This lists the status of issues against the Compliance spec, as we move to resolving them all.
Issue | Title | Next step |
6 | What are the underlying concerns? | Action-101, currently awaiting additional text from Rigo for revisions to John's text. |
10 | What is a first party? | Jonathan Mayer and Tom Lowenthal proposed text; clarifications suggested from Bjoern Hoehrmann; concerns remaining to work through |
14 | ...relate to European law about data controller vs data processor? | Frank Wagner and Rob van Eijk; pending review |
22 | Still have "operational use" of data | Sid Stamm and Shane Wiley, proposed text: will not resolve for SPWD |
23 | Possible exemption for analytics | David Singer and Jonathan Mayer proposed text; grouped with issue-34. |
24 | Possible exemption for fraud detection | Elise Berkower and Peter Eckersley. Reminder with out-of-office reply; try again after 10 January |
25 | Possible exemption for research purposes | Kathy Joe and Alexandros Deliyannis; grouped with issue-74. Reminder with reply from Alex, out-of-office reply from Kathy. Try again after 5 January. |
28 | Exception for mandatory legal process | Elise Berkower, Bryan Sullivan. Reminder with out-of-office reply; try again after 10 January |
30 | Will Do Not Track apply to offline aggregating or selling of data? | Peter Eckersley and MeMe Rasmussen; discussed with both and will be shortly after Jan 10 |
31 | Minimization | Kevin Smith and Sue Glueck proposed text, touching upon issues 22 and 73 as well. |
32 | Minimization | Heather West and Vincent Toubiana. Reassigned from Brett Error; Heather to draft text in early January. |
34 | Possible exemption for aggregate analytics | Grouped with issue-23 |
35 | How will DNT interact with existing opt-out programs | Grouped as Issue-35, Issue-52, Issue-53, Issue-56, Issue-57, Issue-58. Kimon Zorbas and Sid Stamm; reminder sent |
36 | Should DNT opt-outs distinguish between behavioral targeting and other personalization? | JC Cannon and Joanne Furtsch proposed text |
39 | Tracking of geographic data (however it's determined, or used) | Shane Wiley and David Singer proposed the TPWG not address the issue; several responses followed |
52 | What if conflict between opt-out cookie and DNT? | Grouped as Issue-35, Issue-52, Issue-53, Issue-56, Issue-57, Issue-58; status with Issue-35 |
53 | How should opt-out cookie and DNT signal interact? | Grouped as Issue-35, Issue-52, Issue-53, Issue-56, Issue-57, Issue-58; status with Issue-35 |
54 | Can first party provide targeting based on registration information even while sending DNT | Adrian Bateman and Vikram Malaiya; awaiting Vikram's comments |
56 | What if DNT is unspecified and an opt-out cookie is present? | Grouped as Issue-35, Issue-52, Issue-53, Issue-56, Issue-57, Issue-58; status with Issue-35 |
57 | What if an opt-out cookie exists but an "opt back in" | Grouped as Issue-35, Issue-52, Issue-53, Issue-56, Issue-57, Issue-58; status with Issue-35 |
58 | What if DNT is explicitly set to 0 and an opt-out | Grouped as Issue-35, Issue-52, Issue-53, Issue-56, Issue-57, Issue-58; status with Issue-35 |
65 | How does logged in and logged out state work | Andy Zeigler and Thomas Lowenthal; Tom to review Andy's text |
74 | Are surveys out of scope? | Grouped with issue-25 |
92 | very limited retention, is that still tracking? | Haakon Bratsberg and Jonathan Mayer; Haakon finishing text by 6 Jan. |
Issue count:
Closed: 6 (not shown; see full list. By number: 3, 11, 18, 29, 37, 100)
Editors working on: 7 (not shown. By number: 19, 49, 72, 73, 91, 101, 104)
Open, with draft text: 9 (By number: 6, 10, 15, 22, 23/34, 31, 36, 39)
Open, awaiting text: 15 (By number: 14, 24, 25/74, 28, 32, 35/52/53/56/57/58, 54, 65, 92)
Not assigned for drafts in this pass: 24 (not shown. By number: 5, 7, 9, 12, 16, 20, 21, 33, 38, 41, 45, 59, 60, 66, 67, 75, 83, 93, 94, 97, 98, 99, 102, 103)