w3c/wbs-design or
by mail to sysreq.
W3C
Site Navigation
Nearby
Results of Questionnaire Position Paper Review Form: the W3C Workshop on Rich Multimodal Application Development
The results of this questionnaire are available to anybody. In addition, answers are sent to the following email address: team-mmi-ws-chairs@w3.org
This questionnaire was open from 2013-06-29 to 2013-07-15.
12 answers have been received.
Jump to results for question:
- António Teixeira - DETI/IEETA
- Sean M. Prell - Johnson and Wales University
- Masaki Umejima - JSCA and Keio University
- Morio Hirahara - ECHONET Consortium
- Louay Bassbouss - Fraunhofer FOKUS
- Deborah Dahl - Conversational Technologies
- Craig Campbell - iSpeech, Inc
- Holger Banski - Bosch
- IA Institute
- Ryosuke Aoki - NTT
- Brian Dooner - iVVi Media
- Sheau Ng - NBCUniversal
- Yoshiaki Ohsumi - Panasonic
- Kazuyuki Ashimura - W3C - Paper 1
- Kazuyuki Ashimura - W3C - Paper 2
- Wei-Yun Yau - Institute for Infocomm Research
- Yoshiaki Kozaki - NTT Advanced Technology Corporation
- General comments
1. António Teixeira - DETI/IEETA
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 1 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 11 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
Details
| Responder | António Teixeira - DETI/IEETA | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as participant) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as speaker) | The paper mentions an apparently advanced implementation of the MMI Architecture based on HTTP and Apache SCXML, I would be interested in learning more. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | Very interesting project. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as speaker) | Demo of the Apache SCXML based IM for Assisted Applications seems interesting and germane. |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as speaker) | Looks promising for presentation. Working on using MMI architecture for assistive apps |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | This is a very interesting use case for the MMI Architecture (ambient and assisted living). It would fit in as a short presentation in the demo session. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | System implementation based on MMI Architecture |
| James Barnett | Yes (as speaker) | This is the one proposal that seems to have used the MMI Arch. Maybe he should get a chance to present separately. |
2. Sean M. Prell - Johnson and Wales University
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 3 |
| Yes (as speaker) | |
| No | 7 |
| It depends (please leave a comment) | 2 |
Details
| Responder | Sean M. Prell - Johnson and Wales University | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | No | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | I'm not sure about the paper, which seems to be totally off-topic. However, I don't see any harm in having the author participate in the workshop since everyone's invited, and it may be an interesting discussion. |
| Dong-Young Lee | No | I don't see anything related to MMI in the paper. Maybe he submitted a wrong paper? |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as participant) | Wasn't clear how MMI would be part of this talk. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as participant) | This didn't seem that closely related. |
| Michael Johnston | No | Completely off topic. Not clear why this position paper is submitted here. |
| Balwinder Kaur | No | The paper does not explain what the connection between MMI and electronic recycling is |
| Daniel Burnett | No | I can't figure out what this has to do with the workshop. |
| Sheau Ng | It depends (please leave a comment) | Not clear how the paper relates to the theme of this workshop, namely Rich, and Multimodal aspects. |
| Deborah Dahl | No | This paper doesn't have anything to do with the conference |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | No | not related to MMI at all... |
| James Barnett | It depends (please leave a comment) | This submission has nothing to do with multimodality. I guess there's no harm in his attending, but would he be interested? |
3. Masaki Umejima - JSCA and Keio University
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 8 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 4 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
Details
| Responder | Masaki Umejima - JSCA and Keio University | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as participant) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | The paper doesn't mention multimodal interaction explicitly, but the smart home use case is highly relevant, and the relationship between ECHONET Lite and the MMI Architecture needs to be studied. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | MMI-related aspects of their work is not very obvious in their position paper, but I think it would be interesting to discuss HEMS and ECHONET Lite from an MMI perspective. *** Need to ask him to place focus on MMI. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as participant) | Wasn't clear how MMI would be part of this talk. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as participant) | |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as participant) | Not clear that content is a good fit presentation with this group? But certainly look good as participant. |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as participant) | |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as participant) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | How about a panel on ECHONET in the "Day 1, pm 2" session, with this and the following paper? |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | smart power meter and ECHONET standard |
| James Barnett | Yes (as participant) | Good source of use cases |
4. Morio Hirahara - ECHONET Consortium
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 6 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 6 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
Details
| Responder | Morio Hirahara - ECHONET Consortium | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as participant) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as speaker) | Another mention of ECHONET Lite and bridging the Web and home devices, this seems like something that should definitely be discussed in context of the MMI Architecture. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | Great topic. ECHONET introduction and discussion in the context of MMI would be interesting. *** Need to ask him to place focus on MMI. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as participant) | Wasn't clear how MMI would be part of this talk. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as participant) | |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as participant) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as participant) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | How about a panel on ECHONET in the "Day 1, PM 2" session, with this and the preceding paper? |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | smart house and ECHONET standard |
| James Barnett | Yes (as participant) | Good source of use cases. |
5. Louay Bassbouss - Fraunhofer FOKUS
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 1 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 11 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
Details
| Responder | Louay Bassbouss - Fraunhofer FOKUS | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as participant) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as speaker) | I'm very interested in Famium's network discovery and advertising module, looks like a lot of useful information for MMI Discovery. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | I've seen Famium before and it was impressive. MMI aspects of Famium would be interesting. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as speaker) | Lots of MMI goodness. |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as speaker) | Very Relevant Paper. |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | this could be presented in the Day 2, AM 1 session on new directions. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | MMI and multi-screen for future IPTV |
| James Barnett | Yes (as speaker) | Good source of use case and has already considered discovery. Could we give them a role in the discussion of discovery? |
6. Deborah Dahl - Conversational Technologies
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | |
| Yes (as speaker) | 12 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
Details
| Responder | Deborah Dahl - Conversational Technologies | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as speaker) | I'm particularly interested in the HTML/JS Interaction Manager implementation |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | A demo is always valuable. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as speaker) | Demo sounds interesting. |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as speaker) | Yes. If possible this should be recorded and put on YouTube. |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | Well, this is my paper, so of course I want to present it. This could go in the "overview of existing" standards session (AM 2), or as a demo. The application is a natural language sentiment analysis service, but it's interesting because it uses EMMA, the MMI Architecture, and EmotionML, and you can see the XML events. It's running at http://nlportal.elasticbeanstalk.com if you want to try it (Firefox, Chrome, and Safari only) |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | MMI demo featuring EmotionML and EMMA |
| James Barnett | Yes (as speaker) |
7. Craig Campbell - iSpeech, Inc
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 2 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 9 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) | 1 |
Details
| Responder | Craig Campbell - iSpeech, Inc | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | The paper sounds like a marketing pitch, but the author mentions a large developer network and best practices on multimodal user interface design, both of which seem like very good discussion topics for the workshop. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | Their presentation would provide a real-world usage example of MMI. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as speaker) | Seems like some provocative information and good material for talkz. |
| Michael Johnston | It depends (please leave a comment) | Recommend inviting for demo? Slide deck really looks like a sales pitch, not clear that that will work well for formal presentation in this setting. |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | Looks like a proprietary speech interface, but could go in the PM 2 session. This would be useful for learning about how the MMI Architecture could handle their use cases. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | demo of proprietary MMI implementation - for the panel session |
| James Barnett | Yes (as participant) | This seems like a pitch for a proprietary product, but would be a source of use cases. |
8. Holger Banski - Bosch
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 4 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 6 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) | 2 |
Details
| Responder | Holger Banski - Bosch | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as speaker) | I'm quite surprised by the high level of adoption of Web standards by car makers mentioned in the paper, think that this is a killer use case for the MMI Architecture, and am highly interested in learning more about what Bosch is doing. |
| Dong-Young Lee | It depends (please leave a comment) | Automotive web is a hot topic, and MMI should be part of it as he says. It would be great if he could share his experiences, ideas, and views. *** Need to check with him whether he is willing to give a presentation. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as speaker) | Not sure if he's suggesting a talk or not, his abstract wasn't clear to me but given his background and research it would be great to have him do a presentation. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as participant) | |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as participant) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as participant) | The position paper seems to suggest that the candidate is more interested in participating than presenting. |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | I'm really curious as to what a "head unit" is. |
| Sheau Ng | It depends (please leave a comment) | Needs to clarify how this is different than a special, albeit relatively new, application development environment. The multi modality seems to be confined to this new environment alone. |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | A good candidate for the Day 1, PM 2 session. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | integration of HTML5 and MMI Architectur for in-car systems |
| James Barnett | Yes (as participant) | seems quite interested in getting an overview and providing use cases. |
9. IA Institute
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 6 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 6 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
Details
| Responder | IA Institute | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as participant) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | The paper seems to focus on semantic networks rather than multimodal interaction, but this can be valuable for our work on modality component capability description, and the workshop might also give the authors some inspiration on the user interface aspects of their system. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | A very interesting project related to multimodal UI as well as semantic web. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as participant) | Wasn't clear how MMI would be part of this talk. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as speaker) | I think the IAI perspective on semantic capturing would make for an interesting talk. |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as participant) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as participant) | |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as participant) | Not sure what this has to do with MMI other than the apparent UI aspect. |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | This is definitely an important element to be explored: new design for a new kind of web content that not only goes to different platform, but perhaps those different platforms come together at the users' ends as well. |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | I'm not sure if this is completely relevant to our workshop, but perhaps a short presentation on their use cases in Day 1, PM 2. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | possible backyard Web service for MMI mashup |
| James Barnett | Yes (as speaker) | There may be some use cases here, but I'm not sure of the relevance. |
10. Ryosuke Aoki - NTT
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 3 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 8 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) | 1 |
Details
| Responder | Ryosuke Aoki - NTT | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | It depends (please leave a comment) | Can you give more details about how your work is related to the MMI architecture? |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | Interesting use case, and one where a multimodal user interface could be highly useful (but isn't used at the moment, judging by the paper). |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | Their paper addresses a real technical problem. It would be very interesting to hear their experiences and details of their solution. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as participant) | |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | Would like to see the discussion expands from client-side-only to possibly on server side to assist/guide the trimming process. |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | They could present their use case in Day 1, PM 2 |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | multimodal editor by integration of HTML and MMI |
| James Barnett | Yes (as participant) | good source of use cases |
11. Brian Dooner - iVVi Media
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 6 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 5 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) | 1 |
Details
| Responder | Brian Dooner - iVVi Media | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as participant) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | More a note than a position paper, but concise and to the point. Use cases for multimodal interaction with ebooks are always interesting. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | Their presentation of real use cases (multimodal ebook) would be very valuable. |
| Adam Abramski | It depends (please leave a comment) | No discussion about MMI and the use cases they would like to discuss unfortunately. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as participant) | |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as participant) | Invite to give demo? |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as speaker) | Although the content of the position paper was very limited, the requirements for eBooks is very interesting |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as participant) | Perhaps an interesting paper would be to expand upon audio (e)book into multimodal (e)book. |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | This is my customer, who is working on interactive, multimedia ebooks. They could present their use case in Day 1, PM 2. Maybe we should have a "lightening use case" session for a bunch of quick use case presentations. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | multimodal eBook implemenataion - demo panel? |
| James Barnett | Yes (as participant) | good source of use cases |
12. Sheau Ng - NBCUniversal
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 4 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 4 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) | 4 |
Details
| Responder | Sheau Ng - NBCUniversal | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | It depends (please leave a comment) | Can you give more details about how your work is or can be related to the MMI architecture? |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | The paper seems like an abstract for something else --- it ends with "In this paper, we present a particular technology..." and leaves it at that. Seems highly on-topic nevertheless, and it would make sense to discuss said technology at the workshop. |
| Dong-Young Lee | It depends (please leave a comment) | The position paper seems to be an abstract of a longer paper, which would fit the workshop topics. *** Need to check with him whether he is willing to give a presentation. |
| Adam Abramski | It depends (please leave a comment) | Not sure this was a paper to do a talk about MMI and Smart TV's or just a position paper to be asked to attend the workshop. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as speaker) | Sounds like some interesting things about smart tv. I wonder how much of the user interaction goes over the TV, and how much goes over an indirect channel (I.e., twitter from a second screen experience). |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as participant) | Abstract is quite vague on what will be presented. |
| Balwinder Kaur | It depends (please leave a comment) | It would have been nice to have some diagrams or synopsis of the "particular technology" that they plan to present on. |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as participant) | Position paper doesn't really talk about UI at all, but if it did I would recommend them as a speaker as well. |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | The co-author of this paper will present. |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | candidate for "lightening use case" session. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | integration of multiple video sources for SmartTV - demo? |
| James Barnett | Yes (as participant) | source of use cases |
13. Yoshiaki Ohsumi - Panasonic
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 10 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 2 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
Details
| Responder | Yoshiaki Ohsumi - Panasonic | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as participant) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | Panasonic's interest in multimodal applications and their impact on customer satisfaction clearly stated. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as participant) | He mentioned that he doesn't need presentation. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as participant) | Position paper states they would just like to attend and not present anything. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as participant) | |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as participant) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as participant) | |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | They say they do not need to present, but I think it would be fine if they wanted to. |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as participant) | |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | candidate for "lightening use case" session. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as participant) | interested in integration HTML5 and MMI for SmartTV, Smart home and advanced health care services |
| James Barnett | Yes (as participant) | use cases |
14. Kazuyuki Ashimura - W3C - Paper 1
Position paper
Attached files:
-
mmi-over-websocket.pdf
-
interop-ver2.pdf
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | |
| Yes (as speaker) | 12 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
Details
| Responder | Kazuyuki Ashimura - W3C - Paper 1 | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as speaker) | I'm very interested in how the WebSocket implementation turned out. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | MMI over WebSocket is a very interesting idea, and must be presented and discussed. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as speaker) | I'm very interested in Kaz's paper. We've implemented and deployed something very similar (only we used SCXML controller in CCXML as IM) and our event scheme didn't exactly match the MMI architecture - but we were programming all three parts (visual, controller, web). If we were only programming one, and interfacing with other companies, we'd have had more need for MMI events. |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | Candidate for session on new directions |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | new direction for MMI |
| James Barnett | Yes (as speaker) |
15. Kazuyuki Ashimura - W3C - Paper 2
Position paper
Attached file:
speech-juke-box.pdf
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | 3 |
| Yes (as speaker) | 8 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) | 1 |
Details
| Responder | Kazuyuki Ashimura - W3C - Paper 2 | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | Yes (as participant) | |
| Piotr Wiechno | Yes (as participant) | As an amateur bedroom music studio owner, I would argue that modern PC OSes can handle precise timing quite satisfactorily, but the idea of handling speech rhythm nuances in dialog interfaces is interesting anyway. |
| Dong-Young Lee | Yes (as speaker) | If the use case could be further developed (e.g., more detail), it could be presented separately; otherwise it could be presented together with the above. |
| Adam Abramski | Yes (as speaker) | Not sure if this is a presentation more about the real time OS or actual MMI. |
| Michael Bodell | Yes (as participant) | |
| Michael Johnston | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Balwinder Kaur | It depends (please leave a comment) | This seems like a good topic for an open discussion. If this is what the aim of the paper is then it would need to be done as an oral presentation. |
| Daniel Burnett | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | This is a crucial, fundamental, function that needs to be studied and hopefully incorporated into W3C work. It will go beyond human speech, and into web content that can delivers vastly different and improved capabilities. |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | Candidate for session on new directions |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | new direction for MMI |
| James Barnett | Yes (as speaker) |
16. Wei-Yun Yau - Institute for Infocomm Research
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | |
| Yes (as speaker) | 4 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
(8 responses didn't contain an answer to this question)
Details
| Responder | Wei-Yun Yau - Institute for Infocomm Research | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | ||
| Piotr Wiechno | ||
| Dong-Young Lee | ||
| Adam Abramski | ||
| Michael Bodell | ||
| Michael Johnston | ||
| Balwinder Kaur | ||
| Daniel Burnett | ||
| Sheau Ng | Yes (as speaker) | Paper introduces user behavioral modeling into MMI framework and should promote discussion on the aspect of user recommendation in W3C work. It will benefit web content that can delivers vastly different and improved capabilities. |
| Deborah Dahl | Yes (as speaker) | |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | integration of TV with MMI |
| James Barnett | Yes (as speaker) |
17. Yoshiaki Kozaki - NTT Advanced Technology Corporation
Summary
| Choice | All responders |
|---|---|
| Results | |
| Yes (as participant) | |
| Yes (as speaker) | 2 |
| No | |
| It depends (please leave a comment) |
(10 responses didn't contain an answer to this question)
Details
| Responder | Yoshiaki Kozaki - NTT Advanced Technology Corporation | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | ||
| Piotr Wiechno | ||
| Dong-Young Lee | ||
| Adam Abramski | ||
| Michael Bodell | ||
| Michael Johnston | ||
| Balwinder Kaur | ||
| Daniel Burnett | ||
| Sheau Ng | ||
| Deborah Dahl | ||
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | Yes (as speaker) | Good candidate for the panel on use cases |
| James Barnett | Yes (as speaker) |
18. General comments
If you have any comments or suggestions on the program or organization of the workshop, please describe them in the comment field.
Details
| Responder | General comments |
|---|---|
| B Helena RODRIGUEZ | |
| Piotr Wiechno | |
| Dong-Young Lee | |
| Adam Abramski | |
| Michael Bodell | Looks like a great workshop. Has any thought been given to simulcasting it to the web (similar to a tech plenary, or google io, or a ustream thread like several ignite conferences do [http://www.ustream.tv/new]). Not sure if there is a w3c approved tech to use, or if the workshop is confidential, but might be worth considering (especially for a multimodal conference). |
| Michael Johnston | |
| Balwinder Kaur | There was a lot of variation in the proposals submitted. It would be nice to have a bit more uniformity in the abstracts' format. |
| Daniel Burnett | |
| Sheau Ng | |
| Deborah Dahl | Let's try to emphasize use cases, so to that end, how about if we make the PM 2 session on Day 1 a "lightening panel" where people quickly review their applications? I think it would be best to focus on use cases rather than solutions. Papers 8-14 could fit into a session like that. |
| Kazuyuki Ashimura | As usual we should start with use case discussion and then talk about possible mechanism/framework. We should not jump in possible system implementations before clarifying those points. # at least during the workshop :) |
| James Barnett |
More details on responses
- B Helena RODRIGUEZ: last responded on 1, July 2013 at 07:59 (UTC)
- Piotr Wiechno: last responded on 1, July 2013 at 09:11 (UTC)
- Dong-Young Lee: last responded on 1, July 2013 at 12:11 (UTC)
- Adam Abramski: last responded on 1, July 2013 at 14:07 (UTC)
- Michael Bodell: last responded on 1, July 2013 at 19:08 (UTC)
- Michael Johnston: last responded on 1, July 2013 at 21:35 (UTC)
- Balwinder Kaur: last responded on 1, July 2013 at 22:29 (UTC)
- Daniel Burnett: last responded on 1, July 2013 at 23:22 (UTC)
- Sheau Ng: last responded on 3, July 2013 at 06:16 (UTC)
- Deborah Dahl: last responded on 3, July 2013 at 12:37 (UTC)
- Kazuyuki Ashimura: last responded on 11, July 2013 at 20:03 (UTC)
- James Barnett: last responded on 11, July 2013 at 20:08 (UTC)
Compact view of the results / list of email addresses of the responders
WBS home / Questionnaires / WG questionnaires / Answer this questionnaire
Report issues
on GitHub project