W3C Architecture Domain Web Services Activity

XML Schema Patterns for Databinding Interoperability Report

Summary of results

Results in number

Toolkit Version Mapping Passed Failed Skipped
Axis 1.4 Java 401 125 41
Axis2 (ADB) 1.3 Java 455 71 41
Axis2 (XMLBeans) 1.3 java 531 0 36
.NET 2.0.50727.42 C# 483 61 23
IBM RAD (JAX-RPC) 7.0 java 260 28 279
Mono 1.1.13.8 C# 376 76 115
gSOAP2 C 2.7.10 C 494 63 10
gSOAP2 C++ 2.7.10 C++ 465 38 64
PHP5 5.2.0 PHP 467 71 29
SOAP4R 20051204 Ruby 262 23 282
SOAP4R 1.5.8 Ruby 236 49 282
Spring (Castor) 1.0m3 Java 42 91 434
Spring (JAXB2) 1.0m3 Java 500 42 25
Spring (XMLBeans) 1.0m3 Java 479 0 88
WCF 3.0 c# 487 70 10
Weblogic Server 10.0 Java 499 58 10
XBinder 1.4 c 548 1 18
XFire (JAXB2) 1.2.5 Java 448 33 86
XFire (XMLBeans) 1.2.5 Java 479 0 88
ZSI 2.0 Python 211 89 267

Results as graphs

Toolkit Results
Axis 1.4
70% 22% 8%
Axis2 1.3 (ADB)
80% 12% 8%
Axis2 1.3 (XMLBeans)
93% 7%
.NET 2.0.50727.42
85% 10% 5%
IBM RAD 7.0 (JAX-RPC)
45% 4% 51%
Mono 1.1.13.8
66% 13% 21%
gSOAP2 C 2.7.10
87% 11% 2%
gSOAP2 C++ 2.7.10
82% 6% 12%
PHP5 5.2.0
82% 12% 6%
SOAP4R 20051204
46% 4% 50%
SOAP4R 1.5.8
41% 8% 51%
Spring 1.0m3 (Castor)
7% 16% 77%
Spring 1.0m3 (JAXB2)
88% 7% 5%
Spring 1.0m3 (XMLBeans)
84% 16%
WCF 3.0
85% 12% 3%
Weblogic Server 10.0
88% 10% 2%
XBinder 1.4
96% 4%
XFire 1.2.5 (JAXB2)
79% 5% 16%
XFire 1.2.5 (XMLBeans)
84% 16%
ZSI 2.0
37% 15% 48%

Full results

Axis Axis2
(ADB)		 Axis2
(XMLBeans)		 .NET IBM RAD
(JAX-RPC)		 Mono gSOAP2 C gSOAP2 C++ PHP5 SOAP4R SOAP4R Spring
(Castor)		 Spring
(JAXB2)		 Spring
(XMLBeans)		 WCF Weblogic Server XBinder XFire
(JAXB2)		 XFire
(XMLBeans)		 ZSI
1.4 1.3 1.3 2.0.50727.42 7.0 1.1.13.8 2.7.10 2.7.10 5.2.0 20051204 1.5.8 1.0m3 1.0m3 1.0m3 3.0 10.0 1.4 1.2.5 1.2.5 2.0
AllElement01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed skipped passed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
AnyAttributeLax01 [advanced] failed failed passed passed passed skipped failed failed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed failed passed passed passed failed
AnyAttributeOtherLax01 [advanced] failed passed passed passed skipped skipped failed skipped failed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed failed passed skipped skipped skipped
AnyAttributeOtherSkip01 [advanced] failed passed passed passed skipped skipped failed skipped failed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed failed passed skipped skipped skipped
AnyAttributeOtherStrict01 [advanced] failed passed passed passed skipped skipped failed skipped failed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed failed passed skipped skipped skipped
AnyAttributeSkip01 [advanced] failed failed passed passed passed skipped failed failed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed failed passed passed passed failed
AnyAttributeStrict01 [advanced] failed passed passed passed passed skipped failed failed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed failed passed passed passed failed
AnyAttributeStrict02 [advanced] failed passed passed passed passed skipped failed failed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed failed passed passed passed failed
AnyAttributeStrict03 [advanced] failed passed passed passed passed skipped failed failed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed failed passed passed passed failed
AnySimpleTypeAttribute01 [advanced] passed failed passed passed skipped skipped passed passed failed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
AnySimpleTypeAttribute02 [advanced] passed failed passed passed skipped skipped passed passed failed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
AnySimpleTypeElement01 [advanced] passed failed passed passed skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
AnySimpleTypeElement02 [advanced] passed failed passed passed skipped skipped passed passed failed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
AnyTypeElement01 [advanced] failed skipped passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AnyTypeElement02 [advanced] failed passed passed failed passed skipped failed failed passed failed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed failed passed failed
AnyURIAttribute01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AnyURIElement01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AppinfoElement01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
AttributeDefault01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AttributeDefault02 [advanced] passed passed passed failed passed failed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed
AttributeDefault03 [advanced] passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AttributeDefault04 [advanced] passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AttributeElementNameClash01 [advanced] failed passed passed passed skipped passed failed failed failed passed failed skipped skipped skipped passed failed passed skipped skipped failed
AttributeFixed01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AttributeFormQualified01 [advanced] passed failed passed passed skipped passed failed skipped passed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
AttributeFormUnqualifiedExample01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
AttributeGroup01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
AttributeGroup02 [advanced] passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
AttributeOptional01 [advanced] passed passed passed passed