Meeting minutes
Agenda
Minutes
approved
PRs
McCool: cleaned up the Explainer
… also did editorial changes
… Editor's Note around Issue 86
… let's go through them in order
PR 345
McCool: (goes through the changes)
Farshid: (explains his comments)
Farshid: this is about the Explainer. right?
McCool: yes
… (adds edits based on Farshid's comments)
… pagination and incremental transfer
… is the change ok?
Farshid: ok
McCool: (applies the updates)
… any objections to merge this PR?
(none)
merged
PR 347
McCool: let's skip 346 and discuss 347
PR 347 - Get rid of dangling colon in Ontology
McCool: this is cleaning up the sentences
merged
PR 349
PR 349 - Not all directories are self-describing
McCool: not all directories are self-describing
… any objections?
(none)
merged
PR 350
PR 350 - Remove reference to issue 86
McCool: a bit longer
… add clarifications
… TM is normative but should not be considered as the sole reference to implement or interact with a Thing Description Directory.
Farshid: pagination itself is optional
McCool: the question is if we've modeled the spec features correctly
… can you look into that?
Farshid: ok, can look into it
McCool: want to merge this PR 350 itself
… also the original issue 86
… any objections to merge it?
(none)
merged
PR 351
McCool: Farshid pointed out something was missing
… so looked into old PRs
… then updated things
… someone needs to go through the changes to make sure
… Farshid, can you look into it?
Farshid: yeah
McCool: why don't you make suggestions?
PR 346
PR 346 - June 2022 Implementation Report Update
McCool: worked on my scripts and fixed bugs
… note that the CSS is not that smart
… some assertions have the same IDs
… updated my tools to use <div>s
… and <span>s
… note currently using <p> tags around <span> and <div>
… (goes through the changes)
… (shows rendered spec and Implementation Report for Discovery)
… all 0s within the report means no implementation yet
… would like to merge this PR
Kaz: merging this PR is ok
… but we need to fix the issue on overlapping IDs and span/div within <p>
… we need to fix them before publishing the next draft
… because we need to check the document using the Validator, etc., before publication :)
… so let's merge this PR and create another issue to fix the editorial issues
McCool: right
Farshid: how to deal with the exploration features?
McCool: currently, "service-http-***" and "service-coap-***"
… can change them to "exploration-server-http-***", etc.
… (added edits)
… template.csv lists all the assertions
… manual.csv to be installed under the test area
… we've not got volunteers for the todo.csv file
… would like to merge this PR
… and add further improvements later
… (shows wot-discovery/testing/manual.csv)
Farshid: what's the difference between null and fail?
McCool: null means no implementation yet
… fail means there is some implementation but it didn't pass
… please look into it
… and we can have discussion next week
… would merge this PR
(no objections)
merged
todo.csv
McCool: how to fix the remaining issues?
(=unimplemented features)
McCool: anybody working on "exploration-server-coap-alternate-content"?
Farshid: thought Jan was working on that
McCool: also Christian
… (adds Jan and Christian to coap-alternate-content, coap-method, coap-resp, coap-size2)
… http-alternate-content is easy
… (adds "manual, easy" to http-alternate-content and http-alternate-language)
… (also assigns McCool/Farshid to those features)
Farshid: Andrea also?
Andrea: yes, working on some more
… http-resp-content
McCool: tdd-http-error-response-utf-8 is easy
… (assigns McCool/Farshid)
… what about tdd-context-injection?
Andrea: myself and Farshid
McCool: (assigns tdd-context-injection to Andrea and Farshid)
… tdd-http-representation-alternate-output?
McCool: SPARQL does this
Andrea: I've implemented the feature natively without SPARQL
McCool: Farshid, could you look into some more?
… tdd-notification-data, data-create-full, data-diff-unsupporteed, data-td-id
… tdd-things-list-pagination-order-utf-8 by McCool
McCool: let's continue the discussion next week
[adjourned]