This is an archived snapshot of W3C's public bugzilla bug tracker, decommissioned in April 2019. Please see the home page for more details.

This archived bug list includes all the bugs for the product or component specified, including bugs that have been resolved.

Mon Apr 1 2019 03:39:04 UTC
Hide Search Description
2547 bugs found.
ID Product Comp Assignee Status Resolution Summary Opened Changed
5729 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA test issue 2008-06-06 2010-10-04
5744 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike CLOS WONT Improved Fragment Identifiers 2008-06-13 2011-01-26
5749 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA test IGNORE ME 2008-06-14 2010-10-04
5750 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA another test IGNORE ME 2008-06-14 2010-10-04
5751 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA IGNORE ME (sorry for noise...) 2008-06-14 2010-10-04
5752 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike CLOS WONT Parsing should be specified for future updates 2008-06-14 2010-10-04
5753 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK parsing issues with legacy UAs 2008-06-14 2010-10-04
5754 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT List elements content model issues 2008-06-14 2010-10-04
5756 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Need interactive UA norms for exposing (non-displayed) HTML document data 2008-06-14 2010-10-04
5757 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED MediaElement features are needed on OBJECT element 2008-06-14 2010-10-04
5759 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Newly introduced void elements are not mentioned in "Writing HTML Documents" section 2008-06-15 2010-10-04
5766 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE priority request: reply to outline e-mail 2008-06-17 2010-10-04
5768 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE content sniffing should be allowed on link elements with a relationship type of icon 2008-06-18 2010-10-04
5769 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTMLMediaElement.currentLoop readonly? 2008-06-18 2010-10-04
5773 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Authors need more control over handling of linked resources 2008-06-19 2010-10-04
5777 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT referencing subordinate text or asides should be through an alternate attribute 2008-06-20 2010-10-04
5787 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Rename "script that will execute as soon as the parser resumes" 2008-06-23 2010-10-04
5792 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE li/dd/dt end tag in body when no corresponding elt on stack 2008-06-24 2010-10-04
5793 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Cross-reference "as if" 2008-06-24 2010-10-04
5796 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <li><div><p><li> no longer matches IE 2008-06-24 2010-10-04
5798 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Deferring end tag eating to after head gives weird errors 2008-06-24 2010-10-04
5801 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Conformance rules for xmlns unintuitively different for HTML and foreign content 2008-06-25 2010-10-04
5802 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE No mention of %uXXXX escapes 2008-06-25 2010-10-04
5803 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike CLOS FIXE HTML5 serialization is not compatible with XSLT 2008-06-25 2010-10-04
5807 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED User Agent display of title attribute content not defined 2008-06-26 2010-10-04
5808 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Define a way to coerce HTML5 parser output to an XML 1.0 4th ed. + Namespaces 1.0 infoset 2008-06-26 2010-10-04
5809 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Mitigate data loss when conforming documents are coerced to XML 1.0 2008-06-26 2010-10-04
5814 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE WebIDL: Resolve the callback issue 2008-06-27 2010-10-04
5815 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE foreignObject in the SVG namespace should be scoping 2008-06-27 2010-10-04
5820 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Work on WebSockets 2008-06-28 2010-10-04
5821 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike RESO NEED meta/@scheme missing 2008-06-29 2010-10-04
5822 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike CLOS FIXE The headers attribute should be able to reference a td 2008-06-30 2010-10-04
5823 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Scope allowable on a td 2008-06-30 2010-10-04
5830 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Work on video 2008-07-03 2010-10-04
5831 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE WebIDL: mark up constructors in IDL 2008-07-03 2010-10-04
5833 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Work on standalone apps ideas 2008-07-04 2010-10-04
5834 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <area alt=""> has no author-level conformance requirement 2008-07-04 2010-10-04
5835 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA no apparent mechanism for applying a caption to a fieldset 2008-07-05 2010-10-04
5836 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA Syntax section allows <ins><p></ins> 2008-07-06 2010-10-04
5837 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Rename CDATA block state to CDATA section state 2008-07-06 2010-10-04
5839 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Work on Worker Threads 2008-07-07 2010-10-04
5846 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Accessing Object Parameters from an Embedded SVG 2008-07-09 2010-10-04
5848 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Write the "fetching" section 2008-07-09 2010-10-04
5850 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE JS global object 2008-07-10 2010-10-04
5856 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE height/width DOM attributes in combination with display:none 2008-07-11 2010-10-04
5858 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Case marked as fragment when it can occur at other times 2008-07-11 2010-10-04
5859 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Spec doesn't handle unknown schemes 2008-07-12 2010-10-04
5863 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Tokeniser: "Bogus comment" state unclear 2008-07-13 2010-10-04
5866 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE SVG in HTML 2008-07-14 2010-10-04
5881 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Make tokeniser data states headers visible in table of contents 2008-07-18 2010-10-04
5883 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT data: URLs 2008-07-21 2010-10-04
5895 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Require attributes on <embed> and data-* attributes to be lowercase 2008-07-24 2010-10-04
5897 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Make &ohm; and &angst; expand to their NFC equivalents 2008-07-25 2010-10-04
5898 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Don't convert attributes to lowercase for localName/nodeName 2008-07-25 2010-10-04
5899 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Allow uppercase "CHARSET=" in legacy encoding decl 2008-07-25 2010-10-04
5909 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Need a solution for replaceable properties 2008-07-29 2010-10-04
5927 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT WF2: HTMLInputElement need some improvements 2008-08-04 2010-10-04
5933 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <video muted> issues 2008-08-06 2010-10-04
5936 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Offline cache syntax section needs an example 2008-08-07 2010-10-04
5937 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE make cache manifest syntax more extensible 2008-08-07 2010-10-04
5941 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT <video>.width/height should have default values defined 2008-08-07 2010-10-04
5944 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Unclear wording, section 8.2.3.1 2008-08-09 2010-10-04
5946 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE execCommand('insertHTML') should throw in xml 2008-08-10 2010-10-04
5963 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Editorial: xrefs in media event summary table 2008-08-13 2010-10-04
5964 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE getting width/height on <embed>, <iframe>, <object> and <video> 2008-08-13 2010-10-04
5974 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Language tag sameness should probably be ASCII case-insensitive 2008-08-19 2010-10-04
5979 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK unclear whether new Audio(url) should throw 2008-08-21 2010-10-04
5989 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE alt="" 2008-08-26 2010-10-04
5990 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE SVG in HTML 2008-08-26 2010-10-04
5991 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE workers 2008-08-26 2010-10-04
5994 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add note in syntax section 2008-08-26 2010-10-04
5997 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Define script execution for XHTML5 2008-08-28 2010-10-04
6032 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Serializing a doctype with invalid public id 2008-09-07 2010-10-04
6033 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Forms section 2008-09-07 2010-10-04
6034 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Process <video> feedback 2008-09-07 2010-10-04
6035 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Process appcache feedback 2008-09-07 2010-10-04
6036 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTMLCollection.namedItem() should look for non-HTML elements 2008-09-07 2010-10-04
6037 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Elaborate on Web compat characteristics of task queue interaction 2008-09-08 2010-10-04
6038 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "noframes", "script", "style", "title" in 'after head' mode pop prematurely 2008-09-08 2010-10-04
6052 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Should propagate uncaught exceptions from workers to their owner 2008-09-10 2010-10-04
6057 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE in the audio portion of the spec, at the end of 4.7.8.0 it mentions "If the src argument is present..." but the example given calls it the argument 'url' 2008-09-12 2010-10-04
6097 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE [rendering] <body background> is a URL attribute? 2008-09-19 2010-10-04
6098 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED input type=foo as an element-level section 2008-09-19 2010-10-04
6099 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Process notification feedback 2008-09-19 2010-10-04
6100 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Process postMessage feedback 2008-09-19 2010-10-04
6101 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE media elements - ready states - events should be async 2008-09-20 2010-10-04
6102 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Please do not break applet element in HTML 5 2008-09-21 2010-10-04
6103 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE video section editorial issues 2008-09-22 2010-10-04
6104 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT <video> and <audio> should prevent cross-origin media loads 2008-09-22 2010-10-04
6127 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Deal with origin details in WebSocket and postMessage feedback 2008-09-30 2010-10-04
6132 HTML WG pre-LC1 w3c CLOS FIXE [sniffing] No whitespace before "<!DOCTYPE HTML" in content sniffing 2008-10-01 2010-10-04
6134 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Run-on sentence in HTML5 spec 2008-10-04 2010-10-04
6143 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Linkify "pending external script" 2008-10-08 2010-10-04
6145 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Label content model should allow <label for=a><input id=a> 2008-10-08 2010-10-04
6153 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Process <eventsource> feedback 2008-10-10 2010-10-04
6176 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Process WebSocket feedback 2008-10-21 2010-10-04
6177 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Process Workers feedback 2008-10-21 2010-10-04
6181 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Process table feedback (including headers='" issue) 2008-10-23 2010-10-04
6182 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE WebIDL - strokeStyle and fillStyle should be of type 'any' not 'DOMObject' 2008-10-23 2010-10-04
6213 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Noscript content model with script allows fragment parse errors 2008-11-10 2010-10-04
6214 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE insertRow without arguments 2008-11-10 2010-10-04
6216 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <script> in <select> 2008-11-11 2010-10-04
6236 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA scroll bar placement in frames 2008-11-19 2010-10-04
6253 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA <input> bookkeeping aren't consistent 2008-11-27 2010-10-04
6254 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE xref errors in the <input> summary table 2008-11-27 2010-10-04
6256 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Mutation event behavior on document.open() unspecified 2008-11-29 2010-10-04
6257 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Please specify document.write()-safe points in the parse 2008-11-29 2010-10-04
6258 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Changing the encoding doesn't cover non-idempotent navigation 2008-11-29 2010-10-04
6263 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE document.onreadystatechange 2008-12-03 2010-10-04
6293 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE specify that the value attribute on <input type=url> must be an absolute URL 2008-12-10 2010-10-04
6294 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Date microsyntax defines incorrect range for month and day fields 2008-12-10 2010-10-04
6300 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE [references] reference RFC 5322 instead of RFC 2822 2008-12-11 2010-10-04
6336 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE XSLT-compat doctype only allowed for use by XSLT 2008-12-30 2010-10-04
6339 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Define how to deal with onload, ononline, and other document/window-level events 2008-12-31 2010-10-04
6349 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Rewrite the entire script processing model again 2009-01-05 2010-10-04
6350 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Port examples from WF2 to HTML5 2009-01-05 2010-10-04
6351 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Add event handler attributes for all events defined in HTML5 2009-01-05 2010-10-04
6352 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Port acknowledgements from WF2 to HTML5 2009-01-05 2010-10-04
6353 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE play() and pause() don't throw 2009-01-05 2010-10-04
6356 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE 00:99:00 is a valid time string 2009-01-05 2010-10-04
6357 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT <script> start tag parsing 2009-01-05 2010-10-04
6370 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Float exponent part unclear about length of sequence 2009-01-06 2010-10-04
6389 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Avoid double parse error on EOF in DOCTYPE state 2009-01-13 2010-10-04
6390 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Add a note about reaching after head state and the fragment mode 2009-01-13 2010-10-04
6423 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Names of confidence flag states inconsistent 2009-01-14 2010-10-04
6434 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE plugins inside fallback content shouldn't be instantiated 2009-01-14 2010-10-04
6437 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE document.location should update when the browsing context is navigated without the Document changing 2009-01-15 2010-10-04
6438 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Error in step 9.4 of the internal algorithm for scanning and assigning header cells 2009-01-15 2010-10-04
6439 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <area> should stringify href (like <a>) 2009-01-15 2010-10-04
6440 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE To which elements applies the formatBlock command? 2009-01-15 2010-10-04
6457 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE registerContentHandler() and sniffing 2009-01-20 2010-10-04
6460 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Handle onerror feedback for Workers 2009-01-21 2010-10-04
6461 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Fix the definition of "Origin" for Documents from javascript: URLs 2009-01-21 2010-10-04
6462 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Self-reference and cyclic references in headers='' 2009-01-21 2010-10-04
6464 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Support meta refresh with quotes 2009-01-21 2010-10-04
6474 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Event handler DOM attributes on HTMLDocument 2009-01-27 2010-10-04
6475 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL Missing event handler attributes 2009-01-27 2010-10-04
6476 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE cross-origin media element loads and progress events 2009-01-27 2010-10-04
6477 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTMLInputElement.width and height 2009-01-27 2010-10-04
6490 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Event handler attributes should ignore event's interface 2009-01-29 2010-10-04
6491 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <textarea wrap=off> not supported 2009-01-29 2010-10-17
6493 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Use encoding of POSTing document for POST response if meta prescan fails 2009-01-29 2010-10-04
6494 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Make the requiredness about alt more obvious 2009-01-29 2010-10-04
6497 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Examples using title="" with line breaks 2009-01-29 2010-10-04
6507 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Paragraphs section doesn't list all transparent elements 2009-01-30 2010-10-04
6508 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE XHTML doctype without system identifier 2009-01-30 2010-10-04
6515 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE the body element event handler attributes and missing Window object 2009-02-02 2010-10-04
6516 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE obsolete attributes on HTMLDocument assume there is a body element 2009-02-02 2010-10-04
6529 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE value DOM attribute for input element in File Upload state 2009-02-04 2010-10-04
6536 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Time element examples should be in the context of a goal-oriented microformat use case 2009-02-06 2010-10-04
6543 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Mint a new element for figure captions 2009-02-09 2010-10-04
6544 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Allow width=0 on <img> and <iframe> 2009-02-09 2010-10-04
6556 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE When parsing legacy color returns an error 2009-02-11 2010-10-04
6562 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Define parsing quirks 2009-02-12 2010-10-04
6563 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Specify if innerHTML setting should use the quirkiness of the document 2009-02-12 2010-10-04
6585 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Rendering: <marquee bgcolor> 2009-02-16 2010-10-04
6586 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Zero margin quirk not quite right 2009-02-16 2010-10-04
6590 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE character encoding mapping needs to be used for form submission too 2009-02-17 2010-10-04
6608 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT please undeprecate <center> for older browsers 2009-02-22 2010-10-04
6609 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED negative keywords-not meta tags 2009-02-22 2010-10-04
6610 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED add a preventable forced-fragment method 2009-02-22 2010-10-04
6613 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Allow <meta charset="UTF-8"/> in XHTML 2009-02-23 2010-10-04
6614 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Restricting multiple character encoding declarations per document 2009-02-23 2010-10-04
6618 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED </body> and </html> early on handled in a Gecko/WebKit/Presto-inconsisten way 2009-02-24 2010-10-04
6628 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE WebSocket.URL and EventSource.URL should return the absolute URL 2009-02-27 2010-10-04
6630 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Optionalness of start tags when element is empty 2009-02-27 2010-10-04
6637 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Put boolean and enumerated attributes next to each other 2009-02-28 2010-10-04
6652 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE spellcheck should allow empty string 2009-03-05 2010-10-04
6656 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT make clear that Referer headers track the pushState()d URL 2009-03-05 2010-10-04
6659 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE textarea also needs text-indent:initial 2009-03-06 2010-10-04
6662 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Make clearer that "the script's encoding" doesn't refer to the encoding of the script file itself 2009-03-07 2010-10-04
6669 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Rendering: s/disabled/enabled/ for noscript 2009-03-09 2010-10-04
6670 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Allow unescaped &s, at least in attributes that accept URLs 2009-03-09 2011-11-23
6684 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Disregard of RFC 4329 and IANA MIME Media Types 2009-03-11 2014-12-18
6689 HTML WG pre-LC1 silviapfeiffer1 RESO FIXE Removing remaining mention of Element.setAttributeNode() 2009-03-12 2012-10-14
6690 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Document.renameNode() is not part of Web DOM 2009-03-12 2010-10-04
6729 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Attribute getters/setters should lower case argument on HTML elements in HTML docs 2009-03-24 2010-10-04
6736 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE dfn.js doesn't handle class="impl" 2009-03-24 2010-10-04
6742 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA pre-encoded form values should be restorable as submitted 2009-03-27 2010-10-04
6743 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE AAA still reads from the DOM 2009-03-27 2010-10-04
6746 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT case-insensitivity of other than a-z and A-Z, e.g., diacritics 2009-03-29 2010-10-04
6750 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <header><blockquote><h1> issues 2009-04-02 2010-10-04
6759 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE event queueing rules for <img> are nonsensical 2009-04-02 2010-10-04
6760 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "string" misspelled as "stirng" 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6762 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Typos and spelling mistakes 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6763 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Inconsistent use of American and British English 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6764 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Section 2.4.4.1 Non-negative integers - Step 9.4 refers to incorrect step 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6765 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Poor wording in 4.8.2.1.12 General guidelines 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6766 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE document.all definition missing 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6767 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <time> warning regarding Gregorian calendar 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6768 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE 4.8.10.3 Media types -- unclear note 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6769 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Grammar mistake: "element element"? 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6770 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Term emphasis inconsistencies in Terminology section 2009-04-03 2010-10-04
6771 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Sectioning Content Use versus DIV 2009-04-04 2010-10-04
6774 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL <mark> element: restrict insertion by other servers 2009-04-05 2010-10-22
6776 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Note the XSLT implications of assigning HTML elements into the http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml namespace 2009-04-06 2010-10-04
6778 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Note the XPath implications of assigning HTML elements into the http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml namespace 2009-04-06 2010-10-04
6779 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Clarify the difference between elements and tags 2009-04-06 2010-10-04
6784 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE WebStorage should include Window IDL for Storage APIs 2009-04-07 2010-10-04
6790 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE object element with usemap attribute should be in "Interactive content" category 2009-04-08 2010-10-04
6796 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <keygen> in <select> 2009-04-09 2010-10-04
6812 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Typo: JavsScript 2009-04-15 2010-10-04
6832 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <datagrid> content model is silly 2009-04-18 2010-10-04
6833 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Datagrid minor comments 2009-04-18 2010-10-04
6834 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT add more number bases to form inputs? 2009-04-20 2010-10-04
6835 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The multiple attribute on datagrid 2009-04-20 2010-10-04
6841 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA add IDs+titles to tables documenting <input> element keywords/states and attributes/methods 2009-04-22 2010-10-04
6842 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE make it possible/easy to link to tables documenting <input> element keywords/states and attributes/methods 2009-04-22 2010-10-04
6853 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL restore meta keywords, search engines use them 2009-04-29 2010-10-04
6854 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA if attribute values enumerated, allow case-sensitivity for meta content values 2009-04-29 2010-10-04
6858 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE More details needed for "ASCII-compatible encoding" 2009-05-01 2010-10-04
6894 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE add statement that the "checked" attribute on <input> is a boolean attribute 2009-05-09 2010-10-04
6898 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Case shifting terminology is confusing 2009-05-11 2010-10-04
6902 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Note incompatibilities with RDF serializations 2009-05-13 2010-10-04
6949 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Don't use colon shorthand when talking about language-related attributes 2009-05-24 2010-10-04
6953 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA clearly specify that misnested tags are an authoring-conformance error 2009-05-26 2010-10-04
6973 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Support <textarea>.textLength 2009-05-28 2010-10-04
6974 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Please be explicit about inheritance of scripting flag when setting innerHTML 2009-05-28 2010-10-04
6976 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA Image Map Example fails Validation 2009-05-28 2010-10-04
6977 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Unnecessary sentence in <cite> presentation 2009-05-29 2010-10-04
6978 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Mark eof-terminated script elements as malformed 2009-05-29 2010-10-04
6992 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Title of Web IDL misspelled as WebIDL 2009-06-03 2010-10-04
6993 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Tell authoring tools to use UTF-8 2009-06-03 2010-10-04
6999 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Adding tag <NSFW> 2009-06-05 2010-10-04
7003 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Typos 2009-06-07 2010-10-04
7010 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA Making <applet> non-conforming may hinder royalty-free <video> adoption 2009-06-10 2010-10-04
7030 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Define "Text" content model 2009-06-16 2010-10-04
7032 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Sandboxing and Referer 2009-06-17 2010-10-04
7034 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE authoring conformance requirements in the spec should either be removed or replaced 2009-06-18 2010-10-04
7035 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED clarify what the use case is for first illustration under "3.4 Content models" 2009-06-19 2010-10-04
7051 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT add new extended attribute to IDLs with DOM attributes that reflect content attributes 2009-06-23 2010-10-04
7056 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <caption> and <figure><legend> elements should allow flow content children 2009-06-25 2010-10-04
7059 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Forking XPath 2009-06-26 2010-10-04
7061 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED clarify definition of "sectioning content" 2009-06-28 2010-10-04
7062 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED replace terms "CDATA element" and "RCDATA element" with... something better 2009-06-29 2010-10-04
7075 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT The embed element should be deprecated 2009-07-03 2010-10-04
7076 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Client-side image maps attributes missing on the a element 2009-07-03 2010-12-07
7079 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Inconsistency in algorithm descriptions for parsing integers 2009-07-05 2010-10-04
7080 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Grammatical error in DOM trees section 2009-07-05 2010-10-04
7084 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <ul><li>A<ul></li>B is parsed backwards-incompatibly 2009-07-07 2010-10-04
7086 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <a> should be </a> in section 4.5.3 of the HTML5 specification 2009-07-07 2010-10-04
7089 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED CDATA escapes need to close upon --\s*!> 2009-07-08 2010-10-04
7102 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Permitted obsolete doctype compare "HTML" 2009-07-14 2010-10-04
7103 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Content-Language marked as non-conforming 2009-07-14 2010-10-04
7105 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Default fallback behaviour for unsupported tags in browsers! 2009-07-15 2010-10-04
7137 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Need to fill in the references section. 2009-07-24 2010-10-04
7138 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Need to get window.mediaMode into another spec 2009-07-24 2010-10-04
7139 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA test 2009-07-24 2010-10-04
7140 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA test 2009-07-25 2010-10-04
7141 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Typo: "A members..." 2009-07-25 2010-10-04
7142 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Shouldn't SERIALISE_ERR be SERIALIZE_ERR ? 2009-07-25 2010-10-04
7143 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "attributes marked with an asterisk cannot be specified on body elements" is confusing, since <body onload=""> is pretty common. Of course that's the attribute specified on a tag, but still, I'm just a simple author reading the spec for the first time :) 2009-07-25 2010-10-04
7144 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE I am not sure if we are ditching ALT in favour of legend. You don't make this clear here. Some of your alt examples here resemble longdesc, which I am in favour of ditching completely. I'd be interested to see your answer on whatwg list about this 2009-07-25 2010-10-04
7145 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Valid date strings should accept ambiguous inputs, like "2009" or "2007-01". 2009-07-26 2010-10-04
7146 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA goog 2009-07-27 2010-10-04
7147 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE s#one of the optional U+002F SOLIDUS (/) characters#the optional U+002F SOLIDUS (/) character# 2009-07-27 2010-10-04
7150 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Why do these examples have uppercase elements? 2009-07-27 2010-10-04
7151 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE s/users/user 2009-07-27 2010-10-04
7152 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "When the user agent has completely fetched of the entire media resource, […]" No 'of' and only one of 'completely' or 'entire' should remain in the text. Mentioned one week ago on the list. Taking the opportunity to try this inline review box. 2009-07-27 2010-10-04
7153 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Want standardization of .naturalWidth and .naturalHeight, which some browsers already have 2009-07-27 2010-10-04
7154 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT icon attribute: We can't apply so-called "CSS Sprite" technique for command icons. We need another attribute to specify clip position and size. 2009-07-27 2010-10-04
7156 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL I would like to see theora/vorbis as HTML5 standard. I'm tired of codec patents. 2009-07-28 2010-10-04
7157 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED I would like to see theora/vorbis as HTML5 standard. I'm tired of codec patents. 2009-07-28 2010-10-04
7158 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA this is a discribing comment 2009-07-28 2010-10-08
7161 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED If a heading has title text and then an image below it, then more text, how is the figure element handled in header and hgroup elements? 2009-07-29 2010-10-04
7164 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA teste 2009-07-29 2010-10-04
7171 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Is this missing a comment as to how the type attribute is quoted wrt:codecs? "''" + '""' 2009-07-29 2010-10-04
7175 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE clearTimeout and clearInterval are not in the dom-intro box 2009-07-30 2010-10-04
7176 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL The link to [GREGORIAN] doesn't seem to work... 2009-07-30 2010-10-04
7179 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <xmp> should close <p> (does in IE and WebKit) 2009-07-31 2010-10-04
7185 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED itemprop needs to be after item; no longer a-z ordered due to the name change prolly. 2009-08-01 2010-10-04
7186 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA oppo n iuniu in niun iun lin in liunniuniuniun i 2009-08-01 2010-10-04
7188 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK how to use "item" in xhtml5? item="item" ?! 2009-08-01 2010-10-04
7189 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE how to use "item" in xhtml5? item="item" ?! 2009-08-01 2010-10-04
7190 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Since all "specially focusable" elements have an activation behaviour, the Action of accesskey-laden commands is to _not_ focus them if they are focusable. Instead, such elements should probably always be focused if focusable, then be activated. 2009-08-02 2010-10-04
7199 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED microformat 2009-08-03 2010-10-04
7211 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT define "positive integer" and use it consistently, instead of "non-negative integer greater than zero" 2009-08-04 2010-10-04
7213 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED todataurl 2009-08-04 2010-10-04
7214 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Typo: "When an input element's type attribute is in the *Telphone* state" 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7215 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE character encodings and XML 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7219 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA http://abu---wisam.ahlamontada.net 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7220 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA http://abu---wisam.ahlamontada.net 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7221 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA www.abu---wisam.ahlamontada.net 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7222 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA http://abu---wisam.ahlamontada.net 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7224 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Crash in application C++ exception Unsupported file format header 46466c17 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7225 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL http://www.w3.org/Bugs/Public/show_bug.cgi?id=7224 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7226 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE has enabled --> have enabled 2009-08-05 2010-10-04
7227 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE using both "conforming but obsolete" (12.1) and "obsolete but conforming" (12.1.1) - consistency in terminology may be helpful 2009-08-06 2010-10-04
7229 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE input.files should return the same object 2009-08-06 2010-10-04
7232 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA add <iframe> to list of CDATA elements in the "Writing HTML documents" section 2009-08-06 2010-10-04
7234 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA review 123 2009-08-06 2010-10-04
7237 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Let current outlinee be null. (It holds the element whose outline is being created.) Spelling. Outline with one "e" 2009-08-06 2011-03-19
7238 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE more examples 2009-08-07 2010-10-04
7241 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Need to explain exactly what happens if wrap=hard is specified *without* cols being specified. Should it act like wrap=soft, or like cols=20? 2009-08-07 2010-10-04
7243 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED no mension of h3c? 2009-08-08 2010-10-04
7246 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Add examples for <keygen> 2009-08-09 2010-10-04
7248 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA sxdfsdf 2009-08-09 2010-10-04
7254 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL If <audio> was able to play back multiple source urls without gaps, JavaScript could decode or generate continuous audio to data: urls on the fly. 2009-08-10 2010-10-04
7255 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "This will either return a year and month" --> "This will return either a year and month" 2009-08-10 2010-10-04
7256 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "which is not a real time zone currently" --> which is not currently a real time zone 2009-08-10 2010-10-04
7258 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Should state that a new Date object is returned each time the date/time/timezone attributes are accessed if the intention is for them not to be reflecting datetime="" or the element content. 2009-08-11 2010-10-04
7259 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA dfgsgdfsg dgf 2009-08-11 2010-10-04
7261 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE In the third code example, a code element is opened but a </cite> tag closes it. The opening tag should be <cite>. 2009-08-11 2010-10-04
7263 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK this thing really heavy, tried solution: switch to user mode css, after all rendered, return to author mode, scrolling is heavy though,,, try open panel & add info, heavy too.. 2009-08-12 2010-10-04
7264 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT make <% start a bogus comment 2009-08-12 2010-10-04
7265 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA the HTML5 validator says maxlength is not allowed on textarea 2009-08-12 2010-10-04
7266 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Section states twice in green that other specs can define other event loops, can remove one of those 2009-08-12 2010-10-04
7268 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE contradicts 4.7.1 wrt implied paragraph boundaries (should not in 4.7.1, not good practice in 4.7.4). dont repeat example or simplify 2009-08-13 2010-10-04
7269 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT user agent requirements: for value=8 max="", step 4 and 11 will cause current value and maximum value to be set to 1, which is destructive (if script wanted to obtain the original value). suggest step 4 change to set maximum to value 2009-08-13 2010-10-04
7272 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The explanatory text and the diagram suggest that legs and tails should be th, rather than td -- but the example has td. JimJJewett@gmail 2009-08-14 2010-10-04
7273 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The word "left" should not be part of the link when saying that attributes can be left unquoted. It sounds too much like "left outer join" or such, and might imply that it was legal to unquote only one side, or some such oddness. JimJJewett@gmail 2009-08-14 2010-10-04
7274 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL The word "left" should not be part of the link when saying that attributes can be left unquoted. It sounds too much like "left outer join" or such, and might imply that it was legal to unquote only one side, or some such oddness. JimJJewett@gmail 2009-08-14 2010-10-04
7275 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The markup snippet at the top of this section" should be a link to that snippet; the section is long enough that the snippet will already have scrolled off-screen for some people. (In my case, it had also escaped my short-term memory.) JimJJewett@gmail 2009-08-14 2010-10-04
7276 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT "tree order" -- is this a section that can assume formal compsci training, or should a short (4 nodes?) example be given? JimJJewett@gmail 2009-08-14 2010-10-04
7277 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT """(This is only a "SHOULD" and not a "MUST" requirement because it has been proven to be impossible.""" There has to be better wording than 'should do the impossible'. Should attempt to verify? Impossible in some cases? JimJJewett@gmail 2009-08-14 2010-10-04
7278 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT numbers seem ignorant of i18n - is <meter>10,3</meter> taken as 10? requirements for number may expand to include, i.e.: U+002C COMMA for European № 2009-08-14 2010-10-04
7280 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED new comment 2009-08-14 2010-10-04
7281 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED <script language="javascript" type="text/javascript"> 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7282 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add dummy willValidate() and company to object 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7283 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7284 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7285 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7286 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7287 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7288 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7289 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7290 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7291 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7292 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7293 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7294 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7295 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7296 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7297 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7298 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7299 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT mark up examples 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7300 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7301 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7302 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7303 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7304 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7305 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7307 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7308 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7309 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7310 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7311 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7312 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples for tables 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7313 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7314 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7315 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7316 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7317 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7318 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7319 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7320 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7321 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7322 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7323 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7324 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7325 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7326 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7327 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7328 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7329 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7330 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7331 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7332 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7333 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7334 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7335 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7336 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7337 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7338 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7339 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7340 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7341 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7342 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7343 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7344 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7345 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7346 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7347 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples for <command> 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7348 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE add examples for <menu type=context> and contextmenu= 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7349 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT add examples here 2009-08-16 2010-10-04
7351 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The note ("The point of hgroup is to mask an h2 element (that acts as a secondary title) from the outline algorithm.") should be explicitly associated with the example below it that it applies to. (in general, a hgroup could mask an h3, h4, h5, etc.). 2009-08-17 2010-10-04
7357 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE That ApplicationCache implements EventTarget should be a line in the IDL, not in prose: "ApplicationCache implements EventTarget;". This might apply to other sections too. 2009-08-17 2010-10-04
7362 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE inclusion of the title as a case where the alt may be omitted is problematic 2009-08-18 2012-04-20
7364 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The contents attribute is declared as read/write, however the following description only gives information about getting the value of the attribute. Should the contents attribute be marked as readonly? 2009-08-18 2010-10-04
7367 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The HTMLEmbedElement interface needs to have the name and align DOM attributes as well. Web browsers do too. 2009-08-19 2010-10-04
7368 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The suggested UI for the mark element does not match the description and the examples. E.g. code highlighting is not something you want to see marked in the scrollbar. Personally I think code highlighting should just be done with strong. 2009-08-19 2010-10-04
7369 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED if context font is set to '' or null, the font from the css should be used. In this case, you have no idea what font is being use, so measureText should return a height of the font, as well as the width so that proper displaying can be done. 2009-08-19 2010-10-04
7373 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Need to fix "If a Document or image was returned by the XMLHttpRequest API" now that the document pointer concept is gone. 2009-08-19 2010-10-04
7374 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE legend as child of details, figure is unstylable and thus unusable 2009-08-19 2010-10-04
7375 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Incorrect specification for window.postMessage()'s handling of unentangled ports 2009-08-19 2010-10-04
7377 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE s/Dahltröm/Dahlström/ 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7378 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT element name case fixup table is missing two SVG1.2T entries 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7379 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT HTML5 should reference SVG1.1 as well as SVG1.2T 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7380 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Suggest heuristic detection of UTF-8 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7381 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED Clarify default encoding wording and add some examples for non-latin locales. 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7382 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE U+000D CARRIAGE RETURN in escaping text spans 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7383 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE drawImage(video) and createPattern(video) should say that the aspect-ratio-corrected dimensions must be used 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7386 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED SharedWorkerGlobalScope 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7387 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA small element should have same content model as a, ins, del 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7389 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Shouldn't "formnoValidate" be "formNoValidate"? 2009-08-20 2010-10-04
7391 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Reference to WEBADDRESS should be replaced with reference to IRIbis 2009-08-21 2010-10-22
7392 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike VERI WONT Please use some term other than "URL" for Web Addresses 2009-08-21 2010-10-04
7393 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED парпрп 2009-08-21 2010-10-04
7395 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK "value associated with that denominator punctuation character" didn't get xrefed 2009-08-22 2010-10-04
7396 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE shouldn't it be "if the defer attribute is specified, the src attribute must also be specified 2009-08-22 2010-10-04
7397 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE in xref names, s|td/th|tdth|g in obsolete section 2009-08-22 2010-10-04
7398 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED the-basic-syntax 2009-08-22 2010-10-04
7400 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "as part" instead of "sa part" 2009-08-22 2010-10-04
7401 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Looking For this 2009-08-22 2010-10-04
7402 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED The x and y arguments should be better explained. 2009-08-22 2010-10-04
7403 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE What should happen when audio does not have controls but author specifies display:inline? Show fallback? Show blank box with the same size as if it had controls? Force display:none? 2009-08-22 2010-10-04
7405 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Looks good! 2009-08-24 2010-10-04
7406 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Layout system for HTML 2009-08-24 2010-10-04
7409 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED It's not clear what labeled control is in cases with > 1 control as a child of the <label> 2009-08-24 2010-10-04
7411 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT :invalid and :out-of-range shouldn't match until the user has consciously interacted with the form. Roughly, after the input fires a change event. If, say, <input required> matches :invalid immediately on pageload, it becomes basically useless. 2009-08-24 2010-10-04
7412 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Add definition of <meta scheme> 2009-08-24 2010-10-04
7413 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Add definition of <html profile> 2009-08-24 2010-10-04
7414 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Please add a history section 2009-08-24 2010-10-04
7415 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA "The rules for parsing simple color values are as given in the following algorithm." --> "The rules for parsing simple color values are given in the following algorithm." 2009-08-24 2010-10-04
7416 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE IDNA has not been previously used or defined. It is not an obvious term. Please expand it or reference a definition on first use. 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7417 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Why use radians as opposed to degrees? Does this mean I can never draw a complete circle because I don't have enough bits to represent 2pi? 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7418 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE See if we can make popstate more synchronous so that when it fires, the doc is in the expected state, rather than three back-button-steps later. But consider nested calls to history.back(). 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7419 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Add replaceState() — e.g. consider panning on a maps application, not all the steps should be new states for back/forward, but we do want to update the url for persistence. 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7420 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA dfghjxdcfvbnm,,k sdfghjk gfdsdfgh fghj 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7421 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA azsxdcfvghjk 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7422 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Add definition of <a name> 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7423 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA why deprecate s, u, strike, acronym? It makes no sense. 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7425 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED comments hould be after the root node 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7427 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE When the maxlength attribute is omitted it should return -1 like Opera and Firefox and not 0. (Alternatively it could return the maximum value like Chrome and presumably Safari do, but that seems less nice. 2009-08-25 2010-10-04
7428 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Safari 4 preloads media and FF 3.5 doesn't in <audio> tag; perhaps HTML5 sections 4.8.10.5 4.8.10.8 are unclear or need a 'preloading' attribute added. 2009-08-26 2010-10-04
7431 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "willful double violation of RFC 2046": The word "double" is splitting the defined term "willful violation". This sounds like a new defined term and interferes with document searching. Instead use "willful violation of two aspects of RFC 2046" 2009-08-26 2010-10-04
7432 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE 'have been noted as "willful violations"': Other places use the signular, "willful violation". For consistency, non-native english readers and easy text search, use the singular when defining the term. E.g. 'have each been noted as a "willful violation". 2009-08-26 2010-10-04
7433 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE maybe tiny typo in example with figure: the last <figure> should be </figure> ? 2009-08-26 2010-10-04
7434 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Everything with role=heading should also have an associated aria-level that indicates the level of the heading. The level of the heading should probably be based on the outline algorithm. 2009-08-26 2010-10-04
7435 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Fichier XML de mise à jour mal formé (200) 2009-08-26 2010-10-04
7436 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Fichier XML de mise à jour mal formé (200) 2009-08-26 2010-10-04
7437 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK The link for "mutable" points to textareas - no mention made of radio, button, input, password types 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7438 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE refine Status section to clarify difference between editor's bug list and the working-group issue list 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7439 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Where it says "in the example above" when introducing attributes the example is actually below. 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7440 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The markup of the example does not use <th> for Legs and Tails like the actual table does. 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7441 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The specification only ever uses the prefix:localName convention for some attributes in the XML namespace and whenever it does it is pretty explicit about it. xml:id is never mentioned outside this section and the prefixes svg and html are never used. 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7442 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Java applets are never conforming, and sometimes don't work 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7443 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK maybe list role and aria-* here 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7444 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE EUC-JP and ISO-2022-JP also need replacement encodings: CP51932 (or eucJP-ms) and CP50221. 2009-08-27 2011-11-09
7445 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE editorial: This section becomes a subsection of "the xhtml syntax" in the author edition. Maybe either move this section somewhere else or keep the "Rendering" and "Interaction with CSS" headings outside class=impl 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7446 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE editorial: last paragraph should probably have class=impl 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7447 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "Use the data and type attributes to invoke plugins." should also mention that <param> can be used to pass parameters with these names to the plugin 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7448 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE editorial: The ":" in "Author requirements:" should also be marked as class=impl 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7449 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE editorial: hyperlinked "represents" on the id attribute definition 2009-08-27 2010-10-04
7451 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL "In the example above" should be "In the example below" 2009-08-28 2010-10-04
7452 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "The collection of Documents is the browsing context's session history. " -- What do you mean by "the collection of documents" ? not clear 2009-08-28 2010-10-04
7453 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "preferred name" should be "preferred MIME name" but it should also state that if there is no preferred MIME name for the encoding the name of the encoding should be used. 2009-08-28 2010-10-04
7454 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Please do not remove these useful features - or are alternative mechanisms planned? 2009-08-28 2010-10-04
7455 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA The example codes don't have double quotes 2009-08-29 2010-10-04
7456 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Ogg vorbis realy should be standard since it is open and everything can then support it without patent costs. This is REALLY important. Most other standards need patent money. Apple's H.264 is CERTAINly bad here. 2009-08-30 2010-10-04
7457 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Ogg theora needs to be used here as an open standard. Having different standards in different browsers will confuse the matter and it is the only standard to my knowledge that is not patent encumbered. This is seriously important to reinstate. 2009-08-30 2010-10-04
7458 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE inconsistent definition of "up" relation 2009-08-30 2010-10-04
7459 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Nitpicking: an XML document is always well-formed and therefore cannot have syntax errors (including minor). 2009-08-30 2010-10-04
7460 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Under "JavaScript": The note containing a "willful violation" doesn't contain the words "willful violation" as promised by section 1.5.2. 2009-08-30 2010-10-04
7461 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT List of space characters should include U+000B LINE TABULATION (VT) or should note why it is not included. 2009-08-30 2010-10-04
7465 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "a IDL attribute" -> "an IDL attribute" (here and elsewhere) 2009-08-31 2010-10-04
7466 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE This section forbids exposing rel=feed but not exposing e.g. rel=copyright. I think that is wrong. The specification should not dictate UI for this. 2009-08-31 2010-10-04
7468 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE make <table border="1" cellpadding="10" cellspacing="0"> conforming 2009-08-31 2011-04-14
7469 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Is it really necessary to have sections on what HTML5 does not cover? 2009-08-31 2010-10-04
7470 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT JimJJewett gmail: The implications of these tables should also appear at element level -- e.g, td model or dom should mention aria- -- unless it is explicitly not exposed, for some reason. 2009-08-31 2010-10-04
7471 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT JimJJewett gmail: Make explicit reasons for *not* exposing aspect ratio/clipping. (Security vs simplification). Deals with http://www.w3.org/AudioVideo/2007/12/SMIL-AudioVideoControlConcepts.html#L2398 note1 2009-08-31 2010-10-12
7472 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE JimJJewett gmail: Annotations for assistive technology products (ARIA) -- add the "ARIA", like 3.4 mentions XPATH and XSLT 2009-08-31 2010-10-04
7473 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE JimJJewett gmail: Mention explicitly that the mapping for foreign content -- including adopted MathML or SVG -- is left to those working groups. (Otherwise, I would have expected some strong native semantics for math to math) 2009-08-31 2010-10-04
7474 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Shouldn't the listener be added AFTER the function is defined? 2009-08-31 2010-10-04
7475 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Semantics of rel=first and rel=index breaks specs and implementations 2009-09-01 2013-10-22
7476 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE typo in the last example of section 4.6.9: "lt;/time>" where "</time>" is intended. -Tantek 2009-09-01 2010-10-04
7477 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "It is an element with an ID key" makes it sound like "ID" is an adjetive for "key". Consider a phrasing like the previous bullet. Namely, "It is an element with an ID equal to key." 2009-09-01 2010-10-04
7479 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The content attribute should be all-lowercase: formnovalidate 2009-09-02 2010-10-04
7480 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE use of keygen should trigger a warning. 2009-09-02 2010-10-04
7481 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED The Form submission algorithm section states "If the submitter is anything but a form element...", yet this section states "validate the constraints of form element form". 2009-09-02 2010-10-04
7482 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL The maxLength attribute for input elements can be -1, indicating no maxlength attribute present, per DOM Level 2 HTML. HTML 5 has changed that to be "unsigned long", which -1 cannot be. 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7483 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The footer element desperately needs to be able to contain sectioning content descendents, most importantly "nav". Under the current specification, I will just end up using div class="footer" so my footers can contain sectioning content. 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7484 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE head/@profile holds a white-space separated list of URIs 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7485 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT obsolete permitted DOCTYPEs link is broken in author view 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7487 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE An internal general parsed entity is not XML namespace-well-formed in the general case, since a fragment can have text and multiple elements at the top level 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7488 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "These are the only ways to make a DOM unserializable." - this is not correct so long as DOM Core allows nodes to be moved from an HTML document to an XML document without serializability checking 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7489 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE I wanted to know what a fallback entry is so I clicked on the "fallback entries" link. This took me to a section that describes fallback entries as "Resources that were listed in the cache's manifest as fallback entries". But that's a recursive definition 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7490 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Ambiguous phrasing of insertion of quotation punctuation in Q element 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7491 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Unspecified: quotation punctuation in the blockquote element 2009-09-03 2010-10-04
7493 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL I want to know meta information on media src. Name of a song, work name, name of singer, and etc... 2009-09-04 2010-10-04
7497 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Add an example to <aside> that shows it being used to hold a blogroll. 2009-09-04 2010-10-04
7499 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <keygen> should not be defined as a requirement for a conforming HTML5 user agent and should be removed from the spec 2009-09-04 2010-10-04
7501 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Change "The value must be a short free-form string THAT giving the name of the Web application that the page represents." It should read- "The value must be a short free-form string giving the name of the Web application that the page represents." 2009-09-04 2010-10-04
7502 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The clarification that the footer can be used as a site-wide footer or a section footer is not inherently clear via the spec. I suggest specifically stating just that: use for a section or an entire site. 2009-09-04 2010-10-04
7503 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK there is no specification for detection of this feature. how do i know whether to use draggable="true" or revert to a drag simulation library like scriptaculous? - jkwon.work@gmail.com 2009-09-05 2010-10-04
7504 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Occurrences of the terms "Raw text elements", "RCDATA elements", "Foreign elements" and "Normal elements" in the prose of this section should link to their definitions in the definition list above. 2009-09-05 2010-10-04
7505 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED interface HTMLIFrameElement : HTMLElement { attribute DOMString src; attribute DOMString name; attribute DOMString sandbox; attribute boolean seamless; attribute DOMString width; attribute 2009-09-05 2010-10-04
7506 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Clarify that the warning about "The presence of an obsolete permitted DOCTYPE" only applies to HTML, not XHTML which has no restriction on what DOCTYPEs may be used 2009-09-06 2010-10-04
7508 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT <dialog> needs a way to add non-speech related information 2009-09-06 2010-10-04
7509 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Consider <dl type="dialog"> instead of <dialog> 2009-09-06 2010-10-04
7510 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Allow elements beyond just HTML, MathML, and SVG into SVG element 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7511 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The implicit mechanism doesn't fire onsubmit or validate as written today. The exception for when the submitter is the form should be changed to just be a flag for .submit() specifically. 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7512 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike VERI WONT suggested "replacement" for head/@profile does not work 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7519 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Should rephrase "All the elements in this specification have a defined content model, which describes what nodes are allowed inside the elements, and thus what the structure of an HTML document or fragment must look like." to more explicitly say that HTML 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7521 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE This table is confusing because it mixes content, IDL attributes, methods, and events. Maybe the various concepts can be grouped and get an appropriate row-group header so it is more clear. The introduction for the table doesn't mention the events and doe 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7522 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <math> should also be phrasing and flow content, like <img> and <svg>. 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7523 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Treat <metadata> like <title> in SVG foreign content 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7524 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The list of forbidden Unicode characters in the authoring requirements does not match the list that generates parse errors in #tokenizing-character-references 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7525 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE meta/@name=keywords should be specified (and made conforming) 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7526 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE spelling: Before this task is run, *sa* part of the event loop mechanism, the rendering will have been updated to resize the video element if appropriate. 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7527 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Allow implementations to generate meaningful default, implied headings for some sections. 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7539 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Since @summary is an official part of the table element, it is no longer obsolete. Suffienct warning language exists in it's definition that this entry should be removed 2009-09-07 2011-04-13
7540 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Spec for metadata extensions does not define which states are allowed/conforming 2009-09-07 2010-10-04
7542 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike CLOS FIXE Remove Section 5. Microdata 2009-09-08 2010-10-04
7543 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Consensus on ietf-http-wg was that repetition of relations is meaningless and we should rather use numbering (e.g. "up2"), names (e.g. "great-grandparent") or an attribute (e.g. level="3"). 2009-09-08 2010-10-04
7544 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Atom (RFC 4287) further specifies that "The image SHOULD have an aspect ratio of one (horizontal) to one (vertical) and SHOULD be suitable for presentation at a small size". Consider doing the same here. 2009-09-08 2010-10-22
7545 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Atom (RFC 4287) defines a "logo" in addition to the "icon": "The image SHOULD have an aspect ratio of 2 (horizontal) to 1 (vertical)". Consider doing the same here. 2009-09-08 2010-10-04
7546 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT "HTML 5" Editor's draft misnamed and suboptimal for HTML content authors unless refactored into HTML (main) and DOM API (appendix). 2009-09-08 2010-10-04
7548 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE replace <dialog> with advice 2009-09-09 2010-10-04
7549 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE define how to parse a MIME type 2009-09-09 2010-10-04
7550 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The invalid event does have a default action. Namely to display UI. However, UAs should probably not be forbidden to show that a field is invalid before submitting, but how can page author suppress the UI for that? 2009-09-09 2010-10-04
7551 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE People are using <section> incorrectly 2009-09-09 2010-10-04
7552 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Add <article> examples illustrating how to use the element, without an unnecessary <section> wrapper inside. 2009-09-09 2010-10-04
7555 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The scope of this specification does not include documenting every HTML or DOM feature supported by Web browsers. ... For example, the blink element ..." -- but blink is documented in this specification 2009-09-09 2010-10-04
7556 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Where is it defined that only the first <base> element is to be taken into account? Surely that should not be part of iri-bis. 2009-09-09 2010-10-04
7558 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "MIME type" not xreffed in "and any MIME type ending ..." 2009-09-09 2010-10-04
7559 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED What happens when an "option" element has its "selected" attribute removed? 2009-09-10 2010-10-04
7560 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The following sentence could be made more clear, or given an example to indicate what is meant: "The otherwise optional U+000A LINE FEED (LF) character must be included if the element's contents start with that character" 2009-09-10 2010-10-04
7561 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE There's no UA conformance criteria for <meta name>, in particular nothing about case-insensitivity. 2009-09-10 2010-10-04
7574 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The annotation here has 20 tests, but the box for viewing them is bigger than the browser window, hiding the close button. Set a max height and overflow:auto on the popup box. 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7575 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <meter> example isn't highlighted 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7576 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The spec doesn't say for authors what those any namespace-less attributes are for. It should say that they are parameters that are passed to the plugin, and maybe give an example, maybe also give an equivalent example using <object> 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7577 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED meta/@name=descriptions vs invisible metadata 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7578 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "If the defer attribute may be specified": this phrasing is confusing, should "may be specified" be "is specified" 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7579 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Could "interactive widget" in the context of a web application be defined, expanded upon or an example provided? This seems too vague. 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7581 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Should the select() method set focus? MSIE+Opera does not. FF+Chrome sets focus. It should probably be specified to set focus. 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7583 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE IE8 won't run click events on a label's associated input if the input is hidden via CSS with "display:none" or "visibility:hidden". Other browsers will. There doesn't seem to be an appropriate platform behavior to emulate here, so the exact behavior sho 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7584 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The <meter> example doesn't have any highlighting, whereas all the other elements do 2009-09-11 2010-10-04
7585 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Link relations should refer to IANA registry (draft-nottingham-http-link-header) 2009-09-11 2010-10-22
7590 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The sentence about HTMLUnknownElement should s/this specification/this specification (or other appliciable specifications)/ to allow delta specs to define HTML elements 2009-09-12 2010-10-04
7591 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE disabled <fieldset> 2009-09-12 2010-10-04
7593 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Use of the "q.v." abbreviation here, while correct, is fairly obscure. Consider dropping "q.v." or rephrasing. 2009-09-12 2010-10-04
7594 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED "Otherwise, the the body element is null. Append the new value to the root element.": Append it where? At the end? 2009-09-12 2010-10-04
7595 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE editorial: "represents" should be a link 2009-09-12 2010-10-04
7598 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/character data/character data, attribute values and comments/ 2009-09-13 2010-10-04
7599 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Either drop the two places that set the "Origin" HTTP header, or update HTML5 to match the Sec-From/Origin I-D (if the latter is stable enough yet). 2009-09-13 2010-10-04
7602 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED "Note: Playback of any previously " is listed as a step 12 of HTMLMediaElement.load() 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7603 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE If the attributes list is supposed to be sorted alphabetically, @hidden needs to be placed before @id. 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7606 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK the current behaviour in firefox on a disable input type='submit' is not to show the tooltip, in IE it will appear and then disappear but only when hovering over the text. Should the behaviour of the tooltip be more specifically defined when the element 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7608 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Rendering–Introduction: s/normaly/normally 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7614 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED why was this changed again? 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7615 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Whitespace in doctype 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7616 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Move requirement about obsolete doctypes 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7617 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE editorial: "reflect" under HTMLDocument should be a link 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7618 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "Whether a document is an HTML document or an XML document affects the behavior of certain APIs, as well as a few CSS rendering rules." - actually, i think it doesn't affect CSS rendering anymore, just selector matching 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7619 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "Document objects also implement the document-level interface of any other namespaces found in the document that the UA supports." - drop "found in the document" since it doesn't make sense to implement another interface on-the-fly when finding another na 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7620 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED I think Opera has some security checks for location, added because of some Flash vulnerability. If other browsers have similar checks, would be good to specify 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7621 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE editorial: add example for pushState() - it's not clear what to use as the data 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7622 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "There has got to be a better way of doing this, surely." - is there an intent to rewrite this before last call? is there implementor interest? is it considered for removal? 2009-09-14 2010-10-04
7623 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE It'd be really nice if you specified if the angle argument to context.rotate accepts degrees, radians, or what. 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7625 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Since "event handler attributes" is an abstract concept it might be better to just call it "event handlers" so attributes is not confused with either IDL or content attributes here. 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7626 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Spec says: "Note: Removing an event handler content attribute does not reset the corresponding event handler attribute.". In fact browsers will remove or "deactivate" the listener when you remove the HTML attribute. Some browsers reset it to null or undef 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7627 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Cross-reference more occurrences of "being rendered". 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7628 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The later 'block' box container should simply map to the first/last dd element. This makes UA implementations easier and script emulation of the feature in contemporary UAs as well. Both can simply toggle the display property between block and none. 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7629 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE When the dd element is used inside figure and details it should probably not have margin by default. 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7631 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Don't invoke resource selection algorithm when inserting <source> if src="" is present 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7632 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Should resource selection algorithm be run when src="" is removed? 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7633 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike VERI WONT The use of @summary should be encouraged when circumstances warrant 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7635 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Include an example with the table rearranged so that it doesn't need a description, and advice that doing so might be more useful than writing a description 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7636 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE shouldn't dom-table-summary be part of the HTMLTableElement interface proper? 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7637 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Where is HTMLAnchorElement.name defined? I don't see it here nor in the main interface definition 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7638 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT editorial: Add a pointer to the supplemental interface behind a class=impl for all interfaces that have a supplemental interface in this spec (in the obsolete section) 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7639 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Please remove "dc" and "ds" from the parser 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7640 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The definition of the "isindex" element here makes such elements' main interface be HTMLElement rather than HTMLUnknownElement. I suppose that's not intended 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7641 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL The rendering of <details> says everything but the first dt will be hidden, but the element definition says the first dd represents the details. Also, having overflow:hidden when the details are open probably has unintended side-effects like clipping cont 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7642 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE which attribute wins if both pointsize and size are specified? 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7643 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Why not use display:none instead of overflow:hidden; height:0? display:none seems to have the desired behavior in terms of exposure to AT and keyboard navigation in browsers. 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7644 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK The first example for footnotes is actually an example of a dialogue. 2009-09-15 2010-10-04
7645 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK associate printable pages and less-convenient-to-print pages with link rel value "print" 2009-09-16 2010-10-04
7646 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Media Queries 2009-09-16 2010-10-04
7649 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE It would be useful to see an example of how section works when it's not in the context of an article, in the example text (chapters, tabs, etc) all of those would sit inside a wrapping article element. 2009-09-16 2010-10-04
7652 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Is it fine for <nav> to link to a bunch of external pages? E.g. your Flickr/Facebook/Twitter/etc. profiles? 2009-09-16 2010-10-04
7655 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL having overflow:hidden when the details are open probably has unintended side-effects like clipping content and affecting floats. display:none/block seems better in terms of AT exposure and keyboard nav 2009-09-16 2010-10-04
7657 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike CLOS FIXE Redefining dt and dd 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7658 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED s/the requisite element/the requested element/ 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7659 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Clarify what "other applicable specifications" means to say http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-tag/2009Sep/0045.html 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7660 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The resource selection algorithm should set currentSrc in the sync section before invoking resource fetch instead of being set in the async resource fetch. Otherwise checking currentSrc in onloadstart is not reliable. 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7661 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED status 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7663 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED search 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7664 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED The in-memory representation is known as "DOM HTML", or "the DOM" for short. This specification defines version 5 of DOM HTML, known as "DOM5 HTML". 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7668 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE 7.9.6 should explain which events are actually dispatched when copying/cutting/pasting 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7669 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Redefining dt and dd, recommend new element as caption for Figure 2009-09-17 2010-10-04
7672 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT </p> shouldn't be ignored in "before html", "before head", "in head", "in head noscript", "after head". It should be reprocessed through to "in body" like </br>. 2009-09-18 2010-10-04
7674 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED are the chunks for inputs having the content-type header for each chunk specified appropriately? e.g. file inputs should set the header according to the file selected by the user 2009-09-18 2010-10-04
7677 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Is there any behavior defined for setting the src property. For example, is the expectation that object should (A) load the src if autobuffer is true (B) stop playing if currently playing (C) something else (D) nothing at all? 2009-09-18 2010-10-04
7679 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE editorial: "The following content attributes must not be specified" applies to authors but is hidden behind class=impl. It would be helpful if each state listed the attributes that are allowed to be specified for that state. 2009-09-19 2010-10-04
7682 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT link tag: rel: associate pages about the same organization across many sites 2009-09-21 2010-10-04
7684 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA ApplicationCache object can be empty but not an application cache 2009-09-21 2010-10-04
7685 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED States of ApplicationCache objects are inconsistent with application caches 2009-09-21 2010-10-04
7686 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE No need to require user interface in cache update algorithm 2009-09-21 2010-10-04
7687 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Use "representation" instead of "resource" in section 6.9 2009-09-21 2010-10-04
7689 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Cache-defeating semantics are not defined 2009-09-21 2010-10-04
7690 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Incompletely defined priority of fallback over explicit entries 2009-09-21 2010-10-04
7691 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE each of which 'has', not 'have' 2009-09-21 2010-10-04
7693 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA The term "Draft Standard" means something different in IETF than meant here, which adds to the confusion. "Editor's Draft" would be better. 2009-09-22 2010-10-04
7694 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED object@classid is missing from list of Content attributes, even though it is essential 2009-09-22 2010-10-04
7696 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA zxcszxczxc 2009-09-22 2010-10-04
7697 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA The type attribute should ammend the Accept header accordingly. HTTP spec is in accordance with the rules here, in terms of the Accept header being non-authorative. script and style elements already ammend accept header (in firefox) but not for other link 2009-09-22 2010-10-04
7699 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE define reset event 2009-09-22 2010-10-04
7700 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE define abort event 2009-09-22 2010-10-04
7701 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Step 6.2 tells you to remove node from the stack of open elements and then go to step 6.1. 6.1 requires that you set node to be the node above node in the stack of open elements. However node is no longer in the stack of open elements 2009-09-22 2010-10-04
7703 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED HTML document conformance should explicitly depend on foreign content conformance 2009-09-22 2010-10-04
7705 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT What use of providing both "embed" and "object" elements? They play nearly same role. 2009-09-23 2010-10-04
7706 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE This section should reference "matches a fallback namespace" in step 3. 2009-09-23 2010-10-04
7708 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Include some documentation here (or link to) how the time element with a pubdate attribute applies to article. 2009-09-23 2010-10-04
7709 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Prevent PUT/DELETE cross-origin 2009-09-23 2010-10-04
7710 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "Any byte or sequences of bytes [...] that is misinterpreted [...]" - s/sequences/sequence/ 2009-09-23 2010-10-04
7711 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT The "strong native semantics" are worded very similarly -- but not quite the same -- for input type=Number, input type=range, and progressbar. 2009-09-23 2010-10-04
7712 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED oncontextmenu 2009-09-23 2010-10-04
7714 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL the diagram image says "tokeniser"; should be "tokenizer" 2009-09-23 2012-04-05
7717 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE If the user does not give permission it is not stated explicitly what will happen. It would be nice if the specification did state that the algorithm will be terminated at that point. (Should an event be dispatched?) 2009-09-24 2010-10-04
7718 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE "If a Document or image was generated from a data: URL that was returned as the location of an HTTP redirect" ... "If a Document or image was obtained in some other manner (e.g. ... a data: URL returned as the location of an HTTP redirect ...)" - the last 2009-09-24 2010-10-04
7721 HTML WG pre-LC1 gez.lemon CLOS LATE Drag and Drop is not keyboard accessible 2009-09-24 2013-01-16
7722 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Relationship between 2009-09-24 2010-10-04
7723 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE duplicate word ("first first") should be "first five" 2009-09-24 2010-10-04
7724 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK I would like to know: what is to become of the A element’s NAME attribute? I validated a HTML5 website that I am working this Wednesday (2009-09-23) which contained an A element with a NAME attribute: the W3C Markup Validator did not mind one bit. Howe 2009-09-24 2010-10-04
7725 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE It should be made more clear that only the "disk representation" is changed, not the "memory representation". I.e. images are not suddenly reloaded etc. 2009-09-25 2010-10-04
7726 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE legacy doctype syntax allows <!DOCTYPE HTML SYSTEM"about:legacy-compat"> 2009-09-25 2010-10-04
7727 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT legacy doc type does not need to be discouraged by "SHOULD NOT" 2009-09-25 2010-12-16
7730 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE The note starting "The algorithm described..." should end with the word "limitations" or "constraints" or something 2009-09-26 2010-10-04
7732 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Server crawls (also on Safari), then page's loading slow and in parts, get a bizzare feeling, it's no longer a web page but an app I'am loading, don't like that, resizing causes page blanks of seconds length 2009-09-26 2010-10-04
7733 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Too simplistic to handle used cases with more complex controls than toggle, like carousel, tabs. It could work for accordians. 2009-09-26 2010-10-04
7734 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED open being an attribute of the section rather than the content area means you can never use this to mark up content which has multiple control/detail areas which are opened or closed independently like tabs or accordion 2009-09-26 2010-10-04
7735 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT perhaps open could be an int rather than boolean, indicating which content area was open to make using this model for tabs easier 2009-09-26 2010-10-04
7739 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Add ids to author notes to allow direct linking 2009-09-28 2010-10-04
7741 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE First set of examples of alternative stylesheets have stylesheet titles marked up with href attributes rather than title attributes 2009-09-28 2010-10-04
7744 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Is sniffing required? 2009-09-28 2010-10-04
7745 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Shouldn't the spec state that it is the second (or third) versin of XHTML, known as XHTML5 as there haven't been version 3 or 4. 2009-09-28 2010-10-04
7746 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED <link rel=search> should be used instead of <input type=search> for backwards-compatibility and beacuse the search input type poses no additional input restrictions. 2009-09-28 2010-10-04
7747 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Attribute language not allowed on element script at this point 2009-09-28 2010-10-04
7748 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Does it have to be an absolute path or can it be a relative one, too? 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7751 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "the user agent instantiate a Java Language runtime plugin" misses a SHOULD-level requirement after "user agent". 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7752 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Please use "URL character encoding" instead of just "character encoding" for clarity 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7753 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The order of section headers and data lines should be aligned. 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7754 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make it clear that the URLs entered for online whitelist sections are in fact namespaces as well. 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7755 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Rename online whitelist URLs to online whitelist namespaces 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7757 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The "application cache update process" does not take a browsing context as argument. Do you mean the pass the active document as cache host? It should be more explicit about what is what. 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7759 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The "application cache update process" does not take a single application cache as argument. It takes an application cache group. This means the "If document was loaded from an application cache" step is wrong. 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7760 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA appcache event summary for error is wrong 2009-09-29 2010-10-08
7761 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA It would be nice to have some kind of comment as to how the checking and downloading events from step 2 interact with the events of the same name in step 3 and beyond. 2009-09-29 2010-12-01
7762 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE If I'm reading the algorithm in step 17 correctly you never get a process event when all files have been downloaded. 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7763 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The information given in the progress event may not be useful if the user agent decides to skip a URL. It seems that the URLs to skip should be determined beforehand. 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7764 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Since the online whitelist entries are namespaces it should not use a prefix match but instead something more complicated as is defined for fallback entries in 6.9.5. 2009-09-29 2010-12-01
7765 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Maybe progress should be named fetchcachefile or some such 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7766 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Fallback namespace overlap/repetition ignored 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7767 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Atomic update of application cache is not well-defined 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7768 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Manifest download error means obsolete or idle cache group? 2009-09-29 2010-10-04
7769 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT event handler IDL attributes and content attributes should reflect each other 2009-09-30 2010-10-04
7771 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE matching fallback namespaces 2009-09-30 2010-10-04
7772 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE add interfaces to event summary 2009-09-30 2010-10-04
7773 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Suggestion for "Updating an application cache" 2009-09-30 2010-10-04
7775 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA are the extra events needed when status is checking or downloading 2009-09-30 2010-12-01
7776 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA rename appcache events? 2009-09-30 2010-12-01
7778 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED "interpreted as a character encoding" is not linked to a defined algorithm 2009-09-30 2010-10-04
7779 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Missing task source for application cache events 2009-09-30 2010-10-04
7780 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT simplify appcache terminology 2009-10-01 2010-10-04
7781 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE forbid duplicate online whitelist namespaces 2009-10-01 2010-10-04
7782 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED "select an application cache" is vague 2009-10-01 2010-10-04
7783 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT appcache download events 2009-10-01 2010-10-04
7784 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "cache failure steps" feedback 2009-10-01 2010-10-04
7785 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Expiring application caches" feedback 2009-10-01 2010-10-04
7786 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE change priority for online whitelist namespaces other than * 2009-10-01 2010-10-04
7792 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE async on inline script is gratuitously backwards-incompatible, should be ignored 2009-10-02 2010-10-04
7799 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED If the fragid doesn't match an ID or a name in the document, then surely the browser should revert to doing a text search for the fragid text in the document 2009-10-04 2010-10-04
7801 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Shouldn't autofocus be included in this matrix? 2009-10-05 2010-10-04
7803 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The title element's "value" is earlier defined to be the value of its child text nodes -- not textContent 2009-10-05 2010-10-04
7804 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In Firefox and Safari .text returns the value of the child text nodes -- not textContent 2009-10-05 2010-10-04
7805 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK The tag name of foreign elements aren't necessarily all-lowercase. 2009-10-05 2010-10-04
7806 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE atom ID element generation for feed entries 2009-10-05 2010-10-04
7807 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE term "new master" can be ambiguous 2009-10-05 2010-10-04
7809 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The character ranges in this section should follow the conventions of other ranges. I.e. "to" instead of ".." and the name of the character directly after the Unicode code point. 2009-10-05 2010-10-04
7810 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Maybe it's just me, but this paragraph is unclear to me. It is too difficult to understand. What is transparent content? 2009-10-05 2010-10-04
7816 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE editorial: stray colon here in author view 2009-10-06 2010-10-04
7817 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Last example: stray </p> 2009-10-06 2010-10-04
7820 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE s/codec parameter/codecs parameter/ twice 2009-10-06 2010-10-04
7824 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE It would be very helpful to have a brief mention here of *why* the WindowProxy object exists. 2009-10-06 2010-10-04
7825 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK typo: "if one available" should read "if one is available" 2009-10-06 2010-10-04
7826 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Should mention that <hgroup> is a valid context for <hx>. 2009-10-07 2010-10-04
7830 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Does the spec handle selecting multiple objects to drag (holding shift, or command keys) 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7831 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Does the spec handle setting a drag object type, and having drop targets only respond/highlight to certain drag object types? 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7832 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The 'for' attribute could point to a element (eg. form) to indicate progress without need for scripting. 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7834 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "If a new element is inserted between the two nodes that define pointer" - s/element/node/ 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7835 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE It's not defined what the ownerDocument should be for the created HTMLAudioElement. Similarly for new Image() and new Option() 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7836 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Should the name="" of a <map> be unique in the document? 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7837 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "space separated list" in ping="" isn't properly xreffed 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7838 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The words "boolean attribute" aren't xreffed here. 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7839 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Missing (unbalanced) quotemark before "checkbox" keyword. 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7840 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Index of attributes lacks global attributes 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7841 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE s/that the user agent/the user agent/ 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7842 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE No programmatic way to make an HTML document - consider adding createHTMLDocument 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7843 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Please make 'abort', ' loadend' and 'emptied' use "queue a task". Firing them sync is annoying to implement and doesn't seem to solve any problem. 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7844 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Remove "that is in a Document and" when the src attribute is set and when a source is inserted, because there's no reason resource selection shouldn't be run when it's not in the document. Then we also don't have to run resource selection when inserting a 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7845 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED javascript 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7846 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL javascript 2009-10-08 2010-10-22
7847 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK for - label - "Associatd" 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7848 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK MathML version used in HTML5 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7849 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Check whether .search should or shouldn't work with data: URLs 2009-10-08 2010-10-04
7850 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Trying out loud 2009-10-09 2010-10-08
7851 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Some (perhaps all) scripts with a for="" attribute should be ignored 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7852 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE DOM Events has dropped namespaces. Drop all init*EventNS methods. 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7853 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA metadata 2009-10-09 2010-10-08
7854 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "offline application cache" doesn't xref right 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7855 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Define fragment parsing when the context is not an HTML, SVG or MathML node 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7857 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Wait for the browsing context to be closed" should be explicit about spinning a nested event loop 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7858 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE All the current entries should merge into one current entry in the joint session history. (imagine a series of nested iframes that haven't been navigated, and call go(-1)... it should go back at the top-level, not do something weird with the iframes) 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7859 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Mention under step 1 that it can also be aborted if the user agent has discovered that there is no network available and therefore cannot perform HTTP requests. This prevents dispatching error events when the user is using the application offline. 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7861 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK requirements for meta/http-equiv extensions 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7862 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Support Extended Processing Behavior via @profile/@version 2009-10-09 2010-10-04
7865 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE BenB wants an example of use of datetime-local, e.g. "What time should your event start", with no timezone information, so that the site can keep the event starting at that time in the user's time zone regardless of what time zone the user moves to by the 2009-10-10 2010-10-04
7866 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA so much more simple to work with! 2009-10-10 2010-10-08
7867 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT How should a browser render this? Give examples for "typical" or "good" implementations, maybe even for different device types. Should specify that a desktop browser should give a calendar widget, because airlines etc. want that (implement it in JS, but b 2009-10-10 2010-10-12
7868 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED what about time zones? which one is used? local (may be difficult to find out)? is this communicated to the user? can he change it? 2009-10-10 2010-10-12
7869 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE complicated calculation given, but not clearly (only implicitly) stating the obvious question: which day does the week start with? I strongly feel it's Monday, but other people/cultures disagree, I think. 2009-10-10 2010-10-04
7870 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA how does a user enter a "week"? calendar widget? how would he enter it as text? 2009-10-10 2010-10-08
7871 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT there's more meaning to a password field than just being obstructed. it's really only for passwords / credentials. firefox stores them in the password manager, for example, meaning FF really gives it the meaning "password", not just "obstructed". the defi 2009-10-10 2016-11-10
7872 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I have no idea how a "search field" would look like, on any platform. describe. 2009-10-10 2010-10-04
7873 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK what about backwards compat? can you imagine google or my personal blog website using <input type="search"> for the search field? what about older browsers? 2009-10-10 2010-10-04
7875 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT term: a "range" is an interval between two numbers, e.g. 2-4 or 1969-2032. the term "range" does not mean "imprecise number". 2009-10-10 2010-10-04
7876 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "A synchronous section never mutates the DOM, runs any script, or have any other side-effects." should say "has any other". 2009-10-10 2010-10-04
7877 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED A media.stop() method would be advantageous, having just pause does restrict the bounds of use especially for media players on a website. 2009-10-10 2010-10-04
7878 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED An attribute to actually find out if something is playing would be nice (.isplaying). Unless I'm wrong currently you can't actually tell if something is playing without setting var with JS when you start to play and you can't go by the playback position s 2009-10-10 2010-10-04
7879 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE 'unload' event has a different interface than it says in the index 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7880 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE 'popstate' event has a different interface than it says in the index 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7881 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE 'undo', 'redo' events have a different interface than it says in the index 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7882 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE 'message' events has a different interface than it says in the index 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7883 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/defind/defined/ 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7884 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL s/defind/defined/ 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7885 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "…the element does not have an async attribute, or": s/, or// 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7886 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Drop applet, marquee 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7887 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Drop HTMLTableDataCellElement and HTMLTableHeaderCellElement 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7888 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/Computer input/User input/ 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7889 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE audio, canvas and video are missing 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7890 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "When no more character are": s/character/characters/ 2009-10-11 2010-10-04
7892 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7893 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In the example <div id="b" itemprop="band" itemscope id="jazzband"> the div element has two id attributes. Is this desirable? 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7894 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED what is 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7895 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In step 6, it should be allowed (and clear that it is allowed) for UAs to use additional data such as the site TLD to guess the correct encoding 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7896 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Specify pageshow and pagehide events 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7897 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE One can argue that "Any (namespace-less) attribute may be specified ..." contradicts with obsolete feature section where use of some attributes is disallowed 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7898 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Maybe this section should cover all elements and attributes historically allowed by IETF standards and W3C Recommendations but no longer allowed, such as <rb> and <a urn> for consistency 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7900 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED timedate 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7901 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA ijhugytfd 2009-10-12 2010-10-08
7902 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA ijhugytfdsdfgdsd 2009-10-12 2010-10-08
7903 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA yhjrth 2009-10-12 2010-10-08
7904 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA sex and moooooore seeeex 2009-10-12 2010-10-08
7905 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Markup in second example has formatting broken - titlecase on tags and > creating line breaks 2009-10-12 2010-10-04
7906 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The venn diagram is all black in the PDF copy 2009-10-13 2010-10-04
7909 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE It seems like this is a subsection of the wrong section. Either it should just be a level up or it should be moved up one section. 2009-10-13 2010-10-04
7910 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Since IANA considerations is an appendix, its subsections should be marked as such as well. 2009-10-13 2010-10-04
7914 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE step. 6 should say "object" not "array", right? i.e. "whose value is the object _properties_" 2009-10-14 2010-10-04
7915 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE “itemref” element is missing, <http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/semantics.html#itemref> 2009-10-14 2010-10-04
7917 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE document.close() should attempt to tokenize 2009-10-14 2010-10-04
7918 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT prefetching: allow site to deny 2009-10-14 2010-10-04
7920 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT media queries ref 2009-10-14 2010-10-04
7923 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED What about local files access? 2009-10-14 2010-10-04
7924 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED xaXAafs 2009-10-15 2010-10-04
7926 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Undefine insertion point if parser on call stack doing anything other than running script element 2009-10-15 2010-10-04
7927 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE widht/height says "map to the dimension properties" but the link goes to "maps to the pixel length property" 2009-10-15 2010-10-04
7931 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The "loop" label in the 'A start tag whose tag name is "li"' is misplaced, or there is something else wrong that is making the loop useless. 2009-10-15 2010-10-04
7936 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED Consider https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=521670 2009-10-16 2010-10-04
7937 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT er might return the document with one paragraph modified as follows: <p>I also have some <mark>kitten</mark>s who are visiting me these days. They're really cute. I think they like my garden! Maybe I should adopt a <mark>kitten</mark>.</p> 2009-10-16 2010-10-04
7939 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK stalled is a simple event according to the resource fetch algorithm in 4.8.10.5 Loading the media resource 2009-10-17 2010-10-04
7940 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Under "content model", it isn't clear what the significance of the italic "or" is. If it is intended to signify a higher precidence "or", consider using bullet points to clarify the nesting of conjuctions. 2009-10-17 2010-10-04
7944 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA vCard: agent: avoid power-of-attorney implication 2009-10-18 2010-10-08
7945 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Add a reference to [PROGRESS] here, or make |progress| a simple event (twice) 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7946 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Ping-From, Ping-To: wrong heading level or in the wrong section 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7947 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/script's global scope/script's global object/g, s/script browsing context/script's browsing context/g 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7948 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE [RFC2781] should be referenced in the third Note? 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7949 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE This should be marked as a willful violation to RFC 2616 where missing of the charset parameter is interpreted as iso-8859-1 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7950 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK xref "offline application cache" 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7951 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE First example: http://example.com/jon/ & http://example.com/~jon/ are used 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7952 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/<span>same</span>/same/ 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7953 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/must be performd/must be performed/ 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7954 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK s/<span>valid URLs</span>/<span title="valid-url">valid URLs</span>/ 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7956 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It is not obvious if or how a caption can be placed below a table instead of above the table. This section might benefit from a sentence or two clarifying that. 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7957 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE [Webstorage] s/<span>browsing contexts</span>/<span title="browsing-context">browsing contexts</span>/ 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7958 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "(end-1)th position": add title="" 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7959 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/<span>editing hosts</span>/<span title="editing-host">editing hosts</span>/ 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7960 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/<span title="absolute URLs">absolute URL</span>/<span title="absolute URL">absolute URLs</span>/ 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7961 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK "script execution context" isn't defined 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7962 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/<span>last event ID string</span>/<span title="concept-event-stream-last-event-id">last event ID string</span>/g 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7963 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK 11. "Otherwise, if current is not a refid element" should be an itemref element. 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7964 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Either change the "properties of an item" algorithm to be tree-order or HTMLPropertyCollection.values to be algorithm-order 2009-10-18 2010-10-04
7965 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "ASCII case-sensitive" in "Markup declaration open state" is a broken xref 2009-10-19 2010-10-04
7971 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <base> UA requirements (determining base URL of a Document object) 2009-10-19 2010-10-04
7972 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It appears that the steps listed for what to do when reset() is invoked contain a race condition unless step 1 (checking if already marked) and step 2 (marking the form as locked) are performed atomically together. 2009-10-20 2010-10-04
7973 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE atom ID format 2009-10-20 2010-10-04
7974 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Please explain what the use case is for the 'emptied' event or drop the event from the spec 2009-10-20 2010-10-04
7977 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Define whether application/octet-stream with parameters is a type that the user agent knows it cannot render 2009-10-20 2010-10-14
7978 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Form foster parenting introduces extra space to layout 2009-10-20 2010-10-04
7979 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "special characters" is unnecessarily vague -- refer to delimiters 2009-10-20 2010-10-04
7980 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "presented by" should be "represented here by" 2009-10-20 2010-10-04
7981 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/restrictiosn/restrictions/ 2009-10-20 2010-10-04
7987 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Clean up load() 2009-10-20 2010-10-04
7988 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Remove "spacer". IE, WebKit and Opera parse it as a normal unknown element 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7989 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE nextid, rb and spacer should use HTMLUnknownElement (like isindex) 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7990 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Add itemref interface 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7991 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "This specification ... include ... a full duplex client-server communication channel" - I assume that refers to Web Sockets, which is no longer included in this spec 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7992 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Original insertion mode concept doesn't work well when SVG with HTML content embedded in non-body context 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7993 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "areas that are out of scope" - dead link to deleted section #no 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7994 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT afdasfasdf 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7995 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The attribute value can be left unquoted if it doesn't contain any of " ' ` = < or >." - should also mention space characters 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7996 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "any MIME type ending with the four characters "+xml"" - even the 'valid MIME type' "text/html; charset=utf8+xml", and not "application/xhtml+xml; charset=utf8"? Probably this should require the MIME type's *subtype* to end with +xml 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7997 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "if it matches the media-type token" - s/token/rule/ (to use the correct ABNF terminology) 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
7998 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "any of the DOM and WebAPI specifications" - what's a WebAPI specification? (Presumably this refers to Web IDL, but I can only tell that by looking at the Web IDL spec's URL in the references section, so it's not very clear.) 2009-10-21 2010-10-04
8000 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE ARIA roles added to the a element should be conforming in HTML5 2009-10-21 2012-01-13
8003 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike RESO WONT line breaks in attributes (especially title) 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8005 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT For control and permanently undefined characters no action is given: Whould they be replaced my fffd? 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8007 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The step that skips "+" does not say '(The "+" is ignored, but it is not conforming.)', whereas the rules for signed integers do say that (and it seems a helpful comment) 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8008 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The plus-sign case fails to say "If position is past the end of input, return an error" after it advances position, and so the next character used in step 8 may be undefined 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8009 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Add the value of the current character" - is the 'current character' the same as the 'next character'? Why use a different term? Seems better to be consistent. (Same for signed integers) 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8010 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE A valid floating point number was defined as a string, and I'd assume valid ones are a subset of all floating point numbers, so this is the best representation of a string. Applying ToString to a string isn't very interesting. It needs to be clear that it 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8011 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE ECMAScript says the result of ToString on Number is not uniquely determined (in the last digit of s), but HTML5 makes it sound like there's a single best representation of any number. It should explicitly note that the best representation may be any one o 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8012 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE This says "Collect a sequence of characters ... interpret the resulting sequence as a base-ten integer", whereas the signed and unsigned integers had a whole five-step loop to do precisely the same thing. They should all use the simpler phrasing, since it 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8013 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "string is guaranteed to be a valid floating point number" - no it's not - it could be "0." which is not valid 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8014 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "the character immediately after the last one examined by the sub-algorithm" - what does 'examined' mean? To find the number in "123XY" it has to examine the X, so is that counted? Probably should say "after the last one matched" instead 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8015 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "skip all White_Space characters" - should xref to "skip White_Space characters" 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8016 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED anything 2009-10-22 2010-10-04
8018 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT The space characters cases within the before DOCTYPE public/system identifier states can never be reached. To fix that, remove those cases. 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8019 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <!DOCTYPE html PUBLICa> throws two parse errors. 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8020 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "return value as an integer" - that number needs to be categorised as either a percentage or a length, as stated in the introduction 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8021 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The step with dividing by 10^{length} is phrased very differently to the fraction loop for parsing floating point numbers, but seems to be achieving the same result. They should be phrased the same, to make it clear they're computing the same thing. 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8022 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "ISO8601 libraries might not parse dates and times exactly the same manner" - should be "*in* exactly the same manner" 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8023 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "If day is not a number in the range 1 ≤ month ≤ maxday, then fail." - s/month/day/ 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8024 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "the time zone in use on the east coast of North America during daylight saving time." - should say USA, not North America. (e.g. Nova Scotia looks like it's on the east coast of North America, but it's UTC-3 in DST.) 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8025 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Dates before the year zero can't be represented as a datetime in this version of HTML." - s/zero/one/ (though I suppose that's not precisely correct since 0001-01-01T00:00+23:59 is almost a day earlier than the year 1) 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8026 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Given a datetime ...T00:00Z, is the best representation ...T00:00-00:00 or ...T00:00+00:00? 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8027 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Does the time-zone offset also consist of a sign? If so, it should be listed in the introduction. If not, the 'valid ...' definition can't say +/- represents the offset's sign. 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8028 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE If the first character is not Z or + or -, the subalgorithm returns undefined values. It should explicitly fail and return nothing. 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8029 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE From RCDATA state, & goes to char ref in data, which then goes to data state. Should go back to RCDATA state. 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8030 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "either 52 weeks or 53 such seven-day periods" - s/weeks// 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8032 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Wouldn't it be better to show video/audio controls by default? Otherwise you might end up with media visible on the page that is impossible to play. 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8033 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Note in the prose that some exceptions aren't actually defined in [DOMCORE] yet 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8034 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It appears that there is no way to draw more than one line of text per call to fillText/strokeText, so what is the point of discarding any line-height value set in the font attribute? 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8035 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTMLAllCollection should inherit from HTMLCollection 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8036 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTMLOptionsCollection should inherit from HTMLCollection 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8037 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The form controls collection should just be an HTMLCollection instead of having an HTMLFormControlsCollection interface 2009-10-23 2010-10-04
8038 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Permit closing tag for new, void elements - for legacy compatibility = XHTML alignment 2009-10-24 2011-01-19
8039 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Let queue be a stack of elements" - this is quite a confusing choice of terminology 2009-10-24 2010-10-04
8040 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE editorial: this list is not in alphabetical order (itemref should be higher up) 2009-10-24 2010-10-04
8041 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Should say "This algorithm will return either a number, or a number and a denominator character, or two numbers, or nothing", for consistency with other algorithms 2009-10-24 2010-10-04
8042 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "if denominator has value" - should be "*a* value" 2009-10-24 2010-10-04
8043 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "It is given a string and a starting position" - no it's not. It should probably instead say "Let input and position be the same variables as those of the same name in the algorithm that invoked these steps." 2009-10-24 2010-10-04
8044 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The document's current address can contain fragments. HTTP says the Referer must not contain fragments. Presumably HTML5 ought to say to strip the fragment. (document.referrer is affected the same way.) 2009-10-24 2010-10-04
8045 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Should be called "limited to only non-negative numbers", because it allows 0 (which is not a positive number) 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8046 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Reflecting floats: The IDL attribute types include +/-Infinity, so it doesn't make sense to talk about floats being "out of range" because everything is within the infinite range 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8047 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Reflecting floats: The rules for parsing floating point number values return an unlimited-precision (finite in base 10) number. How is it converted to limited-precision IDL attribute types? In particular, what rounding mode is used? and do very large valu 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8048 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The same DOMTokenList object must be returned every time for each attribute" - should say "DOMTokenList or DOMSettableTokenList" 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8049 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE For consistency with HTMLFormControlsCollection and HTMLOptionsCollection, this should probably be called HTMLPropertiesCollection 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8050 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "creator void (in DOMString name);" - should have a 'value' argument 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8051 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK "The following DOMException codes are defined in DOM Core." - no they're not (only 1..17 are defined in the referenced document) 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8052 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The spec should not allow <map name=a> when there is <map name=A> 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8053 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT why &race; defined in older revision has been removed? 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8054 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE lastModified could perhaps return a date like "10/25/0002009". It should say that the year is the "*shortest possible* string of four or more digits ..." 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8055 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "of the RFC 2046" - s/the// 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8056 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Replace any sequence of two or more consecutive space characters in value with a single U+0020 SPACE character." - should be "one or more", so that single newlines etc get turned into spaces too 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8057 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE IDL block needs class="idl" 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8058 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The hgroup element should be used in these kinds of situations:" - shouldn't use normative keywords in non-normative text 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8059 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "This includes HTML elements in XML documents, even when those documents are in another context (e.g. inside an XSLT transform)" - that seems to conflict with an earlier example saying "if the element is found within a transformation expressed in XSLT (as 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8060 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Why must class be a set of unique tokens? It's quite common to have duplicates (~0.5% of dotbot pages), and convenient when you're programmatically generating HTML, and harmless 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8061 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Authors may use any value in the class attribute" - no they mayn't, since earlier it was said it "must have a value that is ...". Maybe it should say "Authors may use any token values ...". Also, s/use the values/use values/ 2009-10-25 2010-10-04
8062 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "there must be namespace declaration" - should be "a" or "declarations" or something 2009-10-26 2010-10-04
8063 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "correponding" 2009-10-26 2010-10-04
8064 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "... and thus their behavior, varies depending on ..." - remove comma 2009-10-26 2010-10-04
8065 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Otherwise, let new children be targets returned." - s/targets/the nodes/ 2009-10-26 2010-10-04
8066 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Parsed the given string text as HTML or XML and inserts" - should be "Parses" 2009-10-26 2010-10-04
8067 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL "Otherwise, let new children be targets returned." - s/targets/the nodes/ 2009-10-26 2010-10-04
8073 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "For example, redirects must be followed" - examples are non-normative, so this should not use normative keywords 2009-10-26 2010-10-04
8074 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The document load event is delayed until all resources are obtained, but obtaining might be delayed indefinitely if the resource is fetched when needed and not pro-actively, so load may be delayed indefinitely, which doesn't sound sensible. Is that intent 2009-10-26 2010-10-04
8077 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED article 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8079 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "the document is therefore required to use UTF-8 as its encoding" - this sounds like it's intended as an informative restatement of the conformance requirements in #character-encoding-declaration, in which case it shouldn't use the normative keyword "requ 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8080 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Event firing section still talks about namespaces 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8081 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE There should be an example of the content="0; url=http://example.com/" style syntax, because it's particularly hard to deduce from the definition of valid syntax 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8082 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "a HTTP header" - s/a/an/ 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8083 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Pragma directions" - s/ons/ves/ 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8084 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "In particular, this applies to encodings in which the bytes corresponding to "<script>" in ASCII can encode a different string." - s/In particular/For example/ (there's nothing particular about <script>, it could be <img onload=...> or <div style=color:e 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8085 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The list of known dangerous encodings should include JOHAB and CP1361, both of which encode characters to sequences with the byte "<", and both of which are supported by iconv (and presumably other implementations) 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8086 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Furtermore" 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8087 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE '<any string that doesn't contain the substring "-->" >' is not valid ABNF (prose-val can't contain '>') 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8088 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Change back the meaning of <meta http-equiv="Content-Language" content="FOO, BAR"> 2009-10-27 2011-04-08
8089 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "identifying a script resource of the type given by the type attribute, if the attribute is present, or of the type "text/javascript", if the attribute is absent." - what does "of the type" mean? Sounds like it means the HTTP content-type must be that val 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8090 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "must be the preferred MIME name for that encoding" - should say it's an ASCII case-insensitive match of the preferred MIME name 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8091 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE What must the flag initially be, when it wasn't set by the HTML parser? 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8092 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTMLCollection subclass interfaces are incompatible with static languages 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8093 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Why is the browsing context name reset on domain navigation? 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8094 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE It's not very clear whether or not this includes word-style, squiggly-line, as-you-type spell-checking. This feature sounds like more of a manual spell-check done after a body of text is completed. Should a spell-check option be added to the CSS spec for 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8095 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL link's "type" attribute could be used to advertise available representations if it were linked to the Accept: header per Mike Kelly's thread(s) 2009-10-27 2010-10-22
8096 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED <link>'s "type" attribute should be allowed to appear multiple times and/or should allow for a space separated list of advertised types, such that clients can request them via the Accept: header. 2009-10-27 2010-10-04
8097 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Link relation types should use the IANA registry per draft-nottingham-http-link-header 2009-10-27 2010-10-22
8099 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Update 9.5 (Parsing HTML Fragments) for "script data" tokenizer state 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8100 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo : double "the" 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8101 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: doubled "the" 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8102 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: doubled "the", and that two times. 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8103 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: doubled "the", and that two times. 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8104 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: doubled "the" 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8105 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: doubled "the" 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8106 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: doubled "the" 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8107 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I dont think that itemid should be prohibited if there is no itemtype. Several of the use cases would work fine with an id but no type 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8109 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I'm looking for the API proposal of accessing metadata of media files. For example, I'll want to access metadata of audio files for to get it's title, artists, etc. Or, if I need to get the shooting time of photo, I'll want to get it from JPEG's EXIF 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8110 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <table border=adsf> should also have 1px border 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8111 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE when <table border> is present, the border-width of the table's th and td should be set to 1px as a presentational hint 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8112 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT the border-style on table and td, th should only be set when <table border> is present 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8113 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE checking should be cancelable 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8114 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Section "months" should be renamed to "year-months". This is clearer, and allows the spec to add a section just handling months (without years) in the future. 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8115 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT The note on time-zone ranges is too absolute in stating the limits from -12 to +14 and 00/30/45 minutes. Add the word "currently" in to the note. 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8116 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT URNs are URIs but not URLs 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8117 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "trusted" is underlined but not a link -- missing definition? Or does the following 'i.e.' define it? 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8118 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Remove the Hidden Attribute 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8120 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Shoud their be any reason that two circles, pure white, alpha =1, drawn in xor mode, do not overlap each other perfectly and then do not "cancel" each other ? (this works with rects). Same effect in Safari and firefox. Thanks 2009-10-28 2010-10-04
8121 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA what does this do? 2009-10-28 2010-10-08
8122 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA This is a test 2009-10-29 2010-10-08
8125 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Can it be specified somewhere that script can define a variable named "top" with 'var top' in a global context? This is currently inconsistent across browsers. 2009-10-29 2010-10-04
8126 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA gfgfdg 2009-10-30 2010-10-08
8135 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The script element has a src attribute set where previously the element had no such attribute." - should probably only happen if the script is in a document at the time, else http://software.hixie.ch/utilities/js/live-dom-viewer/saved/298 would break (th 2009-10-30 2010-10-04
8136 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "the DOM text attribute" - s/DOM/IDL/ [pt] 2009-10-30 2010-10-04
8137 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE In the scripting-enabled case, noscript outside head has to be conforming if replaced by its parsed text, but noscript inside head doesn't (so <noscript><meta bogus></noscript> is allowed); they ought to consistently require conformingness. [pt] 2009-10-30 2010-10-04
8138 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE in aside for blogrolls example <h1>My last post</h1> appears twice, 2nd one should probably be <h1>My first post</h1> 2009-10-31 2010-10-04
8139 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA In #the-section-element the graduation programme example code formatting is strange—closing brackets have been moved to the subsequent line, elements have been first-letter capitalised 2009-10-31 2010-10-08
8140 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Consider adding color IDL attribute (IE, Gecko). [ms] 2009-10-31 2010-10-04
8141 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Add hr color content attribute [ms] 2009-10-31 2010-10-04
8142 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE title: "abbr; dfn;" - remove ";" [ms] 2009-10-31 2010-10-04
8143 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT [gsnedders] Need to add EOF here, as <xmp>foo</xmp behaviour changed when removing content model flags (also to similar RCDATA state). 2009-11-01 2010-10-04
8144 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Is a 'visibility: hidden' element being rendered? 2009-11-01 2010-10-04
8145 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Unclear: "Certain algorithms in this specification spoon-feed the parser characters one *string* at a time." Better: "one character at a time"? 2009-11-02 2010-10-04
8147 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED The suggested size limit is absurd considering the multi-GB space available on even the cheapest netbooks these days. We need a clear "I want this much, how much did the user and his agent allow me to have?" API. Otherwise, online media apps like photo al 2009-11-02 2010-10-04
8149 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Why put the > signs at the beginning of the line here? It distracts from the example. 2009-11-02 2010-10-04
8150 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In the description for article, you talk about "Web log posts" but in the example, you use the much more common and understood "blog post". I think the latter should be used throughout. (I would even go so far as to suggest that "Web log" has lost meaning 2009-11-02 2010-10-04
8151 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "If the resulting value is not a recognized language code, then it must be treated as an unknown language (as if the value was the empty string)." -- consider how this interacts with CSS :lang(), with passthrough/roundtripping, screen readers that recogni 2009-11-02 2010-10-04
8152 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Remove the <progress> and <meter> fallback magic 2009-11-03 2010-10-04
8154 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make it clear that serving polyglot documents as text/html is OK 2009-11-03 2010-10-04
8155 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA jvndjnvfdjnvdfb 2009-11-03 2010-10-08
8156 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE I think the "the" is extraneous. Should be "It indicates that no referrer information is to be leaked..." 2009-11-03 2010-10-04
8171 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Implement the text alternatives proposal from WAI 2009-11-03 2013-02-14
8173 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Last paragraph, first (only) sentence; add the "to" in brackets ([]) as follows: "are expected to distribute the remainder first [to] the last entry whose unit is relative" 2009-11-04 2010-10-04
8174 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED FF, SeaMonkey and Google Chrome crashed 2009-11-04 2010-10-04
8175 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Using the letter 'x' here is just ugly ascii art. Why not use an asterisk ('*') instead? 2009-11-04 2010-10-04
8187 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Section 4.8.7 on video makes no reference to audio description 2009-11-04 2011-03-08
8188 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Has any thought been put into changing "Fetching an external script must delay the load event..." for async scripts? It seems reasonable to at least provide a way for scripts to not block window.onload. 2009-11-04 2010-10-04
8189 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE [WA] "reset the connection" should probably be rephrased to "reestablish the connection" to be less confusing ("does it mean reset the TCP connection?") 2009-11-04 2010-10-04
8190 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE [WA] event source: "completes loading" should probably be defined in terms of the last task from the networking task source's "fetch" algorithm 2009-11-04 2010-10-04
8197 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT This design might work for JavaScript, but it won't work well in static-typed languages like Java or C#. Instead of overridding "namedItem", a better design would be to add a new method called "allNamedItems" which always returns an HTMLCollection. "nam 2009-11-05 2010-10-04
8207 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Change definition of URL to normative reference to IRIBIS 2009-11-05 2011-04-14
8208 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The data-* attributes need to be clearer about their applicability to JS libraries, and in particular should have some suggestions about using unambiguous attribute names like data-dojo-range or data-jq-selector or whatever. 2009-11-05 2010-10-04
8209 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK The term "XML document" needs xreffing throughout. 2009-11-05 2010-10-04
8211 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK HTML 4 defined these as entities &name; where the ";" wasn't part of the entity name, and there wasn't a variation that some names don't have ";". If this is an example of error recovery, valid HTML should require the ;. 2009-11-06 2010-10-04
8212 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA gggfgfgfgfgfgfg 2009-11-06 2010-10-08
8216 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE editorial: Hide "The name must be one that is terminated by a U+003B SEMICOLON character (;)." and relevant rows in the entity table from the author view. [sp] 2009-11-06 2010-10-04
8218 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE No, this algorithm cannot be aborted, as there are no synchronous events from which to call load() 2009-11-06 2010-10-04
8223 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Won't this Doctype trigger Quirks Mode? 2009-11-06 2010-10-04
8224 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Mention that it's possible for the Atom section to generate invalid Atom if there's not enough data (e.g. missing authors). 2009-11-06 2010-10-04
8225 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make it clear that the Atom generation section is not the only such algorithm (e.g. hAtom is fine too). 2009-11-06 2010-10-04
8226 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK inline review is goddamn annoying 2009-11-06 2010-10-04
8228 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL The formatting of the example is very screwed up. Needs to be reformatted to be readable. 2009-11-07 2010-10-04
8230 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It might be good with a comment in script's Content attributes section mentioning onload/onerror being defined in Global attributes (I've had the question come up several times about script.onload missing from html5). 2009-11-07 2010-10-04
8232 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE [gs] End tag "body" ignore case isn't noted as fragment case, but end tag "html" has a note saying that it can only be ignored in the fragment case. Either that note is wrong or end tag body should say it is fragment case. 2009-11-07 2010-10-04
8233 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE [gsnedders] "datagrid" parsing rules should be removed now the element is gone. 2009-11-07 2010-10-04
8234 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Can you clearify what you mean with the author link type, If i writes a paper, should I include an author link to my homepage then? 2009-11-07 2010-10-04
8235 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Given that Gecko and Webkit don't support them in XML, I think that named properties in HTMLDocument objects should be restricted to HTML documents, given that this feature is only included for backward compatibility and is horribly designed. 2009-11-07 2010-10-04
8236 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE 1) why a query is stored in the `search' attribute and a URL fragment is stored in the `fragment' attribute? The naming is a bit confusing. 2) Why the is no restrictions for the `port' attribute: an integer in a range [0-65535]; 3) The getter condition fo 2009-11-07 2010-10-04
8239 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT [gs] "insert a character" is impossible with e.g., ElementTree, as it has no concept of adjacent text nodes. Need to clarify whether that is ever conforming or not. 2009-11-08 2010-10-04
8240 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Quote: "The value attribute must not be present unless the form attribute is present." This doesn't make sense, since the button can also belong to a form by being put between the form element tags. It should read: "The value attribute must not be prese 2009-11-08 2010-10-04
8243 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE It doesn't matter what the initial order of pending is, it is sorted in step 6. 2009-11-08 2018-10-29
8244 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED can you make RDF statements where the subject is another resource here? Metadata has previously been normally where subject is the current resource (or object with rev) but general RDF does not constrain this. 2009-11-08 2010-10-04
8246 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL what about IE parsing problems? http://html5doctor.com/dd-details-wrong-again/ 2009-11-09 2010-10-22
8249 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA gjfhjkffffkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk 2009-11-09 2010-10-08
8252 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT HTTP caching rules are _ignored_? What's wrong with extending Cache-Control to support user-agent caching instead of coming up with an entirely new mechanism? 2009-11-09 2010-10-04
8255 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Channel messaging is missing a description of purpose 2009-11-10 2010-10-04
8256 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT [gs] Is form.submit() async or sync? I don't see where this is defined. From my reading it should be sync, as it should just run the steps to completion. 2009-11-10 2010-10-04
8259 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT There is one case of "The public identifier is set to" in amongst all the "The public identifier starts with". This seems like something that could easily lead to bugs. Please reorder the list to group together by the condition. 2009-11-11 2010-10-04
8260 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The name apparently must be compared in an ASCII case-insensitive manner, even though it is guaranteed to already be all ASCII lowercase from the tokenizer. It would make more sense to compare it case-sensitively (like it is earlier in the "initial" mode) 2009-11-11 2010-10-04
8261 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK "The name is set to anything other than "HTML"." - s/HTML/html/ [sp] 2009-11-11 2010-10-04
8263 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "dimenson" should be "dimension" 2009-11-11 2010-10-04
8264 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Fix terminology for "resource", "representation", "retrieval" 2009-11-11 2010-10-04
8266 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK I would like to suggest that the id attribute should be allowed to start with characters 0-9 2009-11-11 2010-10-04
8267 HTML WG pre-LC1 Ms2ger RESO FIXE the test link (http://ms2ger.freehostia.com/tests/html5/dynamic-markup-insertion/document.open.xhtml) is broken 2009-11-11 2010-10-04
8268 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK XMLHttpRequest fails for documents with named entities due to doctype 2009-11-12 2010-10-04
8272 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT why not make the heading information compulsory for the Section element ?? In a loose implementation like the current one, the Section element is acting just like a Div element but which lacks backward compatibility. 2009-11-13 2010-10-04
8307 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It would be nice if there were a way to draw an image with a color key. The only other way I can think of doing this is by a for loop and pixel by pixel copying... which probably isn't fast 2009-11-14 2010-10-04
8309 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT semantics of footnotes : why not using <aside> elements as well? 2009-11-15 2010-10-04
8310 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE script block's source initialization: please honor the specified charset and type 2009-11-16 2010-10-04
8311 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Typo error in algorithm to calculate ratios 2.4.4.4 2009-11-16 2010-10-08
8313 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The case for U+003E (">") is redundant here, as it'll be processed in the same way in "anything else". 2009-11-16 2010-10-04
8314 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA the <figure><dd></dd><dt></dt><figure> as in your example does not pass validation. it says that dd is not allowed in this format. 2009-11-16 2010-10-08
8321 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE change controller for HTML media type 2009-11-17 2010-10-04
8324 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Browsers are supposed to apply styles to all cells in a column, if the respective col or colgroup has a class attribute, right? 2009-11-17 2010-10-08
8325 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Please remove requirements that errors "must be reported to the user" and "should be reported to the user" throughout; "may be reported to the user" is appropriate. [sp] 2009-11-17 2010-10-04
8328 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA kljhklhlkhj 2009-11-17 2010-10-08
8329 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA should object/@code be omitted from list of obsolete attributes? 2009-11-18 2010-10-04
8330 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE object tag requirements language confusing 2009-11-18 2010-10-04
8332 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA websocket 2009-11-19 2010-10-08
8333 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT In the example: I do not understand why the URL that the user is accessing starts with upper case characters. If the point is, that this part is case insensitive, it should be spelled out instead of this example. 2009-11-19 2010-10-04
8334 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED the stadandard shall explicity cite an example of a url based on RTSP to promote this standard. Today LIVE sreaming is too often achieved with improper "tricks" like HTTP streaming... 2009-11-19 2010-10-04
8335 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL the stadandard shall explicity cite an example of a url based on RTSP to promote this standard. Today LIVE sreaming is too often achieved with improper "tricks" like HTTP streaming... 2009-11-19 2010-10-04
8337 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT This implies that the dragleave event is only fired in the case of an unsuccessful drag, but it's very useful to bubble a dragleave event regardless of success or failure of the drag. 2009-11-19 2010-10-04
8339 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT why html5 should have also presentational tags? 2009-11-19 2010-10-04
8341 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "an URL property element" - s/an/a/. [pt] 2009-11-19 2010-10-04
8343 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA aaaaaaa 2009-11-20 2010-10-04
8344 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Please give the detailed information and the pupose why we are using . with out that no one can understand sorry if any thing wrong with me 2009-11-20 2010-10-04
8345 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED The keygen element ought to be extended to support elliptic curve keys. This is especially important in light of NIST guidelines (see pg 63, 66 in http://csrc.nist.gov/groups/ST/toolkit/documents/SP800-57Part1_3-8-07.pdf (pg 63, pg 66) in http://csrc.nist 2009-11-20 2010-10-04
8347 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA fdfdfd 2009-11-22 2010-10-04
8348 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/content-models.html#transparent 2009-11-23 2010-10-08
8349 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/links.html#hyperlink 2009-11-23 2010-10-08
8350 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/content-models.html#annotations-for-assistive-technology-products-(aria) 2009-11-23 2010-10-08
8351 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/content-models.html#run-canceled-activation-steps 2009-11-23 2010-10-08
8352 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE the example links should include a type="" attribute to allow automatic selection of the resource to retreive without having to query each of their type to see which one is supported by the browser (this cannot be safely deduced from the "extension" in UR 2009-11-23 2010-10-04
8359 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE [WA] For Server-Sent Events, add informative language about how this could be implemented using fallback to a push-proxy using OMA Push 2009-11-23 2010-10-04
8361 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Dropping the noscript element from XHTML is problematic. E.g., in the provided example, the calculate button cannot be removed before it the browser displays it, causing a graphical glitch, whitch can be quite large depending on the size of the alterative 2009-11-24 2010-10-04
8362 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Comparing the doctype name case-insensitively is useless, because the tokenizer has already lowercased it anyway. (hsivonen) 2009-11-24 2010-10-04
8363 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTML 4 says <br> should behave like U+2028 with respect to bidi. CSS 2 refers to HTML4 for HTML elements. Only WebKit does this. Please say explicitly whether <br> should act as a "forced line break" for the purposes of bidi. [sp] 2009-11-24 2010-10-04
8364 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE hastoken = tokenlist . toggle(token): Note more clearly what the return value means for authors [ms] 2009-11-24 2010-10-04
8365 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Remove the Web Browsers Section 5 2009-11-24 2010-10-04
8366 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA 123456 2009-11-24 2010-10-08
8368 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Remove the Communication Section 8 2009-11-24 2010-10-04
8369 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE What about pull quotes (which are not from another source)? 2009-11-24 2010-10-04
8370 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE When <fragment> is present but empty, hash should return the empty string. [sp] 2009-11-25 2010-10-04
8372 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Restore <spacer> parsing as void element 2009-11-25 2010-10-04
8373 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <form> in table and the form pointer 2009-11-25 2010-10-04
8374 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Pointless parse error when an act as if </select> causes a parse error in the fragment case 2009-11-25 2010-10-04
8375 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Mention that when in "in select in table", there is always a "select" element in table scope 2009-11-25 2011-04-20
8376 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Note about createElementNS is wrong since localName preserves case. [sp] 2009-11-25 2010-10-04
8379 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Remove Section 4.11.1 The Details Element 2009-11-25 2010-10-04
8380 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE mistake: 'onpagehide' attribute is listed twice, I guess that the second occurrence should be replaced by 'onpageshow' 2009-11-25 2010-10-04
8381 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED I greatly appreciate the addition of custom user attribute values, but take strong exception to the particular notation. 2009-11-26 2010-10-04
8386 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL For some time functions, it is needed to define a time slice like 22:30-24:00, which allows to calculate time differences; this is not possible with 22:30-0:00. Thus I recommend to extend to 0 <= hour <= 24. 2009-11-26 2010-10-04
8387 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The max value should be extended to 24:00 in order to allow time slices like 22:30-24:00 instead of 22:30-23:59 or 22:30-00:00. 2009-11-26 2010-10-04
8388 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED doesn't work context.getImageData didn't take ImageData if image loaded from http (something that) 2009-11-26 2010-10-04
8389 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make step 6 more explicit by saying it has to be treated as if there was a network error of some kind and not e.g. a 404. (by annevk) 2009-11-27 2010-10-04
8390 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT defaultPlaybackRate / playbackRate 2009-11-27 2010-10-04
8391 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE What is the meaning of having multiple <source> elements? Presumably a sequence in the case of audio and video... where do I find that info. Thx 2009-11-27 2010-10-04
8392 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE there's no need to "set the string being modified to output", it is already the empty string. 2009-11-28 2010-10-04
8393 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK I believe this should allow for lower case letters too... right now a tag can start with upper/lower but only have upper after the first character. Add lower to this state to fix. 2009-11-28 2010-10-04
8395 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK <ruby> OJ <rp>(<rt>Orange Juice<rp>)</ruby> is a wrong example compared to the prior part of the document and not legal html5 it should be <ruby> OJ <rp>(</rp><rt>Orange Juice</rt><rp>)</rp></ruby> 2009-11-28 2010-10-04
8397 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The normative text "...so that user agents can offer to add them to the user's calendar" should be moved to the next sentence which begins "For example". Adding events to a calendar is an *example* usage of the time element, not its raison d'etre. 2009-11-29 2010-10-04
8401 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Remove section 4.12 regarding idioms 2009-11-30 2011-02-22
8411 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT If a video@src is present, where is the @type info for that @src? 2009-12-01 2010-10-04
8412 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT To prevent sites from loading gigabytes of data, shouldn't the user agent explicitly mention the size of the files in the manifest. (This would also require a check during the downloading process, as to whether the provided sizes are real) 2009-12-01 2010-10-04
8413 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Please ensure "valid date string" supports non yyyy-mm-dd formats (UK = ddmmyyyy for example) 2009-12-01 2010-10-04
8414 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Shouldn't the example pattern be "^[0-9][A-Z]{3}$"? The current example would succeed with any string containing a part number, and not just a string that is one. 2009-12-02 2010-10-04
8415 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Nested browsing contexts don't get unloaded currently. I'm guessing that unloading a document should do it for the nested ones too? 2009-12-02 2010-10-04
8416 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The "Fragment identifier loop" part of the "update the session history with the new page" algorithm should spin the event loop instead of just hanging the browser... Also, the last step in that algorithm should jump back to the frag id loop step, not the 2009-12-02 2010-10-04
8417 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "user agents must yield to whatever script invoked the navigation steps" should also allow tasks to continue, with the rest of the algorithm being async, so that the event loop doesn't block waiting for data. 2009-12-02 2010-10-04
8418 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Consider coining the term "entry script" instead of the confusing "first script". 2009-12-02 2010-10-04
8419 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Maybe use a different attribute value than "be evil" 2009-12-02 2010-10-04
8423 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Shouldn't the datalist element be allowed to contain optgroup elements as well as option elements? 2009-12-02 2010-10-04
8425 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Cloning a DOMString with unpaired surrogates should throw SYNTAX_ERR, to allow UAs to serialise structured clones as UTF-8. 2009-12-03 2010-10-04
8426 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Description says "five minutes" example equates to "ten minutes" 2009-12-03 2010-10-04
8430 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE 3.5.4 Minor typo 'thee' instead of 'the'. 2009-12-03 2010-10-04
8435 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE should figure out where in HTML5 to say that WebSocket and XHR connections get closed when the document is unloaded. 2009-12-04 2010-10-04
8436 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "granularity that is expected (and required) of the value, by limiting the allowed values" -- granularity requirments may often be different for validation versus usability/ui-control purposes. There should be a 'step' for possible GUI controls and an oth 2009-12-04 2010-10-04
8443 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA aadsafdsaf 2009-12-05 2010-10-08
8445 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE the picture from wf2 showing url autocomplete seems to have disappeared 2009-12-07 2010-10-04
8446 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE we should add an example here showing a webmail client providing autocomplete suggestions for <input multiple type=email list=contacts> while the UA adds its own suggestions from the platform's native contacts database. 2009-12-07 2010-10-04
8447 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Tighter definition on the aside element 2009-12-07 2010-10-04
8448 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL There's an extra word (marked with ***) in this sentence: "It indicates that ***the*** no referrer information is to be leaked when following the link." 2009-12-07 2010-10-22
8449 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Remove extraneous material from Table section 2009-12-07 2011-04-08
8451 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "The q element uses the HTMLQuoteElement interface." - say "Uses HTMLQuoteElement." instead, for consistency with "Uses HTMLElement." 2009-12-07 2010-10-04
8452 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK It would be really helpful if the current mouse position could be derived from the drag event. 2009-12-07 2010-10-04
8455 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "></samp>" lines in Zork example try to close an already-closed tag 2009-12-08 2010-10-04
8457 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "scripts and form controls in such sections still render execute and submit respectively" - s/render// [pt] 2009-12-08 2010-10-04
8459 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "For instance, a user agent might wait 500ms or 512 bytes, whichever came first." -- IMO this is a bad example, over a satellite link the typical RTT might be 600-1500ms. Or is the assumption that the counting starts after the first packet of data is rece 2009-12-08 2010-10-04
8461 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE valid MIME type vs parameters 2009-12-08 2010-10-04
8462 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "fetch the resulting absolute URL" 2009-12-08 2010-10-04
8463 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK typo in description of <object> 2009-12-08 2010-10-04
8465 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE style element in the example is missing scoped attribute 2009-12-09 2010-10-04
8466 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Possible spelling mistake in “Malinko's comics” example; Promblem -> Problem? (image src and alt text) 2009-12-09 2010-10-04
8468 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Shouldn't there be an option to allow the text field to be edited in select elements? 2009-12-09 2010-10-04
8469 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED which browser can use it 2009-12-09 2010-10-04
8470 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The "Running a script" section has "If either:" and 3 bullets; should be "If:". 2009-12-09 2010-10-04
8472 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Reference http://dev.w3.org/csswg/css-style-attr/ now that's in a useful state [ms] 2009-12-10 2010-10-04
8473 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Sentence about the effect of changing src/async/defer on <script> is wrong 2009-12-10 2010-10-04
8475 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED command-apis 2009-12-11 2010-10-04
8478 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED section-server 2009-12-11 2010-10-04
8479 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE http content-type override mandatory for <object> 2009-12-11 2010-10-04
8484 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE the function in this definition list aren't hyperlinked like all other functions (makes parsing a bit more difficult) 2009-12-13 2010-10-04
8485 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Otherwise, if the col element has no span attribute, or if trying to parse the attribute's value resulted in an error, then let span be 1.": This should account (again) for span=0. [ms] 2009-12-13 2010-10-04
8486 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Define inheritance of lang, dir, style, and presatational attributes (HTML4 §11.3.2.1 "Inheritance of alignment specifications") [ms] 2009-12-13 2010-10-04
8489 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED before the page loaded, so maybe the head section.. 2009-12-14 2010-10-04
8490 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Shouldn't postMessage throw SYNTAX_ERR when targetOrigin is a relative URL (e.g. '/')? [sp] 2009-12-14 2010-10-04
8491 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Using "Window" for this interface is very unfortunate. That word is heavily overloaded and it is already "taken" by javascript. The API documentation here illustrates the issue: note the attribute 'window' of type WindowProxy. In all kinds of discussions 2009-12-14 2010-10-04
8492 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Re: example "<span itemscope><span itemprop="name">The Castle</span></span>" Is "<span itemscope itemprop="name">The Castle</span>" allowed. This wasn't clear to me. 2009-12-15 2010-10-04
8493 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED I think <hr> element should represent NOT ONLY a paragraph-level thematic break BUT ALSO a separator between flow contents, for backword compatibility. 2009-12-15 2010-10-04
8496 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Shouldn't a loop in structured clone throw INVALID_STATE_ERR instead? [sp] 2009-12-15 2010-10-04
8501 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT should make it clearer that fragment identifiers are not conforming if they don't match an id. 2009-12-15 2010-10-04
8506 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The value of a hidden-state input element as defined here does not have a concept of a defaultValue. 2009-12-16 2010-11-11
8509 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA ll for 2009-12-17 2010-10-08
8510 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA alert('x'); 2009-12-17 2010-10-04
8512 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED I'm confused by the wording on the SVG namespace, so in HTML5 the svg namespace will be used? 2009-12-17 2010-10-04
8513 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE AFAICT from WebIDL, ports can never be null, so step 3 is a no-op. If the sequence should be nullable, it has to be written with a question mark in the IDL, I think. [sp] 2009-12-17 2010-10-04
8514 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Shouldn't port1 and port2 be start()ed when the constructor in called? [sp] 2009-12-17 2010-10-04
8515 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Would be nice to clarify how this interacts with https. Many browsers do not cache https data to disk at all and it would be nice for https based applications to have some way to take advantage of disk based cache for non-sensitive data. 2009-12-17 2010-10-04
8516 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA hi there. this is a test comment. 2009-12-17 2010-10-08
8522 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Authoring Tool editing mechanisms 2009-12-18 2010-10-04
8523 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED WYSYWYG tools should gather semantic information 2009-12-18 2010-10-04
8524 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Guidance for Authoring Tool Markup Generators 2009-12-18 2010-10-04
8525 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Authoring Tools are exempt from using elements only for their specified purpose 2009-12-18 2010-10-04
8527 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Syntax for |:lang('xyzzy')| and |:lang('abcde')| is wrong, should be |:lang(xyzzy)| and |:lang(abcde)|. [ms] 2009-12-19 2010-10-04
8528 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "scripts are still prevented from creating popups", therefore shouldn't an "allow-popup" token also be included? 2009-12-20 2010-10-04
8530 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA fallback content 2009-12-21 2010-10-08
8531 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Add specification of atob and btoa 2009-12-21 2010-10-04
8532 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA ghfhfh 2009-12-21 2010-10-04
8533 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Throws a SYNTAX_ERR exception the arguments have invalid values (e.g., in the case of XML documents, if the given string is not well-formed)." Should read "Throws a SYNTAX_ERR exception IF the arguments have invalid values (e.g., in the case of XML docum 2009-12-22 2010-10-04
8535 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT For the sake of consistency, should the misspelling not be preserved, at least as an accepted varient? The keywords "noreferrer" and "noreferer" should be equivalent. 2009-12-22 2010-10-04
8538 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED What is the resolution of the attributes? Should the amount of seconds be expressed as an integer or a float, and in the latter case, with what precision? 2009-12-23 2010-10-04
8539 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Define nobr, wbr and their interfaces [ms] 2009-12-23 2010-10-04
8540 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Make sure to define the interfaces for all these elements (center, etc.) [ms] 2009-12-23 2010-10-04
8541 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA release date of HTML5 2009-12-24 2010-10-08
8542 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL release date of HTML5 2009-12-24 2010-10-04
8543 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED content.attr is not a function 2009-12-24 2010-10-04
8544 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Define HTMLAnchorElement.text [ms] 2009-12-24 2010-10-04
8545 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Remove "Window implements WindowModal; /* sometimes */" as it doesn't add anything and it contradicts the definition of "implements" in WebIDL [ms] 2009-12-24 2010-10-04
8546 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "...can only do so because they have the two Document object have the same origin.": s/they have the two Document object/the two Document objects/ [ms] 2009-12-24 2010-10-04
8547 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Would it make sense to make this an interface with [NoInterfaceObject]? [ms] 2009-12-24 2010-10-04
8548 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Move this section ("Namespaces") out of "9 The HTML syntax" and into "2 Common infrastructure", as it is relevant to other sections as well [ms] 2009-12-24 2010-10-04
8549 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Define bgsound, multicol. [ms] 2009-12-24 2010-10-04
8550 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Add document.createElement("<div>") (Gecko quirks, IE)? [ms] 2009-12-25 2010-10-04
8551 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The following Gecko-supported extensions to HTMLDocument aren't in the spec: [...] [ms] 2009-12-25 2010-10-04
8552 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Remove the Progress Element 2009-12-26 2011-01-24
8554 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <progress> element should be labelable with a label 2009-12-26 2011-03-06
8555 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Remove the Meter Element 2009-12-27 2010-12-08
8556 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "types with unknown parameters must be assumed to be unsupported" - <style type="text/css; charset=xxx"> should be assumed to be unsupported as well? 2009-12-27 2010-10-04
8557 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Where is the definition of "text-based" and "XML-based" languages? In my opinion it should be defined based on whehter type="" is an XML MIME type or not. 2009-12-27 2010-10-04
8558 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE a text node that is a descendant of |style| or |script| element should not be counted as well as |del| element descendants 2009-12-27 2010-10-04
8559 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL Add window.atob, window.btoa? [ms] 2009-12-27 2010-10-04
8560 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Define HTMLElement.style as ElementCSSInlineStyle.style (CSSOM)? [ms] 2009-12-27 2010-10-04
8561 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA testdd 2009-12-27 2010-10-04
8562 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA testdd 2009-12-27 2010-10-04
8565 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The word "trusted" does not appear in the DOM Level 3 Events specification 2009-12-28 2010-10-04
8566 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The 1st paragraph of this section doesn't match the parsing rules in the last paragraph. Also, the first para seems to refer to document type rather than element type. Change "element in the document" to "document element" maybe? 2009-12-28 2010-10-04
8567 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Maybe this should only apply for HTML documents. (Same for <style>.) [sp] 2009-12-29 2010-10-04
8569 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I just checked Firefox, Safari, Opera, Chrome and IE, and Firefox seems to be the only browser treating two subsequent HYPHEN-MINUS characters in a comment as a signature of comment end. I suggest to allow subsequent HYPHEN-MINUS characters in comments, a 2009-12-30 2010-10-04
8571 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA ikonca@wp.pl 2009-12-31 2010-10-04
8572 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA erkotop@wp.pl 2009-12-31 2010-10-04
8575 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The "JavaScript specification current at the time of this writing" is now ES5, not ES3 2009-12-31 2010-10-04
8576 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE ", meaning that by default styles apply to all media" This last part seems to be only appropriate if the imported resource would be a stylesheet, not a media file. It should be left out or replaced by something like: ", meaning that this resource is suita 2010-01-01 2010-10-04
8577 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA http://porn-z.org/ 2010-01-01 2010-10-04
8578 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Too many newlines in the IDL block (due to the v2CUERANGE comment) [ms] 2010-01-01 2010-10-04
8579 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Maybe this section should be together with the "Matching HTML elements using selectors" section 2010-01-02 2010-10-04
8580 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Broken link for body element test : http://ms2ger.freehostia.com/tests/html5/dom-tree-accessors/doc-body-set-01.html 2010-01-02 2010-10-04
8581 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Example lacks closing </dt> tag after the word 'Kissat' 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8582 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?topic=14429&uid=171807349209#/profile.php?id=100000469327089 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8583 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?topic=14429&uid=171807349209#/profile.php?id=100000469327089http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?topic=14429&uid=171807349209#/profile.php?id=100000469327089 2010-01-03 2018-07-04
8584 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?topic=14429&uid=171807349209#/profile.php?id=100000469327089http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?topic=14429&uid=171807349209#/profile.php?id=100000469327089http://www.facebook.com/groups/edit.php?members&gid=171807349209#/r 2010-01-03 2018-07-04
8585 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?topic=14429&uid=171807349209#/profile.php?id=100000469327089http://www.facebook.com/topic.php?topic=14429&uid=171807349209#/profile.php?id=100000469327089http://www.facebook.com/groups/edit.php?members&gid=171807349209#/r 2010-01-03 2018-07-04
8586 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT HTML5 Recommendation missing document metadata 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8587 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT HTML5 Recommendation document has Tidy warnings 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8588 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED state transition diagrams 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8589 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT invalid value default needs markup as definition 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8590 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT can empty string be a valid keyword? 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8591 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT list document.html under DOM tree accessors? 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8592 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE and/or phrasing in Semantics paragraph 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8593 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED extraneous <hr> elements in lang paragraph 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8594 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED further description of dir attribute for SVG and MathML? 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8595 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED svg and math elements listed under Interactive content? 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8596 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT terminology name collision: "Transparent" content models 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8598 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED API return values listed as upper case, should be lowercase? 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8599 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE editorial: singular to plural 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8600 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT include header and footer when printing 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8601 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL include footer when printing 2010-01-03 2010-10-22
8602 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT hr means horizontal rule 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8603 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE blockquote element needs example 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8604 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE missing </li> 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8605 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE clarify single or double quotes 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8606 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED ambiguous ampersand does not include character references 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8607 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE CDATA sections: example needed 2010-01-03 2010-10-04
8608 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT W3C Validator errors reported on HTML5 spec 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8617 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Purpose of the icon attribute 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8619 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Problematic for assistive technologies 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8620 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT No concept of interoperability beyond the site 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8621 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Orphan nodes in content models 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8622 HTML WG pre-LC1 joshue.oconnor VERI NEED Activation behaviour and pre-click activation 2010-01-04 2010-10-05
8623 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Graceful degradation when using the style element 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8627 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Will protocols (e.g., RTP/RTSP) for streaming to remote clients also be part of the spec? TCP-based HTTP isn't ideal for real-time video conferencing. 2010-01-04 2010-10-22
8628 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The term "boolean attribute" gives readers wrong ideas 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8629 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE history.pushState should clear forward history 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8630 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE 6.5.6.1 If I'm reading the paragraph that begins "All event handlers on an element, whether set to null.." correctly, it means that event handling code registered with an IDL or content attribute always runs before any code registered with addEventListene 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8631 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE As I read this section and 'The "in body" insertion mode', you're requiring the first line feed of a plain text file to be stripped. I assume that isn't intentional. [ms] 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8632 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: last line of 6.5.6.3 says "do nothing where where" 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8633 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In step 3 of the setTimeout() algorithm, either delete "either" or add an "or" clause to it. Also, in step 5, the context variable is undefined (unless the definition from the "get the timed task" subroutine applies here). 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8634 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: "was the most recently became" 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8636 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE step 4 in both algoritms refers to "the previous step". I don't think releasing the mutex triggers events, so I think it should reference step 2 in the first case and maybe steps 1&2 in the second? 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8637 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE You mean HTMLDocument, not DocumentHTML, right? DocumentHTML appears twice in this section. 2010-01-04 2010-10-04
8638 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: "is represents" right below the box of IDL 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8639 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED queryCommandIndeterm() always returns false for all commands defined by the spec. So either remove the method or add a note explaining its purpose so that vendor extensions can use it in the way intended. 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8641 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE use type="image/vnd.microsoft.icon" for windows.ico 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8642 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA iframe use to 3 2010-01-05 2010-10-08
8643 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Headings out of sequence 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8645 HTML WG pre-LC1 jbrewer RESO NEED Alt text for images 2010-01-05 2012-01-11
8646 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Private communication exception 2010-01-05 2011-04-25
8647 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Define tab order for IFrame 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8648 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Title attribute on the IFrame element 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8649 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Resize IFrame 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8650 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Is there any need to add additional information about the video file (bitrate, for example) that would help the UA determine if it can play the file? 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8652 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK what to display when images are not available is not well specified 2010-01-05 2010-10-04
8656 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Allow user to select fallback content for the object element 2010-01-06 2010-10-04
8657 HTML WG pre-LC1 jfoliot CLOS NEED Allow UA to reload fallback content if it fails to load 2010-01-06 2014-03-08
8658 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Availability of captions or additional audio tracks 2010-01-06 2011-03-08
8660 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Context for areas on an image map 2010-01-06 2010-10-04
8661 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Contradiction of dimension attributes 2010-01-06 2010-10-04
8664 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Media error code typo 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8665 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Spec currently says "Here is an of a range control" - seems like it should say "Here is an example of a range control" 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8666 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Keyboard accessible date pickers 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8667 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Ability to style validation errors 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8668 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Clarify default behavior for the details element 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8669 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Ability to wrap a command around a larger group of elements 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8670 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Parent for radiobuttons with same radiogroup 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8671 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Requiring the label attribute 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8672 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Synthetic clicks same as real clicks 2010-01-07 2014-05-20
8674 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Add popup as a value for the type attribute for menu element 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8675 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE visibility:hidden and visibility:collapse should probably also mean it's not "being rendered" [sp] 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8676 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT can the placeholder text be styled via css? for example, if I believe the shade of gray is too light, can I make it darker easily? 2010-01-07 2010-10-04
8679 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Menu example contains a violation of WCAG 2.0 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8680 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Meaningful label in menu example 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8681 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Separator menu items 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8682 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Tab and reading order for context menus 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8683 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT UA context menu when author context menu shown 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8684 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Ensuring user can always access UA's default context menus 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8685 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "JavaScript libraries may use the custom data attributes,": fix xref [ms] 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8686 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Space ship example: s/<code class="attr-class">class</code>/<code title="attr-class">class</code>/ [ms] 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8687 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK "[HTML5CORE] … December 2010." doesn't sound right. [ms] 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8688 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Second example uses ALLCAPS for elements 2010-01-08 2010-10-04
8689 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Consider moving the Links subsection into the Elements section, since the Elements subsection these days has lots of processing model subsections. 2010-01-09 2010-10-04
8690 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE move WindowProxy under the Window section rather than making it a peer, since it's just an implementation detail. 2010-01-09 2010-10-04
8691 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Consider moving Timers, User prompts, System state and capabilities, and Offline Web applications into a "Web application APIs" section, and renaming the remaining material from that section to "Core" or some such, to split up that section and make it mor 2010-01-09 2010-10-04
8692 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE |datagrid| is not commented out in Special set 2010-01-09 2010-10-04
8693 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA is <output> a valid html element? 2010-01-09 2010-10-04
8695 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Spec currently says " because the order is not particular important" - should say " because the order is not particularly important" or " because the order is not of particular importance" 2010-01-10 2010-10-04
8696 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "close tag" -> "end tag" for consistency 2010-01-10 2010-10-04
8698 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE add conformance criteria info to header/banner 2010-01-10 2010-10-04
8699 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE the second note is not always true: script.innerHTML = '<!--' does raise a parse error if the "script data" state is used but does not if the PLAINTEXT state is used 2010-01-10 2010-10-04
8700 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE modify contentinfo mapping and conformance 2010-01-10 2010-10-04
8701 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE modify main role conformance info 2010-01-10 2010-10-04
8702 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "Within a single dl element, there should not be more than one dt element for each name" - intention of this requirement is unclear; is this a machine-checkable requirement, or a requirement on semantics? What will be used to compare "name"s, textContent 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8703 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE please disallow charset parameter in type="" (it is disallowed in script's type="") 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8704 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE please disallow attributes for form submission unless the |type| attribute is in the Submit Button state 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8705 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The request must include a Referer (sic) HTTP header [sic]" [sic] [ms] 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8709 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "If the current outlinee is null." ends in a full-stop, the rest of the list does not. 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8710 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT option . text: c/p'd too much; also add a line in the IDL [ms] 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8711 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Conversion of blockquote and q elements to RDF (sec 5.5.2, step 4) states that the subject should be the document address, but it should be an identifier for the quote. 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8712 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA dosn't understund this timer 2010-01-11 2010-10-08
8715 HTML WG pre-LC1 joshue.oconnor VERI NEED Scrolling elements into view 2010-01-11 2010-10-05
8716 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Replace img Guidance for Conformance Checkers with Suggested Text for Short Text Alternatives 2010-01-11 2013-02-14
8717 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Usability and Element-level-focus-apis 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8718 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Typo in "and thus typically encodings" should say "and thus typical encodings" 2010-01-11 2010-10-04
8719 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL "Referer (sic) HTTP header [sic]" s/[sic]// 2010-01-12 2010-10-04
8720 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE define rendering for wbr [sp] 2010-01-12 2010-10-04
8721 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Getting an error that the local database can't be found..And how is the privacy being handled? And should i be worried about security leaks? 2010-01-12 2010-10-04
8725 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT text/sandboxed-html vs <iframe sandbox> and backcompat 2010-01-12 2010-10-04
8726 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE the <figure/> element should be under 4.5 Grouping content and not here (4.8 Embedded content) 2010-01-12 2010-10-04
8727 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT registration procedure for meta/@name values 2010-01-12 2010-10-04
8728 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/<code title="attr-font-style">style</code>/<code title="attr-style">style</code>/ [ms] 2010-01-12 2010-10-04
8729 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK dataTransfer for dragenter and dragover can't really be Empty if the drop target is to actually determine whether it can accept the drag. In an ideal world, files would exist but only make the mime type of the file available. 2010-01-12 2010-10-04
8730 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Buffering should not be a boolean "autobuffer" tag - but something along the lines of "buffermax= n%" There should also be a "no-cache" attribute - this will overcome expected objections from copyright holders 2010-01-13 2010-10-04
8731 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Consider expanding buffering control for media elements 2010-01-13 2010-10-04
8733 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Add examples: <video src onerror>; <video><source ...><source ...><source ... onerror> (see http://lists.whatwg.org/pipermail/help-whatwg.org/2010-January/000391.html) [sp] 2010-01-13 2010-10-04
8734 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA hello 2010-01-13 2010-10-04
8736 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK Decision to playback for media should be left to the user agent 2010-01-14 2011-03-08
8737 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Allowing option with no value to be a command 2010-01-14 2010-10-09
8738 HTML WG pre-LC1 cyns RESO INVA Role-based navigation 2010-01-14 2013-01-21
8739 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Link element with active pseudo-class 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8740 HTML WG pre-LC1 joshue.oconnor VERI NEED How do pseudo-class selectors interact with WAI-ARIA? 2010-01-14 2010-10-05
8741 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Isn't pre-order the same as depth-first? That would make "pre-order, depth-first" redundant. 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8742 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED User informed when URI can#t be resolved 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8743 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT Auditory icons clashing with AT 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8745 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Deprecation of the use of TABLE for Layout 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8746 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Text separator between links in markup example 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8748 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Differentiating hyperlinks referring to the same tag in different scopes 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8749 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Conveying the hierarchy or relationship between the links to AT 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8750 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK User able to override the hidden attribute in incorrectly rendered pages 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8751 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WORK User should have ability to override automatic scrolling 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8752 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI NEED Allow user to manage focus changes 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8753 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS LATE Undo for drag and drop 2010-01-14 2013-01-16
8754 HTML WG pre-LC1 gez.lemon VERI WONT Overflow when text is resized 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8755 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Automatic reduction of text-size is unnecessary 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8756 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL The word "trusted" does not appear in the current editor's draft of the referenced DOM Events specification 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8757 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE This section shouldn't be marked as impl, it's mainly for authors. [ms] 2010-01-14 2010-10-04
8759 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA nice idea 2010-01-15 2010-10-09
8760 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED No codec is suggested for baseline for standardization. A codec that is able to be freely licensed (gratis and libre) for any purpose needs to be chosen at least as a "strong suggestion or recommendation." 2010-01-15 2010-10-04
8761 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL No codec is suggested for baseline for standardization. A codec that is able to be freely licensed (gratis and libre) for any purpose needs to be chosen at least as a "strong suggestion or recommendation." 2010-01-15 2010-10-04
8764 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The first instance of the term "needs a date" should be marked up with <dfn> so cross references work. 2010-01-15 2010-10-04
8767 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <svg><font>x</font>y</svg>z is not parsed as intended. the in body insertion mode processes </font> as HTML formatting element, not as a foreign element's tag. 2010-01-16 2010-10-04
8768 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The attribute value can be left unquoted if it doesn't > The attribute value can stay unquoted if it doesn't (in order to prevent thinking about unquoting left-side-part of the "=" character) 2010-01-16 2010-10-04
8769 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Can there be a link to the XML proper syntax-level requirements? This specification does not define any syntax-level requirements beyond those defined for XML proper. 2010-01-16 2010-10-04
8772 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "This doesn't apply to Document.setAttributeNS()and Document.setAttributeNodeNS()." Is that because there are no such methods on *Document*? [ms] 2010-01-17 2010-10-04
8773 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED there is should be public property array transformMatrix [] 2010-01-17 2010-10-04
8774 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Double newline after getItems [ms] 2010-01-17 2010-10-04
8776 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA REPLACE element.labels[0].textContent WITH element.textContent 2010-01-18 2010-10-04
8777 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA review the example code, doesnt work on fox3.5 2010-01-18 2010-10-04
8778 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK should convert this to actual rdf statements (using equivalentProperty, sameAs, etc) 2010-01-18 2010-10-04
8781 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT 'being closed' -> 'was closed' 2010-01-19 2010-10-04
8782 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK reinvestigate what parts of session history should be sync and what parts should be async 2010-01-19 2010-10-04
8784 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT politics in <param> example 2010-01-19 2010-10-04
8786 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Fix meee... fix meee! All my tags are messed up. 2010-01-19 2010-10-04
8787 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA how to handle session in html 2010-01-20 2010-10-09
8788 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Should the compact IDL attribute on (ul|ol|dl|dir|menu) be boolean as in DOM2HTML? [ms] 2010-01-20 2010-10-04
8789 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED What characters can be used in a name? 2010-01-20 2010-10-04
8790 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA tesssst 2010-01-21 2010-10-04
8792 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE getElementsByName and getElementsByClassName allow returning the same NodeList repeatedly 2010-01-21 2010-10-04
8793 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE registration procedure for@rel values 2010-01-21 2011-04-13
8796 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK So is an attribute with no value valid? Like <input type="file" multiple /> ? Because writing multiple="" isn't really logical, nor is multiple="multiple". multiple="true" would be logical. This irks me... 2010-01-21 2010-10-04
8797 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL <a type="..."> should influence Accept header sent by browsers 2010-01-22 2010-10-22
8798 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE It seems Opera and Firefox now have coordinate (0,0) at the content edge instead of the border edge (and allow negative coordinates if clicking on the border). Consider revising this requirement to match Opera and Firefox. (Haven't tested IE.) [sp] 2010-01-22 2010-10-04
8800 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Cut/copy/paste should use dedicated events instead of overloading drag and drop 2010-01-23 2011-05-09
8802 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The drawImage function should be able to handle animated pictures by adding an additional parameter 'restart'. If restart is set to true, then the first frame is loaded - otherwise, it moves one frame forward from the last time drawImage was called on the 2010-01-23 2010-10-04
8803 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE scope=rowgroup or scope=colgroup header cells should not be added to /header list/ if the header cell is the /principal cell/ itself (substeps 5. and 6.) 2010-01-24 2010-10-04
8806 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE iframe srcdoc examples 2010-01-24 2010-10-14
8807 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE If the "body" attribute no longer exists, "body" should be removed from the list of IDL attributes that reflect their respective content attributes of the same name 2010-01-25 2010-10-04
8808 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE extraneous colon in author view 2010-01-25 2010-10-04
8809 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL attributterne 2010-01-25 2010-10-22
8811 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT itemtype should be http://microformats.org/profile/hcard#vcard 2010-01-25 2010-10-04
8812 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL attributter 2010-01-25 2010-10-22
8813 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "mime type of plugin" 2010-01-25 2010-10-04
8816 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Need to define that setting HTMLOptionsCollection.length fires mutation events accordingly. 2010-01-25 2010-10-04
8817 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA attribute 2010-01-26 2010-10-09
8818 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Remove the srcdoc attribute 2010-01-26 2010-10-04
8819 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA GREASE MONKEY NO WORK WITH SCRIPTS 2010-01-26 2010-10-09
8820 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK use <http://purl.org/dc/terms/title> instead of <http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/title> 2010-01-26 2010-10-04
8821 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE discarding a doc that hasn't gone through the unload steps should run the steps that clear timeouts, databases, etc 2010-01-26 2010-10-04
8822 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE should make cookie setting dependent on whether the document has a URL, not on whether it has a browsing context; and should fail silently (set does nothing, get returns "") when there isn't one. 2010-01-26 2010-10-04
8823 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA properties 2010-01-27 2010-10-09
8824 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL properties 2010-01-27 2010-10-22
8825 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "begin to use the bytes provided for the document as the input stream for that parser" is way too vague -- it should relate to the parsing tasks mentioned in the event loop section ("one per byte" etc) 2010-01-27 2010-10-04
8826 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED about:blank should use standards mode 2010-01-27 2010-10-04
8828 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE definition of "plugin" 2010-01-27 2010-10-04
8830 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE cut-n-paste error: in the "agent" paragraph you can read: "Any number of properties with the name _logo_ may...." -- Gianmarco Armellin 2010-01-27 2010-10-04
8831 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA section text box 2010-01-27 2010-10-09
8833 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Please allow the title of the spec currently known as "HTML5" to be changed to an accurate title. 2010-01-28 2010-10-04
8834 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Please remove the subtitle from the spec known as "HTML5" 2010-01-28 2010-10-04
8836 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The Selectors specification, in conjunction with CSS, can be used to style text selections using the ::selection pseudo-element.": Not anymore. [ms] 2010-01-28 2010-10-04
8837 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Initial about:blank should fire DOMFrameContentLoaded and load events when not navigated immediately 2010-01-29 2010-10-04
8839 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA dsfsdfsd 2010-01-29 2010-10-09
8840 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL dsfsdfsd 2010-01-29 2010-10-22
8841 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Section 2.7.8 Exceptions: The DOMException codes with code number >= 18 do not appear in the referenced document [DOMCORE]. So it should be noted that these codes were introduced by HTML5 2010-01-29 2010-10-04
8842 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE id="dome" should be id="home" 2010-01-29 2010-10-04
8843 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Is <pre> element a phrasing content? An example of <figure> element shows a <pre> element in <figure> element. 2010-01-30 2010-10-04
8844 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Since this section is shared with the XML parser should this be its own generic section rather than a subsection of the HTML parser? [avk] 2010-01-30 2010-10-04
8845 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Reference for (US-)ASCII 2010-01-30 2010-10-04
8846 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Wording 2010-01-30 2010-10-09
8847 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE srcdoc should be listed after src, not autoplay; in attributes overview table 2010-01-30 2010-10-04
8848 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL there is no dom-iframe-body; remove this IDL attribute 2010-01-30 2010-10-22
8849 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT The ability for an author to completely disable javascript on their webpage - an html scripts="no" attribute 2010-01-31 2010-10-04
8850 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT “himself” assumes all authors are male, which is incorrect (and misogynistic). “themself” is correct. 2010-01-31 2010-10-04
8851 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "vevent" example: "dtend" value and accompanying text inconsistent? (20 vs 19) 2010-01-31 2010-10-04
8853 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA sessionStorage 2010-02-01 2010-10-09
8854 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA opendatabase 2010-02-01 2010-10-09
8855 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE tel URI reference 2010-02-01 2010-10-04
8856 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE url parameter in register*Handler 2010-02-01 2010-10-04
8857 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE references to openDatabase and localStorage 2010-02-01 2010-10-04
8864 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT If there are two <param>s with the same name, the last one should be used, apparently. [sp] 2010-02-02 2010-10-04
8865 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The order of the attributes need to be the same as the source order when passing as parameters to the plugin, apparently. [sp] 2010-02-02 2010-10-04
8866 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE definition of "same-origin policy" 2010-02-02 2010-10-04
8868 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE content model should say "if the span attribute is specified: empty. otherwise: zero or more col elements." [sp] 2010-02-03 2010-10-04
8869 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Fetch algorithm should specify that no Referer is sent when the origin is a unique identifier 2010-02-03 2010-10-04
8870 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Firefox 3.5.7 was non responsive on a 15' Macbook Pro running OSX 10.5.8 after visiting this page 2010-02-03 2010-10-04
8872 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE split out and modify parts of Section 4.8.2.1 the img element 2010-02-03 2016-02-23
8878 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Otherwise, the user agent must must split the attribute's value on spaces, and let keys be the resulting tokens." - Double "must" at the second point. 2010-02-04 2010-10-04
8880 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA line feed 2010-02-04 2010-10-09
8883 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA insert number 2010-02-05 2010-10-09
8888 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT maybe this should have id="loading-web-pages" instead of id="browsers" 2010-02-06 2010-10-04
8889 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Web application APIs link points to Loading Web pages 2010-02-06 2010-10-04
8897 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED note: W3C markup validation tool (for HTML5 and not HTML 4.01) gives two errors in the case of height = width = 0 2010-02-07 2010-10-04
8898 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE please make title element optional if higher-level protocol provides similar information (e.g. as email Subject: header field) 2010-02-07 2011-06-03
8899 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED it should define how to parse or compare mime types because http spec does not define it but html UAs have to know how to treat invalid input such as type="text/css; incomplete-parameter" 2010-02-07 2010-10-04
8902 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Sentence 2 "When ..." is unclear to me.For instance, what does 'that' refer to? 2010-02-08 2010-10-04
8903 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Algorithm given is missing a final check to reject strings with trailing non-digits, like "123A", which the initial definition appears to exclude. 2010-02-08 2010-10-04
8904 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE synchronous version of fetch algorithm 2010-02-09 2010-10-04
8905 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA will we be able to stream data from a device through a socket? 2010-02-09 2010-10-09
8906 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE terminology "URL" 2010-02-09 2010-10-04
8910 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "If the user has requested the user of particular focus rings" -- should probably be "requested the use"? 2010-02-09 2010-10-04
8911 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL "Pause until" if implemented literally would lock the browser up since fetch tasks can't be processed while paused. 2010-02-09 2010-10-22
8912 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Why can't defer be used on inline scripts? If the script execution is slow (which can include loading of preceeding style sheets), the browser will have to wait until it can continue parsing and start downloading subsequent external resources. 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8914 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Are there cases other than the fragment id where the current address can change during the lifetime of a Document 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8915 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "the active document of the script's browsing context" -- is there more author-friendly terminology we can use here (in addition to the existing) 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8916 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "effective script origin" links to "Relaxing the same-origin restriction" but the term is not used. At the very least, the linked-to section should say that .domain sets the "effective script origin" -- perhaps a reference to the same origin policy here w 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8917 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED This could use an introduction. What does "resource metadata management" mean? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8918 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Are there other cases than coming from no referrer (just typing into the UA) and the noreferrer link that will result in a blank document.referrer? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8919 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Should be clearer that the setter actually appends, and not replaces 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8920 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "sandboxed into a unique origin" means in an iframe with the seamless attribute? Are there other cases? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8921 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Is there a way to get the time zone of the server? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8922 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Returns what might be the user agent's default character encoding" -- when might it not be? What are the caveats here? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8923 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The "document's character encoding" link does not go anywhere. 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8924 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Custom attribute names in dataset 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8926 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE How does an author *get* an object implementing DOMHTMLImplementation? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8927 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Instead of a list of on* elements, perhaps have a general-purpose event table we can use over and over? And then describe the actual events here? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8928 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED A listing of which events were fired on which elements, and at what times, would be extremely useful. For instance, the table in http://www.whatwg.org/specs/web-apps/current-work/multipage/section-index.html#events-0 claims that the volumechange event is 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8929 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In the assistive technology section, explicitly mention role and aria-* (as we do a few lines above for "custom data attributes") 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8930 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In HTML, an element's "home subtree" is the set of descendants from the HTML node. Perhaps say that? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8931 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The description for getting the lang from an ancestor is different from the description for getting the title, even though it appears they would behave identically. 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8932 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "The attribute has no defaults" is inconsistent with "otherwise, the element's directionality is the same as its parent element, or 'ltr' if there is no parent element" 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8933 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Add a forms intro section that walks the user through creating a form, and discusses what would be submitted, and how to do client-side form validation. 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8934 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The Atom specification example could be rewritten as: "For example, the Atom specification defines a content element. When its type element has the value xhtml, the specification requires that it contain a single HTML div element. Thus ..." 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8935 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL The Atom specification example could be rewritten as: "For example, the Atom specification defines a content element. When its type element has the value xhtml, the specification requires that it contain a single HTML div element. Thus ..." 2010-02-10 2010-10-22
8937 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT setAttribute should specify the parameters (at least how many, but probably also a short description of each) 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8938 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE We should explicitly say that using document.write after a document has been fully parsed results in the document being replaced. It's currently implicit in "calls the open() method implicitly first" but it would be nice to be clearer 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8939 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL so nice 2010-02-10 2010-10-22
8940 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA so nice 2010-02-10 2010-10-09
8941 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "Wherever a subdocument fragment is allowed in a compound document" -- what cases are these exactly? 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8942 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Only the newest application cache in an application cache group can have its completeness flag set to incomplete, the others are always all complete." s/,/;/ (thanks DanC) 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8943 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Each browsing context, including nested browsing context, has a distinct session history." is missing an "s" in the middle clause. (Thanks DanC.) 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8944 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL "Where metadata content is expected" -- Where is that defined? 2010-02-10 2010-10-22
8945 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Missing <del> in the interfaces index (Thanks Mike) 2010-02-10 2010-10-04
8948 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE text/richtext is obsolete; it is inappropriate as an example 2010-02-11 2010-10-04
8949 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA The exact behavior for links to external resources depends on the exact relationship, as defined for the relevant link type. Some of the attributes control whether or not the external resource is to be applied (as defined below). For external resources th 2010-02-11 2010-10-09
8950 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Apparently the codebase attribute on object should not be passed to the plugin. (This does not apply to embed or applet.) [sp] 2010-02-11 2010-10-04
8951 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "When the labeled control is not being rendered, then the label element's activation behavior must be to do nothing." - doesn't match opera/webkit/firefox: http://software.hixie.ch/utilities/js/live-dom-viewer/saved/371 . (Regarding focus management, visi 2010-02-11 2010-10-04
8953 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK URL decomp. IDL attributes when parsing fails 2010-02-11 2010-10-04
8954 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA browser support 2010-02-12 2010-10-09
8955 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "were the only form with a validity constraint problem" should be the only form _control_. 2010-02-12 2010-10-04
8957 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK comments about HTTP requirements on redirects 2010-02-12 2010-10-04
8958 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The constraint on "low" and "high" should be expressed as the others: "low &#8804; high (if low and high are both specified)" 2010-02-12 2010-10-04
8959 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Shouldn't the headers in the second example's comments be footers? "A footer typically contains information about its section such as who wrote it" makes it confusing. 2010-02-12 2010-10-04
8961 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK HTMLImageElement does not inherit from HTMLMediaElement? 2010-02-12 2010-10-04
8963 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA img url 2010-02-12 2010-10-09
8964 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT is INDEX_SIZE_ERR fired if value is less than zero also? 2010-02-12 2010-10-04
8966 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Consider "<svg><desc><div><svg><desc><b>X" — Should we change "Pop elements from the stack of open elements until the current node is in the HTML namespace." in the in-foreign-content mode to actually be "Pop elements until there's no element in scope t 2010-02-13 2010-10-04
8967 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Why is the optional argument in the middle? Isn't it more convenient when copy/pasting code to make optional modifications at either end without having to precisely place the cursor somewhere in the middle? Particularly for piecing together arguments, too 2010-02-13 2010-10-04
8968 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: "comparedi" should, I presume, be "compared". 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
8969 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "If the entry in the list of active timeouts that was added in the earlier step has been cleared, then abort this algorithm" should be done in the task that is queued, not before the task is queued. Same for setInterval(). 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
8970 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Should "Empty the Document's Window's list of active timeouts and its list of active intervals." actually happen if the document is to be salvaged? 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
8971 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Keygen example <form> has type in enctype - should be "multipart/form-data", not "multipart/formdata". 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
8972 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Would a <figcaption> that is the last element of a <figure> be a candidate for this list? The validator doesn't think so, but I it would be convenient. 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
8973 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make sure "script's browsing context" is not used to define an origin, since browsing contexts don't have origins. It has to be the script's browsing context's active document. 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
8974 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Check why the last sentence of "script's URL character encoding" is an xref error (same with the next <dd> too). 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
8975 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA trees are good 2010-02-14 2010-10-09
8999 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Change the .cookie API to be based on the actual Origin of the document (vs its URL) and not on the sandboxed origin flag, so that text/html-sandboxed is handled as well. (But beware that data: URLs still have to fail silent, not throw SECURITY_ERR.) 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
9000 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE datasrc, <script event>, <script for> and so on are missing 2010-02-14 2010-10-04
9001 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike RESO FIXE Consistent "Status" sections for Microdata and RDFa 2010-02-15 2010-10-04
9002 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT @sandbox should not allow content with text/html MIME type to force authors to change type to secure one. 2010-02-15 2010-10-04
9003 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Tag should be closed 2010-02-15 2010-10-09
9004 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Tag should be closed 2010-02-15 2010-10-22
9006 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA help on mnie gryzie 2010-02-15 2010-10-09
9013 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Empty attribute syntax" doesn't actually say that the value is the empty string. 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9014 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE should probably wait with instantiating a plugin until the end tag has been parsed, otherwise the <param>s might not have been parsed yet 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9015 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Opera now sends PARAM:"" to the plugin for compat with mozilla 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9016 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make parameters on applet use the same rules as object (except for codebase="") 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9017 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT The origin argument should be used to determine whether Referer is to be omitted for XMLHttpRequest. I'm not a 100% sure at the moment when that would matter, but it seems safer. 2010-02-16 2018-10-29
9018 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Should "origin" be marked up as "<i>origin</i>" just like the synchronous flag? 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9020 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "When a control has a pattern attribute,": xref pattern 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9021 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE perhaps mention here semantic alternatives to common use cases: <strike> → <del>, <tt> → <code>, &c. 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9022 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE spec author names 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9023 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Dependency on Document does not work for Web Workers. 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9024 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED fetch should be referenced from algorithms in Web workers. 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9025 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "the first five character removed" - should be "characters". [pt] 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9027 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE doubled "as possible" 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9028 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "(either because of a fatal error during load that's about to be reported, or because the load() method was invoked while the resource selection algorithm was already running, in which case it is fired synchronously during the load() method call)." - empt 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9029 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Steps 2 and 3 should be in the relevant specifications, rather than inline 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9030 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Add more dfns (more helpful list coming) 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9033 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In the green box, please clarify that event.state contains a clone of the object passed to pushState 2010-02-16 2010-10-04
9034 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Is there any "white-space avoiding rule"? If not, Some HTML Editor may insert evil-poorlooked white-space. 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9035 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Interfaces for URL manipulation: concept of "hierarchical" 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9036 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Can we explain what setAttribute and setAttributeNode actually do? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9037 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT can we explain what getAttribute and and getAttributeNode do? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9038 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL can we explain what getAttribute and and getAttributeNode do? 2010-02-17 2010-10-22
9039 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Can we explain what getElementsByTagName does (and specifically, that it returns a NodeList)? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9040 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "Wherever a subdocument fragment is allowed in a compound document" -- What's an example of this? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9041 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Is it worth mentioning that while there's no DOM API for the "manifest" attribute itself, there is an API for the cache manifest? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9042 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED In neither section 4.2.1 or 4.8.2 is the reason for leaving out the title in an iframe srcdoc clarified. Is this because it's inherited from the parent? Because it's irrelevant? What does document.title return in this case? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9043 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Must the href attribute of <base> be a full URL, including http://...; if so, what is the correct terminology for that? I tried following the "valid URL" link and it goes down a rabbit hole to http://www.w3.org/html/wg/href/draft, which does not define "v 2010-02-17 2011-05-10
9044 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The context of <base> is "In a head element containing no other base elements" -- there are additional restrictions specified below that are not reflected here 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9045 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK The term "valid URL" is used here, but following the link does not lead to a definition 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9046 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED What, if anything, are UAs allowed to do with the advisory "type" attribute of <link>? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9047 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Should UAs print a page in a <link media=print> if no stylesheet with media=print is provided? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9048 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "If either name, http-equiv, or itemprop is specified, then the content attribute must also be specified. Otherwise, it must be omitted." Might be more clearly stated as "If charset is specified, then the content attribute must be omitted. Otherwise it mu 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9049 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT What is the correct behavior if a <meta http-equiv="Content-Type"> conflicts with <meta charset>? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9051 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE feed autodiscovery for main feed on posts 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9052 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL All DOCTYPE variants that trigger standards mode pre-HTML5 should continue to trigger standards mode in HTML5 2010-02-17 2010-10-22
9053 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Should the "name=size" attributes in the "Pizza Size" radio buttons also be included in the <strong> markup which immediately follows them? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9054 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL There is no direct replacement for a frameset. This supports some functionality and features that can't be emulated 100% by other methods. 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9055 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT There is no direct replacement for a frameset. This supports some functionality and features that can't be emulated 100% by other methods. Server side includes cannot dynamically udpate pages, nor can new pages be loaded with javascript. This is a crit 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9057 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE status section, ref to "HTML specifications" 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9058 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED there is not CURIE or PREFIX? 2010-02-17 2010-10-04
9059 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED can I use wildcards to cache the whole directory? 2010-02-18 2010-10-04
9060 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Add "in" into: "the user agent must act as if the element was" ...in... "a stack of open elements." 2010-02-18 2010-10-04
9066 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT You state "many users disable scripting"... the most reliable stats I can find indicate that at most 1-2% of users have JS diabled. So using "many" is rather misleading. 2010-02-18 2010-10-04
9068 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Windows-31J preferred name is with the "W" uppercase, not as given in the overrides where it is lowercase. (w00t! consistency!) 2010-02-18 2010-10-04
9071 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Handling of "[" in between-doctype-public-and-system-identifiers-state may not be ideal 2010-02-18 2010-10-04
9072 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT There's inconsistent quoting of attributes between the highlighted and non-highlited parts of this section 2010-02-18 2010-10-04
9073 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK "Configuring o form"? [pt] 2010-02-18 2010-10-04
9074 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Ogg Theora and Vorbis should be set as standard. 2010-02-18 2010-10-04
9082 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Step 20. "the table" seems to be repeated unnecessarily 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9083 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE This should mention that it includes framing overhead. 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9084 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Opera's implementation of this treats the comma as a delimiter (i.e. if you select Abyssinian from the drop-down and type a ',' after that, it gives you the drop-down again to select another item). I like this feature but want to make sure it is interopab 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9085 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "If the playback has ended, seek to the earliest possible position of the media resource." - should also check if direction is forwards, since if direction is backwards we're already at the earliest position 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9086 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL "If the playback has ended, seek to the earliest possible position of the media resource." - should also check if direction is forwards, since if direction is backwards we're already at the earliest position 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9088 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA test test test test 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9091 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA <span itemprop="fn">David Junger</span> 2010-02-19 2010-10-09
9092 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA </br><frameset>text would generate a frameset per spec, since the frameset-ok flag should be ok after </br> is seen. But an IE8 test shows otherwise 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9093 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT </p>text would ignore </p>, but it does not on IE8. 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9094 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It should be stylable (thru CSS markup) 2010-02-19 2010-10-04
9096 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Mapping U+0000 to U+FFFD regresses rendering of pages 2010-02-20 2010-10-04
9099 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT suggestion; use list for <br> non-conforming example form alternative 2010-02-20 2010-10-04
9101 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE How noHref "reflect"s nohref is not well defined; nohref is not explicitly mentioned as a "boolean attribute" 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9102 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE this CSS style sheet does not work because "type" attribute values are compared case-insensitively according to the "Matching HTML elements using selectors" section 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9103 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE 'padding-left' here should be marked as LTR-specific 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9104 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE there were <link urn=""> and <link methods="">, too. [RFC1866] 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9105 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED t.target instanceof HTMLLIElement) { // use the element's data-value="" attribute as the value to be moving: event.dataTransfer.setData(internalDNDType, event.target.dataset.value); event.effectAllowed = 'move'; // only allow moves } 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9106 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Description of the commandType attribute talks about a value of "checked". Should be "checkbox". 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9108 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT not necessary 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9109 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA its fucke 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9110 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK http://whatwg.org/html5 link failed to load 2010-02-21 2010-10-04
9112 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT item/namedItem should return HTMLElement or Element 2010-02-22 2010-10-04
9113 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE re: "axis on td and th elements" text could say "Use the scope attribute on the relevant th" 2010-02-22 2011-12-20
9115 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA What's this bar? 2010-02-22 2010-10-09
9116 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Will we be to manipulate the address via JavaScript without the # to get true deeplinking? 2010-02-22 2010-10-04
9117 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Throws an INDEX_SIZE_ERR exception if the offset it out of range" - s/it/is/ [pt] 2010-02-22 2010-10-04
9118 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "If either of the radii are negative throws an INDEX_SIZE_ERR exception." - s/throws/, throws/ [pt] 2010-02-22 2010-10-04
9119 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Gradients must be painted only where ..." - this sentence applies to all gradients (not just radial), so it should be placed after the following sentence ("The points in the radial gradient ..."), so that all the radial-specific sentences are kept togthe 2010-02-22 2010-10-04
9120 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The allowed values for repeat are repeat" - should be "allowed values for <var>repetition</var>" [pt] 2010-02-22 2010-10-04
9121 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Returns the one-dimensional array containing the data." - should say "in RGBA order, as integers in the range 0 .. 255", so that it's giving the information authors need to know. [pt] 2010-02-22 2010-10-04
9122 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Obsolete but Conforming 2010-02-22 2010-10-04
9124 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE missing formatBlock candidates 2010-02-23 2010-10-04
9125 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL missing formatBlock candidates 2010-02-23 2010-10-22
9126 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Please make the bug filing dialog ignoreable (e.g. make it a single-line box above or instead of the comment box). Consider moving focus so that pressing enter in an attempt to close the dialog doesn't file a dup bug. 2010-02-23 2010-10-04
9127 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK As others have pointed out: why have so many willfull violations to support legacy content if there is *no legacy HTML5 content to support?* 2010-02-23 2010-10-04
9128 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA It seems a bad idea to willfully violate the character model specification for a new standard. New HTML documents should have the correct encoding and should not need to be mis-interpreted. Why not specify mandatory UTF-8 anyway? 2010-02-23 2010-10-04
9129 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The terms used from the DOM specification need some <code> love. 2010-02-23 2010-10-04
9131 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED please elaborate on "If there is no relevant pointing device" - how can you get the mouse position on the drag or dragend events? 2010-02-23 2010-10-04
9134 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL I'm strongly opposed to having "willful violations" of the specs, and of mandating the use of platform-specific Windows encodings in preference to standardised ISO ones, on the grounds of supporting "legacy" content; isn't this supposed to be a new spec f 2010-02-24 2010-10-22
9138 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Resolving Web addresses" 2010-02-24 2010-10-04
9141 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT 10.2.2.2: overriding explicitly declared encodings is a bad idea maybe make this only for when both HTTP and HTML didn't specify the encoding 2010-02-24 2010-10-04
9143 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The b element lacks encouragement to use classes (cf i element) 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9144 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE &#13; should expand to CR 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9145 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE steps 1 to 3 could be merged into "A string that is an ASCII case-insensitive match for the string "<!DOCTYPE"" 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9146 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA is this useful? 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9148 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "either does not expect the user to need the media resource, but that" -- "either ... but" is wrong, this needs to be reworded. 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9149 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Don't require set-cookie2; see <https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=472529#c129> 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9151 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The first item in the list seems truncated or not in item list form. It ends "and," 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9152 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The list of elements doesn't include elements like input, select (and probably others) that are includes in MSIE. 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9153 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The element list isn't in alphabetical order (unlike the same element list further down). 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9154 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE the message in dom-intro boxes look like "issue" boxes. could you make them look less like issue boxes? e.g. be styled the same way as other "this section is non-normative" paragraphs; possibly have .impl style (so they get highlighted in highlight UA tex 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9155 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The attribute must be ignored if the autoplay attribute is present." - seems wrong when the user has set a pref to make autoplay="" not autoplay 2010-02-25 2010-10-04
9156 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED INVALID_STATE_ERR: INVALID_STATE_ERR 2010-02-26 2010-10-04
9157 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK What does this mean for <a>? What does it mean for <a target=_blank>? Following links should probably always work. 2010-02-26 2010-10-04
9159 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT metadata keyword description - "Hints to the user agent that the author either does not expect the user to need the media resource...". The word "either" seems to be unnecessary. 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9160 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT input['type=checkbox'].checkValidity ought to work like the radio type, testing the whole checkbox group, not each checkbox individually 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9161 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE it should explicitly say alt="" MUST NOT be blank unless it MAY be left blank 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9162 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED please define authors' requirements and non-normative introduction for authors to HTML's fragment identifiers 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9163 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The domintro box only has document.dir, and ought to have element.dir too. [pt] 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9164 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT If maxWidth = 0, repeatedly choosing smaller font sizes will never result in a zero-width piece of text, so steps 3-4 loop infinitely; there should be some way to e.g. abort and draw nothing if maxWidth is too small. [pt] 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9165 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Must not contain periods(".") de id and class, (and posible not #, :, {) because is not accesible from CSS 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9166 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Must not contain periods(".") de id and class, (and posible not #, :, {) because is not accesible from CSS . example in html id="name.last" in CSS selectors is imposible to select it because will search form id name class last. 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9167 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Must not contain periods(".") de id and class, (and posible not #, :, {) because is not accesible from CSS . example in html id="name.last" in CSS selectors is imposible to select it because will search form id name class last. In html is possible use 2010-02-27 2010-10-04
9168 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE iframeborder -> frameborder 2010-02-28 2010-10-04
9170 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Too good 2010-02-28 2010-10-04
9172 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK "© Copyright 2004-2009" - s/2009/2010/ [pt] 2010-03-01 2010-10-04
9173 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE This section should have a stable id so that http://dev.w3.org/html5/tests/submission/Microsoft/windowobject/security_location_0.htm can link to it 2010-03-01 2010-10-04
9175 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE should clearly say that cellIndex is not necessarily the same as slot_x (and there should be easy access to slot_x and slot_y) 2010-03-01 2010-10-04
9176 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo in 4th |th|: ‘per _c_ent’ (or rather ‘percent’) and please be metric, not inchic 2010-03-01 2010-10-04
9177 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Can the script element please allow the scope attribute in the same semantic way as the style element? The dom would be limited to only elements under that node. 2010-03-02 2010-10-04
9178 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE add definition of "conforming document" 2010-03-02 2011-04-12
9179 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED <body><section> results in <section> being associated with the <body> element's section. I'd expect <section> to be associated with its own section. 2010-03-02 2010-10-04
9180 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "The event thus is not to be fired faster than about 66Hz or slower than 4Hz." - unless the event handler is still running, in which case it could be slower 2010-03-03 2010-10-04
9181 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Find the effectAllowed line 2010-03-03 2010-10-04
9182 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Can I nest <ruby> elements? I think that you should add content model of the <ruby> element, "but there must be no ruby element descendants.". 2010-03-03 2010-10-04
9184 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "COOKIES" reference references old Internet Draft 2010-03-03 2010-10-04
9185 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: search for |(such as Cookie")| 2010-03-04 2010-10-04
9186 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED @abbr (td/th): may authors use @title instead? 2010-03-04 2010-10-04
9188 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Fix the references in the txt version to have URLs. 2010-03-04 2010-10-04
9192 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA test sdgfdsfg dfsgdfsg dsgd 2010-03-04 2010-10-04
9193 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "If hash changed is true, then, if the new URL has a fragment identifier, scroll to the fragment identifier." is wrong. It should scroll if it's a new entry that hasn't been traversed to before, even if it's the same fragid as before; and it should _not_ 2010-03-05 2010-10-04
9194 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA hello android 2010-03-05 2010-10-04
9195 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT the icns format does not support such ridiculously huge icon sizes! Where can I get an 8k x 8k screen please? printing would use the SVG anyway. 2010-03-05 2010-10-04
9197 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Remove unnecessary editorialization in acknowledgement section 2010-03-05 2010-10-04
9198 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <embed hspace> and <embed vspace> should not be allowed 2010-03-06 2010-10-04
9199 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE [a-urn] xref "href" 2010-03-06 2010-10-04
9200 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE xref document.getElementById(), and clarify on which document it should be called. 2010-03-06 2010-10-04
9201 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK xref getElementById() 2010-03-06 2010-10-04
9202 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE This comment overlays found text in my Firefox 3.0.18, which is bad. 2010-03-06 2010-10-04
9204 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED The onload event is missing a description on when it fires. Particularly on elements downloading auxiliary documents (img, script, link) it is important to specify when exactly that event is fired. Same for onerror and onabort events (and similar). 2010-03-06 2010-10-04
9205 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED I'm missing a specification on the relation between onreadystatechange and onload. Will they be used interchangeably? When will they fire? Will onreadystatechange fire multiple times during downloading an external resource (readystate="loading")? 2010-03-06 2010-10-04
9206 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "datetime content attribute" xref is dead 2010-03-07 2010-10-04
9207 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Anything else: This part of the spec is problematic, for example, a query string variable &lang_id=1 in as part of an attribute of say an img tag, will get converted into an character token when it shouldn't be. Why is the set of characters a-z, A-Z, 0- 2010-03-08 2010-10-04
9208 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED “isn't” – either “s not” or “isn’t” 2010-03-08 2010-10-04
9209 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE sectionRowIndex: check text in parentheses, seems redundant 2010-03-08 2010-10-04
9210 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED colSpan: there is no default value (rowSpan has one) 2010-03-08 2010-10-04
9212 HTML WG pre-LC1 travil RESO FIXE Change the Generator Mechanism for img from Document Level to Element Level 2010-03-08 2012-09-14
9214 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO WORK Allow role="presentation" img as conformance Criteria 2010-03-08 2010-10-04
9217 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Remove the Paragraph-Section-Heading loophole for not providing a text alternative. 2010-03-08 2010-12-07
9218 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL Enable Automatic Validators to Programmatically Determine the Presence or Absence of a Set of Text Alternatives 2010-03-08 2011-01-01
9220 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT xref doesn't work for "bgcolor" in "When a body, table, thead, tbody, tfoot, tr, td, or th element has a bgcolor attribute set" 2010-03-08 2010-10-04
9221 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED still unclear definition of "plugin" 2010-03-09 2010-10-04
9222 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA If this state does not conform to RFC 5322, how IS it of practical use? 2010-03-10 2010-10-04
9223 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK It is unlikely this will work on mobile as you cannot make tcp connections into a mobile phone. They will be blocked by the operator's firewall and this is very unlikely to change. Of course, this isn't a reason not to specify this, but it's good to be aw 2010-03-10 2011-05-10
9224 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It should be mentioned that setting playbackRate can be ignored. I.e. if playing backwards is not supported by the codec, if hardware acceleration does not support it, etc. 2010-03-11 2010-10-04
9225 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE lax interpretation of legacy encoding decl allows attackers to change encoding of a page 2010-03-11 2010-10-04
9226 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The subcategories of form-associated elements should have consistent naming. Probably all of them should end in "elements". 2010-03-11 2010-10-04
9227 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Setting IDL attributes that map enumerated content attributes to invalid values should not throw 2010-03-12 2010-10-04
9228 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The i and b elements should not be included. Fundamentally they are visual markup elements and that should be accomplished in CSS, not using element. 2010-03-12 2010-10-04
9229 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE meter and progress elements constraint validation status shouldn't be mentionned 2010-03-12 2010-10-04
9230 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Név: C:\Documents and Settings\bb\Dokumentumok\Videók\amator-tini-punci (77).jpg Formátum: JPG - Joint Photographic Experts Group Méret: 10.86 KB Dátum: 2010. március 12., 11:32:42 Szélesség: 325 Pixels Magasság: 425 Pixels Színmélység: 24 B 2010-03-12 2010-10-04
9232 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT name=size should also be highlighted 2010-03-12 2010-10-04
9233 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Incorporate a Link to UAAG with appropriate wording into browser sections 2010-03-12 2010-12-07
9234 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA some comment 2010-03-12 2010-10-09
9237 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA html5 2010-03-12 2010-10-09
9239 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE specify a convention for preventing vendor-specific non-standard extensions from clashing with themselves and future standard development 2010-03-13 2010-10-04
9240 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE rules for td[align=center] are missing 2010-03-13 2010-10-04
9241 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Explicitly state, "For guidance on accessibility requirements for text alternatives authors should consult WCAG 2.0" and link to WCAG 2.0 2010-03-13 2014-02-10
9242 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It is not clear whether "shortcut icon" is a valid keyword; it is widely used and seems to validate in the experimental HTML5 validator. 2010-03-13 2010-10-04
9243 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE This section should print the character in addition to its unicode number. 2010-03-14 2010-10-04
9244 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "if the values used are not allowed according to the definitions in this specification, then the element does not define a link": What should happen if one value is valid and one isn't? 2010-03-14 2010-10-04
9245 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Poster should somehow also be able to define a frame (or timeline position) to be used as the frame. 2010-03-14 2010-10-04
9247 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE last note states small does not de-emphasize. This naturally leads to the question what does. Answer that question 2010-03-15 2010-10-04
9249 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Step 9.4 s/is are/are/ 2010-03-15 2010-10-04
9251 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "When content fails to load (e.g. due to a network error), then the user agent must queue a task to fire a simple event named error at the element instead." is pretty vague (e.g. do bad URLs fire onerror? cross-domain failures?) Same applies to <frame>. 2010-03-15 2010-10-04
9255 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA why the hell is it uppercase in the longer exemple? 2010-03-16 2010-10-04
9259 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE clarification needed: "one big page with a scrollbar would be equivalent" Many readers might think as I did, "equivalent to what?" On reflection, I understand -- to the tabbed interface -- but the language could be clearer. 2010-03-17 2010-10-04
9260 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK On one extreme, we have parentheses. On the other extreme, we have sidebars. But in the middle ground, we have footnotes. How should footnotes be handled if <aside> is not the right way to do it? 2010-03-17 2010-10-04
9261 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Copying all the attributes would include the "id" attribute. Doesn't this allow multiple duplicate ID attributes? This is what current browsers do, so I guess which element gets selected in this situation by CSS or getElementById should be specified in th 2010-03-17 2010-10-04
9263 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Incorrect language determination algorithm 2010-03-18 2010-10-04
9264 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED There should be a link/border between META content-language algorithm and HTTP content-language headers 2010-03-18 2010-10-04
9265 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Although I’m loving the spec in general, what about a generic <h>header</h> element that can be nested? After all, we are not writing <section1>, <section2>, <section3>, and so on … 2010-03-18 2010-10-04
9267 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Allow alternative of simple <h> element that uses ancestors to determine hierarchy. (Or take a lesson from DocBook and reuse the <title> element, allowing its semantic meaning to change depending on the context.) 2010-03-18 2010-10-04
9268 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Why can’t we just reuse the <caption> element and describe its meaning according to context? (i.e., spec gives directions for “caption in table” and “caption in figure” contexts.) Semantically, both fulfill the same purpose. And even if there 2010-03-18 2010-10-04
9270 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Add <dialog> back 2010-03-18 2010-10-04
9272 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED This admonition should probably be marked as “Important” rather than “Note”, because of the consequences confusing the definitions of whitespace could have. 2010-03-18 2010-10-04
9278 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT "...with the same argument, the user agent **may** return the same object as the object returned by the earlier call.": Make this a must. To quote hsivonen, "The Web leaves no edge case unexercised." 2010-03-18 2010-10-04
9279 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Align the English isindex prompt with Firefox and Chrome 2010-03-19 2010-10-04
9281 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The sentence "When used to include data blocks..." would benefit from clarification: "When used to include non-JavaScript data blocks..." 2010-03-19 2010-10-04
9282 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL The sentence "When used to include data blocks..." would benefit from clarification: "When used to include non-JavaScript data blocks..." 2010-03-19 2010-10-22
9286 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE marginheight and topmargin are missing from the list of obsolete elements 2010-03-20 2010-10-04
9287 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE DOCTYPE "mostly useless" 2010-03-21 2010-10-04
9289 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE What about polyglot documents which are *both* HTML5 and XHTML5 ? I think it would make a lot of sense to spend a few words on that because virtually nobody will use XHMTL5 with the correct MIME-type because of the legacy browsers. 2010-03-22 2010-10-04
9300 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Remove the requirement to close NCR and entities with a semicolon 2010-03-22 2011-01-21
9309 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "For the purposes of the CSS ruby model, runs of descendants of ruby elements ..." - s/descendants/children/ ? 2010-03-24 2010-10-04
9311 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Two instances of "(unless this has been overrriden as described above)" where: s/overrriden/overriden 2010-03-24 2010-10-04
9322 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA dsdfs fe efefaafd asd 2010-03-25 2010-10-04
9329 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT drawImage filtering when dx and dy aren't integers needs defined 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9330 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA very gud 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9331 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Columns can correspond to col elements, but in the absence of col elements are implied." appears to be missing a comma after "... but in the absence of col...". 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9332 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It's not clear that the (implied) HTML 4.01 use of tfoot is prohibited (which seems to demand content identical to thead). Or should duplicate thead content be allowed in tfoot? Section should also have a tfoot example with meaningful content (a failing o 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9335 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE values need to be case-insensitive in xhtml too for the ua style sheet to work (e.g. <input type="HIDDEN"/>) 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9336 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE Remove concept of views as per discussion at last TPAC in the WebApps WG. At some point DOM Level 2 Views will be updated to recommend that implementors not implement the concept. 2010-03-26 2010-12-04
9337 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Frameset/Frame Specification Amendment 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9338 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Why can't I have the resource files (CSS file, images, JavaScript files) be cached without caching the whole page? I hacn't have a different HTML tag for just the sign-on page, and the other pages need to not be cached due to private, frequently changing 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9339 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED " Until the manifest is changed, those pages will not be fetched from the server again." WHAAAA? In order to get the benefits of app cached images and scripts and css, I have to have HTML pages that are never updated with fresh info, except when I change 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9340 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "RCDATAs element" should be "RCDATA elements" (or rephrase to refer to a single element) 2010-03-26 2010-10-04
9343 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE s/inlien/inline/, s/this specifications makes it/this specification makes it/ 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9344 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "constrolled" [pt] 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9345 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "what matters for implementations it the presence of the attribute" - s/it/is/ [pt] 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9346 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE define attr-option-name 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9347 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL s/title="attr-href"/title="attr-a-href"/ 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9348 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/<span title="event-click">/<code title="event-click">/ 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9349 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Make <nobr> element conforming 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9350 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make <wbr> element conforming 2010-03-27 2011-07-06
9351 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL Do not interpret & followed by an entity name followed by = as an entity reference in attribute values (maybe in text content too) 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9352 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Make unescaped & conforming in attribute values in some cases 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9353 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT autocomplete=off should be allowed and should work on non-<input> form controls 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9354 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Leading/trailing whitespace in attributes that take a URL should be conforming 2010-03-27 2010-10-04
9355 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Obsolete presentational markup should be conforming 2010-03-28 2011-07-28
9356 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Presumably "Errors that encourage a correct understanding of the spec" should read "an incorrect" instead of "a correct". 2010-03-28 2010-10-04
9357 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT input element color state should be able to suffer from a type mismatch 2010-03-28 2010-10-04
9358 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Explanation of content model requirements could be improved 2010-03-28 2010-10-04
9359 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE hspace and vspace attributes should be listed in obsolete section 2010-03-28 2010-10-04
9360 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <iframe allowTransparency> should be mentioned in the obsolete section 2010-03-28 2010-10-04
9361 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT script element should be allowed essentially anywhere 2010-03-28 2010-10-04
9364 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/dom-MessagpePort-postMessage/dom-MessagePort-postMessage/ 2010-03-29 2010-10-04
9365 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA Attribute selectors for HTML5 audio and video should be listed as case insensitive 2010-03-30 2010-10-04
9366 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Add |addClass|, |removeClass|, and shorten |getElementsByClassName| to |getElementsByClass| for |HTMLElement|. 2010-03-30 2010-10-04
9367 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT fix broken links in IDLs by changing id references of hyperlinks in IDLs to point to content in domintro boxes instead of UA implementation details 2010-03-30 2010-10-04
9369 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Propose Changing Content model to phrasing content model 2010-03-30 2010-10-04
9371 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE I misinterpreted "represents a paragraph-level thematic break" to mean "should occur between paragraphs". Might be nice to add "can be used anywhere the p element is used", or to mention "for rendering or analysis purposes" or "most flow elements are para 2010-03-31 2010-10-04
9372 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA html 5 2010-03-31 2010-10-04
9374 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL implementation of dash-styles for lines as seen in the pdf-specification would be nice (would require two additional parameters, "dashStyle" and "dashLength", for example) 2010-03-31 2010-10-22
9375 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA progress uses ProgressEvent 2010-03-31 2010-10-09
9378 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It is confusing that rank is defined in terms of h1-h6 elements and then later the behaviour for hgroup is tacked on. It would be clearer to define rank further down for everything all at once 2010-03-31 2010-10-04
9379 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT If contenteditable is true, this *should* mean that the *content* of the element is editable, not the element itself. For example, if the user selects "mytext" in <div contenteditable=true>mytext</div>, and then invokes execCommand('bold'), this should wr 2010-03-31 2010-10-04
9380 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL If contenteditable is true, this *should* mean that the *content* of the element is editable, not the element itself. For example, if the user selects "mytext" in <div contenteditable=true>mytext</div>, and then invokes execCommand('bold'), this should wr 2010-03-31 2010-10-04
9383 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE make it clearer that async and defer aren't allowed with src, and then remove "These attributes must not be specified when the element is used to include data blocks". 2010-04-01 2010-10-04
9385 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Presumably "_ferret-smellcode" is intended, not "fetter", unless the vendor is particularly incompetent. 2010-04-02 2010-10-04
9386 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE margintop dfn has wrong text 2010-04-02 2010-10-04
9387 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE this section is missing "view this example online" links 2010-04-02 2010-10-04
9388 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL this section is missing "view this example online" links 2010-04-02 2010-10-22
9389 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK add location change event 2010-04-02 2010-10-04
9390 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL "_fetter-smellcode="LEM01"" - s/fetter/ferret/, unless this is meant to be an obscure joke that I'm missing 2010-04-02 2010-10-04
9391 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED What about a CR character token after <pre> or <listing>? 2010-04-02 2010-10-04
9392 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The ABNF looks wrong. Trailing periods shouldn't be allowed before the @. Shouldn't it be: 1*atext *("." 1*atext) ? 2010-04-03 2010-10-04
9393 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "If the datetime attribute is present, the user agent should convey the attribute's value to the user when rendering the element." seems to not quite match the rendering section, which says that it's only bound if the element is :empty. 2010-04-03 2010-10-04
9394 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE This domintro box has the optional ports argument in the middle, should be at the end. 2010-04-03 2010-10-04
9395 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE postMessage IDL: use "in optional MessagePortArray ports"? 2010-04-03 2010-10-04
9396 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Make meta http-equiv="PICS-Label" conforming 2010-04-03 2010-10-04
9397 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED midi support 2010-04-03 2010-10-04
9399 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED "The contact information for a node node is a collection .." : SUdden appearance of the term "node" here is confusing and not explained. Also here a shift in tone where the writing here is more dense and a bit off-putting. 2010-04-03 2010-10-04
9400 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Native support for dashed and dotted lines. This is highly desirable, especially in charting. 2010-04-03 2010-10-22
9401 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Poonanny time! Yes please. 2010-04-04 2010-10-09
9403 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The output element example is confusing 2010-04-04 2010-10-04
9404 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Email address regexp should not allow first part to end in dot 2010-04-04 2010-10-04
9405 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Certain elements are parsed in someone eccentric ways" someone? 2010-04-04 2010-10-04
9406 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Reset buttons should be non-conforming 2010-04-04 2010-10-04
9407 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA zxczxc asd asdf 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9408 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Why return to step 6 rather than step 5 at the end? 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9409 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Spec that the last 'default-style' (whether http-equiv or http) takes precedence 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9410 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Say that 'default-style' can be set via HTTP (in addition to via HTTP-EQUIV) 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9411 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Say that it is the last META content-language declaration which takes precedence 2010-04-05 2012-09-21
9415 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Bring the meaning of "a valid BCP 47 language code" in accordance with BCP47 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9417 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Make the algorithm treat an empty META content-language and an empty lang="" the same way. 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9418 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Good sample 2010-04-05 2010-10-09
9420 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED The legal syntax of <META http-equive="content-language" content="*"> 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9421 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA please remove this "comment" thing. It throws errors and gets in the way. 2010-04-05 2010-10-09
9422 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Mozilla and <META http-equiv="content-language" content="<emptystring>" > 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9423 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Modern browsers have converged on giving <hr> vertical margins of .5em. The spec should reflect this. 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9424 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Conformance checking of the syntax of <META http-equiv="content-language" content="*"> 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9425 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE This section incorrectly specifies what happens when size > 1 but the multiple attribute is not set 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9426 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Define an algorithm for how to extract a language/languages from a comma separated content-language list 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9427 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Suggestion: Deprecate Legend Element 2010-04-05 2010-10-04
9428 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Permit <object> to be used without the data or type attribute present 2010-04-06 2011-01-22
9429 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Unobsolete the <strike> element - instead suggest how to use it 2010-04-06 2011-02-17
9430 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE [URL-terminology] "If it does not, then results in the following components": "then it results in", or "then it returns"? 2010-04-06 2010-10-04
9431 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT I believe that the link type "tag" should follow the same applicability as the author link type - i.e. nearest article parent / page as whole otherwise. It would also be consistent with the already used rel-tag microformat. http://microformats.org/wiki/re 2010-04-06 2010-10-04
9434 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK precedence between charset and http-equiv 2010-04-06 2010-10-04
9435 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE You should consider mentioning an outline on :link:focus 2010-04-06 2010-10-04
9436 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Telephone state note should mention pattern attribute 2010-04-06 2010-10-04
9437 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE change ARIA section title and add extra text about use of ARIA 2010-04-06 2011-04-08
9438 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE several issues with the hidden attribute 2010-04-06 2010-10-04
9439 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED UA should not change values of input elements in telephone state 2010-04-06 2010-10-04
9440 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Add window.stop()? 2010-04-07 2010-10-04
9441 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Graduation program example HTML formatting (while valid) seems broken 2010-04-07 2010-10-04
9442 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE table[align=abscenter], table[align=absmiddle], table[align=middle] do not seem to be required; AFAICT, only Gecko quirks mode supports them 2010-04-07 2012-01-26
9443 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA nee test 2010-04-07 2010-10-09
9445 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Spec td[align=middle], td[align=absmiddle] 2010-04-08 2010-10-04
9449 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA very olufy f ouf 2010-04-08 2010-10-04
9450 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL very olufy f ouf 2010-04-08 2010-10-04
9451 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE [NoInterfaceObject] *and* [Constructor] doesn't look right 2010-04-09 2010-10-04
9452 HTML WG pre-LC1 public-html-a11y RESO FIXE <video> Handling of additional tracks of a multitrack audio/video resource 2010-04-09 2011-06-10
9453 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA this is cool 2010-04-09 2010-10-09
9454 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA sdfsdf sd 2010-04-09 2014-12-02
9455 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL sdfsdf sdf 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9456 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL sdfsdf sdfsd 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9457 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL sdfsdf sdfsdfsd 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9458 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL sdfsdf sdfsdfsdf 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9459 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL sdfsdf sdfsdfsdfsdf 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9460 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL sdfsdf sdfsdfsdfsdfdsf sdfsdf 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9461 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL sdfsdf sdfsdfsdfsdfdsf sdfsdf 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9462 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL sdfsdf sdfsdfsdfsdfdsf sdfsdf 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9464 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE last example (empty element) is not described in prose 2010-04-09 2010-10-04
9465 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED This 'Device' section finds the W3C sadly still oblivious of the opportunity to integrate sensor-rich mobile devices into the web. What is wrong with "generic"?! The standard should enable barcode readers, accelerometers, thermometers, RFID readers, ... 2010-04-09 2010-10-04
9466 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL That should be http://home.comcast.net/~johnjbarton/ubicomp/Publications/SensorEnhancedWebClients.PDF (published in WWW2003) 2010-04-09 2010-10-22
9467 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED in example: not 'kanji' but 'on'/'kun' reading? 2010-04-09 2010-10-04
9468 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT code hilite is a usecase for 'mark', not 'span' 2010-04-09 2010-10-04
9470 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Boolean attribute reflecting 2010-04-09 2010-10-04
9471 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Introduce declarative markup to associate timed text resources with media elements 2010-04-09 2010-11-11
9472 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE deal with broken links in dynamic author view of spec by prompting users to choose to switch to full view 2010-04-10 2010-10-04
9473 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE add wording to explicitly indicate that option/@selected cannot be used unless as a descendant of select/@multiple 2010-04-10 2010-10-04
9474 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Renaming hgroup to h would be better (like XHTML2), so we can deprecate 'h*' in the future without the "group" sounding strange 2010-04-10 2010-10-04
9475 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT please add (script-based) syntax highlighting to examples 2010-04-10 2010-10-04
9476 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT 'rp' would be nice to have inside 'q', too (or rather would have been) 2010-04-10 2010-10-04
9478 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA change src 2010-04-10 2010-10-09
9480 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE the type for getter WindowProxy() by index or name should be any, not WindowProxy, to match the description of its behavior below 2010-04-10 2010-10-04
9481 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Should there be a step between 3 and 4: Otherwise, if elements has no elements, return undefined? 2010-04-10 2010-10-04
9484 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED <audio> should have width (and height) as well. <video> has it, so it's pointless for <audio> not to. Currently, <audio> not having this breaks page layouts such as wikipedia, unless you workaround the problem by using <video> to play back audio content, 2010-04-11 2010-10-04
9485 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Mandate all conformance checkers and validators must refer to WCAG 2010-04-11 2013-05-14
9486 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE autocomplete form element attribute should be a DOMString attribute 2010-04-11 2010-10-04
9487 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE selection . collapsed(parentNode, offset) <== should be collapse(...) 2010-04-11 2010-10-04
9488 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE selection . getRangeAt(index) <== Exception name is inccorrect should be INDEX_SIZE_ERR (Chris Apers) 2010-04-11 2010-10-04
9489 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Range object methods/properties is not described here. Should link to the related DOM Level 2 Reference http://www.w3.org/TR/DOM-Level-2-Traversal-Range/ranges.html (Chris Apers) 2010-04-11 2010-10-04
9490 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE autocomplete input element attribute should be a DOMString attribute 2010-04-11 2010-10-04
9491 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Suggested wording improvement for <section> and <article> definitions 2010-04-11 2010-10-04
9493 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE NAME attribute value rules need clarifying 2010-04-12 2010-10-04
9495 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Need links to text syntax in attributes index 2010-04-12 2010-10-04
9496 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <button> should not be scoping 2010-04-12 2010-10-04
9498 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA gfds gsfdgds 2010-04-12 2010-10-09
9499 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA derp derp derp derp derp derp derp 2010-04-12 2010-10-09
9500 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA 2010-3-25 msn messenenger 2010-04-12 2010-10-09
9501 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE so 'hr' is (almost) like empty 'h#' with # being the next applicable level ('h2' in the first example) and the first one being left out -- this section should point to the element's role (or non-role) in generating the document outline 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9502 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE @bug 9186: "abbr on td and th elements" -> "Use text ... <ins>or use the title attribute instead</ins>" 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9503 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE change controller for text/html-sandboxed media type 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9504 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "text ... highlighted for reference purposes" sounds to me as if code syntax highlighting was one application, but #the-span-element and bug 9468 say otherwise 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9505 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Immutable checkbox, radio and file input types should not suffer from value missing 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9506 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Content inside a blockquote must be quoted from another source, whose address, if it has one, should be cited in the cite attribute." **Should** be cited? 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9507 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA what the 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9508 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Both xrefs to |rel| are broken above the table. 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9510 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Allow a meta content-language element to occur more than once 2010-04-13 2010-10-04
9511 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK 4.2.5.1 keywords: strip spaces at separation comma 2010-04-14 2010-10-04
9512 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT 4.6.5: the cite element when a person's name is the work's name 2010-04-14 2010-10-04
9513 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It's not clear what takes precendece on a conflit: For spliting our web site structure into sections, should we use a section (without header on some cases) our should we use DIV (knowing that div brings no semantic relevance at all). The *should* on the 2010-04-14 2010-10-04
9515 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Allow <noscript> element as child element of <head> element 2010-04-14 2010-10-04
9516 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA space characters 2010-04-14 2010-10-09
9517 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Homogenize linkage of external sources 2010-04-14 2010-10-04
9518 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Should reference W3C Recommendation 01 April 2010 "XML Entity Definitions for Characters" 2010-04-14 2010-10-04
9519 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Is it me, or is this a big deal not to support dates before year one? 2010-04-14 2010-10-04
9521 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Window Object 2010-04-14 2010-10-09
9522 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Window Object 2010-04-14 2010-10-09
9523 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <figcaption> should allow <p>s (change content model to flow) 2010-04-15 2010-10-04
9524 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "...the user agent is 7configured to block access" s/7// 2010-04-15 2010-10-04
9525 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED WHat happens when a browser supports both XHTML and HTML? Which has precedence? There should be a decision chart leading to this point with defaults for missing elements then something to say what you use if you support both and the Web page is missing w 2010-04-15 2010-10-04
9526 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Replace "text/javascript" with "application/ecmascript" 2010-04-15 2010-10-22
9527 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA tags and syntax 2010-04-15 2010-10-09
9528 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL tags and syntax 2010-04-15 2010-10-04
9529 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE output element reset algorithm should set value mode flag to default _before_ setting textContent 2010-04-15 2010-10-04
9530 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Validity of meta "pragmas" 2010-04-15 2010-12-01
9534 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA audio element 2010-04-16 2010-10-09
9535 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Consider the poem example of figure. It should be possible to omit the </p> tag there. Maybe we should make <figcaption> imply </p> in the parser. 2010-04-16 2010-10-04
9542 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Recommended rendering for table alignment does not match reality 2010-04-16 2010-10-04
9545 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT frameborder attribute on <iframe> should be obsolete but conforming 2010-04-17 2010-10-04
9546 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA computing atom:updated 2010-04-17 2010-12-01
9547 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE If more than one element has the autofocus attribute specified, only the first one should be focused 2010-04-17 2010-10-04
9548 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT autofocus attribute should be ignored after the load event 2010-04-17 2010-10-04
9550 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA not all work with chrome 2010-04-18 2010-10-09
9551 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA the clipping region are cool but how select one 2010-04-18 2010-10-09
9552 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE xref 'URL decomposition IDL attributes' 2010-04-19 2010-10-04
9555 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Inconsistent specification of 'href' attribute for <link> 2010-04-19 2010-10-04
9556 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Spelling Check: "Let current outlinee be null" Outlinee should be Outline? 2010-04-19 2010-10-04
9559 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA "Color well control" should be "color wheel control" I think. 2010-04-20 2010-10-09
9560 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE [history] The line game example doesn't work properly 2010-04-20 2010-10-04
9564 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/<span title="dom-output-wrap">htmlFor</span>/<span title="dom-output-htmlFor">htmlFor</span>/ 2010-04-20 2010-10-04
9573 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED spec input.onsearch 2010-04-21 2010-10-04
9575 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT header lacks footer’s reference to scoping (nearest ancestor sectioning element/body) 2010-04-22 2010-10-04
9576 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE just say "an ASCII case-insensitive match for "URL"" instead of "either a U+0055 LATIN CAPITAL LETTER U character (U) or a U+0075 LATIN SMALL LETTER U character (u), a U+0052 LATIN CAPITAL LETTER R character (R) or a U+0072 LATIN SMALL LETTER R character 2010-04-22 2010-10-04
9577 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Define the x and y attributes. Both Gecko and WebKit have them and apparently some sites depend on them :/ 2010-04-22 2010-10-09
9578 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE On http-state it was mentioned that browsers support Set-Cookie here. Ugh! 2010-04-22 2010-10-04
9579 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT An element should not suffer from pattern mismatch if the pattern attribute value is the empty string 2010-04-22 2010-10-04
9580 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Steps for handling end tags in the "in foreign" mode walk past the root node in the stack 2010-04-22 2010-10-04
9581 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Steps for handling end tags in the "in foreign" mode may compare the name of an already-popped node 2010-04-22 2010-10-04
9582 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Steps for handling end tags in the "in foreign" mode get stuck in an infinite loop 2010-04-22 2010-10-04
9585 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK "The compatMode Implemented and widely deployed #dom-document-compatmode Tests: 6 — View... Demos: 0 Latest Internet Explorer beta: excellent support Latest Firefox trunk nightly build: excellent support Latest WebKit or Chromium trunk build: inc 2010-04-23 2010-10-04
9586 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL need support for changing tracks - especially audio tracks in the case of multilingual video media types 2010-04-23 2010-10-22
9587 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It is not clear whether document styles then scoped styles should be applied to the scope or only the scoped styles, ignoring the document styles. 2010-04-23 2010-10-04
9589 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE HTML5 should give examples for how to present @title when the user can't use a pointing device 2010-04-25 2010-10-04
9590 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Consider "prefix--" instead of "_prefix-" as a pattern for proprietary extensions 2010-04-25 2010-10-15
9591 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE itemref should say "HTML elements" 2010-04-26 2010-10-04
9592 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT user agents should provide an indication that an image has not been rendered 2010-04-26 2010-10-04
9594 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE iphone icon size is 57x57, not 59x60 2010-04-27 2010-10-04
9601 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA ose corners are the four points (sx, sy), (sx+sw, sy), (sx+sw, sy+sh), (sx, sy+sh). If the source rectangle is not entirely within the source image, or if one of the sw or sh arguments is zero, the implementation must raise an INDEX_SIZE_ERR exception. 2010-04-27 2010-10-09
9602 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Autofocus attribute. 2010-04-27 2010-10-04
9603 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT If the origin parameter does not match the Document origin the Referer header should also be excluded. Alternatively a way to omit the Referer header would be good for CORS. 2010-04-28 2010-10-04
9604 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE For CORS we want a way to prevent setting cookies. Might be nice if that was part of the fetch algorithm. 2010-04-28 2010-10-04
9614 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA this is for testing 2010-04-29 2010-10-04
9615 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA this is sexy 2010-04-29 2010-10-04
9621 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT How do we read the current Transform applied to the context? 2010-04-29 2010-10-04
9622 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA How do we set the clip region for a draw operation? 2010-04-29 2010-10-09
9623 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE <details> and <summary> are missing from the "strong aria semantics" table 2010-04-30 2011-12-20
9624 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK datalist should not filter options with no value 2010-04-30 2010-10-04
9625 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE select element should be able to suffer from being missing 2010-04-30 2010-11-29
9626 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Elements which can't match :required pseudo-class should not match :optional pseudo-class 2010-04-30 2010-10-04
9627 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA be more specific in external references 2010-04-30 2010-12-01
9628 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Algorithm for detecting the charset="" parameter. 2010-04-30 2011-03-11
9629 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It says that UAs should provide controls to enable/disable closed captions, but it doesn't define how to load/set the available closed captions or how to render them 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9630 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT declaration of drawImage is repeated 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9631 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Change name of <figcaption> to <summary> 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9632 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED To be able to go to first page in history, we should probably change the rule when (index of current entry + delta) is less than zero? 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9634 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Most enumerated attributes are not limited to only known values 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9635 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK input.type attribute should be limited to only known values 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9636 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE autocomplete IDL attribute should be limited to only known values 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9637 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT autocomplete IDL attribute should reflect the resulting autocompletion state 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9638 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Freeze while scrolling 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9639 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE step 31: ..."as a post-oad task". Obviousy misses a L ;) 2010-05-01 2010-10-04
9641 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA I know HTML,and this "head" tag is known by many Web Weavers! 2010-05-02 2010-10-04
9642 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE type != "text/html": this probably needs a line feed after the pre tag as well 2010-05-02 2010-10-04
9643 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT <rp> should be able to used outside of rubies, for cases where CSS is used to present content. For example, in a chatting application: <span>John Doe<span><rp> [</rp>12:30am<rp>]</rp></span><span> where the inner <span> is floated right and the <rp> is hi 2010-05-03 2010-10-04
9644 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <marquee truespeed> is a boolean attribute 2010-05-03 2010-10-04
9649 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It doesn't look like any browser supports document.innerHTML 2010-05-03 2011-07-20
9650 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK WHATWG Spec Web Site Freeze 2010-05-03 2010-10-04
9651 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK autofocus should not work if the focused document is a sub-document 2010-05-03 2010-10-04
9652 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Help me get thia resolved 2010-05-04 2010-10-04
9657 HTML WG pre-LC1 erika.doyle RESO FIXE Content model of object 2010-05-05 2012-08-24
9658 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Define (correctly) how object, ins, del, map, button affects outlines 2010-05-05 2010-10-04
9659 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Initial U+0000 should not set frameset-ok to "not ok" 2010-05-05 2010-11-11
9660 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED false" missed double quote 2010-05-05 2010-10-04
9662 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT canPlayType should return enum instead of string 2010-05-05 2010-10-04
9663 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Should sequences of bytes be replaced by a single U+FFFD, or one U+FFFD per input byte? 2010-05-06 2010-10-04
9667 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA assdadadada das da da d ad ads 2010-05-06 2010-10-09
9668 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA teracts be shared by all thontent of the empty (collapsed, s 2010-05-06 2010-10-04
9672 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "...whether or not the <user> can edit..." 2010-05-06 2010-10-04
9673 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Remove any reference to a specific Time Stamp format for video captioning from the specification at this time 2010-05-06 2010-10-04
9674 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED "event" and "for" attributes are obsolete 2010-05-07 2010-10-04
9682 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE bad reference to MIMESNIFF 2010-05-07 2010-10-04
9686 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Check whether some cases of "other relevant specifications" should link to "other applicable specifications". 2010-05-08 2010-10-04
9688 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA ormat, as in "for HTML, ... (this does not apply to XHTML)". This specification uses the term document to refer to any use of HTML, ranging from short static documents to long essays or reports with rich multimedia, as well as to fully-fledged interactiv 2010-05-09 2010-10-09
9689 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE cross-reference "ordinal value" everywhere (<li>, <ol>, rendering of decorations) 2010-05-09 2010-10-04
9690 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Redefining elements can cause compatibility issues. What if some browsers read it the old way, and some the new way. This can lead to problems if someone uses the element the new way, only for it to be read the old way, or for old documents to require rew 2010-05-09 2010-10-04
9692 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA var mboxCopyright = "&copy; 2003-2009. Omniture, Inc. All rights reserved.";mboxUrlBuilder = function(a, b) { this.a = a; this.b = b; this.c = new Array(); this.d = function(e) { return e; }; this.f = null;};mboxUrlBuilder.prototype.addParameter = functio 2010-05-09 2010-10-09
9704 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL The HTML in the graudation programme looks weird. There are line breaks before the closing &gt; and tag names are capitalised. 2010-05-11 2010-10-04
9705 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED The use of the colon in the first sentence (‘...within the page: a section with navigation links.’) may be confusing. Suggestion: ‘within the page. It is a section with navigation links.’ 2010-05-11 2010-10-04
9707 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Obsolete permitted DOCTYPE strings: which MIME-type? 2010-05-11 2010-10-09
9708 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Remove step 20 from 'Forming a table' section ("table model error") 2010-05-11 2010-10-04
9718 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA gjy khjk hkhjk hjk hh 2010-05-12 2010-10-09
9719 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA ASsad asdawewfvdfqwe we qeased awe wdq 2010-05-12 2010-10-09
9720 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA " method="post" enctype="application/x-www-form-urlencoded"> 2010-05-12 2010-10-09
9723 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA HTML is in capitals? I believe that's incorrect or at least unusual standards since XHTML 1.0 2010-05-12 2010-10-04
9724 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA value attribute, if specified, must have a value that contains no U+000A LINE FEED (LF) or U+000D CARRIAGE RETURN (CR) characters. 2010-05-13 2010-10-09
9725 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL value attribute, if specified, must have a value that contains no U+000A LINE FEED (LF) or U+000D CARRIAGE RETURN (CR) characters. 2010-05-13 2010-10-22
9726 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Spec the features argument 2010-05-13 2010-10-04
9727 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT We told people for years that I and B are a bad idea as they are only visual but hint at making things more prominent. Can we just let them die? 2010-05-13 2010-10-04
9728 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA help me to get out of here! 2010-05-13 2010-10-09
9730 HTML WG pre-LC1 Ms2ger RESO FIXE The div.status.LC.current popup box for the <wbr>element refers to the <br> element. 2010-05-14 2010-10-04
9731 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE please, add "nested forms, form nesting" words to the section (name or body) so search engines can find it, please!!! 2010-05-14 2010-10-04
9732 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Give more varied examples on the codecs parameter 2010-05-14 2010-10-04
9733 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA one reason for having this not restricted to audiovisual streams would be the option of, say, reading a barcode scanning device to fill a shopping cart. This is something you currently need Java or a custom plugin for. rs232 and fs are the perfect thing f 2010-05-14 2010-10-09
9735 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Given that the media elements provide a clear fallback path, is there really a use case for canPlayType and its uncertainty? 2010-05-14 2010-10-04
9741 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE enctype, formenctype, method and formmethod IDL attributes should be limited to only known values 2010-05-15 2010-10-04
9742 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA vikram here to put a test comment 2010-05-16 2010-10-09
9743 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE I misread this initially as pubdate or pubdate="pubdate" were allowed, then as pubdate="" or pubdate="pubdate" were allowed. providing an example of all three styles would be great 2010-05-17 2010-10-04
9744 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA hiwhat the hell is this 2010-05-17 2010-10-09
9748 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE There should also be a absolute time, a time from the media playing. For sync issues etc. See <https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=566375> 2010-05-17 2010-10-04
9749 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA document object model 2010-05-17 2010-10-09
9750 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Why may a content-type handler that isn't a plugin not handle a resource linked to by <embed>? 2010-05-17 2010-10-04
9752 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA <p>What fruits do you like?</p> <ol ondragstart="dragStartHandler(event)" ondragend="dragEndHandler(event)"> ...as before... </ol> <script> function dragStartHandler(event) { // ...as before... } function dragEndHandler(event) { // remove t 2010-05-18 2010-10-09
9753 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA yes yes yes 2010-05-18 2010-10-09
9754 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA function dragEndHandler(event) { // remove the dragged element event.target.parentNode.removeChild(event.target); } 2010-05-18 2010-10-09
9755 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA function dragEndHandler(event) { // remove the dragged element event.target.parentNode.removeChild(event.target); } 2010-05-18 2010-10-09
9756 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA <p>What fruits do you like?</p> <ol ondragstart="dragStartHandler(event)"> <li draggable data-value="fruit-apple">Apples</li> <li draggable data-value="fruit-orange">Oranges</li> <li draggable data-value="fruit-pear">Pears</li> </ol> <script> var int 2010-05-18 2010-10-09
9760 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK "It might not be zero if the clip's timeline is not zero-based" - please make startTime start at 0 even for clips that are not zero-based, to make the API simpler to use for authors. If this change is made, startTime seems to be equivalent to buffered.sta 2010-05-18 2010-10-04
9761 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA not fount problem 2010-05-18 2010-10-09
9762 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA not found problem 2010-05-18 2010-10-09
9767 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Consider ignoring document.write() when IE ignores it if comes from the network task source 2010-05-19 2010-10-12
9770 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT There should be a way to exclude the page that calls the manifest from the cache as well, for those who want to use the cache manifest to speed up a site, but not use it as an offline application. 2010-05-19 2010-10-04
9771 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It's slightly strange that the Tokenizer keeps changing the "insertion mode" which appears to be parser-state. eric@webkit.org 2010-05-19 2010-10-04
9772 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED space skipping in initial mode is redundant with "before html" 2010-05-20 2010-10-04
9782 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED This could be a valuable addition to the textarea element as well 2010-05-20 2010-10-04
9783 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE I'd like to see a short explanation of online white list in this section and a link where it's used the first time. 2010-05-20 2010-10-04
9784 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED I think input elements associated with datalists should have a "must-be-in-list" attribute which should cause a validation error when the value is not found in the datalist 2010-05-21 2010-10-04
9788 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA aD adsa D AS 2010-05-21 2010-10-04
9794 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK typo. use -> user. 2010-05-22 2010-10-04
9795 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA nice..i like it.. 2010-05-22 2010-10-04
9797 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <meta http-equiv="Link"> not addressed by spec 2010-05-22 2010-10-04
9798 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The type attribute on <ol> and <ul> is semantic and should be permitted 2010-05-22 2010-10-04
9800 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED The wording for the suspend event ("but does not have the entire media resource downloaded") puts it in the same boat as the removed load event. The description should reflect that the event is fired when the networkState changes to the state of NETWORK_I 2010-05-22 2010-10-04
9801 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It would be useful to mention sectioning root elements with a link to 4.4.11 here 2010-05-24 2010-10-04
9802 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "Finally, switch back to the attribute value state that you were in when were switched into this state." is not an english sentence. :) 2010-05-25 2010-10-04
9803 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA an sdas dkjasd kasd 2010-05-25 2010-10-09
9804 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA "the alt attribute must be specified" so are you saying ALT is required? 2010-05-25 2010-10-04
9805 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Help with current pattern should not use the title attribute (4.10.7.2.8) 2010-05-25 2010-10-04
9810 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK How is the onLine parameter to be implemented? Here it is described, that it returns true if the user-agent might be online - I think it really has to be rewritten, 2010-05-27 2010-10-04
9811 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL How is the onLine parameter to be implemented? Here it is described, that it returns true if the user-agent might be online - I think it really has to be rewritten, 2010-05-27 2010-10-04
9813 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED bgsound: Use "audio" instead isn't helpful for back-compat. Proposal: Use "audio" instead, with "embed" fallback for backwards compatibility 2010-05-27 2010-10-04
9817 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve CLOS WORK Details element Focus problem 2010-05-27 2013-03-28
9820 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA How can I join the mailing list? 2010-05-28 2010-10-09
9821 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I think the Keywords should be capitalized (e.g. Content-Type rather than content-type) so that they match the HTTP header spec 2010-05-28 2010-10-04
9824 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA comentariu destul de mare pentru ca editorul sa il inteleeaga 2010-05-29 2010-10-04
9828 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Update "Embedding custom non-visible data" with guidance for library authors to avoid naming collisions 2010-06-02 2010-10-04
9829 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <button> should be scoping for the purpose of implicitly closing <p> 2010-06-02 2010-10-04
9830 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE When describing the type attribute, the charset sentence makes the following sentence ambiguous 2010-06-02 2010-10-04
9831 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Handling of EOF in foreignContent mode causes all tags to be popped of stack of open elements 2010-06-02 2010-10-04
9833 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA 4.6 Text-level semantics 2010-06-02 2010-10-09
9834 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Please restrict the quirk to same-origin loads per CVE-2010-0654 2010-06-02 2010-10-04
9835 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Remove image analysis 2010-06-02 2010-10-04
9839 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "then set the foreign flag to true." - this would be easier to understand if it just said "set /foreign/ to true" since it is not called a flag when it is defined 2010-06-03 2010-10-04
9841 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT input ="date" should allow pattern="" for national formats (ex: French date is dd/mm/yyyy ) 2010-06-03 2010-11-17
9843 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Specced behavior for document.write("<link rel=stylesheet href=...><script>...</script>...") matches none of the top 4 engines 2010-06-03 2010-10-12
9844 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE namedItem domintro links to item dfn 2010-06-03 2010-10-04
9845 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK provide reference and info about HTML5: Techniques for providing useful text alternatives in html5 spec 2010-06-03 2015-06-17
9847 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE legacy color value parsing algorithm should trim whitespace 2010-06-03 2011-05-08
9848 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK legacy color values should not require handling of CSS2 system colors 2010-06-04 2010-10-04
9849 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Comments that contain the string "-->" can be represented in the DOM but not in the HTML syntax or in XML." could be confusing. 2010-06-04 2010-10-04
9851 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Allow plugins in @sandbox via "allow-plugins" option 2010-06-04 2010-11-05
9852 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA fgdjggfhj fkg kjf 2010-06-04 2010-10-09
9853 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA fgdjggfhj fkg kjf s dgsd hff g 2010-06-04 2010-10-09
9854 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA multiple attribute 2010-06-04 2010-10-04
9855 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA multiple attribute 2010-06-04 2010-10-04
9856 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA multiple attribute 2010-06-04 2010-10-04
9859 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT add document-conformance constraints for documents that contain SVG or MathML content that in turn contains HTML content 2010-06-05 2010-10-04
9861 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT drop |blink{text-decoration:blink}|; not supported by IE and WebKit, not needed for web compat 2010-06-05 2010-10-04
9862 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA testing... asdfghjkl asdfghjkl 2010-06-05 2010-10-04
9863 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA сссс ччччч ччч чч 2010-06-06 2010-10-04
9864 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE It would be nice to explicitly list what elements are media elements (video, audio, source) 2010-06-06 2010-10-04
9865 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Encrypted HTML5 forms 2010-06-06 2010-10-09
9867 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK "To draw on the canvas, authors must first obtain a reference to a context": abuse of "must" 2010-06-06 2010-10-04
9868 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA this is a good one 2010-06-06 2010-10-09
9869 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA this is a good one 2010-06-06 2010-10-09
9870 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA jasdfjasfsafas dfasdfasdfjasdjfasldfjasldfjals asldfjasldfj asdfj a;sldf asldfjasdf asdfl asflajsd flasjkdf aslfasdfajsdf 2010-06-06 2010-10-09
9871 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT provide normative advice to conformance checkers about use of onevent handler attributes 2010-06-07 2010-10-12
9872 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT trigger a conformance error when javascript is included in href attribute 2010-06-07 2010-10-12
9873 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA hi i am here 2010-06-07 2010-10-09
9875 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA what the fuck ? 2010-06-08 2010-10-09
9876 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Clarify that a figure can be any content with a caption 2010-06-08 2012-01-10
9877 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Why not for link – a permalink to the whole document? 2010-06-08 2010-10-04
9880 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT noticed the comment about per-source mutexes for storage. If that's not desired, an approach that has worked well in other API designs is an application-selectable mutex per context. Thus, each localStorage object could have a "_mutex" property, which by 2010-06-08 2010-10-04
9881 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA The paragraph about setting a value with valueAsNumber is a bad copy/paste from valueAsDate. Some sentences should be changed with s/Date/Number/. 2010-06-08 2010-10-09
9883 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Notes on and request for references for Section 1.4: History 2010-06-08 2010-10-04
9885 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Need to clarify that "User agents must treat plaintext elements in a manner equivalent to pre elements." and other similar lines added in r3502 only refer to the semantics and not the IDL interface or the tag name in the DOM. 2010-06-08 2010-10-04
9886 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK valueAsNumber is a double but the algorithm to convert a string to a number have to follow the rules for parsing float 2010-06-08 2010-10-04
9887 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE parsing algorithm should allow HTML content in MathML <annotation-xml> 2010-06-09 2010-10-04
9889 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE I wish the two states, Soft and Hard, were explained 2010-06-09 2010-10-04
9891 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK poster image should be showed when video hasn't been played 2010-06-09 2010-10-04
9892 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK s/specifically with regarding to/specifically regarding/ 2010-06-09 2010-10-04
9893 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE tabindex not listed in Table of Contents 2010-06-09 2011-01-01
9895 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE HTMLImageElement's "complete" attribute definition implies immediate image decoding 2010-06-09 2010-10-19
9896 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL need closing quote and /> for the p tag 2010-06-10 2010-10-04
9897 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA need closing quote and /> for the very last p tag 2010-06-10 2010-10-04
9904 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE <progress> element: max IDL attribute should return 1 not 0 when the content attribute is missing 2010-06-10 2010-10-04
9905 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK this tag is inappropriate for the html spec. it does not follow philosophy of good semantic markup and should be removed. 2010-06-10 2010-10-04
9906 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Are RFC 2822 formatted dates valid? 2010-06-10 2010-10-04
9908 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA in the example HTML for the "generator" attribute, the word generator is not quoted. 2010-06-10 2010-10-04
9909 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA df fd 2010-06-11 2010-10-09
9910 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <basefont> and <bgsound> should not break out of 'in head', should be treated as a void elements within <head> 2010-06-11 2010-10-04
9911 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA test yyy yeyey eeeeeey 2010-06-11 2010-10-09
9912 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA test yyy yeyey eeeeeey 2010-06-11 2010-10-09
9914 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL hspace, vspace are long, not unsigned long 2010-06-11 2010-10-04
9915 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED application cache progress event should also indicate how many more resources are yet to be downloaded 2010-06-11 2010-10-04
9917 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Often times the first non-blank frames are the least interesting. Poster images should do just that: show the most interesting part to entice the user to watch the video. 2010-06-13 2010-10-04
9919 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Remove kbd, samp, and maybe var, like acronym; expand <code>/<tt>/<i> or whatever to replace them 2010-06-14 2010-10-04
9924 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Apparently a form can be submitted before it is fully loaded (close-tag not yet seen, close-html-tag not yet seen). This is insane behavior, but should be documented. 2010-06-14 2010-10-04
9926 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED when lots of keywords (tags) you waste lots of bandwidth in html. A meterGROUP looks more usefull where max is the total amount of tags, min is 0 and value is the current instances of the tag. example: <metergroup max="100" min="0" high="60" optimal="80" 2010-06-14 2010-10-04
9928 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The "dirty value" concept should be removed or used more 2010-06-15 2010-10-04
9935 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE select tag's size attribute default value discrepency 2010-06-16 2010-10-04
9936 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED onclick attributes on any element that is not focusable should trigger a conformance error 2010-06-16 2010-10-12
9938 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT No API for fullscreen? Really? Can we please have better options other than a totalitarian "you can't do it?" I thought the idea was to be better than Flash. Yet, you still don't allow simple functionality such as that. Tie it to a button. Ask the user's 2010-06-16 2010-10-04
9940 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED what is the means of aside in HTML 5? 2010-06-17 2010-10-04
9941 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA If a script gets inserted into a document it will "run" and its "already started" flag will be set. How can the conditions of being in a document and child nodes being changed or src attribute being set ever apply? 2010-06-17 2010-12-01
9943 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Add a sudoku puzzle as an example table to demonstrate a table without headers. 2010-06-17 2010-10-04
9944 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Should have "navigator" in the toc for this section 2010-06-17 2010-10-04
9945 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL usage of uppercase characters in element names 2010-06-17 2010-10-04
9946 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA element names are written in all uppercase 2010-06-17 2010-10-04
9947 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In the start tag whose tag name is "select" clause, the special behaviour if the insertion mode is "In Column Group" doesn't seem to be possible; that is you can never reach this clause in that insertion mode. Also there is a missing quote before in table 2010-06-17 2010-10-04
9948 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK In "Any other end tag" the generate implied end tags should probably be excluding the name of the token otherwise we tend to pop everything off the stack 2010-06-17 2010-10-04
9949 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK there should be a way for developers to not allow their pages to be sandboxed, like if they absolutely need javascript. 2010-06-17 2010-10-04
9950 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK It should mention explicitly that br doesn't have to close. 2010-06-18 2010-10-04
9951 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA this is a test 2010-06-18 2010-10-04
9952 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA this is a test 3 2010-06-18 2010-10-04
9954 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA here the mouse was clicked, or the start of the selection or element that was selected for the drag), may have any number of intermediate steps (elements that the mouse moves over during a drag, or elements that the user picks as possible drop points as h 2010-06-19 2010-10-04
9956 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT be nice to have an attribute to limit the max # of selections, eg- <input name='uploads[]' type="file" multiple="true" maxselections="10"/> 2010-06-19 2010-10-04
9974 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA test test test 2010-06-21 2010-10-09
9977 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It shall be valuable if you add a "forcedownload" link type which forces the client to download the target document in the download window rather than opening the document in the same window of the browser as what is hapening right now 2010-06-22 2010-10-04
9979 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Why can't a value start out incomplete, e.g. "2010-" ? 2010-06-22 2010-10-04
9981 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA let try this 2010-06-22 2010-10-09
9983 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA [parser] Insertion point not saved for external scripts 2010-06-22 2010-10-09
9984 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT [parser] Insertion point for script@onload doesn't match Firefox 2010-06-22 2010-10-04
9985 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT [parser] How to parse </foo </bar> 2010-06-22 2010-10-04
9986 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT add ability to add noscroll 'property' for objects like video. Right now when you scroll and your mouse hovers a video object it stops scrolling because it tries to scroll inside the video tag. 2010-06-22 2010-10-04
9987 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Attribute values should be allowed to contain ambiguous ampersands since large amounts of content on the web uses them in URLs and most or all web browsers already interpret them consistently. 2010-06-23 2010-10-04
9988 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Seems the example does not match the description. Shouldn't the textarea (line 3) also be required? 2010-06-23 2010-10-04
9990 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA this is very nice 2010-06-23 2010-10-09
9993 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA this is a retarded web site 2010-06-23 2010-10-09
9994 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA im bored and his is retarded 2010-06-23 2010-10-09
9995 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA im being forced to read this and i dont understand it 2010-06-23 2010-10-09
9996 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA this website isnt interesting and it takes too long to load 2010-06-23 2010-10-09
9997 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA so how has your day been i wonder if your job is fun i mean what exactly do u do do you even get payed well enough 2010-06-23 2010-10-09
9998 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED I would like to see how the form looks 2010-06-23 2010-10-04
9999 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In the example, should the draggable attribute be set to true? 2010-06-23 2010-10-04
10001 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA For <ol> and <ul>, it would be very useful to have an array containing all top-level elements of the list, such as 'HTMLOListElement.listItems' 2010-06-23 2010-10-09
10002 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE add fragment ID for the equivalence table in "Tokenizing character references" 2010-06-24 2010-10-04
10006 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE clearTimeout/clearInterval are not clear what the behaviour should be if handle is not in the list 2010-06-24 2010-10-04
10009 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA excellent thank you for all 2010-06-24 2010-10-09
10010 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA excellent!!! thank you for all 2010-06-24 2010-10-09
10011 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "then the UA should obtain the resource" should say WHEN rel=stylesheet obtains the resource (when the element is created?) 2010-06-24 2010-10-04
10012 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Grammatical typo at the end: "Notice the user of footer to give information [in|before] each comment" 2010-06-25 2010-10-04
10013 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Details missing regarding contenteditable 2010-06-25 2010-10-04
10015 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA longdesc URL checking 2010-06-25 2014-02-10
10016 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA longdesc and @role (ARIA) 2010-06-25 2014-02-10
10017 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA longdesc and @aria-describedby (ARIA) 2010-06-25 2010-12-01
10018 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Webkit and firefox implement networkState 2010-06-26 2010-10-04
10019 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Native user agent support for exposing longdesc to all users 2010-06-26 2014-02-10
10020 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK s/The WebSRTs format/The WebSRT format/? 2010-06-26 2010-10-04
10024 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK A WebSRT cue identifier presumably needs to be followed by a WebSRT line terminator. This is not mentioned. 2010-06-28 2010-10-04
10026 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Scope attribute for TD 2010-06-28 2010-10-04
10029 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA I don't know where the error is only thing I know that in 3 different types of browsers this page runs slower than molasses 2010-06-29 2010-10-09
10043 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Why are true and false not allowed? 2010-06-29 2010-10-04
10044 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Should allow the SCOPE attribute on TD elements so do not have to create a class to override the TH element styles set automatically by browsers. 2010-06-29 2010-10-04
10045 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Is the AXIS attribute going to be supported? If so, should be applicable to TH and TD elements. 2010-06-29 2010-10-04
10047 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT HTML5 parser possible compat problem with pages that use MathML elements in <mi>, <mo>, etc 2010-06-29 2010-10-04
10049 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA ололо, ололо, я увидел нло. обоссаца! 2010-06-29 2010-10-09
10050 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Q should be quotation or "quote." Otherwise footer whould be "F" and Header should be "H." 2010-06-29 2010-10-04
10054 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Suggestions for HTML5 2010-06-30 2010-10-04
10055 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK </html> and </body> in "in foreign content" cause severe badness 2010-06-30 2010-10-04
10057 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I do not like the "or do nothing" part, as the label is an really good aid for aiming at small form elemnts like a checkbox or radiobutton. 2010-07-01 2010-10-04
10061 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT rt and rp elements end tags should not be allowed to be omitted 2010-07-01 2010-10-04
10062 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "If the attribute is specified, the attribute's value must be the ID of a . . ." No algorithm is given for what it means to "be the ID" of an element. 2010-07-01 2010-10-04
10063 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Foster Parenting Paragraph is confusing 2010-07-02 2010-10-04
10066 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE replace section 3.2.6 with the alternative spec text provided (ARIA) 2010-07-02 2013-10-23
10067 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED this only lists entities whose replacement text is a single character, for example many of the negated operators, for example 2010-07-02 2010-10-04
10068 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Suggest making noscript obsolete but conforming 2010-07-02 2010-10-04
10069 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Structured clone algorithm should throw something more informative than NOT_SUPPORTED_ERR 2010-07-02 2010-10-04
10071 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED there should be a 'stop()' method or a 'clear()' method to clear the currently playing media because pause() doesnt clear it and setting the src to an empty string or null doesnt work 2010-07-03 2010-10-04
10077 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT The <embed> should support an alt attribute. While the embedded content should provide for accessilibility of the embedded object, the developer doesn't always have control over those content, some embeddable formats are inherently less accessible, and th 2010-07-04 2010-10-04
10078 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Step 2.2 of "in body" "any other end tag" seems wrong. 2010-07-04 2010-10-04
10079 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Step 2.2 of "in body" "any other end tag" seems wrong. 2010-07-04 2010-10-22
10080 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "in body" insertion mode, "any other end tag", step 2.2 seems wrong. 2010-07-04 2010-10-22
10081 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Okay, so could you add a note explaining what kind of active Document is *not* "fully active"? After reading very carefully for a few minutes and pondering a bit, I *think* it would be a Document that is the active Document of its browsing context, but w 2010-07-05 2010-10-04
10082 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE s/then the name argument/then the target argument/ 2010-07-05 2010-10-04
10087 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Replace "Obsolete but conforming" by "Deprecated" 2010-07-05 2010-10-04
10090 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Removing then, or removing the entire sandbox attribute" -- should "then" be "them"? 2010-07-05 2010-10-04
10091 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT As far as I can tell, nothing specifies what the intrinsic width/height/ratio for iframes should be. You'd assume it's the height/width/ratio of the document, but of course that's wrong unless the iframe is seamless. 2010-07-05 2010-10-04
10092 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "The transitive closure of all the browsing contexts that are directly reachable browsing contexts forms a unit of related browsing contexts." Since a browsing context is not a directly reachable browsing context of itself, this means that top-level brow 2010-07-05 2010-10-04
10093 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Typo: "either the element's end tag is parsed on the parser detects" should be "is parsed _or_ the parser detects" 2010-07-05 2010-10-04
10095 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT "isindex" is ignored inside a form 2010-07-06 2010-10-04
10096 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Adoption Agency 6.4 and 6.5 should be re-ordered 2010-07-06 2010-10-04
10098 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Stray comma or typo in "in cell" "end tag whos name is 'table'" case 2010-07-06 2010-10-04
10099 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "Updates the current entry in the session histor to have" -- "histor" should be "history". 2010-07-06 2010-10-04
10101 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT What does non-normative mean? 2010-07-07 2010-10-04
10102 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Can an option element be disabled by a fieldset@disabled ancestor? 2010-07-07 2010-10-04
10103 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE s/that its namedItem() method returns an HTMLCollection object/that its namedItem() method returns an *HTMLAllCollection* object/ 2010-07-07 2010-10-04
10105 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE What about optgroup[disabled]>option? Not :disabled? 2010-07-07 2010-10-04
10106 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Define setter for selected 2010-07-07 2010-10-04
10112 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT should element.click() also set focus on the clicked element? This is not clear from the steps given for the click() method 2010-07-08 2010-10-04
10114 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Rather than having inline documentation for external scripts, what would be infinitely more useful would be the contents of a script tag with a src attribute should be executed upon the complete loading and execution of the remote script. Therefore <scrip 2010-07-08 2010-10-04
10115 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL EOF handling in foreign content needs to change the insertion mode 2010-07-08 2010-10-22
10116 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTMLFrameElement is missing contentWindow attribute 2010-07-09 2010-10-04
10117 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Tag name state algorithm has mis-ordered step 2010-07-09 2011-11-11
10118 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL in foreign content "current node is not an element in the HTML namespace" algorithm is wrong 2010-07-09 2010-10-22
10122 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE re: resolving a step mismatch, it would be good to state that if two values are equally near to round up 2010-07-09 2010-10-04
10133 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Use of this element requires passing a contextID string to getContext, but the standard does prescribe either (a) an enumeration of valid contextIDs or (b) a method to enumerat the contextIDs supported by a given UA. (b) should be a requirement of the sta 2010-07-11 2010-10-04
10136 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE I would love some clarification about the DOM tree example. Why is there no text node between DOCTYPE and <html>? Between <html> and <head>? Two at the end of <body>? I'm very picky :-) 2010-07-12 2010-10-04
10137 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE What criteria should browsers use to determine whether a URL's hash fragment differs from the previous one? Should the comparison be case-sensitive? Currently, all implementations of hashchange use case-sensitive comparisons except IE8, which uses a case- 2010-07-12 2010-10-04
10139 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA active form element markers are never removed 2010-07-13 2010-12-01
10140 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Not possible to ever leave "secondary insertion mode" 2010-07-13 2010-10-04
10145 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA lop lop lop lop loplop 2010-07-13 2010-10-04
10146 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Labelability of hidden form inputs unclear 2010-07-13 2010-10-04
10147 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Allow td in thead 2010-07-13 2010-10-04
10157 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Whitespace between <head> and <body> should be ignored 2010-07-13 2010-10-04
10158 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT HTML5 parser: comments after </body> and after </html> should be put in body 2010-07-13 2010-10-04
10164 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Get rid of RadioNodeList 2010-07-14 2010-10-04
10166 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Where is the <datagrid>? 2010-07-14 2010-10-04
10170 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I really think it should be possible to nest the ul and ol elements using normal tag standard. whey not make it possible to nest it by allowing ul/ol inside other ul/ol tags, just like any other li elements? 2010-07-15 2010-10-04
10171 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Button is in the list twice 2010-07-15 2010-10-04
10172 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT nofollow/noreferrer not allowed on <link> 2010-07-15 2010-10-04
10173 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Rendering of replaced content and foreign content 2010-07-15 2010-10-04
10177 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Typo in 'An end tag whose tag name is "p"': "sbutton cope" 2010-07-15 2010-10-04
10178 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE In the DOM tree visualisation the doctype node is presented weird: The string "html" is marked up like a reference to the definition of the HTML element; like it is done with all following nodes. That just leads to a doubled link to the HTML element defin 2010-07-15 2010-10-04
10181 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA its not valid according to newer version of xhtml 2010-07-16 2010-10-04
10184 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Please spec HTMLOptionsCollection.selectedIndex 2010-07-16 2010-10-04
10185 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE I would like to suggest that "4.8.1.1.9 A Key Part of the content" is moved up, so it becomes 4.8.1.1.1 i.e. it is the first subsection. This subsection seems to be the most important or dominant case, whereas the others are important, but are exceptions? 2010-07-16 2010-10-04
10186 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE typo: e.g. because it a simple movie file - s/it a/it is a/ 2010-07-16 2010-10-04
10187 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Should say "...objects that browsing context..." 2010-07-16 2010-10-04
10188 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA i just demo 2010-07-17 2010-10-09
10189 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA i just demo 2010-07-17 2010-10-09
10190 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA i just demo 2010-07-17 2010-10-09
10191 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA how to use 2010-07-17 2010-10-09
10192 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE item() should return Element, unlike namedItem 2010-07-17 2010-10-04
10195 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED length function does not work for SVG circle and line elements 2010-07-17 2010-10-04
10196 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Relationship to xml:id 2010-07-18 2010-10-04
10197 HTML WG pre-LC1 contributor CLOS WONT xml:space is not listed as a global attribute 2010-07-18 2010-10-04
10198 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The Gregorian is not a Universal standard for calendars. HTML5 must provide ways for other calendar types. e.g. The "Hijri" calendar is used throughout in Arab countries. The "Persian" calendar is used in Iran, Afghanistan and Pakistan. The "Hebrew" calen 2010-07-18 2011-12-08
10200 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA just a test 2010-07-19 2010-10-09
10201 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL typo: "1. Let current outlinee" 2010-07-19 2010-10-04
10202 HTML WG pre-LC1 contributor RESO FIXE use of "codecs" parameter 2010-07-19 2011-04-12
10204 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED The algorithm is unclear here whether we mean the "current node" at this point in time or the "current node" at the time the insertion occurs (which might be different). As an example, consider "<table><p><p>Foo". I think you mean the current element at 2010-07-19 2010-10-04
10210 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I prefer to have some legacy content show up faulty than to introduce an artificial complexity for the generations to come 2010-07-20 2010-10-04
10212 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Redundant? This is implied by the heading. 2010-07-20 2010-10-04
10215 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT not sure what's mean by "User agents must _synchronously_ run the focusing steps". Does this mean that the event handlers involved in steps 1 and and 3 must return before further steps in the procedure can be taken? A reasonable alternative interpretation 2010-07-21 2010-10-04
10216 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE When inserting a <form> element in table we need to set the form element pointer to point to the element created. 2010-07-21 2010-10-04
10217 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE EOF after foreign content can cause crash 2010-07-21 2010-10-04
10219 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL "in sbutton cope" 2010-07-21 2010-10-22
10220 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK button already is in the elements listed above, so "in button scope" is the same as "in scope" 2010-07-21 2010-10-04
10221 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Always coalesce adjacent text nodes even in the case where the previous node was not the one last inserted by the parser. 2010-07-21 2010-10-04
10222 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE button appears twice in the list of special elements 2010-07-21 2010-10-04
10223 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Presumably button shouldn't appear in this list given that we have a notion of "in button scope" which explicitly adds button to this list... 2010-07-21 2010-10-04
10224 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE please add IDs to each attribute row in "List of event handler content attributes" table 2010-07-22 2010-10-04
10225 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT ugly prefix "href", why not use the lang directly? 2010-07-22 2010-10-04
10226 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Typo: "Updates the current entry in the session histor to have..." s/histor/history/ --@miketaylr 2010-07-22 2010-10-04
10227 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT It'd be nice to have a collected IDL in an appendix. 2010-07-22 2010-10-04
10228 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE write-neutralized is a horrible, horrible name 2010-07-22 2010-10-04
10232 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE There is no "|selected| attribute is a boolean attribute" 2010-07-24 2010-10-14
10237 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA hi hello how are you 2010-07-26 2010-10-09
10239 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT How about using file-extensions instead of mime-types? It would allow application-specific files to be set as allowed. 2010-07-26 2010-10-04
10240 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Just setting the <script> to "already started" doesn't prevent it from running if we then immediately "run" it. 2010-07-27 2010-10-04
10241 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The platform specific activation behavior does not work in practice. E.g. http://us.starcraft2.com/dominion/entrance-exam-qna.xml relies on a click event for a display:none input element. The Web is the platform so we should just standardize on that :-) 2010-07-27 2010-10-04
10243 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED It should register Refresh: HTTP header field, as wiki-registered pragma extensions are forced to do 2010-07-28 2010-10-04
10244 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The processing is not defined if the <ruby> content model is violated (e.g. if there are multiple <rt> elements, more than 2 <rp> elements, mis-ordered <rp> elements, and so forth. 2010-07-28 2010-10-04
10245 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Specify the exception that the case-insensitivity of the type attribute does not apply to the type attribute on ol elements 2010-07-28 2010-10-04
10246 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Add "/* case-insensitive */" marker to selectors for [type=disc], [type=circle] and [type=square] 2010-07-28 2010-10-04
10247 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE What should happen when the URL to be fetched is a mailto: URL or some other weird scheme. (Mostly curious in relation to EventSource, but it applies elsewhere too.) 2010-07-28 2010-10-04
10250 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT why must context menus not reflect changes in the DOM? Maybe some browsers want to always show the possible actions for an element. In order to do this they would have to regularly fire the contextmenu event to update it reflecting changes in the DOM. 2010-07-28 2010-10-04
10251 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Psuedo-Cascade of Multiple Accesskeys Definable for an Individual Element 2010-07-28 2010-10-04
10252 HTML WG pre-LC1 chaals CLOS MOVE HTML5 hard-binds "Action" to accesskey key-press 2010-07-28 2014-05-01
10253 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA doesn't say anything except what the container type is, and even a type like 2010-07-29 2010-10-09
10254 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Missing word in "The address element" section 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10255 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT address element needs to apply more granularly 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10256 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA 3.2.2 Elements in the DOM 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10257 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Meta charset sniffing need to resolve aliases before checking UTF-16ness 2010-07-29 2010-12-01
10258 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Spec should be more careful about UTF-16, UTF-16BE and UTF-16LE 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10259 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make it clearer that <dt> can be used for questions and <dd> for answers (maybe move away from the terminology "name-value group"?) 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10260 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Meta charset handling during the parse should special-case UTF-16 and reject non-ASCII supersets 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10262 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT autocomplete attribute seams to do more than it should. There should be a 'confidential' attribute that will do all that is mention here and autocomplete=off would only disable autocomplete, but let browsers remember the value for back button. 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10264 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED This paragraph is phrased awkwardly 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10265 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Should this be "conversation"? 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10266 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "contexts in which this element may be used:" should read "where flow content or phrasing content is expected" 2010-07-29 2010-10-04
10267 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA What happens if you delete an attribute? For the following test case, Chrome outputs "string undefined", while Firefox and Opera give "string string": data:text/html,<!doctype html><script>var el = document.createElement("a"); var type = typeof el.id; de 2010-07-30 2010-10-04
10274 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK The sentence starting "On setting, if the new value is true" seems to be out of place. Also raising a syntax_err is not web compatible and breaks at least TinyMCE. 2010-07-30 2010-10-04
10276 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE change spellcheck IDL attribute back to boolean 2010-07-31 2010-10-04
10278 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE element.hidden doesn't always return the Hidden facet; e.g. on <label>s. We should make that clearer. 2010-07-31 2010-10-04
10279 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE please add "interactive" to domintro; add xref for "readystatechange" event 2010-08-01 2010-10-04
10280 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "the user agent must associate ... ***before*** inserting it wherever it is to be inserted." - does this imply the insertion might change the form owner by invoking "reset the form owner" algorithm? If so, please make it clearer. 2010-08-01 2010-10-04
10281 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Confusion bug in space ship game example: "Notice how the hyphenated attribute name becomes capitalized in the API." The word "capitalized" may confuse authors because it usually means something else than camel-cased. I suggest to use "camel-cased" instea 2010-08-01 2010-10-04
10282 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Typo: "overrride" 2010-08-01 2010-10-04
10283 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Restrict the permittance to use the META charset elemetn in XHTML5 2010-08-02 2011-01-21
10284 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA fuck and ya very fucking lessons...I was dosing...cant you make them interactive?? 2010-08-02 2010-10-04
10285 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA line 3 dijdw wow 2010-08-03 2010-10-04
10286 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL line 3 dijdw wow 2010-08-03 2010-10-04
10287 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA The definition for an ambiguous ampersand excludes known named character references, but fails to exclude valid decimal or hex numeric character references. 2010-08-03 2010-10-04
10289 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Limit to only known values 2010-08-03 2010-10-04
10290 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The type attribute needs to be restricted to only known values to match browser behavior. 2010-08-03 2010-10-04
10292 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT For XML documents, attributes from other namespaces (##other) should be allowed, but not validated (lax), on all html elements. This is to allow validating using XML schema for custom attributes (dojo:type, dojo:attach-point) 2010-08-04 2010-10-04
10296 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL your page is unusable! Freezes firefox 3 on Windows and Mac! 2010-08-05 2010-10-04
10297 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Update the definition from "a line break" to "a text-level thematic break." 2010-08-05 2010-10-04
10298 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Update the definition of BR from "a line break" to "a text-level thematic break." 2010-08-05 2010-10-04
10301 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE HTMLOptionElement.text should not be identical to .textContent - causes interop issues with web content 2010-08-05 2010-10-21
10308 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL wouldn't a minlength attrib be good to prevent 1 or 2 letter searches? 2010-08-06 2010-10-22
10311 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED this is a nice article, if this article can also contain the server side image mapping example it would be better 2010-08-07 2010-10-04
10312 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED "transport layer" -> something else; in TCP/IP context "transport layer" usually refers to TCP or UDP 2010-08-07 2010-10-04
10314 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "in cell" (secondary) insertion mode shows strange behavior for e.g. <table><tr><td><svg><td></td><td>, <table><tr><td><svg><tbody></tbody> 2010-08-08 2010-10-04
10315 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT please allow "command" and "base" in "in head noscript" insertion mode so all void elements that might be handled in head-related insertion modes are treated in the same manner, which would simplify parser implementation a little 2010-08-08 2010-10-04
10317 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Wow....This is awesome 2010-08-08 2010-10-09
10318 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED time element shouldn't alter the display value 2010-08-08 2010-10-04
10330 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL I guess this element would be helpful to user net attached printers and other devices like that 2010-08-09 2010-10-04
10331 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Clarify meaning of "defined to contain a URL" and "defined to contain one or more URLs" 2010-08-09 2010-10-04
10332 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS INVA Shipping browsers don't have form.action reflect the DOM attribute exactly. Specifically, if the content attribute is the empty string, they generally return "" on an IDL get, not the current address. This contradicts the spec, but it would be confusing 2010-08-09 2010-10-04
10333 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Spec form.encoding := form.enctype 2010-08-09 2010-10-04
10334 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Bad grammar here: should probably be "The size IDL attribute *is* limited to . . ." 2010-08-09 2010-10-04
10338 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE End tag of </td> or </th> in "in cell" mode wrongly asserts current node will be "tr" 2010-08-09 2010-10-04
10340 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The [OverrideBuiltins] annotation on the Window interface IDL block should be removed because it breaks sites 2010-08-10 2010-10-04
10343 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE width and height are said to be DOMStrings in this interface, but in fact Chrome, Firefox, and Opera all output "number" on this test. data:text/html,<!doctype html><script>alert(typeof document.createElement("video").width);</script> 2010-08-10 2010-10-04
10344 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL col.span, colgroup.span, textarea.cols, textarea.rows should not be limited to only non-negative numbers greater than zero 2010-08-10 2010-10-04
10345 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT hspace and vspace on HTMLImageElement are signed long in DOM 2 HTML. Was there a good reason for the incompatible change to unsigned long? 2010-08-11 2010-10-04
10346 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Should define 'class' better 2010-08-11 2010-10-04
10350 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Do not reward Microsoft's willful violation of standards by "codifying" them in this document 2010-08-12 2010-10-04
10351 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE """The stack of open elements cannot have both a td and a th element in table scope at the same time, nor can it have neither when the insertion mode is "in cell".""" - the second part of this is wrong in the fragment case 2010-08-12 2010-10-04
10352 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The range of unsigned long should be [0, 2147483647], since no browser allows setting to values outside that range 2010-08-12 2010-10-04
10353 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA good work? no no amaizing work :) 2010-08-12 2010-10-09
10354 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE What happens if you do an IDL get on size for <select size=0>? Does it return 0 or 1? 2010-08-12 2010-10-04
10355 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Kill most or all of the special IDL attributes for marquee 2010-08-12 2010-12-30
10358 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL play in html 2010-08-13 2010-10-22
10359 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL play in html 2010-08-13 2010-10-22
10360 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL play in html 2010-08-13 2010-10-22
10361 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL play in html 2010-08-13 2010-10-22
10362 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA play in html 2010-08-13 2010-10-09
10363 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA i see it 2010-08-13 2010-10-09
10364 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA If the element has a src attribute, the closing tag should be forbidden, and if it doesn't have a src element, should be required. 2010-08-14 2010-10-04
10365 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT popstate event fires after onload (first page visit) -- intended behavior? would be annoying if there was a script that ajax loaded a page at onpopstate, and hand typing in a url, the page is returned by the server, and then onpopstate fires after onload, 2010-08-14 2010-11-13
10366 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT please ban <input type=file> if the form's enctype is application/x-www-form-urlencoded, as this seems an authoring error 2010-08-14 2010-10-04
10367 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE align=absmiddle should be case-insensitive 2010-08-14 2010-10-04
10369 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED MSIE has had a window object since probably before IE4 (my knowledge does not go back any further). 2010-08-15 2010-10-04
10370 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE RFC 3339 date-time format, which looks very similar to HTML's date and time strings, gives special semantics to "-00:00" time zone. HTML should either follow the convention or disallow use of "-00:00" time zone. 2010-08-15 2010-10-04
10371 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "dataformatas on ..., span, table" -> "dataformatas on ..., span, _and_ table _elements_" 2010-08-15 2010-10-04
10372 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Authors should ensure that in each set of radio buttons that one is initially "on". Because some have made bad UI choices you should not recant this rule! At all times, exactly one of the radio buttons in a set is checked. Radio button Only one item 2010-08-15 2010-10-04
10373 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA getting some serious lag on this page 2010-08-15 2010-10-09
10375 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Please remove language from appVersion. UAs are removing that information to reduce fingerprinting. 2010-08-16 2010-10-04
10380 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Description of IDL sets for enumerated attributes does not appear to match reality 2010-08-16 2010-10-04
10383 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK DOCTYPE token: The text here seems to require lower-case "html" as the node type; i.e. "<!DOCTYPE HTML>" would be invalid. This contradicts Section 10.1.1, which says both are valid (and in fact gives the latter for all its examples). 2010-08-17 2010-10-04
10388 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Canonical case for GET/POST/PUT/DELETE should be lowercase instead of uppercase, to match browsers 2010-08-17 2010-10-04
10395 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA test test test 2010-08-19 2010-10-09
10399 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA base64 def in algorithm for put to data URI 2010-08-19 2010-12-01
10404 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK pre needs class=idl 2010-08-19 2010-10-04
10405 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Should be "</p>" in <p><button>Submit order</button><p> 2010-08-19 2010-10-04
10408 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Implemented in Chromium per http://code.google.com/p/chromium/issues/detail?id=13505 2010-08-20 2010-10-09
10409 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Adoption agency + SVG bug 2010-08-20 2010-10-04
10410 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED On getting, should the UA percent-decode document.location.hash? It's not clear. 2010-08-20 2010-10-07
10411 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Why are all the RFCs referenced in .txt versions? The HTML versions are more convenient (and it's silly for HTML to avoid the HTML versions!). 2010-08-20 2010-10-12
10412 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT restriction of "bookmark" to <a>/<area> is arbitrary 2010-08-21 2010-10-04
10413 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED width attribute is necesary in col elements when styles are disabled 2010-08-22 2010-10-04
10414 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT What is up with that whitespace inside the tagnames? 2010-08-24 2010-10-04
10415 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE This is the only place where online and offline events are referenced in this section and they are marked as UA text. If authors hide UA text they won't see anything about online/offline events in this section 2010-08-24 2010-10-04
10417 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE the example images for DETAILS (osx finder file info?) ... does this indicate form fields could be marked up with details, using summary for the label? would summary > label be required for accessibility? if so, might be good to include sample code (promo 2010-08-24 2010-10-04
10418 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Scoping element inside e.g. <mi> causes insertion mode to switch to secondary insertion mode too early 2010-08-24 2010-10-04
10419 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <video> should allow muted as a content attribute 2010-08-24 2011-04-13
10421 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Setting media element's src and autoplay attribute may expose a race 2010-08-24 2010-10-04
10424 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE Permit <details> to take "roles that use the aria-expanded state" 2010-08-25 2010-12-15
10427 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Object should be a little less scoping 2010-08-25 2010-11-03
10429 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Is it still correct to have a 2px inset border on an seamless iframe? 2010-08-25 2010-10-04
10433 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA Google Chrome Search 2010-08-25 2010-10-04
10434 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Mint a link type for pointing to long descriptions (rel="longdesc") 2010-08-25 2010-12-15
10435 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK example code uses @disabled but introductory text uses @readonly 2010-08-25 2010-10-04
10437 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The pushState algorithm doesn't save the scroll position of the original history entry, but it should. See Mozilla bug 590573. 2010-08-25 2010-10-04
10438 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO WONT math should be changed changed from no role to "math" role 2010-08-26 2013-01-21
10440 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO WONT menu type=context should have "menu" role 2010-08-26 2010-12-22
10441 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO WONT <link> that represents a hyperlink should probably have no role by default 2010-08-26 2010-12-15
10442 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA current playback position 2010-08-26 2010-10-09
10443 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA good and clear..... 2010-08-26 2010-10-04
10444 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO LATE ARIA section does not list elements that have no default role or role restrictions 2010-08-26 2013-01-21
10445 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Certain elements with no role should have that as a strong semantic 2010-08-26 2010-12-15
10446 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Consider limiting the roles of certain media and plugin elements 2010-08-26 2010-12-15
10447 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE <output> should not have a status role by default after all 2010-08-26 2010-12-15
10448 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE Consider broadening the set of allowed roles for command elements 2010-08-26 2013-01-21
10449 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO WONT Consider allowing various command-like ARIA roles for h1-h6 2010-08-26 2013-01-21
10450 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE Allow lists to be used as menus or tab sets 2010-08-26 2010-12-15
10451 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO LATE Consider restricting the roles allowed for the label element 2010-08-26 2013-01-21
10452 HTML WG pre-LC1 cyns RESO WONT Consider documenting attributes that map to ARIA properties in a separate table 2010-08-26 2013-01-21
10455 HTML WG pre-LC1 Paul.Cotton CLOS WONT Mint a href description attribute for the img element 2010-08-26 2013-04-16
10456 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Should not emit ]] or ] when ]]EOF or ]EOF appears in the CDATA section state 2010-08-26 2010-10-04
10458 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT legacy-color: should do the empty string check after whitespace trimming 2010-08-26 2010-10-04
10460 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Proposal about doctype. I think correct doctype must be <!DOCTYPE html5.0> or <!DOCTYPE html5> or <!DOCTYPE html5.> or <!DOCTYPE html 5>. Not <!DOCTYPE html> because unknown version of HTML. (Eugene.Mirny@gmail.com) 2010-08-27 2010-10-04
10461 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE This algorithm needs more detail on how the data is to be actually encoded. E.g. does it depend on the document encoding, etc. 2010-08-27 2010-10-12
10462 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve CLOS LATE merge ARIA mapping tables and list 2010-08-27 2013-10-09
10463 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO WONT provide a comprehensive HTML5 to accessibility API mapping reference 2010-08-27 2011-01-22
10465 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL provide correct aria mapping and role info for the table element 2010-08-27 2010-12-14
10467 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT provide headings in the WAI-ARIA section of the spec to make it easier to understand 2010-08-27 2010-12-14
10477 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA this is terrible 2010-08-27 2010-10-04
10478 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE modify table, tr and td roles 2010-08-28 2010-12-15
10479 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE add role=radiogroup to details element 2010-08-28 2010-12-15
10480 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT add role="presentation" on the ASCII fish image 2010-08-28 2011-01-11
10481 HTML WG pre-LC1 xn--mlform-iua RESO FIXE Default role of <IMG> should be "img" 2010-08-28 2012-11-29
10482 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO LATE Specify how @usemap affects role (of <img> and <object>) 2010-08-28 2013-01-21
10483 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED <figcaption> should be considered the caption of <figure> _itself_ 2010-08-28 2011-01-13
10484 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO WONT default roles for figcaption and caption: Make it simple to achieve accessibility 2010-08-29 2013-01-21
10485 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL The img element with non-empty alt should default to the img aria role 2010-08-29 2011-01-11
10487 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Allow radio buttons and checkboxes to be used as radio and check menu items respectively 2010-08-29 2010-10-04
10490 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "If node is not an element with the same tag name as the token, then this is a parse error." <- Tag name comparison must use ASCII case-insensitive match 2010-08-29 2010-10-04
10491 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE r5300 change breaks "<svg><title>(EOF)" 2010-08-29 2010-10-04
10492 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Should "<table>a<tr>b" generate one or two text nodes? 2010-08-29 2010-10-04
10494 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI FIXE modify aria example and fix spelling 2010-08-29 2011-01-11
10495 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA default role(s) "inheriting" for figure - common use cases 2010-08-29 2010-12-01
10496 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE fix error in aria conformance checker advice 2010-08-29 2010-12-14
10497 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve CLOS WORK What happens to role of <img alt="non-empty"> inside a <figure role="img">? 2010-08-29 2011-01-21
10498 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA you go do that html5 stuff, you super nerds. 2010-08-29 2010-10-04
10499 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE I would like to see an example of a cache manifest using URLs with leading slashes, or full URLs, just to make clear this is allowed. 2010-08-29 2010-10-04
10500 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA The paragraph tags aren't closed. See <caption><p>Table 1.<p> but no </p>'s anywhere. 2010-08-30 2010-10-04
10501 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE xref "presentational hint" in the wrap=off case 2010-08-30 2010-10-04
10505 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED A dataTransfer object should be able to be passed to an <input type="file" id="recipient"> object to simplify form processing where ajax is not required or desired. 2010-08-30 2010-10-04
10511 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE [scroll] fragment identifier algo should use scroll element into view 2010-08-30 2010-10-13
10512 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA im trying to make two buttons, on top of each other, when i click or hover on either one, i want the a blank button with info to appear under the one i clicked on. pushing the other one down, please help. Julio.Avila@live.com 2010-08-31 2010-10-04
10515 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT s/nearest positive infinity./nearest to positive infinity./ 2010-08-31 2010-10-04
10517 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE input.size should default to 20 (per IE8/WebKit), not 0 (per Gecko/Presto/current spec) 2010-08-31 2010-10-04
10519 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Parser-inserted script must lose its parser-insertedness if the 'already started' flag does not get set when the parser tries to run the script 2010-09-01 2010-10-04
10520 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The script's 'for' and 'event' attributes should be checked after setting 'already started' 2010-09-01 2010-10-04
10521 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Should say explicitly that parser-initiated script-running fails without setting 'already started' if the script is no longer in the document when the parser tries to run the script 2010-09-01 2010-10-07
10522 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Consider making iframe, noframes or noembed as the ancestor of a script prevent execution 2010-09-01 2010-10-04
10523 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Scripting disabled check should happen after setting 'already started' 2010-09-01 2010-10-04
10526 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA I'm sorry, but misinterpretation for compatibility is simply wrong. Why do we have standards again? 2010-09-01 2010-10-04
10528 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Presumably we should resolve URL relative to some base URL... 2010-09-02 2010-10-04
10529 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA dsdfasd dsdfa da sa da 2010-09-02 2010-10-04
10530 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA dfdsfaaf da dfdsf 2010-09-02 2010-10-04
10535 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Don't throw WRONG_DOCUMENT_ERRs 2010-09-02 2010-10-04
10536 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Don't throw WRONG_DOCUMENT_ERRs 2010-09-02 2010-10-04
10537 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT document.readyState for aborted parser 2010-09-02 2010-10-04
10538 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED "values… values" probably typo 2010-09-03 2010-10-04
10539 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Please add a note about script moving a script that blocks the parser 2010-09-03 2010-10-11
10540 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Please say that 'list of scripts that will execute when the document has finished parsing' is coupled with the parser--not the document 2010-09-03 2010-10-04
10541 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Make parser-inserted scripts delay the load event of the document whose active parser the inserter parser is 2010-09-03 2010-10-04
10542 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Please associate a "style sheet blocking scripts" with its inserter-parser--not with it's Document 2010-09-03 2010-11-11
10543 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Rename a "style sheet blocking scripts" to a "style sheet that is blocking scripts" 2010-09-03 2010-10-04
10544 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED The "following components" does not include li, label, etc. 2010-09-03 2010-10-04
10545 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED this non-dismissable "Last call for comments" popover is fucking obnoxious 2010-09-03 2010-10-04
10546 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE It looks like at least some browsers restrict legend display values to "block" 2010-09-04 2010-10-13
10547 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The rendering requirements for legend in fieldset need to change if the legend is floated or positioned 2010-09-04 2010-10-04
10548 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA canvas is undefined Line 27 2010-09-04 2010-10-09
10549 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Please remove PARSE_ERR and SERIALIZE_ERR as they are from DOM L&S which should be nuked at some point. 2010-09-04 2010-10-04
10550 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA hey you have been hacked by reynaldo vm Warning page not html ,,,caution never try to upload your own life ,,bghhdsll hacker 2010-09-04 2010-10-09
10551 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT r5032 breaks "<option><button><option>" (</option> implied by second <option> does not close <button>, as <button> is in the special category, and second <option> itself is never processed) 2010-09-05 2010-10-04
10552 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK input type search : onChange on plateform actions 2010-09-05 2010-10-04
10556 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Document tells people to register canvas context types at WhatWG 2010-09-06 2010-10-04
10557 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Submission as entity body can't happen for GET, can it? Yet there is a check for it, which also rejects PUT. 2010-09-06 2010-10-04
10559 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT blur() is handy, and should not be ignored 2010-09-07 2010-10-12
10561 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA jikioh nk ku 2010-09-07 2010-10-22
10563 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA ties), and must eithble="true" data-value="fruit-orange">Oranges</li> <li draggable="true" data-value="fruit-pear">Pears</li> </ol> <script> var internalDNDType = 'text/x-example'; // set thier have 2010-09-07 2010-10-09
10564 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT There is no "rightmargin" attribute. This should be "leftmargin". 2010-09-07 2010-10-04
10565 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA there is no error 2010-09-07 2010-10-09
10566 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL there is no error 2010-09-07 2010-10-22
10567 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK How will the input name be processed for multiple files? can mime/multipart "part" names be the same? 2010-09-07 2010-10-04
10575 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE It appears that parser-inserted scripts should block if an ancestor browsing context has a style sheet blocking scripts 2010-09-08 2010-11-01
10576 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA that is good. 2010-09-08 2010-10-09
10578 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Please remove the 'comment end space' state 2010-09-08 2010-10-04
10580 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Please put a comment 2010-09-08 2010-10-09
10581 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Drop the color input type 2010-09-08 2010-12-14
10587 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Please remove a redundant "still in foreign" check 2010-09-09 2010-10-04
10588 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Infinite loop with <math><mi>EOF 2010-09-09 2010-10-04
10589 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT figure and figcaption shouldn't automatically close p 2010-09-09 2010-10-04
10591 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE conflicting info for table element in aria section 2010-09-09 2010-10-05
10592 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO LATE "h1 to h6 element that does have an hgroup ancestor" not listed in ARIA section 2010-09-09 2013-01-21
10593 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK thead, tfoot and tbody conflicts in aria section 2010-09-09 2010-10-05
10594 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT conforming use of various aria attributes not specified 2010-09-09 2010-10-12
10595 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE contextmenu event should be a MouseEvent 2010-09-09 2010-10-04
10596 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Clarify what <img> represents if no@alt, no@title and NOT the sole content of a <figure>+<figcaption> element 2010-09-09 2010-10-05
10599 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Provide examples implementing these concepts. 2010-09-10 2010-10-04
10600 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Strong semantics role="presentation" for <img alt="<empty>"> is wrong or inaccurate 2010-09-10 2010-10-12
10602 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT No boundary behavior specified for playbackRate/defaultPlaybackRate 2010-09-11 2010-10-04
10603 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE Clarify what default roles UAs may assign to elements not listed in the ARIA section 2010-09-11 2010-12-14
10604 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Don't say 'empty' about @alt anywhere, say 'empty string' everywhere 2010-09-11 2010-10-12
10605 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Typo: Replace 'the alt attribute's value may be omitted' with '@alt may be omitted' 2010-09-11 2011-01-21
10606 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Define what alt="<whitespace>" means for <img> 2010-09-12 2010-12-01
10611 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL typo: outlinee should be outline. 2010-09-12 2010-10-04
10612 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The 'change' definition has no references to it. Remove it? 2010-09-12 2010-10-04
10616 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE s/a inline/an inline/ 2010-09-12 2010-10-04
10617 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA I believe <kbd><table></kbd> gets the parsing algorithm into a bad state. When we see </kbd> we process it using the rules for "any other end tag" of the inbody mode, which pops off the table and the kbd element from the stack of open elements. However, 2010-09-12 2010-12-01
10620 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Browsers recognize five font groups 2010-09-13 2010-10-09
10621 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Processing EOF InForeignContent mode can cause an infinite loop if we don't switch the insertion model to the secondary insertion mode. Suppose the input is <svg><title>. Now, we won't pop anything off the stack of open elements. The insertion mode wil 2010-09-13 2010-10-22
10625 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Spec should cover stopping parsing on location.href = "foo" 2010-09-13 2010-12-07
10626 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT non-normative? this sounds confusing and vauge... 2010-09-13 2010-10-04
10627 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Where this says "Number object" and "String object", it should say "number" and "string". Normal strings and numbers are not objects. A "String object" is actually a different kind of thing (rarely used). 2010-09-13 2010-10-04
10628 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Where this says "Number object" and "String object", it should say "number" and "string". Normal strings and numbers are not objects. A "String object" is actually a different kind of thing (rarely used). 2010-09-13 2010-10-22
10629 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE 2.2.2 mentions the itemprop attribute without it being defined. 2010-09-14 2010-10-04
10630 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Potential spec bug: the spec doesn't match IE for <div><body><frameset>. IE sets frameset-ok to "not ok" for <body> in "in body". See http://software.hixie.ch/utilities/js/live-dom-viewer/saved/631 vs http://software.hixie.ch/utilities/js/live-dom-viewer/ 2010-09-14 2010-10-04
10631 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Named access on the Window object doesn't work for XHTML documents in WebKit, Firefox, or (trivially) IE. Dumping objects in the global scope is sad face. Can we restrict this behavior to HTML documents? (The bug for implementing this in XHTML was rece 2010-09-14 2011-12-10
10633 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Minimums for timer granularity should be left to the user agent - different form factors have different power requirements 2010-09-15 2010-10-04
10634 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Please update the base64 reference to the latest relevant RFC 2010-09-15 2010-10-04
10635 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE I could be reading the spec wrong, but are the default flow behaviors for these elements undefined? Will an article be rendered as a block-level element, or have no effect on flow at all? I've found several top-teir web-dev ref sites which all have differ 2010-09-15 2010-10-04
10636 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL I could be reading the spec wrong, but are the default flow behaviors for these elements undefined? Will an article be rendered as a block-level element, or have no effect on flow at all? I've found several top-teir web-dev ref sites which all have differ 2010-09-15 2010-10-22
10638 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Unclear behavior specified for negative 'dimensional attributes' 2010-09-15 2010-10-04
10639 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Cross Document Messaging 2010-09-15 2010-10-09
10641 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA let us know 2010-09-17 2010-10-04
10642 HTML WG pre-LC1 john VERI WONT No alternative text description for video key frame (poster) 2010-09-17 2013-06-05
10644 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT over-complex characterization of link types 2010-09-17 2010-10-04
10645 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE <dialog> Add support for in-page dialogs 2010-09-17 2012-04-12
10648 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE "When the relevant content attributes are absent, the IDL attributes must return zero." Surely this is redundant with the rules for reflecting doubles? 2010-09-17 2010-10-04
10649 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA drag and drop 2010-09-18 2010-10-05
10656 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The spec says that for scripts the BOM overrides the HTTP charset 2010-09-20 2010-10-04
10657 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT integration of "aria-autocomplete" with the various autocompletion mechanisms in html5 2010-09-20 2012-08-24
10659 HTML WG pre-LC1 contributor RESO WONT GET -> "Mutate action" 2010-09-20 2011-01-12
10660 HTML WG pre-LC1 mike RESO FIXE use < and > and not &#8592; and &#8594; to indicate previous and next 2010-09-20 2010-12-05
10661 HTML WG pre-LC1 contributor RESO WONT use an ISO 639-2 specified language for HTML5 documents 2010-09-20 2015-01-12
10665 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT These tables should include obsolete elements somewhere, for the benefit of implementers. Or at least some such index should be provided. It's annoying to have no easily-used index like this when writing tests. 2010-09-21 2010-10-04
10666 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE textarea.cols should default to 20, and textarea.rows should default to 2. IE8 and WebKit do this; Opera defaults to 0 and Gecko defaults to -1. Of the three behaviors, IE/WebKit makes the most sense, and I'm submitting a patch to get Gecko to line up w 2010-09-21 2010-10-04
10672 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED the media element onplay event is not always called when the user hits the play button 2010-09-22 2010-10-04
10673 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Typo in HTMLAllCollections 2010-09-22 2010-10-04
10675 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT B implies BOLD, which is styling. Styling should be done with CSS, not with HTML markup 2010-09-22 2010-10-04
10676 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT I implies ITALIC, which is styling. Styling should be done with CSS, not with HTML markup 2010-09-22 2010-10-04
10692 HTML WG pre-LC1 contributor CLOS INVA Fix coercion to Infoset for HTML5 to correctly preserve xmlns attributes 2010-09-23 2010-12-04
10709 HTML WG pre-LC1 david100 CLOS NEED @title should be a required attribute for FRAME and IFRAME in HTML5 2010-09-23 2013-01-16
10710 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Require controls to have programatically associated names 2010-09-24 2011-08-15
10712 HTML WG pre-LC1 ma_mat40 CLOS FIXE Drag and Drop: Add an attribute to identify drop targets 2010-09-24 2010-11-02
10713 HTML WG pre-LC1 dave.null CLOS LATE Drag and Drop: Add guidance for keyboard-only interaction 2010-09-24 2013-01-16
10714 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA kinds of phrasing 2010-09-24 2010-10-09
10717 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Extensibility text mentions microdata but not RDFa 2010-09-24 2010-10-04
10718 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Remove Microdata from Acknowledgements 2010-09-24 2011-04-13
10720 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Remove modifications to Extensibility section 2010-09-24 2011-06-01
10726 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The sentence "For each article element, there must no more than one time element..." is missing the word "be" in "must be no". 2010-09-24 2010-10-04
10730 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Confusing spec text in 'media seeking' scenario 2010-09-24 2010-10-04
10735 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Use classes on b/i elements in examples 2010-09-25 2010-10-12
10738 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Insert 'data-' in the heading/table of contents (editorial) 2010-09-25 2010-10-04
10739 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The attribute table doesn't mention data-* 2010-09-25 2010-10-04
10740 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT encourage use of SHARED (vendor) prefixes: experimental--feature 2010-09-25 2010-10-04
10741 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED align @extension with @vendor--feature (Rob Ennals's ISSUE-41 prop) 2010-09-26 2010-10-04
10742 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA attributes must be taken care of 2010-09-26 2010-10-09
10743 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE This is no longer correct -> In the following fragment, however, the attribute's value is actually "?original=1©=2", not the intended "?original=1&copy=2": 2010-09-26 2010-10-11
10748 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Second example snippet is incompatible with accompanying text 2010-09-26 2010-10-18
10753 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WORK Typo: "occurance" instead of "occurrence". 2010-09-26 2010-10-04
10754 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Typo: "occurance" instead of "occurrence". 2010-09-26 2010-10-22
10755 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Typo: "occurance" instead of "occurrence". 2010-09-26 2010-10-22
10756 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Typo: "occurance" instead of "occurrence". 2010-09-26 2010-10-22
10757 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Typo: "occurance" instead of "occurrence". 2010-09-26 2010-10-04
10758 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Typo: "occurance" instead of "occurrence". 2010-09-26 2010-10-04
10759 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL Typo: "occurance" instead of "occurrence". 2010-09-26 2010-10-04
10760 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Where is the closing </header> tag in the second 4.4.8 example, "Little green guys with guns"? Confusing. 2010-09-26 2010-10-04
10761 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Where is the closing </header> tag in the second 4.4.8 example, "Little green guys with guns"? Confusing. 2010-09-26 2010-10-22
10762 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL Where is the closing </header> tag in the second 4.4.8 example, "Little green guys with guns"? Confusing. 2010-09-26 2010-10-22
10763 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS DUPL Typo: "occurance" instead of "occurrence". 2010-09-26 2010-10-04
10764 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA hello ddd ssd 2010-09-27 2010-10-09
10767 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE The <progress> and <meter> elements' value IDL attribute should be constrained by the range. Just like with <input type=range>. 2010-09-27 2010-10-07
10769 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE In the table, it says vLinkColor and aLinkColor; it should be vlinkColor and alinkColor (as in the interface). 2010-09-27 2010-10-04
10771 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE User agents disagree with each other and with the spec on rendering of multiple legends if the first one is styled 2010-09-27 2010-10-14
10772 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO MOVE accesskey and an ordered set of unique space-separated tokens 2010-09-27 2016-02-23
10773 HTML WG pre-LC1 oedipus VERI WONT accesskey should chosen from document's declared charset 2010-09-27 2011-01-18
10774 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI WONT fallback for accesskey insufficiently defined 2010-09-27 2013-10-23
10775 HTML WG pre-LC1 oedipus VERI FIXE how is user to decide which set of access keys to use? 2010-09-27 2013-10-23
10776 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT accesskey value token subsets 2010-09-27 2013-10-23
10777 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE user agent assignment of modifier keys subset of accesskey processing subset 2010-09-27 2016-02-23
10778 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS MOVE use element.accessKeyLabel to generate list of available accesskeys 2010-09-27 2016-02-23
10779 HTML WG pre-LC1 chaals CLOS WONT triggering the Action of the command via accesskey 2010-09-27 2014-02-10
10780 HTML WG pre-LC1 chaals RESO NEED reference to definition of Action insufficient for definition of accesskey 2010-09-27 2013-10-23
10781 HTML WG pre-LC1 oedipus VERI FIXE are accesskeys case sensitive? 2010-09-27 2011-01-18
10782 HTML WG pre-LC1 chaals CLOS MOVE problems with button example for accesskey 2010-09-27 2014-05-01
10783 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL change summary from an attribute to an element 2010-09-27 2010-10-22
10784 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED change summary from an attribute to an element 2010-09-27 2011-10-13
10787 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Add a way to get a File/Blob from a <canvas> 2010-09-28 2011-11-01
10793 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make the DOCTYPE by default XML-compatible: lowercase 'html' 2010-09-28 2010-10-04
10800 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Reconsider form feed (U+000C) conformance 2010-09-29 2010-10-05
10801 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Limit the number of iterations in the loops in the AAA 2010-09-29 2010-10-19
10802 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Limit the number of identical items on the list of active formatting elements by removing previous duplicates when adding new items 2010-09-29 2010-10-15
10803 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Ignore document.written charset metas 2010-09-29 2011-01-19
10804 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE charset sniffing: please describe the incompatibility 2010-09-29 2010-10-04
10805 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE treating single quotes as double quotes not needed for compatibility with existing content 2010-09-29 2011-04-08
10806 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT ignoring escapes is not needed for compatibility with existing content 2010-09-29 2011-03-24
10807 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE i18n comment 1 : new attribute: ubi 2010-09-29 2010-11-11
10809 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE i18n comment 3 : new attribute: submitdir 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10810 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED i18n comment 5 : U+2028 and U+2029 in textarea and pre elements 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10811 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT i18n comment 6 : U+2028 and U+2029 in dialog text 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10812 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE i18n comment 7 : line breaks in textarea and pre elements 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10813 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE i18n comment 8 : line breaks in dialog text 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10814 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED i18n comment 9 : block-display elements should act as UBA paragraph breaks 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10815 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE i18n comment 10 : block elements with display:inline should get ubi instead of default dir 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10816 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT i18n comment 11 : default ignorable code points 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10817 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE i18n comment 12 : title element should support and inherit dir attribute 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10818 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT i18n comment 14 : title and alt attribute direction and two new attributes: titledir and altdir 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10819 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE i18n comment 15 : option element should support the dir attribute and be displayed accordingly both in the dropdown and after being chosen 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10820 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE i18n comment 16 : option element should support text-align CSS property and be displayed accordingly both in the dropdown and after being chosen 2010-09-29 2010-10-18
10821 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE i18n comment 17 : setting input and textarea element direction through browser UI should set the dir attribute and trigger oninput event 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10822 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT i18n comment 18 : on an OS that has a widespread UI convention for setting direction, user agent should support it on input and textarea elements 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10825 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT i18n comment 21 : location of user agent window's overall vertical scrollbar 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10826 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT i18n comment 22 : location of an element's vertical scrollbar when it is not the user agent window's overall vertical scrollbar 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10827 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE i18n comment 23 : script dialog text direction 2010-09-29 2011-01-22
10832 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE The scroll event is also a "magic event handler" in that <body onscroll> registers something on Window. 2010-09-29 2010-10-05
10833 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT The element should only suffer from being missing if all of the checkbox choices are unselected - like radio buttons 2010-09-29 2010-10-12
10834 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Garbage collection is the wrong level of abstraction 2010-09-29 2010-10-04
10836 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Several legacy attributes should reflect as URLs, not strings 2010-09-29 2010-10-07
10837 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE playbackrate: undefined behavior when the user agent can't play back at the requested rate 2010-09-29 2011-04-27
10838 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make <u> conforming. 2010-09-29 2011-07-30
10839 HTML WG pre-LC1 jfoliot CLOS WORK Providing visible indication that descriptions and captions are available. 2010-09-30 2011-01-11
10840 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS NEED Allow the user to independently adjust the volumes of the audio description and original soundtracks. 2010-09-30 2011-01-12
10841 HTML WG pre-LC1 jfoliot CLOS NEED We require a method to allow the user to control playback timing in order to have more time to understand the material. 2010-09-30 2013-03-13
10842 HTML WG pre-LC1 jfoliot CLOS NEED Support the isolation of speech from other background sounds in AV media 2010-09-30 2013-03-13
10843 HTML WG pre-LC1 jfoliot CLOS NEED Support user control over the visual presentation of caption text. 2010-09-30 2013-03-13
10844 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Mono ruby, group ruby, and jukugo ruby 2010-09-30 2010-10-04
10845 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Clarify the difference between @srcdoc documents and @srcdoc value 2010-09-30 2010-10-04
10846 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Sections may contain headings of any rank 2010-09-30 2010-10-04
10847 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Could small be achieved with a more general statement? Eg, Legal, notice etc. Its very close to being presentation at this stage IMHO. 2010-09-30 2010-10-04
10849 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve CLOS NEED provide means to add image content catagories to images 2010-09-30 2012-01-10
10851 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Javascript access to rendered (calculated) styling information of a DOM node 2010-09-30 2010-10-19
10853 HTML WG pre-LC1 Paul.Cotton CLOS WONT HTML5 lacks a verbose description mechanism 2010-09-30 2013-04-16
10854 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE willful violation of RFC2046 may be an exaggeration 2010-09-30 2010-10-04
10862 HTML WG pre-LC1 contributor RESO WONT Remove the newly added "s" element 2010-09-30 2010-11-14
10873 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT Provide a method of explicitly setting a tooltip for an element 2010-09-30 2013-01-16
10877 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Spec should explain that the structured clone algorithm breaks Directed Acyclic Graphs into trees 2010-09-30 2010-10-11
10878 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Structured clone algorithm should be updated to support Directed Acyclic Graphs 2010-09-30 2010-10-06
10879 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Including "impossible" requirements even as a SHOULD is unnecessary 2010-09-30 2010-10-05
10887 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE "garbage characters" in non-negative integers should be clarified 2010-09-30 2010-10-12
10888 HTML WG pre-LC1 chaals CLOS MOVE Access Command Requirements for HTML5 2010-09-30 2014-05-01
10889 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Content Model section should cite the Polyglot document for further advice 2010-09-30 2010-10-12
10890 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT i18n comment : Allow utf-16 meta encoding declarations 2010-09-30 2014-02-27
10892 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE onreset IDL attribute missing from Window, HTMLDocument, HTMLElement 2010-09-30 2010-10-10
10893 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Allow definition lists to markup dialogue 2010-09-30 2010-11-06
10895 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Use markup compatible with both HTML/XML syntax in examples 2010-09-30 2011-01-05
10897 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO DUPL In general, synthetic events dispatched from script do not trigger default actions - click is the exception for compatibility 2010-09-30 2014-05-20
10898 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Additional attributes should be wired up to window when on body 2010-09-30 2010-11-12
10899 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE DOMActivate is deprecated in DOM L3 Events 2010-09-30 2010-10-18
10900 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO FIXE HTML to Platform Accessibility APIs Implementation Guide 2010-09-30 2011-04-12
10901 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Use same parsing for HTML <script> and SVG <script> 2010-09-30 2011-11-13
10902 HTML WG pre-LC1 contributor RESO WONT <video> element needs to support some form of DRM solution 2010-09-30 2011-12-12
10905 HTML WG pre-LC1 chaals CLOS DUPL clarify how assigning an accesskey to an element affects the elements default role 2010-09-30 2016-02-23
10907 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Reset algorithm for input elements doesn't seem to reset <input type='file'> 2010-09-30 2010-10-12
10909 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE Clarify how fieldset's first legend should behave if the fieldset is disabled because of another disabled fieldset 2010-09-30 2010-10-14
10914 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO LATE Allow multiple space separated values for the ARIA role attribute 2010-09-30 2013-01-21
10915 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve VERI FIXE clarify why a command element that is not in a menu is conforming 2010-09-30 2011-01-18
10916 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Add a new <control> element to convey the common semantics of a script enabled UI control 2010-09-30 2011-01-25
10917 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS WONT modify user agent requirement for details element 2010-09-30 2011-01-11
10918 HTML WG pre-LC1 faulkner.steve RESO NEED provide better examples 2010-09-30 2011-01-11
10920 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Remove reference to WHAT WG wiki from other metadata names section 2010-09-30 2010-10-07
10921 HTML WG pre-LC1 contributor RESO FIXE put back direct link to the W3C version of the canvas 2d context spec 2010-09-30 2011-04-12
10922 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Use normative keywords (MUST/SHOULD/MAY) in other metadata section 2010-09-30 2010-10-12
10923 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Add an attribute to override UA's validation message 2010-09-30 2010-10-12
10924 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian CLOS FIXE double negation in "not not the disabled ones" 2010-10-01 2010-10-13
10925 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI DUPL double negation in "not not the disabled ones" 2010-10-01 2010-10-22
10927 HTML WG pre-LC1 cyns RESO NEED collection of all interactive (actionable, focusable) elements 2010-10-01 2011-01-11
10928 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED Dynamic markup insertion effect on accessibiltiy APIs should be spec'd 2010-10-01 2010-10-12
10929 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT would the <small> element be better handled in CSS? 2010-10-01 2010-10-21
10931 HTML WG pre-LC1 cyns RESO FIXE Add details or summary to focus management section 2010-10-01 2010-10-26
10932 HTML WG pre-LC1 cyns RESO WORK add area to 7.4.2 Focus management 2010-10-01 2010-10-26
10936 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Missing word in "a timed track cue is considered to of a timed track only" 2010-10-01 2010-10-05
10938 HTML WG pre-LC1 xn--mlform-iua RESO NEED Add <textual/> - a visible textual substitute element w/link capability 2010-10-01 2012-01-10
10953 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Clarify what word the "s" element represents ("s"trike?) 2010-10-01 2010-10-05
10954 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE plain text processing breaks text/plain; format=flowed 2010-10-01 2010-10-12
10956 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO NEED If you were to say: The Business Continuity Institute (BCI) ... should you write it as <dfn>The Business Continuity Institute (<abbr title="The Business Continuity Institute">BCI</abbr>)</dfn> or The Business Continuity Institute (<dfn><abbr title="The 2010-10-01 2010-10-12
10962 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Change <param> to be dynamic 2010-10-01 2010-10-14
10963 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Table prohibited from being used as a layout aid 2010-10-01 2011-04-19
10964 HTML WG pre-LC1 schwer VERI FIXE Canvas needs to support a backing store in the DOM subtree capable of supporting screen reading 2010-10-02 2012-01-24
10965 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WONT Refer to SVG Integration spec for element and attribute names 2010-10-02 2010-10-07
11196 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Please add a way to hide the Working Draft warning 2010-11-02 2010-11-11
11207 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE Make track element additions technology neutral 2010-11-03 2011-01-22
11211 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO WORK Need a way to force a line wrap with the bidi semantics of LINE SEPARATOR when necessary. 2010-11-03 2010-11-14
11238 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian VERI INVA Enable canvas to support accessible rich text editing 2010-11-05 2012-11-13
12526 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO FIXE image verbiage 2011-04-20 2011-05-10
19481 HTML WG pre-LC1 ian RESO INVA test 2012-10-11 2012-10-11
2547 bugs found.
CSV