F2f3

When & Where

• May 8-9 (Tuesday-Wednesday)

• Istituto per la Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche "Enrico Magenes" (IMATI), Colombo Hall, 11th floor, Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche (CNR) Via de Marini,6 (Torre di Francia), 16149 Genoa,Italy Map

Attendees

In person

1. Simon - both days
2. LarsG - Tuesday + Wednesday
3. DaveBrowning - both days (need to leave early Wednesday)
4. Karen - both days (also would like to leave by ~4:30 on Wednesday)
5. Peter - both days
6. Riccardo - both days
7. Andrea - both days
8. Jaroslav - both days
9. Dan - both days

Remotely

1. Makx - Tuesday until 11:00; Wednesday whole day
2. Antoine - at this stage I don't know but I'll try to be available for the profile discussion. Actually I may be able to come half-day live (my holidays are in Italy)
3. Rob? Tuesday till 10:30. Wed till about 2pm
4. Nick? (when?)
5. Tom Baker (DCMI) (Tuesday morning)

Not attending at all

1. ...

Disorganised List of Topics that may eventually get into the agenda

Just add to the list below anything you think needs to have space in the agenda

• Nic & Rob proposal for "profile description"
• Karen - Dublin Core approach to application profile
• Makx - EC approach to application profile (presentation)
• Lars - Profile document proposal
• Simon - finer grained semantics (DCAT)
• Simon - cataloguing services (DCAT)
• Jaroslav - Simon's topics, UC "real world context", UCR document status and update procedure
  • 2 new uses cases?

Agenda

Tuesday, May 8, 8-17 CEST (in your time zone)

Time	Topic	Links	Scribe (≥ 1)
8:00	Gather		LarsG
8:15-10:00	Part I
10 min	Review agenda and goals	we need to: have an understanding of what a profile is look at the requirements and yes/no each try to pin down these requirements sufficient to write a first draft
5 min	Review definition of "profile"	Draft document Discussion and options
20 min	DCAT-AP - Makx	PDF
20 min	Proposal - (Nick & Rob)	Draft wiki page github folder
10 min	Proposal - Lars	proposal	PWinstanley
?	Others?
10 min	DCMI AP - Karen	Framework Constraint vocabulary Guidelines
10 min	Proposal/Questions - Antoine	proposal
10:00-10:20	Break
10:20-12:30	Proposals		SimonCox
	Discussion		AndreaPerego
12:30-13:00	Lunch
13:00-15:30	Discussion: scope, plans		Jaroslav_Pullmann
15:30-15:50	Break
15:50-16:15	Miscellaneous		DaveBrowning
	New Use cases?
16:15-17:00	Begin requirements
	Already approved (?)	Profile negotiation [RPFN #74] Profiles listing [RPFL #73] Profile definition [RPFDF #72] Metadata guidance rules [RMDG #69
	To approve	All Profile representation [RPFRP #75]

Some questions

• What do we need so that content negotiation works with application profiles?
• Where should the profile information reside?
• What are the dependencies between deliverables 2 & 3?

Wednesday, May 9, 8-17 CEST (in your time zone)

Time	Topic	Links	Scribe (≥ 1)
8:00	Gather
8:15-10:00	Requirements to approve		SimonCox
	Relationships between profiles	Machine-readable specifications of application profiles need to be easily publishable, and optimize re-use of existing specifications (6.1) Each application profile needs to be documented, preferably by showing/reusing what is common across profiles (6.1) #207 A mechanism must be available to identify conformance to each inherited profile given conformance to a profile that specialises it (6.1) Profiles have URI identifiers that resolve to more detailed descriptions (6.1) #205
	Inheritance	Profiles may inherit clauses from one or more parent profiles (6.1) Profiles must support a view that includes all inherited constraints clearly identifying the parent profile the constraint is defined in (6.1)
10:00-10:20	Break
10:20-12:30	Requirements to approve		AndreaPerego
	Profile contents	Profiles must have properties for at least two levels of documentation: 1) short definition 2) input and editing guidance (6.1) Profiles extend or refine (UC 5.37) #216 Profiles list valid vocabulary terms for a metadata usage environment (UC 5.37) Profile vocabulary lists may be defined as closed (no other terms are allowed) or open (other terms are allowed) (UC 5.37) Profiles should reuse vocabulary terms defined elsewhere Profiles support data creation functions (UC 5.46)
	Conneg	Responses can conform to multiple, modular profiles (UC 5.3)
12:30-13:00	Lunch
13:00-15:30	Requirements to approve		PWinstanley
	Profiles and validation	Clarify any relationship between profiles and validation languages (6.1) #204 Application profiles need a rich expression for the validation of metadata (6.1) Profiles must support declaration of vocabulary constraints (6.1) Profiles describe conformance to metadata standards (6.1) Profiles should provide both machine and human readable views (6.1) Profiles must support discoverability via search engines (UC 5.40)
	Other github issues
		Definition of "Schema" (as opposed to profile) Definition of "Formalism" needed Profile Composition and Languages #162 DCAT - DDI alignment (profile) #164 Entailment of schema.org [RES ] use standard for profile identification ID37 Europeana profile ecosystem: representing, publishing and consuming application profiles of the Europeana Data Model (EDM)
15:30-15:50	Break
15:50-17:00	Plans and next steps	Who? When?

Monday Evening Meet-Up

Those wishing to meet for dinner on Monday night, prior to the DXWG F2F, are invited to come to the "Tiflis" restaurant (Vico del Fico, 35/r).

A reservation has been made for 7/8 people, at 7:30PM. The plan is to gather at 7:15PM in Piazza De Ferrari, close to The Doge's Palace Entrance (In Italian: Entrata di Palazzo Ducale), which is an easy place to find, and then move to the restaurant together.

If you plan to come, please drop a mail asap to Riccardo, so he can adjust the reservation accordingly.

Tuesday Evening Dinner

Dinner at the "La cabotina" restaurant (Vico della Loggia Spinola).

A reservation has been made for 8 people, at 8:15 PM. This restaurant serves a quite wide range of typical Genoese dishes, most of the dishes are suitable for vegetarians.

The plan is to gather at 8:00 PM in Piazza De Ferrari, close to The Doge's Palace Entrance (In Italian: Entrata di Palazzo Ducale), the same meeting point of Monday, and then move to the restaurant together.

Annotations

• F2F
• DXWG F2F3 Meeting @ Genoa
• 2018-05-08
• 2018-05-09
• https://www.w3.org/2018/05/08-dxwg-minutes
• https://www.w3.org/2018/05/09-dxwg-minutes
• Various