Main WoT WebConf/2021

Events

• November 30: IoT Tech Expo Panel on Security (McCool)
• November 29: WISHI - Update on TMs (Sebastian)
• October 25-29: TPAC Joint meetings
• October 5, 7, 26, 27, 28: Virtual F2F
• September 28-October 2: Plugfest/Testfest
• June 26-30: IETF 111 (online)
• June 25: W3C Smart Cities Workshop (online)
• June 21, 22, 23; 28, 29, 30; optionally July 2: WoT vF2F (online)
• June 21: T2TRG Summary call (pre-IETF), 15:00-17:00 UTC/11:00-13:00 EDT
• June 19-23: IETF Hackathon (online)
• June 17: WISHI, 15:00-16:30 UTC/11:00-13:30 EDT
• June 7-11, 18: Testfest
  • 9am Eastern every day June 7-11 for 1h for a sync call
  • a slightly longer call on Friday June 11 (2h)
  • (optionally) another 1-2h call Friday June 18
• Jan 27 at 9 ET, APA/WoT Meeting (accessibility) - replaces WoT Plugfest call
• Jan 19 at 11 ET, SDWWG/AR Meeting (geolocation)
• March 1-5, Joint plugfest (with IETF hackathon)
• March 6-12, IETF 110 (online)
• March 15-26, WoT online F2F
• March 24-25, Geo Connect Asia 2021 Conference

Future Topics

• Linked Data Signatures WG Proposed Charter - any updates?
  • Proposed charter
  • Issue tracker
  • Endorsements
  • Comment by McCool - WoT work on canonicalization signing
  • Review/feedback issue - endorsement, updated comment wrt TD Signing PR (TD Signing PR)
  • TD Canonicalization and Signatures...
    • See https://pr-preview.s3.amazonaws.com/mmccool/wot-thing-description/pull/1151.html#signature
• IP-BLiS (Zoltan?)
• EU Projects - LSPs in IoT (Dave Raggett)
• Plugfest and Testing
• Marketing (Sebastian)
  • Keeping Web presence up-to-date
    • recurring problem: see last IG page update is from May 2018
• Discovery (McCool/Toumura)
  • DNS-SRV/SD, CoRE Resource Directories, etc.
• eCl@ss (Sebastian/Reigel)
• Automotive WG and Use Case discussion (Sebastian w/ Ted Guild)
• Conexxus? (Ezell)
• EdgeX? (McCool)
• Verifiable Claims? (McCool)
• CHIP? (Koster)
• WISHI
  • Followups from T2TRG/WoT Workshop planned for June 30 call
  • Agenda here: https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
• JSON
  • Joint meetings on JSON Path and JSON Schema standardizatino
  • post-TPAC?

---

Deliverable and F2F Meeting Plan

Note: this schedule updates and supercedes the draft schedule in the WoT WG 2020 Charter and the previous schedule.

• Q1 2020
  • March 2020: Virtual F2F
• Q2 2020
  • June 2020: Virtual F2F and plugfest
• Q3 2020
• Q4 2020
  • October 2020: F2F and plugfest (TPAC)
  • November 2020: FPWD for WoT Profile
  • November 2020: FPWD for WoT Architecture 1.1
  • November 2020: FPWD for WoT Discovery
  • November 2020: FPWD for WoT Thing Description 1.1
  • November 2020: IG NOTE for WoT Scripting API (Update)
• Q1 2021
  • February 2021: IG NOTE for WoT Use Cases
• Q2 2021
  • March 18 2021: First possible CR transition for prev FPWDs
    • https://w3c.github.io/spec-releases/milestones/?fpwd=2020-11-24
  • March 2021: F2F and plugfest
    • March 1-5: Joint plugfest with IETF hackathon
    • Avoid March 6-12: (IETF110 online conflict)
    • March 15-26: WoT online F2F
  • Publication moratorium around the upcoming AC Meeting on April 26-27
    • no publications on April 23-29
  • 1 May 2021: Stable pre-CR drafts
  • 7-11, 18 June 2021: Testfest
  • 21-2 June/July 2021: F2F
• Q3 2021
  • July 2021: Update Security Notes (reflect new docs, eg Discovery)
  • 15 July 2021: Target CR Transition for TD
  • 15 July 2021: (Aug?) Target CR Transition for Architecture
  • 15 August 2021: Target CR Transition for Discovery
  • 15 August 2021: (?) Target CR Transition for Profiles
  • September/October 2021: Plugfest (TPAC) - online
  • September/October 2021: F2F (TPAC) - online
  • 1 September, 2021: Target PR Transition for TD
  • 1 September, 2021: Target PR Transition for Architecture
• Q4 2021
  • 1 October, 2021: Target PR Transition for Profiles
  • 1 October, 2021: Target PR Transition for Discovery
  • 11-15 October: TestFest (Proposed)
  • 18-22 October, 2021: TPAC Breakouts
  • 25-29 October, 2021: TPAC Group/Joint Meetings
  • 1-5 November: F2F extension (Proposed)
  • 1 November, 2021: Target REC Transition for TD
  • 1 November, 2021: Target REC Transition for Architecture
  • 1 December, 2021: Target REC Transition for Profiles
  • 1 December, 2021: Target REC Transition for Discovery
  • 9 December 2021: Last possible CR transition
• Q1 2022
  • 27 January 2022: Last possible PR transition
  • 31 January 2022: Charter end date
  • (EXT) 15 January 2022: Target CR Transition for Discovery
  • (EXT) 1 April 2021: Target PR Transition for Discovery
• Q2 2022
  • (EXT) 1 June 2022: Target REC Transition for Discovery

Agendas

22 December 2021

Chair: Sebastian

Regrets: McCool

Scribe: Michael L.

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Dec-15
• Quick updates
  • Editors' sync-up call on Tuesday
    • Dec-21 call cancelled
    • Further discussion continued during the TF calls
  • Updates on the possible new Architecture call slot?
    • Currently: Thursday, 05:00-07:00 EST / 10:00-12:00 UTC time and date for your timezone
    • New doodle polls: Architecture call, Profile call
  • WoT Japanese CG updates?
    • held the first session of the kick-off meetings on Dec 22 - Draft minutes
    • will hold the second session on Jan 28
  • Smart Cities updates?
    • nothing specific
• Rechartering and Charter Extensions
  • IG Rechartering
    • AC Review (Member-only) ongoing - Please ask your AC Rep to respond!
    • Our current IG Charter has been extended by 3-mo to accommodate the AC Review procedure.
  • WG Charter Extension
    • Draft WG Charter for 12mo extension available
    • not discussed by W3M last week...
  • WG Rechartering AFTER the 12mo extension
    • Draft WG Charter for the next period
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Need to finalize and submit the new WG charter a few months before the end of the extended charter
• Discuss decision process:
  • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/pull/1005
  • Each TF should discuss and provide input to PR
• Publications
  • Call for Resolution to publish updated WoT Use Cases and Requirements
  • Call for Resolution for TD 1.1 2nd WD release
    • some feedback was provided after the call for review 2 weeks ago
    • deep review was provided by Ben https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/1324
    • some PRs are derived, which deal with the findings https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pulls?q=is%3Apr+is%3Aopen+label%3A%222nd+WD%22
    • there are editorial ones and there are PRs that have assertion impact #1341, #1340, and #1339
    • do we need more time for review those PRs? Postpone resolution to tomorrow's Arch call?
  • Any others?
  • Need to check the progress based on the updated plan - Need to update the schedule again? If so, how?
• Marketing
  • WoT CG
    • https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/236
    • WoT Community Group
    • Use for mailing list, announcements, open events (eg Open Day), update page to point to main web page...
    • Call for nominations for a second chair in addition to Ege
  • Wiki page improvements
    • Description on each TF: https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/231
    • Proposed structure: https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/IG_Security_WebConf
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • Want to update implementation descriptions in Testing/Plugfest call today
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Joint call now set for Feb 3 at 09:00 EDT / 15:00 CET, for 2h
    • checking with ITU-T about the possible speakers/talks W3C WoT (proposing 60m total; McCool (15m), Kaz (15m), Sebastian (30m) to present)
  • ECHONET
    • Report from Plugfest during TPAC 2021 has been merged
    • Next step: clarification on concrete binding for smart home use cases
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • OPC UA
    • PR for a use case based on Industry 4.0
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • OneDM
  • SDW/OCG/OpenAR - Geospatial Data
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 14
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • OneM2M
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

15 December 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Daniel

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Dec-8
• Quick updates
  • Editors' sync-up call on Tuesday
    • Dec-14 minutes (members-only)
      • Discussion on Scripting API, Profile, Use Cases and Architecture
      • Further discussion continued during the TF calls
  • Updates on the possible new Architecture call slot?
    • Currently: Thursday, 05:00-07:00 EST / 10:00-12:00 UTC time and date for your timezone
    • New doodle polls concluded: Architecture call, Profile call
  • WoT Japanese CG updates?
    • Organizing kick-off meetings on Dec 22 and Jan 28 to get as many participants as possible
  • Smart Cities updates?
    • nothing specific
  • OPC-UA
• Rechartering and Charter Extensions
  • IG Rechartering
    • Updated draft IG Charter got W3M approval
    • Kaz working with the MarComm Team for AC review
    • Our current IG Charter expires on Dec 31, so asking W3M for 3-mo extenion to accommodate the AC Review procedure. - expecting to get approval today, Dec 15 and send the Call for Review today (or tomorrow at the latest)
  • WG Charter Extension
    • Draft WG Charter for 12mo extension available
    • not discussed by W3M last week, expecting to be discussed today, Dec 15
  • WG Rechartering AFTER the 12mo extension
    • Draft WG Charter for the next period
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Need to finalize and submit the new WG charter a few months before the end of the extended charter
• Discuss decision process:
  • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/pull/1005
  • Each TF should discuss and provide input to PR
• Publications
  • Call for Resolution to publish updated WoT Use Cases and Requirements
  • Any others?
• Marketing
  • WoT CG
    • https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/236
    • WoT Community Group
    • Use for mailing list, announcements, open events (eg Open Day), update page to point to main web page...
    • Chair nominations for Ege Korkan
    • Call for nominations for a second chair
  • Wiki page improvements
    • Description on each TF: https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/231
    • Proposed structure: https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/IG_Security_WebConf
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • Want to update implementation descriptions in Testing/Plugfest call today
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Joint call now set for Feb 3 at 09:00 EDT / 15:00 CET, for 2h
    • Need speakers from W3C WoT (proposing 60m total, McCool (15m), Kaz (15m), Sebastian (30m) to present)
  • ECHONET
    • Report from Plugfest during TPAC 2021 is requested - to be merged during the Plugfest call today - Draft summary
    • Next step: clarification on concrete binding for smart home use cases
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • OPC UA
    • PR for a use case based on Industry 4.0
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • OneDM
  • SDW/OCG/OpenAR - Geospatial Data
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 14
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • OneM2M
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

8 December 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Ege

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Dec-1
• Quick updates
  • Editors' sync-up call on Tuesday
    • Dec-7 minutes (members-only)
      • Discussion on Scripting API's Use Cases section and Profile spec
      • Further discussion continued during the TF calls
  • Updates on the possible new Architecture call slot?
    • Currently: Thursday, 05:00-07:00 EST / 10:00-12:00 UTC time and date for your timezone
    • New doodle polls ongoing for the Architecture call and the Profile call separately.
  • WoT Japanese CG updates?
    • Organizing kick-off meetings on Dec 22 and Jan 28 to get as many participants as possible
  • Smart Cities updates?
    • nothing specific
• Rechartering and Charter Extensions
  • IG Rechartering
    • Updated draft IG Charter is under review by W3M
    • no W3M meeting on Dec 1 so probably will be discussed today, Dec 8
  • WG Charter Extension
    • Draft WG Charter for 12mo extension available
    • no W3M meeting on Dec 1 so probably will be discussed today, Dec 8
  • WG Rechartering AFTER the 12mo extension
    • Draft WG Charter for the next period
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Need to finalize and submit the new WG charter a few months before the end of the extended charter
• Discuss decision process:
  • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/pull/1005
  • Each TF should discuss and provide input to PR
• Marketing
  • Wiki page improvements
    • Description on each TF: https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/231
  • Proposed structure: https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/IG_Security_WebConf
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • Want to update implementation descriptions in Testing/Plugfest call today
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Joint call now set for Feb 3 at 09:00 EDT / 15:00 CET, for 2h
    • Need speakers from W3C WoT (proposing 30m slot, McCool/Sebastian to present)
  • ECHONET
    • need clarification on concrete binding for smart home use cases
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • OPC UA
    • PR for a use case based on Industry 4.0
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • OneDM
  • SDW/OCG/OpenAR - Geospatial Data
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 14
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • OneM2M
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

1 December 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Scribe: Daniel

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Nov-24
• Quick updates
  • Brief report from the panel at IoT Tech Expo Nov 30 at 11:10am CET - Security (McCool)
    • https://www.w3.org/blog/talks/event/live-panel-iot-security-acting-ahead-of-the-threat/
    • https://www.iottechexpo.com/europe/track/iot-innovations-day-1/
  • Editors' sync-up call on Tuesday
    • Nov-30 minutes (members-only)
      • Checked the current status
      • Discussion continued during the TF calls
  • Updates on the possible new Architecture call slot?
    • Currently: Thursday, 05:00-07:00 EST / 10:00-12:00 UTC time and date for your timezone
  • WoT Japanese CG updates?
    • Japanese version of the WoT Architecture spec published as a TTC standard (TTC is a Japanese SDO on telecommunications.)
    • Organizing a kick-off meeting - announcement on the CG list
  • Smart Cities updates?
    • nothing specific
• Rechartering and Charter Extensions
  • IG Charter Rechartering/Renewal
    • merged PRs to address W3M comments:
      • for PLH's comments
      • for Ralph's comments
    • Updated draft IG Charter available
    • asking W3M to proceed with the procedure (=AC review)
  • WG Charter Extension
    • Draft WG Charter for 12mo extension available
    • asking W3M to proceed with the procedure (=AC review)
    • FYI, our updated schedule assuming 12-mo extension
      • This still uses our deadlines for the 6mo extension, but gives us a buffer for horizontal review
  • Draft WG Charter for the next period AFTER the 12mo extension
    • Draft charter has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Need to finalize and submit the new WG charter a few months before the end of the extended charter.
• Discuss decision process:
  • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/pull/1005
  • Each TF should discuss and provide input to PR
• Marketing
  • Wiki page improvements
    • Description on each TF: https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/231
  • Proposed structure: https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/IG_Security_WebConf
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • Want to update implementation descriptions in Testing/Plugfest call today
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Joint call now set for Feb 3
    • Proposed announcement approved by W3M
  • ECHONET
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • PR for a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • OPC UA
    • PR for a use case based on Industry 4.0
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • OneDM
  • SDW/OCG/OpenAR - Geospatial Data
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 14
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • OneM2M
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

24 November 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Scribe: McCool

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Main call minutes
    • Nov-17
• Quick updates
  • Upcoming panel at IoT Tech Expo Nov 30 - Security
    • Zoom live at 11:10am CET
    • https://www.w3.org/blog/talks/event/live-panel-iot-security-acting-ahead-of-the-threat/
    • https://www.iottechexpo.com/europe/track/iot-innovations-day-1/
    • Note: registration is not free...
  • Editors' sync-up call on Tuesday
    • Nov-23 minutes (members-only)
      • Confirmed the Basic strategy for collaborative review for normative sections
      • Checked the current status
      • Discussion continued during the TF calls
  • Tentative new Architecture call slot
    • Starting this week
    • Thursday, 05:00-07:00 EST / 10:00-12:00 UTC time and date for your timezone
    • New doodle to be distributed to see a possible better slot
  • WoT Japanese CG updates?
  • Smart Cities updates?
• Rechartering and Charter Extensions
  • IG Charter Rechartering/Renewal
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • Issue 986 to address the W3M comment from PLH
      • wot-marketing Issue 217
      • wot-testing Issue 198
      • wot Pullrequest to fix the draft Charter
    • Issue 1007 to address another W3M comment from Ralph
      • PR 1008 to update the Charter based on the issue
  • WG Charter Extension
    • Got response from W3M about our request for a 12-mo extension.
      • W3M clarified that group extension is limited to less than 6mo
      • an extension longer than 6mo should be handled as a rechartering with a slightly updated Charter
      • necessary changes for the "slightly updated Charter" are:
        • The end date of the Charter to be changed: 31 January 2023.
        • The Patent Policy to be Patent Policy 2020 (which will require the participants to rejoin the Group).
        • Start date for the updated Charter should be 1 February 2022
      • our updated schedule assuming 12-mo extension
      • This still uses our deadlines for the 6mo extension, but gives us a buffer for horizontal review
      • See also milestone calculator
      • Need to do a resolution today to proceed
  • WG Charter Rechartering/Renewal
    • Draft charter has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Need to finalize and submit the new WG charter a few months before the end of the extended charter.
• Discuss decision process:
  • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/pull/1005
• Marketing
  • Wiki page improvements
    • Description on each TF: https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/231
    • ToC at the top of wiki pages: https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/228 - done
  • event information has been updated.
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • Want to update implementation descriptions in Testing/Plugfest call today
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Joint call now set for Feb 3
    • Proposed announcement approved by W3M
  • ECHONET
    • description on ECHONET submitted to the Liaison section of the Use Cases document - style to be fixed
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • PR for a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • OPC UA
    • PR for a use case based on Industry 4.0
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • OneDM
  • SDW/OCG/OpenAR - Geospatial Data
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 14
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • OneM2M
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

17 November 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Koster

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Main call minutes
    • Nov-10
  • vF2F minutes review completed
    • Oct-5 Day 1
    • Oct-7 Day 2
    • Oct-11 Open Day 1
    • Oct-14 Open Day 2
    • Oct-26 Day 3
    • Oct-27 Day 4
    • Oct-28 Day 5
• Quick updates
  • Panel at IoT Tech Expo Nov 23 - Security
    • https://www.w3.org/blog/talks/event/live-panel-iot-security-acting-ahead-of-the-threat/
  • Editors' sync-up call on Tuesday
    • Nov-17 minutes (members-only) - collaborative discussion on the structure of normative specs (Architecture, TD, Profile, Discovery) by the Editors
      • Document structure and content of all the WoT specs #996
      • Relationship between WoT Architecture and related specs #997
  • Proposed new Architecture call slot
    • Thursday, 05:00-07:00 EST / 10:00-12:00 UTC time and date for your timezone
    • See also Lagally's announcement (Members-only)
  • Events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
    • Note: need to take down completed TPAC events
  • Proposal from the Marketing TF to remove the TF links at the top of the wiki pages: https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/228
  • WoT Japanese CG - any updates?
• Rechartering and Charter Extensions
  • IG Charter Rechartering/Renewal
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • Issue 986 to address the W3M comment from PLH
      • wot-marketing Issue 217
      • wot-testing Issue 198
      • wot Pullrequest to fix the draft Charter
    • Issue 1007 to address another W3M comment from Ralph
      • PR 1008 to update the Charter based on the issue
  • WG Charter Rechartering/Renewal
    • Draft charter has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Need to finalize and submit the new WG charter by end of April 2022 to avoid a gap.
  • WG Charter Extension
    • We're requesting a 12-mo extension to our current charter
      • Would like to start the new Charter around August 2021 for smooth start of the WoT 2.0 specs.
      • our updated schedule assuming 12-mo extension submitted to W3M (discussion in parallel today)
      • See also milestone calculator
• Smart Cities
  • Draft Charter updated based on the feedback from the TPAC breakouts - diff from the previous draft
    • discussion on how to involve key stakeholders from countries/cities ongoing
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • Want to update implementation descriptions in Testing/Plugfest call today
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Joint call now set for Feb 3
    • Proposed announcement approved by W3M
  • ECHONET
    • description on ECHONET submitted to the Liaison section of the Use Cases document - style to be fixed
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • PR for a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • OPC UA
    • PR for a use case based on Industry 4.0
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • OneDM
  • SDW/OCG/OpenAR - Geospatial Data
    • see minutes of joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 14
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • OneM2M
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

10 November 2021

Chair: Sebastian

Scribe: Daniel

Regrets: McCool

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Main call minutes
    • Nov-3
  • vF2F minutes
    • To be reviewed
      • Oct-27 Day 4 (for Scripting API)
      • Oct-28 Day 5 (for OPC-UA, T2TRG/DID, Signatures, Versioning and Plugfest/Teting report)
    • Already reviewed
      • Oct-5 Day 1
      • Oct-7 Day 2
      • Oct-11 Open Day 1
      • Oct-14 Open Day 2
      • Oct-26 Day 3
• Current WG Charter Extension
  • As a prereq to our WG charter extension request, we need a plan to complete our specs
  • Need to review plan, confirm
    • rendered branch version
    • possible extension for 12 months instead of 6 months
  • See also milestone calculator
• Rechartering
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • W3M review ongoing - Issue 986 based on the W3M comments
    • wot-marketing Issue 217
    • wot-testing Issue 198
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • Has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Need to finalize and submit the new WG charter by end of April 2022 to avoid a gap, assuming a 6mo extension(?)
• Smart Cities
  • Two breakout session during TPAC - Report out
    • breakout 1
    • breakout 2
  • Draft Charter updated based on the feedback from the breakouts
    • diff from the previous draft
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
    • need more stakeholders from countries/cities and vendors
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • Want to update implementation descriptions in Testing/Plugfest call today
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Joint call now set for Feb 3
    • Proposed announcement approved by W3M
  • ECHONET
    • HTML version of use cases included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • also participated in the Plugfest
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • OneDM
  • SDW/OCG/OpenAR - Geospatial Data
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 14
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • OneM2M
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

3 November 2021

Chair: Sebastian

Scribe: Ege

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Main call minutes
    • Oct-20
  • vF2F minutes
    • To be reviewed
      • Oct-27 Day 4 (except Marketing topics)
      • Oct-28 Day 5 (except Marketing topics)
    • Already reviewed
      • Oct-5 Day 1
      • Oct-7 Day 2
      • Oct-11 Open Day 1
      • Oct-14 Open Day 2
      • Oct-26 Day 3
• Quick updates
  • ask for resolutions for changing the moderator of the Marketing and PlugFest TF
  • Editors' sync-up call on Tuesday
    • Nov-2 minutes (members-only)
    • Document structure and content of all the WoT specs #996
    • Relationship between WoT Architecture and related specs #997
  • IEEE Workshop on IoT Interoperability and the Web of Things - 11 Jan 2022
    • checking with the Liaison Team
    • deadline November 8th, 2021
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
    • Note: need to take down completed TPAC events
  • WoT Japanese CG - any updates?
• Scheduling
  • As a prereq to our WG charter extension request, we need a plan to complete our specs
  • Need to review plan, confirm
  • See also milestone calculator
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • W3M review ongoing - Issue 986 based on the W3M comments
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • Has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Need to finalize and submit the new WG charter by end of April 2022 to avoid a gap, assuming a 6mo extension
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Draft Charter updated based on the report above - diff from the previous draft
  • Two breakout session during TPAC - Report out
    • breakout 1
    • breakout 2
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • Want to update implementation descriptions in Testing/Plugfest call today
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Joint call now set for Feb 3
    • Proposed announcement approved by W3M
  • ECHONET
    • HTML version of use cases included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • also participated in the Plugfest
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 28
  • OneDM
  • SDW/OCG/OpenAR - Geospatial Data
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on Oct 14
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • OneM2M
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

27 October 2021

Cancelled due to the vF2F

20 October 2021

Chair: McCool

Scribe: Daniel

Regrets: Sebastian

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Oct-13 main call
  • Oct-14 Open Day call
• Quick updates
  • Editors' sync-up call on Wednesday
    • Kaz's generated issue as the starting point
    • Currently two hours before the WoT main call, however the time does not seem to work for all the editors.
    • Doodle for new slot
  • IEEE Workshop on IoT Interoperability and the Web of Things - 11 Jan 2022
    • checking with the Liaison Team as well
    • deadline November 8th, 2021
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
  • WoT Japanese CG - any updates?
• Scheduling
  • As a prereq to our WG charter extension request, we need a plan to complete our specs
  • Editors for each spec need to come up with a revised plan
  • In particular, we should resolve TD 1.1 vs. TD 2.0
  • See also milestone calculator
• TPAC 2021 vF2F status and planning
  • wiki for Testfest and vF2F
  • TPAC Group Meetings wiki
  • Upcoming meetings
    • Oct 26 (2h): Use Cases and WoT-JP CG
      • Note: currently 2h, but conflict has been resolved, can extend by an hour if necessary.
    • Oct 27 (3h): Architecture, Profiles, Scripting API and Marketing
    • Oct 28 (3h): Joint Calls, Security and Plugfest/Testfest report
  • TPAC Registration now open
    • https://www.w3.org/register/tpac2021virtual
    • https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/chairs/2021JulSep/0081.html
      • NOTE: This time we use CVent site, so need to (1) once get registered with the W3C site, (2) get an email from the Event Team on the link for the CVent site, and then (3) get registered with the concrete meetings on the CVevent
  • Upcoming joint calls:
    • T2TRG/IETF: McCool
      • Scheduling joint call on Oct 28
    • OPC UA: Sebastian
      • Scheduling joint call on Oct 28
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • W3M review ongoing - Issue 986 based on the W3M comments
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • Has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Draft Charter updated based on the report above - diff from the previous draft
  • Two breakout session during TPAC
    • Oct 18, 15UTC - done. see the draft minutes
    • Oct 21, 14UTC - please visit CVent site and register by searching for "Smart Cities"
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • will discuss in Testing/Plugfest call today
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Event repo

Maybe we can skip the following topics today.

• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
      • Created initial WoT EJS document - Enveloped JSON Signatures
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • They want to announce 2mos in advance
    • Scheduling Dec 13 joint call
    • continue the discussion on the additional documents mentioned during June F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussed the ECHONET Use Case during the Use Cases call on Sep. 7 with Lagally
    • HTML version text already included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • also participated in the Plugfest
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

13 October 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Sebastian

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
• Minutes
  • Oct-6 main call
  • Oct-11 Open Day call
• Quick updates
  • IoT Tech Expo Europe - Nov 30
    • Another panel on IoT security
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
  • WoT Japanese CG - any updates?
  • Ege will start chairing Testing call after the TPAC meetings
• TPAC 2021 vF2F status and planning
  • wiki for Testfest and vF2F
  • TPAC Group Meetings wiki
  • Schedule
    • Oct 14 (3h): Open Day: Netzo, ECHONET, SDW (tentative)
    • Oct 26 (2h): Use Cases and WoT-JP CG
    • Oct 27 (3h): Architecture, Profiles, Scripting API and Marketing
    • Oct 28 (2h): Joint Calls, Security and Plugfest/Testfest report
  • TPAC Registration now open
    • https://www.w3.org/register/tpac2021virtual
    • https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/chairs/2021JulSep/0081.html
      • NOTE: This time we use CVent site, so need to (1) once get registered with the W3C site, (2) get an email from the Event Team on the link for the CVent site, and then (3) get registered with the concrete meetings on the CVevent
  • Joint calls:
    • ITU-T: McCool
      • They want to announce 2mos in advance
      • Scheduling Dec 13 joint call
    • T2TRG/IETF: McCool
      • Scheduling joint call on Oct 28
    • OGC and IEEE P2874: McCool
      • Related to SDW; tentative Oct 14
      • needs to be second hour
    • APA: McCool
      • Deferred
    • ECHONET: Kaz
      • Confirmed for Thursday, Oct. 14
    • ISO TC184/SC4: Kaz
      • Deferred
    • OPC UA: Sebastian
      • Scheduled for Oct 28
      • needs to be in first hour
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • W3M review ongoing - Issue 986 based on the W3M comments
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • Has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Draft Charter updated based on the report above - diff from the previous draft
  • Dedicated breakout session has been organized; please visit CVent site and register
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD report updated post testfest
        • will discuss in Testing/Plugfest call today
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Event repo

Maybe we can skip the following topics today, can't we?

• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • Editors' sync-up call on Wednesday
    • two hours before the WoT main call, however...
    • Time does not seem to work for all the editors
    • Doodle for new slot: TBD
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
      • Created initial WoT EJS document - Enveloped JSON Signatures
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussed the ECHONET Use Case during the Use Cases call on Sep. 7 with Lagally
    • HTML version text already included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • also participated in the Plugfest
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

6 October 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Scribe: Michael Koster

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert: Farshid Tavakolizadeh
• Minutes
  • Sep-29 main call
• Quick updates
  • Very sorry about the W3C service outage yesterday on Oct 5
    • Now all the services including Wiki and IRC are available.
    • See also the regenerated minutes from yesterday
  • DIoT Workshop --> cancelled
    • https://oeg-upm.github.io/DIoT/
    • Camera-ready papers due Oct 18
  • IoT Tech Expo - Sept 29
    • Kaz joined panel on IoT, AI and Digital Technology
    • "WoT useful for interop, Smart Cities as a use case, etc."
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
  • WoT Japanese CG - any updates?
  • Open Day guests
    • Netzo
      • startup using WoT - spinoff from TUM
      • inviting to Open Day - Sebastian in contact
      • can join the Open Day on Monday, Oct 11? or only Tuesday, Oct 12?
    • Takenaka Corporation
      • Japanese construction company using WoT for smart building management
      • confirmed Mr. Kasuya from Takenaka will join Open Day on Monday, Oct 11
  • Testing - chair volunteers
    • Ege would start to contribute after the TPAC meetings
• TPAC 2021 vF2F status and planning
  • wiki for Testfest and vF2F
  • Confirmed schedule - information added to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki
    • Plugfest Sept 27-Oct 1 - DONE
    • vF2F
      • Oct 5 (3h): Discovery - DONE
      • Oct 7 (3h): TD - Tomorrow!
      • Oct 26 (2h): Use Cases and WoT-JP CG
      • Oct 27 (3h): Architecture, Profiles, Scripting API and Marketing
      • Oct 28 (2h): Liaisons, Security and Plugfest/Testfest report
    • Joint meetings also on Oct 25-29
      • Possibly with T2TRG/DID on Oct 28
    • OpenDay Oct 11-15 - Doodle to identify dates/times
      • Monday, Oct 11: Takenaka (T2TRG still a possibility, but Oct 28 more likely)
      • Tuesday, Oct 12: CANCELLED
      • Thursday, Oct 14: ECHONET, SDW? Netzo
  • See also the official TPAC schedule
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 12 - AC Meeting
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 18-22 - Breakouts
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 25-29 - Group/Joint Mtgs
  • TPAC Registration now open
    • https://www.w3.org/register/tpac2021virtual
    • https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/chairs/2021JulSep/0081.html
      • NOTE: This time we use CVent site, so need to (1) once get registered with the W3C site, (2) get an email from the Event Team on the link for the CVent site, and then (3) get registered with the concrete meetings on the CVent site.
  • TODOs
    • Need to finalize detailed subtopics in agenda
    • Need to organize and schedule joint calls
    • Need to schedule liaison calls:
      • ITU-T: McCool
        • They want to announce 2mos in advance
        • now planning for Dec 13 joint call
      • T2TRG/IETF: McCool
        • Call on Oct 26 starting at 10am Eastern
        • Have shortened F2F schedule that day by an hour
      • Now aiming for joint call on Oct 28, but Oct 14 still open
      • OGC and IEEE P2874: McCool
        • In progress; related to SDW; aiming for Oct 14
      • APA: McCool
        • Deferred
      • ECHONET: Kaz
        • Confirmed for Thursday, Oct. 14
      • ISO TC184/SC4: Kaz
        • In progress... not confirmed yet.
      • OPC UA: Sebastian
        • In planning - proposing adding to F2F schedule, on Oct 28
    • Need to organize OpenDay - see below
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • W3M review ongoing - Issue 986 based on the W3M comments
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • Has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Draft Charter updated based on the report above - diff from the previous draft
  • Dedicated breakout session is being organized during the breakout week, Oct 18-22
    • Doodle to choose the date/time
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Event repo

Maybe we can skip the following topics today, can't we?

• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • Editors' sync-up call on Wednesday, two hour before the WoT main call
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
      • Created initial WoT EJS document - Enveloped JSON Signatures
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussed the ECHONET Use Case during the Use Cases call on Sep. 7 with Lagally
    • HTML version text already included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • also participated in the Plugfest
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

29 September 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Ege

Regrets: any?

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications - invite to Open Day meeting?
• Minutes
  • Sep-22 main call
• Quick updates
  • DIoT Workshop
    • https://oeg-upm.github.io/DIoT/
    • Camera-ready papers due Oct 18
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
  • WoT Japanese CG - any updates?
    • TF invitation sent to the group list
  • Netzo
    • startup using WoT - spinoff from TUM
    • inviting to Open Day - Sebastian in contact
  • Takenaka Corporation
    • Japanese construction company using WoT for smart building management
    • inviting to Open Day - Kaz in contact - should be available on Monday, Oct 11
  • Testing - chair volunteers?
• TPAC 2021 planning
  • wiki for Testfest and vF2F
  • Confirmed schedule - information added to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki
    • Plugfest Sept 27-Oct 1
    • vF2F Oct 5, 7, 26, 27, 28 (Conflict with MEIG on Oct 28 in last hour (14-15 UTC))
    • Joint meetings Oct 25-29
    • OpenDay Oct 11-15
      • Monday Oct 11, Thursday Oct 14
      • T2TRG, Takenaka can join Monday
      • Netzo can only join Tuesday or Friday
      • Doodle to identify dates/times
  • This aligns with the official TPAC schedule except for our "extra" meetings Oct 5 and 7:
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 12 - AC Meeting
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 18-22 - Breakouts
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 25-29 - Group/Joint Mtgs
  • TPAC Registration now open
    • https://www.w3.org/register/tpac2021virtual
    • https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/chairs/2021JulSep/0081.html
  • TODOs
    • Need to collect topics
    • Need to organize and schedule joint calls
    • Need to schedule liaison calls:
      • ITU-T: McCool
        • They want to announce 2mos in advance
        • now planning for Dec 13 joint call
      • T2TRG/IETF: McCool
        • Call on Oct 26 starting at 10am Eastern
        • Have shortened F2F schedule that day by an hour
      • OGC and IEEE P2874: McCool
        • In progress; related to SDW
      • APA: McCool
      • ECHONET: Kaz
        • In progress - can join Thursday, Oct. 14
      • ISO TC184/SC4: Kaz
        • In progress
      • Smart Cities Workshop participants: Kaz
      • ECLASS: Sebastian
        • Planned for upcoming use case call (use case call this week)
      • OPC UA: Sebastian
        • In planning - proposing adding to F2F schedule
    • Need to organize OpenDay - see below
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • W3M review ongoing - Issue 986 based on the W3M comments
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • Has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Draft Charter to be updated
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
  • Dedicated breakout session to be organized during the breakout week, Oct 18-22
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • Editors' sync-up call held today, Sep 29
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
      • Created initial WoT EJS document - Enveloped JSON Signatures
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussed the ECHONET Use Case during the Use Cases call on Sep. 7 with Lagally
    • will generate HTML version text for the use case to be included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • working on collaboration for their Plugfest participation as well
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

22 September 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Lagally

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications - invite to Open Day meeting?
    • Zhao Wenk (Fudan University)
    • Jürgen Pannosch (Technische Universität Wien)
• Minutes
  • Sep-15 main call
• Quick updates
  • DIoT Workshop
    • https://oeg-upm.github.io/DIoT/
    • Camera-ready papers due Oct 18
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
  • WoT Japanese CG - any updates?
  • Netzo
    • startup using WoT - spinoff from TUM
    • inviting to Open Day - Sebastian in contact
  • Takenaka Corporation
    • Japanese construction company using WoT for smart building management
    • inviting to Open Day - Kaz in contact
  • Marketing - Fady Salama started to moderate the Marketing call on Sep-21.
  • Testing - chair volunteers?
• TPAC 2021 planning
  • draft wiki for Testfest and vF2F
  • Confirmed schedule - information added to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki
    • Plugfest Sept 27-Oct 1
      • Need to decide what else is cancelled!
    • vF2F Oct 5, 7, 26, 27, 28 (Conflict with MEIG on Oct 28 in last hour (14-15 UTC))
    • Joint meetings Oct 25-29
    • OpenDay Oct 11-15
      • Doodle to identify dates/times
  • This aligns with the official TPAC schedule except for our "extra" meetings Oct 5 and 7:
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 12 - AC Meeting
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 18-22 - Breakouts
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 25-29 - Group/Joint Mtgs
  • TPAC Registration now open
    • https://www.w3.org/register/tpac2021virtual
    • https://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/chairs/2021JulSep/0081.html
  • TODOs
    • Need to add updated information on Joint Meetings to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki by September 20 (over now... we are late)
    • Would be good to organize Open Day (week of Oct 11) soon
    • Need to avoid Oct 12 due to AC Meeting
      • Chairs unavailable
    • Need to collect topics
    • Need to organize and schedule joint calls
    • Need to schedule liaison calls:
      • ITU-T: McCool
        • They want to announce 2mos in advance
        • now planning for Dec 13 joint call
      • T2TRG/IETF: McCool
        • Proposal for call on Oct 26; conflict in last hour
        • Propose shorten F2F schedule that day by an hour
      • OGC and IEEE P2874: McCool
        • In progress; related to SDW
      • APA: McCool
      • ECHONET: Kaz
        • In progress
      • ISO TC184/SC4: Kaz
        • In progress
      • Smart Cities Workshop participants: Kaz
      • ECLASS: Sebastian
        • Planned for upcoming use case call (use case call this week)
      • OPC UA: Sebastian
        • In planning - proposing adding to F2F schedule
    • Need to organize OpenDay - see below
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • Has been updated to template
    • Still need to update deliverables, calendar, etc.
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Draft Charter to be updated
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
      • Created initial WoT EJS document - Enveloped JSON Signatures
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussed the ECHONET Use Case during the Use Cases call on Sep. 7 with Lagally
    • will generate HTML version text for the use case to be included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • working on collaboration for their Plugfest participation as well
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

15 September 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Jan

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications
    • Jan Romann has just joined as an IE.
• Minutes
  • Sep-8 main call
• Quick updates
  • DIoT Workshop updates? - https://oeg-upm.github.io/DIoT/
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
  • WoT Japanese CG - starting TFs on concrete work
  • Netzo - startup using WoT
  • Takenaka Corporation - Japanese construction company using WoT
  • Marketing - new chair to be introduced: Fady Salama
  • Testing - chair volunteers?
• TPAC 2021 planning
  • draft wiki for Testfest and vF2F
  • Confirmed schedule - information added to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki
    • Plugfest Sept 27-Oct 1
    • vF2F Oct 5, 7, 26, 27, 28
    • Joint meetings Oct 25-29
    • Conflict with MEIG on Oct 28 in last hour (14-15 UTC)
  • This aligns with the official TPAC schedule except for our "extra" meetings Oct 5 and 7:
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 18-22 - Breakouts
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 25-29 - Group/Joint Mtgs
  • TODOs
    • Need to add updated information on Joint Meetings to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki by September 20
    • Would be good to organize Open Day (week of Oct 11) by then as well
    • Need to collect topics
    • Need to organize and schedule joint calls
    • Need to schedule liaison calls:
      • ITU-T: McCool
        • They want to announce 2mos in advance, proposing Dec 13
      • T2TRG/IETF: McCool
        • Proposal for call on Oct 26; conflict
      • OGC: McCool
      • IEEE P2874: McCool
        • In progress; related to OGC (and SDW)
      • APA: McCool
      • ECHONET: Kaz
        • In progress
      • ISO TC184/SC4: Kaz
        • In progress
      • ECLASS: Sebastian
        • Planned for upcoming use case call (next week)
      • OPC UA: Sebastian
        • Planned for upcoming use case call (week after next)
    • Need to organize OpenDay - Smart City theme?
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • See new consolidated procedure
    • Like IG, is an updated template
    • May need other minor changes
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Draft Charter to be updated
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
      • Created initial WoT EJS document - Enveloped JSON Signatures
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussed the ECHONET Use Case during the Use Cases call on Sep. 7 with Lagally
    • will generate HTML version text for the use case to be included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • working on collaboration for their Plugfest participation as well
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

8 September 2021

Chair: McCool

Regrets: Sebastian

Scribe: Daniel

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications
• Minutes
  • Sep-1 main call
• Quick updates
  • DIoT Workshop - https://oeg-upm.github.io/DIoT/ submission deadline extended to Sept 10.
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
  • WoT Japanese CG - Joint Discussion at TPAC
• TPAC 2021 planning
  • Need to confirm the dates
  • Need to schedule open day
  • Need to decide on times
  • Need to collect topics
  • Need to organize and schedule joint calls
  • Need to schedule liaison calls
  • Need to organize OpenDay - Smart City theme?
  • draft wiki for Testfest and vF2F
  • Doodle to identify the weeks: https://doodle.com/poll/c48w8m4naxfnzw5n
    • Need to confirm proposed schedule:
      • Plugfest Sept 27-Oct 1
      • vF2F Oct 5, 7, 27, 28, 29 26, 27, 28
      • Joint meetings Oct 25-29
  • This aligns with the official TPAC schedule except for our "extra" meetings Oct 5 and 7:
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 18-22 - Breakouts
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 25-29 - Group/Joint Mtgs
  • NOTE: Need to add the meeting information to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki by September 10
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • See new consolidated procedure
    • Like IG, is an updated template
    • May need other minor changes
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Chair(s) to be identified
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussed the ECHONET Use Case during the Use Cases call on Sep. 7 with Lagally
    • will generate HTML version text for the use case to be included in the Use Cases and Requirements document
    • working on collaboration for their Plugfest participation as well
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

1 September 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Sebastian

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications
• Minutes
  • August-4 main call
• Quick updates
  • DIoT Workshop - https://oeg-upm.github.io/DIoT/ submission deadline extended to Sept 10.
  • Kaz presented at workshop in Korea (TTA - Korean standards org)
  • Other events updated on web page: https://www.w3.org/WoT/activities/general/
• TPAC 2021 planning
  • Need to confirm the dates
  • Need to decide on times
  • Need to collect topics
  • Need to organize and schedule joint calls
  • Need to organize OpenDay - Smart City theme?
  • draft wiki for Testfest and vF2F
  • Doodle to identify the weeks: https://doodle.com/poll/c48w8m4naxfnzw5n
    • Current proposed schedule:
      • Plugfest Sept 28-Oct 2
      • vF2F Oct 5, 7, 20, 21, 22
      • Joint meetings week of Oct 14
  • This however does not completely align with TPAC's schedule, e.g. joint meetings should be the week of the 25th, our proposed schedule overlaps with the breakouts, etc:
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 18-22 - Breakouts
    • TPAC Official: Oct. 25-29 - Group/Joint Mtgs
  • New Proposal:
    • • Plugfest Sept 28-Oct 2
      • vF2F Oct 5, 7, 27, 28, 29
      • Joint meetings week of Oct 25
  • NOTE: Need to add the meeting information to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki by September 10
• Charters
  • IG Charter re-Chartering status
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • See new consolidated procedure
    • Like IG, is an updated template
    • May need other minor changes
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
• Smart Cities
  • Official report available online
  • Chair(s) to be identified
  • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • reviewed the updated ECHONET Use Case during the Use Cases call on Aug. 31
    • need to wrap up the discussion at the next use case call on Sep.7
    • also working on collaboration for their Plugfest participation
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
    • EdgeX Foundry
    • IEEE P2874 - Spatial Web Protocol, Architecture, and Governance Working Group
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?
  • Japanese CG - Joint Discussion at TPAC
  • Takenaka - using WoT for building management now

4 August 2021

Chair: Sebastian

Regrets: McCool

Scribe: Cristiano

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications
• Minutes
  • July-28 main call
• Quick updates
  • Meeting schedule for August - See also the Cancellations section of this wiki
  • DIoT Workshop
    • https://oeg-upm.github.io/DIoT/
  • TPAC 2021 planning
    • draft wiki for Testfest and vF2F
    • Doodle to identify the dates: https://doodle.com/poll/c48w8m4naxfnzw5n
      • Sep. 27-Oct. 1
      • Oct. 4-8 (two weeks before breakouts)
      • Oct. 11-15 (week before breakouts)
      • TPAC Official: Oct. 18-22 - Breakouts
      • TPAC Official: Oct. 25-29 - Group/Joint Mtgs
      • Nov 1-5: F2F (week after official group mtgs)
    • NOTE: Need to add the meeting information to the TPAC Group Meetings wiki by September 10
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June and need to re-Charter
    • Merge PR 979 and finalize the Draft new Charter today
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel
    • Issue to suggest changes: https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/966
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • See new consolidated procedure
    • Like IG, is an updated template
    • May need other minor changes
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
  • W3C Smart Cities Workshop
    • Updated draft report to be published shortly
    • Chair(s) to be identified
    • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • got a Use Case proposal during the Use Cases call on Aug. 3
    • concentrate on the discussion about their Use Case and Plugfest contribution
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • got a use case based on retail
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page --> we have to ok for doing so
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

28 July 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Daniel

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications
• Minutes
  • July-21 main call
  • June vF2F - all the days have been reviewed now
• Quick updates
  • Meeting schedule for August
    • Which meetings will be cancelled in August?
  • DIoT Workshop
    • https://oeg-upm.github.io/DIoT/
  • TPAC 2021 planning
    • draft wiki for Testfest and vF2F
    • Doodle to identify the dates: https://doodle.com/poll/c48w8m4naxfnzw5n
      • Sep. 27-Oct. 1
      • Oct. 4-8 (two weeks before breakouts)
      • Oct. 11-15 (week before breakouts)
      • TPAC Official: Oct. 18-22 - Breakouts
      • TPAC Official: Oct. 25-29 - Group/Joint Mtgs
      • Nov 1-5: F2F (week after official group mtgs)
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June and need to re-Charter
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel and Issue 966 on the wot repo
    • Draft new Charter
    • Issue to suggest changes: https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/966
    • Has been updated to new template: https://github.com/w3c/wot/pull/977
    • Need to finalize before August 2
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • See new consolidated procedure
    • Like IG, is an updated template
    • May need other minor changes
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
  • W3C Smart Cities Workshop
    • Draft report updated and under review
    • Chair(s) to be identified
    • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • All the Editors to check and update the publication schedule using the Milestone calculator.
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery - aiming for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Still working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
      • Cleanup, review during August, aim to publish in Sept
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussing how to proceed with the discussion on concrete binding between ECHONET and WoT
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on Jul 27
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - continue discussion during the Use Cases call on August 3
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • ASHRAE
    • Brick
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

21 July 2021

Chair: McCool

Regrets: Sebastian

Scribe: Kaz

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications
• Minutes
  • July-14 main call
  • June vF2F
• Quick updates
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June and need to re-Charter
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel and Issue 966 on the wot repo
    • Draft new Charter
    • Issue to suggest changes: https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/966
    • Has been updated to new template: https://github.com/w3c/wot/pull/977
    • Need to finalize before August 2
  • WG Charter should be also renewed
    • See new consolidated procedure
    • Like IG, is an updated template
    • May need other minor changes
    • See https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/978
    • Let's aim to finalize and make the request by TPAC (October)
  • W3C Smart Cities Workshop
    • Draft report under review
    • Chair(s) to be identified
    • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery
      • Needs some updates
      • Will aim for review in August, pub in Sept.
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
    • WoT Security Best Practices
      • Working on cleanup, object security; not ready for pub.
• Liaisons
  • Need to follow up on discussion at F2F
  • ITU-T SG20
    • continue the discussion on the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • got clarification on the workshop organized by TTA - Kaz will give a talk
    • additional documents mentioned during F2F that were not included in summary document
  • ECHONET
    • discussing how to proceed with the disussion on concrete binding between ECHONET and WoT
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • some specific examples would be useful
    • parts are also used as upper ontology for ECLASS, so we will pick up a few things if we start with ECLASS
  • ECLASS
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page
    • an example was given during the F2F that used ECLASS for Thing metadata, but there may be other use cases for interaction annotation; to be discussed
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline - discussion expected during the Use Cases call
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

14 July 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Lagally

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications
• Minutes
  • July-7 main call
  • June vF2F - Day 4 (Open Day)
• Quick updates
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June and need to re-Charter
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel and Issue 966 on the wot repo
    • Draft new Charter
    • Need to look at new template, however: https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/966
    • Need to finalize before August 2
  • W3C Smart Cities Workshop
    • Draft report under review
    • Chair(s) to be identified
    • IG creation to be proposed on the strategy funnel
• Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery
      • Would like to publish update, will probably call for a resolution next week
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
    • WoT Security Best Practices
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
    • need to follow up on the email response around the expected joint meeting, etc.
    • also invited to a wokshop organized by TTA; need further clarification
  • ECHONET
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
    • need clarification on concrete binding between ECHONET and WoT
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
  • ECLASS
    • joint discussion during the Use Cases call on July 13
    • need clarification on how to refer to their ontologies from TD
    • also a question about ECLASS logo on the WoT web page
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • joint discussion during the vF2F on June 28
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

7 July 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Sebastian

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert applications
    • Thomas Jaeckle, Bosch.io - accepted
• Minutes
  • June-16 main call
  • June vF2F
• Quick updates
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June and need to re-Charter
    • Issue 274 on the strategy funnel and Issue 966 on the wot repo
    • Draft new Charter
    • Need to look at new template, however: https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/966
    • Need to finalize before August 2
  • W3C Smart Cities Workshop
    • Next steps: generate report
• Testfest followup
  • Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • To do:
    • Create draft Implementation report for each deliverable
      • TD done
      • Need to do Architecture, Profiles, and Discovery
    • Capture implementation descriptions, update reports
      • Move main implementation descriptions to Architecture
    • Identify testing gaps
    • Create test plans for CR transition
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• Publication planning
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery
      • Would like to publish update, will probably call for a resolution next week
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
    • WoT Security Best Practices
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Status: need to follow up on email response
  • ECHONET
    • discussing next steps
    • asking them about how to proceed
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
  • ECLASS
    • In communication with Christian Block of ECLASS office
    • WoT Liaison, ECLASS logo on web page, etc.
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • Held sessions during IETF 111, hackathon
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA - need use case PR
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

16 June 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Ege

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert application
• Minutes
  • June-9 main call
• Quick updates
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June and need to re-Charter
    • Kaz has created Issue 274 on the strategy funnel and Issue 966 on the wot repo
    • Draft new Charter has been updated; please review
    • Need to look at new template, however...
    • Aim to finalize during F2F
    • will be discussed by W3M today (June 16) and we'll ask for a 6-month extension to finalize the procedure
  • Linked Data Signatures WG Proposed Charter - any updates?
    • Proposed charter
    • Issue tracker
    • Endorsements
    • Comment by McCool - WoT work on canonicalization signing
    • Review/feedback issue - endorsement, updated comment wrt TD Signing PR (TD Signing PR)
    • TD Canonicalization and Signatures...
      • See https://pr-preview.s3.amazonaws.com/mmccool/wot-thing-description/pull/1151.html#signature
  • W3C Smart Cities Workshop
    • official CfP - 25 June 2021
    • Three presentations from WoT; pre-recorded video recording is ongoing
      • McCool (representing the WoT-WG/IG): The Web of Things in the Smart City - recording done; working on editing and captions still
      • Andrea (smart communities): to be reviewed; to be recorded on June 16
      • Sebastian (Standardized Service Orchestration): to be reviewed; to be recorded on June 17
    • Next steps: upload drafts to wot-marketing repo as above; record 6-min videos for the presentations using the W3C zoom service (including 1m talking head self-intro, then 5m slides)
    • need to decide the concrete times (expecting two separate sessions on June 25)
  • Brief report from the Voice Agent Interoperability Workshop - Kaz
• Testfest report
  • Testing needed prior to CR transition
  • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • another 1-2h call Friday June 18
  • Testfest wiki
  • Event repo
• vF2F agenda finalization
  • Dates set: June 21-July 2 - doodle
    • 21 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
    • 22 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
    • 23 June: 9:00-12:00 EDT (3h)
    • 28 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
    • 29 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
    • 30 June: 9:00-12:00 EDT (3h)
    • 2 July: 8:00-11:00 (opt, 3h, only as long as needed)
  • Draft vF2F wiki
• Publication planning
  • IG
    • Use Cases and Requirements
  • WG
    • WoT Thing Description
    • WoT Binding Templates
    • WoT Architecture
    • WoT Profile
    • WoT Discovery
    • WoT Scripting API
    • WoT Security
    • WoT Security Best Practices
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Status: response formal request for meeting pending
    • Also update on some (new) Smart Cities activity
      • Liaison statement sent to the ITU-T SG20
      • They confirmed they discussed in their meeting May 17-27
  • ECHONET
    • their WG discussing the next steps for use case description and plugfest
    • asking them about how to proceed
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
  • ECLASS
    • Under discussion...
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • Update meeting planned for June 21; WISHI call June 17; see calendar above
    • McCool present WoT update (similar to Smart City slides)
    • Note various schedule overlaps between IETF Hackathon and IETF 111 with WoT vF2F
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

9 June 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Sebastian

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert application
    • Debbie Perouli from Marquette University
• Minutes
  • June-2 main call
• Quick updates
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June and need to re-Charter
    • Kaz is talking with Wendy about the procedure, and will register a dedicated issue on the strategy funnel for the Draft new Charter
  • Linked Data Signatures WG Proposed Charter - any updates?
    • Proposed charter
    • Issue tracker
    • Endorsements
    • Comment by McCool - WoT work on canonicalization signing
    • Review/feedback issue - endorsement, updated comment wrt TD Signing PR (TD Signing PR)
    • TD Canonicalization and Signatures...
      • See https://pr-preview.s3.amazonaws.com/mmccool/wot-thing-description/pull/1151.html#signature
  • W3C Smart Cities Workshop
    • official CfP - 25 June 2021
    • Three presentations from WoT should be coordinated to avoid overlaps/redundancy
      • McCool (representing the WoT-WG/IG): The Web of Things in the Smart City - reviewed during the Marketing call on June 1; recording done, working on editing and captions still
      • Andrea: Shifting from smart cities to smart communities using Web technologies - to be reviewed
      • Sebastian: Standardized Service Orchestration in Smart City - to be reviewed
    • Next steps: upload drafts to wot-marketing as above; record 5-min videos for the presentations using the W3C zoom service (actually, 1-2m talking head self-intro, then 5m slides)
  • Testfest/Plugfest
    • CURRENTLY IN PROGRESS
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • June 7-10 (1h), 11 (2h), opt 18 (1-2h)
      • 9am Eastern every day June 7-11 for 1h for a sync call
      • a slightly longer call on Friday June 11 (2h)
      • (optionally) another 1-2h call Friday June 18
    • Testfest wiki
    • Event repo
    • All other meetings cancelled this week!
  • vF2F
    • Dates set: June 21-July 2 - doodle
      • 21 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 22 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 23 June: 9:00-12:00 EDT (3h)
      • 28 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 29 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 30 June: 9:00-12:00 EDT (3h)
      • 2 July: 8:00-11:00 (opt, 3h, only as long as needed)
    • Draft vF2F wiki
    • Next week main call need to finalize schedule!
• Publication status
  • All three updates have now been published
  • Use Cases and Requirements (IG Note)
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • updated WD published
  • WoT Thing Description (WG WD)
    • updated WD published
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Status: response formal request for meeting pending
    • Also update on some (new) Smart Cities activity
      • Liaison statement sent to the ITU-T SG20
      • They confirmed they discussed in their meeting May 17-27
  • ECHONET
    • their WG discussing the next steps for use case description and plugfest
    • asking them about how to proceed
  • ISO TC184/SC4
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
  • ECLASS
    • Under discussion...
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • Update meeting planned for June 21; WISHI call June 17; see calendar above
    • McCool present WoT update (similar to Smart City slides)
    • Note various schedule overlaps between IETF Hackathon and IETF 111 with WoT vF2F
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

2 June 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: any?

Scribe: TBD

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert application
    • none
• Minutes
  • May-26 main call
• Quick updates
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June and need to re-Charter
    • Kaz talking with the W3M about the procedure
    • Draft new Charter to be updated
  • Linked Data Signatures WG Proposed Charter - any updates?
    • Proposed charter
    • Issue tracker
    • Endorsements
    • Comment by McCool - WoT work on canonicalization signing
    • Review/feedback issue - endorsement?
    • TD Canonicalization and Signatures...
      • See https://pr-preview.s3.amazonaws.com/mmccool/wot-thing-description/pull/1151.html#signature
  • Proposals for the Smart Cities workshop
    • official CfP - 25 June 2021
    • 3 proposals from the WoT group - All the three presentations should be coordinated to avoid overlaps/redundancy
      • McCool (representing the WoT-WG/IG): The Web of Things in the Smart City - reviewed during the Marketing call on June 1
      • Andrea: Shifting from smart cities to smart communities using Web technologies - to be reviewed
      • Sebastian: Standardized Service Orchestration in Smart City - to be reviewed
    • Next steps: draft presentations (5m)
      • review in the main call today?June 1 (deadline: June 11)
      • to be recorded using the W3C Zoom service moderated by Kaz (with captions scribed by Kaz :)
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Dates set: June 7-10 (1h), 11 (2h), opt 18 (1-2h)
      • 9am Eastern every day June 7-11 for 1h for a sync call
      • a slightly longer call on Friday June 11 (2h)
      • (optionally) another 1-2h call Friday June 18
    • Testfest wiki
    • Event repo
    • Need to discuss meeting cancellations next week!
  • vF2F
    • Dates set: June 21-July 2 - doodle
      • 21 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 22 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 23 June: 9:00-12:00 EDT (3h)
      • 28 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 29 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 30 June: 9:00-12:00 EDT (3h)
      • 2 July: 8:00-11:00 (opt, 3h, only as long as needed)
    • Draft vF2F wiki
• Publication status
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • Release candidate
    • Resolution to publish previously made
    • Publication preparation ongoing - to be published Wednesday, June 2 (today!) using Echidna
    • Needed to update change log (now done)
  • WoT Thing Description (WG WD)
    • release candidate
    • Resolution to publish made during the previous main call
    • Publication preparation ongoing
      • if the changes log is OK, the draft will be published today on June 2 using Echidna
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Action: formal request for meeting
      • Liaison statement sent to the ITU-T SG20
      • They confirmed they'll discuss in their meeting May 17-27
  • ECHONET
    • their WG discussing the next steps for use case description and plugfest
    • asking them about how to proceed
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • continue the liaison discussion with ISO TC184/SC4 instead, who are working on actual ontology definition for industries
  • ECLASS
    • Under discussion...
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • Update meeting planned for June 21; WISHI call June 17; see calendar above
    • McCool or Sebastian to present WoT update
    • Note various overlaps between IETF Hackathon and IETF 111 with WoT vF2F
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• Andrea has submitted a workshop proposal (on discovery in IoT, "DIoT") to the IoT conference
  • https://iot-conference.org/iot2021/call-for-workshops/
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

26 May 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Regrets: any?

Scribe: McCool

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert application
    • Thomas Jäckle, Eclipse Ditto (and Bosch IO), replacing Kevin Otolo
• Minutes
  • May-19 main call
• Quick updates
  • IG Charter expires at the end of June
    • need to re-Charter
    • also need a short-term extension for the re-Charter procedure (Kaz will request)
    • Need to update charter; draft will be here
  • Linked Data Signatures WG Proposed Charter - any updates?
    • Proposed charter
    • Issue tracker
    • Endorsements
    • Comment by McCool - WoT work on canonicalization signing
    • Review/feedback issue - endorsement?
    • TD Signatures (TDS)
      • Proposal: Base on XML Signatures and Advanced XML Signatures, but using JSON Pointers for filters and a limited cryptosuite (SHA-256 + NIST-P256 and X25519). Need to add ability to canonicalize a *TD Fragment* or *Partial TD*, not just a TD, though. LDS based on RDF processing, TDS to be based on JSON processing. So in the long run, could support both. Might also support other kinds later... e.g. DID Signatures (currently in (second) CR).
      • See https://pr-preview.s3.amazonaws.com/mmccool/wot-thing-description/pull/1151.html#signature
  • Proposals for the Smart Cities workshop
    • official CfP - 25 June 2021
      • Proposals sent out to the Program Committee
        • McCool (representing the WoT-WG/IG): The Web of Things in the Smart City
        • Andrea: Shifting from smart cities to smart communities using Web technologies
        • Sebastian: Standardized Service Orchestration in Smart City
      • Next steps: draft presentations: 5m, review in Marketing call June 1; deadline is June 11
      • Note: All the three presentations should be coordinated to avoid overlaps/redundancy
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Dates set: June 7-10 (1h), 11 (2h), opt 18 (1-2h)
      • 9am Eastern every day June 7-11 for 1h for a sync call
      • a slightly longer call on Friday June 11 (2h)
      • (optionally) another 1-2h call Friday June 18
    • Testfest wiki
    • Event repo
  • vF2F
    • Dates set: June 21-July 2 - doodle
      • 21 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 22 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 23 June: 9:00-12:00 EDT (3h)
      • 28 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 29 June: 8:00-10:00 EDT (2h)
      • 30 June: 9:00-12:00 EDT (3h)
      • 2 July: 8:00-11:00 (opt, 3h, only as long as needed)
    • Draft vF2F wiki
• Publication status
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • Release candidate
    • Resolution to publish
    • Publication preparation ongoing - to be published Thursday, May 27 using Echidna
  • WoT Thing Description (WG WD)
    • release candidate
    • Resolution to publish made during the previous main call
    • Publication preparation ongoing - to be published Thursday, June 1 using Echidna
    • Note: using temporary namespaces
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Action: formal request for meeting
      • Liaison statement sent to the ITU-T SG20
      • They confirmed they'll discuss in their meeting May 17-27
  • ECHONET
    • their WG discussing the next steps for use case description and plugfest
    • asking them about how to proceed
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • continue the liaison discussion with ISO TC184/SC4 instead, who are working on actual ontology definition for industries
  • ECLASS
    • Under discussion...
  • T2TRG/IETF
    • Update meeting planned for June 17 or 21 or 22 (doodle ongoing)
    • McCool or Sebastian to present WoT update
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• Andrea plans to submit a workshop proposal to the IoT conference
  • https://iot-conference.org/iot2021/call-for-workshops/
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

19 May 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Cristiano

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • Invited Expert application
    • Jürgen Pannosch (TUW - Technical University of Vienna)
• Minutes
  • May-12 main call
• Quick updates
  • Linked Data Signatures WG Proposed Charter
    • Proposed charter
    • Issue tracker
    • Endorsements
    • Comment by McCool - WoT work on canonicalization signing
    • Review/feedback issue - endorsement?
    • TD Signatures (TDS)
      • Proposal: Base on XML Signatures and Advanced XML Signatures, but using JSON Pointers for filters and a limited cryptosuite (SHA-256 + NIST-P256 and X25519). Need to add ability to canonicalize a *TD Fragment* or *Partial TD*, not just a TD, though. LDS based on RDF processing, TDS to be based on JSON processing. So in the long run, could support both. Might also support other kinds later... e.g. DID Signatures (currently in (second) CR).
  • Proposals for the Smart Cities workshop
    • official CfP - 25 June 2021
      • Proposals sent out to the Program Committee
        • McCool (representing the WoT-WG/IG): The Web of Things in the Smart City
        • Andrea: Shifting from smart cities to smart communities using Web technologies
        • Sebastian: Standardized Service Orchestration in Smart City
      • Next steps: draft presentation: 5m, review in late May; deadline is June 11
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Dates set: June 7-10 (1h), 11 (2h), opt 18 (1-2h)
      • 9am Eastern every day June 7-11 for 1h for a sync call
      • a slightly longer call on Friday June 11 (2h)
      • (optionally) another 1-2h call Friday June 18
    • Testfest wiki
    • Event repo
  • vF2F
    • Doodle
    • Draft vF2F wiki
• Call for Resolutions planned
  • WoT Thing Description (WG WD)
    • finalized candidate draft two weeks ago
    • call for resolution to publish
    • but... two pending PRs to informative sections
      • Change log
      • Abstract and introduction updated to include TM
    • Note: using temporary namespaces
• Publication status
  • WoT Use Cases and Requirements (IG Note)
    • First Public IG Note published on May 18
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • Release candidate
    • Resolution to publish made during the previous main call
    • Publication preparation ongoing - to be published Thursday, May 20 using Echidna
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Action: formal request for meeting
      • Liaison statement sent to the ITU-T SG20
      • They confirmed they'll discuss in their meeting May 17-27
  • ECHONET
    • their WG discussing the next steps for use case description and plugfest
    • asking them about how to proceed
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • Kaz talked with them about the next steps on Monday, May 17
    • got suggestion we liaise with ISO TC184/SC4, who are working on actual ontologie definition for industries (Kaz thinks the relationship between IEC CDD and ISO TC184/SC4 is kind of like the relationship between JSON-LD and TD.)
  • ECLASS
    • Under discussion...
  • T2TRG/IETF
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

12 May 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Michael Lagally

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (just rejoined)
    • Vlad Baruta (Schaeffler, 6mo, approved, just joined)
• Minutes
  • May-5 main call
• Quick updates
  • Linked Data Signatures WG Proposed Charter
    • Proposed charter
    • Issue tracker
    • Endorsements
    • Comment by McCool - WoT work on canonicalization signing
    • Review/feedback issue - endorsement?
  • Proposals for the Smart Cities workshop
    • official CfP - 25 June 2021
      • Proposals sent out to the Program Committee
        • McCool (representing the WoT-WG/IG): The Web of Things in the Smart City
        • Andrea: Shifting from smart cities to smart communities using Web technologies
        • Sebastian: Standardized Service Orchestration in Smart City
      • Next steps: draft presentation: 10m, review in late May; deadline is June 11
  • Next Generation IoT (NGIoT) workshop
    • Dave will give a presentation about Web of Things
    • https://www.ngiot.eu/event/ngiot-thematic-workshop-health-and-care/
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Dates set: June 7-10 (1h), 11 (2h), opt 18 (1-2h)
      • 9am Eastern every day June 7-11 for 1h for a sync call
      • a slightly longer call on Friday June 11 (2h)
      • (optionally) another 1-2h call Friday June 18
    • Testfest wiki
    • Event repo
  • vF2F
    • Doodle
    • Draft vF2F wiki
• Call for Resolutions planned
  • WoT Thing Description (WG WD)
    • finalized candidate draft in last week's TD call
    • call for resolution to publish on May 19
• Publications in Preparation
  • WoT Use Cases and Requirements (IG Note)
    • Release candidate
    • Transition request approved - to be published tomorrow, May 13
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • Release candidate
    • Resolution to publish made during the previous main call
    • Publication preparation ongoing - to be published next Tuesday, May 18 using Echidna
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • Action: formal request for meeting
      • Liaison statement sent to the ITU-T SG20
      • They confirmed they'll discuss in their meeting May 17-27
  • ECHONET
    • their WG discussing the next steps for use case description and plugfest
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • Kaz has sent yet another reminder and will talk with them about the next steps on Monday, May 17
  • ECLASS
    • Under discussion...
  • T2TRG/IETF
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

5 May 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: any?

Scribe: Sebastian

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (ongoing)
    • Vlad Baruta (Schaeffler, 6mo, approved, in process)
• Minutes
  • Apr-28 main call
• Quick updates
  • Proposals for the Smart Cities workshop
    • official CfP
    • Proposed date: June 25
    • Updated deadline for proposals: May 10
      • Proposal
        • WoT Intro
        • Summary of Smart City use cases so far
        • Challenges
      • McCool submitted (shortened) abstract
      • Next steps: draft presentation: 10m, review in late May; deadline is June 11
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Dates set: June 7-10 (1h), 11 (2h), opt 18 (1-2h)
      • 9am Eastern every day June 7-11 for 1h for a sync call
      • a slightly longer call on Friday June 11 (2h)
      • (optionally) another 1-2h call Friday June 18
    • Testfest wiki
    • Event repo
  • vF2F
    • Doodle
    • Draft vF2F wiki
• Call for Resolutions planned
  • WoT Thing Description (WG WD)
    • expect to finalize candidate draft today in TD call
    • will call for resolution to publish on May 19
• Publications in Preparation
  • WoT Use Cases and Requirements (IG Note)
    • Release candidate
    • Transition request approved
    • Publication preparation ongoing
    • aiming for publication next Tuesday, May 11
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • Release candidate
    • Resolution to publish made during the previous main call
    • Publication preparation ongoing
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • follow-up call held Apr-13
    • Action: formal request for meeting
      • draft
      • sent today
      • They will discuss in their meeting May 17-27
  • ECHONET
    • ongoing
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • Kaz has sent yet another reminder and waiting for their response
  • ECLASS
    • Under discussion...
  • T2TRG/IETF
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

28 April 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Regrets: Lagally

Scribe: Philipp

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (ongoing)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Apr-21 main call
• Quick updates
  • AC meeting debriefing (note: part of the AC topics are Member-only)
    • WoT Mention - Alibaba Digital Twin (Member-only)
  • Proposals for the Smart Cities workshop
    • official CfP
    • Proposed date: June 25
    • Deadline for proposals: April 30
    • WoT Intro
      • Summary of Smart City use cases so far
      • Proposal: McCool to do a final draft, review during the main call today
      • Initial proposal: one paragraph, email, resolution during the main call
      • Presentation: 10m, draft, review in May
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Needed before July 1 CR transition - some time in June?
    • Doodle poll June 7-23, day(s) and time(s)
  • vF2F
    • Doodle
• Publications in Preparation
  • WoT Use Cases and Requirements (IG Note)
    • Release candidate
    • publication preparation ongoing - Transition request sent
      • Question: Do we really want to use "wot-use-cases-requirements" as the shortname for pubication?
      • Proposal: wot-usecases (no hyphen, no -requirements) would be shorter and consistent with the repo
• Calls for Publication Resolutions
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • Release candidate
    • Resolution proposal: "Publish an updated version of the WoT Discovery WD as identified by the branch https://github.com/w3c/wot-discovery/tree/wd-update-candidate."
    • see also McCool's Call for Review message
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • follow-up call held Apr-13
    • Action: revised draft for formal email request for meeting
  • ECHONET
    • liaison table updated with WoT liaison
    • Kaz attended the Echonet Lite WebAPI WG meeting on April 28, and confirmed we'll work on Use Cases and Plugfest collaboratively.
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • still waiting for responses - Kaz will nudge them
  • ECLASS
    • Under discussion...
  • T2TRG/IETF
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
    • GaiaX
    • Solid CG
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

21 April 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Regrets: Lagally

Scribe: Ege

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (ongoing)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Apr-14 main call
  • vF2F minutes - already reviewed, and to be approved
• Quick updates
  • AC meeting will be held on April 26-27 at 13:30-15:00 UTC
    • overlap with Discovery on Monday, April 26
  • Proposals for the Smart Cities workshop
    • official CfP
    • Proposed date: June 25
    • Deadline for proposals: April 30
    • WoT Participation?
      • WoT Intro
      • Summary of Smart City use cases so far
      • Proposal: McCool to do a draft, review during the main call today
        • Initial proposal: one paragraph, email, resolution during the main call
        • Presentation: 10m, draft, review in May
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Needed before July 1 CR transition - some time in June?
    • Doodle poll June 7-23, day(s) and time(s)
  • Blog Post
    • official blog post published
    • Note: In general in calls for review, [public-wot-ig@w3.org] should be used
• Publications in Preparation
  • WoT Use Cases and Requirements (IG Note)
    • Release candidate
    • resolution to publish made last week; publication preparation ongoing
• Calls for Publication Resolutions
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • Release candidate
    • Resolution planned for April 28
    • see also McCool's Call for Review message
• Coming Soon...
  • WoT Scripting API (WG Note)
    • Release candidate
• Liaisons
  • ITU-T SG20
    • follow-up call held Apr-13
    • Action: draft and discuss formal email request for meeting
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • still waiting for responses - Kaz will nudge them
  • ECHONET
    • liaison table updated with WoT liaison
    • Kaz proposed to their HQ we work on Use Cases and Plugfest collaboratively.
    • They're basically ok but need to get consensus within their HQ committee.
    • Kaz will continue to help them.
  • T2TRG/IETF
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

14 April 2021

Chair: McCool

Regrets: Lagally, Sebastian

Scribe: Farshid

Next time: Ege

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Konstantinos Kotis (approved)
      • IoT ontologies, energy management
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Mar-10 main call
  • Apr-7 main call
  • vF2F minutes
• Quick updates
  • Smart Cities
    • official CfP published
    • Proposed date: June 25
    • Deadline for proposals: April 30
    • WoT Participation?
      • WoT Intro
      • Summary of Smart City use cases so far
      • Proposal: McCool to do a draft, review next week
        • Initial proposal: one paragraph, email, resolution next week
        • Presentation: 10m, draft, review in May
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Needed before July 1 CR transition - some time in June?
    • Doodle poll June 7-25, day(s) and time(s)
• Blog Post
  • Resolution needed before publication
  • Draft PR
• Pending Publications
• Resolutions Needed for Publication
  • Note: In general in calls for review, [public-wot-ig@w3.org] should be used
  • WoT Use Cases and Requirements (IG Note)
    • Release candidate
    • see also Lagally's Call for Review message
• Calls for Publication Resolutions
  • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
    • Release candidate
    • see also McCool's Call for Review message
  • WoT Scripting API (WG Note)
    • Release candidate
• Liaison
  • ITU-T SG20
    • follow-up call held Apr-13
    • Action: draft and discuss formal email request for meeting
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
    • still waiting for responses - Kaz will nudge them
  • ECHONET
    • Kaz got update from their HQ saying ECHONET HQ would like to continue the W3C liaison even more actively this year
    • will have another call for planning with them
  • T2TRG/IETF
  • OneDM
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
    • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
  • OpenAR
    • AR applications of WoT
    • AR use cases
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
    • NOTE: "main" branch is now a live website; should not update directly without review
    • Marketing policies updated based on the discussion at vF2F
    • updates from Apr-13 call
      • Blog post: PR 158, PR 159
      • Captions: Issue 141, PR 152
    • Discussion still ongoing about the W3C policy on video installation - how to handle videos in China since YouTube does not work...
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

7 April 2021

Chair: McCool

Regrets: Sebastian

Scribe: Kaz

Note: No resolutions today, including for review of past minutes.

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • Membership classes and fees
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • To be reviewed in next main call
  • TFs should review minutes for their own sessions in the F2F
  • Mar-10 main call
  • vF2F minutes
• Quick updates
  • All repos now use "main" as default branch
    • Remember to update any forks or copies!
  • Daylight Saving Time changes
    • See the announcement sent to the Chairs list
  • VPN service on AWS to be renewed
    • Different host name, resources moved... needs to be checked
    • Kaz's message on the Member list
  • Smart Cities
    • draft CfP available
    • official announcement to be made
  • Testfest/Plugfest planning
    • Testing needed prior to CR transition
    • Goal: create draft Implementation Report, identify testing gaps, create test plan for CR transition
    • Needed before July 1 CR transition
    • June?
  • WoT Marketing Update
    • NOTE: "main" branch is now a live website; should not update directly without review
    • New marketing policies requiring review before release
    • Policy updated with tweet policy as discussed
    • Captions
      • Junde Yhi has generated Simplified Chinese captions - merged, reviewed (by W3C Beihang team)
      • Cristiano has generated Italian captions - merged, reviewed
      • Coralie has generated French captions - need review
      • Other languages pending: German and Japanese
    • Discussion ongoing about how to handle videos in China... YouTube does not work...
  • Pending Publications
    • 2 weeks review started
    • 1 week left - resolution planned for next main call
    • Note: In general in calls for review, [public-wot-ig@w3.org] should be used
    • WoT Use Cases and Requirements (IG Note)
      • Release candidate
      • see also Lagally's Call for Review message
    • WoT Discovery (WG WD)
      • Release candidate
    • WoT Scripting API (IG Note)
      • Release candidate
  • Liaison
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
      • wait responses from them
    • ITU-T SG20
      • doodle ongoing
    • T2TRG/IETF
    • OneDM
    • OPC UA
      • Proposal on further collaboration
      • Collecting interested members
      • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
    • OGC
      • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
      • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
      • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
      • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
      • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery
    • OpenAR
      • AR applications of WoT
      • AR use cases
    • ECHONET
      • Kaz talked with them on March 5 and clarified how to proceed
      • basically reboot the liaison for further collaboration
      • presentation on their latest WebAPI work on March 15
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

10 March 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Sebastian

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Mar-3 main call
  • Mar-4 liaison call minutes
• Quick updates
  • Daylight Saving Time changes
    • US Daylight Saving will start on March 14, and European Summer Time will start on March 28.
    • From March 15 till March 26: the main call starts at the same time in US, but one hour earlier in the other countries.
    • After March 28: all the calls start at the same time in US and Europe, but remains one hour earlier in the non-summertime countries like China, Singapore, Korea and Japan.
    • see also the announcement sent to the Chairs list
  • WoT Marketing Update
    • NOTE: "main" branch is now live website; should not update directly without review
    • New marketing policies requiring review before release confirmed on March 9
    • Minor change review: PR 134
    • Additional minor change review: PR 133
    • Other Tentative Minor PRs
    • Captions
      • Got volunteer for Simplified Chinese captions (could still use a volunteer for Traditional Chinese)
      • Also Cristiano has generated Italian captions
      • Other languages pending (German, Japanese, etc.)
    • Discussion ongoing about how to handle videos in China... YouTube does not work...
  • Publication plan for WoT Use Cases Note
    • Release candidate available
      • 2 weeks review started
      • discussion during the vF2F on March 18 and final decision on March 25
      • publication after that
      • see also Lagally's Call for Review message
        • Note: In general in calls for review, [public-wot-ig@w3.org] should be used
  • Renaming the "master" branches to "main" (Member-only)
    • Every repo' default branch now renamed
    • Some trouble with GitHub pages functionality and 404 errors, but already fixed
    • Please fix forks and local copies - See notes below under "Repo Management"
• Plugfest and Virtual F2F Planning
  • Plugfest: March 1-5
    • Summary results
    • Summary presentation in progress; will work on during plugfest call after this call, present during F2F
    • Will also review plugfest minutes during plugfest call
  • F2F: March 15, 17, 18, 22, 24, and 25
    • Agenda updates?
    • Please focus on presenting to others not in your TF
    • Put presentations here (ideally in advance)
    • Opening, closing, and some presentation material already there
• Liaisons and Joint calls
  • Liaison discussion right before the PlugFest on March 4 - see minutes
  • Confirmed meetings/calls
    • WebThings
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
      • joint discussion during the vF2F meeting on March 15 (in prep for their own March 17 meeting)
      • Relationship to ECLASS
      • confirmed they'll join at the beginning of the vF2F day 1 on March 15
    • ITU-T SG20
      • got confirmation from Gyu Myoung from SG20 that he'll join the vF2F call on March 22 to discuss our understanding on the ITU-T use cases
  • Ongoing
    • T2TRG/IETF
      • Tentative confirmation
      • https://github.com/t2trg/2021-03-hackathon
      • https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
      • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-rest-iot
      • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-iot-edge-computing
      • Relevant topics at IETF: JSON, DNS, CBOR, CORE, CoAP, etc.
      • DNS-based discovery
      • 10-15m slot reserved in 2h T2TRG update session
      • Summary presentation - please review (known issues: Sebastian's title, Profiles...)
    • OneDM
      • Summary by Michael Koster?
      • Possible joint call in the future?
    • OPC UA
      • Proposal on further collaboration
      • Collecting interested members
      • Need to clarify the targets (goals, use cases, outcomes, documents...) and timeline
    • OGC
      • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
      • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
      • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
      • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
      • Also OGC GeoSPARQL which is relevant to discovery...
    • ECHONET
      • Kaz talked with them on March 5 and clarified how to proceed
      • basically reboot the liaison for further collaboration
      • presentation on their latest WebAPI work on March 15
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

3 March 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Scribe: Michael Lagally

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Feb-24 main call
• Quick updates
  • WoT Marketing
    • New WoT Welcome page was released on March 1st
    • Animation also available including captions - additional languages (other than English) to be added
    • Procedure for making important decision to be clarified
  • Publication plan for WoT Use Cases Note
    • preliminary review by the whole group ongoing
    • resolution for publication during the vF2F
    • publication after that
  • Renaming the "master" branches to "main" (Member-only)
    • done: wot-testing, wot-discovery, wot-security, wot-thing-description
    • please fix local copies - See notes below under "Repo Management"
    • to be done on March 4th: wot-scripting-api, wot-marketing, wot, wot-profile, wot-binding-templates, wot-architecture, wot-usecases
• Plugfest and Virtual F2F Planning
  • Plugfest: March 1-5
    • Cancellations
  • F2F: March 15, 17, 18, 22, 24, and 25
    • Agendas updates?
    • Please focus on presenting to others not in your TF
    • Put presentations here (ideally in advance)
• Liaisons and Joint calls
  • Liaison discussion right before the PlugFest on March 4 - see also th Doodle results
    • WebEx
  • Confirmed meetings/calls
    • WebThings
    • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
      • joint discussion during the vF2F meeting on March 15 (in prep for their own March 17 meeting)
      • Relationship to ECLASS
      • confirmed they'll join at the beginning of the vF2F day 1 on March 15
    • ITU-T SG20
      • got confirmation from Gyu Myoung from SG20 that he'll join the vF2F call on March 22 to discuss our understanding on the ITU-T use cases
  • Ongoing
    • T2TRG
      • https://github.com/t2trg/2021-03-hackathon
      • https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
      • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-rest-iot
      • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-iot-edge-computing
    • IETF
      • TBD: JSON, DNS, CBOR, CORE, CoAP, etc.
      • DNS-based discovery
      • 10-15m slot reserved in 2h T2TRG update session
      • Workshop (2h open session)? Joint session during vF2F (1h joint session)?
    • OneDM
      • possible joint call?
    • OPC UA
      • Proposal on further collaboration
      • Collecting interested members
      • need to clarify the targets/timeline
    • OGC
      • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
      • the procedure to extend the liaison for WoT is ongoing
      • technical discussion can be continued meanwhile
      • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
    • ECHONET
      • Kaz will talk with them on March 5 to clarify how to proceed
  • Possible
    • APA
    • Microsoft DTDL
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

24 February 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Daniel

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Feb-17 main call
• Quick updates
  • Publication plan for WoT Use Cases Note
    • start preliminary review by the whole group today, Feb 24
    • resolution for publication during the vF2F
    • publication after that
  • Publication moratorium around the upcoming AC Meeting on April 26-27
    • no publications on April 23-29
  • Renaming the "master" branches to "main" (Member-only)
    • wot-discovery and wot-security have been updated; please fix local copies
    • See notes below under "Repo Management"
    • Still checking that PRs will be updated correctly, so hold off renaming other repos
  • Joint calls
    • Confirmed
      • WebThings
      • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
        • joint discussion during the vF2F meeting on March 15 (in prep for their own March 17 meeting)
        • Relationship to ECLASS
    • Pending
      • IRTF/IETF (T2TRG)
    • Possible
      • APA
      • Microsoft DTDL
• Plugfest and Virtual F2F Planning
  • Plugfest: March 1-5
    • Cancellations next week?
  • F2F: March 15, 17, 18, 22, 24, and 25
    • Agendas should be finalized this week, including time estimates
    • Please focus on presenting to others not in your TF
    • Put presentations here (ideally in advance)
• Liaisons
  • Doodle for Liaison discussion
  • T2TRG
    • https://github.com/t2trg/2021-03-hackathon
    • https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-rest-iot
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-iot-edge-computing
  • IETF
    • TBD: JSON, DNS, CBOR, CORE, CoAP, etc.
    • DNS-based discovery
    • 10-15m slot reserved in 2h T2TRG update session
    • Workshop (2h open session)? Joint session during vF2F (1h joint session)?
  • OneDM
    • possible joint call?
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • need to clarify the targets/timeline
  • ITU-T SG20
    • will ask SG20 guys about our understanding
    • asking their availability - possibly during the vF2F
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • currently liaising with SDWIG
    • liaison contacts from OGC have been updated + asking them to extend the liaison for WoT as well
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
  • ECHONET
    • alignment of web APIs
    • Kaz will talk with them on March 5 to clarify how to proceed
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
    • Geospatial information proposal
  • Marketing
    • New webpage launch: March 1st
    • Animation ready including captions; to be launched at the same time
    • PR 128 add information on the WoT-JP CG
    • Please review material before end of the month, i.e., Feb 28
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

17 February 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Scribe: McCool

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Feb-10 main call
• Quick updates
  • TPAC to be virtual this year; so we should plan on a virtual fall F2F
  • WoT Japanese CG
    • Saturday Feb 27 virtual meeting planned
    • CG GitHub repo
    • How to handle on the WoT CG Welcome page?
      • Issue 121 created for further discusssion
  • Renaming the "master" branches to "main" (Member-only)
    • See notes below under "Repo Management"
  • Joint calls
    • Planning
      • WebThings
      • APA
      • IETF/ITRF (T2TRG)
      • Microsoft DTDL
      • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
        • confirmed they'll join the vF2F meeting on March 15 (in prep for their own March 17 meeting)
        • Relationship to ECLASS
• Plugfest and Virtual F2F Planning
  • Plugfest: March 1-5
  • F2F: March 15, 17, 18, 22, 24, and 25
• Liaisons
  • T2TRG
    • https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-rest-iot
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-iot-edge-computing
  • IETF
    • TBD: JSON, DNS, CBOR, CORE, CoAP, etc.
    • DNS-based discovery
    • 10-15m slot reserved in 2h T2TRG update session
    • Workshop (2h open session)? Joint session during vF2F (1h joint session)?
  • OneDM
    • possible joint call?
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal on further collaboration
    • Collecting interested members
    • need to clarify the targets/timeline
  • ITU-T SG20
    • will ask SG20 guys about our understanding
    • asking their availability - possibly during the vF2F
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • currently liaising with SDWIG
    • liaison contacts from OGC have been updated + asking them to extend the liaison for WoT as well
    • OGC GeoPose and WoT Geolocation proposal
  • ECHONET
    • alignment of web APIs
    • need to update the liaison contacts (like OGC) + clarify how to proceed
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
    • Geospatial information proposal
  • Marketing
    • New webpage launch: March 1st
    • Please review material before end of the month (1.5 wks from now...)
    • Animation mostly ready, except for captions; to be launched at the same time
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

10 February 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Raggett

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Philip Blum (approved)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Feb-3 main call
• Quick updates
  • WoT Japanese CG
    • CG launching event Feb 27 (in Japanese)
    • CG GitHub repo
    • How to handle on the WoT CG Welcome page?
      • Discuss in marketing; obsolete information at least needs to be removed
  • Renaming the "master" branches to "main" (Member-only)
    • Has been changed in w3c/wot-testing (and mccool/wot-testing)
    • Make sure to update your forks and local copies
    • BEFORE making change in local copies or fork, check in all pending edits/updates
    • Do NOT rebase a fork until you make this change
    • To change in forks, look under Settings/Branches and change "master" to "main"
    • For local copies...
      • easiest to delete and reclone
      • Alternatively, for local direct clones of the w3c repo

    git branch -m master main
    git fetch origin
    git branch -u origin/main main

• • • See above link for instructions
    • Note: github server has been crashing lately. Have fun!
  • Goals and Objectives
    • Publications and industry outreach
  • Joint calls
    • Planning
      • WebThings
      • Microsoft DTDL
      • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
        • inviting to the vF2F meeting in March (pref March 15 in prep for their own March 17 meeting)
        • Relationship to ECLASS
• Plugfest and Virtual F2F Planning
  • Plugfest: March 1-5
  • F2F: March 15, 17, 18, 22, 24, and 25
• Liaisons
  • T2TRG
    • https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-rest-iot
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-iot-edge-computing
  • IETF
    • TBD: JSON, DNS, CBOR, CORE, CoAP, etc.
    • DNS-based discovery
    • 10-15m slot reserved in 2h T2TRG update session
    • Workshop (2h open session)? Joint session during vF2F (1h joint session)?
  • OneDM
    • possible joint call?
  • OPC UA
    • Proposal to create new subgroup
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to develop "companion standard" joint charter
    • Can be an official joint activitycharter draft]
  • ITU-T SG20
    • discussed the summary in Use Case call on January 26
    • confirm SG20 guys about our understanding
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • collab with SDWIG
  • ECOHNET
    • alignment of web APIs?
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
    • Geospatial information proposal
  • Marketing
    • New webpage launch: March 1st
    • Please review material before end of the month
    • Animation ready; to be launched at the same time
  • Use Cases
  • PlugFest/Testing
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

3 February 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Scribe: Michael Koster

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • New Invited Experts
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Philip Blum?
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Jan-27 main call
  • APA joint meeting
    • agenda
• Quick updates
  • WoT Japanese CG created
  • Renaming the "master" branches to "main" (Member-only)
  • Joint calls
    • Planning
      • Microsoft DTDL
      • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries - IEC61360, IEC62656
        • Plan to invite to main call in the near future
        • Relationship to ECLASS
• Plugfest and Virtual F2F Planning
  • Plugfest: March 1-5
  • F2F: March 15, 17, 18, 22, 24, and 25
• Liaisons
  • T2TRG
    • https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-rest-iot
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-iot-edge-computing
  • IETF
    • TBD: JSON, DNS, CBOR, CORE, CoAP, etc.
    • DNS-based discovery
    • 10-15m slot reserved in 2h T2TRG update session
    • Workshop (2h open session)? Joint session during vF2F (1h joint session)?
  • OPC-UA
    • Proposal to create new subgroup
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to develop "companion standard" joint charter
    • Can be an official joint activity - Sebastian generates a proposal charter draft
  • ITU-T SG20
    • discussed the summary in Use Case call on January 26
    • confirm SG20 guys about our understanding
  • OGC
    • geospatial information models for TDs and discovery
    • collab with SDWIG
  • ECOHNET
    • alignment of web APIs?
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
    • partial TD, InteractionOutput
  • Security
    • URI template location for security scheme parameters
    • security issues in discovery
  • Discovery
    • Implementation status, security in discovery, SPARQL DDoS, information model
  • Marketing
    • Animation, web pages, wikipedia
  • Use Cases
    • no call this week
  • PlugFest/Testing
    • no call last week due to the APA joint call
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
    • defer issues to TD 2.0
    • draft TD context URI
    • apikey and psk security schemes
    • URI template loction for security scheme parameters
    • Thing Model
  • Architecture and Profiles
    • APA joint report
    • partial TD
    • TD fragment (-> perhaps change to TD element)
    • profile: max nesting, max size of profile-compliant TD, max number of objects, events are loosely constrained
• AOB?

27 January 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Ege

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • New Invited Experts
    • Christine Perey (AR, geospatial)
    • Michael Koster (pending)
    • Any others?
• Minutes
  • Jan-20 main call
  • Jan-19 AR joint call
• Quick updates
  • Joint calls
    • Upcoming
      • Accessibility/APA - Jan 27, 9am ET (replaces plugfest call TODAY): https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/953
    • Planning
      • Microsoft DTDL
• Virtual F2F Planning
  • Proposed:
    • Plugfest: March 1-5, 9am (?) ET - doodle
      • Does not seem to be one time good all days, so...
      • Monday - 8am ET
      • Tuesday - 9am ET
      • Wednesday - 9am ET
      • Thursday - 10am ET
      • Friday - 9am ET
    • Virtual F2F: March 15-26, 8-11am (?) ET - doodle
    • NOTE: US Daylight Saving starts on March 14, while European Summertime starts on March 28. See also http://www.webexhibits.org/daylightsaving/b.html
      • Results: 8am-11am ET generally works
      • Exceptions: Tuesdays, Fridays
      • 6 days, 3 hours each: 18h
      • Need minimum of 15h
      • Some conflicts on Thursdays... drop one?
• Liaisons
  • T2TRG
    • https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-rest-iot
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-iot-edge-computing
  • IETF
    • TBD: JSON, DNS, CBOR, CORE, CoAP, etc.
    • DNS-based discovery
    • 10-15m slot reserved in 2h T2TRG update session
    • Workshop?
  • OPC-UA
    • Proposal to create new subgroup
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to develop "companion standard" joint charter
    • Can be an official joint activity - Sebastian generating a proposal
  • ITU-T SG20
    • discussed the summary in Use Case call on January 26
    • confirm SG20 guys about our understanding
  • ISO
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary) - ontologies for various industries
    • IEC61360, IEC62656
    • DNS-based discovery
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
    • partial TD definition
  • Security
    • security architecture of home assistant/openhab
    • apikey and psk explanation improvement
    • add URI template location for security scheme parameters
  • Discovery
    • AR joint call
    • possible extension of OGC liaison for WoT
    • PRs on updating README for wot-usecases repo
    • Update for SPARQL DDoS editor's note
  • Marketing
    • Animation, web pages...
  • Use Cases
    • ITU-T use cases summary
    • OPC-UA Liaison
  • PlugFest/Testing
    • March plugfest planning...
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
    • defer issues to TD 2.0
    • observeAllProperties and unobserveAllProperties
    • link relation types
    • apikey and psk security schemes
    • URI template location for security scheme parameters
    • Extended forms in case of multiple op values
  • Architecture and Profiles
    • wot-profile FPWD feedback
• AOB?

20 January 2021

Chair: Sebastian/McCool

Scribe: McCool

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
  • New Invited Experts
    • Christine Perey
    • Others pending...
• Minutes
  • Jan-13
• Quick updates
  • Joint calls
    • Recently completed
      • Geolocation/SDW/AR Use Cases - Jan 19, 11am ET: https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/955
    • Upcoming
      • Accessibility/APA - Jan 27, 9am ET (replaces plugfest call): https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/953
    • Planning
      • Microsoft DTDL
• Virtual F2F Planning
  • Proposed:
    • Plugfest: March 1-5, 9am (?) ET - doodle
    • Virtual F2F: March 15-26, 8-11am (?) ET - doodle
    • NOTE: US Daylight Saving starts on March 14, while European Summertime starts on March 28. See also http://www.webexhibits.org/daylightsaving/b.html
• Liaisons
  • T2TRG
    • https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-rest-iot
    • https://github.com/t2trg/t2trg-iot-edge-computing
  • IETF
    • TBD: JSON, DNS, CBOR, CORE, CoAP, etc.
    • DNS-based discovery
  • OPC-UA
    • Proposal to create new subgroup
    • Collecting interested members
    • Need to develop "companion standard" joint charter
    • Can be an official joint activity
  • ITU-T SG20
    • To be discussed in Use Case call on March 26
  • ISO
  • IEC CDD (Common Data Dictionary)
    • IEC61360-1,2, IEC62656
    • DNS-based discovery
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
    • Animation, web pages...
  • PlugFest/Testing
    • March plugfest planning...
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Use Cases
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?

13 January 2021

Chair: McCool/Sebastian

Scribe: Daniel

• Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
  • W3C 2017 Patent Policy
  • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
• Minutes
  • Dec-16
• Quick updates
  • Joint calls
    • SDWWG - Jan 19, 11am ET: https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/955
    • APA - Jan 27, 9am ET (replaces plugfest call): https://github.com/w3c/wot/issues/953
    • Microsoft DTDL?
  • Publication follow-up
    • Architecture: https://github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/pull/576
    • TD: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pull/1027
    • Discovery: https://github.com/w3c/wot-discovery/pull/108
    • Profile: https://github.com/w3c/wot-profile/pull/62
    • Scripting API: https://github.com/w3c/wot-scripting-api/pull/288
• Virtual F2F Planning
  • proposed:
    • Plugfest: March 1-5, 9am (?) ET
      • Need a doodle to finalize...
    • Virtual F2F: March 15-26, 8-11am (?) ET
      • Need a doodle to finalize...
• Liaisons
  • IETF/ASDF/T2TRG
  • OPC-UA
  • ITU-T SG20
• TF Reports
  • Scripting
  • Security
  • Discovery
  • Marketing
    • Animation, web pages...
  • PlugFest/Testing
    • March plugfest planning...
  • Thing Description/Binding Templates
  • Use Cases
  • Architecture and Profiles
• AOB?