Meeting minutes
<addison> trackbot, prepare teleconference
Agenda Review
Action Items
<addison> https://
action-1017?
<trackbot> action-1017: Addison Phillips to Send wpwg list of specs that implement lang/dir -- due 2021-04-22 -- OPEN
addison: I sent email
action-1109?
<trackbot> action-1109: Addison Phillips to Remind shepherds to tend to their awaiting comment resolutions -- due 2022-01-27 -- OPEN
addison: Please, go through your comments!
action-1127?
<trackbot> action-1127: Addison Phillips to Check thread on urls for language tags -- due 2022-03-17 -- OPEN
addison: We may want to talk to Unicode.
action-1129?
<trackbot> action-1129: Addison Phillips to Review httpapi-linkset for concerns -- due 2022-03-24 -- OPEN
addison: still pending
action-1131?
<trackbot> action-1131: Richard Ishida to Follow up on personalization-semantics #144 with commentary discussed in telecon -- due 2022-03-24 -- OPEN
r12a: Did that.
addison: Any kind of followup?
xfq: They said this was their last CR blocker, so they want a quick response.
<addison> close action-1131
<trackbot> Closed action-1131.
r12a: They haven't replied to us yet.
Info Share
r12a: I published something about pronouncing Ukrainian names.
RADAR Review
<addison> https://
addison: We got a request to review WebGPU. Who wants to review it?
… They did a checklist. So they probably want an i18n request.
r12a: It's actually two documents.
atsushi: First published last May, but the WD and the ED should be the same.
xfq: I can review it.
addison: About Secure Payment Confirmation: I have comments, but only about language metadata. What to do? Wait for the TAG's opinion on that matter?
ACTION: addison: contact ian about spc comments vs. tag conversation
<trackbot> Created ACTION-1132 - Contact ian about spc comments vs. tag conversation [on Addison Phillips - due 2022-04-07].
r12a: Ask Ian if they can wait longer?
Specdev text regarding identifiers
<addison> https://
<addison> https://
addison: We discussed last time. I made updates. Moved the mustard higher up. Ready to merge?
… Anybody needs more time to look at it?
<atsushi> +1 (read offline)
xfq: I looked and it looks good.
addison: So publish?
ACTION: addison: merge specdev pull 61 and publish
<trackbot> Created ACTION-1133 - Merge specdev pull 61 and publish [on Addison Phillips - due 2022-04-07].
r12a: Yes
… We had a problem before with the GitHub create checkbox, class name. Your merge will not overwrite that?
addison: No, I merged previously.
r12a: Might want to test it anyway.
Canvas formatted text
<xfq> https://
xfq: We discussed this before and Addison commented. Currently it is a tracker issue. Do we want to chnage that? Also, I saw there were suggestions about terminology, what were they?
addison: Mostly about Unicode jargon: grapheme cluster, code point, etc.
ACTION: addison: create PR against canvas formatted text
<trackbot> Created ACTION-1134 - Create pr against canvas formatted text [on Addison Phillips - due 2022-04-07].
Make autospace a property, rather than a value of text-spacing
<addison> https://
<addison> https://
r12a: Wondering if people have an opinion.
<xfq> https://
<xfq> https://
xfq: What r12a says in the issue makes sense.
<xfq> ^ compare these two drafts
r12a: People get dazzled. I think there are multiple things going on, spacing marks, auto-spacing... CSS kind of lumped them together.
xfq: And there is also justification.
<r12a> https://
r12a: I tried to describe how it works here ^^
… And it was easier to explain when split.
<xfq> https://
addison: Tag this as "needs-resolution"?
xfq: There some 700 possible combinations of values for text-spacing.
xfq: In #6950
<xfq> https://
xfq: I agree it should be "needs-resolution".
addison: Any objections?
ACTION: RI to add to issue https://
<trackbot> Created ACTION-1135 - Add to issue https://
addison: r12a, can you do that?
CSS Text pending issues
<addison> https://
r12a: A lang value would allow breaking at word boundaries in Japanese. In Thai, people would like to be able to turn it off.
… In some SE Asian scripts, you'd need to recognize syllables instead.
… The proposed property 'word-boudary-detection' for CSS has a language as value.
… I think that is weird. You already know the language.
… Fantasai said it was intended to specify for *which* language it was turned on, not to select a language to use the rules from.
… Could have a list of several languages.
+1
<addison> https://
RESOLUTION: make 1472 into a comment.
r12a: A word boundary should be invisible to justification.
Two SVG issues
RESOLUTION: 1473 also accepted as comment.
ACTION: RI send css-text issues with needs-resolution label
<trackbot> Created ACTION-1136 - Send css-text issues with needs-resolution label [on Richard Ishida - due 2022-04-07].
<addison> https://
<addison> https://
<xfq> https://
<atsushi> +1
xfq: We said they should mention Grapheme Cluster. They said they already linked to CSS. Are we OK with that?
addison: Looks good to me.
<xfq> https://
xfq: I will reply and close the issue.
xfq: They changed to match language tags case-insensitively. They don't say ASCII-case-insensitive, but language tags are normally ASCII. Good enough?
addison: Looks good to me.
<atsushi> +1 either w/ or w/o
<r12a> https://
atsushi: Should we ask to change line 1654 in ^^ ?
r12a: Seems fine as is.
Response to TAG
xfq: I will reply and close the issue.
<addison> https://
addison: I could probably do some code example, as requested in a comment.
indexed-db issue
xfq: I have an Indexed DB issue
… About unique key
… I see r12a is satisfied with their resolution. Are we satisfied?
addison: It is not an i18n issue.
r12a: And the tag I added was just to sync the repos. OK to close it.
RESOLUTION: close issue 360
AOB?
Adjourned.