See also: IRC log
1. Regarding the prioritised list of requirements it was agreed that appraisal should be shifted to the number one priority group while regulation should be kept within the less important group due to its complexity though two votes for shifting it existed. Further it was agreed to keep one "blank", that is general, Global Metadata in the first part as all Global Metadata were found in the second.
2. No progress was possible on the XML-RDF-OWL discussion, because all three volunteers were absent. Also no volunteer was found for comparing the possibilities for including RDF or OWL with existing XML markup languages.
Marc: everybody clear on history of list of
requirements? (explains...)
... should first and second priority items be shifted among groups or
kept?
... Appraisals might be shifted to core description.
Dylan: agrees that appraisals should be shifted.
<eva> yet
Eva: asks for reconsideration within 1 week.
Marc: let's give everybody 1 week for reconsideration.
Bjoern: would like to safe regulation.
Marc: reminds that this ranking is only helping
us but not mandatory.
... considers No. 11 as difficult to accomplish example (semantics of links
to the rest of the world)
Enrico: let's have a borderline group (e.g. appraisal, regulation)
Bjoern: Catherine stresses need of regulation.
Marc: if we do not have anybody vote against
appraisal: include it.
... would not include regulation due to added complexity.
... there is a good reason to include regulation but for the moment we will
keep it in the second group.
Bjoern: agrees to keep regulation less prioritized.
Christian: Global Metadata is all in group two.
Marc: let's have one "blank" Global Metadata in the first part of the list.
Christian: agrees.
<marc> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/emotion/
<marc> http://www.w3.org/2005/Incubator/emotion/charter-20071129#deliverables
<scribe> ACTION: Dylan to send around updated requirement list - due 2008-03-06 [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/02/28-emotion-minutes.html#action02]
<trackbot-ng> Created ACTION-15 - send around updated requirement list [on Dylan Evans - due 2008-03-06].
<scribe> ACTION: Felix to organize revised requirements documents and ensure W3C conformity - due 2008-03-15 [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/02/28-emotion-minutes.html#action03]
<trackbot-ng> Created ACTION-16 - organize revised requirements documents and ensure W3C conformity [on Felix Burkhardt - due 2008-03-15].
Marc: we will shift this item due to absence of the experts on this.
Christian: favours XML in order not to force people to learn new MLs.
Marc: the question how easily these could be
combined should be answered.
... we will have to leave it open due to lack of volunteers on this one.
agrees...
<enrico> ok for me
<mrseo> yeah
Marc: suggests to leave next meeting open and
decide upon progress wrt syntax.
... suggests to clarify details by email.
<mrseo> ok, thank tou
<mrseo> bye