ISSUE-2: Assertion Protocol-2020 missing RFC 2119 language

Protocol-2020 is spurious

Assertion Protocol-2020 missing RFC 2119 language

State:
CLOSED
Product:
SOAP-JMS Binding specification
Raised by:
Eric Johnson
Opened on:
2009-07-27
Description:
Description:
------------
We have this bullet point under the "soapAction" property: "if using SOAP 1.2, and the contentType property has an action parameter, that parameter value MUST match this SOAPJMS_soapAction value.† [Definition: Use fault subcode mismatchedSoapAction if the SOAP 1.2 action does not match.†] "

Protocol-2019 captures the first sentence, and Protocol-2020 covers the [Definition:]. Notice that the definition doesn't have any RFC 2119 language.

Justification:
--------------
It is impossible to test Protocol-2020 without also testing 2019. Further, Protocol-2020 does not contain any RFC 2119 language. Yet it is clearly subsidiary to Protocol-2019, and the absence of this language leaves it unclear as to what MUST be done. Combining the two statements will clarify the possible confusion.

Proposal:
---------

Change the paragraph that reads:

"if using SOAP 1.2, and the contentType property has an action parameter, that parameter value MUST match this SOAPJMS_soapAction value.† [Definition: Use fault subcode mismatchedSoapAction if the SOAP 1.2 action does not match.†] "

to this:

"if using SOAP 1.2, and the contentType property has an action parameter, that parameter value is checked for a match with the SOAPJMS_soapAction value. A fault MUST be generated with [Definition: subcode mismatchedSoapAction if the SOAP 1.2 action does not match the SOAPJMS_soapAction value.]†"
Related Actions Items:
No related actions
Related emails:
  1. Agenda for the 2009-08-18 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-08-17)
  2. Minutes 2009/08/11 (from M8PHILLI@uk.ibm.com on 2009-08-11)
  3. RE: Agenda for 2009-08-11 conference call (from peaston@progress.com on 2009-08-11)
  4. Agenda for 2009-08-11 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-08-10)
  5. Re: ISSUE-2: update available (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-08-10)
  6. ISSUE-2: update available (from phil_adams@us.ibm.com on 2009-08-10)
  7. Re: Agenda for 2009-08-04 conference call (from M8PHILLI@uk.ibm.com on 2009-08-04)
  8. Re: Agenda for 2009-08-04 conference call (from ylafon@w3.org on 2009-08-04)
  9. Agenda for 2009-08-04 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-08-03)
  10. Action item 95 complete (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-07-29)
  11. RE: Agenda for 2009-07-28 conference call (from peaston@progress.com on 2009-07-28)
  12. Agenda for 2009-07-28 conference call (from eric@tibco.com on 2009-07-27)
  13. ISSUE-2 (Protocol-2020 is spurious): Assertion Protocol-2020 missing RFC 2119 language [SOAP-JMS Binding specification] (from sysbot+tracker@w3.org on 2009-07-27)

Related notes:

Proposed and accepted change to proposal, from conference call of 2009-08-04:
"if using SOAP 1.2, and the contentType property has an action parameter, that parameter value is compared with the SOAPJMS_soapAction value. A fault MUST be generated with [Definition: subcode mismatchedSoapAction if the SOAP 1.2 action does not match the SOAPJMS_soapAction value.]†"

Eric Johnson, 4 Aug 2009, 16:37:16

Accepted resolution text as per http://www.w3.org/2009/08/18-soap-jms-minutes.html

Eric Johnson, 24 Aug 2009, 19:18:05

Completing issue record:
Opened: http://www.w3.org/2009/08/04-soap-jms-minutes.html
Resolved with changes: http://www.w3.org/2009/08/04-soap-jms-minutes.html

XML diff:
http://dev.w3.org/cvsweb/2008/ws/soapjms/soapjms.xml.diff?r1=1.54&r2=1.55&f=h

HTML diff:
http://dev.w3.org/cvsweb/2008/ws/soapjms/soapjms.html.diff?r1=1.53&r2=1.54&f=h

Eric Johnson, 6 Oct 2010, 01:54:07

Follow-up XML diff
http://dev.w3.org/cvsweb/2008/ws/soapjms/soapjms.xml.diff?r1=1.59&r2=1.60&f=h

Eric Johnson, 6 Oct 2010, 01:56:47

Display change log ATOM feed


Chair, Staff Contact
Tracker: documentation, (configuration for this group), originally developed by Dean Jackson, is developed and maintained by the Systems Team <w3t-sys@w3.org>.
$Id: 2.html,v 1.1 2013-09-16 14:06:34 carine Exp $