W3C

Site Navigation

Nearby

Results of Questionnaire EOWG – Accessible UI Components Last Call

The results of this questionnaire are available to anybody. In addition, answers are sent to the following email addresses: shawn@w3.org,shadi@w3.org,ee@w3.org

This questionnaire was open from 2016-04-22 to 2016-05-02.

9 answers have been received.

Jump to results for question:

Last Call Comments

1. Last Call Comments

summary | by responder | by choice

Accessible UI Components List

Note: If you put comments in GitHub, please put in the Comments box below a link to the GitHub issue or edit.

Summary

Choice	All responders
Choice	Results
I support using this UI.	2
I support using this UI; however, I suggest changes in GitHub or the comments section below (for editors’ discretion).	4
I support using this UI only with changes suggested in GitHub or the comment section below.
I do not support using this UI, because of the comments in GitHub or the comments section below.
I abstain (not vote).	2

(1 response didn't contain an answer to this question)

Skip to view by choice.

View by responder

Details

Responder	Last Call Comments	Comments
Denis Boudreau	I support using this UI; however, I suggest changes in GitHub or the comments section below (for editors’ discretion).	Provide a little more padding to the different elements, so it doesn't feel so compacted. Increase the difference in design between the tools descriptions and the metadata that comes with it (put the latter in a light graybox for example).
Sharron Rush	I abstain (not vote).	I would like the UI to be even more closely aligned to that of the Tools list, but also understand the need for conservation of development resource time.
Eric Eggert	I support using this UI.	[Editor]
Andrew Arch	I support using this UI; however, I suggest changes in GitHub or the comments section below (for editors’ discretion).	I would like to see a 'Filters' heading on the left-hand column (and see the 'clear filters' button closer to the filter options).
Laura Keen	I support using this UI.	Suggestion: move "clear filters" button to the left at the top of the filter options. Suggestion: move the "Add your Component" button. It could go at the top of the page just below the introductory paragraph. It gets lost beneath the options for navigating the existing components.
Brent Bakken		I do like the addition of the grey background for the additional information about the component. Added issue to GitHub but not sure it is relevant as the interface will be updated to match the tools list.
James Green	I abstain (not vote).
Howard Kramer	I support using this UI; however, I suggest changes in GitHub or the comments section below (for editors’ discretion).	Can we make the thumbnail clickable to the same url as listed in each record? I think visual feedback for the keyboard focus would be helpful. It's a little too subtle right now. Otherwise, looks nice.
Shadi Abou-Zahra	I support using this UI; however, I suggest changes in GitHub or the comments section below (for editors’ discretion).	I love this resource! Looks greaaaaaaat. My comments are in GitHub. Except for self-referencial link, everything else could wait for a next release. I strongly disagree with moving the clear filters to the left or to the filters nav bar! Rationale: #1. They are better closer to the status bar where the filtering information appears #2. It is more aligned with our other tools and resources, for consistency (they were tested)

View by choice

Choice	Responders
I support using this UI.	Eric Eggert Laura Keen
I support using this UI; however, I suggest changes in GitHub or the comments section below (for editors’ discretion).	Denis Boudreau Andrew Arch Howard Kramer Shadi Abou-Zahra
I support using this UI only with changes suggested in GitHub or the comment section below.
I do not support using this UI, because of the comments in GitHub or the comments section below.
I abstain (not vote).	Sharron Rush James Green