The W3C Advisory Board (AB) provides ongoing guidance to the W3C Team on issues of strategy, management, legal matters, process, and conflict resolution. This page documents current AB projects, and is open to suggestions from W3C members and non-members.
- 1 Priorities 2018
- 2 Priorities 2017
- 3 New project to suggest to the AB ?
- 4 AB F2F Meetings and conference calls
- 5 Projects
- 6 W3C Community and Tools
- 7 Side Projects
- 8 Historical Documents
- 9 See Also
The AB started discussion on 2018 priorities at our 2017 October f2f meeting.
For work in progress, and individual AB member initial thoughts on our 2018 Priorities, see:
For work in progress, and individual AB member thoughts on 2017 Priorities, see:
New project to suggest to the AB ?
Suggestions for the AB can be done directly by editing this wiki, here, anytime.
AB F2F Meetings and conference calls
- 2018-08-07/08 f2f in Boston (MIT)
- 2018-10-22/26 FYI: TPAC in Lyon, FRANCE — NO AB MEETING (but expected to attend AC meeting)
- 2018-11-28/29 f2f in Tokyo
Taxi sharing for f2f meetings can be organized on the wiki: MeetingTaxis
More: https://www.w3.org/Member/Board/ (W3C Member-only)
The AB holds teleconference meetings twice monthly, currently:
- 14:00-15:00 UTC every 1st & 3rd Thursday (resolved 2017-03-07) barring f2f meeting conflicts or cancellation due to f2f meeting adjacency (next/prev week).
The AB meets and participates in several face to face meetings every year:
- Winter AB meeting
- Spring AC meeting participation, and adjacent AB meeting
- Summer AB meeting (transition meeting usually after AB election)
- Fall TPAC meeting participation, but NO AB meeting
AB meeting summaries are available from the AB’s W3C Member-only page.
(2016-03-22) The AB collects live agenda for their next meeting in on their private AB wiki.
Past f2f meetings wiki pages, most recent first: 2017:
- 2018-05-16/17 f2f in Berlin (DFKI, W3C Office)
- 2018-05-13…15 FYI: AC Meeting in Berlin
- 2018-03-13/14 f2f in Hangzhou host Alibaba
- 2017-12-06/07 f2f in SF, host Mozilla
- 2017-11-06/10 FYI: TPAC in Burlingame, CA — NO AB MEETING
- 2017-10-16/17 f2f in London, host GSMA
- 2017-06-21/22 f2f in Boston, host MIT, Stata Center Room G882
- 2017-04-26/27 f2f in Beijing (after the AC meeting)
- 2017-02-22/23 f2f in Berlin, host Yandex
- 2016 planning is past
- 2016-12-12/13 f2f in Hawaii, host Google
- 2016-08-23/24 f2f at MIT, Cambridge, MA
- 2016-06-22/23 f2f in Paris, France (hosted by Virginie/Gemalto)
- 2016-03-23..24 Cambridge, MA, USA (hosted by W3C/MIT)
- 2016-01-11..12 Hawaii, USA (hosted by Chris/Google)
- 2015-10-29..30 Sapporo, Japan during TPAC/2015
- 2015-09-08..09 Seattle, USA hosted by Mike/Microsoft
- 2015-05-04..05 Paris, France adjacent to AC Meeting
- 2015-02-11..12 Tokyo, Japan hosted by W3C/Keio University
- 2014-10-30..31 Santa Clara, California during TPAC/2014
- 2014-09-16..17 London, England hosted by Chris/Google
- 2014-06-11..12 Cambridge, MA adjacent to AC Meeting
- 2014-03-04..05 San Francisco hosted by Tantek/Mozilla
- 2017-02-06 telcon
- 2017-01-23 telcon
- 2017-01-09 telcon
- ... many more
- 2016-03-07 telcon
- ... many more
- 2015-12-21 telcon
- ... and many before
Editing and Publishing minutes of AB Meetings
Quote from the summary of 3-4 November 2011 AB face-to-face meeting (W3C Member only link):
The Advisory Board, recognizing that the IRC minutes are not a verbatim transcription, adopted a protocol by which each speaker can have their recorded statements edited when he or she feels that what is recorded is either incorrect or needs clarification.
Other AB participants can ask a participant to clarify his or her remarks, but cannot insist on a change.
The protocol is to send requests in e-mail to the AB list, as the only mechanism to change the minutes generated from the IRC record. The goal is to increase both transparency and coherence.
AB projects related to W3C Process, Governance, IP, etc.
W3C Process maintenance
W3C process improvements are discussed in the community group:
- http://www.w3.org/community/w3process/ (Process CG)
Interested in participating in the AB?
Join the Process CG to meet some AB members and get a firsthand impression of our work on perhaps the most important document that the AB is responsible for!
Many AB members participate in the Process CG, and prefer to do actual process iteration work openly in the CG.
See process for more details.
Working Group Effectiveness Task Force
The AB takes an active interest in improving W3C working group effectiveness by documenting and communicating existing good practices that help significantly, above and beyond formal processes, for everyone (especially chairs) participating in working groups.
See the Working Group Effectiveness Task Force (TF) home page:
Several AB members participate in the Working Group Effectiveness Task Force, and prefer to do that work openly in the TF.
The Working Group Effectiveness Task Force is another excellent opportunity to meet some AB members and get an impression of some of the work we do.
Any W3C Group Chairs, Particpants, Invited Experts and Members are welcome to join! See the top of the README for instructions.
AB Wiki Editing Itself
Things to work on wiki-editing workflow for (Tantek, additional volunteers)
- long lived projects having their own undated URLs
- using redirects for per year priorities
- incorporate stuff in W3C AB 2013 2014 OLD PAGE into specific subpages for more navigable archival.
Cultural conventions for attribution
The new HTMLWG charter allows for working group members to contribute HTML5 Extension specifications using CC-by, and then places attribution requirements on any derivative works.
These attribution requirements are a good start for growing cultural conventions for attribution both inside W3C, and beyond W3C, towards a goal of making attribution founded in cultural norms rather than legal (copyright) requirements, potentially allowing for use of CC0 for contributions to W3C in the future.
See AB/attribution for draft suggested best practices for attribution.
The AB has created a Trademark License task force (Tantek Çelik and Michael Champion) to build broad consensus on a combination trademark / license policy to potentially permit more permissive copyright licenses on W3C drafts and specifications.
The AB is working on (as is evident by this wiki page) doing more and more of its work in the open.
Currently Open AB work is occurring in two places:
- http://www.w3.org/wiki/AB (all projects on this wiki page)
- see "Suggestions" section below to contribute
The Advisory Board has a Twitter account: @W3CAB
Nearly the entire AB has access and can post anything regarding AB-related matters. The methodology is to empower individual responsibility and trust by default, especially in such a small group. This method has worked well with the CSSWG (any CSSWG member may "have the keys" to @CSSWG) and it's been hugely successful in engaging the broader developer community.
- 2013-09-18 access broadly shared with AB members in person W3C AB meeting at MIT.
- 2013-06-04 @W3CAB Twitter created.
Making sure the ABs get members opinion
- AB are elected by W3C members and need to make sure that they are collecting their ideas, suggestion... That wiki is great, the recent minutes members-only minutes issued by Coralie were great, but regular open debriefing communication to members/interested parties is key. It could be interesting to have an every-6-months call scheduled in advance to 'meet the AB'. This would be the opportunity to ask direct question to the AB, based on a collaborative agenda.
Virginie Galindo (gemalto AC rep) ~~~~
AB and TAG election : voting experiment
AB has been conducting work in order to audit voting and representativity. An experiment will be conducted in 2014/2015. See FAQ and explanation for that first experiment page
W3C Community and Tools
W3C Chairs Training
The Advisory Board has established Chair Training as a priority for 2014. At TPAC2013, Chairs had a breakfast meeting and expressed what additional information and skills they required to improve their effectiveness. The W3C Team developed a list of areas which have now evolved into a quarterly Chair Training program.
- W3C, Process, and the W3C Team, Philippe Le Hegaret, 23 January 2014
- Tools, Ralph Swick, 24 April 2014
- The Human Dimension, Charles McCathie Nevile, 17 June 2014
- Focus and Productivity, Arnaud Le Hors, 23 October 2014
- Focus and Productivity, Arnaud Le Hors, 29 January 2015
- Horizontal reviews, Virginie Galindo, September 2015
- New W3C process, its philosophy, and how to use it for agility, Steve Zilles, February/March 2015
- TBC: Making rapid progress in developing specs in W3C despite the W3C process
- IPR Management in a Github age - repo manager training, Kaz Ashimura, Sep 21 2017
Use of GitHub at W3C
The AB looks at use of GitHub at W3C specifically in terms of impacts on process and IP concerns.
Some W3C groups use use GitHub to develop specifications or edit non-normative documents. While the strategy for using Tracker and/or Bugzilla and/or GitHub is left to WG decision, there are some good practices that can be gathered. That section is pointing to effort to federate experiences and good practices.
- Read the GitHub draft guidelines
- Note that some experimentation is happening in WebRTC WG is order to link W3C mailing list and GitHub, based on Dominique Hazael-Massieux github notify effort
- Ask questions here GitHub.
The AB is looking at issues related to remote participation in W3C meetings.
OpenWeb Tools at W3C
The AB has discussed how to increase the use of OpenWeb Tools at W3C itself (a form of dogfooding). Many (most?) presentations at W3C workshops (e.g. the Workshop on Social Standards: The Future of Business) use non-open-web technologies/formats. W3C should work on good practices to encourage more use of OpenWeb Tools instead of, or at least before non-open-web technologies/formats.
- See open web tool
In addition to the above some members of the AB work on additional side projects related to W3C process, culture, etc.
Past Home Pages
Past AB Priorities
The AB has identified (at the 2016-01 f2f meeting) the following 2016 project priorities, clustered:
- Maintenance (obsoleting, errata, bug fixing) TÇ, MC, CW
- Supergroups CMN (co-lead), DS (co-lead)
- Be more global JZ (co-lead), JK (co-lead), CMN (co-lead)
- Best practices for rec track MC (lead), JJ, TÇ, JZ, JK, CW
- Modern Tools VG, JK
- Security VG (co-lead recruiting), TÇ (co-lead security & privacy questionnaire), JZ
- Funding transparency and how to deploy team resources CW (lead), VG, CMN
- Role of director JJ (co-lead), DS (co-lead)
- Voting JJ (co-lead), CMN (co-lead)
AB Priorities for 2014/2015
AB identified some projects gathering enough support by AB members to be rolled out in 2014/2015. Here is a short description of each identified project.
- Identify work not destined for success. Lead: Mike Champion. See plan
- Identify the most important priorities for the Web and W3C. Lead: Jeff Jaffe. See plan
- Improve agility of W3C. Lead: Chris Wilson. See plan
- W3C Process Revision 2015. Lead: Steve Zilles, Editor: Chaals McCathie Nevile.
- Trademark Policy and Licensing. Lead: Mike Champion and Tantek Çelik. See plan
- Voting experiment. Lead: Chaals McCathie Nevile.
- W3C synchronization and consistency. Lead: Virginie Galindo. See plan
- Improving how AB represents the AC. Lead: Virginie Galindo. See plan
- Best practices to support multilingual W3C Lead: Daniel Park and Jay Kishigami See plan
See how AB members selected these topics 2014-2015 AB Priorities wiki page.