Pending review Actions

Apply the following changes to selected action items:

There are 131 pending review actions.

ID State Title Person Due Date Associated with
ACTION-68 (edit) pending review Provide text on ISSUE-54 Justin Brookman 2012-02-01 ISSUE-54
ACTION-69 (edit) pending review Propose renaming issue-54 Sean Harvey 2012-02-03 ISSUE-54
ACTION-72 (edit) pending review Draft text on issue-25, issue-74 Kathy Joe 2012-02-06 ISSUE-74
ACTION-91 (edit) pending review Write text on fingerprinting risk (ISSUE-109, ISSUE-114), with Nick Doty Andy Zeigler 2012-02-29 ISSUE-109
ACTION-97 (edit) pending review Add similar protocol language to TPE spec David Singer 2012-02-01 Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-99 (edit) pending review Write up automated discoverability of party relationships proposal (Nick and Bryan to help) David Singer 2012-02-13
ACTION-100 (edit) pending review Write up use of machine-readable party relationships for site-specific exceptions (Joanne and Kevin to help) Amy Colando 2012-02-02
ACTION-105 (edit) pending review Write-up "reasonably discoverable assertions" standard for party membership assertion for purposes of researcher/enforcement only Jonathan Mayer 2012-02-02 Compliance Next
ACTION-106 (edit) pending review Sharing of data between entities via cookie syncing / identity brokering, with Vincent Toubiana Heather West 2012-02-02 ISSUE-32
ACTION-110 (edit) pending review Write proposal text for what it means to "not track" Ninja Marnau 2012-02-10 ISSUE-119
ACTION-111 (edit) pending review Follow up on JavaScript API and report hallway conversation with Shane Thomas Roessler 2012-02-02
ACTION-116 (edit) pending review Draft text prohibitng third parties from acting or representing themselves as first parties Thomas Lowenthal 2012-03-06 ISSUE-123
ACTION-122 (edit) pending review Draft possible use of site-specific exception API to test existence of DNT / ask for exceptions even without DNT turned on Nick Doty 2012-02-15 Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-133 (edit) pending review Collect comparison criteria and summarize comparison in URIvsHeaders table Matthias Schunter 2012-02-29
ACTION-135 (edit) pending review Detail use case for ISSUE-111 (DNT;2) Shane Wiley 2012-03-28 Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-146 (edit) pending review Review the proposed text for ISSUE-111 in the context of a redirect chain where some parties get 0, some parties get 1, and there is potentially some data sharing between the parties in the redirect chain Ian Fette 2012-03-21
ACTION-147 (edit) pending review Enumerate scenarios in which requesting exception[mysite,*] might not work, e.g. user says no, then how do you figure out what you can or cannot get exceptions for, such as if user is only saying no to facebook but you don't know which, if any, of their ad networks the user is objecting to Ian Fette 2012-03-21
ACTION-154 (edit) pending review Draft an unlinkable data/unidentifiable data/pick favorite term exception Jonathan Mayer 2012-04-04
ACTION-157 (edit) pending review Update logged-in consent proposal by April 24 Shane Wiley 2012-04-24 Compliance Next
ACTION-160 (edit) pending review Work with Shane on common ground on unlinkability normative/non-normative text Peter Eckersley 2012-05-23 Compliance Next
ACTION-161 (edit) pending review work on issue-49 Shane Wiley 2012-09-05 service provider
ACTION-165 (edit) pending review Draft example text around using the Geolocation API for non-normative text on "Geolocation compliance" section in Compliance Ian Fette 2012-04-25 Compliance Next
ACTION-174 (edit) pending review Write up implication of origin/* exceptions in EU context Ninja Marnau 2012-06-06 ISSUE-129
ACTION-175 (edit) pending review Draft API method for sites to remove, a la removeTrackingException() Vincent Toubiana 2012-05-05 ISSUE-83
ACTION-176 (edit) pending review Update site-specific exceptions text to note that embedded third-party javascript may make the call rather than the first party (even though it probably shouldn't do so without working it out with the publisher) David Singer 2012-05-30 ISSUE-129
ACTION-177 (edit) pending review Add an API to let a site request a web-wide exception Shane Wiley 2012-05-05 ISSUE-130
ACTION-179 (edit) pending review Draft section on seriousness of the request for a user-granted exception (with ninja) Shane Wiley 2012-04-19 ISSUE-129
ACTION-180 (edit) pending review Provide a text update to section 4.3 to resolve issue 116 and ISSUE-84 Nick Doty 2012-05-23 ISSUE-116
ACTION-185 (edit) pending review Draft specific field proposal for optional auditors Kevin Trilli 2012-05-26 Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-186 (edit) pending review Clarify non-normative text on making a public commitment (also in a privacy policy, e.g.) Justin Brookman 2012-06-25
ACTION-187 (edit) pending review Write text for ISSUE-99 around identity providers as first or third parties, DUE May 5 2012 Ian Fette 2012-06-06
ACTION-189 (edit) pending review Differentiate observers from members in attendee list for DC minutes Nick Doty 2012-05-02
ACTION-190 (edit) pending review Write up proposal for allowed uses for protocol data in the first N weeks Ian Fette 2012-05-02 ISSUE-174
ACTION-191 (edit) pending review Write up proposal for allowed uses for protocol data in the first N weeks for ISSUE-142 Thomas Lowenthal 2012-05-05
ACTION-193 (edit) pending review Document difficulties around well known URIs for large sites and propose alternatives Ian Fette 2012-05-09
ACTION-194 (edit) pending review Write up a proposal for transitive third party exceptions Ian Fette 2012-05-09
ACTION-195 (edit) pending review Clarify action items needed for issue-65 Justin Brookman 2012-08-15 ISSUE-65
ACTION-196 (edit) pending review Draft text on whether url shorteners are first or third parties Justin Brookman 2012-08-15 ISSUE-97
ACTION-197 (edit) pending review Propose alternative media access policies Jonathan Mayer 2012-05-16
ACTION-206 (edit) pending review Integrate by May 30 David Singer 2012-05-30 Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-211 (edit) pending review Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal Justin Brookman 2012-06-13 Compliance Next
ACTION-212 (edit) pending review Draft text on how user agents must obtain consent to turn on a DNT signal Shane Wiley 2012-09-26 user-education
ACTION-213 (edit) pending review Draft text perhaps with roy and ifette around notion of filtering out data that is received in large amounts that should be required to be filtered out Jonathan Mayer 2012-07-15
ACTION-218 (edit) pending review Write up proposal on issue-112 that we do exceptions based on origin Nick Doty 2012-07-18
ACTION-220 (edit) pending review Write up tl/matthias sub-group agreement on exception approach Matthias Schunter 2012-06-29
ACTION-222 (edit) pending review Document out-of-band js api Ian Fette 2012-07-25
ACTION-224 (edit) pending review Ensure that Section 4 reflects the latest DomAPI proposal by Nick Nick Doty 2012-07-15 ISSUE-84
ACTION-225 (edit) pending review Propose an alternative definition of first party (based on ownership? alternative to inference?) Heather West 2012-08-22
ACTION-226 (edit) pending review Spec update to address ISSUE/116 David Singer 2012-08-15 Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-227 (edit) pending review Collect input (from Tom, Jonathan, Ed, Rob) on needs for a service-provider flag and compare to current draft David Singer 2012-07-25
ACTION-229 (edit) pending review Draft crisp definition [of data append] Chris Pedigo 2012-08-01 ISSUE-170
ACTION-232 (edit) pending review Write a short proposal on issue-153 David Wainberg 2012-08-22
ACTION-235 (edit) pending review Draft middle way draft on permitted uses Nick Doty 2012-09-04
ACTION-237 (edit) pending review Update Compliance spec with pointer regarding issue-21 Heather West 2012-08-15
ACTION-240 (edit) pending review Insert a note on how sites can avoid repeatedly asking the user for an exception David Singer 2012-08-22
ACTION-241 (edit) pending review Propose changes regarding issue-116 (and also "general preference") Nick Doty 2012-09-10
ACTION-246 (edit) pending review draft proposal regarding making a public compliance commitment (with Alan, Ian) David Wainberg 2012-10-10 ISSUE-45
ACTION-247 (edit) pending review Re-insert values that specify what exceptions are actually in use to the TPE spec David Singer 2012-08-30 Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-249 (edit) pending review Ensure that the qualifiers reflect the permissions documented in the compliance document, due 10 october David Singer 2012-10-10 Tracking Preference Expression (DNT)
ACTION-252 (edit) pending review Propose defining formerly-known-as absolutely-not-tracking via permitted uses Nick Doty 2012-09-12
ACTION-253 (edit) pending review Propose dropping any tracking status value for None/Anonymous David Wainberg 2012-09-12
ACTION-254 (edit) pending review Draft text on freq. capping that would avoid new definitions and/or remove redundant normative requirement (with nick and amy?) Shane Wiley 2012-09-19
ACTION-255 (edit) pending review Work on financial reporting text (with nick, ian) as alternative to legal requirements Alan Chapell 2012-09-19
ACTION-256 (edit) pending review Propose update on security/fraud regarding deception/ad fraud David Wainberg 2012-09-19
ACTION-260 (edit) pending review Update debugging text (add normative 'short term', 'diagnostic', expand on or replace "graduated response") Nick Doty 2012-10-03
ACTION-261 (edit) pending review Update draft to remove aggregate permitted use, highlight unlinkable section where discussion may continue Justin Brookman 2012-10-03
ACTION-262 (edit) pending review Draft text regarding existing contracts (with vinay) Amy Colando 2012-10-03 ISSUE-28
ACTION-264 (edit) pending review Draft updated 'share' definition to avoid concerns (with rigo and chris-p) Amy Colando 2012-10-10
ACTION-265 (edit) pending review Update text in 3.8.1 regarding bringing into compliance, not just deletion Shane Wiley 2012-10-10
ACTION-266 (edit) pending review Suggest retention related to a timed grace period (with dwainberg) Ian Fette 2012-10-10 ISSUE-174
ACTION-267 (edit) pending review Propose first/third party definitions from existing DAA documents Rachel Thomas 2012-10-10
ACTION-268 (edit) pending review Edit the TPE document to make sure that the final definition of parties is in sync across the two specifications David Singer 2012-11-12
ACTION-269 (edit) pending review Update 3.5.2 to expand beyond "Web site" Justin Brookman 2012-10-10
ACTION-273 (edit) pending review Propose text regarding multiple first parties Rob Sherman 2012-11-02 ISSUE-181
ACTION-274 (edit) pending review Propose non-normative text on service providers to clarify "independent use" (with rvaneijk) Shane Wiley 2012-10-10
ACTION-275 (edit) pending review Update middle way proposals to avoid relying on "tracking" Nick Doty 2012-10-10
ACTION-277 (edit) pending review Propose non-normative text regarding contracts/other specifications David Singer 2012-10-10
ACTION-278 (edit) pending review Suggest an alternative to debugging graduated response ('once identified a problem') Thomas Lowenthal 2012-10-10 Compliance Next
ACTION-279 (edit) pending review Write an explanation of graduated response and a list of explanatory use cases Ian Fette 2012-10-10 ISSUE-24
ACTION-280 (edit) pending review Draft updated text on UA requirements; explanatory text made more general; add 'prior to selecting DNT'; add examples; change MUST to SHOULD Shane Wiley 2012-10-10 user-education
ACTION-282 (edit) pending review Add to the TPE that at most one DNT header is permitted in any HTTP request (issue-150) David Singer 2012-10-10
ACTION-284 (edit) pending review Propose barring other software from altering a DNT signal if the browser already set it Ian Fette 2012-10-10
ACTION-286 (edit) pending review Propose DAA text regarding de-identification (for unlinkability discussion) Rachel Thomas 2012-11-22 unlinkable-deidentified
ACTION-287 (edit) pending review Define "user expectation" as it's used in the context of the two documents. Brendan Riordan-Butterworth 2012-11-14 Compliance Next
ACTION-288 (edit) pending review Update unlinkable with non-normative text from Shane Heather West 2012-10-10
ACTION-289 (edit) pending review Define "unlinkable" related to section 3.6 on unlinkable data in compliance document Walter van Holst 2012-10-10 unlinkable-deidentified
ACTION-290 (edit) pending review Remove incorrect terminology in TPE (top-level domain) David Singer 2012-10-30 ISSUE-173
ACTION-291 (edit) pending review update to 3.5.2 to address different requirements regarding screen size Kevin Smith 2012-10-10
ACTION-292 (edit) pending review Move global requirements above enumerated permitted uses Justin Brookman 2012-10-18 Compliance Next
ACTION-293 (edit) pending review Draft non-normative examples illustrating graduated response Jonathan Mayer 2012-10-11 ISSUE-24
ACTION-294 (edit) pending review Revise security/fraud based on existing proposals Justin Brookman 2012-10-11
ACTION-298 (edit) pending review Draft examples for Jonathan Mayer 2012-10-11 ISSUE-31
ACTION-299 (edit) pending review Revise data minimization (flip ONLY --> NOT, "had expired," non-norm examples, et alia. Justin Brookman 2012-10-11 Compliance Next
ACTION-300 (edit) pending review Add a service provider option (or condense with option 1) from jmayer Heather West 2012-10-11
ACTION-301 (edit) pending review Eijk to draft explanation on intermediaries and inserted headers Rob van Eijk 2012-10-11 ISSUE-176
ACTION-302 (edit) pending review Draft intermediary requirements, without implementation details (with Brendan) Brendan Riordan-Butterworth 2012-11-14
ACTION-303 (edit) pending review Draft definition of "visit" Ian Fette 2012-10-11 ISSUE-97
ACTION-304 (edit) pending review Draft proposal on url re-direction Ian Fette 2012-10-11
ACTION-305 (edit) pending review Remove 6.3.2 on logged in transactions Justin Brookman 2012-10-11
ACTION-306 (edit) pending review Define "declared" data Shane Wiley 2012-10-11 ISSUE-54
ACTION-307 (edit) pending review Propose non-normative text on 119 (with schunter) David Singer 2012-10-11
ACTION-311 (edit) pending review Merge definitions of "party" Justin Brookman 2013-04-01 Compliance Next
ACTION-313 (edit) pending review Draft normative text based on adrianba's exception proposal Ian Fette 2012-10-12
ACTION-314 (edit) pending review Draft non-normative examples of how a multi-domain site technically can ask for exceptions Shane Wiley 2012-10-12
ACTION-316 (edit) pending review Draft update on when service provider indication is necessary (with fielding) David Singer 2012-10-12
ACTION-318 (edit) pending review Update draft with JS window/navigator change (coordinate with dsinger/adrianba text) Nick Doty 2012-10-12 ISSUE-116
ACTION-319 (edit) pending review Draft non-normative text on how to accomplish non-JS third parties that want to request for exceptions (with lou) Nick Doty 2012-10-12 ISSUE-138
ACTION-320 (edit) pending review Write reference/examples as necessary for explaining out-of-band consent in TPE (with Joanne) David Singer 2012-10-12
ACTION-323 (edit) pending review Share results of what-the-response-is-for discussion David Singer 2012-12-12
ACTION-324 (edit) pending review Compile public compliance commitment options for potential Call Aleecia McDonald 2012-10-24 ISSUE-45
ACTION-325 (edit) pending review Help re-factor into appendices (with justin, jmayer?) Nick Doty 2012-10-24 ISSUE-175
ACTION-334 (edit) pending review Re-update on handling of sub-domains, clarify concrete options (issue-112, perhaps with Shane) Nick Doty 2012-11-14
ACTION-339 (edit) pending review Propose a refinement to debugging permitted use Walter van Holst 2012-11-21 ISSUE-24
ACTION-341 (edit) pending review Write up potential use cases for optional indication of service provider status, including points from Roy David Singer 2012-12-05
ACTION-345 (edit) pending review Condense non-norm examples on non-JS third parties and integrate into spec David Singer 2012-12-12
ACTION-348 (edit) pending review Ensure that the exception APIs do not preclude the UA from pending the set to get user approval David Singer 2013-01-16
ACTION-349 (edit) pending review Propose 'does my exception stand' APIs for both site and web exceptions David Singer 2013-01-16
ACTION-351 (edit) pending review Make updates to window/navigator version of doNotTrack (with Nick) David Singer 2013-01-16
ACTION-353 (edit) pending review Design the 'confirm exceptions' APIs David Singer 2013-01-16
ACTION-357 (edit) pending review Add service provider option text (with jmayer) as an issue in the draft with an option box David Singer 2013-02-20 ISSUE-137
ACTION-360 (edit) pending review Send email explaining why the proposal in ISSUE-152 is not needed and why issue 152 shall be closed Nick Doty 2013-02-06 ISSUE-152
ACTION-363 (edit) pending review Draft text for user agent flexibility on exceptions Nick Doty 2013-02-20
ACTION-364 (edit) pending review Draft section on best practices for sites requesting exceptions David Singer 2013-02-20
ACTION-366 (edit) pending review Draft text on another non-compliant/ignoring the expressed preference (by suggestion of WileyS) David Singer 2013-02-20
ACTION-414 (edit) pending review Propose new text regarding other software (perhaps building off of npdoty, dsinger) Alan Chapell 2013-06-12
ACTION-415 (edit) pending review Provide text proposal regarding limitations on using a Potential Consent signal Justin Brookman 2013-06-12
ACTION-422 (edit) pending review Introduce changes proposed by Nick David Singer 2013-06-26 ISSUE-168
ACTION-423 (edit) pending review integrate Alan's intermediary text David Singer 2013-06-26 ISSUE-153
ACTION-424 (edit) pending review Clarify UGEs and out of band consent David Singer 2013-06-26 ISSUE-201
ACTION-429 (edit) pending review Add wiki page regarding how-to, dashboard on our process for issues/change proposals Nick Doty 2013-09-25
ACTION-467 (edit) pending review Highlight where "tracking data" is used and proposed meaning in each place Roy Fielding 2015-04-01

Add a new action item. See all the action items

Chair, Staff Contact
Tracker: documentation, (configuration for this group), originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <>.
$Id: pendingreview.html,v 1.1 2019/02/01 09:32:25 vivien Exp $