W3C

GRDDL Test Cases

W3C Working Draft 2 May 2007

This version:
http://www.w3.org/TR/2007/WD-grddl-tests-20070502/
Latest version:
http://www.w3.org/TR/grddl-tests/
Previous versions:
http://www.w3.org/TR/2007/WD-grddl-tests-20070328/
Editor:
Chimezie Ogbuji, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, <ogbujic@ccf.org>
Authors:
see Acknowledgments

Abstract

This document describes and includes test cases for software agents that extract RDF from XML source documents by following the set of mechanisms outlined in the Gleaning Resource Description from Dialects of Language [GRDDL] specification. They demonstrate the expected behavior of a GRDDL-aware agent by specifying one (or more) RDF graph serializations which are the GRDDL results associated with a single source document.

Status of This Document

This section describes the status of this document at the time of its publication. Other documents may supersede this document. A list of current W3C publications and the latest revision of this technical report can be found in the W3C technical reports index at http://www.w3.org/TR/.

This document reconciles tests from other documents in the repository (see Acknowledgements) as well as material from the editor's draft of the primer

This is a Last Call Working Draft of the GRDDL Test Cases. This document was developed by the GRDDL Working Group, which was chartered in July 2006 to review the specification and develop use cases, tutorial materials, and tests.

This May 2nd 2007 release of the GRDDL specification is a Last Call Working Draft by the W3C GRDDL Working Group (part of the Semantic Web Activity) for review by W3C Members and other interested parties. The Working Group seeks confirmation that these test adequately address all comments and that all these tests reflect and clarify all the issues in Gleaning Resource Descriptions from Dialects of Languages (GRDDL). Comments are due by 31 May 2007 to public-grddl-comments@w3.org, a mailing list with public archive). A log of changes is maintained for the convenience of editors and reviewers.

Please send comments about this document to public-grddl-comments@w3.org (with public archive). A log of changes is maintained for the convenience of editors and reviewers.

Publication as a Working Draft does not imply endorsement by the W3C Membership. This is a draft document and may be updated, replaced or obsoleted by other documents at any time. It is inappropriate to cite this document as other than work in progress.

This document was produced by a group operating under the 5 February 2004 W3C Patent Policy. W3C maintains a public list of any patent disclosures made in connection with the deliverables of the group; that page also includes instructions for disclosing a patent. An individual who has actual knowledge of a patent which the individual believes contains Essential Claim(s) must disclose the information in accordance with section 6 of the W3C Patent Policy.

Table of Contents

Introduction

A set of test cases is provided as part of the definition of [GRDDL]. This document presents those test cases. They are intended to provide examples for, and clarification of, the normative behavior of a GRDDL-aware agent. They should be used for testing the conformance of GRDDL-aware agents. The normative tests cover behavior expected of a GRDDL-aware agent.  The informative tests demonstrate other permitted behavior with respect to the issues resolved by the Working Group. This document itself has (as a GRDDL result) a manifest describing the test cases in RDF. For convenience, serializations of the GRDDL result are available as RDF/XML and Turtle.

Deliverables

The deliverables included as part of the test case collection are:

Note: the zip archive does not include tests which require network connectivity in order to properly calculate their GRDDL results.

Test Manifest Format

This test collection uses an RDF vocabulary for manifests developed for the RDF Test Cases Recommendation. A GRDDL-aware agent can extract the test collection and automatically test compliance by attempting to reproduce the expected GRDDL result(s) associated with each test case. Some input documents have multiple output documents, see below

Using the Test Driver

We provide testft.py, a test driver, written in Python and based on rdflib 2.3.3. Run it a la:

$ python testft.py --run your_grddl_impl testlist1.rdf >earl_out.rdf
All tests were passed!

It has options for --debug and such; invoke it with no arguments (or with --help) for details:

Options:
  -r, --run              path to a GRDDL implementation to use to process the 
                         source document (checking results)
  -u, --update           path to a GRDDL Implementation to use to process the 
                         source document
      --tester           The URI of an agent associated with the EARL test assertions.
                         A BNode is used if none is given                          
      --project          The URI of the EARL 'subject' (the implementation being tested).
                         A BNode is used if none is given
      --local            A boolean flag (false by default) which indicates whether to run only the local tests               

The tests do not require the use of this driver

EARL Reporting

In addition to writing various diagnostic messages to STDERR, the test harness writes additional RDF data to STDOUT: an [EARL] test assertion about each test it runs.

To tell it about the person running the tests and the software project being tested, point it to a tester (a URI in a [FOAF] RDF graph) and a test subject (a URI in a [DOAP] RDF graph).

Protocol Tracing

We find TCPWatch useful for debugging [HTTP] protocol interactions. If you start TCPWatch like so:

$ python tcpwatch.py -p 6543 &

then you can use it as a proxy:

$ http_proxy=http://127.0.0.1:6543 python testft.py
--run your_grddl_impl testharness.rdf

GRDDL Transform Library

A library of standard transforms is available for widespread use by authors

Local Policies, Faithful Rendition, and Conformance

The GRDDL specification states that any transformation identified by an author of a GRDDL source document will provide a Faithful Rendition of the information expressed in the source document. The specification also grants a GRDDL-aware agent the license to makes a determination of whether or not to apply a particular transformation guided by user interaction, a local security policy, or the agent's capabilities. However, in defining these tests it was assumed that the GRDDL-aware agent being tested is using a security policy which does not prevent it from applying transformations identified in each test. Such an agent should produce the GRDDL result associated with each normative test, except as specified immediately below.

Tests with Multiple GRDDL Results

multiple GRDDL results

Certain tests have multiple GRDDL results as a direct consequence of Faithful Infoset considerations, information resources with multiple representations, and seperate GRDDL mechanisms which produce distinct GRDDL results.

Tests of these kind can be considered as groups of N where N is the number of valid GRDDL results for the common input document.

Testing for Multiple Infosets

Testing GRDDL when XInclude processing is enabled and Testing GRDDL when XInclude processing is disabled are examples of tests which share the same source document, but have different XPath data models depending on whether any XInclude processing occurs. For such tests, a GRDDL-aware agent should output at least one of the GRDDL results associated with the single source document.

The tests manifest includes a symmetric property [OWL] (http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/grddl-test-vocabulary#alternative) asserted between them. A GRDDL-aware agent running the tests can take this into consideration.

Testing for Multiple Representations

Information resources can also have multiple representations in response to content negotiation. In addition to the GRDDL results associated with each representation a test for the maximal result is included: the GRDDL result which consists of the merge of all possible GRDDL results.

Note, however, that the maximal result is not isomorphic with the other results. To aid a test harness in determining compliance for scenarios such as these, the tests have a property (http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/grddl-test-vocabulary#subsumes) asserted from the test for the maximal result to the other tests in the group. A GRDDL-aware agent running the tests can take this into consideration.

Testing for Maximal Result

The remaining set of tests with multiple results are those where there is no ambiguity with the XPath data model associated with the source document, there is a single representation, and multiple GRDDL mechanisms apply. In the absence of a policy which prevents each GRDDL result from being computed, a GRDDL-aware agent should produce the maximal result.

Test Naming Convention

Every test has a URI of the form:

http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/grddl-tests#LOCALNAME

The test collection can either be run locally (see "Localized Tests") or over a network. Certain tests are marked as requiring a network connection with an open circle as their list item marker. These tests are asserted as members of the http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/grddl-test-vocabulary#NetworkedTest class in the test manifest. A GRDDL-aware agent running the tests can take this into consideration.

The tests which require a network connection use absolute URIs (in the test manifest) to refer to their test material (input and output) using the form:

http://www.w3.org/2001/sw/grddl-wg/td/LOCALNAME

Tests which do not require a network connection use relative URIs (in the test manifest) instead.

Normative Tests

Each test has an input document and an output document. the output document is an RDF/XML document and represents a GRDDL result of the input document.

Localized Tests

For the sake of convenience, this first set of normative tests cover simple scenarios where neither namespace documents nor absolute URIs are used. Such tests can run offline rather easily.

Namespace Documents and Absolute Locations

These tests include the use of namespace documents and absolute URIs and are more difficult to run offline.

Library Tests

The following tests are tests primarily of the library code.

Ambiguous Infosets, Representations, and Traversals

These tests help check for robustness of implementations in the face of various odd cases.

Primer Material

This section includes material from the [Primer].

Informative Tests

This section includes tests not covered explicitely by the normative text of the GRDDL but demonstrate additional behavior that a GRDDL-aware agent may exhibit. They reflect behavior suggested by the Working Group as a result of resolving certain issues.

Security Tests

The following security tests are provided for implementers to adapt and use for their implementation. Security issues are usually system specific, and it may be possible for a malicious party to access XSLT version and vendor information concerning a specific GRDDL agent instance.

We do not provide instructions as to how to test your system against these tests, since they are likely to be not directly applicable. Developers of GRDDL aware agents are encouraged to understand these tests, and consider how their own systems may have potential security weaknesses.

References

Normative

[GRDDL]
Gleaning Resource Descriptions from Dialects of Languages (GRDDL), Dan Connolly, 2007/03/02
[RDF Concepts]
RDF Concepts and Abstract Syntax, Graham Klyne and Jeremy J. Carroll, Editors, W3C Recommendation 10 February 2004. Latest version available at http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-concepts/ .
[RDF Syntax]
RDF/XML Syntax Specification (Revised). Dave Beckett, Editor, W3C Recommendation 10 February 2004. Latest version available at http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-syntax-grammar/ .

Informative

[TURTLE]
Turtle - Terse RDF Triple Language. Dave Beckett, Editor, 04 December 2006.
[PRIMER]
GRDDL Primer , I. Davis, Editor, W3C Working Draft (work in progress), 2 October 2006, http://www.w3.org/TR/2006/WD-grddl-primer-20061002/ . Latest version available at http://www.w3.org/TR/grddl-primer/ ..
[EARL]
Evaluation and Report Language (EARL) 1.0 Schema. Shadi Abou-Zahra and Charles McCathieNevile, Editors, W3C Working Draft 27 September 2006, http://www.w3.org/TR/EARL10-Schema/ .
[WEBARCH]
Architecture of the World Wide Web, Volume One , N. Walsh, I. Jacobs, Editors, W3C Recommendation, 15 December 2004. Latest version available at http://www.w3.org/TR/webarch/ .
[OWL]
OWL Web Ontology Language Reference , S. Bechhofer, F. van Harmelen, J. Hendler, I. Horrocks, D. L. McGuinness, P. F. Patel-Schneider, L. Andrea Stein, W3C Recommendation, 10 February 2004. Latest version available at http://www.w3.org/TR/owl-ref/ .
[RFC2616]
IETF RFC 2616: Hypertext Transfer Protocol - HTTP/1.1, J. Gettys, J. Mogul, H. Frystyk, L. Masinter, P. Leach, T. Berners-Lee, June 1999. Available at http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc2616.txt.
[FOAF]
FOAF Vocabulary Specification , Dan Brickley, Libby Miller, 27 July 2005.
[DOAP]
DOAP: Description of a Project , Edd Dumbill.

Acknowledgements

The editor thankfully acknowledges the contributions of the following Working Group members and personel:

The security tests were created during the development of the Jena GRDDL Reader which uses the Saxon8.8 XSLT processor. They hence illustrate how a malicious party may try to abuse features of such an implementation.

Change Log

Changes since the Working Groups decision to publish on 7 March:

  
$Log: Overview.html,v $
Revision 1.3  2007/05/03 16:59:38  jean-gui
fixing links

Revision 1.42  2007/05/03 16:47:55  cogbuji
fixed #changelog anchor

Revision 1.41  2007/05/03 16:40:34  cogbuji
fixed anchor links to GRDDL reference

Revision 1.40  2007/05/03 16:35:10  cogbuji
fixed more broken links

Revision 1.39  2007/05/03 14:49:25  cogbuji
fixed broken links

Revision 1.38  2007/04/30 15:56:16  cogbuji
changed per thread on #xmlbase3.  See: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-grddl-wg/2007Apr/0266.html

Revision 1.37  2007/04/30 15:42:38  cogbuji
removed  base-detail.  See: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-grddl-wg/2007Apr/0264.html

Revision 1.36  2007/04/28 05:24:57  cogbuji
removed bad css color

Revision 1.35  2007/04/28 04:57:03  cogbuji
fixed date

Revision 1.32  2007/04/28 04:43:26  cogbuji
fixed pubrules violations and merged conflicts

Revision 1.31  2007/04/27 22:36:20  hhalpin
updated status text, removed embeddedrdf-4 approval

Revision 1.30  2007/04/27 20:07:33  cogbuji
added text for xmlbase1-4

Revision 1.29  2007/04/27 19:12:44  cogbuji
fixed correct output for xmlbase2 and xmlbase4

Revision 1.28  2007/04/27 15:22:20  cogbuji
fixed output files for xmlbase1-4 tests

Revision 1.27  2007/04/27 15:01:34  cogbuji
- changed all test input/output to absolute URIs
- updated approval indications
- removed tests per WG decision (httpHeaders and primer-hotel-data)
- added base-detail

Revision 1.26  2007/04/25 14:20:41  cogbuji
well-formedness-fixes

Revision 1.25  2007/04/25 05:59:18  cogbuji
removed obsolete todos

Revision 1.24  2007/04/25 05:50:38  cogbuji
added ack for Dom..

Revision 1.23  2007/04/25 03:39:25  cogbuji
fixed CSS class for network test (requires .htaccess magic)

Revision 1.22  2007/04/25 02:48:29  cogbuji
fixed double ref-WEBARCH, removed incorrect approval citation, fixed test li id syntax, added networked tests

Revision 1.21  2007/04/23 16:57:46  cogbuji
- moved in fixed versions of missing tests
- removed use of 'will'

Revision 1.20  2007/04/23 16:23:34  cogbuji
- added text to tests (from john-l suggestions)
- synched in commentary from jeremy
- added missing tests
- moved in additional tests from the pending list
- updated approved tests

Revision 1.19  2007/04/16 20:03:31  cogbuji
- updated multiple output section to clarify the 3 kinds of multiple output scenarios
- removed background color for approved test links
- added approval links for tests approved during 4/11 teleconference
- Collapsed single infoset / representation multiple output tests into maximal result

Revision 1.18  2007/04/09 22:09:03  cogbuji
- added CSS hooks for maximal result tests
- added security tests section
- clarifications to multiple output section
- removed three-transforms

Revision 1.17  2007/04/08 05:23:37  cogbuji
- Minor editorial fixes
- added note about Primer editorial draft material
- moved library tests to normative section
- added primer material test section
- updated documentation for testft.py (--local option)
- fixed links to GRDDL spec LC draft
- shrunk multiple output diagram and floated left
- removed uneccessary 'should's
- fixed input link to loop instead of loop.xml (see result)
- added primer material section
- informative link to primer

Revision 1.16  2007/04/06 20:32:42  cogbuji
xhtmlWithGrddlEnabledProfile properly marked as a NetworkedTest (and movd appropriately)

Revision 1.15  2007/04/06 19:29:27  cogbuji
Fixed erroneous text about (and proper generation of) g:alternative and added further text using an explicit example to demonstrate multiple outputs and their effect on compliance.

Revision 1.14  2007/04/06 18:11:40  cogbuji
Fixes towards WG actions:

- migrated all remaining tests from testlist* and pendinglist
- added CSS styling for test approval and network tests
- moved hcarda (networked test)
- removed WD indications
- added text for naming conventions and use of NetworkedTest and alternative in test manifest

Revision 1.13  2007/04/05 04:42:48  cogbuji
Moved in most of remaining tests from repository.  Added editorial todos / notes.  Added clear indication that this is an editors draft.

Revision 1.12  2007/04/04 15:50:36  cogbuji
removed indication of WD (commented styling to that effect)

Revision 1.11  2007/03/27 23:28:43  cogbuji
fixed patent policy link

Revision 1.10  2007/03/24 19:25:06  cogbuji
more pubrules fixes: ids for references headings, fixed cascade of css

Revision 1.9  2007/03/24 05:48:34  cogbuji
removed recursive log directive

Revision 1.8  2007/03/24 05:45:47  cogbuji
fixed change log link and added retrospective change log entries

Revision 1.7  2007/03/24 05:42:42  cogbuji
fixed changelog entries

Revision 1.6 2007/03/24 05:09:36  cogbuji;
fixed broken links to manifest files

Revision 1.5 2007/03/24 04:59:19 cogbuji
added SOTD and fixed css for WD (per pubrules)


Revision 1.4 2007/03/24 04:39:30 cogbuji
various XHTML validity modifications, synched up with deprecated doc50/grddl-tests.html (which was subject of WG approval), and other pre-transtion pubrules checks

Valid XHTML 1.0 Strict