tags	2009-02-22	2010-10-04
6610	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	add a preventable forced-fragment method	2009-02-22	2010-10-04
6613	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Allow <meta charset="UTF-8"/> in XHTML	2009-02-23	2010-10-04
6614	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Restricting multiple character encoding declarations per document	2009-02-23	2010-10-04
6618	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	</body> and </html> early on handled in a Gecko/WebKit/Presto-inconsisten way	2009-02-24	2010-10-04
6628	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	WebSocket.URL and EventSource.URL should return the absolute URL	2009-02-27	2010-10-04
6630	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Optionalness of start tags when element is empty	2009-02-27	2010-10-04
6637	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Put boolean and enumerated attributes next to each other	2009-02-28	2010-10-04
6652	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	spellcheck should allow empty string	2009-03-05	2010-10-04
6656	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	make clear that Referer headers track the pushState()d URL	2009-03-05	2010-10-04
6659	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	textarea also needs text-indent:initial	2009-03-06	2010-10-04
6662	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Make clearer that "the script's encoding" doesn't refer to the encoding of the script file itself	2009-03-07	2010-10-04
6669	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Rendering: s/disabled/enabled/ for noscript	2009-03-09	2010-10-04
6670	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Allow unescaped &s, at least in attributes that accept URLs	2009-03-09	2011-11-23
6684	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Disregard of RFC 4329 and IANA MIME Media Types	2009-03-11	2014-12-18
6689	HTML WG	pre-LC1	silviapfeiffer1	RESO	FIXE	Removing remaining mention of Element.setAttributeNode()	2009-03-12	2012-10-14
6690	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Document.renameNode() is not part of Web DOM	2009-03-12	2010-10-04
6729	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Attribute getters/setters should lower case argument on HTML elements in HTML docs	2009-03-24	2010-10-04
6736	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	dfn.js doesn't handle class="impl"	2009-03-24	2010-10-04
6742	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	pre-encoded form values should be restorable as submitted	2009-03-27	2010-10-04
6743	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	AAA still reads from the DOM	2009-03-27	2010-10-04
6746	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	case-insensitivity of other than a-z and A-Z, e.g., diacritics	2009-03-29	2010-10-04
6750	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	<header><blockquote><h1> issues	2009-04-02	2010-10-04
6759	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	event queueing rules for <img> are nonsensical	2009-04-02	2010-10-04
6760	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"string" misspelled as "stirng"	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6762	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Typos and spelling mistakes	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6763	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Inconsistent use of American and British English	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6764	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Section 2.4.4.1 Non-negative integers - Step 9.4 refers to incorrect step	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6765	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Poor wording in 4.8.2.1.12 General guidelines	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6766	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	document.all definition missing	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6767	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	<time> warning regarding Gregorian calendar	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6768	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	4.8.10.3 Media types -- unclear note	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6769	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Grammar mistake: "element element"?	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6770	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Term emphasis inconsistencies in Terminology section	2009-04-03	2010-10-04
6771	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Sectioning Content Use versus DIV	2009-04-04	2010-10-04
6774	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	<mark> element: restrict insertion by other servers	2009-04-05	2010-10-22
6776	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Note the XSLT implications of assigning HTML elements into the http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml namespace	2009-04-06	2010-10-04
6778	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Note the XPath implications of assigning HTML elements into the http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml namespace	2009-04-06	2010-10-04
6779	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Clarify the difference between elements and tags	2009-04-06	2010-10-04
6784	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	WebStorage should include Window IDL for Storage APIs	2009-04-07	2010-10-04
6790	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	object element with usemap attribute should be in "Interactive content" category	2009-04-08	2010-10-04
6796	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<keygen> in <select>	2009-04-09	2010-10-04
6812	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Typo: JavsScript	2009-04-15	2010-10-04
6832	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<datagrid> content model is silly	2009-04-18	2010-10-04
6833	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Datagrid minor comments	2009-04-18	2010-10-04
6834	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	add more number bases to form inputs?	2009-04-20	2010-10-04
6835	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The multiple attribute on datagrid	2009-04-20	2010-10-04
6841	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	add IDs+titles to tables documenting <input> element keywords/states and attributes/methods	2009-04-22	2010-10-04
6842	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	make it possible/easy to link to tables documenting <input> element keywords/states and attributes/methods	2009-04-22	2010-10-04
6853	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	DUPL	restore meta keywords, search engines use them	2009-04-29	2010-10-04
6854	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	if attribute values enumerated, allow case-sensitivity for meta content values	2009-04-29	2010-10-04
6858	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	More details needed for "ASCII-compatible encoding"	2009-05-01	2010-10-04
6894	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	add statement that the "checked" attribute on <input> is a boolean attribute	2009-05-09	2010-10-04
6898	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Case shifting terminology is confusing	2009-05-11	2010-10-04
6902	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Note incompatibilities with RDF serializations	2009-05-13	2010-10-04
6949	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Don't use colon shorthand when talking about language-related attributes	2009-05-24	2010-10-04
6953	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	clearly specify that misnested tags are an authoring-conformance error	2009-05-26	2010-10-04
6973	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Support <textarea>.textLength	2009-05-28	2010-10-04
6974	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Please be explicit about inheritance of scripting flag when setting innerHTML	2009-05-28	2010-10-04
6976	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	Image Map Example fails Validation	2009-05-28	2010-10-04
6977	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Unnecessary sentence in <cite> presentation	2009-05-29	2010-10-04
6978	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Mark eof-terminated script elements as malformed	2009-05-29	2010-10-04
6992	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Title of Web IDL misspelled as WebIDL	2009-06-03	2010-10-04
6993	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Tell authoring tools to use UTF-8	2009-06-03	2010-10-04
6999	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Adding tag <NSFW>	2009-06-05	2010-10-04
7003	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Typos	2009-06-07	2010-10-04
7010	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	Making <applet> non-conforming may hinder royalty-free <video> adoption	2009-06-10	2010-10-04
7030	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Define "Text" content model	2009-06-16	2010-10-04
7032	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Sandboxing and Referer	2009-06-17	2010-10-04
7034	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	authoring conformance requirements in the spec should either be removed or replaced	2009-06-18	2010-10-04
7035	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	NEED	clarify what the use case is for first illustration under "3.4 Content models"	2009-06-19	2010-10-04
7051	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	add new extended attribute to IDLs with DOM attributes that reflect content attributes	2009-06-23	2010-10-04
7056	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<caption> and <figure><legend> elements should allow flow content children	2009-06-25	2010-10-04
7059	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Forking XPath	2009-06-26	2010-10-04
7061	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	NEED	clarify definition of "sectioning content"	2009-06-28	2010-10-04
7062	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	NEED	replace terms "CDATA element" and "RCDATA element" with... something better	2009-06-29	2010-10-04
7075	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	The embed element should be deprecated	2009-07-03	2010-10-04
7076	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Client-side image maps attributes missing on the a element	2009-07-03	2010-12-07
7079	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Inconsistency in algorithm descriptions for parsing integers	2009-07-05	2010-10-04
7080	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Grammatical error in DOM trees section	2009-07-05	2010-10-04
7084	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<ul><li>A<ul></li>B is parsed backwards-incompatibly	2009-07-07	2010-10-04
7086	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	<a> should be </a> in section 4.5.3 of the HTML5 specification	2009-07-07	2010-10-04
7089	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	CDATA escapes need to close upon --\s*!>	2009-07-08	2010-10-04
7102	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Permitted obsolete doctype compare "HTML"	2009-07-14	2010-10-04
7103	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Content-Language marked as non-conforming	2009-07-14	2010-10-04
7105	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	Default fallback behaviour for unsupported tags in browsers!	2009-07-15	2010-10-04
7137	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Need to fill in the references section.	2009-07-24	2010-10-04
7138	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Need to get window.mediaMode into another spec	2009-07-24	2010-10-04
7139	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	test	2009-07-24	2010-10-04
7140	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	test	2009-07-25	2010-10-04
7141	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Typo: "A members..."	2009-07-25	2010-10-04
7142	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Shouldn't SERIALISE_ERR be SERIALIZE_ERR ?	2009-07-25	2010-10-04
7143	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"attributes marked with an asterisk cannot be specified on body elements" is confusing, since <body onload=""> is pretty common. Of course that's the attribute specified on a tag, but still, I'm just a simple author reading the spec for the first time :)	2009-07-25	2010-10-04
7144	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	I am not sure if we are ditching ALT in favour of legend. You don't make this clear here. Some of your alt examples here resemble longdesc, which I am in favour of ditching completely. I'd be interested to see your answer on whatwg list about this	2009-07-25	2010-10-04
7145	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Valid date strings should accept ambiguous inputs, like "2009" or "2007-01".	2009-07-26	2010-10-04
7146	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	goog	2009-07-27	2010-10-04
7147	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	s#one of the optional U+002F SOLIDUS (/) characters#the optional U+002F SOLIDUS (/) character#	2009-07-27	2010-10-04
7150	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Why do these examples have uppercase elements?	2009-07-27	2010-10-04
7151	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	s/users/user	2009-07-27	2010-10-04
7152	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"When the user agent has completely fetched of the entire media resource, […]" No 'of' and only one of 'completely' or 'entire' should remain in the text. Mentioned one week ago on the list. Taking the opportunity to try this inline review box.	2009-07-27	2010-10-04
7153	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Want standardization of .naturalWidth and .naturalHeight, which some browsers already have	2009-07-27	2010-10-04
7154	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	icon attribute: We can't apply so-called "CSS Sprite" technique for command icons. We need another attribute to specify clip position and size.	2009-07-27	2010-10-04
7156	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	I would like to see theora/vorbis as HTML5 standard. I'm tired of codec patents.	2009-07-28	2010-10-04
7157	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	I would like to see theora/vorbis as HTML5 standard. I'm tired of codec patents.	2009-07-28	2010-10-04
7158	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	this is a discribing comment	2009-07-28	2010-10-08
7161	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	If a heading has title text and then an image below it, then more text, how is the figure element handled in header and hgroup elements?	2009-07-29	2010-10-04
7164	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	teste	2009-07-29	2010-10-04
7171	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Is this missing a comment as to how the type attribute is quoted wrt:codecs? "''" + '""'	2009-07-29	2010-10-04
7175	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	clearTimeout and clearInterval are not in the dom-intro box	2009-07-30	2010-10-04
7176	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	The link to [GREGORIAN] doesn't seem to work...	2009-07-30	2010-10-04
7179	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<xmp> should close <p> (does in IE and WebKit)	2009-07-31	2010-10-04
7185	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	itemprop needs to be after item; no longer a-z ordered due to the name change prolly.	2009-08-01	2010-10-04
7186	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	oppo n iuniu in niun iun lin in liunniuniuniun i	2009-08-01	2010-10-04
7188	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	how to use "item" in xhtml5? item="item" ?!	2009-08-01	2010-10-04
7189	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	how to use "item" in xhtml5? item="item" ?!	2009-08-01	2010-10-04
7190	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Since all "specially focusable" elements have an activation behaviour, the Action of accesskey-laden commands is to _not_ focus them if they are focusable. Instead, such elements should probably always be focused if focusable, then be activated.	2009-08-02	2010-10-04
7199	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	microformat	2009-08-03	2010-10-04
7211	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	define "positive integer" and use it consistently, instead of "non-negative integer greater than zero"	2009-08-04	2010-10-04
7213	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	todataurl	2009-08-04	2010-10-04
7214	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Typo: "When an input element's type attribute is in the Telphone state"	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7215	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	character encodings and XML	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7219	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	http://abu---wisam.ahlamontada.net	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7220	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	http://abu---wisam.ahlamontada.net	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7221	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	www.abu---wisam.ahlamontada.net	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7222	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	http://abu---wisam.ahlamontada.net	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7224	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Crash in application C++ exception Unsupported file format header 46466c17	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7225	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	http://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=7224	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7226	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	has enabled --> have enabled	2009-08-05	2010-10-04
7227	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	using both "conforming but obsolete" (12.1) and "obsolete but conforming" (12.1.1) - consistency in terminology may be helpful	2009-08-06	2010-10-04
7229	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	input.files should return the same object	2009-08-06	2010-10-04
7232	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	add <iframe> to list of CDATA elements in the "Writing HTML documents" section	2009-08-06	2010-10-04
7234	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	review 123	2009-08-06	2010-10-04
7237	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Let current outlinee be null. (It holds the element whose outline is being created.) Spelling. Outline with one "e"	2009-08-06	2011-03-19
7238	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	more examples	2009-08-07	2010-10-04
7241	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Need to explain exactly what happens if wrap=hard is specified without cols being specified. Should it act like wrap=soft, or like cols=20?	2009-08-07	2010-10-04
7243	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	no mension of h3c?	2009-08-08	2010-10-04
7246	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Add examples for <keygen>	2009-08-09	2010-10-04
7248	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	sxdfsdf	2009-08-09	2010-10-04
7254	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	If <audio> was able to play back multiple source urls without gaps, JavaScript could decode or generate continuous audio to data: urls on the fly.	2009-08-10	2010-10-04
7255	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"This will either return a year and month" --> "This will return either a year and month"	2009-08-10	2010-10-04
7256	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"which is not a real time zone currently" --> which is not currently a real time zone	2009-08-10	2010-10-04
7258	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Should state that a new Date object is returned each time the date/time/timezone attributes are accessed if the intention is for them not to be reflecting datetime="" or the element content.	2009-08-11	2010-10-04
7259	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	dfgsgdfsg dgf	2009-08-11	2010-10-04
7261	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	In the third code example, a code element is opened but a </cite> tag closes it. The opening tag should be <cite>.	2009-08-11	2010-10-04
7263	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	this thing really heavy, tried solution: switch to user mode css, after all rendered, return to author mode, scrolling is heavy though,,, try open panel & add info, heavy too..	2009-08-12	2010-10-04
7264	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	make <% start a bogus comment	2009-08-12	2010-10-04
7265	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	the HTML5 validator says maxlength is not allowed on textarea	2009-08-12	2010-10-04
7266	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Section states twice in green that other specs can define other event loops, can remove one of those	2009-08-12	2010-10-04
7268	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	contradicts 4.7.1 wrt implied paragraph boundaries (should not in 4.7.1, not good practice in 4.7.4). dont repeat example or simplify	2009-08-13	2010-10-04
7269	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	user agent requirements: for value=8 max="", step 4 and 11 will cause current value and maximum value to be set to 1, which is destructive (if script wanted to obtain the original value). suggest step 4 change to set maximum to value	2009-08-13	2010-10-04
7272	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The explanatory text and the diagram suggest that legs and tails should be th, rather than td -- but the example has td. JimJJewett@gmail	2009-08-14	2010-10-04
7273	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The word "left" should not be part of the link when saying that attributes can be left unquoted. It sounds too much like "left outer join" or such, and might imply that it was legal to unquote only one side, or some such oddness. JimJJewett@gmail	2009-08-14	2010-10-04
7274	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	The word "left" should not be part of the link when saying that attributes can be left unquoted. It sounds too much like "left outer join" or such, and might imply that it was legal to unquote only one side, or some such oddness. JimJJewett@gmail	2009-08-14	2010-10-04
7275	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"The markup snippet at the top of this section" should be a link to that snippet; the section is long enough that the snippet will already have scrolled off-screen for some people. (In my case, it had also escaped my short-term memory.) JimJJewett@gmail	2009-08-14	2010-10-04
7276	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	"tree order" -- is this a section that can assume formal compsci training, or should a short (4 nodes?) example be given? JimJJewett@gmail	2009-08-14	2010-10-04
7277	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	"""(This is only a "SHOULD" and not a "MUST" requirement because it has been proven to be impossible.""" There has to be better wording than 'should do the impossible'. Should attempt to verify? Impossible in some cases? JimJJewett@gmail	2009-08-14	2010-10-04
7278	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	numbers seem ignorant of i18n - is <meter>10,3</meter> taken as 10? requirements for number may expand to include, i.e.: U+002C COMMA for European №	2009-08-14	2010-10-04
7280	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	new comment	2009-08-14	2010-10-04
7281	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	<script language="javascript" type="text/javascript">	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7282	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add dummy willValidate() and company to object	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7283	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7284	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7285	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7286	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7287	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7288	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7289	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7290	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7291	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7292	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7293	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7294	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7295	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7296	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7297	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7298	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7299	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	mark up examples	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7300	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7301	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7302	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7303	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7304	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7305	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7307	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7308	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7309	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7310	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7311	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7312	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples for tables	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7313	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7314	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7315	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7316	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7317	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7318	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7319	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7320	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7321	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7322	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7323	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7324	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7325	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7326	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7327	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7328	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7329	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7330	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7331	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7332	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7333	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7334	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7335	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7336	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7337	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7338	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7339	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7340	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7341	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7342	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7343	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7344	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7345	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7346	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7347	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples for <command>	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7348	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	add examples for <menu type=context> and contextmenu=	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7349	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	add examples here	2009-08-16	2010-10-04
7351	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The note ("The point of hgroup is to mask an h2 element (that acts as a secondary title) from the outline algorithm.") should be explicitly associated with the example below it that it applies to. (in general, a hgroup could mask an h3, h4, h5, etc.).	2009-08-17	2010-10-04
7357	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	That ApplicationCache implements EventTarget should be a line in the IDL, not in prose: "ApplicationCache implements EventTarget;". This might apply to other sections too.	2009-08-17	2010-10-04
7362	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	inclusion of the title as a case where the alt may be omitted is problematic	2009-08-18	2012-04-20
7364	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The contents attribute is declared as read/write, however the following description only gives information about getting the value of the attribute. Should the contents attribute be marked as readonly?	2009-08-18	2010-10-04
7367	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The HTMLEmbedElement interface needs to have the name and align DOM attributes as well. Web browsers do too.	2009-08-19	2010-10-04
7368	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The suggested UI for the mark element does not match the description and the examples. E.g. code highlighting is not something you want to see marked in the scrollbar. Personally I think code highlighting should just be done with strong.	2009-08-19	2010-10-04
7369	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	if context font is set to '' or null, the font from the css should be used. In this case, you have no idea what font is being use, so measureText should return a height of the font, as well as the width so that proper displaying can be done.	2009-08-19	2010-10-04
7373	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Need to fix "If a Document or image was returned by the XMLHttpRequest API" now that the document pointer concept is gone.	2009-08-19	2010-10-04
7374	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	legend as child of details, figure is unstylable and thus unusable	2009-08-19	2010-10-04
7375	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Incorrect specification for window.postMessage()'s handling of unentangled ports	2009-08-19	2010-10-04
7377	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	s/Dahltröm/Dahlström/	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7378	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	element name case fixup table is missing two SVG1.2T entries	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7379	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	HTML5 should reference SVG1.1 as well as SVG1.2T	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7380	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Suggest heuristic detection of UTF-8	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7381	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	NEED	Clarify default encoding wording and add some examples for non-latin locales.	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7382	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	U+000D CARRIAGE RETURN in escaping text spans	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7383	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	drawImage(video) and createPattern(video) should say that the aspect-ratio-corrected dimensions must be used	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7386	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	NEED	SharedWorkerGlobalScope	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7387	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	small element should have same content model as a, ins, del	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7389	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Shouldn't "formnoValidate" be "formNoValidate"?	2009-08-20	2010-10-04
7391	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	Reference to WEBADDRESS should be replaced with reference to IRIbis	2009-08-21	2010-10-22
7392	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	VERI	WONT	Please use some term other than "URL" for Web Addresses	2009-08-21	2010-10-04
7393	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	парпрп	2009-08-21	2010-10-04
7395	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	"value associated with that denominator punctuation character" didn't get xrefed	2009-08-22	2010-10-04
7396	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	shouldn't it be "if the defer attribute is specified, the src attribute must also be specified	2009-08-22	2010-10-04
7397	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	in xref names, s\|td/th\|tdth\|g in obsolete section	2009-08-22	2010-10-04
7398	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	the-basic-syntax	2009-08-22	2010-10-04
7400	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"as part" instead of "sa part"	2009-08-22	2010-10-04
7401	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Looking For this	2009-08-22	2010-10-04
7402	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	The x and y arguments should be better explained.	2009-08-22	2010-10-04
7403	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	What should happen when audio does not have controls but author specifies display:inline? Show fallback? Show blank box with the same size as if it had controls? Force display:none?	2009-08-22	2010-10-04
7405	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Looks good!	2009-08-24	2010-10-04
7406	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Layout system for HTML	2009-08-24	2010-10-04
7409	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	It's not clear what labeled control is in cases with > 1 control as a child of the <label>	2009-08-24	2010-10-04
7411	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	:invalid and :out-of-range shouldn't match until the user has consciously interacted with the form. Roughly, after the input fires a change event. If, say, <input required> matches :invalid immediately on pageload, it becomes basically useless.	2009-08-24	2010-10-04
7412	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Add definition of <meta scheme>	2009-08-24	2010-10-04
7413	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Add definition of <html profile>	2009-08-24	2010-10-04
7414	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Please add a history section	2009-08-24	2010-10-04
7415	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	"The rules for parsing simple color values are as given in the following algorithm." --> "The rules for parsing simple color values are given in the following algorithm."	2009-08-24	2010-10-04
7416	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	IDNA has not been previously used or defined. It is not an obvious term. Please expand it or reference a definition on first use.	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7417	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Why use radians as opposed to degrees? Does this mean I can never draw a complete circle because I don't have enough bits to represent 2pi?	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7418	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	See if we can make popstate more synchronous so that when it fires, the doc is in the expected state, rather than three back-button-steps later. But consider nested calls to history.back().	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7419	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Add replaceState() — e.g. consider panning on a maps application, not all the steps should be new states for back/forward, but we do want to update the url for persistence.	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7420	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	dfghjxdcfvbnm,,k sdfghjk gfdsdfgh fghj	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7421	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	azsxdcfvghjk	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7422	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Add definition of <a name>	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7423	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	why deprecate s, u, strike, acronym? It makes no sense.	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7425	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	comments hould be after the root node	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7427	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	When the maxlength attribute is omitted it should return -1 like Opera and Firefox and not 0. (Alternatively it could return the maximum value like Chrome and presumably Safari do, but that seems less nice.	2009-08-25	2010-10-04
7428	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Safari 4 preloads media and FF 3.5 doesn't in <audio> tag; perhaps HTML5 sections 4.8.10.5 4.8.10.8 are unclear or need a 'preloading' attribute added.	2009-08-26	2010-10-04
7431	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"willful double violation of RFC 2046": The word "double" is splitting the defined term "willful violation". This sounds like a new defined term and interferes with document searching. Instead use "willful violation of two aspects of RFC 2046"	2009-08-26	2010-10-04
7432	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	'have been noted as "willful violations"': Other places use the signular, "willful violation". For consistency, non-native english readers and easy text search, use the singular when defining the term. E.g. 'have each been noted as a "willful violation".	2009-08-26	2010-10-04
7433	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	maybe tiny typo in example with figure: the last <figure> should be </figure> ?	2009-08-26	2010-10-04
7434	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Everything with role=heading should also have an associated aria-level that indicates the level of the heading. The level of the heading should probably be based on the outline algorithm.	2009-08-26	2010-10-04
7435	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Fichier XML de mise à jour mal formé (200)	2009-08-26	2010-10-04
7436	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	Fichier XML de mise à jour mal formé (200)	2009-08-26	2010-10-04
7437	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	The link for "mutable" points to textareas - no mention made of radio, button, input, password types	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7438	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	refine Status section to clarify difference between editor's bug list and the working-group issue list	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7439	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Where it says "in the example above" when introducing attributes the example is actually below.	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7440	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The markup of the example does not use <th> for Legs and Tails like the actual table does.	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7441	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The specification only ever uses the prefix:localName convention for some attributes in the XML namespace and whenever it does it is pretty explicit about it. xml:id is never mentioned outside this section and the prefixes svg and html are never used.	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7442	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Java applets are never conforming, and sometimes don't work	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7443	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	maybe list role and aria-* here	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7444	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	EUC-JP and ISO-2022-JP also need replacement encodings: CP51932 (or eucJP-ms) and CP50221.	2009-08-27	2011-11-09
7445	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	editorial: This section becomes a subsection of "the xhtml syntax" in the author edition. Maybe either move this section somewhere else or keep the "Rendering" and "Interaction with CSS" headings outside class=impl	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7446	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	editorial: last paragraph should probably have class=impl	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7447	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"Use the data and type attributes to invoke plugins." should also mention that <param> can be used to pass parameters with these names to the plugin	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7448	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	editorial: The ":" in "Author requirements:" should also be marked as class=impl	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7449	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	editorial: hyperlinked "represents" on the id attribute definition	2009-08-27	2010-10-04
7451	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	"In the example above" should be "In the example below"	2009-08-28	2010-10-04
7452	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"The collection of Documents is the browsing context's session history. " -- What do you mean by "the collection of documents" ? not clear	2009-08-28	2010-10-04
7453	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"preferred name" should be "preferred MIME name" but it should also state that if there is no preferred MIME name for the encoding the name of the encoding should be used.	2009-08-28	2010-10-04
7454	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Please do not remove these useful features - or are alternative mechanisms planned?	2009-08-28	2010-10-04
7455	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	The example codes don't have double quotes	2009-08-29	2010-10-04
7456	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	Ogg vorbis realy should be standard since it is open and everything can then support it without patent costs. This is REALLY important. Most other standards need patent money. Apple's H.264 is CERTAINly bad here.	2009-08-30	2010-10-04
7457	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Ogg theora needs to be used here as an open standard. Having different standards in different browsers will confuse the matter and it is the only standard to my knowledge that is not patent encumbered. This is seriously important to reinstate.	2009-08-30	2010-10-04
7458	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	inconsistent definition of "up" relation	2009-08-30	2010-10-04
7459	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Nitpicking: an XML document is always well-formed and therefore cannot have syntax errors (including minor).	2009-08-30	2010-10-04
7460	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Under "JavaScript": The note containing a "willful violation" doesn't contain the words "willful violation" as promised by section 1.5.2.	2009-08-30	2010-10-04
7461	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	List of space characters should include U+000B LINE TABULATION (VT) or should note why it is not included.	2009-08-30	2010-10-04
7465	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"a IDL attribute" -> "an IDL attribute" (here and elsewhere)	2009-08-31	2010-10-04
7466	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	This section forbids exposing rel=feed but not exposing e.g. rel=copyright. I think that is wrong. The specification should not dictate UI for this.	2009-08-31	2010-10-04
7468	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	make <table border="1" cellpadding="10" cellspacing="0"> conforming	2009-08-31	2011-04-14
7469	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Is it really necessary to have sections on what HTML5 does not cover?	2009-08-31	2010-10-04
7470	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	JimJJewett gmail: The implications of these tables should also appear at element level -- e.g, td model or dom should mention aria- -- unless it is explicitly not exposed, for some reason.	2009-08-31	2010-10-04
7471	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	JimJJewett gmail: Make explicit reasons for not exposing aspect ratio/clipping. (Security vs simplification). Deals with http://www.w3.org/AudioVideo/2007/12/SMIL-AudioVideoControlConcepts.html#L2398 note1	2009-08-31	2010-10-12
7472	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	JimJJewett gmail: Annotations for assistive technology products (ARIA) -- add the "ARIA", like 3.4 mentions XPATH and XSLT	2009-08-31	2010-10-04
7473	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	JimJJewett gmail: Mention explicitly that the mapping for foreign content -- including adopted MathML or SVG -- is left to those working groups. (Otherwise, I would have expected some strong native semantics for math to math)	2009-08-31	2010-10-04
7474	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Shouldn't the listener be added AFTER the function is defined?	2009-08-31	2010-10-04
7475	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Semantics of rel=first and rel=index breaks specs and implementations	2009-09-01	2013-10-22
7476	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	typo in the last example of section 4.6.9: "lt;/time>" where "</time>" is intended. -Tantek	2009-09-01	2010-10-04
7477	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"It is an element with an ID key" makes it sound like "ID" is an adjetive for "key". Consider a phrasing like the previous bullet. Namely, "It is an element with an ID equal to key."	2009-09-01	2010-10-04
7479	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The content attribute should be all-lowercase: formnovalidate	2009-09-02	2010-10-04
7480	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	use of keygen should trigger a warning.	2009-09-02	2010-10-04
7481	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	The Form submission algorithm section states "If the submitter is anything but a form element...", yet this section states "validate the constraints of form element form".	2009-09-02	2010-10-04
7482	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	The maxLength attribute for input elements can be -1, indicating no maxlength attribute present, per DOM Level 2 HTML. HTML 5 has changed that to be "unsigned long", which -1 cannot be.	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7483	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The footer element desperately needs to be able to contain sectioning content descendents, most importantly "nav". Under the current specification, I will just end up using div class="footer" so my footers can contain sectioning content.	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7484	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	head/@profile holds a white-space separated list of URIs	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7485	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	obsolete permitted DOCTYPEs link is broken in author view	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7487	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	An internal general parsed entity is not XML namespace-well-formed in the general case, since a fragment can have text and multiple elements at the top level	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7488	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"These are the only ways to make a DOM unserializable." - this is not correct so long as DOM Core allows nodes to be moved from an HTML document to an XML document without serializability checking	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7489	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	I wanted to know what a fallback entry is so I clicked on the "fallback entries" link. This took me to a section that describes fallback entries as "Resources that were listed in the cache's manifest as fallback entries". But that's a recursive definition	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7490	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	Ambiguous phrasing of insertion of quotation punctuation in Q element	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7491	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Unspecified: quotation punctuation in the blockquote element	2009-09-03	2010-10-04
7493	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	I want to know meta information on media src. Name of a song, work name, name of singer, and etc...	2009-09-04	2010-10-04
7497	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Add an example to <aside> that shows it being used to hold a blogroll.	2009-09-04	2010-10-04
7499	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	<keygen> should not be defined as a requirement for a conforming HTML5 user agent and should be removed from the spec	2009-09-04	2010-10-04
7501	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Change "The value must be a short free-form string THAT giving the name of the Web application that the page represents." It should read- "The value must be a short free-form string giving the name of the Web application that the page represents."	2009-09-04	2010-10-04
7502	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The clarification that the footer can be used as a site-wide footer or a section footer is not inherently clear via the spec. I suggest specifically stating just that: use for a section or an entire site.	2009-09-04	2010-10-04
7503	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	there is no specification for detection of this feature. how do i know whether to use draggable="true" or revert to a drag simulation library like scriptaculous? - jkwon.work@gmail.com	2009-09-05	2010-10-04
7504	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Occurrences of the terms "Raw text elements", "RCDATA elements", "Foreign elements" and "Normal elements" in the prose of this section should link to their definitions in the definition list above.	2009-09-05	2010-10-04
7505	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	interface HTMLIFrameElement : HTMLElement { attribute DOMString src; attribute DOMString name; attribute DOMString sandbox; attribute boolean seamless; attribute DOMString width; attribute	2009-09-05	2010-10-04
7506	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Clarify that the warning about "The presence of an obsolete permitted DOCTYPE" only applies to HTML, not XHTML which has no restriction on what DOCTYPEs may be used	2009-09-06	2010-10-04
7508	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	<dialog> needs a way to add non-speech related information	2009-09-06	2010-10-04
7509	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Consider <dl type="dialog"> instead of <dialog>	2009-09-06	2010-10-04
7510	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Allow elements beyond just HTML, MathML, and SVG into SVG element	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7511	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The implicit mechanism doesn't fire onsubmit or validate as written today. The exception for when the submitter is the form should be changed to just be a flag for .submit() specifically.	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7512	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	VERI	WONT	suggested "replacement" for head/@profile does not work	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7519	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Should rephrase "All the elements in this specification have a defined content model, which describes what nodes are allowed inside the elements, and thus what the structure of an HTML document or fragment must look like." to more explicitly say that HTML	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7521	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	This table is confusing because it mixes content, IDL attributes, methods, and events. Maybe the various concepts can be grouped and get an appropriate row-group header so it is more clear. The introduction for the table doesn't mention the events and doe	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7522	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<math> should also be phrasing and flow content, like <img> and <svg>.	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7523	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Treat <metadata> like <title> in SVG foreign content	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7524	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The list of forbidden Unicode characters in the authoring requirements does not match the list that generates parse errors in #tokenizing-character-references	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7525	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	meta/@name=keywords should be specified (and made conforming)	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7526	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	spelling: Before this task is run, sa part of the event loop mechanism, the rendering will have been updated to resize the video element if appropriate.	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7527	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Allow implementations to generate meaningful default, implied headings for some sections.	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7539	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Since @summary is an official part of the table element, it is no longer obsolete. Suffienct warning language exists in it's definition that this entry should be removed	2009-09-07	2011-04-13
7540	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Spec for metadata extensions does not define which states are allowed/conforming	2009-09-07	2010-10-04
7542	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	CLOS	FIXE	Remove Section 5. Microdata	2009-09-08	2010-10-04
7543	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Consensus on ietf-http-wg was that repetition of relations is meaningless and we should rather use numbering (e.g. "up2"), names (e.g. "great-grandparent") or an attribute (e.g. level="3").	2009-09-08	2010-10-04
7544	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	Atom (RFC 4287) further specifies that "The image SHOULD have an aspect ratio of one (horizontal) to one (vertical) and SHOULD be suitable for presentation at a small size". Consider doing the same here.	2009-09-08	2010-10-22
7545	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Atom (RFC 4287) defines a "logo" in addition to the "icon": "The image SHOULD have an aspect ratio of 2 (horizontal) to 1 (vertical)". Consider doing the same here.	2009-09-08	2010-10-04
7546	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	"HTML 5" Editor's draft misnamed and suboptimal for HTML content authors unless refactored into HTML (main) and DOM API (appendix).	2009-09-08	2010-10-04
7548	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	replace <dialog> with advice	2009-09-09	2010-10-04
7549	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	define how to parse a MIME type	2009-09-09	2010-10-04
7550	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The invalid event does have a default action. Namely to display UI. However, UAs should probably not be forbidden to show that a field is invalid before submitting, but how can page author suppress the UI for that?	2009-09-09	2010-10-04
7551	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	People are using <section> incorrectly	2009-09-09	2010-10-04
7552	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Add <article> examples illustrating how to use the element, without an unnecessary <section> wrapper inside.	2009-09-09	2010-10-04
7555	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"The scope of this specification does not include documenting every HTML or DOM feature supported by Web browsers. ... For example, the blink element ..." -- but blink is documented in this specification	2009-09-09	2010-10-04
7556	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Where is it defined that only the first <base> element is to be taken into account? Surely that should not be part of iri-bis.	2009-09-09	2010-10-04
7558	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"MIME type" not xreffed in "and any MIME type ending ..."	2009-09-09	2010-10-04
7559	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	What happens when an "option" element has its "selected" attribute removed?	2009-09-10	2010-10-04
7560	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The following sentence could be made more clear, or given an example to indicate what is meant: "The otherwise optional U+000A LINE FEED (LF) character must be included if the element's contents start with that character"	2009-09-10	2010-10-04
7561	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	There's no UA conformance criteria for <meta name>, in particular nothing about case-insensitivity.	2009-09-10	2010-10-04
7574	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The annotation here has 20 tests, but the box for viewing them is bigger than the browser window, hiding the close button. Set a max height and overflow:auto on the popup box.	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7575	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	<meter> example isn't highlighted	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7576	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The spec doesn't say for authors what those any namespace-less attributes are for. It should say that they are parameters that are passed to the plugin, and maybe give an example, maybe also give an equivalent example using <object>	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7577	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	meta/@name=descriptions vs invisible metadata	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7578	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"If the defer attribute may be specified": this phrasing is confusing, should "may be specified" be "is specified"	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7579	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Could "interactive widget" in the context of a web application be defined, expanded upon or an example provided? This seems too vague.	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7581	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Should the select() method set focus? MSIE+Opera does not. FF+Chrome sets focus. It should probably be specified to set focus.	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7583	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	IE8 won't run click events on a label's associated input if the input is hidden via CSS with "display:none" or "visibility:hidden". Other browsers will. There doesn't seem to be an appropriate platform behavior to emulate here, so the exact behavior sho	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7584	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The <meter> example doesn't have any highlighting, whereas all the other elements do	2009-09-11	2010-10-04
7585	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	Link relations should refer to IANA registry (draft-nottingham-http-link-header)	2009-09-11	2010-10-22
7590	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The sentence about HTMLUnknownElement should s/this specification/this specification (or other appliciable specifications)/ to allow delta specs to define HTML elements	2009-09-12	2010-10-04
7591	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	disabled <fieldset>	2009-09-12	2010-10-04
7593	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Use of the "q.v." abbreviation here, while correct, is fairly obscure. Consider dropping "q.v." or rephrasing.	2009-09-12	2010-10-04
7594	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	"Otherwise, the the body element is null. Append the new value to the root element.": Append it where? At the end?	2009-09-12	2010-10-04
7595	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	editorial: "represents" should be a link	2009-09-12	2010-10-04
7598	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/character data/character data, attribute values and comments/	2009-09-13	2010-10-04
7599	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Either drop the two places that set the "Origin" HTTP header, or update HTML5 to match the Sec-From/Origin I-D (if the latter is stable enough yet).	2009-09-13	2010-10-04
7602	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	"Note: Playback of any previously " is listed as a step 12 of HTMLMediaElement.load()	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7603	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	If the attributes list is supposed to be sorted alphabetically, @hidden needs to be placed before @id.	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7606	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	the current behaviour in firefox on a disable input type='submit' is not to show the tooltip, in IE it will appear and then disappear but only when hovering over the text. Should the behaviour of the tooltip be more specifically defined when the element	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7608	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Rendering–Introduction: s/normaly/normally	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7614	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	why was this changed again?	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7615	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Whitespace in doctype	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7616	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Move requirement about obsolete doctypes	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7617	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	editorial: "reflect" under HTMLDocument should be a link	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7618	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"Whether a document is an HTML document or an XML document affects the behavior of certain APIs, as well as a few CSS rendering rules." - actually, i think it doesn't affect CSS rendering anymore, just selector matching	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7619	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"Document objects also implement the document-level interface of any other namespaces found in the document that the UA supports." - drop "found in the document" since it doesn't make sense to implement another interface on-the-fly when finding another na	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7620	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	I think Opera has some security checks for location, added because of some Flash vulnerability. If other browsers have similar checks, would be good to specify	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7621	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	editorial: add example for pushState() - it's not clear what to use as the data	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7622	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"There has got to be a better way of doing this, surely." - is there an intent to rewrite this before last call? is there implementor interest? is it considered for removal?	2009-09-14	2010-10-04
7623	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	It'd be really nice if you specified if the angle argument to context.rotate accepts degrees, radians, or what.	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7625	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Since "event handler attributes" is an abstract concept it might be better to just call it "event handlers" so attributes is not confused with either IDL or content attributes here.	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7626	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Spec says: "Note: Removing an event handler content attribute does not reset the corresponding event handler attribute.". In fact browsers will remove or "deactivate" the listener when you remove the HTML attribute. Some browsers reset it to null or undef	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7627	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Cross-reference more occurrences of "being rendered".	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7628	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The later 'block' box container should simply map to the first/last dd element. This makes UA implementations easier and script emulation of the feature in contemporary UAs as well. Both can simply toggle the display property between block and none.	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7629	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	When the dd element is used inside figure and details it should probably not have margin by default.	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7631	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Don't invoke resource selection algorithm when inserting <source> if src="" is present	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7632	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Should resource selection algorithm be run when src="" is removed?	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7633	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	VERI	WONT	The use of @summary should be encouraged when circumstances warrant	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7635	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Include an example with the table rearranged so that it doesn't need a description, and advice that doing so might be more useful than writing a description	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7636	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	shouldn't dom-table-summary be part of the HTMLTableElement interface proper?	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7637	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Where is HTMLAnchorElement.name defined? I don't see it here nor in the main interface definition	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7638	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	editorial: Add a pointer to the supplemental interface behind a class=impl for all interfaces that have a supplemental interface in this spec (in the obsolete section)	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7639	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Please remove "dc" and "ds" from the parser	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7640	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The definition of the "isindex" element here makes such elements' main interface be HTMLElement rather than HTMLUnknownElement. I suppose that's not intended	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7641	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	The rendering of <details> says everything but the first dt will be hidden, but the element definition says the first dd represents the details. Also, having overflow:hidden when the details are open probably has unintended side-effects like clipping cont	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7642	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	which attribute wins if both pointsize and size are specified?	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7643	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Why not use display:none instead of overflow:hidden; height:0? display:none seems to have the desired behavior in terms of exposure to AT and keyboard navigation in browsers.	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7644	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	The first example for footnotes is actually an example of a dialogue.	2009-09-15	2010-10-04
7645	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	associate printable pages and less-convenient-to-print pages with link rel value "print"	2009-09-16	2010-10-04
7646	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Media Queries	2009-09-16	2010-10-04
7649	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	It would be useful to see an example of how section works when it's not in the context of an article, in the example text (chapters, tabs, etc) all of those would sit inside a wrapping article element.	2009-09-16	2010-10-04
7652	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Is it fine for <nav> to link to a bunch of external pages? E.g. your Flickr/Facebook/Twitter/etc. profiles?	2009-09-16	2010-10-04
7655	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	DUPL	having overflow:hidden when the details are open probably has unintended side-effects like clipping content and affecting floats. display:none/block seems better in terms of AT exposure and keyboard nav	2009-09-16	2010-10-04
7657	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	CLOS	FIXE	Redefining dt and dd	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7658	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	s/the requisite element/the requested element/	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7659	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Clarify what "other applicable specifications" means to say http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-tag/2009Sep/0045.html	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7660	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The resource selection algorithm should set currentSrc in the sync section before invoking resource fetch instead of being set in the async resource fetch. Otherwise checking currentSrc in onloadstart is not reliable.	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7661	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	status	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7663	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	search	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7664	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	The in-memory representation is known as "DOM HTML", or "the DOM" for short. This specification defines version 5 of DOM HTML, known as "DOM5 HTML".	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7668	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	7.9.6 should explain which events are actually dispatched when copying/cutting/pasting	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7669	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Redefining dt and dd, recommend new element as caption for Figure	2009-09-17	2010-10-04
7672	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	</p> shouldn't be ignored in "before html", "before head", "in head", "in head noscript", "after head". It should be reprocessed through to "in body" like </br>.	2009-09-18	2010-10-04
7674	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	are the chunks for inputs having the content-type header for each chunk specified appropriately? e.g. file inputs should set the header according to the file selected by the user	2009-09-18	2010-10-04
7677	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Is there any behavior defined for setting the src property. For example, is the expectation that object should (A) load the src if autobuffer is true (B) stop playing if currently playing (C) something else (D) nothing at all?	2009-09-18	2010-10-04
7679	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	editorial: "The following content attributes must not be specified" applies to authors but is hidden behind class=impl. It would be helpful if each state listed the attributes that are allowed to be specified for that state.	2009-09-19	2010-10-04
7682	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	link tag: rel: associate pages about the same organization across many sites	2009-09-21	2010-10-04
7684	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	INVA	ApplicationCache object can be empty but not an application cache	2009-09-21	2010-10-04
7685	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	NEED	States of ApplicationCache objects are inconsistent with application caches	2009-09-21	2010-10-04
7686	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	No need to require user interface in cache update algorithm	2009-09-21	2010-10-04
7687	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Use "representation" instead of "resource" in section 6.9	2009-09-21	2010-10-04
7689	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	Cache-defeating semantics are not defined	2009-09-21	2010-10-04
7690	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Incompletely defined priority of fallback over explicit entries	2009-09-21	2010-10-04
7691	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	each of which 'has', not 'have'	2009-09-21	2010-10-04
7693	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	The term "Draft Standard" means something different in IETF than meant here, which adds to the confusion. "Editor's Draft" would be better.	2009-09-22	2010-10-04
7694	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	object@classid is missing from list of Content attributes, even though it is essential	2009-09-22	2010-10-04
7696	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	zxcszxczxc	2009-09-22	2010-10-04
7697	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	The type attribute should ammend the Accept header accordingly. HTTP spec is in accordance with the rules here, in terms of the Accept header being non-authorative. script and style elements already ammend accept header (in firefox) but not for other link	2009-09-22	2010-10-04
7699	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	define reset event	2009-09-22	2010-10-04
7700	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	define abort event	2009-09-22	2010-10-04
7701	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Step 6.2 tells you to remove node from the stack of open elements and then go to step 6.1. 6.1 requires that you set node to be the node above node in the stack of open elements. However node is no longer in the stack of open elements	2009-09-22	2010-10-04
7703	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	HTML document conformance should explicitly depend on foreign content conformance	2009-09-22	2010-10-04
7705	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WONT	What use of providing both "embed" and "object" elements? They play nearly same role.	2009-09-23	2010-10-04
7706	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	This section should reference "matches a fallback namespace" in step 3.	2009-09-23	2010-10-04
7708	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Include some documentation here (or link to) how the time element with a pubdate attribute applies to article.	2009-09-23	2010-10-04
7709	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Prevent PUT/DELETE cross-origin	2009-09-23	2010-10-04
7710	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"Any byte or sequences of bytes [...] that is misinterpreted [...]" - s/sequences/sequence/	2009-09-23	2010-10-04
7711	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	The "strong native semantics" are worded very similarly -- but not quite the same -- for input type=Number, input type=range, and progressbar.	2009-09-23	2010-10-04
7712	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	oncontextmenu	2009-09-23	2010-10-04
7714	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	DUPL	the diagram image says "tokeniser"; should be "tokenizer"	2009-09-23	2012-04-05
7717	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	If the user does not give permission it is not stated explicitly what will happen. It would be nice if the specification did state that the algorithm will be terminated at that point. (Should an event be dispatched?)	2009-09-24	2010-10-04
7718	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	"If a Document or image was generated from a data: URL that was returned as the location of an HTTP redirect" ... "If a Document or image was obtained in some other manner (e.g. ... a data: URL returned as the location of an HTTP redirect ...)" - the last	2009-09-24	2010-10-04
7721	HTML WG	pre-LC1	gez.lemon	CLOS	LATE	Drag and Drop is not keyboard accessible	2009-09-24	2013-01-16
7722	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Relationship between	2009-09-24	2010-10-04
7723	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	duplicate word ("first first") should be "first five"	2009-09-24	2010-10-04
7724	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	I would like to know: what is to become of the A element’s NAME attribute? I validated a HTML5 website that I am working this Wednesday (2009-09-23) which contained an A element with a NAME attribute: the W3C Markup Validator did not mind one bit. Howe	2009-09-24	2010-10-04
7725	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	It should be made more clear that only the "disk representation" is changed, not the "memory representation". I.e. images are not suddenly reloaded etc.	2009-09-25	2010-10-04
7726	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	legacy doctype syntax allows <!DOCTYPE HTML SYSTEM"about:legacy-compat">	2009-09-25	2010-10-04
7727	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	legacy doc type does not need to be discouraged by "SHOULD NOT"	2009-09-25	2010-12-16
7730	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	The note starting "The algorithm described..." should end with the word "limitations" or "constraints" or something	2009-09-26	2010-10-04
7732	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Server crawls (also on Safari), then page's loading slow and in parts, get a bizzare feeling, it's no longer a web page but an app I'am loading, don't like that, resizing causes page blanks of seconds length	2009-09-26	2010-10-04
7733	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Too simplistic to handle used cases with more complex controls than toggle, like carousel, tabs. It could work for accordians.	2009-09-26	2010-10-04
7734	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	open being an attribute of the section rather than the content area means you can never use this to mark up content which has multiple control/detail areas which are opened or closed independently like tabs or accordion	2009-09-26	2010-10-04
7735	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	perhaps open could be an int rather than boolean, indicating which content area was open to make using this model for tabs easier	2009-09-26	2010-10-04
7739	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Add ids to author notes to allow direct linking	2009-09-28	2010-10-04
7741	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	First set of examples of alternative stylesheets have stylesheet titles marked up with href attributes rather than title attributes	2009-09-28	2010-10-04
7744	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	Is sniffing required?	2009-09-28	2010-10-04
7745	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Shouldn't the spec state that it is the second (or third) versin of XHTML, known as XHTML5 as there haven't been version 3 or 4.	2009-09-28	2010-10-04
7746	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	<link rel=search> should be used instead of <input type=search> for backwards-compatibility and beacuse the search input type poses no additional input restrictions.	2009-09-28	2010-10-04
7747	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	NEED	Attribute language not allowed on element script at this point	2009-09-28	2010-10-04
7748	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Does it have to be an absolute path or can it be a relative one, too?	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7751	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"the user agent instantiate a Java Language runtime plugin" misses a SHOULD-level requirement after "user agent".	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7752	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Please use "URL character encoding" instead of just "character encoding" for clarity	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7753	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	The order of section headers and data lines should be aligned.	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7754	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Make it clear that the URLs entered for online whitelist sections are in fact namespaces as well.	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7755	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Rename online whitelist URLs to online whitelist namespaces	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7757	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	The "application cache update process" does not take a browsing context as argument. Do you mean the pass the active document as cache host? It should be more explicit about what is what.	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7759	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	The "application cache update process" does not take a single application cache as argument. It takes an application cache group. This means the "If document was loaded from an application cache" step is wrong.	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7760	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	appcache event summary for error is wrong	2009-09-29	2010-10-08
7761	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	It would be nice to have some kind of comment as to how the checking and downloading events from step 2 interact with the events of the same name in step 3 and beyond.	2009-09-29	2010-12-01
7762	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	If I'm reading the algorithm in step 17 correctly you never get a process event when all files have been downloaded.	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7763	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	The information given in the progress event may not be useful if the user agent decides to skip a URL. It seems that the URLs to skip should be determined beforehand.	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7764	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Since the online whitelist entries are namespaces it should not use a prefix match but instead something more complicated as is defined for fallback entries in 6.9.5.	2009-09-29	2010-12-01
7765	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Maybe progress should be named fetchcachefile or some such	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7766	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Fallback namespace overlap/repetition ignored	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7767	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	WORK	Atomic update of application cache is not well-defined	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7768	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Manifest download error means obsolete or idle cache group?	2009-09-29	2010-10-04
7769	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	event handler IDL attributes and content attributes should reflect each other	2009-09-30	2010-10-04
7771	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	matching fallback namespaces	2009-09-30	2010-10-04
7772	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	add interfaces to event summary	2009-09-30	2010-10-04
7773	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Suggestion for "Updating an application cache"	2009-09-30	2010-10-04
7775	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	are the extra events needed when status is checking or downloading	2009-09-30	2010-12-01
7776	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	rename appcache events?	2009-09-30	2010-12-01
7778	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	NEED	"interpreted as a character encoding" is not linked to a defined algorithm	2009-09-30	2010-10-04
7779	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	FIXE	Missing task source for application cache events	2009-09-30	2010-10-04
7780	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	simplify appcache terminology	2009-10-01	2010-10-04
7781	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	forbid duplicate online whitelist namespaces	2009-10-01	2010-10-04
7782	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	"select an application cache" is vague	2009-10-01	2010-10-04
7783	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	appcache download events	2009-10-01	2010-10-04
7784	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"cache failure steps" feedback	2009-10-01	2010-10-04
7785	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"Expiring application caches" feedback	2009-10-01	2010-10-04
7786	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	change priority for online whitelist namespaces other than *	2009-10-01	2010-10-04
7792	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	async on inline script is gratuitously backwards-incompatible, should be ignored	2009-10-02	2010-10-04
7799	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	If the fragid doesn't match an ID or a name in the document, then surely the browser should revert to doing a text search for the fragid text in the document	2009-10-04	2010-10-04
7801	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Shouldn't autofocus be included in this matrix?	2009-10-05	2010-10-04
7803	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	The title element's "value" is earlier defined to be the value of its child text nodes -- not textContent	2009-10-05	2010-10-04
7804	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	In Firefox and Safari .text returns the value of the child text nodes -- not textContent	2009-10-05	2010-10-04
7805	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WORK	The tag name of foreign elements aren't necessarily all-lowercase.	2009-10-05	2010-10-04
7806	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	atom ID element generation for feed entries	2009-10-05	2010-10-04
7807	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	term "new master" can be ambiguous	2009-10-05	2010-10-04
7809	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	The character ranges in this section should follow the conventions of other ranges. I.e. "to" instead of ".." and the name of the character directly after the Unicode code point.	2009-10-05	2010-10-04
7810	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	Maybe it's just me, but this paragraph is unclear to me. It is too difficult to understand. What is transparent content?	2009-10-05	2010-10-04
7816	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	editorial: stray colon here in author view	2009-10-06	2010-10-04
7817	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Last example: stray </p>	2009-10-06	2010-10-04
7820	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	s/codec parameter/codecs parameter/ twice	2009-10-06	2010-10-04
7824	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	It would be very helpful to have a brief mention here of why the WindowProxy object exists.	2009-10-06	2010-10-04
7825	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WORK	typo: "if one available" should read "if one is available"	2009-10-06	2010-10-04
7826	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Should mention that <hgroup> is a valid context for <hx>.	2009-10-07	2010-10-04
7830	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	Does the spec handle selecting multiple objects to drag (holding shift, or command keys)	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7831	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WORK	Does the spec handle setting a drag object type, and having drop targets only respond/highlight to certain drag object types?	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7832	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	The 'for' attribute could point to a element (eg. form) to indicate progress without need for scripting.	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7834	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"If a new element is inserted between the two nodes that define pointer" - s/element/node/	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7835	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	It's not defined what the ownerDocument should be for the created HTMLAudioElement. Similarly for new Image() and new Option()	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7836	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Should the name="" of a <map> be unique in the document?	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7837	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"space separated list" in ping="" isn't properly xreffed	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7838	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	The words "boolean attribute" aren't xreffed here.	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7839	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WORK	Missing (unbalanced) quotemark before "checkbox" keyword.	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7840	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Index of attributes lacks global attributes	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7841	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	s/that the user agent/the user agent/	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7842	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	No programmatic way to make an HTML document - consider adding createHTMLDocument	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7843	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Please make 'abort', ' loadend' and 'emptied' use "queue a task". Firing them sync is annoying to implement and doesn't seem to solve any problem.	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7844	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Remove "that is in a Document and" when the src attribute is set and when a source is inserted, because there's no reason resource selection shouldn't be run when it's not in the document. Then we also don't have to run resource selection when inserting a	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7845	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	javascript	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7846	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	DUPL	javascript	2009-10-08	2010-10-22
7847	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	for - label - "Associatd"	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7848	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WORK	MathML version used in HTML5	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7849	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Check whether .search should or shouldn't work with data: URLs	2009-10-08	2010-10-04
7850	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	Trying out loud	2009-10-09	2010-10-08
7851	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Some (perhaps all) scripts with a for="" attribute should be ignored	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7852	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	DOM Events has dropped namespaces. Drop all init*EventNS methods.	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7853	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	metadata	2009-10-09	2010-10-08
7854	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"offline application cache" doesn't xref right	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7855	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Define fragment parsing when the context is not an HTML, SVG or MathML node	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7857	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"Wait for the browsing context to be closed" should be explicit about spinning a nested event loop	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7858	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	All the current entries should merge into one current entry in the joint session history. (imagine a series of nested iframes that haven't been navigated, and call go(-1)... it should go back at the top-level, not do something weird with the iframes)	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7859	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Mention under step 1 that it can also be aborted if the user agent has discovered that there is no network available and therefore cannot perform HTTP requests. This prevents dispatching error events when the user is using the application offline.	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7861	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WORK	requirements for meta/http-equiv extensions	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7862	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Support Extended Processing Behavior via @profile/@version	2009-10-09	2010-10-04
7865	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	BenB wants an example of use of datetime-local, e.g. "What time should your event start", with no timezone information, so that the site can keep the event starting at that time in the user's time zone regardless of what time zone the user moves to by the	2009-10-10	2010-10-04
7866	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	so much more simple to work with!	2009-10-10	2010-10-08
7867	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	How should a browser render this? Give examples for "typical" or "good" implementations, maybe even for different device types. Should specify that a desktop browser should give a calendar widget, because airlines etc. want that (implement it in JS, but b	2009-10-10	2010-10-12
7868	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	what about time zones? which one is used? local (may be difficult to find out)? is this communicated to the user? can he change it?	2009-10-10	2010-10-12
7869	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	complicated calculation given, but not clearly (only implicitly) stating the obvious question: which day does the week start with? I strongly feel it's Monday, but other people/cultures disagree, I think.	2009-10-10	2010-10-04
7870	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	how does a user enter a "week"? calendar widget? how would he enter it as text?	2009-10-10	2010-10-08
7871	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	there's more meaning to a password field than just being obstructed. it's really only for passwords / credentials. firefox stores them in the password manager, for example, meaning FF really gives it the meaning "password", not just "obstructed". the defi	2009-10-10	2016-11-10
7872	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	I have no idea how a "search field" would look like, on any platform. describe.	2009-10-10	2010-10-04
7873	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WORK	what about backwards compat? can you imagine google or my personal blog website using <input type="search"> for the search field? what about older browsers?	2009-10-10	2010-10-04
7875	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	term: a "range" is an interval between two numbers, e.g. 2-4 or 1969-2032. the term "range" does not mean "imprecise number".	2009-10-10	2010-10-04
7876	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"A synchronous section never mutates the DOM, runs any script, or have any other side-effects." should say "has any other".	2009-10-10	2010-10-04
7877	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	A media.stop() method would be advantageous, having just pause does restrict the bounds of use especially for media players on a website.	2009-10-10	2010-10-04
7878	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	An attribute to actually find out if something is playing would be nice (.isplaying). Unless I'm wrong currently you can't actually tell if something is playing without setting var with JS when you start to play and you can't go by the playback position s	2009-10-10	2010-10-04
7879	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	'unload' event has a different interface than it says in the index	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7880	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	'popstate' event has a different interface than it says in the index	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7881	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	'undo', 'redo' events have a different interface than it says in the index	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7882	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	'message' events has a different interface than it says in the index	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7883	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/defind/defined/	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7884	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	DUPL	s/defind/defined/	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7885	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"…the element does not have an async attribute, or": s/, or//	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7886	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Drop applet, marquee	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7887	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	Drop HTMLTableDataCellElement and HTMLTableHeaderCellElement	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7888	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/Computer input/User input/	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7889	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	audio, canvas and video are missing	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7890	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"When no more character are": s/character/characters/	2009-10-11	2010-10-04
7892	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	typo	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7893	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	In the example <div id="b" itemprop="band" itemscope id="jazzband"> the div element has two id attributes. Is this desirable?	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7894	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	what is	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7895	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	In step 6, it should be allowed (and clear that it is allowed) for UAs to use additional data such as the site TLD to guess the correct encoding	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7896	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Specify pageshow and pagehide events	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7897	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	One can argue that "Any (namespace-less) attribute may be specified ..." contradicts with obsolete feature section where use of some attributes is disallowed	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7898	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Maybe this section should cover all elements and attributes historically allowed by IETF standards and W3C Recommendations but no longer allowed, such as <rb> and <a urn> for consistency	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7900	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	timedate	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7901	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	ijhugytfd	2009-10-12	2010-10-08
7902	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	ijhugytfdsdfgdsd	2009-10-12	2010-10-08
7903	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	yhjrth	2009-10-12	2010-10-08
7904	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	sex and moooooore seeeex	2009-10-12	2010-10-08
7905	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Markup in second example has formatting broken - titlecase on tags and > creating line breaks	2009-10-12	2010-10-04
7906	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	The venn diagram is all black in the PDF copy	2009-10-13	2010-10-04
7909	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	It seems like this is a subsection of the wrong section. Either it should just be a level up or it should be moved up one section.	2009-10-13	2010-10-04
7910	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Since IANA considerations is an appendix, its subsections should be marked as such as well.	2009-10-13	2010-10-04
7914	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	step. 6 should say "object" not "array", right? i.e. "whose value is the object _properties_"	2009-10-14	2010-10-04
7915	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	“itemref” element is missing, <http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/semantics.html#itemref>	2009-10-14	2010-10-04
7917	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	document.close() should attempt to tokenize	2009-10-14	2010-10-04
7918	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	prefetching: allow site to deny	2009-10-14	2010-10-04
7920	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	media queries ref	2009-10-14	2010-10-04
7923	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	What about local files access?	2009-10-14	2010-10-04
7924	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	xaXAafs	2009-10-15	2010-10-04
7926	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	Undefine insertion point if parser on call stack doing anything other than running script element	2009-10-15	2010-10-04
7927	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	widht/height says "map to the dimension properties" but the link goes to "maps to the pixel length property"	2009-10-15	2010-10-04
7931	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	The "loop" label in the 'A start tag whose tag name is "li"' is misplaced, or there is something else wrong that is making the loop useless.	2009-10-15	2010-10-04
7936	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	NEED	Consider https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=521670	2009-10-16	2010-10-04
7937	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	er might return the document with one paragraph modified as follows: <p>I also have some <mark>kitten</mark>s who are visiting me these days. They're really cute. I think they like my garden! Maybe I should adopt a <mark>kitten</mark>.</p>	2009-10-16	2010-10-04
7939	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	stalled is a simple event according to the resource fetch algorithm in 4.8.10.5 Loading the media resource	2009-10-17	2010-10-04
7940	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Under "content model", it isn't clear what the significance of the italic "or" is. If it is intended to signify a higher precidence "or", consider using bullet points to clarify the nesting of conjuctions.	2009-10-17	2010-10-04
7944	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	VERI	INVA	vCard: agent: avoid power-of-attorney implication	2009-10-18	2010-10-08
7945	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	Add a reference to [PROGRESS] here, or make \|progress\| a simple event (twice)	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7946	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	Ping-From, Ping-To: wrong heading level or in the wrong section	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7947	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/script's global scope/script's global object/g, s/script browsing context/script's browsing context/g	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7948	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	[RFC2781] should be referenced in the third Note?	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7949	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	This should be marked as a willful violation to RFC 2616 where missing of the charset parameter is interpreted as iso-8859-1	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7950	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	xref "offline application cache"	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7951	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	First example: http://example.com/jon/ & http://example.com/~jon/ are used	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7952	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/<span>same</span>/same/	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7953	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/must be performd/must be performed/	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7954	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	s/<span>valid URLs</span>/<span title="valid-url">valid URLs</span>/	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7956	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	It is not obvious if or how a caption can be placed below a table instead of above the table. This section might benefit from a sentence or two clarifying that.	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7957	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	[Webstorage] s/<span>browsing contexts</span>/<span title="browsing-context">browsing contexts</span>/	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7958	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"(end-1)th position": add title=""	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7959	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/<span>editing hosts</span>/<span title="editing-host">editing hosts</span>/	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7960	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/<span title="absolute URLs">absolute URL</span>/<span title="absolute URL">absolute URLs</span>/	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7961	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	"script execution context" isn't defined	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7962	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/<span>last event ID string</span>/<span title="concept-event-stream-last-event-id">last event ID string</span>/g	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7963	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WORK	11. "Otherwise, if current is not a refid element" should be an itemref element.	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7964	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Either change the "properties of an item" algorithm to be tree-order or HTMLPropertyCollection.values to be algorithm-order	2009-10-18	2010-10-04
7965	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"ASCII case-sensitive" in "Markup declaration open state" is a broken xref	2009-10-19	2010-10-04
7971	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	<base> UA requirements (determining base URL of a Document object)	2009-10-19	2010-10-04
7972	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	It appears that the steps listed for what to do when reset() is invoked contain a race condition unless step 1 (checking if already marked) and step 2 (marking the form as locked) are performed atomically together.	2009-10-20	2010-10-04
7973	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	atom ID format	2009-10-20	2010-10-04
7974	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Please explain what the use case is for the 'emptied' event or drop the event from the spec	2009-10-20	2010-10-04
7977	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Define whether application/octet-stream with parameters is a type that the user agent knows it cannot render	2009-10-20	2010-10-14
7978	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Form foster parenting introduces extra space to layout	2009-10-20	2010-10-04
7979	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"special characters" is unnecessarily vague -- refer to delimiters	2009-10-20	2010-10-04
7980	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"presented by" should be "represented here by"	2009-10-20	2010-10-04
7981	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	s/restrictiosn/restrictions/	2009-10-20	2010-10-04
7987	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Clean up load()	2009-10-20	2010-10-04
7988	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Remove "spacer". IE, WebKit and Opera parse it as a normal unknown element	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7989	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	nextid, rb and spacer should use HTMLUnknownElement (like isindex)	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7990	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Add itemref interface	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7991	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"This specification ... include ... a full duplex client-server communication channel" - I assume that refers to Web Sockets, which is no longer included in this spec	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7992	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	Original insertion mode concept doesn't work well when SVG with HTML content embedded in non-body context	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7993	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"areas that are out of scope" - dead link to deleted section #no	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7994	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	afdasfasdf	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7995	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"The attribute value can be left unquoted if it doesn't contain any of " ' ` = < or >." - should also mention space characters	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7996	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"any MIME type ending with the four characters "+xml"" - even the 'valid MIME type' "text/html; charset=utf8+xml", and not "application/xhtml+xml; charset=utf8"? Probably this should require the MIME type's subtype to end with +xml	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7997	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"if it matches the media-type token" - s/token/rule/ (to use the correct ABNF terminology)	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
7998	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"any of the DOM and WebAPI specifications" - what's a WebAPI specification? (Presumably this refers to Web IDL, but I can only tell that by looking at the Web IDL spec's URL in the references section, so it's not very clear.)	2009-10-21	2010-10-04
8000	HTML WG	pre-LC1	faulkner.steve	RESO	FIXE	ARIA roles added to the a element should be conforming in HTML5	2009-10-21	2012-01-13
8003	HTML WG	pre-LC1	mike	RESO	WONT	line breaks in attributes (especially title)	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8005	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	For control and permanently undefined characters no action is given: Whould they be replaced my fffd?	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8007	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The step that skips "+" does not say '(The "+" is ignored, but it is not conforming.)', whereas the rules for signed integers do say that (and it seems a helpful comment)	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8008	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The plus-sign case fails to say "If position is past the end of input, return an error" after it advances position, and so the next character used in step 8 may be undefined	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8009	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"Add the value of the current character" - is the 'current character' the same as the 'next character'? Why use a different term? Seems better to be consistent. (Same for signed integers)	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8010	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	A valid floating point number was defined as a string, and I'd assume valid ones are a subset of all floating point numbers, so this is the best representation of a string. Applying ToString to a string isn't very interesting. It needs to be clear that it	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8011	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	ECMAScript says the result of ToString on Number is not uniquely determined (in the last digit of s), but HTML5 makes it sound like there's a single best representation of any number. It should explicitly note that the best representation may be any one o	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8012	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	This says "Collect a sequence of characters ... interpret the resulting sequence as a base-ten integer", whereas the signed and unsigned integers had a whole five-step loop to do precisely the same thing. They should all use the simpler phrasing, since it	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8013	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"string is guaranteed to be a valid floating point number" - no it's not - it could be "0." which is not valid	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8014	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"the character immediately after the last one examined by the sub-algorithm" - what does 'examined' mean? To find the number in "123XY" it has to examine the X, so is that counted? Probably should say "after the last one matched" instead	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8015	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"skip all White_Space characters" - should xref to "skip White_Space characters"	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8016	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	anything	2009-10-22	2010-10-04
8018	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	The space characters cases within the before DOCTYPE public/system identifier states can never be reached. To fix that, remove those cases.	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8019	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	<!DOCTYPE html PUBLICa> throws two parse errors.	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8020	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"return value as an integer" - that number needs to be categorised as either a percentage or a length, as stated in the introduction	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8021	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The step with dividing by 10^{length} is phrased very differently to the fraction loop for parsing floating point numbers, but seems to be achieving the same result. They should be phrased the same, to make it clear they're computing the same thing.	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8022	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"ISO8601 libraries might not parse dates and times exactly the same manner" - should be "in exactly the same manner"	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8023	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"If day is not a number in the range 1 ≤ month ≤ maxday, then fail." - s/month/day/	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8024	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"the time zone in use on the east coast of North America during daylight saving time." - should say USA, not North America. (e.g. Nova Scotia looks like it's on the east coast of North America, but it's UTC-3 in DST.)	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8025	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"Dates before the year zero can't be represented as a datetime in this version of HTML." - s/zero/one/ (though I suppose that's not precisely correct since 0001-01-01T00:00+23:59 is almost a day earlier than the year 1)	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8026	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Given a datetime ...T00:00Z, is the best representation ...T00:00-00:00 or ...T00:00+00:00?	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8027	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Does the time-zone offset also consist of a sign? If so, it should be listed in the introduction. If not, the 'valid ...' definition can't say +/- represents the offset's sign.	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8028	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	If the first character is not Z or + or -, the subalgorithm returns undefined values. It should explicitly fail and return nothing.	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8029	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	From RCDATA state, & goes to char ref in data, which then goes to data state. Should go back to RCDATA state.	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8030	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"either 52 weeks or 53 such seven-day periods" - s/weeks//	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8032	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	Wouldn't it be better to show video/audio controls by default? Otherwise you might end up with media visible on the page that is impossible to play.	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8033	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Note in the prose that some exceptions aren't actually defined in [DOMCORE] yet	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8034	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	WONT	It appears that there is no way to draw more than one line of text per call to fillText/strokeText, so what is the point of discarding any line-height value set in the font attribute?	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8035	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	HTMLAllCollection should inherit from HTMLCollection	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8036	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	HTMLOptionsCollection should inherit from HTMLCollection	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8037	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The form controls collection should just be an HTMLCollection instead of having an HTMLFormControlsCollection interface	2009-10-23	2010-10-04
8038	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	NEED	Permit closing tag for new, void elements - for legacy compatibility = XHTML alignment	2009-10-24	2011-01-19
8039	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	"Let queue be a stack of elements" - this is quite a confusing choice of terminology	2009-10-24	2010-10-04
8040	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	RESO	FIXE	editorial: this list is not in alphabetical order (itemref should be higher up)	2009-10-24	2010-10-04
8041	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Should say "This algorithm will return either a number, or a number and a denominator character, or two numbers, or nothing", for consistency with other algorithms	2009-10-24	2010-10-04
8042	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"if denominator has value" - should be "a value"	2009-10-24	2010-10-04
8043	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"It is given a string and a starting position" - no it's not. It should probably instead say "Let input and position be the same variables as those of the same name in the algorithm that invoked these steps."	2009-10-24	2010-10-04
8044	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	The document's current address can contain fragments. HTTP says the Referer must not contain fragments. Presumably HTML5 ought to say to strip the fragment. (document.referrer is affected the same way.)	2009-10-24	2010-10-04
8045	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Should be called "limited to only non-negative numbers", because it allows 0 (which is not a positive number)	2009-10-25	2010-10-04
8046	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	WONT	Reflecting floats: The IDL attribute types include +/-Infinity, so it doesn't make sense to talk about floats being "out of range" because everything is within the infinite range	2009-10-25	2010-10-04
8047	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	Reflecting floats: The rules for parsing floating point number values return an unlimited-precision (finite in base 10) number. How is it converted to limited-precision IDL attribute types? In particular, what rounding mode is used? and do very large valu	2009-10-25	2010-10-04
8048	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	"The same DOMTokenList object must be returned every time for each attribute" - should say "DOMTokenList or DOMSettableTokenList"	2009-10-25	2010-10-04
8049	HTML WG	pre-LC1	ian	CLOS	FIXE	For consistency with HTMLFormControlsCollection and HTMLOptionsCollection, this should probably be called HTMLPropertiesCollection	2009-10-25	2010-10-04