Details on Product Compliance Next

All Issues

New issues for this product are notified to (change it).

There are 87 issues listed in the system.

ID State Title Raised on Product Open Actions
ISSUE-200 (edit) OPEN Transitive exceptions 2013-06-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-3 (edit) CLOSED What is the granularity of the choice we expect users to make? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-6 (edit) CLOSED What are the underlying concerns? Why are we doing this / what are people afraid of? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-7 (edit) CLOSED What types of tracking exist, and what are the use cases for these types of tracking? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-8 (edit) CLOSED How do we enhance transparency and consumer awareness? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-9 (edit) CLOSED Understand all the different first- and third-party cases. 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-11 (edit) CLOSED Document a longer list of use cases -- what's going on today 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-12 (edit) CLOSED How does tracking require relation to unique identities, pseudonyms, etc.? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-15 (edit) CLOSED What special treatment should there be for children's data? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-17 (edit) CLOSED Data use by 1st Party 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-18 (edit) CLOSED Collection definition (not sure I said the prefix before?) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-19 (edit) CLOSED Data collection / Data use (3rd party) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-20 (edit) CLOSED Different types of data, what counts as PII, and what definition of PII 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-23 (edit) CLOSED Possible exemption for analytics 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-26 (edit) CLOSED Providing data to 3rd-party widgets -- does that imply consent? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-28 (edit) CLOSED Exception for mandatory legal process 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-29 (edit) CLOSED Tracking that may be required by law enforcement 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-30 (edit) CLOSED Will Do Not Track apply to offline aggregating or selling of data? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-33 (edit) CLOSED Complexity of user choice (are exemptions exposed to users?) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-34 (edit) CLOSED Possible exemption for aggregate analytics 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-35 (edit) CLOSED How will DNT interact with existing opt-out programs (industry self-reg, other)? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-36 (edit) CLOSED Should DNT opt-outs distinguish between behavioral targeting and other personalization? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-37 (edit) CLOSED Granularity based on business types and uses 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-38 (edit) CLOSED Granularity for different people who share a device or browser 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-39 (edit) CLOSED Tracking of geographic data (however it's determined, or used) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-41 (edit) CLOSED Consistent way to discuss tracking with users (terminology matters!) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-45 (edit) CLOSED Companies making public commitments with a "regulatory hook" for US legal purposes 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-52 (edit) CLOSED What if conflict between opt-out cookie and DNT? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-53 (edit) CLOSED How should opt-out cookie and DNT signal interact? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-54 (edit) CLOSED can first parties use declared data while in a 3rd party context? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-55 (edit) CLOSED What is relationship between behavioral advertising and tracking, subset, different items? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-56 (edit) CLOSED What if DNT is unspecified and an opt-out cookie is present? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-57 (edit) CLOSED What if an opt-out cookie exists but an "opt back in" out-of-band is present? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-58 (edit) CLOSED What if DNT is explicitly set to 0 and an opt-out cookie is present? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-60 (edit) CLOSED Will a recipient know if it itself is a 1st or 3rd party? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-64 (edit) CLOSED How do we describe non-identifiable data 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-65 (edit) CLOSED How does logged in and logged out state work 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-66 (edit) CLOSED Can user be allowed to consent to both third party and first party to override general DNT? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-69 (edit) CLOSED Should the spec say anything about minimal notice? (ie. don't bury in a privacy policy) 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-71 (edit) CLOSED Does DNT require purging or modifying data collected in the past (not under DNT)? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-72 (edit) CLOSED Basic principle: independent use as an agent of a first party 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-73 (edit) CLOSED In order for analytics or other contracting to count as first-party: by contract, by technical silo, both silo and contract 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-74 (edit) CLOSED Are surveys out of scope? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-75 (edit) CLOSED How do companies claim exemptions and is that technical or not? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-88 (edit) CLOSED different rules for impression of and interaction with 3rd-party ads/content 2011-09-23 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-89 (edit) CLOSED Does DNT mean at a high level: (a) no customization, users are seen for the first time, every time. (b) DNT is about data moving between sites. 2011-10-05 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-91 (edit) CLOSED Might want prohibitions on first parties re-selling data to get around the intent of DNT 2011-10-12 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-92 (edit) CLOSED If data collection (even very specific with IP address, user agent, referrer) is time-limited, with very limited retention, is that still tracking? 2011-10-19 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-93 (edit) CLOSED Should 1st parties be able to degrade a user experience or charge money for content based on DNT? 2011-10-19 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-94 (edit) CLOSED Is "Do Not Track" the right name to use? 2011-10-24 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-100 (edit) CLOSED What is a user? 2011-11-09 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-101 (edit) CLOSED What is a user? add to defns 2011-11-09 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-102 (edit) CLOSED Short names & titles of specifications 2011-11-13 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-103 (edit) CLOSED We're not sure where the exceptions should be and ensure they are categorically captured in the base 3rd party prohibition statement. 2011-11-23 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-104 (edit) CLOSED Could use a better defn of user agent, rather than browser 2011-11-28 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-117 (edit) CLOSED Terms: tracking v. cross-site tracking 2012-01-13 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-122 (edit) CLOSED Should we have use limitations on referrer data? 2012-02-01 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-132 (edit) CLOSED Should the spec speak to intermediaries or hosting providers to modify any responses/statements about DNT compliance? 2012-04-10 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-133 (edit) CLOSED What effect does legal liability or consistent data practices between affiliates have on the definition of breadth of a party? 2012-04-10 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-142 (edit) CLOSED How should protocol data be allowed to be used in the first N weeks? 2012-04-25 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-149 (edit) CLOSED Compliance section for user agents 2012-05-30 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-154 (edit) CLOSED Are First parties allowed to use data (either offline or online) from third parties 2012-06-20 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-163 (edit) CLOSED How in the spec should we ensure user agents don't twist a user preference one way or another? 2012-09-19 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-169 (edit) CLOSED What do we mean by tracking? 2012-10-03 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-174 (edit) CLOSED How do we create straightforward compliance for implementers retaining data for N weeks or less? 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-177 (edit) CLOSED Should we specify compliance requirements for software and hardware other than user agents? For example, is a web server package compliant if it tweaks DNT headers? 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-178 (edit)
CLOSED Add "Marketing" to list of permitted uses in Compliance document 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-179 (edit) CLOSED Make sure in the spec that we clarify information provided explicitly by a user (e.g. data typed into a form on a site with a clear privacy policy) is not subject to DNT. 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-180 (edit)
CLOSED Add "advertising" as a Permitted Use in the Compliance Document 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-181 (edit) CLOSED Finalize language regarding multiple first parties 2012-10-08 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-186 (edit)
CLOSED Ensure that browsers communicae DNT functionality accurately 2012-11-05 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-191 (edit)
Descriptive DeID
CLOSED Non-normative Discussion of De-Identification 2013-01-15 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-22 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Still have "operational use" of data (auditing of where ads are shown, impression tracking, etc.) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-31 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Minimization -- to what extent will minimization be required for use of a particular exemption? (conditional exemptions) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-32 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-49 (edit)
service provider
PENDING REVIEW Third party as first party - is a third party that collects data on behalf of the first party treated the same way as the first party? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-97 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Re-direction, shortened URLs, click analytics -- what kind of tracking is this? 2011-10-31 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-99 (edit) PENDING REVIEW How does DNT work with identity providers? 2011-11-05 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-172 (edit)
PENDING REVIEW How should user agents be required to provide information about DNT? 2012-10-03 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-175 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Have an appendix of best practices? 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-194 (edit)
PENDING REVIEW How should we ensure consent of users for DNT inputs? 2013-04-10 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-196 (edit) PENDING REVIEW What compliance requirements apply when a signal has been disregarded? 2013-05-07 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-201 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Interplay between UGE and out of band consent 2013-06-12 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-150 (edit) RAISED DNT conflicts from multiple user agents 2012-05-30 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-184 (edit) RAISED 3rd party dependencies in 1st party content 2012-10-24 Compliance Next 1
ISSUE-123 (edit) POSTPONED Third parties should be prohibited from acting or representing themselves as first parties. 2012-02-01 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-131 (edit) POSTPONED What should implementations look like to satisfy our exit criteria for CR? 2012-04-10 Compliance Next 0

All Actions

There are 40 actions.

ID State Title Person Due Date Associated with
ACTION-68 (edit) pending review Provide text on ISSUE-54 Justin Brookman 2012-02-01 ISSUE-54
ACTION-69 (edit) pending review Propose renaming issue-54 Sean Harvey 2012-02-03 ISSUE-54
ACTION-72 (edit) pending review Draft text on issue-25, issue-74 Kathy Joe 2012-02-06 ISSUE-74
ACTION-105 (edit) pending review Write-up "reasonably discoverable assertions" standard for party membership assertion for purposes of researcher/enforcement only Jonathan Mayer 2012-02-02 Compliance Next
ACTION-106 (edit) pending review Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering, with Vincent Toubiana Heather West 2012-02-02 ISSUE-32
ACTION-110 (edit) pending review Write proposal text for what it means to "not track" Ninja Marnau 2012-02-10 ISSUE-119
ACTION-116 (edit) pending review Draft text prohibitng third parties from acting or representing themselves as first parties Thomas Lowenthal 2012-03-06 ISSUE-123
ACTION-157 (edit) pending review Update logged-in consent proposal by April 24 Shane Wiley 2012-04-24 Compliance Next
ACTION-160 (edit) pending review Work with Shane on common ground on unlinkability normative/non-normative text Peter Eckersley 2012-05-23 Compliance Next
ACTION-161 (edit) pending review work on issue-49 Shane Wiley 2012-09-05 service provider
ACTION-165 (edit) pending review Draft example text around using the Geolocation API for non-normative text on "Geolocation compliance" section in Compliance Ian Fette 2012-04-25 Compliance Next
ACTION-190 (edit) pending review Write up proposal for allowed uses for protocol data in the first N weeks Ian Fette 2012-05-02 ISSUE-174
ACTION-195 (edit) pending review Clarify action items needed for issue-65 Justin Brookman 2012-08-15 ISSUE-65
ACTION-196 (edit) pending review Draft text on whether url shorteners are first or third parties Justin Brookman 2012-08-15 ISSUE-97
ACTION-211 (edit) pending review Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal Justin Brookman 2012-06-13 Compliance Next
ACTION-212 (edit) pending review Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal Shane Wiley 2012-09-26 user-education
ACTION-246 (edit) pending review draft proposal regarding making a public compliance commitment (with Alan, Ian) David Wainberg 2012-10-10 ISSUE-45
ACTION-262 (edit) pending review Draft text regarding existing contracts (with vinay) Amy Colando 2012-10-03 ISSUE-28
ACTION-266 (edit) pending review Suggest retention related to a timed grace period (with dwainberg) Ian Fette 2012-10-10 ISSUE-174
ACTION-273 (edit) pending review Propose text regarding multiple first parties Rob Sherman 2012-11-02 ISSUE-181
ACTION-278 (edit) pending review Suggest an alternative to debugging graduated response ('once identified a problem') Thomas Lowenthal 2012-10-10 Compliance Next
ACTION-279 (edit) pending review Write an explanation of graduated response and a list of explanatory use cases Ian Fette 2012-10-10 ISSUE-24
ACTION-280 (edit) pending review Draft updated text on UA requirements; explanatory text made more general; add 'prior to selecting DNT'; add examples; change MUST to SHOULD Shane Wiley 2012-10-10 user-education
ACTION-286 (edit) pending review Propose DAA text regarding de-identification (for unlinkability discussion) Rachel Thomas 2012-11-22 unlinkable-deidentified
ACTION-287 (edit) pending review Define "user expectation" as it's used in the context of the two documents. Brendan Riordan-Butterworth 2012-11-14 Compliance Next
ACTION-289 (edit) pending review Define "unlinkable" related to section 3.6 on unlinkable data in compliance document Walter van Holst 2012-10-10 unlinkable-deidentified
ACTION-292 (edit) pending review Move global requirements above enumerated permitted uses Justin Brookman 2012-10-18 Compliance Next
ACTION-293 (edit) pending review Draft non-normative examples illustrating graduated response Jonathan Mayer 2012-10-11 ISSUE-24
ACTION-298 (edit) pending review Draft examples for Jonathan Mayer 2012-10-11 ISSUE-31
ACTION-299 (edit) pending review Revise data minimization (flip ONLY --> NOT, "had expired," non-norm examples, et alia. Justin Brookman 2012-10-11 Compliance Next
ACTION-301 (edit) pending review Eijk to draft explanation on intermediaries and inserted headers Rob van Eijk 2012-10-11 ISSUE-176
ACTION-303 (edit) pending review Draft definition of "visit" Ian Fette 2012-10-11 ISSUE-97
ACTION-306 (edit) pending review Define "declared" data Shane Wiley 2012-10-11 ISSUE-54
ACTION-311 (edit) pending review Merge definitions of "party" Justin Brookman 2013-04-01 Compliance Next
ACTION-324 (edit) pending review Compile public compliance commitment options for potential Call Aleecia McDonald 2012-10-24 ISSUE-45
ACTION-339 (edit) pending review Propose a refinement to debugging permitted use Walter van Holst 2012-11-21 ISSUE-24
ACTION-401 (edit) open Update compliance standard to provide requirements for sending D tracking status signal when disregarding DNT:1 signals Justin Brookman 2013-05-14 Compliance Next
ACTION-404 (edit) open Further Fact finding on scope of audience measurement and the DAA exception (one page of text) Susan Israel 2013-06-19 AudienceMeasurement
ACTION-408 (edit) open Review security/fraud text (with chris mejia and dan auerbach) David Wainberg 2013-05-29 ISSUE-24
ACTION-410 (edit) open Review issue-184 with Walter and Rob before merging/pending review Peter Swire 2013-05-29 ISSUE-184

Add a new action item.

See only open and raised issues and actions.

Chair, Staff Contact
Tracker: documentation, (configuration for this group), originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <>.
$Id: all.html,v 1.1 2019/02/01 09:32:50 vivien Exp $