Notes on Agenda for
11 June 2011 W3C TAG F2F

Note: the (X) markings near some items are the chair's private tracking marks...other readers can ignore them. Thank you.

Top Priorities

More details on these are provided in the sections below.

• Establish 2-3 committed 2011 deliverables for the TAG, with success criteria and schedules (Need session)
• (X) Client-side state: we will try to move the finding toward publication, but note dependency on the RDFa and #! discussions.
• Align product pages and assignments with actual TAG deliverables and priorities
• Additional technical priorities to be propsed between now and the F2F

Required Reading

Note: this list is incomplete...expect more required reading to be announced.

Available today:

• (X) W3C Privacy Workshop Report
• (X) HTML/XML Task Force Report - 22 March 2011 Editor's Draft
• (X) Jonathan announces the Information Resources and Web Metadata: Editor's Draft 17 May 2011, first of two readings relating to ISSUE-57; also relates to ISSUE-63, and ACTION-282
• (X) Jonathan announces further ISSUE-57 reading in a temporary location for now.
• Web Security Framework: Problem Statement and Requirements (http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-hodges-websec-framework-reqs-00)
• TAG Product Pages (chair is hoping to prepare more in time for the F2F)
• (X) Copyright and deep linking:
  • Jeni provides Publishing and Linking on the Web: Draft TAG Finding 28 May 2011
  • On 26 May call, Jeni asks for a session focusing especially on early parts of the draft

Expected soon:

• (X) Jonathan hopes to have reading on persistent references by Monday 30 May

Not sure whether these are coming or not:

• NOT DOING AT F2F per 26 May 2011 telcon: ACTION-531: on - Larry Masinter - Draft document on architectural good practice relating to registries - Due: 2011-05-27 - OPEN

Administration and future meetings

• (X) Summer schedule
• (X) Fall F2F: Edinburgh or London? Confirm date.
• (X) Future meetings

General Topics

• The TAG needs to commit 2 or 3 goals to W3M and Jeff Jaffe. We need to provide success criteria, delivery dates, etc. We'll have a F2F session to agree on what the commitment should be.
• (X) Jim Gettys will join us for lunch on Monday, 6 June to discuss Buffer Bloat
• (X) IAB call on the 8th
  • ACTION-549: on - Larry Masinter - (with help from Henry and Yves) make proposals for topics to be pursued with IAB - Due: 2011-05-12 - OPEN
• (X) Copyright and deep linking:
  • ACTION-541: on - Jeni Tennison - Helped by DKA to produce a first draft of terminology about (deep-)linking etc. - Due: 2011-05-24 - OPEN
  • Jeni provides Publishing and Linking on the Web: Draft TAG Finding 28 May 2011
• (X) Privacy
  • Ashok offers on 26 May to lead F2F review of privacy workshop and do not track
  • ACTION-550: on - Daniel Appelquist - With help from Noah to plan TAG work on privacy, leading to session at F2F, next step is contact with TLR - Due: 2011-05-12 - OPEN
  • W3C Privacy Workshop Report
  • Larry Masinter requests F2F discussion of privacy and Do Not Track (per email from Ashok)
  • ACTION-460: on - Daniel Appelquist - Coordinate with IAB regarding next steps on privacy policy - Due: 2011-05-24 - OPEN
• On May 26, Henry requests "1/2 slot" on 3023bis and IRIbis"

(X) HTML & HTML/XML Unification

• HTML5 Last Call
  • public-iri mailing list discussion of IRI handling and RFC 3987 in HTML5 (heads up email from Noah)
• ACTION-548 : review the report http://www.w3.org/2010/html-xml/snapshot/report.html
• Noah has sent a query to Norm as to his availability.
• Noah took action to find out if anything is new

Web Applications

• (X) Significant push on client-side state, including decision on whether to make it a Rec or a finding
  • ACTION-481: on - Ashok Malhotra - Update client-side state document with help from Raman - Due: 2011-05-10 - OPEN
• (X) Client-side storage
  • Slides from Ashok (announcement email)
• API Minimization
  • (X) ACTION-514: on - Daniel Appelquist - Draft finding on API minimization - Due: 2011-05-17 - OPEN Will hav a draft on the 3rd
• Packaged Web Apps
  • ACTION-544: on - Daniel Appelquist - Propose TAG input, if any, to possible workshop on packaged Web apps - Due: 2011-05-31 - OPEN
  • Per discussion on 26 May: 20 mins session of it fits
• Security

  Agreed on 26 May that as chair, Noah decides whether to have a F2F session on security

  Noah sent e-mail to Larry Masinter and John Kemp on 24 May 2011 asking what progress will be made in time for the F2F.

  • ACTION-515: on - Larry Masinter - (as trackbot proxy for John) who will publish http://www.w3.org/2001/tag/2011/02/security-web.html, slightly cleaned up, with help from Noah and Larry - Due: 2011-04-12 - OPEN
  • ACTION-516: on - Noah Mendelsohn - Talk with Thomas Roessler about organizing W3C architecture work on security - Due: 2011-05-17 - PENDING REVIEW
  • ACTION-554: on - Noah Mendelsohn - Formulate product page for TAG work on security including John Kemp security draft Due: 2011-05-24 - Due: 2011-05-31 - OPEN

(X) Metadata and HTTP semantics

• Jonathan announces the Information Resources and Web Metadata: Editor's Draft 17 May 2011, first of two readings relating to ISSUE-57; also relates to ISSUE-63, and ACTION-282

Core mechanisms of the Web

• (X)Fragment IDs, including #! and RDFa issues
  • ACTION-553: on - Jeni Tennison - With Jonathan to prepare F2F discussion of fragids including #!, RDFa, 3023bis, etc. Due 2011-05-24 - Due: 2011-05-19 - OPEN
  • Email from Jeni proposing agenda
• (X) Persistence of references
  • Jonathan reports he has made progress since last time, and requests a F2F slot.
• Kemp security draft: there's an action to Larry as proxy for John to move it forward -- should check on that also, from masinter on 3/30 http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-hodges-websec-framework-reqs-00 -- might be a useful document for TAG to review, or even to invite Jeff Hodges to come present to TAG? In fact, some of the terminology here needs better terminology than webarch supplies.

Not scheduled for the F2F

The chair proposes not to schedule discussion of the following at the F2F

• ISSUE-27: modifying URIs, e.g. punycoding, in RDFa (see e-mail from Jonathan). Also, note that ISSUE-27 is PENDING REVIEW.
• E-mail from Jonathan on ISSUE-27
• Registries? On May 5, Larry says he will do this for the F2F, per ACTION-531: on - Larry Masinter - Draft document on architectural good practice relating to registries - Due: 2011-05-27 - OPEN Suggest we get PLH to join us
• MIME and the Web:
  • ACTION-543: on - Jeni Tennison - Propose addition to MIME/Web draft to discuss sem-web use of fragids not grounded in media type - Due: 2011-06-15 - OPEN
  • The chair's notes and the due date suggest that Jeni has asked to defer ACTION-543 until after the F2F. Accordingly, MIME & the Web will not be scheduled for the F2F.
• Interaction
  • ACTION-537: on - Daniel Appelquist - Reach out to Web apps chair to solicit help on framing architecture (incluing terminology, good practice) relating to interaction - Due: 2011-05-31 - OPEN
  • Per discussion of 26 May, we are not doing this at the June F2F
• Maybe: ACTION-510: on - Tim Berners-Lee - Write a note conveying the TAG's concerns re: the microdata -> RDF URI mappings in the HTML5 microdata draft Due: 2011-01-20 - Due: 2011-04-26 - OPEN (See email from Tim on 20 May 2011)