Closed Issues

Apply the following changes to selected issues:

There are 129 closed issues listed in the system.

ID State Title Raised on Product Open Actions
ISSUE-2 (edit)
Obsoleting
CLOSED TR documents which are obsolete or have been "parked" or abandoned 2011-11-24 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-3 (edit)
wd-tr-updates
CLOSED Allow change in place in /TR 2012-03-02 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-7 (edit)
EASYAPPEAL
CLOSED Make appealing decisions more believably possible and available 2013-06-06 Process Document 0
ISSUE-8 (edit)
wide review
CLOSED How much to define the review requirements for transitions 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-9 (edit)
widely-reviewed
CLOSED What does “widely reviewed” mean and how is it encouraged/ensured? (Jeff 2) 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-10 (edit)
cr-awareness
CLOSED Raising awareness before CR 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-11 (edit)
process-goals
CLOSED Documenting Process goals 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-12 (edit) CLOSED Requirements for a Recommendation in the Process Document 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-13 (edit)
cr-meaning
CLOSED What is the distinction between Candidate Recommendations and LCCR? 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-14 (edit) CLOSED cr review by the director 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-15 (edit) CLOSED Definition of substantive changes 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-16 (edit) CLOSED Documenting significant editorial changes and conformance 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-17 (edit)
requirements tracking
CLOSED Document changes of Working Group Requirements 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-18 (edit)
dependency tracking
CLOSED Documenting dependencies with other groups 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-19 (edit) CLOSED Evidence of wide review 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-20 (edit)
late issues
CLOSED Issues raised after LC-CR 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-21 (edit) CLOSED Heartbeat Consensus 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-22 (edit) CLOSED Listing of unfulfilled requirements and document advancement 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-23 (edit) CLOSED Length of review period for LCCR 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-24 (edit) CLOSED Differences in between a basis for recommendation and PR 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-25 (edit) CLOSED Reporting LCCR issues to the director 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-26 (edit)
implementation epxerience
CLOSED Requirements for interoperability - Two independant implementations 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-27 (edit) CLOSED Call for Review of a PR by the Director without implementations 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-28 (edit) CLOSED Scope of review (wide, effective public review) 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-29 (edit) CLOSED Requirements for publication of a working draft when group is closing 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-30 (edit) CLOSED Following the process for new features - Sentence removed 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-31 (edit) CLOSED Advices on section 7, new placeholders and linking 2013-06-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-32 (edit)
consensusInfo
CLOSED If info about consensus deemed useful for one class of docs, why not all? 2013-06-13 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-33 (edit) CLOSED Normative Reference "policy" is blocking IP commitments from becoming final 2013-06-26 Normative Reference Policy 0
ISSUE-34 (edit)
good standing
CLOSED Remove the Good Standing rules from the process document? 2013-07-08 Process Document 0
ISSUE-35 (edit) CLOSED Clarify "base" document for Technical Reports change requests 2013-07-08 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-37 (edit)
generic shoulds
CLOSED Drop the shoulds for general transitions 2013-07-20 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-38 (edit)
documenting implementation
CLOSED Add a should requirement to document known implementation 2013-07-23 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-39 (edit)
transitioning
CLOSED Managing the transition to a new TR cycle 2013-09-18 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-40 (edit)
Just WD
CLOSED Make Working Draft a single state and describe the transitions 2013-09-18 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-41 (edit)
Reviewing corrections
CLOSED Remove the "Review of corrections" process? 2013-10-03 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-42 (edit)
Patent Policy refs
CLOSED Accurate and clear references to the Patent Policy 2013-10-03 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-43 (edit)
edited rec: transition?
CLOSED Does publishing an edited Recommendation require meeting all "state transition" requirements? 2013-10-03 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-44 (edit)
MinorUpdateNoNewReview
CLOSED Process should be clear that minor edits at same level do not trigger new review period 2013-10-09 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-45 (edit)
fix all the erratas
CLOSED Is the requirement that all errata should be addressed in an edited Recommendation too strong? 2013-10-09 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-46 (edit)
explain heartbeat-only
CLOSED Publish and explain if 6 months pass with no change 2013-10-09 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-47 (edit)
in situ TR changes
CLOSED What kind of changes can be "silently" made to a document in /TR 2013-10-17 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-48 (edit)
status of provisionally approved Rec
CLOSED Status of this document requirements for Provisionally vs formally approved W3C Recommendations 2013-10-18 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-49 (edit)
LinkCheck
CLOSED Links in chapter 7 ed don't work e.g. https://dvcs.w3.org/hg/ab/raw-file/default/tr.html#moztocid983157 2013-10-21 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-50 (edit)
Directors-Calls
CLOSED If LC and CR are combined, Director's Calls can be excessive overhead 2013-10-31 Processes that Suck e.g. too much time, resources, make work, etc. 0
ISSUE-51 (edit)
SoTD
CLOSED What to do with the Status section? 2013-11-09 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-52 (edit)
Wide Review Ensured
CLOSED How is satisfying “widely reviewed” encouraged/ensured? 2013-11-10 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-53 (edit)
Rename LCCR
CLOSED Rename Last Call Candidate Recommendation 2013-11-12 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-54 (edit)
CallThemStandards
CLOSED Change Recommendation to Standard 2013-11-12 0
ISSUE-56 (edit)
Pending LCCR Announcement
CLOSED How are groups outside the W3C, but with dependencies on a specification notified of a pending LCCR? 2013-11-25 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-57 (edit)
Editor's Drafts
CLOSED Avoid using the term "publishing" for Editor's Drafts 2013-11-25 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-58 (edit)
Implementation of "this" specification
CLOSED Clarifying that implementation experience is for specification being progressed 2013-11-25 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-59 (edit)
Chap7-Organization
CLOSED The 24-Oct-2013 Draft of Ch7 has some organizational issues and readability suffers 2013-11-26 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-60 (edit)
Ch7-Evolution
CLOSED Chapter 7 should be moved to Github to encourage and facilitate contributions to its evolution 2013-11-26 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-61 (edit)
Ch7-Acknowledgements
CLOSED Move the Acknowledgements to a separate Appendix at the end of the doc 2013-11-26 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-62 (edit)
Ch7-Comments-List
CLOSED Chapter 7: include the mail list for comments and a link to the archive 2013-11-26 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-63 (edit)
Ch7-Changes-Appendix
CLOSED Chapter 7: Changes since last publication should be in an Appendix 2013-11-26 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-64 (edit)
Ch7-Errata
CLOSED Chapter 7: add a link to an errata page 2013-11-26 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-65 (edit)
Ch7-Define-(un)Stable
CLOSED Chapter 7: define stable and unstable 2013-11-27 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-66 (edit)
Ch7-Please-Dont-Create-New-Problems
CLOSED Elimination of LC or combining LC and CR creates new problems 2013-11-27 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-67 (edit)
Ch7-Education-Is-the-Key
CLOSED Rather than change LC and CR, it seems like it would be more effective to attack the cycle problem via Education and Outreach 2013-11-27 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-68 (edit)
Ch7-DogFood-The-New-CR
CLOSED Rather than implement it across-the-board, perhaps it would be useful to have a "candidate" period 2013-11-27 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-69 (edit)
Ch7-Get-Review-from-SDOs
CLOSED Chapter 7: get Wide Review of Chapter 7 from other SDOs 2013-11-27 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-70 (edit)
Ch7-Eliminate-"Normative"
CLOSED Usage of "normative" needs clarification 2013-11-27 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-72 (edit)
change types
CLOSED Rationalising the definition of different types of change 2013-12-06 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-74 (edit)
NeXtSteps?
CLOSED Must specs describe next steps? 2013-12-12 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-75 (edit)
Announcing transitions
CLOSED How and to whom are transitions announced? 2013-12-12 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-76 (edit)
CR changelogs
CLOSED Requirement to document changes between CR publications 2013-12-12 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-77 (edit)
Publishing a Rec
CLOSED Clarify the process of moving from CR to REC 2013-12-12 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-78 (edit)
Redundant Rescindment Requirements
CLOSED Requirements for public discussion and wide review of rescindment request are redundant 2013-12-12 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-79 (edit) CLOSED Don't require republication after 6 months of no publication 2013-12-13 0
ISSUE-80 (edit) CLOSED Publishing Note to end unfinished REC should only be SHOULD 2013-12-13 0
ISSUE-81 (edit) CLOSED Opening of AC review 2014-01-06 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-82 (edit) CLOSED Process for provisional approval 2014-01-06 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-83 (edit)
mchampion
CLOSED Explicitly allow WGs to customize process steps in their charters 2014-01-13 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-84 (edit)
Reinstate PR
CLOSED Reinstate Proposed Recommendation 2014-01-20 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-85 (edit)
editorial changes
CLOSED Make editorial changes a may or should? 2014-02-07 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-86 (edit)
end of review?
CLOSED When should the PR review end? 2014-02-14 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-87 (edit)
coming to CR
CLOSED How to ensure you got wide review to enter CR 2014-02-14 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-88 (edit) CLOSED The events section of procdoc-2005 is arcane and needs updating 2014-04-03 Non-W3C Events - Workshops, Conferences, Meetups 0
ISSUE-95 (edit)
Clarify Rec->Edited Rec
CLOSED Clarify the process of moving from REC to edited REC 2014-04-23 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-96 (edit)
Errata Pages
CLOSED Should there be clear requirements on maintaining errata? 2014-04-23 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-97 (edit)
AB-Name
CLOSED Is using the term "Board" in "Advisory Board" really accurate and representative? 2014-06-04 Process Document 0
ISSUE-98 (edit)
meeting rules
CLOSED What are requirements for meetings 2014-06-11 Process Document 0
ISSUE-99 (edit)
patent policy timelines
CLOSED Can we shorten the timelines required by the patent policy 2014-06-12 Patent Policy 0
ISSUE-100 (edit)
PR in exclusion period
CLOSED Should it be possible to publish a pr before a call for exclusion ends 2014-06-12 Document life cycle (pre 2014 chapter 7, now chapter 6) 0
ISSUE-101 (edit)
better diagrams
CLOSED Improve the diagrams in the Process document 2014-06-18 Process Document 0
ISSUE-105 (edit) CLOSED Please ensure PatPol / Process "binding" described as normative. 2014-07-17 Patent Policy 0
ISSUE-108 (edit)
Activity updates
CLOSED Continue requiring updated information on work every six months? 2014-08-19 Dashboard 0
ISSUE-109 (edit)
Unreviewed Charter Extension
CLOSED Should AC approval be required to extend a charter 2014-08-19 Process Document 0
ISSUE-110 (edit) CLOSED 2014-08-26 0
ISSUE-111 (edit)
CharterInterest
CLOSED W3C creates a charter based on interest from the Members and Team 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-112 (edit) CLOSED Remove Activity Proposals 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-113 (edit) CLOSED Advisory Committee Review of Charter Extentions 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-114 (edit)
CharterExtensionReview
CLOSED Review period for charter extensions 2014-08-26 0
ISSUE-115 (edit)
ActivityStatementRevision
CLOSED Revising the Activity Statement for each Activity every 6 months 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-116 (edit)
CharterAnnoucement
CLOSED Announcing a Working Group Charter 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-117 (edit)
ActivityAppealDissent
CLOSED Requirement for dissent in the AC Review of an Activity Proposal to Appeal an approval 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-118 (edit)
ContextInformation
CLOSED Context Informaton in Activity Proposals 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-119 (edit)
CharterScope
CLOSED Description of the Activity/Charter's scope 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-120 (edit)
LevelOfMembeEffort
CLOSED threshold level of effort that Members are expected to pledge 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-121 (edit)
IPinforInCharters
CLOSED Intellectual property information.in charters 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-122 (edit)
WhoBenefits
CLOSED What community is expected to benefit from this Activity? 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-123 (edit)
FirstMeetingDateForWG
CLOSED Date of the first face-to-face meeting.of a newly chartered WG 2014-08-26 Process Document 0
ISSUE-124 (edit)
WHATWG-blacklist
CLOSED Normative Reference policy should explicitly black list WHATWG specs 2014-09-08 Normative Reference Policy 0
ISSUE-128 (edit)
Lack of Test Cases
CLOSED Lack of test cases is a major contributor to schedule delay. 2014-09-13 Process Document 0
ISSUE-129 (edit)
CoordGroups
CLOSED Should the Process define Coordination Groups? 2014-09-13 Process Document 0
ISSUE-132 (edit)
voting
CLOSED Change the voting system for elections? 2014-09-14 Process Document 0
ISSUE-134 (edit)
Appeal non-WG creation
CLOSED Appeal against decisions *not* to create a group? 2014-09-15 Process Document 0
ISSUE-135 (edit)
AC appeal in WG
CLOSED Direct appeal of WG decisions for AC? 2014-09-15 Process Document 0
ISSUE-137 (edit)
rationalise heartbeat
CLOSED Rationalise the heartbeats in chapter 6 and 7 2014-09-16 Process Document 0
ISSUE-138 (edit)
editor-free
CLOSED Does the process assume ‘an’ editor, or is group-editing formally ok? 2014-09-16 Process Document 0
ISSUE-140 (edit)
The Team in the process
CLOSED The description of the Team in Section 2.2 of the process document is out of date 2014-09-18 Process Document 0
ISSUE-143 (edit)
Abstract grammar
CLOSED The grammar in the abstract is somewhat unclear 2014-10-02 Process Document 0
ISSUE-145 (edit)
W3Chair...
CLOSED Clean up mentions of W3C Chair, COO etc 2014-10-22 Process Document 0
ISSUE-146 (edit)
cepc-does-not-override-local-laws
CLOSED state the obvious: the policy does not and cannot override local laws and regulations, particularly those regarding employment 2014-11-05 Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct 0
ISSUE-148 (edit)
Consider Liaisons
CLOSED Consider Liaison when deciding who should review a REC Track document 2014-11-17 Process Document 0
ISSUE-150 (edit)
Invited Experts Agreement
CLOSED Remove restriction on "branching" from invited experts agreement 2014-12-18 0
ISSUE-151 (edit)
Resigning from a WG
CLOSED How to resign from a working group 2015-01-11 Process Document 0
ISSUE-152 (edit)
Regress Editorial Change
CLOSED Process2014 Regresses Editorial Revision of RECs 2015-01-13 Process Document 0
ISSUE-154 (edit)
AC review default confidenitality
CLOSED SHould there be a default confidentiality level for AC reviews? 2015-01-30 Process Document 0
ISSUE-158 (edit)
New or continued WG?
CLOSED Does rechartering extinguish a WG or continue it? 2015-02-12 Process Document 0
ISSUE-159 (edit)
define editorial change
CLOSED Remove the current circularity in definition of "editorial change" 2015-04-07 Process Document 0
ISSUE-164 (edit)
Appeal Cleanup
CLOSED Clean up the description of Appeals throughout the Process Document 2015-07-12 Process Document 0
ISSUE-165 (edit)
List of Appealable Decisions
CLOSED Where and how should an appealable decision be identified 2015-07-12 Process Document 0
ISSUE-166 (edit)
Appeals of Decisions not in the Process
CLOSED How should appeals for decisions not mentioned in the Process Document be documented 2015-07-12 Process Document 0
ISSUE-167 (edit)
Proposal Rejection with positive reviews
CLOSED Allow appeal of the Director's rejection of a Proposal up for AC Review if there were positive reviews 2015-07-12 Process Document 0
ISSUE-169 (edit)
Team submission consensus
CLOSED Consensus on a Team Submission 2016-08-03 Process Document 0
ISSUE-174 (edit) CLOSED Rescinding a Recommendation in conflict with later versions and patent obligations 2016-10-10 Process Document 0

Raise an issue .


David Singer <singer@apple.com>, Chair, Veronica Thom <veronica@w3.org>, Staff Contact
Tracker: documentation, (configuration for this group), originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <w3t-sys@w3.org>.
$Id: issues.php,v 1.18 2015/07/01 14:43:27 vivien Exp $