Details on Product Compliance Next

All Issues

New issues for this product are notified to public-tracking@w3.org (change it).

There are 87 issues listed in the system.

ID State Title Raised on Product Open Actions
ISSUE-200 (edit) OPEN Transitive exceptions 2013-06-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-3 (edit) CLOSED What is the granularity of the choice we expect users to make? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-6 (edit) CLOSED What are the underlying concerns? Why are we doing this / what are people afraid of? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-7 (edit) CLOSED What types of tracking exist, and what are the use cases for these types of tracking? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-8 (edit) CLOSED How do we enhance transparency and consumer awareness? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-9 (edit) CLOSED Understand all the different first- and third-party cases. 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-11 (edit) CLOSED Document a longer list of use cases -- what's going on today 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-12 (edit) CLOSED How does tracking require relation to unique identities, pseudonyms, etc.? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-15 (edit) CLOSED What special treatment should there be for children's data? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-17 (edit) CLOSED Data use by 1st Party 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-18 (edit) CLOSED Collection definition (not sure I said the prefix before?) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-19 (edit) CLOSED Data collection / Data use (3rd party) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-20 (edit) CLOSED Different types of data, what counts as PII, and what definition of PII 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-23 (edit) CLOSED Possible exemption for analytics 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-26 (edit) CLOSED Providing data to 3rd-party widgets -- does that imply consent? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-28 (edit) CLOSED Exception for mandatory legal process 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-29 (edit) CLOSED Tracking that may be required by law enforcement 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-30 (edit) CLOSED Will Do Not Track apply to offline aggregating or selling of data? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-33 (edit) CLOSED Complexity of user choice (are exemptions exposed to users?) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-34 (edit) CLOSED Possible exemption for aggregate analytics 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-35 (edit) CLOSED How will DNT interact with existing opt-out programs (industry self-reg, other)? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-36 (edit) CLOSED Should DNT opt-outs distinguish between behavioral targeting and other personalization? 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-37 (edit) CLOSED Granularity based on business types and uses 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-38 (edit) CLOSED Granularity for different people who share a device or browser 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-39 (edit) CLOSED Tracking of geographic data (however it's determined, or used) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-41 (edit) CLOSED Consistent way to discuss tracking with users (terminology matters!) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-45 (edit) CLOSED Companies making public commitments with a "regulatory hook" for US legal purposes 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-52 (edit) CLOSED What if conflict between opt-out cookie and DNT? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-53 (edit) CLOSED How should opt-out cookie and DNT signal interact? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-54 (edit) CLOSED can first parties use declared data while in a 3rd party context? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-55 (edit) CLOSED What is relationship between behavioral advertising and tracking, subset, different items? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-56 (edit) CLOSED What if DNT is unspecified and an opt-out cookie is present? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-57 (edit) CLOSED What if an opt-out cookie exists but an "opt back in" out-of-band is present? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-58 (edit) CLOSED What if DNT is explicitly set to 0 and an opt-out cookie is present? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-60 (edit) CLOSED Will a recipient know if it itself is a 1st or 3rd party? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-64 (edit) CLOSED How do we describe non-identifiable data 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-65 (edit) CLOSED How does logged in and logged out state work 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-66 (edit) CLOSED Can user be allowed to consent to both third party and first party to override general DNT? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-69 (edit) CLOSED Should the spec say anything about minimal notice? (ie. don't bury in a privacy policy) 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-71 (edit) CLOSED Does DNT require purging or modifying data collected in the past (not under DNT)? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-72 (edit) CLOSED Basic principle: independent use as an agent of a first party 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-73 (edit) CLOSED In order for analytics or other contracting to count as first-party: by contract, by technical silo, both silo and contract 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-74 (edit) CLOSED Are surveys out of scope? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-75 (edit) CLOSED How do companies claim exemptions and is that technical or not? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-88 (edit) CLOSED different rules for impression of and interaction with 3rd-party ads/content 2011-09-23 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-89 (edit) CLOSED Does DNT mean at a high level: (a) no customization, users are seen for the first time, every time. (b) DNT is about data moving between sites. 2011-10-05 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-91 (edit) CLOSED Might want prohibitions on first parties re-selling data to get around the intent of DNT 2011-10-12 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-92 (edit) CLOSED If data collection (even very specific with IP address, user agent, referrer) is time-limited, with very limited retention, is that still tracking? 2011-10-19 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-93 (edit) CLOSED Should 1st parties be able to degrade a user experience or charge money for content based on DNT? 2011-10-19 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-94 (edit) CLOSED Is "Do Not Track" the right name to use? 2011-10-24 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-100 (edit) CLOSED What is a user? 2011-11-09 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-101 (edit) CLOSED What is a user? add to defns 2011-11-09 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-102 (edit) CLOSED Short names & titles of specifications 2011-11-13 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-103 (edit) CLOSED We're not sure where the exceptions should be and ensure they are categorically captured in the base 3rd party prohibition statement. 2011-11-23 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-104 (edit) CLOSED Could use a better defn of user agent, rather than browser 2011-11-28 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-117 (edit) CLOSED Terms: tracking v. cross-site tracking 2012-01-13 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-122 (edit) CLOSED Should we have use limitations on referrer data? 2012-02-01 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-132 (edit) CLOSED Should the spec speak to intermediaries or hosting providers to modify any responses/statements about DNT compliance? 2012-04-10 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-133 (edit) CLOSED What effect does legal liability or consistent data practices between affiliates have on the definition of breadth of a party? 2012-04-10 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-142 (edit) CLOSED How should protocol data be allowed to be used in the first N weeks? 2012-04-25 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-149 (edit) CLOSED Compliance section for user agents 2012-05-30 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-154 (edit) CLOSED Are First parties allowed to use data (either offline or online) from third parties 2012-06-20 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-163 (edit) CLOSED How in the spec should we ensure user agents don't twist a user preference one way or another? 2012-09-19 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-169 (edit) CLOSED What do we mean by tracking? 2012-10-03 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-174 (edit) CLOSED How do we create straightforward compliance for implementers retaining data for N weeks or less? 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-177 (edit) CLOSED Should we specify compliance requirements for software and hardware other than user agents? For example, is a web server package compliant if it tweaks DNT headers? 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-178 (edit)
marketing-permitted
CLOSED Add "Marketing" to list of permitted uses in Compliance document 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-179 (edit) CLOSED Make sure in the spec that we clarify information provided explicitly by a user (e.g. data typed into a form on a site with a clear privacy policy) is not subject to DNT. 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-180 (edit)
advertising-permitted
CLOSED Add "advertising" as a Permitted Use in the Compliance Document 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-181 (edit) CLOSED Finalize language regarding multiple first parties 2012-10-08 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-186 (edit)
Chapell
CLOSED Ensure that browsers communicae DNT functionality accurately 2012-11-05 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-191 (edit)
Descriptive DeID
CLOSED Non-normative Discussion of De-Identification 2013-01-15 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-22 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Still have "operational use" of data (auditing of where ads are shown, impression tracking, etc.) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-31 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Minimization -- to what extent will minimization be required for use of a particular exemption? (conditional exemptions) 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-32 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering 2011-09-21 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-49 (edit)
service provider
PENDING REVIEW Third party as first party - is a third party that collects data on behalf of the first party treated the same way as the first party? 2011-09-22 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-97 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Re-direction, shortened URLs, click analytics -- what kind of tracking is this? 2011-10-31 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-99 (edit) PENDING REVIEW How does DNT work with identity providers? 2011-11-05 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-172 (edit)
user-education
PENDING REVIEW How should user agents be required to provide information about DNT? 2012-10-03 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-175 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Have an appendix of best practices? 2012-10-04 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-194 (edit)
user-consent
PENDING REVIEW How should we ensure consent of users for DNT inputs? 2013-04-10 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-196 (edit) PENDING REVIEW What compliance requirements apply when a signal has been disregarded? 2013-05-07 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-201 (edit) PENDING REVIEW Interplay between UGE and out of band consent 2013-06-12 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-150 (edit) RAISED DNT conflicts from multiple user agents 2012-05-30 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-184 (edit) RAISED 3rd party dependencies in 1st party content 2012-10-24 Compliance Next 1
ISSUE-123 (edit) POSTPONED Third parties should be prohibited from acting or representing themselves as first parties. 2012-02-01 Compliance Next 0
ISSUE-131 (edit) POSTPONED What should implementations look like to satisfy our exit criteria for CR? 2012-04-10 Compliance Next 0

All Actions

There are 40 actions.

ID State Title Person Due Date Associated with
ACTION-68 (edit) pending review Provide text on ISSUE-54 Justin Brookman 2012-02-01 ISSUE-54
ACTION-69 (edit) pending review Propose renaming issue-54 Sean Harvey 2012-02-03 ISSUE-54
ACTION-72 (edit) pending review Draft text on issue-25, issue-74 Kathy Joe 2012-02-06 ISSUE-74
ACTION-105 (edit) pending review Write-up "reasonably discoverable assertions" standard for party membership assertion for purposes of researcher/enforcement only Jonathan Mayer 2012-02-02 Compliance Next
ACTION-106 (edit) pending review Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering, with Vincent Toubiana Heather West 2012-02-02 ISSUE-32
ACTION-110 (edit) pending review Write proposal text for what it means to "not track" Ninja Marnau 2012-02-10 ISSUE-119
ACTION-116 (edit) pending review Draft text prohibitng third parties from acting or representing themselves as first parties Thomas Lowenthal 2012-03-06 ISSUE-123
ACTION-157 (edit) pending review Update logged-in consent proposal by April 24 Shane Wiley 2012-04-24 Compliance Next
ACTION-160 (edit) pending review Work with Shane on common ground on unlinkability normative/non-normative text Peter Eckersley 2012-05-23 Compliance Next
ACTION-161 (edit) pending review work on issue-49 Shane Wiley 2012-09-05 service provider
ACTION-165 (edit) pending review Draft example text around using the Geolocation API for non-normative text on "Geolocation compliance" section in Compliance Ian Fette 2012-04-25 Compliance Next
ACTION-190 (edit) pending review Write up proposal for allowed uses for protocol data in the first N weeks Ian Fette 2012-05-02 ISSUE-174
ACTION-195 (edit) pending review Clarify action items needed for issue-65 Justin Brookman 2012-08-15 ISSUE-65
ACTION-196 (edit) pending review Draft text on whether url shorteners are first or third parties Justin Brookman 2012-08-15 ISSUE-97
ACTION-211 (edit) pending review Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal Justin Brookman 2012-06-13 Compliance Next
ACTION-212 (edit) pending review Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal Shane Wiley 2012-09-26 user-education
ACTION-246 (edit) pending review draft proposal regarding making a public compliance commitment (with Alan, Ian) David Wainberg 2012-10-10 ISSUE-45
ACTION-262 (edit) pending review Draft text regarding existing contracts (with vinay) Amy Colando 2012-10-03 ISSUE-28
ACTION-266 (edit) pending review Suggest retention related to a timed grace period (with dwainberg) Ian Fette 2012-10-10 ISSUE-174
ACTION-273 (edit) pending review Propose text regarding multiple first parties Rob Sherman 2012-11-02 ISSUE-181
ACTION-278 (edit) pending review Suggest an alternative to debugging graduated response ('once identified a problem') Thomas Lowenthal 2012-10-10 Compliance Next
ACTION-279 (edit) pending review Write an explanation of graduated response and a list of explanatory use cases Ian Fette 2012-10-10 ISSUE-24
ACTION-280 (edit) pending review Draft updated text on UA requirements; explanatory text made more general; add 'prior to selecting DNT'; add examples; change MUST to SHOULD Shane Wiley 2012-10-10 user-education
ACTION-286 (edit) pending review Propose DAA text regarding de-identification (for unlinkability discussion) Rachel Thomas 2012-11-22 unlinkable-deidentified
ACTION-287 (edit) pending review Define "user expectation" as it's used in the context of the two documents. Brendan Riordan-Butterworth 2012-11-14 Compliance Next
ACTION-289 (edit) pending review Define "unlinkable" related to section 3.6 on unlinkable data in compliance document Walter van Holst 2012-10-10 unlinkable-deidentified
ACTION-292 (edit) pending review Move global requirements above enumerated permitted uses Justin Brookman 2012-10-18 Compliance Next
ACTION-293 (edit) pending review Draft non-normative examples illustrating graduated response Jonathan Mayer 2012-10-11 ISSUE-24
ACTION-298 (edit) pending review Draft examples for Jonathan Mayer 2012-10-11 ISSUE-31
ACTION-299 (edit) pending review Revise data minimization (flip ONLY --> NOT, "had expired," non-norm examples, et alia. Justin Brookman 2012-10-11 Compliance Next
ACTION-301 (edit) pending review Eijk to draft explanation on intermediaries and inserted headers Rob van Eijk 2012-10-11 ISSUE-176
ACTION-303 (edit) pending review Draft definition of "visit" Ian Fette 2012-10-11 ISSUE-97
ACTION-306 (edit) pending review Define "declared" data Shane Wiley 2012-10-11 ISSUE-54
ACTION-311 (edit) pending review Merge definitions of "party" Justin Brookman 2013-04-01 Compliance Next
ACTION-324 (edit) pending review Compile public compliance commitment options for potential Call Aleecia McDonald 2012-10-24 ISSUE-45
ACTION-339 (edit) pending review Propose a refinement to debugging permitted use Walter van Holst 2012-11-21 ISSUE-24
ACTION-401 (edit) open Update compliance standard to provide requirements for sending D tracking status signal when disregarding DNT:1 signals Justin Brookman 2013-05-14 Compliance Next
ACTION-404 (edit) open Further Fact finding on scope of audience measurement and the DAA exception (one page of text) Susan Israel 2013-06-19 AudienceMeasurement
ACTION-408 (edit) open Review security/fraud text (with chris mejia and dan auerbach) David Wainberg 2013-05-29 ISSUE-24
ACTION-410 (edit) open Review issue-184 with Walter and Rob before merging/pending review Peter Swire 2013-05-29 ISSUE-184

Add a new action item.

See only open and raised issues and actions.


Matthias Schunter <matthias.schunter@intel.com>, Chair, Bert Bos <bert@w3.org>, Staff Contact
Tracker: documentation, (configuration for this group), originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <w3t-sys@w3.org>.
$Id: index.php,v 1.326 2018/10/13 17:29:51 vivien Exp $