WG WoT Thing Description WebConf

WebConf Information

• Quick start guide
• Monday
  • Scripting WebConf
  • Security WebConf
  • Discovery WebConf
• Tuesday
  • Marketing WebConf
  • Proof-of-Concept WebConf
• Wednesday
  • Joint IG/WG WebConf
  • PlugFest/Testing WebConf
  • TD WebConf
• Thursday
  • Architecture WebConf
  • Use Case WebConf

See also the consolidated WoT Web meetings table on the main wiki page of the WoT IG/WG.

Obsolete calls

• Binding WebConf (now part of the TD WebConf)
• OCF Liaison WebConf
• Linked Data and Semantic Processing WebConf
• Test WebConf
• Charter WebConf

Wednesdays at 7am US Pacific / 10am US Eastern / 4pm Europe / 11pm China / 0am (Thu) Korea & Japan

This is a WoT WG WebConf and underlies the W3C Patent Policy

Note: The TD TF should consider adjusting the slot again after November 1, 2020.

Note: Due to the end of Daylight Savings, the call will start one hour earlier in Europe between October 25 and November 1 in 2020. Calls are all scheduled in US Eastern Time, European daylight savings starts on a different date, and many places do not have Daylight Savings at all, so the following changes will need to be observed:

• In Europe, calls will start one hour earlier after October 25 and then go back one hour later (=usual time) after November 1.
• In China, Japan and Russia, where Daylight Savings is not observed, calls will start one hour later after November 1.

See email here for further information.

WebEx

• Meeting link to WebEx page (Member-only)

Note:

• Calls are all scheduled in US Eastern Time, and European daylight savings starts on a different date, so...
• In Europe, calls will start one hour earlier after October 27 and then go back one hour later (=usual time) after November 3.
• In Japan, calls will start one hour later after November 3.

IRC

• IRC #wot-td channel
• Custom clients: irc.w3.org, port 6667

The IRC is used for the minutes, speaker queue, and sharing links etc.

Schedule

• FPWD: done (see [10] )
• WDs: every 3 month (aligned with the F2F meetings); last version in October 2018 - done.
• CR: May 2019
• CR comments deadline: June 13 2019
• CR2 transition request on 22. October
• PR publication request: December 3 2019
• REC: January 2020

Next Scribe

See Victims List

Agenda

December 2, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
     • W3C Patent Policy
     • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Plans for the next calls,
     • we will have the calls on 9. and 16. Dec.
     • For 23. Dec. not sure yet
     • Will be canceled on 30. Dec and 6. Jan
   • Draft minutes:
     • November 25
2. Defer issue to TD 2.0
   • https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22Defer+to+TD+2.0%22
   • Please review and provide a veto if you are disagree that the issue will defer to TD 2.0
3. PRs
   • https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/labels/PR%20available
4. Issues
   • Consider adding keyword to describe synchronous actions
   • Maximum and minimum are not clear about inclusiveness
   • DataSchema "Only applicable to..."
   • extend op options with observeallproperties and observemultipleproperties
   • TD Producer field in TD (similar to Server header field in HTTP)
   • Multiple methodName's ?
   • Allow array for response in From class?
   • How to describe Philips Hue security scheme
5. Bindings (cont.)
   • Guideline for defining new protocol templates https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/103
   • Meaning of htv:headers in forms

November 25, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
     • W3C Patent Policy
     • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes:
     • November 18
2. TD content for new Web page + normalize TD wiki page
   • https://w3c.github.io/wot-marketing/
   • https://github.com/w3c/wot-marketing/issues/85
3. Status TD 1.1 FPWD + TD 2.0 roadmap
   • https://www.w3.org/TR/wot-thing-description11/
   • Root TD address points to TD 1.0: https://www.w3.org/TR/wot-thing-description/
4. Issues
   • Example of Oracle's device model (Festo)
   • Default value for op in Property Affordance should be linked to read/writeOnly
   • "MultiLanguage Map" is used without definition
   • Introducing assumptions about TD instances that have no IP addresses
   • Undefiend behevior for writeOnly and readOnly
5. Bindings (cont.)
   • Guideline for defining new protocol templates https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/103
   • Meaning of htv:headers in forms

November 18, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
     • W3C Patent Policy
     • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes:
     • November 4
     • TPAC Thing Model session
     • TPAC JSON-LD session
2. Status TD 1.1 FPWD
   • Transition request approved
   • Issue with cross-referencing
3. Guests from LBD CG
4. Issues
   • Example of Eclipse Vorto model
   • Example of Oracle's device model (Festo)
   • Add "precision" to data schema
   • Add "reliability" to the TD
5. Bindings
   • Guideline for defining new protocol templates https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/103

November 11, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Guests, New Members, and Invited Experts
     • W3C Patent Policy
     • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: November 4
   • Next week: Guests from LBD CG
2. Status TD 1.1 FPWD
   • Transition request approved
3. Thing Model Examples
   • Example of Oracle's device model (Festo)
   • Example of Eclipse Vorto model
4. Guests: Schaeffler
   • Presentation & Questions

November 4, 2020

1. Preliminaries
2. Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
3. Draft minutes: September 30, October 21
4. PRs
   • add "(WoT)" to the title #996
5. Issues
   • TDT shall allow to define placeholders #897
   • We need an OAuth2 example for TD 1.1 #948
   • Introducing assumptions about TD instances that have no IP addresses #977
6. Binding

September 30, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: Sep 23
   • TD session next week?
2. TD@TPAC (please see https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/F2F_meeting,_October_2020)
3. Preparation for FPWD TD 1.1
   • PRs: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pulls

September 23, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: Sep 16
   • TD session next week --> yes, we will use the time to merge PRs which are not done yet
2. TPAC
   • Topics for joint meetings
     • JSON-LD: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/labels/JSON-LD%201.1 --> doodle
     • LBD CG and Spatial Data on the Web IG --> meeting after TPAC
   • Topics for TD session
     • How much time do we need?
     • Topics:
       • review the changes of TD 1.1 (diff of TD 1.0 and TD 1.1) --> Organizer: Taki, 10+5min
       • conclusion about the dynamic TD discussion (hyperlinks in actions) --> Organizer: Daniel, 10+5min
       • Thing Model --> Organizer: Sebastian, Interested: Michael Lagally, 1h
       • coffee break 15min
       • System Description --> Organizer: Ege, 15min
       • component approach for TD (also see https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/958) --> Organizer: Taki, Who is interested: Cristiano, 3xMichael, 1h
       • <tbd>
3. Preparation for FPWD TD 1.1
   • PRs: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pulls
4. New issues
   • how to find the Form pair for an operation
5. Binding
   • Sample how to provide a new binding? https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/103

September 16, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: Sep 9
2. TPAC
   • topics for joint meetings
     • JSON-LD: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/labels/JSON-LD%201.1
     • LBD CG and Spatial Data on the Web IG --> no joint meeting during TPAC, focus on a meeting in a TD session after TPAC
   • topics for vf2f:
     • conclusion about the dynamic TD discussion (hyperlinks in actions)
     • Thing Model
     • component approach for TD (also see https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/958),
     • System Description
     • <tbd>
3. Check, which PR can be merged
   • https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pulls
4. Binding
   • Sample how to provide a new binding?

September 09, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: Sep 2
2. TPAC
   • topics for joint meetings
     • JSON-LD: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/labels/JSON-LD%201.1
     • ...
   • topics for vf2f:
     • conclusion about the dynamic TD discussion (hyperlinks in actions)
     • Thing Model
     • component approach for TD (also see https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/958),
     • <tbd>
3. Issue/PR updates for TD 1.1 FPWD
   • Add a component mechanism to support mashups #950
   • JSON Schema validation issue wr.t. "format": "iri-reference"
   • Unsubscribing and unobserving are not in default values
   • Evaluate geolocation terms in TD model (input from Profile TF)
   • Clarify the usage of base64 encodings in DataSchema/ContentType
   • PR overview: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pulls

September 02, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: August-12
2. Issue/PR updates for TD 1.1 FPWD
   • description of observable should mention unobserveproperty (besides observeproperty) #950
   • Complex IOT device #952
   • Allow array for response in From class? #617
   • Better validate/describe "variant records", eg in SecurityScheme and OAuth2 scheme #954
   • Better validate "oneOf" choices #955
   • For OAuth2 device flow, should we define a "device authorization" element? #953
   • JSON Schema validation issue wr.t. "format": "iri-reference" #956
   • Unsubscribing and unobserving are not in default values #957
3. Binding Topics

August 12, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: July-29
   • The TD meeting is definitively cancelled on August 19. The August 26 is not decided yet.
2. Issue/PR updates for TD 1.1 FPWD
   • Evaluate new terms in TD model (input from Profile TF)
   • WIP: Introduce minLength, maxLength, multipleOf, contentEncoding and contentMediaType in JSON Schema Ontology
   • WIP: move TDT to a main section + formalize TDT + introduce placeholder
   • WIP: Add proof and proofChain sections
   • WIP: Combination security scheme
   • WIP: Simplified inline security definitions
   • Rename "Thing Template" to "Thing Model"
3. OAuth2 topics (McCool)

August 5, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: July-29
   • The TD meeting is definitively cancelled on August 19. The August 26 is not decided yet.
2. Issues updates
   • Clarify the usage of base64 encodings in DataSchema/ContentType
   • feat: add content type tables with data schema
   • Evaluate new terms in TD model (input from Profile TF)
   • Example 35 is incorrect or has inconsistency
   • Allow array for response in From class?
3. Binding Topics

July 29, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes: July-15 and July-22
   • check the TD calls in August due to the vacation time
     • Sebastian will be not available on 19.8., 26.8. ,3.9
     • Taki will be available in August
     • will cancel the meeting on 19.8., 26.8 will be decided on possible topics. Taki will take care on it.
     • 3.9. will be regularly meeting moderated by Taki
2. Issues updates
   • Init PRs for FPWD TD 1.1
   • Thing Description versioning and Scripting API
   • Fields for interface generation (e.g. UI, dashboards, IDE): description, icon
   • Add a class field to the TD
   • streams and compound values
3. OAuth2
4. Binding Topics
   • Modbus binding

July 22, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. plans for FPWD
   • discussion about the expected release date (also see)
   • discussion about backwards compatibility to TD 1.0
   • what will be new?
     • bug fixes (see https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/920)
     • OAuth2 flow (also see https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pull/927)
     • new terms in Data Schema model (https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pull/896)
     • move TDT (currently in annex so far) to a main section
       • introduce formal definition
       • placeholder feature (https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/897)
     • ...
3. Status CoAP RDF
   • heads-up in next WISHI call 30. July

July 15, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes of the TD session on June 26, 2020.
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. Issues updates
   • Issue #926 Add OAuth2 client and device flows
   • Issue #901 Clarifying use of multiple security schemes in the security term
   • Issue #922 How to describe apikey in query
   • Issue #923 How to describe Philips Hue security scheme
   • Issue #899 Managing Dynamically Created Resources in TDs
3. Binding Templates

July 10, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • CoAP RDF Kick off meeting https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/97
   • New TD time slot discussion
     • doodle ongoing
     • Only conflict-free 2h slot
2. ROS Binding (Guest Marcus Schmidt)
3. Issues updates (short update)
4. TDT (cont. from vf2f)
5. Hypermedia (cont. from vf2f)
6. Binding Templates
   • Modbus RDF https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/pull/98

June 12, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Pick a scriber (see ScribeRoll)
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • Any take away from IRTF T2TRG/W3C WoT work meeting ?
   • Doodle poll for CoAP RDF teleconferences
2. TD Issues updates
   • Examples for actions using URI variables should explain why not using input #910
   • Managing Dynamically Created Resources in TDs #899
   • TDT of an OneDM Example #903
   • Clarifying how readmultipleproperties work #848
3. Binding Templates

June 5, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Guests?
   • W3C Patent Policy
   • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
     • May-15
     • May-29
2. T2TRG/W3C joint meeting on Monday
   • https://github.com/t2trg/2020-06-helsinki
3. Binding Template
   • Init work on CoAP in RDF
4. Issues updates
   • Managing Dynamically Created Resources in TDs
   • Is the use of "$ref" and "definitions" allowed in TD ?
   • Missing default value for observable
   • TD ontology minor suggestions
5. What kind of features we want to see and test for the PlugFest?
   • Proposal query action status, usage of the new terms minLength, maxLength and multipleOf, usage of CoAP and MQTT namespaces, ...
6. Collecting topics for vf2f
   • Hypermedia of the actions, TDT, "$ref" and "definitions", ODM-TDT-iotschema, Status CoAP RDF, ...

May 29, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Guest from Schneider Electrics
   • W3C Patent Policy
   • Patent Policy FAQ - Q6
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. Updates from iotschema.org (Michael Koster)
3. Issues updates
   • Missing triple resolution in JSON-LD playground for properties forms
   • Standardizing how to describe the location of the TD
   • TDT of an OneDM Example
   • query action status
   • Is the use of "$ref" and "definitions" allowed in TD ?
4. PlugFest plannings
   • What kind of features we want to see and test for the PlugFest?
   • Proposal query action status, usage of the new terms minLength, maxLength and multipleOf, usage of CoAP and MQTT namespaces, ...
5. Binding Template
   • CoAP in RDF
6. Outlook next TD call

May 22, 2020

1. Issues updates (any particular interest? are there any more?)
   • Missing triple resolution in JSON-LD playground for properties forms #905
   • Introduction is missing security component #904
   • Managing Dynamically Created Resources in TDs #899
   • TDT shall allow to define placeholders #897
   • HTTP Binding for providing historical events. #892
   • Describing common event subscription pattern such as subscriptionId #887
2. PlugFest plannings
   • What kind of features we want to see and test for the PlugFest?
   • Proposal query action status, usage of the new terms minLength, maxLength and multipleOf, usage of CoAP and MQTT namespaces, ...
3. Binding Templates

May 15, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. W3C decided to cancel in-person TPAC 2020 in Vancouver
3. Repo logistics
   • render.sh status (Victor)
4. Issues updates
   • Link misses description
   • Managing Dynamically Created Resources in TDs
   • TDT of an OneDM Example
   • Semantic information in TDTs
5. PlugFest plannings
   • What kind of features we want to see and test for the PlugFest?
   • Proposal query action status, usage of the new terms minLength, maxLength and multipleOf, usage of CoAP and MQTT namespaces, ...
6. Binding Template
   • Inits of the CoAP in RDF and MQTT in RDF are available https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/93
7. Outlook next TD call

May 8, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. Repo logistics
   • New information about TD family
   • New feature log document
   • render.sh is still in REC mode --> Victor will fix it soon
3. Summary of the WISHI online meeting
   • Agenda https://github.com/t2trg/wishi/wiki/Agenda-items#wishi-online-meeting-1
   • Minutes: https://hackmd.io/lY_ktzBjTuSu_5oh3u20Bg
4. PR updates
   • Add 'minLength', 'maxLength' and 'multipleOf' to Data Schema
5. Issues updates
   • HTTP Binding for providing historical events
   • Semantic information in TDTs
   • TDT shall allow to define placeholders
6. PlugFest plannings
   • What kind of features we want to see and test for the PlugFest?
   • Proposal query action status, ...
7. Binding Template
   • Inits of the CoAP in RDF and MQTT in RDF are available https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/93
8. Outlook next TD call

Apr 24, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. Repo logistics
   • New information about TD family
   • Deleted merged and outdated branches
3. Issues updates
   • Add 'minLength' and 'maxLength' to StringSchema
   • Evaluate AsyncAPI
   • Consider adding keyword to describe synchronous actions
   • HTTP Binding for providing historical events
4. TD Template
   • https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/labels/TD%20Template
   • see presentation from Virtual F2F
   • current draft definition of a TDT: https://github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/454#issuecomment-604272883
5. Outlook next TD call
   • no TD meeting next week?

Apr 17, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. Repo logistics
   • new release created for TD REC
   • continue to work in TD repo for TD 1.1?
3. Design decisions: Should new TD 1.1 instances still be processed by implementations following TD 1.0?
4. Issues updates
   • Example 32 has a non functioning button
   • Add 'minLength' and 'maxLength' to StringSchema
   • Consider adding keyword to describe synchronous actions
   • HTTP Binding for providing historical events
5. Binding Template
   • How to kick off CoAP in RDF and MQTT in RDF? https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/93
   • check PR https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/pulls
6. Outlook next TD call
   • TDT (invite Kevin from Bosch)

Apr 3, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. TD REC Transition
   • transition request approved: https://github.com/w3c/transitions/issues/236 - expected publication date, April 9
   • Thing Description draft
3. Issues updates
   • Should writing to an observable property trigger new values being pushed
   • Describing common event subscription pattern such as subscriptionId
4. Continue topic discussion from VF2F meeting:
   • OAuth2 (Michael McCool)
5. Binding Template
   • also see https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/93
   • start to design ontology for CoAP
     • Who wants to be involved? So far Klaus, Sebastian, Ege, Michael Koster, ...
   • still need supporters to design ontology for MQTT
     • Who wants to be involved? So far Sebastian, Ege, Michael Koster, <someone from MQTT>...

March 27, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • check also the minutes from the VF2F meeting
2. TD REC Transition
   • Thing Description draft (diff from PR)
3. Summary of the T2TRG/OneDM meeting (Ege, Michael Koster)
   • https://github.com/t2trg/2020-03-vancouver
   • Minutes: https://hackmd.io/R9n8naQcTMeX0n1miV5_Yw?both
4. Issues updates
   • Describing common event subscription pattern such as subscriptionId
5. Continue topic discussion from VF2F meeting:
   • Efficient formats for TD (Taki and Daniel)
   • OAuth2 (Michael McCool)

March 20, 2020

• no meeting

March 13, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
2. TD REC Transition
   • Thing Description draft ( diff from PR to be checked)
3. Virtual F2F preparation
   • see Online F2F meeting TD session (March 17th 6am PST / 9am EST / 2pm CET / 3pm EET / 10pm JST; 2h)
4. Binding Template
   • designing ontologies for MQTT and CoAP

March 6, 2020

1. Press Release
2. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • Online F2F meeting TD session (March 17th 6am PST / 9am EST / 2pm CET / 3pm EET / 10pm JST; 2h)
3. PRs
   • Giving credit to editors and contributors of the implementation report.
4. Issues updates
   • Describing initial connection
   • Make a request for TD media type registration at IANA
   • Automate running TD rendering script
   • How do you cancel or query the state of an action request?

February 28, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • Online F2F meeting TD session (March 17th 6am PST / 9am EST / 2pm CET / 3pm EET / 10pm JST; 2h)
2. PRs
   • #880 provide CoAP content-format id 432 in the TD spec
     • #881 A note in section 6.4 Identification should be removed
3. Issues updates
   • #851 [Editorial] Implementation report uses non-static links and missing contributor (Ege)
   • #848 Clarifying how readmultipleproperties work (Ege)
   • #842 [Editorial] Example 32 has a non functioning button

February 21, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview: https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/WG_WoT_Thing_Description_ScribeRoll
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • Virtual F2F meeting TD session (Tentative: March 17th 6am PST / 9am EST / 3pm CET / 4pm EET / 11pm JST; 2h) - needs confirmation
   • Questionnaire to see preferred dates/times/sessions
   • collecting topics for TD sessions:
     • TD Templates
     • Eventing
     • Alternative formats for TDs (like binary representation of TDs)
     • Have a look on the marked issues for the next TD version (Zoltan)
     • ...
   • clarification about github usage for the TD 1.1 version --> Kaz will ask some W3C staff what would be the best
   • IANA completed the registration for application/td+json (https://www.iana.org/assignments/media-types/media-types.xhtml) and id: 432 for CoAP (https://www.iana.org/assignments/core-parameters/core-parameters.xhtml)
2. PR
   • https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pull/872 --> Seb generates a new index.html and push it to the master
3. Issues updates
   • Describing initial connection https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/878
   • How do you cancel or query the state of an action request? https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/302
4. Technical Discussion
   • continue discussion about Payload Templates (Michael Koster)
5. Binding Templates (Ege)
   • https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues/93

February 14, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • Virtual F2F meeting TD session (Tentative: March 17th 6am PST / 9am EST / 3pm CET / 4pm EET / 11pm JST; 2h) - needs confirmation
2. Pull Requests
   • Fix typo in validation schema #879
3. Issues
   • Describing initial connection #878
   • Clarify read-only/write-only behavior #854
   • How do you cancel or query the state of an action request? #302
   • Should it be possible to indicate whether writing a property returns set value? #875
   • No mechanism to indicate the "desired" form entry #877
4. Binding Templates (Ege)

February 7, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview: https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/WG_WoT_Thing_Description_ScribeRoll
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • Proposed Recommendation is released https://www.w3.org/TR/wot-thing-description/
2. New Issue
   • No mechanism to indicate the "desired" form entry - https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/877
3. Technical Discussion
   • How do you cancel or query the state of an action request - https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/302
   • TD Payload Template (Sebastian)
4. Binding Templates (Ege)

January 31, 2020

no call

January 24th, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • TD ScribeRoll overview: https://www.w3.org/WoT/IG/wiki/WG_WoT_Thing_Description_ScribeRoll
   • The TD call starts after 5 minutes at the latest.
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • Static version of HTML for publication is available: https://w3c.github.io/wot-thing-description/publication/pr/index.html
   • Diff from CR2: https://w3c.github.io/wot-thing-description/publication/pr/diff.html
     • result of diff analysis (Taki)
2. Thing Description
   • New Issue from Scripting API team
     • #875 Should it be possible to indicate whether writing a property returns set value?
   • Continue Classification of Issue (see minutes from January 10th)
     • Forms related topics: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3AForms
     • ActionAffordance related topics: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3AActionAffordance
     • EventAffordance related topics: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3AEventAffordance
3. Binding Templates

January 17th, 2020

1. Preliminaries
   • Draft minutes of last telecon
   • Doodle poll for TD-TF web meeting timeslot
   • Face-to-Face Meeting Logistics
     • Status of March F2F venue
     • Joint T2TRG/WoT workshop as part of industry track at ICWE 2020 in June. (McCool)
2. Thing Description
   • Recent Changes
     • #874 Address feedback from IANA (Sebastian)
   • Pull Requests
     • #872 chore: fix ReSpec errors
   • Recent Discussions
     • #604 Consider to cross reference JSON Schema definitions (external or internal) (Ege)
3. Binding Templates
4. Marketing (spillover from main call if any)

January 10th, 2020

0) f2f plannings for Helsinki in June

1) Small change requested from WoT Transition call

• see PR: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pull/873

2) there are some questions from IANA

3) Keep or find a new TD time slot?

4) check TD issues for implementation into the new version

• JSON Schema related: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+sort%3Acomments-desc+label%3A%22JSON+Schema%22
• TD Templated related: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+sort%3Acomments-desc+label%3A%22TD+Template%22
• Security related: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+sort%3Acomments-desc+label%3ASecurity
• Optimiziation related: https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+sort%3Acomments-desc+label%3AOptimization
• and more ...

5) Protocol binding topics

• also see issues https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues

December 13th, 2019

1) Status TD

• PR request https://github.com/w3c/transitions/issues/203
• Media type registration https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues/560

2) Protocol binding topics

• also see issues https://github.com/w3c/wot-binding-templates/issues

December 6th, 2019

Meeting goal: Resolution to go for the PR transition with the TD and Arch specification.

1) Check and decide to merge PRs

• https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/pulls?q=is%3Apr+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22by+PR+transition%22

2) Check and decide to close issues

• https://github.com/w3c/wot-thing-description/issues?q=is%3Aissue+is%3Aopen+label%3A%22by+PR+transition%22

Meeting Minutes

2020

October 2020

• 21 October 2020 vF2F (scribe: zoltan, ege, cristiano)

September 2020

• 30 September 2020 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)
• 23 September 2020 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)
• 16 September 2020 TD-TF (scribe: sebastian)
• 09 September 2020 TD-TF (scribe: koster)
• 02 September 2020 TD-TF (scribe: mizushima, kaz)

August 2020

• 12 August 2020 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 05 August 2020 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

July 2020

• 29 July 2020 TD-TF (scribe: mccool)
• 22 July 2020 TD-TF (scribe: sebastian)
• 15 July 2020 TD-TF (scribe: koster)
• 10 July 2020 TD-TF (scribe: ege, kaz)

June 2020

• 12 June 2020 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)
• 05 June 2020 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

May 2020

• 29 May 2020 TD-TF (scribe: sebastian)
• 22 May 2020 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 15 May 2020 TD-TF (scribe: mizushima)
• 08 May 2020 TD-TF (scribe: victor)

April 2020

• 24 April 2020 TD-TF (scribe: koster)
• 17 April 2020 TD-TF (scribe: ege)
• 03 April 2020 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

March 2020

• 27 March 2020 TD-TF (scribe: sebastian)
• 17 March 2020 WG Web Meeting (scribe: mcCool)
• 13 March 2020 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)
• 06 March 2020 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)

February 2020

• 28 February 2020 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 21 February 2020 TD-TF (scribe: zoltan, mizushima)
• 14 February 2020 TD-TF (scribe: kaz, daniel)
• 07 February 2020 TD-TF (scribe: lagally, ege)

January 2020

• 24 January 2020 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 17 January 2020 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)
• 10 January 2020 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

2019

December 2019

• 13 December 2019 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 05 December 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

November 2019

• 22 November 2019 TD-TF (scribe: victor)
• 15 November 2019 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)
• 08 November 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel, taki)

October 2019

• 25 October 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel, taki)
• 18 October 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel, mlagally)
• 11 October 2019 TD-TF (scribe: lagally, taki)
• 04 October 2019 TD-TF (scribe: lagally)

September 2019

• 19-20 September 2019 Fukuoka F2F (scribe: dezell, mccool)

August 2019

• 30 August 2019 TD-TF (scribe: lagally, mccool)
• 16 August 2019 TD-TF (scribe: kaz, taki)

July 2019

• 26 July 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)
• 19 July 2019 TD-TF (scribe: victor, taki)
• 12 July 2019 TD-TF (scribe: mjkoster, mlagally)
• 5 July 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

June 2019

• 28 June 2019 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)
• 14 June 2019 TD-TF (scribe: taki)

May 2019

• 17 May 2019 TD-TF (scribe: lagally, kaz)
• 03 May 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel, kaz)

April 2019

• 26 April 2019 TD-TF (scribe: mccool, victor)
• 19 April 2019 TD-TF (scribe: kaz, taki)
• 12 April 2019 TD-TF (scribe: matthias, lagally)
• 05 April 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel, taki)

March 2019

• 29 March 2019 TD-TF (scribe: toru, taki)
• 22 March 2019 TD-TF (scribe: kaz, victor)
• 15 March 2019 TD-TF (scribe: mjkoster)
• 8 March 2019 TD-TF (scribe: taki, mccool)
• 1 March 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

Feb 2019

• 22 Feb 2019 TD-TF (scribe: Lagally)
• 15 Feb 2019 TD-TF (scribe: kawaguch, mjkoster)
• 8 Feb 2019 TD-TF (scribe: MariaPoveda, ege)

January 2019

• 18 January 2019 TD-TF (scribe: McCool)
• 11 January 2019 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

2018

December 2018

• 21 December 2018 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 14 December 2018 TD-TF (scribe: kaz, mjkoster )
• 7 December 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Taki, Victor)

November 2018

• 30 November 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Lagally)
• 23 November 2018 TD-TF (scribe: maxime, mccool, kaz)
• 16 November 2018 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 9 November 2018 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

October 2018

• 12 October 2018 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)
• 5 October 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Maria)

September 2018

• 21 September 2018 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 14 September 2018 TD-TF (scribe: mlagally, kaz)
• 7 September 2018 TD-TF (scribe: mjkoster)

August 2018

• 31 August 2018 TD-TF (scribe: DarkoAnicic)
• 24 August 2018 TD-TF (scribe: McCool)
• 17 August 2018 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 10 August 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Danh)
• 3 August 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Maria)

July 2018

• 27 July 2018 TD-TF (scribe: toru)
• 20 July 2018 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)

June 2018

• 22 June 2018 TD-TF (scribe: McCool)
• 15 June 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Michael Lagally)
• 8 June 2018 TD-TF (scribe: darko)
• 1 June 2018 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)

May 2018

• 25 May 2018 TD-TF (scribe: mjkoster)
• 18 May 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Maria)
• 11 May 2018 TD-TF (scribe: McCool)
• 4 May 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Taki)

Apr 2018

• 20 April 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Darko)
• 13 April 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Michael Lagally)
• 6 April 2018 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)

Mar 2018

• 16 March 2018 TD-TF (scribe: daniel)
• 9 March 2018 TD-TF (scribe: kawaguch)
• 2 March 2018 TD-TF (scribe: taki)

Feb 2018

• 23 February 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Victor)
• 16 February 2018 TD-TF (scribe: McCool)
• 09 February 2018 TD-TF (scribe: mjkoster)
• 02 February 2018 TD-TF (scribe: MariaPoveda)

Jan 2018

• 26 January 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Daniel)
• 19 January 2018 TD-TF (scribe: Michael Lagally)
• 12 January 2018 TD-TF (scribe: taki)

2017

Dec 2017

• 15 December 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Toru)
• 8 December 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Darko)
• 1 December 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Maria)

Nov 2017

• 24 November 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Kaz)

Oct 2017

• 13 October 2017 TD-TF (scribe: victor)
• 6 October 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Michael McCool, kaz)

Sep 2017

• 29 September 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Niklas)
• 22 September 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Darko)
• 15 September 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Daniel)
• 8 September 2017 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• 1 September 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Kaz)

Aug 2017

• 11 August 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Maria)
• 4. Aug no TD call

Jul 2017

• 28 July 2017 TD-TF (scribe: mjkoster)
• 21 July 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Kaz)

Jun 2017

• 30 June 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Uday)
• 23 June 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Danh)
• 16 June 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Daniel)
• 9 June 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Niklas)
• 2 June 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Taki)

May 2017

• 26 May 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Daniel)
• 5 May 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Darko)

Apr 2017

• 28 Apr 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Daniel)
• 26 Apr 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Michael Koster)
• 21 Apr 2017 TD-TF (scribe: Uday)
• 7 Apr 2017 TD-TF (scribe: McCool)

Mar 2017

• 31 Mar 2017 TD-TF (scribe: yingying)
• 24 Mar 2017 TD-TF (scribe: taki)
• No TD call on 17 Mar 2017
• 6 Mar 2017 TD-TF (scribe: kaz)

Feb 2017

• 22 Feb 2017, No TD call
• 15 Feb 2017, No TD call
• 1 Feb 2017, No TD Call

Jan 2017

• 25 Jan 2017 TD Restructuring
• 18 Jan 2017 TD Restructuring

2016

Dec 2016

• 21 Dec 2016, No TD Restructuring call (Member-only)
• 14 Dec 2016 TD Restructuring
• 7 Dec 2016 TD Restructuring

Nov 2016

• 30 Nov 2016, No TD Restructuring call
• 23 Nov 2016 TD Restructuring
• 16 Nov 2016, No TD Restructuring call
• 9 Nov 2016 TD Restructuring

Oct 2016

• 26 Oct 2016 TD Restructuring
• 19 Oct 2016 TD Restructuring
• 12 Oct 2016 TD Restructuring
• 5 Oct 2016 TD Restructuring