Meeting minutes
Minutes of last week
Ege: Any concern?
… -> none -> minutes are approved
Binding Templates
PR 346
Ege: Decided to merge asynchronously
Registry Analysis
Cristiano: PR 1161 not done yet
wot PR 1161 - docs: IANA procedures for registries summary
Cristiano: Proceeded further with different mechanism
… added description for "first come first serve"
… added also "Expert Review"
… do next: report rules for URI Schemes
Ege: Extend the generic policy?
Cristiano: Yes, but not much..
… e.g., lower-case / upper case sensitiveness
… usually additional constraints
Ege: Expert Review is going to be important for us
Cristiano: There is a dedicated section how to choose the "expert"
… a lot of information to digest.. takes a bit of time
Ege: Let's look at it next time again
… another aspect is whether we should start writing our requirements
… I think we can start
… and extend later what we learn
Cristiano: I think it is good to start
… like a TOC
… I have some ideas
Jan: Should we define use-cases as well where we can get requirements
Ege: Need a solution for a use-case/requirement
… maybe that is a good idea
Ege: We can add story-line about registry (in registry-analysis/Readme.md)
… a la "WoT to support multiple protocols" ...made interoperable with a descriptive approach
Kaz: Updated text might be also useful
… however, can use text from charter as well
Ege: Good point. I might have written some text for that
<kaz> WoT WG Charter
Ege: Maybe parts from Section 2 in charter document
… will do some homework later
… started PR 1169
<kaz> wot PR 1169 - Use Case and Story for Registries
Ege: please comment
Reviews of the individual bindings
Ege: related to DataMapping from yesterdays TD call
Ege: Interesting part: Missing protocol mechanisms
… e.g., we cannot describe a given mechanism in a TD
… people can also ask for help how to solve that in TD
Cristiano: e.g., MQTT pattern
… pretending we can describe it in a TD but we do not describe it
Ege: Is lack of documentation, not a new use case
Cristiano: Like the idea to ask experts for ideas
Ege: for example HiveMQ feedback
… with CoAP Klaus Hartke and Jan
Jan: I would know some more people
Ege: w.r.t. HTTP, people of WG are quite knowledgeable
… WebSocket needs people
… SSE needs people
… w.r.t. Modbus we got a lot of input already
… BACnet, quite recent, needs more time
Management
Project Management Proposal:
<kaz> project-management.md
wot-thing-description PR 1954 - Extending the project management proposal
Ege: Last week we extended it in coordination call
… issue coming from use case pipeline
… TF working on planning the work
… separation of concerns
Ege: Any points or objections to merge this PR?
Kaz: Any update like this is fine.
… we should think about which part is managed by use-case and Mizushima-San
Ege: Good point. Should be in line
… we might want to align the "naming"
… "gap analysis" is missing in my document
… I will link Process.md from wot-usecases
Ege: Can I merge 1954 ?
<cris_> +1
Ege: no objections -> merging
TD
Data Mapping
wot PR 1165 - Initial expansion of the DataMapping work item
Ege: Luca extended the PR
… I added related issues and added them to the PR
… others can do the same.. also from other task forces
Formatting before starting work
wot-thing-description Issue 1926 - Aligning formatting across files
Ege: Consistent way of working
… looked how prettier and editorconfig work together
… unfortunately we need to use both
… should keep them consistent
Ege: I don't think we should format output files which are generated
Ege: picked option "space" and "2 spaces" for indentation
Ege: In the end I can format all files in one go
… leads to a HUGE diff
… e.g. removing trailing whitespaces
… any concern or preferences on settings used
Cristiano: Style is okay.. no strong preference
… don't get some changes.. like line breaks
Daniel: I think there is a 80 character limit
Ege: "printWidth" might be the option
… default like 80
Cristiano: Should go with 120
Ege: BTW I excluded "publication" folder
Ege: Any other business?
[adjourned]