Meeting minutes
Regrets
McCool: Lagally or Toumura-san can't make the Testfest this week unfortunately
… so should concentrate on TD and Discovery
Minutes
McCool: let's review the minutes next week
Logistics
McCool: have updated the logistics page
… should add the CSV template as well
… (add minor edits to remove extra parts)
… anything to be added?
(none)
PRs
PR 369
PR 369 - Add July discovery files
McCool: Farshid made this PR
… let's merge this
(merged)
PR 366
PR 366 - Create manual.csv snapshots for 2022.07 Testfest
McCool: updated manual.csv
(merged)
PR 366
Ege: (explains the changes)
… added security things
… "td-arrays_scopes", etc., are removed
McCool: not for manual tests but for the automatic test?
Ege: yeah, or even not needed to be checked
McCool: should clarify what it means
… if you could fix your tool to read the manual.csv first and then process the automatic results, would be nice
Ege: good point
… will look into it
… manual.csv is more important. right?
McCool: should discuss that
Ege: could have that discussion to see the expected behavior
McCool: would be better if the tool could identify that
Kaz: kind of confused
… this PR includes two portions
… one for the template for the manul.csv
… and actual example CSV for Ditto
Ege: yeah
Kaz: in that case, we should have split the PR into two pieces
… one for the template, and another for the actual results
McCool: would merge this PR itself
Kaz: merging this PR itself is fine
… but for the next time, we should have two separate PRs
… one for the template and another for the results
… and also we should describe why "td-arrays_scopes", etc., could be removed, i.e., could be tested by the automatic tests within the logistics page
McCool: will add notes on that
Daniel: implementers can/should provide their results based on the new template. right?
McCool: yes
… currently, we have snapshot version of the manual.csv files
snapshot version of the manual.csv files at 2022.07.Online
McCool: Architecture_manual.csv, etc.
Ege: complicated...
ek updated template for TD available
Kaz: in that case, we should update the "TD_manual.csv"?
McCool: (adds comments about that)
… related to the PR
(closed without being merged)
PR 362
PR 362 - Update TinyIoT Thing Directory reports
McCool: updating the old results at this moment is confusing
… so would leave this open
Kaz: if it's still working, can we include it into the results of this Testfest
McCool: would get clarification from Farshid
(not merged)
PR 367
PR 367 - Added TM examples showing tm:optional usage in scope of Ditto/TMs
McCool: let's merge this
(merged)
McCool: data/input_2022/TD/batchValidation.sh has been updated
PR 349
PR 349 - Add TMs and manual.csv for sdf-wot-converter
McCool: Philipp is not here...
… but let's merge this to get maximum coverage
… however, need to change the location to data/input_2022
… will merge this PR right after the change
… (put comments)
… (add another Note)
… some more fixes can be also added
PR 368
PR 368 - add additional Eclipse Ditto generated TDs with security scheme oauth2
(merged)
PR 370
Ege: just updated
(merged)
Issues
Issue 358
McCool: can close this?
Cristiano: yes
(closed)
Issue 329
Issue 329 - Clarify Expectations for Implementers
McCool: close this after Fady's review
Issue 327
Issue 327 - Missing TD Features
Ege: can close this
(closed)
Issue 321
Issue 321 - [TD] Missing manual.csv contributions
McCool: old one?
Ege: but still need to check
McCool: let's keetp this then
Kaz: in that case, we should update the title
McCool: ok
Ege: still need feedback from Fady, etc.
McCool: let's look into the current status
Ege: ECLASS is already there
McCool: flask-tum not yet
… ECLASS done
… Fujitsu not yet
… Hitachi done
… manual TM by TUM not yet
… WebThings not yet
… Logilab done
McCool: missing results from some more group participants
… let me rerun the tool to update the results again
… should create another issue to see if those results need updated
Kaz: separate issue for each implementer?
McCool: could generate a checklist including all the results
… Ege, can you work on that?
Ege: need people's input. right?
… let's wait
McCool: ok
Other old issues
McCool: (checks 2022_03 and 2022_06)
… (and then 2021)
… (Plugfest Followup)
AOB?
Kaz: would suggest we quickly skim the updated README.md so that we can ask all the implementers to provide updated results based on the document
McCool: (quickly skims it)
… if anything missing, please let me know
Ege: corner cases from my side
Cristiano: will provide my results
McCool: new directory?
Cristiano: yeah, completely new one from scratch
… discovery capability for node-wot as well
… as part of the Scripting API
McCool: anybody else?
Daniel: wondering how much compatible node-wot can be with the WoT Profile spec
McCool: if we have automatic test for Profile, we should do that
… good way to get the test
… but maybe we should focus on the manual test this time given Lagally is not around
Sebastian: action query within Profile, etc.
… have never seen implementations for it
… maybe we should postpone the test for Profile
McCool: yeah, I hear you
… pragmatic thing we can do is simply deferring the test for Profile
<Zakim> Ege, you wanted to discuss aob part
Ege: wondering about the potential dependency...
McCool: we didn't get review for Architecture or Security
… need to figure out how to deal with that
[adjourned]