This is an archived snapshot of W3C's public bugzilla bug tracker, decommissioned in April 2019. Please see the home page for more details.

Bug 6901 - Tests using bogus gMonth format --mm--
Summary: Tests using bogus gMonth format --mm--
Status: NEW
Alias: None
Product: XML Schema Test Suite
Classification: Unclassified
Component: Microsoft tests (show other bugs)
Version: 2006-11-06
Hardware: PC Windows NT
: P2 normal
Target Milestone: ---
Assignee: Henry S. Thompson
QA Contact: XML Schema Test Suite mailing list
URL:
Whiteboard: WG decided, see minutes 2010-04-16
Keywords: disputedTest
: 6215 (view as bug list)
Depends on:
Blocks:
 
Reported: 2009-05-12 22:47 UTC by Michael Kay
Modified: 2010-04-16 16:19 UTC (History)
2 users (show)

See Also:

Attachments

Description Michael Kay 2009-05-12 22:47:04 UTC 
The following tests use the bogus gMonth lexical representation --mm--, and have expected results that assume this format is valid. This format was specified in the first edition of XSD 1.0 and subsequently corrected (to --mm) in Erratum E2-12. 

<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_enumeration002_203"
      name="gMonth_enumeration002_203"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxInclusive002_205"
      name="gMonth_maxInclusive002_205"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxExclusive002_208"
      name="gMonth_maxExclusive002_208"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive002_210"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive002_210"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive002_213"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive002_213"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_pattern001_1274"
      name="gMonth_pattern001_1274.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_enumeration001_1275"
      name="gMonth_enumeration001_1275"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_enumeration002_1276"
      name="gMonth_enumeration002_1276"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_enumeration002_1276"
      name="gMonth_enumeration002_1276.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_enumeration003_1277"
      name="gMonth_enumeration003_1277"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_enumeration004_1278"
      name="gMonth_enumeration004_1278"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_enumeration004_1278"
      name="gMonth_enumeration004_1278.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxInclusive001_1279"
      name="gMonth_maxInclusive001_1279"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxInclusive001_1279"
      name="gMonth_maxInclusive001_1279.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxInclusive002_1280"
      name="gMonth_maxInclusive002_1280"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxInclusive003_1281"
      name="gMonth_maxInclusive003_1281"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxInclusive003_1281"
      name="gMonth_maxInclusive003_1281.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxExclusive001_1282"
      name="gMonth_maxExclusive001_1282"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxExclusive002_1283"
      name="gMonth_maxExclusive002_1283"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxExclusive003_1284"
      name="gMonth_maxExclusive003_1284"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_maxExclusive003_1284"
      name="gMonth_maxExclusive003_1284.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive001_1285"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive001_1285"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive001_1285"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive001_1285.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive002_1286"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive002_1286"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive003_1287"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive003_1287"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive003_1287"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive003_1287.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive004_1288"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive004_1288"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive004_1288"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive004_1288.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive005_1289"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive005_1289"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minInclusive005_1289"
      name="gMonth_minInclusive005_1289.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive001_1290"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive001_1290"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive002_1291"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive002_1291"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive003_1292"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive003_1292"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive003_1292"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive003_1292.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive004_1293"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive004_1293"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive004_1293"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive004_1293.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive005_1294"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive005_1294"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth_minExclusive005_1294"
      name="gMonth_minExclusive005_1294.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth002_2061"
      name="gMonth002_2061.v"/>
<test set="MS-DataTypes2006-07-15"
      group="gMonth004_2063"
      name="gMonth004_2063.v"/>
Comment 1 Michael Kay 2009-05-13 09:53:29 UTC 
The same problem affects the Sun-submitted test:

set SType, group ST_facets00119m
Comment 2 Michael Kay 2009-05-13 09:56:15 UTC 
The same problem affects the Microsoft-submitted test:

set Errata, group errE006
Comment 3 Michael Kay 2009-05-13 09:58:31 UTC 
The same problem affects the Microsoft-submitted test

test set = regex group = reDG7
Comment 4 Michael Kay 2009-05-13 10:08:14 UTC 
And Microsoft tests:

set=simpleType, group=stE075
set=simpleType, group=stE096
set=simpleType, group=stE097
set=simpleType, group=stZ043 (file test107331_1.xml)
Comment 5 Henry S. Thompson 2010-04-16 16:14:24 UTC 
*** Bug 6215 has been marked as a duplicate of this bug. ***
Comment 6 David Ezell 2010-04-16 16:19:42 UTC 
WG decided to change the outcome in the metadata.  The WG verified that NIST tests correctly test the valid format.