w3c/wbs-design or
by mail to sysreq.
W3C
Site Navigation
Nearby
Results of Questionnaire EOWG Tutorials Drafts for TPAC 2014
The results of this questionnaire are available to anybody. In addition, answers are sent to the following email addresses: shawn@w3.org,shadi@w3.org
This questionnaire was open from 2014-10-14 to 2014-10-23.
10 answers have been received.
Jump to results for question:
- Support for posting the Forms Tutorial
- Support for posting the Carousels Tutorial
- Support for posting the Menus Tutorial
- Support for posting the Page Structure Tutorial
1. Support for posting the Forms Tutorial
Draft Forms Tutorial
Please put below only comments that need to be addressed before posting the draft.
Please put other comments in Github or wiki page or EOWG e-mail or (typos, copyedits, etc. in editors list).
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | 8 |
| I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages only with the changes in the comments sections below | 1 |
| I do not support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages, because of the comments in the comments sections below | |
| I abstain (not vote) | 1 |
Details
| Responder | Support for posting the Forms Tutorial | |
|---|---|---|
| Anna Belle Leiserson | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Paul Schantz | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Andrew Arch | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Kevin White | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Eric Eggert | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | (Latest revision, of course :-) |
| Shawn Lawton Henry | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Sharron Rush | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages only with the changes in the comments sections below | As stated in the wiki, the lead sentence is too broad. Suggest something like "Forms are commonly used to provide user interaction on web sites and web applications." |
| Helle Bjarnø | I abstain (not vote) | |
| Vicki Menezes Miller | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Jonathan Metz | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are |
2. Support for posting the Carousels Tutorial
Draft Carousels Tutorial
Please put below only comments that need to be addressed before posting the draft.
Please put other comments in Github or wiki page or EOWG e-mail or (typos, copyedits, etc. in editors list).
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | 8 |
| I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages only with the changes in the comments sections below | |
| I do not support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages, because of the comments in the comments sections below | |
| I abstain (not vote) | 2 |
Details
| Responder | Support for posting the Carousels Tutorial | |
|---|---|---|
| Anna Belle Leiserson | I abstain (not vote) | I haven't had time to carefully review. Sorry. |
| Paul Schantz | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Andrew Arch | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Kevin White | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Eric Eggert | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Shawn Lawton Henry | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Sharron Rush | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Helle Bjarnø | I abstain (not vote) | |
| Vicki Menezes Miller | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Jonathan Metz | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are |
3. Support for posting the Menus Tutorial
Draft Menus Tutorial
Please put below only comments that need to be addressed before posting the draft.
Please put other comments in Github or wiki page or EOWG e-mail or (typos, copyedits, etc. in editors list).
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | 7 |
| I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages only with the changes in the comments sections below | |
| I do not support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages, because of the comments in the comments sections below | |
| I abstain (not vote) | 3 |
Details
| Responder | Support for posting the Menus Tutorial | |
|---|---|---|
| Anna Belle Leiserson | I abstain (not vote) | I haven't had time to carefully review. Sorry. |
| Paul Schantz | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Andrew Arch | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | Fly-out menus page - suggest adding a warning about automatically opening any fly-out/drop-down on keyboard focus (I've seen menus that require dozens of tabs to navigate due to automatically opening several levels) Tips and Tricks page - suggest adding some examples of icons that are commonly used, Also suggest adding a tip about testing (with a list of common keystrokes) |
| Kevin White | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Eric Eggert | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Shawn Lawton Henry | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Sharron Rush | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | Central concepts are good, but language is still quite rough. Needs extensive polishing and focus. |
| Helle Bjarnø | I abstain (not vote) | |
| Vicki Menezes Miller | I abstain (not vote) | Sorry, haven't had time to go through |
| Jonathan Metz | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are |
4. Support for posting the Page Structure Tutorial
Draft Page Structure Tutorial
Please put below only comments that need to be addressed before posting the draft.
Please put other comments in Github or wiki page or EOWG e-mail or (typos, copyedits, etc. in editors list).
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | 7 |
| I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages only with the changes in the comments sections below | |
| I do not support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages, because of the comments in the comments sections below | |
| I abstain (not vote) | 3 |
Details
| Responder | Support for posting the Page Structure Tutorial | |
|---|---|---|
| Anna Belle Leiserson | I abstain (not vote) | I haven't had time to carefully review. Sorry. |
| Paul Schantz | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Andrew Arch | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | Headings - enable keyboard navigation by section in some browsers (i.e. not exclusively for navigation by screen reader ATs) Content page - needs a section on tables to provide structure for data In-page / Skips links - still needed for visual keyboard (non-mouse) users to skip to main areas. As I understand, no main-stream browsers enable recognition of landmarks for keyboard users yet |
| Kevin White | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Eric Eggert | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Shawn Lawton Henry | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Sharron Rush | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are | |
| Helle Bjarnø | I abstain (not vote) | |
| Vicki Menezes Miller | I abstain (not vote) | Sorry, haven't had time yet to go through |
| Jonathan Metz | I support posting the Draft of these Tutorial pages as they are |
More details on responses
- Anna Belle Leiserson: last responded on 17, October 2014 at 01:28 (UTC)
- Paul Schantz: last responded on 17, October 2014 at 04:12 (UTC)
- Andrew Arch: last responded on 17, October 2014 at 12:25 (UTC)
- Kevin White: last responded on 21, October 2014 at 13:31 (UTC)
- Eric Eggert: last responded on 21, October 2014 at 15:37 (UTC)
- Shawn Lawton Henry: last responded on 22, October 2014 at 01:50 (UTC)
- Sharron Rush: last responded on 22, October 2014 at 03:36 (UTC)
- Helle Bjarnø: last responded on 22, October 2014 at 07:47 (UTC)
- Vicki Menezes Miller: last responded on 23, October 2014 at 13:10 (UTC)
- Jonathan Metz: last responded on 24, October 2014 at 03:30 (UTC)
Everybody has responded to this questionnaire.
Compact view of the results / list of email addresses of the responders
WBS home / Questionnaires / WG questionnaires / Answer this questionnaire
Report issues
on GitHub project