Apply the following changes to selected issues:

There are 234 issues listed in the system.

ID State Title Raised on Product Open Actions
ISSUE-1 (edit)
CLOSED What inferencing can or must be used? 2014-11-18 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-2 (edit)
Audience skills
CLOSED What skills are expected/required from our audience? 2014-11-18 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-3 (edit)
Shape association
CLOSED How is a shape associated with a graph? 2014-11-18 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-4 (edit)
CLOSED Test - please ignore 2014-11-26 0
ISSUE-5 (edit)
Resource Shape Association
CLOSED How is a resource associated with shapes? 2014-12-04 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-6 (edit)
ShExC example
CLOSED Story S2 - upgrade ShExC part 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-7 (edit)
S4 no story
CLOSED Story S4 is missing a story 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-8 (edit)
S6 Clarification
CLOSED S6 doesn't clearly state what feature is required 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-9 (edit)
S7 no story
CLOSED S7 does not appear to have a story 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-10 (edit)
S8 no story
CLOSED S8 does not have a story 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-11 (edit)
S9 impossible
CLOSED S9 is about existing but unspecified values 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-12 (edit)
S10 story upgrade
CLOSED S10 needs a better story 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-13 (edit)
S12 no constraints
CLOSED it is not apparent where S12 involves constraints 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-14 (edit)
S14 constraints?
CLOSED S14 might be about change not constraints 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-15 (edit)
S17 constraint?
CLOSED S17 is about access not constraints 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-16 (edit)
S18 constraints?
CLOSED S18 does not appear to be about constraints 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-17 (edit)
S19 and S20 ontologies
CLOSED S19 and S20 need information to distinguish from ontology recognition 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-18 (edit)
S35 examples
CLOSED S35 needs to state what constraints are required 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-19 (edit)
S35 not RDF
CLOSED S35 appeals to something that is not RDF 2014-12-19 User Stories 0
ISSUE-20 (edit)
S2 ShExC calling
CLOSED ShExC example in S2 doesn't indicate how to set it up 2014-12-29 User Stories 0
ISSUE-21 (edit)
Shape Expressions?
CLOSED What is shape expressions? 2015-02-24 0
ISSUE-22 (edit)
CLOSED Treatment of recursive shape definitions 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-23 (edit)
CLOSED Shapes as classes 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-24 (edit)
CLOSED Can shapes specialise other shapes? 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-25 (edit)
CLOSED What's in Core/Lite? 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-26 (edit)
CLOSED Can extensions invoke the high-level language? 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-27 (edit)
CLOSED Can extension constraints be used in the high-level language? 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-28 (edit)
CLOSED Is the macro facility part of the high-level language or of the extension mechanism? 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-29 (edit)
CLOSED Formalism for definition of high-level language 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-30 (edit)
CLOSED Are shapes and data in the same graph? 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-31 (edit)
unitary semantics
CLOSED Is there going to be a single unitary semantics for all of SHACL 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-32 (edit)
CLOSED SHACL = high-level + extensions ? 2015-03-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-33 (edit)
shape selection
CLOSED Shifting section "Shape Selection" to introduction? 2015-04-01 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-34 (edit)
CLOSED 2 disjuncts at a time in sh:OrConstraint 2015-04-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-35 (edit)
Language-tags Req
CLOSED Language-tags Requirement 2015-04-02 Requirements 0
ISSUE-36 (edit)
Value type facet
CLOSED Naming of value type facet 2015-04-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-37 (edit)
Node kind facet
CLOSED Naming of node kind facet 2015-04-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-38 (edit)
Cardinality facet
CLOSED Naming of cardinality facets 2015-04-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-39 (edit)
Value shape facet
CLOSED Naming of value shape facet 2015-04-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-40 (edit)
Property Cardinality
CLOSED sh:min/max constrains properties, not values 2015-04-05 0
ISSUE-41 (edit)
property paths (sh:path?)
CLOSED Using property paths to refer to values/types? 2015-04-07 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-42 (edit)
CLOSED Adding sh:notEqual to potential datatype properties? 2015-04-07 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-43 (edit)
CLOSED Proposal for creating the FPWD of SHACL Part 1 2015-04-09 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-44 (edit)
Graph dependencies
CLOSED How to express dependencies between graphs 2015-04-15 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-45 (edit)
CLOSED Should SPARQL be a built-in extension language 2015-04-17 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-46 (edit)
RDF lists
CLOSED Support for RDF Collections? 2015-04-22 Requirements 0
ISSUE-47 (edit)
CLOSED Can SPARQL-based constraints access the shape graph, and how? 2015-04-23 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-48 (edit)
CLOSED How do we limit the scope for a shape? 2015-04-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-49 (edit)
scoped/unscoped shapes
CLOSED Distinction between scoped and unscoped shapes 2015-05-13 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-50 (edit)
presentation requirements
CLOSED Presentations to the working group 2015-05-21 0
ISSUE-51 (edit)
Results Vocabulary
CLOSED What types of validation results should be returned 2015-05-22 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-52 (edit)
abstract syntax
CLOSED Define an Abstract Syntax for SHACL 2015-05-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-53 (edit)
CLOSED Multi-occurrence of the same predicate 2015-05-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-54 (edit)
CLOSED OneOf vs. SomeOf 2015-05-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-55 (edit)
CLOSED Triple constraints (drop me) 2015-05-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-56 (edit)
CLOSED Inverse triple constraints (drop me) 2015-05-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-57 (edit)
group cardinality
CLOSED Cardinalities on expressions or groups of triple constraints 2015-05-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-58 (edit)
Closed shapes
CLOSED Signalling closed shapes/Defining closed shapes 2015-05-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-59 (edit)
default cardinalities
CLOSED What are the default values for cardinalities? 2015-05-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-60 (edit)
Other Extension Languages
CLOSED Shall SHACL support other extension languages beside SPARQL (like JavaScript)? 2015-05-30 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-61 (edit)
Direction of sh:nodeShape
CLOSED Direction of individual scoping: sh:nodeShape vs. sh:individualScope 2015-05-30 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-62 (edit)
General selection or filtering
CLOSED Selection or filtering by arbitrary expressions and shapes 2015-05-30 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-63 (edit)
CLOSED Nested shapes: sh:hasShape function versus recursive SPARQL code generation 2015-06-01 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-64 (edit)
XSD Datatype facets
CLOSED Should the Core vocabulary support datatype facets such as sh:minInclusive and sh:maxLength? 2015-06-01 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-65 (edit)
nomenclature consistency
CLOSED Consistency and cohesiveness of nomenclature (e.g., shapes, scopes, and constraints) 2015-06-01 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-66 (edit)
CLOSED SHACL spec ill-founded due to non-convergence on data loops 2015-06-10 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-67 (edit) CLOSED Http:// 2015-06-11 0
ISSUE-68 (edit)
CLOSED pre-binding not defined in SHACL spec 2015-06-12 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-69 (edit)
CLOSED status of rdf:langString values with xsd:string datatype 2015-06-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-70 (edit)
blank node default type
CLOSED special treatment of blank node types 2015-06-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-71 (edit)
CLOSED SHACL Endpoint Protocol 2015-06-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-72 (edit)
CLOSED Qualified Cardinality Restrictions 2015-06-25 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-73 (edit)
sh:hasShape error handling
CLOSED how do recursion errors from sh:hasShape interact with SPARQL 2015-07-10 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-74 (edit)
SPARQL endpoint support
CLOSED Should SHACL support validating RDF graphs accessible via unmodified SPARQL endpoints 2015-07-12 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-75 (edit)
error vs violation
CLOSED How to distinguish constraint violations from errors 2015-07-13 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-76 (edit)
CLOSED Specifying execution order and commutativity of AND and OR 2015-07-13 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-77 (edit)
sh:pattern flags
CLOSED Shall sh:pattern also support sh:flags? 2015-07-24 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-78 (edit)
CLOSED Should SHACL support marking classes as abstract 2015-08-04 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-79 (edit)
Validation functions
CLOSED Cleaner separation between value checking and property iteration 2015-08-13 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-80 (edit)
Scheme URIs
CLOSED Constraint to limit IRIs against scheme/namespace, possibly with dereferencing 2015-08-13 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-81 (edit)
Property pair constraints
CLOSED Shall SHACL Core include support for disjoint properties and other property pair constraints? 2015-08-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-82 (edit)
Unique language
CLOSED Shall SHACL Core include support for unique language constraints? 2015-08-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-83 (edit)
multiple sh:qualifiedValueShapes
CLOSED How should multiple definitions of sh:qualifiedValueShape of a property constraint be treated? 2015-08-21 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-84 (edit)
Allowed IRIs
CLOSED Constraint to limit IRIs of focus nodes to a given enumeration (similar to owl:oneOf) 2015-09-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-85 (edit)
only one xor
CLOSED what is the definition of XOR? 2015-09-09 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-86 (edit)
ontology association
CLOSED Associating shapes with ontologies or vocabularies 2015-09-10 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-87 (edit)
Turtle file
CLOSED Shall we publish RDF files for the SHACL namespace? 2015-09-11 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-88 (edit)
CLOSED Should we add sh:qualifiedValue ? 2015-09-11 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-89 (edit)
recursion without properties
CLOSED How should recursion that does not involve a property be handled? 2015-09-15 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-90 (edit)
Literal focus nodes
CLOSED Can the focus node be a literal? 2015-09-21 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-91 (edit)
default cardinality
CLOSED Default Cardinality in property constraints 2015-09-24 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-92 (edit)
additive repeated properties
CLOSED Should repeated properties be interpreted as additive or conjunctive? 2015-09-24 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-93 (edit)
engine / language
CLOSED SHACL engine vs. SHACL instance requirements 2015-09-24 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-94 (edit)
separate syntax and semantics
CLOSED Should RDF syntax requirements be separated from SHACL semantics 2015-09-24 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-95 (edit)
Template Simplifications
CLOSED Proposed simplification and clean up of template mechanism 2015-09-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-96 (edit)
Violation IDs
CLOSED Should the validation results contain stable IDs to indicate the type of violation 2015-09-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-97 (edit)
CLOSED Shall SHACL include a mechanism to define constraints using derived values 2015-09-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-98 (edit)
Node constraints
CLOSED Can property constraints also apply to focus nodes? 2015-10-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-99 (edit)
special cases
CLOSED special treatment of rdfs:Resource and rdf:List in sh:valueClass (and possibly elsewhere) 2015-10-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-100 (edit)
CLOSED Specifying the order of property constraints (e.g. with sh:index) 2015-10-07 SHACL - UI 0
ISSUE-101 (edit)
templates as classes
CLOSED use of rdfs:subClassOf for template inheritance 2015-10-08 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-102 (edit)
Specifying defaults
CLOSED Missing a way to explicitly code unbound cardinality and open shapes 2015-10-14 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-103 (edit)
Syntax simplifications
CLOSED Can we further simplify the syntax of some constraint types? 2015-10-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-104 (edit)
Union ranges
CLOSED Should sh:datatype and sh:class have better support for OR? 2015-10-23 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-105 (edit)
defined prefixes
CLOSED SHACL SPARQL constraints depend on namespaces in a graph, which is not defined 2015-10-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-106 (edit)
annotation properties
CLOSED Annotation properties are not defined well 2015-10-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-107 (edit)
annotations v. arguments
CLOSED annotations and arguments use different mechanisms for specifying the SPARQL variable name 2015-10-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-108 (edit)
CLOSED Should operations be specified? 2015-10-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-109 (edit)
function calling
CLOSED SHACL requires that SPARQL implementations be able to call functions defined on the fly 2015-11-04 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-110 (edit)
single-property constraints
CLOSED relationship between sh:constraint and sh:property and sh:inverseProperty 2015-11-04 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-111 (edit)
charter issues
CLOSED How should the working group address the issues called out in the WG charter? 2015-11-05 0
ISSUE-112 (edit)
misuse of some RDFS properties
CLOSED SHACL uses rdfs:label and rdfs:comment in ways that violate their intended RDFS meaning 2015-11-05 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-113 (edit)
SHACL and user interfaces
CLOSED Let a user interface group design the connection between SHACL and UI tools 2015-11-12 SHACL - UI 0
ISSUE-114 (edit)
Property Groups
CLOSED Should SHACL include a grouping mechanism of properties (for UI purposes) 2015-11-12 SHACL - UI 0
ISSUE-115 (edit)
CLOSED Closeness is an aspect of a Shape, but the current syntax treats it like all other constraints. 2015-12-16 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-116 (edit) CLOSED 108 2015-12-17 0
ISSUE-117 (edit)
non-classes as classes
CLOSED sh:class should not require that its objects be known to be instances of rdfs:Class 2016-01-11 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-118 (edit)
syntax errors
CLOSED syntax errors should not be confusable with validation results 2016-01-11 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-119 (edit)
CLOSED Defining constraints on (values of) rdf:Lists 2016-01-27 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-120 (edit)
CLOSED The spec must be more precise and consistent about when a resource is a shape, a class, and an instance of a class 2016-01-28 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-121 (edit)
# in graph name
CLOSED Should the SHACL owl:Ontology include the # character 2016-02-04 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-122 (edit)
CLOSED Should we postpone publishing a SHACL shapes file (indefinitely)? 2016-02-10 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-123 (edit)
DirectType syntax
CLOSED Shall we unify the syntax of sh:directType and sh:class? 2016-02-28 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-124 (edit)
CLOSED sh:group is only mentioned in examples 2016-03-06 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-125 (edit)
sh:NodeConstraint missing
CLOSED sh:NodeConstraint is mentioned but never defined 2016-03-06 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-126 (edit)
sh:TemplateConstraint undefined
CLOSED sh:TemplateConstraint is used in examples but not defined 2016-03-06 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-127 (edit)
sh:TemplateScope undefined
CLOSED sh:TemplateScope is mentioned but not defined 2016-03-06 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-128 (edit)
CLOSED sh:defaultValueType is rdfs:range 2016-03-06 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-129 (edit)
existential constraints
CLOSED Existential constraints should be consistent 2016-03-07 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-130 (edit)
rdf dataset assumption
CLOSED SHACL should not assume that the data graph is in an RDF dataset 2016-03-07 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-131 (edit)
sh:hasShape ill defined
CLOSED The definition of sh:hasShape has errors and holes 2016-03-07 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-132 (edit)
sh:predicate in constraints
CLOSED sh:predicate is used in many constraints but not always available 2016-03-07 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-133 (edit)
CLOSED syntax simplification and regularization 2016-03-08 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-134 (edit)
knowing inverse
CLOSED does SHACL syntax distinguish inverse property constraints 2016-03-10 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-135 (edit)
and/or syntactic sugar
CLOSED Should sh:and/sh:or/sh:not/sh:valueShape support constraints too? 2016-03-10 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-136 (edit)
Property pair names
CLOSED Can we clarify the names of property pair constraint types? 2016-03-13 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-137 (edit)
language tag
CLOSED Missing constraint for language tag 2016-03-14 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-138 (edit)
Property constraints as lists
CLOSED Should property constraints use rdf:Lists? 2016-03-18 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-139 (edit)
Universal applicability
CLOSED Can all constraint properties be applied in all scenarios? 2016-03-18 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-140 (edit)
Individual validation
CLOSED SHACL needs to support validation of individual nodes 2016-03-21 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-141 (edit)
Mixed ranges
CLOSED How to represent mixed datatype-or-class ranges 2016-03-22 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-142 (edit)
loose terminology
CLOSED SHACL spec is too loose with its uses of terminology 2016-03-30 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-143 (edit)
pre-binding in core
CLOSED more pre-binding is needed in Section 3 2016-04-08 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-144 (edit)
CLOSED substitution is sometimes used instead of pre-binding 2016-04-08 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-145 (edit)
minExclusive code incorrect
CLOSED the SPARQL code for sh:minExclusive is incorrect 2016-04-08 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-146 (edit)
CLOSED treatment of unbound results from sh:hasShape in sh:qualifiedMinCount (and elsewhere) 2016-04-08 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-147 (edit)
vocabulary typos
CLOSED [EDITORIAL] misspelled vocabulary in specification document 2016-04-10 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-148 (edit)
scope syntax
CLOSED non-uniform syntax in scopes 2016-04-15 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-149 (edit)
? vs $ in nodeKind
CLOSED the SPARQL codefor nodeKind uses both ?value and $value 2016-04-18 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-150 (edit)
nested severities
CLOSED Treatment of nested severities 2016-04-18 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-151 (edit)
illegal shapes
CLOSED [EDITORIAL] shape for sh:and is illegal 2016-04-18 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-152 (edit)
sh:labelTemplate not defined
CLOSED sh:labelTemplate should be defined for all its uses 2016-04-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-153 (edit)
sh:sourceConstraintComponent modality
CLOSED [EDITORIAL] sh:sourceConstraintComponent is not required but some wording indicates that it is 2016-04-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-154 (edit)
value set not defined
CLOSED the description of sh:equals and sh:disjoint use the term "value set", which is not defined 2016-04-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-155 (edit)
property pair constraints
CLOSED problems in the description of property pair constraints 2016-04-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-156 (edit)
property pair constraints
CLOSED problems in the description of property pair constraints 2016-04-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-157 (edit)
constraint component support
CLOSED the support for constraint components is incorrectly stated 2016-04-28 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-158 (edit)
ill-typed literals and sh:datatype
CLOSED ill-typed literals do not always trigger a validation result 2016-04-29 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-159 (edit) CLOSED [Editorial] Eliminate "scope class" from 2.1.3.n 2016-05-01 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-160 (edit)
Generalize sh:valueShape
CLOSED Shall we generalize sh:valueShape to sh:shape 2016-05-11 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-161 (edit)
CLOSED [EDITORIAL] terminology fixups 2016-05-14 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-162 (edit)
section 1.2 editorial
CLOSED [EDITORIAL] Section 1.2 2016-05-14 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-163 (edit)
CLOSED should "constraining" and other forms of "constraint" be used less in the specification 2016-05-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-164 (edit)
mutable graphs
CLOSED [EDITORIAL] Section 1.4 (and maybe other places) looks as if graphs are mutable 2016-05-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-165 (edit)
shapes and scopes introduction
CLOSED [EDITORIAL] The introduction of shapes and scopes has confused a reader 2016-05-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-166 (edit)
two documents
CLOSED separate out advanced part of specification 2016-05-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-167 (edit)
implicit class scope
CLOSED [EDITORIAL] implicit class scope gives impression of inferencing 2016-05-19 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-168 (edit)
instance count
CLOSED How to constrain number of instances of a class in a graph 2016-06-13 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-169 (edit)
sh:scopeProperty naming
CLOSED Should we rename sh:scopeProperty/InverseProperty 2016-06-18 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-170 (edit)
exists blank nodes
CLOSED SPARQL specifies a different reading for exists and blank nodes than needed for SHACL 2016-06-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-171 (edit)
negated sh:classIn
CLOSED sh:classIn SPARQL definition incorrect 2016-06-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-172 (edit)
sh:nodeKind SPARQL definition
CLOSED the sh:nodeKind SPARQL definition is unnecessarily complex 2016-06-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-173 (edit)
CLOSED [Editorial] Text related to SPARQL definitions needs to be hidden together with query 2016-07-08 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-174 (edit)
CLOSED Scopenode does not use RDF node definition 2016-07-11 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-175 (edit)
scope naming
CLOSED Alternate naming for term for scope / in-scope 2016-07-22 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-176 (edit)
CLOSED Should SHACL include a (simple) rules feature 2016-08-20 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-177 (edit)
CLOSED Abstract Syntax is disconnected from concrete syntax 2016-09-07 0
ISSUE-178 (edit)
sh:message constraints
CLOSED Should sh:message be permitted at constraints, too? 2016-09-21 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-179 (edit)
label annotations
CLOSED Should SHACL include a mechanism to specify display labels? 2016-09-22 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-180 (edit)
Path bnodes
CLOSED Should IRI paths always be interpreted as predicates? 2016-09-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-181 (edit) CLOSED SHACL conformance for partial validation reports 2016-09-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-182 (edit)
Validation report
CLOSED Clarifications needed to section 3.0 2016-09-29 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-183 (edit)
undefined term
CLOSED Eliminating the term "Undefined" 2016-10-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-184 (edit)
paths & value nodes
CLOSED Property paths and value nodes 2016-10-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-185 (edit)
processing order
CLOSED Processing order for filters and constraints 2016-10-02 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-186 (edit)
validation report properties
CLOSED Properties in validation report mis-use shapes graph properties 2016-10-09 0
ISSUE-187 (edit)
severity and message
CLOSED sh:severity and sh:message are not defined as shapes graph properties 2016-10-09 0
ISSUE-188 (edit)
define validation
CLOSED "Validation" needs to be defined 2016-10-09 0
ISSUE-189 (edit)
validation trigger
CLOSED Clarify validation report trigger in section 3 2016-10-09 0
ISSUE-190 (edit)
Shape identification
CLOSED Identifying the shapes in a SHACL Full shapes graph 2016-10-13 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-191 (edit)
Parameter value types
CLOSED Should the value types of parameters be constraints 2016-10-18 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-192 (edit)
Are filter shapes shapes?
CLOSED Should filter shapes be of type sh:Shape? if not, then what? 2016-10-19 0
ISSUE-193 (edit)
Focus nodes
CLOSED [Editorial] Targets can be refined; focus nodes do not change 2016-10-27 0
ISSUE-194 (edit)
CLOSED stems in value sets 2016-11-08 0
ISSUE-195 (edit)
TTL File
CLOSED [Editorial] Prepare TTL file for publication 2016-11-15 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-196 (edit)
Delete filters
CLOSED Should we delete filter shapes? 2016-11-16 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-197 (edit)
CLOSED "Defined" and "declared" used in multiple ways, and not defined 2016-11-17 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-198 (edit)
CLOSED rdf:langString not included in datatypes 2016-11-17 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-199 (edit)
Constraint component IRIs
CLOSED [Editorial] Constraint Component IRIs need to be defined before use 2016-11-17 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-200 (edit)
CLOSED [Editorial] Processors, processing not defined 2016-11-17 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-201 (edit)
node target
CLOSED how does node target specify targets for a shape? 2016-11-17 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-202 (edit)
Remove pre-binding from core
CLOSED Suggestion to remove pre-binding from core 2016-11-17 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-203 (edit)
Constraint components
CLOSED Constraint component is an IRI 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-204 (edit)
Constraint node
CLOSED Fourth node is unclear 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-205 (edit)
Validation report
CLOSED Section 1.4 - graph is the result of validation 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-206 (edit)
Target node
CLOSED Not clear how a node target specifies targets for a shape 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-207 (edit)
CLOSED Parameter descriptions for constraint components 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-208 (edit)
CLOSED $this in aggregations 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-209 (edit)
What is a shape?
CLOSED What is a shape 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-210 (edit)
Expected type
CLOSED value types and expected types 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-211 (edit)
property constraints
CLOSED Eliminate property constraints 2016-11-20 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-212 (edit)
Property constraints
CLOSED Property constraints and focus node constraints 2016-11-22 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-213 (edit)
Finding shapes
CLOSED Finding shapes 2016-11-22 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-214 (edit)
must & may
CLOSED [Editorial] Read through for "must" and "may" 2016-11-30 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-215 (edit)
literal parameters
CLOSED parameters with a value type that is a datatype 2016-12-01 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-216 (edit)
CLOSED [Editorial] Shall we switch to the (mathematical) style of definitions suggested by Peter? 2016-12-06 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-217 (edit)
Path vs predicate clean up
CLOSED Further clean up of paths versus predicate 2016-12-09 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-218 (edit)
Move annotations
CLOSED Should we move SPARQL Annotations mechanism into the WG Note? 2017-01-17 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-219 (edit)
One-of shapes
CLOSED Should we add a one-of-a-list-of-shapes operator 2017-01-24 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-220 (edit)
what is a shape
CLOSED defining shapes in a shapes graph 2017-01-25 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-221 (edit)
sh:Shape hierarchy
CLOSED Simplify the class hierarchy of shapes 2017-01-25 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-222 (edit)
Pre-binding 2
CLOSED Response to "On pre-binding" 2017-01-31 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-223 (edit)
Shapes mismatching type
CLOSED Should we disallow shapes with mismatching type 2017-02-05 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-224 (edit)
Improved shape type definitions
CLOSED Can we improve the language around the use of rdf:types for shapes 2017-02-05 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-225 (edit)
Validation Report details
CLOSED Respond to "Validation results and reports" - part 1 2017-02-08 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-226 (edit)
JSON-LD @context
CLOSED Should the WG produce a JSON-LD @context 2017-02-09 0
ISSUE-227 (edit)
SPARQL-based constraint components using EXISTS
CLOSED Behavior of SPARQL-based constraint components that use EXISTS 2017-02-09 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-228 (edit)
Form of the validation report
CLOSED Respond to the comment about the form of the validation report 2017-02-10 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-229 (edit)
results included in a validation report
CLOSED Respond to the comment about what results to be included in a validation report 2017-02-10 SHACL - Core 0
ISSUE-230 (edit)
$this and $PATH in sh:sparql
CLOSED Inconsistency in the use of $this and $PATH in sh:sparql vs constraint components 2017-02-10 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-231 (edit)
sh:message in components
CLOSED Could we allow sh:message for constraint components, not just validators? 2017-02-15 SHACL - SPARQL 0
ISSUE-232 (edit)
Privacy and Security
CLOSED Respec suggests a section on privacy and security 2017-02-15 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-233 (edit)
Shapes syntax checking
CLOSED Should we require support for checking of well-formed shapes graphs? 2017-02-21 SHACL Spec 0
ISSUE-234 (edit)
Peter 2017-02-22
CLOSED Public comment 2017-02-27 SHACL Spec 0

Raise an issue .

Ted Thibodeau <>, Irene Polikoff <>, Chairs, Sandro Hawke <>, Staff Contact
Tracker: documentation, (configuration for this group), originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <>.
$Id: issues.php,v 1.18 2015/07/01 14:43:27 vivien Exp $