W3C

– DRAFT –
WoT-WG - TD-TF

26 April 2023

Attendees

Present
Daniel_Peintner, Ege_Korkan, Jan_Romann, Kaz_Ashimura, Luca_Barbato, Sebastian_Kaebisch
Regrets
-
Chair
Ege
Scribe
kaz

Meeting minutes

Organization

Sebastian: given less participation, let's review editorial issues on TD
… based on the previous decision, Ege can still moderate the call today

Minutes

Apr-12

Ege: (goes through the minutes)

approved

Next week

Ege: we need to discuss how to moderate the TD TF again

Kaz: will there be a TD call next Wednesday?

Sebastian: we confirmed we wouldn't have no TF calls except the Test call

Ege: ok
… what about May 9th?

Sebastian: not clear...

Ege: to be decided but can be cancelled due to the AC meeting
… then May 16?
… will decide on the TF moderator
… Ege still can prepare the agenda for May 16

TPAC 2023

TPAC WoT wiki

Ege: topics for TD is being identified

* JSON-LD Collaboration
** Canonicalization
** Restricting prefixes for JSON (no JSON-LD) parsers
* Linting: Maybe needs discussion with JSON-LD
* Showing planned activity

Ege: anything to be added?

(none at the moment)

Binding

PR 283

PR 283 - Subprotocol improvements

Ege: any comments/objections?

(none)

merged

PR 285

PR 285 - Some very minor editorial issues

Ege: any objections?

(none)

merged

PR 286

PR 286 - Fix Editorial issues and examples

Ege: (go through the preview)

Kaz: have you talked with Koster about this change?

Ege: not yet
… so can postpone this
… will ping Koster and Cristiano as the co-Editors

PR 288

PR 288 - Make XML Binding "planned"

Sebastian: the idea is removing the link?
… there is no work yet. right?
… would be better to have some draft idea there
… thought Taki and Daniel had been working on this topic for a while

Daniel: hasn't really used widely
… OK with either way, removing the link or saying work-in-place

Kaz: I'm also OK with either option
… but given the small participation today, we should talk about this next time

Publication

Ege: would like to talk about this next time

TD

Testfest feedback

wot-thing-description/testing/atrisk.csv

Ege: (shows the latest atrisk.csv)

Sebastian: a bit surprised to see versioning still there

Ege: this CSV file is not completely updated...

Kaz: when can it be updated then?
… maybe after the Testfest tomorrow?

Ege: yeah
… can see the latest status today too

PR 1803

PR 1803 - Capitalize assertive keywords on assertive table

Ege: (shows the diff)

Kaz: we should use the RFC2119 style, shouldn't we?

Ege: the CSS Styling doesn't work within tables, it seems

Kaz: is that the case?

<em class="rfc2119" title="SHOULD">SHOULD</em>

Ege: think ReSpec will automatically add the CSS styling

Kaz: anyway
… let's create an issue to handle this strange situation that some of the capitalized "SHOULD", etc., have "rfc2119" styling explicitly, and some don't.

Jan: I think the relevant part of the ReSpec documentation can be found here: https://respec.org/docs/#conformance-section

PR 1801

PR 1801 - Add producer to terminology|

merged

PR 1800

PR 1800 - Mention apikey creation is only for object and arrays

Kaz: don't see it as controversial, but would be better to get wider review than today
… since this is more than typo fix

Ege: ok

PR 1799

PR 1799 - Adapt op mapping ed note

Ege: changing "ednote" style to "note" style

merged

PR 1796

PR 1796 - fix title for fadeOut action

merged

PR 1790

PR 1790 - Editorial fixes for issue 1735

Kaz: some of the changes are just removing "-" from "Thing-level"
… but some of the changes are kind of long and require some more reviews

Ege: ok

PR 1802

PR 1802 - Fix html checker errors

Kaz: this is fixing the problem pointed out by the HTML Validator. right?

Ege: right

Kaz: we need to apply these cleaning up to the draft before the Proposed REC publicaton

Jan: seems there is some removal of text there...

Kaz: why didn't you simply used HTML Tidy for this purpose?

Kaz: would suggest we keep this open, and check the HTML with the result of Tidy as well
… I can help you for that purpose
… the PR has conflicts as well

Ege: note that some problem with the TTL files as well
… which requires us manual edit

Issue 1798

Issue 1798 - 2019 urls in the context file

Sebastian: we made a decision to use the 2019 location
… when we work on WoT 2.0, we can revisit the discussion on the policy around how to deal with the namespaces

Kaz: this is also bigger than editorial typo fix
… so should have further discussion next time

Sebastian: already generated an Issue around this

[adjourned]

Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 210 (Wed Jan 11 19:21:32 2023 UTC).