IMSC1.0.1 Comments tracker

From W3C Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

IMSC1.0.1 Wide review Comments tracker

Wide Review Working Draft published 22 March 2017,"TTML Profiles for Internet Media Subtitles and Captions 1.0.1 (IMSC1)" https://www.w3.org/TR/2017/WD-ttml-imsc1.0.1-20170322/

The public review is now closed since 7 May 2017.

Call for Review sent to following W3C Groups

  • I18N ( 3 comments received)
  • Accessible Platform Architectures (APA) Working Group answer1 (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • Web Media Text Tracks Community Group (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • Web Platform Working Group answer1, Thierry's answer (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • Web and TV Interest Group (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • CSS Working Group (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • Privacy Interest Group (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • Web Security Interest Group (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TAG / Self-Review Questionnaire (Status: No comments)

Call for Review sent to following external Bodies

  • TTWG liaison to EBU (Status: Answer to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to DVB TM-SUB (Status: Answer to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to TTA (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to SMPTE(Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to ITU-T Group 16 IPTV (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to ISO JTC1/SC 29 (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to IPTV Forum Japan (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to HbbTV (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to ETSI MCD (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to DLNA (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to DTG (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to DASH-IF (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to CTA (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to ATSC (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to ARIB (Status: No response to Call for Review)
  • TTWG liaison to 3GPP (Status: No response to Call for Review)

These messages are archived in member-tt

Comments received from external bodies

(each TTWG proposal needs commenter's approuval)


We also received incoming liaisons in support of IMSC 1.0.1 as part of the Wide Review from the following external bodies:

Comments received from W3C groups

  • C2 - From: Richard Ishida (i18n-comment) via GitHub | Clarification: Should the character sets be minimum *font* requirements? (#236) , issue 236 - (Status: Done) No answer from RI, the questions have been answered).
  • C3 - From: Richard Ishida (i18n-comment) via GitHub | Why exclude hebrew and arabic proportional reference fonts? (#237) , issue 237 - Closed by issue 245- (Status: Done)
  • C4 - From: Addison Phillips (i18n-comment) via GitHub | Recommended character sets considered harmful (#243) , issue 243 - (Status: Done) - (No answer from Addison).

Comments sent by TTWG members

(should only need approval from WG members, no formal approval should be needed)