W3C

– DRAFT –
WoT Discovery

22 August 2022

Attendees

Present
Kaz_Ashimura, Kunihiko_Toumura, Michael_McCool, Tomoaki_Mizushima
Regrets
-
Chair
McCool
Scribe
kaz

Meeting minutes

agenda

McCool: heads-up on possible switch to Zoom due to trouble with my PC...
… we need to use Zoom for TPAC, etc., anyway
… will discuss this during the main call

Minutes

Aug-8

McCool: let's discuss cancellation again later during this call
… let's talk about the next Charter topic as well later
… OK with the minutes.

(approved)

Logistics

McCool: let's look into the schedule
… (refers to the main wiki)
… cancellations, pre-TPAC meeting, ...

pre-TPAC meeting

McCool: we have to decide whether we'll have a Discovery meeting or not
… need to consider the 2-week review period before CR transition
… Aug-29 to make resolution for review
… so let's un-cancel the meeting on Aug-29

Cancellations section on the WoT main wiki

McCool: is that OK?

Farshid: yes

McCool: tentatively, we'll have the Discovery call on Sep 5 only if we can't finalize CR Candidate on Aug 29
… stick to WebEx for a while to avoid confusion
… any other logistics things?

(none)

McCool: note that I'll take some vacation in October
… so some cancellations at that time

TAG review

McCool: think most of the points have been resolved

design-reviews issue 733 - Web of Things (WoT) Discovery

McCool: we're basically done

design-reviews issue 736 - Web of Things (WoT) Architecture 1.1

McCool: don't see anything explicit about Discovery here
… TAG review is now addressed
… everything is closed

IANA review

<McCool_> Registration of Well-known URI, Service Name and CoRE Resource Type

McCool: not done yet
… going to edit this issue
… URI suffix to be "wot" instead of "wot-thing-description"
… wondering about the timing

Kaz: pre-CR is ideal but pre-PR is OK
… technically, IANA registration is a separate procedure than the REC transition itself
… we can consult with PLH and Ralph during the transition call or on the transition GitHub issue

McCool: consensus
… no changes expected
… add Editors Note to document that there are in progress
… wondering about who to be put as the contact person
… myself as the Chair or maybe Toumura-san as one of the Editors

Kaz: if you want, you can put my name as the contact too

Farshid: if nobody implements CoRE RD, it's at-risk

McCool: right
… but that's different from the procedure itself
… will do this immediately
… will put Kaz's name as the contact

Next Charter deliverables

Issues labeled as "defer to Discovery 2.0"

McCool: (goes through the issues marked as "defer to Discovery 2.0")

Issue 234

Issue 234 - JSONPath as a search query language

McCool: (add comments)

comments

Other issues

Issue 382

Issue 382 - How should non-URN ids be encoded in /things/{id} URLs and Location headers?

McCool: Farshid has agreed to draft a PR

Issue 390

Issue 390 - Use date-time (RFC 3339) instead of XML dateTime

McCool: (adds "defer to Discovery 2.0" label)

Issue 388

Issue 388 - Change tm:required to tm:optional in TM

McCool: do you want to do this, Farshid?

Farshid: yes

McCool: (assigns the issue to Farshid)

Issue 387

Issue 387 - JSONPath queries filtering on semantic annotations

McCool: (gives comments)
… JSON Path implementations are not consistent because there is no standard yet

comments

Issue 386

Issue 386 - Tweak DDoS assertion about 3x rule

McCool: (adds "Resolve by CR" label)

Issue 385

Issue 385 - Adjust Policy-Like Assertions

Kaz: based on the same strategy as the one for Architecture. right?

McCool: yes
… (adds "Propose Closing" label)

Issue 384

Issue 384 - tm:required --> tm:optional

McCool: duplicate
… see issue 388
… Farshid will resolve it

Issue 388 - Change tm:required to tm:optional in TM

[adjourned]

Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 192 (Tue Jun 28 16:55:30 2022 UTC).