F2F5 Agenda

See F2F5 and minutes Day 1 and Day 2

Day 1

• 09:00 - 09:15 Welcome, local arrangements, introductions
• 09:15 - 10:45 Admin (scribe: pfps)
  • Roll Call
  • Agenda amendments?
    • LC Comments 62 and 63??
  • Roadmap and schedule review
• 10:45 - 11:15 Coffee
• 11:15 - 13:00 LC Comments: Presentation (scribe: Mike Smith)
  • Introduction/Roadmap
    • Document introduction 10
    • Editorial-Guide to documents desired 42
    • Roadmap needed 49
  • Naming
    • inconsistent use of OWL/DL/Full 28
    • Naming issues 52b
    • Inconsistent use of OWL/DL/Full + more triple syntax needed 48
    • documents should show triple-serialisation - Response Drafted 29
• 13:00 - 14:00 Lunch
• 14:00 - 15:45 LC Comments: Datatypes (scribe: Michael Schneider)
  • OWL/RIF
    • non-disjointness of numeric datatypes 24
    • OWL/RIF datatypes 22
    • OWL/RIF datatypes 25
  • OWL RL
    • Supported RL datatypes 20
    • OWL RL Datatypes 43b
  • Other
    • named datatypes - Response drafted 51
    • datatype properties should be functional - Response sent 51
    • wants nary datatype predicates 46
• 15:45 - 16:15 Coffee
• 16:15 - 18:00 LC Comments: Profiles (scribe: Markus Krötzsch)
  • OWL RL
    • RL semantics 61
    • RL Theorem PR1 - Response drafted 15
  • OWL QL
    • Extending QL 18
    • Extending QL + complexity (editorial) 19
    • QL sameAs 59
  • General
    • IRI names for profiles (as annotations) - Response sent 31
• 18:30 - 19:15 Drinks/Dinner

Day 2

• 09:00 - 10:45 LC Comments: Technical (scribe: Jie Bao)
  • TQ 34b
  • Imports
    • definition(s) of imports closure - Response drafted, under debate 53
    • Imports by location 7 Draft response TR1
  • Axioms
    • axiom hiding 39
    • axiom naming via canonical annotation 41
  • Other
    • object to new treatment of anonymous individuals - Response drafted 30
    • strong typing 58
    • redesign XML syntax 40
    • keys should be 1:1 (i.e., multiple key values not allowed) 47
    • automated testing + OWLlink interface - Response drafted 45
    • extended annotations to support sanctioning 23
    • GRDDL 17, 10
• 10:45 - 11:15 Coffee
• 11:15 - 11:45 LC Comments: Editorial & Philosophical (scribe: Boris Motik)
  • Philosophical
    • OWL diverging from RDF 56 Response drafted
    • disruption of SW stack 54 Response already sent
    • Hostility to XML 29 Two Responses Drafted
    • Cost of OWL2 is too high 34a
    • doubts about need for OWL2 27
    • Industry not interested; hard to use; hard to select profiles 26a Response already sent
    • Supporting 26a 37 Response already sent
  • Editorial
    • 8 Facet space
    • 9 Examples for global restrictions
    • 14 Entailment question Response drafted
    • 16 Lexical form/value Response drafted
    • 21 Various
    • 26b Editorial comments + general praise?! Response already sent
    • 32 Documentation of OWL2-RL Response drafted
    • 33 SSFSS Editorial comments
    • 44 Structures, elements of the structural specification, and equivalence
    • 50 Sameness and Namedness Raiser ACK - OK
    • 52a RDF Semantics editorials 'Not LC comment
    • 55 octets vs. characters Raiser ACK - OK
    • 38 syntax editorial Response drafted
    • 43a Editorial comments from Oracle One Response already sent, Other drafted
    • 60 Syntactic conformance
    • 51 Racer editorial Response drafted
• 13:00 - 14:00 Lunch
• 14:00 - 15:45 Remaining Issues & Other Documents (scribe: ???)
  • Issues
    • Issue 56 Repairs
    • Issue 97 GRDDL
    • Issue 146 Labels
  • Documents
    • RDF-Based Semantics
    • Quick Reference Guide
    • New Features and Rationale
    • Manchester Syntax
    • rdf:text: A Datatype for Internationalized Text
    • Primer
• 15:45 - 16:15 Coffee
• 16:15 - 18:00 Test Cases and Discussion (scribe: Zhe Wu)
  • Test Cases
    • Problems (if any)
    • Progress on tool support, e.g., for "species validation"
    • Other issues?
  • Recap and further discussion of choices we need to make, actions, and schedule
  • AOB