W3C Architecture Domain Web Services Activity

XML Schema Patterns for Databinding Interoperability Report

Disclaimer: The tests were conducted by Working Group members, not directly by toolkit vendors.

Summary of results

Results in number

Toolkit Version Mapping Passed Failed Skipped
Axis 1.4 Java 120 27 12
Axis2 (ADB) 1.3 Java 135 13 11
Axis2 (XMLBeans) 1.3 java 152 0 7
.NET 2.0.50727.42 C# 148 5 6
IBM RAD (JAX-RPC) 7.0 java 88 3 68
Mono 1.1.13.8 C# 135 13 11
gSOAP2 C 2.7.10 C 141 12 6
gSOAP2 C++ 2.7.10 C++ 139 10 10
PHP5 5.2.0 PHP 141 12 6
SOAP4R 20051204 Ruby 86 5 68
SOAP4R 1.5.8 Ruby 86 5 68
Spring (Castor) 1.0m3 Java 21 39 99
Spring (JAXB2) 1.0m3 Java 141 12 6
Spring (XMLBeans) 1.0m3 Java 142 0 17
WCF 3.0 c# 148 5 6
Weblogic Server 10.0 Java 150 3 6
XBinder 1.4 c 150 1 8
XFire (JAXB2) 1.2.5 Java 138 4 17
XFire (XMLBeans) 1.2.5 Java 142 0 17
ZSI 2.0 Python 83 7 69

Results as graphs

Toolkit Results
Axis 1.4
75% 16% 9%
Axis2 1.3 (ADB)
84% 8% 8%
Axis2 1.3 (XMLBeans)
95% 5%
.NET 2.0.50727.42
93% 3% 4%
IBM RAD 7.0 (JAX-RPC)
55% 1% 44%
Mono 1.1.13.8
84% 8% 8%
gSOAP2 C 2.7.10
88% 7% 5%
gSOAP2 C++ 2.7.10
87% 6% 7%
PHP5 5.2.0
88% 7% 5%
SOAP4R 20051204
54% 3% 43%
SOAP4R 1.5.8
54% 3% 43%
Spring 1.0m3 (Castor)
13% 24% 63%
Spring 1.0m3 (JAXB2)
88% 7% 5%
Spring 1.0m3 (XMLBeans)
89% 11%
WCF 3.0
93% 3% 4%
Weblogic Server 10.0
94% 1% 5%
XBinder 1.4
94% 6%
XFire 1.2.5 (JAXB2)
86% 2% 12%
XFire 1.2.5 (XMLBeans)
89% 11%
ZSI 2.0
52% 4% 44%

Full results

Axis Axis2
(ADB)		 Axis2
(XMLBeans)		 .NET IBM RAD
(JAX-RPC)		 Mono gSOAP2 C gSOAP2 C++ PHP5 SOAP4R SOAP4R Spring
(Castor)		 Spring
(JAXB2)		 Spring
(XMLBeans)		 WCF Weblogic Server XBinder XFire
(JAXB2)		 XFire
(XMLBeans)		 ZSI
1.4 1.3 1.3 2.0.50727.42 7.0 1.1.13.8 2.7.10 2.7.10 5.2.0 20051204 1.5.8 1.0m3 1.0m3 1.0m3 3.0 10.0 1.4 1.2.5 1.2.5 2.0
AnyURIAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AnyURIElement01 passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AttributeFormUnqualifiedExample01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
AttributeOptional01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AttributeOptional02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
AttributeReference01 passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed failed failed passed skipped failed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed
AttributeTypeReference01 skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped failed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed
AttributeTypeReference02 skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped
BareVector01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BareVector02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BareVector03 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BareVector04 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
Base64BinaryElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
Base64BinaryElement02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
Base64BinaryElement03 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BooleanAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BooleanAttribute02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BooleanElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BooleanElement02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BooleanElement03 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
BooleanElement04 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ByteAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ByteAttribute02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
ByteAttribute03 passed failed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
ByteElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed
ByteElement02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
ByteElement03 passed skipped passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
ChameleonInclude01 skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped
ComplexTypeAttribute01 skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped
ComplexTypeAttributeExtension01 failed failed passed failed skipped failed failed failed failed skipped skipped skipped failed passed failed failed failed failed passed skipped
ComplexTypeConcreteExample01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
ComplexTypeSequence01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ComplexTypeSequence02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ComplexTypeSequenceExtension01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
DateTimeAttribute01 passed passed passed passed failed failed passed passed passed passed failed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed
DateTimeAttribute02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
DateTimeAttribute03 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
DateTimeAttribute04 failed failed passed passed skipped failed failed failed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
DateTimeAttribute05 failed failed passed passed skipped failed failed failed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
DateTimeAttribute06 failed failed passed failed skipped failed failed failed passed skipped skipped skipped failed passed failed passed passed failed passed skipped
DateTimeElement01 passed passed passed passed failed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed
DateTimeElement02 passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
DateTimeElement03 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
DateTimeElement04 failed failed passed passed skipped failed failed failed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
DateTimeElement05 failed failed passed passed skipped failed failed failed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
DateTimeElement06 failed failed passed failed skipped failed failed failed passed skipped skipped skipped failed passed failed passed passed failed passed skipped
DocumentationElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
DoubleAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
DoubleElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
DoubleElement02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
DoubleElement03 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
DoubleElement04 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
DoubleElement05 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementEmptyComplexType01 skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementEmptySequence01 skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementFormQualified01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed failed failed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
ElementMaxOccurs101 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMaxOccurs102 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMaxOccursUnbounded01 failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMaxOccursUnbounded02 failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMinOccurs001 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMinOccurs002 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMinOccurs0MaxOccursUnbounded101 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMinOccurs0MaxOccursUnbounded102 failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMinOccurs101 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMinOccurs1MaxOccursUnbounded101 failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementMinOccurs1MaxOccursUnbounded102 failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementReference01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
ElementTypeReference01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
GlobalAttribute01 failed failed passed failed skipped passed failed skipped passed skipped skipped skipped failed skipped failed failed skipped skipped skipped skipped
GlobalComplexTypeExample01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
GlobalElement01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped failed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
GlobalElement02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped failed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
GlobalElement03 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped failed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
GlobalElementComplexType01 skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped skipped
GlobalElementConcreteExample01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
GlobalElementSequence01 skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
GlobalSimpleType01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
IdExample01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
IdentifierName02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
IntAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
IntAttribute02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
IntAttribute03 failed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
IntAttribute04 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
IntAttribute05 passed failed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
IntElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
IntElement02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
IntElement03 failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
IntElement04 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
IntElement05 passed skipped passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
LocalElementComplexType01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
LongAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
LongAttribute02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
LongAttribute03 failed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
LongAttribute04 passed failed passed passed skipped passed passed passed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
LongAttribute05 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
LongElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
LongElement02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
LongElement03 failed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
LongElement04 passed skipped passed passed skipped passed passed passed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
LongElement05 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
MaxOccurs01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
MaxOccurs02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
MinOccurs01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed skipped passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped
NCNameAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
NCNameElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed
NameAttribute01 skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
NameElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed
NestedSequenceElementList01 failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
NillableElement01 passed passed passed passed passed passed failed failed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
NillableElement02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
NonIdentifierName02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
NonNegativeIntegerAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
NonNegativeIntegerAttribute02 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
NonNegativeIntegerAttribute03 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
NonNegativeIntegerAttribute04 failed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
NonNegativeIntegerAttribute05 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed failed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
NormalizedStringAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
NormalizedStringElement01 skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
NormalizedStringElement02 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed
NotMixedExample01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
NotNillableElement01 passed passed passed passed skipped passed passed passed passed skipped skipped skipped passed passed passed passed passed passed passed skipped
NullEnumerationType01 passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed failed failed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed passed
PositiveIntegerAttribute01 passed passed passed passed passed passed