Input for Agenda Planning for the Technical Architecture Group

Open issues with open and pending review action items

Meeting planning and records

ISSUE-42 (ultimateQuestion-42): weekly misc.

ACTION-215 on Ashok Malhotra: Send minutes of Nov 19 TAG teleconference to www-tag for review - due 2009-11-23 - open

ACTION-213 on Noah Mendelsohn: Prepare 3 Dec weekly teleconference agenda (regrets: Tim) - due 2009-12-02 - open

Unbound actions:

ACTION-277 on Noah Mendelsohn: Ensure patent policy issue is resolved with Art - due 2009-09-08 - pending review

ACTION-330 on Dan Connolly: Prepare Dec f2f agenda in collaboration with Noah etc. - due 2009-11-24 - open

HTML 5 review

ISSUE-33 (mixedUIXMLNamespace-33): Composability for user interface-oriented XML namespaces

ACTION-332 on Dan Connolly: Note that the HTML 5 spec has a proposed design for mixing in SVG and MathML, which is said to be the scope of IsSUE-33 mixedUIXMLNamespace-33 - due 2009-11-10 - pending review

ISSUE-54 (TagSoupIntegration-54): Tag soup integration

ACTION-327 on Henry S. Thompson: Review Microsoft's namespaces in HTML 5 proposal - due 2009-11-19 - pending review

ACTION-335 on Dan Connolly: Remind us about data-* when progress on distributed extensibility next becomes available - due 2010-01-01 - open

ISSUE-24 (contentTypeOverride-24): Can a specification include rules for overriding HTTPcontent type parameters?

ACTION-308 on John Kemp: Propose updates to Authoritative Metadata and Self-Describing Web to acknowledge the reality of sniffing, due 2009-10-20 - due 2009-11-25 - open

ISSUE-20 (errorHandling-20): What should specifications say about error handling?

ACTION-309 on Henry S. Thompson: Henry to bring back proposed TAG pushback on sniffing and HTTP bis draft http://trac.tools.ietf.org/wg/httpbis/trac/export/663/draft-ietf-httpbis/latest/p3-payload.html, or his recommendation that we leave it alone - due 2009-11-26 - open

ISSUE-41 (LanguageVersioning-41): What are good practices for designing extensible languages and for handling versioning?

ACTION-283 on Larry Masinter: Update document on version identifiers w.r.t. Cambridge June discussion - due 2009-12-10 - pending review

Unbound actions:

ACTION-304 on Larry Masinter: Write up issue around normative references to particular versions of specs - due 2009-09-30 - pending review

ACTION-292 on Noah Mendelsohn: Alert group to review HTML Authoring Drafts [trivial] [self-assigned] - due 2009-10-13 - pending review

ACTION-303 on Henry S. Thompson: Draft text on writing references - due 2009-10-28 - pending review

ACTION-334 on Henry S. Thompson: Start an email thread regarding the treatment of pre-HTML5 versions in the media type registration text of HTML5 - due 2009-11-26 - open

ACTION-326 on Henry S. Thompson: track HTML WG progress on their bug 8154 on polyglot documents - due 2009-12-05 - open

ACTION-302 on Noah Mendelsohn: Raise (as individual issue) question of 3 words "other applicable specifictions" in 3.2.1 (3.3.1) of HTML 5 - due 2009-12-08 - open

Metadata Architecture

ISSUE-62 (UniformAccessToMetadata-62): Uniform Access to Metadata

ACTION-336 on Ashok Malhotra: Prep Metadata Architecture for Dec f2f - due 2009-11-13 - pending review

ACTION-281 on Ashok Malhotra: Keep an eye on progress of link header draft, report to TAG, warn us of problems (ISSUE-62) - due 2009-12-01 - open

ACTION-282 on Jonathan Rees: Draft a finding on metadata architecture. - due 2009-12-01 - open

ISSUE-57 (HttpRedirections-57): The use of HTTP Redirection

ACTION-201 on Jonathan Rees: Report on status of AWWSW discussions - due 2009-12-01 - open

ACTION-116 on Tim Berners-Lee: Align the tabulator internal vocabulary with the vocabulary in the rules http://esw.w3.org/topic/AwwswDboothsRules, getting changes to either as needed. - due 2009-12-10 - open

Unbound actions:

ACTION-337 on Larry Masinter: frame the F2F agenda and preparation on metadata formats/representations - due 2009-11-24 - open

ACTION-278 on Jonathan Rees: Draft changes to 2.7 of Metadata in URIs to cover the "Google Calendar" case - due 2009-12-10 - open

Web Application Architecture

Unbound actions:

ACTION-306 on Ashok Malhotra: Work with Raman, LM, JK to update Web APplication architecture outline based on discussions at TAG meetings - due 2009-11-20 - open

ACTION-318 on Noah Mendelsohn: Send note to Device APIs and Policy (DAP) Working Group on behalf of the TAG - due 2009-11-20 - open

ACTION-321 on Larry Masinter: lightly edit TAG input to DAP WG per 8 Oct and tell Noah - due 2009-11-20 - open

ACTION-331 on Dan Connolly: Consider ways to track the 'confused deputy problem' issue in webapps/cors - due 2009-12-01 - open

ACTION-323 on Dan Connolly: As Thomas for a report form the security BOF - due 2009-12-08 - open

ACTION-280 on Dan Connolly: (with John K) to enumerate some CSRF scenarios discussed in Jun in Cambridge - due 2010-01-01 - open

Unbound issues

ISSUE-50 (URNsAndRegistries-50): URIs, URNs, "location independent" naming systems and associated registries for naming on the Web

ACTION-311 on Noah Mendelsohn: Schedule discussion of a persistent domain name policy promotion - due 2009-11-10 - pending review

ACTION-312 on Jonathan Rees: Find a path thru the specs that I think contradicts Dan's reading of webarch - due 2009-12-01 - pending review

ACTION-121 on Henry S. Thompson: HT to draft TAG input to review of draft ARK RFC - due 2009-12-01 - open

ACTION-33 on Henry S. Thompson: revise naming challenges story in response to Dec 2008 F2F discussion - due 2009-12-04 - open

ISSUE-30 (binaryXML-30): Standardize a "binary XML" format?

ACTION-328 on Noah Mendelsohn: Convey to the EXIWG the resolution "We thank the EXI WG for registering the conetnt encoding and encourage them in their endeavours.". - due 2009-11-13 - pending review

ISSUE-34 (xmlFunctions-34): XML Transformation and composability (e.g., XSLT,XInclude, Encryption)

ACTION-239 on Henry S. Thompson: alert chair when updates to description of xmlFunctions-34 are ready for review (or if none made) - due 2009-12-01 - open

ACTION-113 on Henry S. Thompson: HT to a) revise composition.pdf to take account of suggestions from Tim & Jonathan and feedback from email and b) produce a new version of the Elaborated Infoset finding, possibly incorporating some of the PDF - due 2010-01-01 - open

ISSUE-53 (genericResources-53): Generic resources

ACTION-232 on Henry S. Thompson: Follow-up to Hausenblas once there's a draft of HTTPbis which has advice on conneg - due 2009-12-01 - open

ISSUE-8 (namespaceDocument-8): What should a "namespace document" look like?

ACTION-23 on Henry S. Thompson: track progress of #int bug 1974 in the XML Schema namespace document in the XML Schema WG - due 2009-12-08 - open

ISSUE-58 (scalabilityOfURIAccess-58): Scalability of URI Access to Resources

ACTION-163 on Henry S. Thompson: Coordinate with Ted to build a sample catalog - due 2009-12-10 - open

Action Items Pending Review

There are 11 pending review actions.

ID	State	Title	Person	Due Date	Associated with
ACTION-277	pending review	Ensure patent policy issue is resolved with Art	Noah Mendelsohn	2009-09-08	Meeting planning and records
ACTION-283	pending review	Update document on version identifiers w.r.t. Cambridge June discussion	Larry Masinter	2009-12-10	LanguageVersioning-41
ACTION-292	pending review	Alert group to review HTML Authoring Drafts [trivial] [self-assigned]	Noah Mendelsohn	2009-10-13	HTML 5 review
ACTION-303	pending review	Draft text on writing references	Henry S. Thompson	2009-10-28	HTML 5 review
ACTION-304	pending review	Write up issue around normative references to particular versions of specs	Larry Masinter	2009-09-30	HTML 5 review
ACTION-311	pending review	Schedule discussion of a persistent domain name policy promotion	Noah Mendelsohn	2009-11-10	URNsAndRegistries-50
ACTION-312	pending review	Find a path thru the specs that I think contradicts Dan's reading of webarch	Jonathan Rees	2009-12-01	URNsAndRegistries-50
ACTION-327	pending review	Review Microsoft's namespaces in HTML 5 proposal	Henry S. Thompson	2009-11-19	TagSoupIntegration-54
ACTION-328	pending review	Convey to the EXIWG the resolution "We thank the EXI WG for registering the conetnt encoding and encourage them in their endeavours.".	Noah Mendelsohn	2009-11-13	binaryXML-30
ACTION-332	pending review	Note that the HTML 5 spec has a proposed design for mixing in SVG and MathML, which is said to be the scope of IsSUE-33 mixedUIXMLNamespace-33	Dan Connolly	2009-11-10	mixedUIXMLNamespace-33
ACTION-336	pending review	Prep Metadata Architecture for Dec f2f	Ashok Malhotra	2009-11-13	UniformAccessToMetadata-62

Overdue action items

There are 4 overdue actions.

ID	State	Title	Person	Due Date	Associated with
ACTION-215	open	Send minutes of Nov 19 TAG teleconference to www-tag for review	Ashok Malhotra	2009-11-23	ultimateQuestion-42
ACTION-306	open	Work with Raman, LM, JK to update Web APplication architecture outline based on discussions at TAG meetings	Ashok Malhotra	2009-11-20	Web Application Architecture
ACTION-318	open	Send note to Device APIs and Policy (DAP) Working Group on behalf of the TAG	Noah Mendelsohn	2009-11-20	Web Application Architecture
ACTION-321	open	lightly edit TAG input to DAP WG per 8 Oct and tell Noah	Larry Masinter	2009-11-20	Web Application Architecture

Action items due next week

There are 5 upcoming actions.

ID	State	Title	Person	Due Date	Associated with
ACTION-308	open	Propose updates to Authoritative Metadata and Self-Describing Web to acknowledge the reality of sniffing, due 2009-10-20	John Kemp	2009-11-25	contentTypeOverride-24
ACTION-309	open	Henry to bring back proposed TAG pushback on sniffing and HTTP bis draft http://trac.tools.ietf.org/wg/httpbis/trac/export/663/draft-ietf-httpbis/latest/p3-payload.html, or his recommendation that we leave it alone	Henry S. Thompson	2009-11-26	errorHandling-20
ACTION-330	open	Prepare Dec f2f agenda in collaboration with Noah etc.	Dan Connolly	2009-11-24	Meeting planning and records
ACTION-334	open	Start an email thread regarding the treatment of pre-HTML5 versions in the media type registration text of HTML5	Henry S. Thompson	2009-11-26	HTML 5 review
ACTION-337	open	frame the F2F agenda and preparation on metadata formats/representations	Larry Masinter	2009-11-24	Metadata Architecture

Issues discussed over the last week

There are 9 recently discussed issues listed in the system.

ID	State	Title	Raised on	Product	Open Actions
ISSUE-4 xformsReview-4	CLOSED	Request to review XForms Last Call document	2002-01-18		0
ISSUE-6 rdfmsQnameUriMapping-6	CLOSED	Algorithm for creating a URI from a QName?	2002-01-22		0
ISSUE-27 IRIEverywhere-27	OPEN	Should W3C specifications start promoting IRIs?	2002-10-09		0
ISSUE-33 mixedUIXMLNamespace-33	OPEN	Composability for user interface-oriented XML namespaces	2003-02-06	HTML 5 review	0
ISSUE-34 xmlFunctions-34	OPEN	XML Transformation and composability (e.g., XSLT,XInclude, Encryption)	2003-02-06		2
ISSUE-41 LanguageVersioning-41	OPEN	What are good practices for designing extensible languages and for handling versioning?	2003-06-27	HTML 5 review	0
ISSUE-50 URNsAndRegistries-50	OPEN	URIs, URNs, "location independent" naming systems and associated registries for naming on the Web	2005-03-15		2
ISSUE-62 UniformAccessToMetadata-62	OPEN	Uniform Access to Metadata	2009-03-04	Metadata Architecture	2
ISSUE-63	OPEN	Metadata Architecture for the Web	2009-04-02	Metadata Architecture	0

Raised Issues

There is 1 raised issue listed in the system.

ID	State	Title	Raised on	Product	Open Actions
ISSUE-25 deepLinking-25	RAISED	What to say in defense of principle that deep linking isnot an illegal act?	2002-07-05		1

Pending Review Issues

The following issues are candidate for closing.

There are 5 pending review issues listed in the system.

ID	State	Title	Raised on	Product	Open Actions
ISSUE-1 w3cMediaType-1	PENDING REVIEW	Should W3C WGs define their own media types?	2002-01-09		0
ISSUE-8 namespaceDocument-8	PENDING REVIEW	What should a "namespace document" look like?	2002-01-14		1
ISSUE-16 HTTPSubstrate-16	PENDING REVIEW	Should HTTP be used as a substrate protocol? Does W3C agree with RFC 3205?	2002-03-24		0
ISSUE-35 RDFinXHTML-35	PENDING REVIEW	Syntax and semantics for embedding RDF in XHTML	2003-02-06		0
ISSUE-51 selfDescribingWeb-51	PENDING REVIEW	well known formats and URI based extensibility	2005-04-06		0