Publishing Working Group Telco — Minutes

Date: 2020-09-14

See also the Agenda and the IRC Log

Attendees

Present: Ivan Herman, Avneesh Singh, gregorio, Gregorio Pellegrino, Juliette McShane, Ben Schroeter, Laurent Le Meur, charles, Charles LaPierre, Brady Duga, Garth Conboy, Teenya Franklin, Matt Garrish

Regrets: Bill Kasdorf, Tzviya Siegman, George Kerscher, Lars Wallin

Guests:

Chair: Wendy Reid

Scribe(s): Gregorio Pellegrino

Content:

Wendy Reid: https://www.w3.org/publishing/groups/publ-wg/Meetings/Minutes/2020/2020-08-24-pwg

Wendy Reid: Hi everyone! We are getting close to the end of the charter, this is one of the last call
… minutes approved!
… join the EPUB3 WG!
… we have to talk about last things before sending the docs
… we are resolving some issue that became during testing

Matt Garrish: mostly there where issue with the TOC
… and the primary entry page

Gregorio Pellegrino: (can you post the issue URLs in IRC)?

Matt Garrish: the linking method required for the primary entry page, and also if it was required (it depends on the format)
… there was also a mismatching between the processing algorithm and the TOC specs

Garth Conboy: in the current spec we will get: TOC is not required

Gregorio Pellegrino: quite difficult to scribe :(

Garth Conboy: if you have one it needs to be <nav role="doc-toc">

Ivan Herman: the fact that we removed the requirement, it means we have to pickup one of the tests from the test suite
… it is in the index page

Laurent Le Meur: doing that you can close issue #65

Garth Conboy: we think it’s likely people will read this and will do it the right way

Ivan Herman: the TOC discussion was the longest and most passionate we had last year
… we got a compromise

Matt Garrish: could we point a note there?

Wendy Reid: regular or editor’s note?

Ivan Herman: regular note

Action #1: add note to audiobooks (Wendy Reid)

Laurent Le Meur: it is good to have a note now, but as a maintenance issue I think we have to manage it correctly

Ivan Herman: in theory the new version of the W3C process will become live tomorrow, so when this document will become a rec, we can made some modifications, without having to come back to the beginning
… the idea is something like a “live-recommendation”
… we have to vote for this type of recommendation

Proposed resolution: Request the Director to move Publication Manifest and Audiobooks to Proposed Recommendation (Wendy Reid)

Matt Garrish: +1

Ivan Herman: +1

Gregorio Pellegrino: +1

Wendy Reid: +1

Laurent Le Meur: +1

Avneesh Singh: +1

Juliette McShane: +0

Wendy Reid: tzviya: +1

Garth Conboy: +1

Ben Schroeter: +1

Brady Duga: +1

Resolution #1: Request the Director to move Publication Manifest and Audiobooks to Proposed Recommendation

Proposed resolution: Request the Director allow Publication Manifest and Audiobooks to be continuously developed as part of the the maintenance working group per Process 2020 (Wendy Reid)

Matt Garrish: +1

Ben Schroeter: +1

Juliette McShane: +1

Teenya Franklin: +1

Avneesh Singh: Ivan there are two type of continuous process in process 2020

Proposed resolution: Request the Director allow Publication Manifest and Audiobooks to be continuously developed as part of the the maintenance working group per Process 2020 after achieving Recommendation Status (Wendy Reid)

Ivan Herman: +1

Ben Schroeter: +1

Garth Conboy: +1

Gregorio Pellegrino: +1

Avneesh Singh: +1

Wendy Reid: +1

Laurent Le Meur: +1

Juliette McShane: +1

Resolution #2: Request the Director allow Publication Manifest and Audiobooks to be continuously developed as part of the the maintenance working group per Process 2020 after achieving Recommendation Status

Ivan Herman: now on the practical stuff, I wait for a green light from Matt to start the process
… when we start the process, we can’t edit the specs
… I hope the guy who made all the comments has finished with his work :)

Wendy Reid: I think it somebody from Laurent’s team

Laurent Le Meur: Yes! It is Pierre

Ivan Herman: His work was great, but I hope he has finished ;-)

Laurent Le Meur: Yep, he is done

Ivan Herman: once the PR has gone, your company rep has to vote

Wendy Reid: thank you to all

1. Resolutions

2. Action Items