Meeting minutes
Minutes
clarification of previous approval added
and approved
Implementation Reports
McCool: have updated the Implementation Reports for TD, Architecture and Discovery
<McCool_> TD 1.1
<McCool_> https://
<McCool_> Discovery Architecture 1.1
McCool: copied the template HTML from the ones for the previous RECs
… need to capture the testimonials too
… but wondering about the need
… features are same as assertions
… my hope is having some blanket descriptions for testimonials
Kaz: having a separate testimonial document would be fine
… but we still need to describe who provided the results within the IR
McCool: having a separate testimonial document would be nice
… OK with having the self-contained style, though
Lagally: please show the section 5 again
… if we look at the columns, can we tell why we have fails?
Ege: check for TD is stricter
McCool: maybe the testing tool doesn't work properly...
Lagally: it would make sense to look into the CSV again
… the above CSV shows which features implemented by which implementations
McCool: let's mention the potential issues
… probably issues with manual assertions
… useful to look into the rows of this consolidated CSV
… having no TDs would cause the "XXXX" field here
Kaz: I think it would be better for us to check the rows with 0 results
… we can share the load by 7 people here
McCool: yeah, agree
Lagally: also wondering about the divergence
McCool: sometimes the number of the total field doesn't match the sum because some of the fields are minimum
… also for the manual assertions, we still many 0 results
… so Lagally's consolidated CSV should be useful for further check
Kaz: would suggest we quickly skim the test results based on the consolidated CSV
… not during this call, but should do that quickly
McCool: can we do that next week?
Lagally: yeah
… let's adjust the agenda for that
Next Testfest Logistics
McCool: (creates the work area)
McCool: (also copies the README.md from the one for the previous Testfest)
Lagally: (explains his expectation for the next Testfest/Plugfest)
Kaz: we should concentrate on Testing for WoT Profiles this time in December
… also we're getting out of time or today, so I'd suggest we continue the discussion next week
… and people are encouraged to create Issues and PRs for proposals
McCool: yeah
… I'll merge this README.md as the starting point for that purpose
template README.md as a starting point
[adjourned]