This is an archived snapshot of W3C's public bugzilla bug tracker, decommissioned in April 2019. Please see the home page for more details.

This archived bug list includes all the bugs for the product or component specified, including bugs that have been resolved.

Mon Apr 1 2019 13:02:39 UTC
Hide Search Description
334 bugs found.
ID Product Comp Assignee Status Resolution Summary Opened Changed
220 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Correlation 2003-06-10 2004-03-04
267 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO WONT Specific Language for Describing MEPs 2003-07-15 2004-03-23
268 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO FIXE Formalism Task Force 2003-07-15 2003-07-15
269 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO FIXE Evaluate Inputs Listed in Charter 2003-07-15 2003-07-15
270 WS Chore Spec: Na martin.chapman RESO FIXE Party Identify in an Interaction 2003-07-15 2004-08-24
271 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT Choreography States 2003-07-15 2004-03-24
272 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT State Exposure 2003-07-15 2004-03-24
273 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE Enforcement of a Choreography 2003-07-15 2004-03-04
274 WS Chore Spec: Co steve CLOS WONT Communication of State Change 2003-07-15 2005-01-04
275 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO DUPL Expand WSDL 2003-07-15 2004-01-08
276 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE Where does Web Services Choregraphy ground? 2003-07-15 2004-03-23
280 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO WONT Semantics of messages 2003-07-29 2017-01-01
281 WS Chore Spec steve RESO WONT MEP as a simple choreography 2003-07-29 2004-03-24
282 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO FIXE Our time lines are constrained by the WSDL progress 2003-07-29 2004-03-04
302 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO WONT What do we mean by external process choreography 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
303 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO WONT What do we mean by internal process choreography? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
304 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO WONT what do users actually need? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
305 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO WONT Is this group about internal, extrenal, or both aspects of a business process? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
306 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT Is a choreography defintion exectutable? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
307 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE What is the difference (if any) between choreography and orchestration? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
308 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Reusable choreographies and data formats 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
309 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO DUPL should choreographies be enforced? 2003-08-27 2004-01-08
310 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Do we encode time into choreographies? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
311 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO WONT Storing and retreiving choreographies 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
312 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Can actual partipants in a choreography change during the lifetime of a choreography 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
313 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE What is our formal underpinning? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
314 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE how are decisions expressed in a choreography 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
315 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO FIXE Is a choreography a contract? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
316 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE is negotiation part of the choreography language or should it be modelled as a choreography? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
317 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Do all participants need to be known in advance? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
318 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO DUPL how are state changes (e.g. new participant join) communicated? part of the choreography infrastructure or built into a choreography? 2003-08-27 2004-01-08
319 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE should transport "signals" be modelled in a choreography? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
320 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO DUPL how do you compose two web services together? 2003-08-27 2004-01-08
321 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE Is a choreography an MEP? 2003-08-27 2004-03-23
322 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO DUPL How much state needs to be exposed? 2003-08-27 2004-01-08
323 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO DUPL what states do we need to distinguish, and what ones do choreography have to describe? 2003-08-27 2004-01-08
324 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO FIXE what does validation mean for a choreography language? 2003-08-27 2004-03-04
325 WS Chore Spec: Fo martin.chapman RESO FIXE Is a choreography itself a web service (i.e has a wsdl interface)? 2003-08-27 2004-08-24
326 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO FIXE What is the lifecycle of a choreography? 2003-08-27 2004-03-23
332 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO WONT What do we mean by semantics of web services and what are they for. 2003-09-03 2004-03-04
333 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE We need a choreography protocol use case. 2003-09-03 2004-03-04
342 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Turing complete or not turing complete 2003-09-16 2004-03-04
431 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Security as related to specifying policy and/or assertions. 2003-12-16 2004-03-04
432 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE CSF-004 - not addressed in requirements use cases 2003-12-16 2004-03-04
433 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Can there be a choreography with no web services? 2003-12-16 2004-03-04
434 WS Chore Primer martin.chapman RESO LATE concrete use case to show differences between BPEL abstract processes and WS-CDL 2003-12-16 2005-07-14
435 WS Chore Uncatego martin.chapman RESO FIXE Intermediaries 2003-12-16 2004-03-04
436 WS Chore Requirem steve RESO FIXE Transaction capability in CDL 2003-12-16 2004-03-04
464 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Flesh out section on structured references 2004-01-20 2004-12-01
465 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - DocumentReferece should be a URI, not URL 2004-01-20 2004-09-07
466 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Seems to imply that all messages handles by the choreography are SOAP 2004-01-20 2004-09-07
467 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - WSDL port types are mentioned as example of physical structure 2004-01-20 2004-04-19
468 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - The table lists the "Message Structure" and "Technology used" entries for Portable as "Defined". 2004-01-20 2004-04-19
469 WS Chore Spec: Im gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - "Import" is a concept used in XML Schema, WSDL and BPEL. 2004-01-20 2004-09-30
470 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - A Concrete Channel Type is defined to be the same as Portable Channel Type 2004-01-20 2004-04-19
471 WS Chore Spec: Co gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - At run time new information is added to a Concrete Interaction Channel Variable. 2004-01-20 2004-09-30
472 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Are abstract choreographies worth the effort? 2004-01-20 2004-03-04
473 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - ability to handle legacy web service 2004-01-20 2004-03-04
474 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - benefit of having an 'active' choreography mechanism that is required to manage its own state 2004-01-20 2004-04-19
475 WS Chore Requirem martin.chapman RESO FIXE Is fork/join covered as requirements 2004-01-20 2004-03-04
476 WS Chore Requirem martin.chapman RESO DUPL Is external/internal choice is covered as requirements? 2004-01-20 2004-01-20
484 WS Chore Spec: Im gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Issue CCI-01 2004-01-23 2004-09-30
485 WS Chore Spec: Im gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Issue CCI-02 2004-01-23 2004-09-30
486 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Issue TVT-01 2004-01-23 2004-08-12
487 WS Chore Spec steve RESO FIXE CDL - Issue TVT-02 2004-01-23 2004-12-01
488 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Issue I-01 2004-01-23 2004-04-19
489 WS Chore Spec: Co gritzinger CLOS FIXE CDL - Issue I-02 2004-01-23 2005-01-04
490 WS Chore Spec: Ex gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Issue I-03 2004-01-23 2004-12-01
491 WS Chore Spec: Va gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Issue I-04 2004-01-23 2004-08-12
492 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Issue ACS-01 2004-01-23 2004-05-18
493 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Issue ACS-02 2004-01-23 2004-09-30
494 WS Chore Spec: Ex gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Issue CET-01 2004-01-23 2004-08-24
495 WS Chore Spec: Ex gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Issue CET-02 2004-01-23 2004-08-24
496 WS Chore Spec: Ex gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Issue CET-03 2004-01-23 2004-08-11
497 WS Chore Spec: Ex gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Issue CET-04 2004-01-23 2004-08-24
498 WS Chore Spec: Va gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Issue CET-05 2004-01-23 2004-08-12
499 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Issue CET-06 2004-01-23 2004-09-30
500 WS Chore Spec: Ex gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Issue CET-07 2004-01-23 2010-12-24
506 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger CLOS WONT CDL - Identifying Choreographies 2004-01-23 2005-01-04
516 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Do we need 3 levels of abstraction for choreographies? 2004-02-03 2004-03-04
550 WS Chore Spec: Co martin.chapman RESO FIXE Should we support wsdl 1.1 2004-02-20 2004-09-16
552 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman CLOS LATE State alignment 2004-02-23 2005-07-14
553 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO WONT BPEL 2004-02-23 2004-04-19
554 WS Chore Spec gritzinger CLOS FIXE QOS, reliability and security 2004-02-23 2005-01-04
555 WS Chore Spec: Co martin.chapman RESO FIXE Dependency to other technologies - Section 3.5.3 2004-02-23 2004-12-01
556 WS Chore Spec: Co gritzinger CLOS FIXE Dependency to other technologies - Section 3.5.6 2004-02-23 2005-01-04
557 WS Chore Spec: Co gritzinger RESO DUPL Dependency to other technologies - Section 2.3 2004-02-23 2004-12-01
558 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO DUPL Dependency to other technologies - Section 2.4 2004-02-23 2004-04-26
559 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE Abstract CDL 2004-02-23 2004-03-04
560 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE Transactions 2004-02-23 2004-04-26
561 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE Import 2004-02-23 2005-07-14
562 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO WONT Section 3.4.1.2 - Role changes may dictate constraints on the definition of channels 2004-02-23 2004-09-07
563 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE Business Semantic - Variable values 2004-02-23 2005-01-04
564 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO WONT Section 3.4.2.1 - Clarify verbiage 2004-02-23 2004-10-11
565 WS Chore Spec: Ex gritzinger RESO FIXE Section 3.5 - Interactions and exceptions 2004-02-23 2004-12-01
566 WS Chore Primer gritzinger ASSI --- Section 3.6 - Work Unit 2004-02-23 2007-03-29
569 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO DUPL Number of abstraction levels in the language specification 2004-02-24 2004-03-04
607 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL Figure 2: Doesn't recognize the potential value of integration within an 2004-03-23 2004-04-26
608 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO INVA CDL - Resolve issue on abstract combination into portable and concrete 2004-03-23 2004-04-26
609 WS Chore Spec: Im gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - May be importing or 'receiving' rules outside of the choreography 2004-03-23 2004-09-30
610 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - "Relationship" not within WS_CHOR 's scope 2004-03-23 2004-09-30
611 WS Chore Spec: Im gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Import dependency on rules 2004-03-23 2004-09-30
612 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Business process failures outside of the scope of WS-Chor 2004-03-23 2004-09-30
613 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Explain how an assign can be made within only one role when the choreography should be recognizing all parties in the interaction 2004-03-23 2004-04-26
614 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - A control mechanism that indicates a Finalization WorkUnit must complete before a parent choreography 2004-03-23 2004-09-30
615 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Explain example in section 3.0 2004-03-23 2004-12-01
616 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Hold on extensibility until we know how this will be accommodated in WSDL 2.0 2004-03-23 2004-04-26
617 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO DUPL CDL - Import does not address dependencies, priority or impacts/conflicts 2004-03-23 2004-04-26
618 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Clarify description of Role construct 2004-03-23 2004-04-26
619 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Relationship / Channel clarification or correction 2004-03-23 2004-05-21
620 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - How can we allow non-visible behavior (Variables)? 2004-03-23 2004-09-07
621 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Explain what a ChoreographyNotation is 2004-03-23 2004-12-01
622 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Explain what a common viewpoint is 2004-03-23 2004-04-26
623 WS Chore Spec: Re martin.chapman RESO FIXE CDL - Editorial - Suggested editorial changes. 2004-03-23 2004-12-01
624 WS Chore Requirem gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Definition of Choreography and CDL 2004-03-23 2005-12-12
625 WS Chore Spec: Fo gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Precision of Specification 2004-03-23 2004-08-24
626 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO WONT CDL - Collaboration Types 2004-03-23 2004-05-18
627 WS Chore Spec: In gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - MEP support 2004-03-23 2004-12-01
628 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Definition of Choreograpy Transaction 2004-03-23 2004-05-18
629 WS Chore Spec: Va gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Variable definition 2004-03-23 2004-09-30
630 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Editorial - Editors List 2004-03-23 2004-05-18
631 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Editorial - 4th paragraph of Introduction section 2004-03-23 2004-09-07
632 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Editorial - figure 1 2004-03-23 2004-05-18
633 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Editorial - section 1.4 2004-03-23 2004-05-18
634 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Editorial - Section 3. example 2004-03-23 2004-05-18
635 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Editorial - WSDL example 2004-03-23 2004-05-18
636 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE CDL - Editorial - Section 4 2004-03-23 2004-05-18
661 WS Chore Spec: Na gritzinger RESO WONT Adding partnerType and roleType to the language model 2004-04-13 2004-12-01
662 WS Chore Spec: Le gritzinger RESO FIXE specify at least two levels or types of Choreography description 2004-04-13 2004-12-01
663 WS Chore Primer gritzinger RESO DUPL The specification should contain the basic underlying model of the 2004-04-13 2005-12-12
664 WS Chore Primer gritzinger NEW --- Add UML diagram to primer along with textual description 2004-04-13 2015-10-05
665 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO FIXE Concrete WSDL defined by each participant must built on this abstract WSDL? 2004-04-13 2004-12-01
666 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE Why specify a message type in the interaction? 2004-04-13 2004-09-07
667 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO DUPL No Notifcation and Sollicite-Response will be needed/allowed? 2004-04-13 2004-05-18
668 WS Chore Spec: Co gritzinger RESO WONT The granularity at which isAligned() can be used is too big 2004-04-13 2004-10-05
677 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE proprietary terminology used 2004-04-19 2004-09-07
678 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO FIXE If you are going to use a registry reference you should specify 2004-04-19 2004-10-05
679 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO FIXE application integration in Figure 1 2004-04-19 2004-05-18
680 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO DUPL No explicit references provided for abstract and concrete 2004-04-19 2004-05-18
681 WS Chore Spec gritzinger RESO DUPL Import and overwritten objects 2004-04-19 2004-05-18
682 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO FIXE Element visibility 2004-04-19 2004-10-05
683 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO FIXE Clarify that the reference with support from tokens, token types, etc. 2004-04-19 2005-01-04
684 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO INVA Variable and role assumptions 2004-04-19 2004-10-05
686 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO DUPL Need to address concerns on reuse before assessing against recovery 2004-04-20 2004-10-11
687 WS Chore Spec: Re gritzinger RESO FIXE Clearly differentiate a performed choreography vs. an imported definition. 2004-04-20 2004-12-01
688 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE Schema element attribute values need to be in quotes 2004-04-20 2004-09-07
691 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO FIXE Locally defined variables: Structure: How are locally defined variables defined when they are not consistent between roles that participate in the choreography? 2004-04-26 2005-01-04
692 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO WONT Types, variables and tokens: Dual variable objects are for different purposes in the abstract and portable context. 2004-04-26 2004-08-12
693 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO FIXE Variable combinations (Issue TVT-02) 2004-04-26 2004-12-01
709 WS Chore Spec: Ed gritzinger RESO FIXE In namespace table in Section 1.1 Notational Conventions: 2004-05-10 2012-10-26
721 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE Lack of a conformance clause 2004-05-21 2005-01-04
722 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO DUPL Use of participants for scoping 2004-05-21 2004-12-01
723 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT Channels and Channel Ends 2004-05-21 2004-09-09
724 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO FIXE Editorial 2004-05-21 2005-01-04
741 WS Chore Primer martin.chapman ASSI --- Semantics examples needed 2004-05-24 2005-12-12
742 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO FIXE Maybe we should look at existential qualifiers 2004-05-24 2004-09-28
743 WS Chore Primer gritzinger NEW --- Examples in the CDL specification and the Primer 2004-05-24 2015-10-05
753 WS Chore Spec: Na martin.chapman RESO WONT Replace 'interaction' with 'interact' 2004-05-28 2004-12-01
779 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT Participants aren't explicitly used anywhere 2004-06-01 2004-09-09
780 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT "Roles within Roles". Can one have a role within a role? 2004-06-01 2004-09-09
781 WS Chore Requirem martin.chapman RESO WONT Delegation Use Case (The Agent Acting On Behalf) 2004-06-01 2004-09-09
782 WS Chore Spec: In martin.chapman RESO FIXE Exchanges & MEPs. We will need to explore this relationship. 2004-06-01 2004-12-01
783 WS Chore Spec: In martin.chapman RESO FIXE Relationships (1:1 behaviour?) 2004-06-01 2004-09-28
792 WS Chore Spec: Na martin.chapman RESO WONT Change <reference> to <serviceReference> 2004-06-10 2004-12-01
839 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO WONT Description of WS Choreography:Spec component contains a typo: 'Choreograpghy' 2004-08-17 2004-09-09
846 WS Chore Spec: St martin.chapman RESO FIXE The defining characteristic of a Participant 2004-08-24 2004-12-01
849 WS Chore Spec: Na martin.chapman RESO DUPL The defining characteristic of a Participant 2004-08-27 2004-09-09
850 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO DUPL Conformance Statements in CDL 2004-08-27 2004-12-01
853 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT We need InputChannelVariable, OutputChannelVariable, FaultChannelVariable 2004-08-31 2004-09-09
854 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT Requirements for rules governing endpoint generation both in the absence and presence of WSDL 2004-08-31 2004-09-09
855 WS Chore Spec: In martin.chapman RESO FIXE Investigate the solicit-response and notification in WSDL 1.0 and WDSL 2.0 2004-08-31 2004-12-01
867 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT There are currently two mechanisms for performing assignment. 2004-09-07 2004-09-30
868 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO FIXE There is unnecessary redundancy in the syntax of the 'assign' activity. 2004-09-07 2004-09-30
869 WS Chore Spec: St martin.chapman RESO WONT There is no explicit mechanism for defining a repeating set of activities. 2004-09-07 2004-09-29
870 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT The current reactive mechanism is complex because it introduces implicit links. 2004-09-07 2004-12-01
871 WS Chore Spec: Ne martin.chapman RESO LATE The current 'composition/perform' mechanism does not enable complex choreographies to be composed. 2004-09-07 2005-07-14
872 WS Chore Part 2 ( martin.chapman ASSI --- Support for overcoming race conditions, other than by using variables. 2004-09-07 2005-12-12
883 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE There is no mechanism to define the absence of any work (nop) in CDL 2004-09-15 2004-09-30
884 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE There is no mechanism to obtain/set in CDL of the reference/identity of channel variable 2004-09-15 2004-09-30
885 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO FIXE Concept of "global time" or the absense of it and how we work around this 2004-09-15 2004-12-01
886 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE Catch All does not exist for an Exception 2004-09-15 2004-09-30
897 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO FIXE Move contents in WS-CDL Functions section into the body of the specification. 2004-09-28 2004-10-25
898 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO FIXE How can a variable become unavailable? 2004-09-28 2004-12-01
899 WS Chore Spec: Na martin.chapman RESO FIXE silentAction attribute in variableDefinition shuld be renamed 2004-09-29 2004-12-01
901 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE Raise the allowed isolation level of nested choreographies as an issue. 2004-10-05 2004-12-01
913 WS Chore Primer martin.chapman RESO WONT Clarification on workunit guard projectionI understand the role of the globalizedTrigger, to provide a guard condition for each role that is relevant to a work unit.However, if a work unit does not use a globalizedTrigger, and the guard condition is re... 2004-10-12 2004-12-01
916 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO FIXE If a "free" variable in an enclosed choreography is not BOUND then what is the variable's status? 2004-10-12 2004-12-01
923 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO FIXE No explanation of "action" and "new" in channel type defns2.3.4 Channel Types<channelType name="ncname" usage="once"|"unlimited"? action="request-respond"|"request"|"respond"? > <passing channel="qname" action="request-respond"|"request... 2004-10-25 2004-12-01
927 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE Removing the attribute root on a Choreography definition 2004-10-28 2004-12-01
928 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE ParticipantType and RoleType implementation restrictions are outside the scope of WS-CDL 2004-10-28 2004-12-01
929 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman CLOS WONT CDL order of interpretation is not clearly defined. 2004-10-28 2005-01-04
930 WS Chore Spec: In martin.chapman CLOS WONT Correlating separate channel instances to a choreography instance 2004-10-29 2005-01-04
935 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO INVA Clarification on interaction identifying an operation 2004-11-08 2004-11-08
937 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO WONT include description at 2.4.6 overuses word "Choreography" 2004-11-09 2005-01-04
938 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT Support for sub-choreography being performed concurrently with multiple participants 2004-11-09 2005-01-04
939 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO FIXE Boolean conditions 2004-11-09 2005-01-04
940 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO DUPL Correlating separate channel instances to a choreography instance 2004-11-09 2004-11-16
943 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO FIXE RFC 2119 terminology usage 2004-11-16 2005-01-04
944 WS Chore Spec: St martin.chapman RESO DUPL CDL does not support a choreography which needs to *concurrently* perform multiple instances of a sub-choreography against multiple participants 2004-11-16 2004-12-01
945 WS Chore Spec: Ed martin.chapman RESO FIXE Section 2.4.9.1 - typo, says "getGlobalizedTrigger" instead of "globalizedTrigger". 2004-11-16 2004-12-01
946 WS Chore Spec: Va martin.chapman RESO FIXE Section 2.5.2.3 - record element, target variable attribute. 2004-11-16 2004-12-01
947 WS Chore Spec: St martin.chapman RESO FIXE CDL does not contain any mechanisms to detect whether a timeout actually occurred or not 2004-11-17 2005-01-04
957 WS Chore Last Cal ylafon CLOS FIXE XHTML Compliance 2004-12-20 2005-08-03
958 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Normative sections and References 2004-12-20 2005-08-02
959 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Namespace name 2004-12-20 2005-05-10
960 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Notation/Psuedo Schema 2004-12-20 2005-05-10
961 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Informal vs Formal Definition 2004-12-20 2005-08-02
962 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Different visual blocks per example 2004-12-20 2005-08-02
963 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Different styles for syntax and examples 2004-12-20 2005-08-03
964 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT cdl namespace prefix 2004-12-20 2005-05-10
965 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE XML Well-formedness 2004-12-20 2005-08-02
966 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Editorial in References 2004-12-20 2005-08-03
967 WS Chore Last Cal ylafon CLOS LATE Ambiguity in the spec 2004-12-20 2005-08-03
968 WS Chore Last Cal ylafon CLOS FIXE CDL MIME Type 2004-12-20 2005-09-28
969 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Xpath name 2004-12-20 2005-08-02
970 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE example domain 2004-12-20 2005-08-02
971 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Break up section 2 2004-12-20 2005-08-02
972 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE getVariable usage 2004-12-20 2005-08-02
973 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Extension Wording 2004-12-20 2005-09-28
977 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Finalization text 2004-12-21 2005-08-02
996 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS LATE CDL Last Call comment - Choice of response message in WSDL 2005-01-10 2005-05-17
997 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE some minor editorial comments 2005-01-10 2005-09-28
998 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT State that sequential lexically ordering is the default for interpretation of CDL 2005-01-10 2005-05-17
999 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Short Circuit Evaluation 2005-01-10 2005-08-03
1000 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE CDL 'ROLE' FUNCTIONS 2005-01-10 2005-08-02
1001 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE CORRELATION OF CHANNEL INSTANCES 2005-01-10 2005-09-28
1002 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN RELATIONSHIP TYPES 2005-01-10 2005-05-10
1003 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE RELINGUISHING CONTROL OF PASSED OUTPUT CHANNELS 2005-01-10 2005-09-28
1004 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT WORKUNIT GUARD CONDITION SEMANTICS 2005-01-10 2005-08-02
1005 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT WORKUNIT REPETITION 2005-01-10 2005-08-02
1006 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT RECORD REFERENCE (in Interaction) RESTRICTION 2005-01-10 2005-05-12
1007 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE CHOICE WITH MIXTURE OF BLOCKING AND NON-BLOCKING ELEMENTS 2005-01-10 2005-09-28
1008 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE FAULT HANDLING 2005-01-10 2005-08-02
1014 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Point of clarity- Section 2.1, 1st bullet, last sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1015 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.2.3, 5th paragraph. 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1016 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.2.3, 6th paragraph 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1017 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.2.4, Title 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1018 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Information model - Section 2.3.2, 2nd last paragraph 2005-01-20 2005-08-03
1019 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman RESO DUPL Point of clarity - Section 2.3.2, 2nd last paragraph 2005-01-20 2005-08-03
1020 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Information model - Section 2.3.2, last paragraph, 1st sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1021 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Point of clarity - Section 2.3.3, 3rd paragraph, 2nd sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1022 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.3.3, 3rd paragraph, 2nd sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1023 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Question on constraint - Section 2.3.3, 3rd paragraph, last sentence 2005-01-20 2005-08-03
1024 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Missing descriptive text - Section 2.3.4, 5th last paragraph 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1025 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Information model - Section 2.3.4, 4th last paragraph 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1026 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Information model - Section 2.3.4, 3rd last paragraph, last sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1027 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Question on constraint - Section 2.3.4, 2nd last paragraph, 1st sentence 2005-01-20 2005-08-03
1028 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Missing descriptive text on Information model - Section 2.4.2, 1st paragraph 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1029 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.4.3.1, 1st function, 1st sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1030 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.4.3.1, 2nd function, 1st sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1031 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.4.3.1, 3rd function, 1st sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1032 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.4.3.1, 4th function, 1st sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1033 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Point of clarity - Section 2.4.3.1, 9th function, 1st sentence 2005-01-20 2005-08-03
1034 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.4.3.1, 2nd last function, 1st sentence 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1035 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Point of clarity - Section 2.5.2.3, 11th paragraph, 3rd bullet 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1036 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS DUPL Point of clarity - Section 2.5.2.3, 11th paragraph, 4th bullet 2005-01-20 2005-07-14
1037 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Comments of editorial nature 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1038 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Section 3 is Incomplete 2005-01-20 2005-07-18
1039 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Section 8 is Incomplete 2005-01-20 2008-12-02
1053 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Define the bindings between related concepts in WS-CDL and WS-Addressing 2005-01-25 2005-07-18
1054 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE An old version of WS-Addressing specification Abstract is quoted 2005-01-25 2005-07-18
1055 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE The purpose of the createNewID function does not seem clear 2005-01-25 2005-08-02
1062 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Section 2.4.7 does not describe whether the 'complete' could cause the premature completion of a finalizer 2005-01-27 2005-08-02
1063 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Finalization of an enclosed choreography when exception occurs 2005-01-27 2005-08-02
1064 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE WSDL dilemma about outbound operations not fully resolved 2005-01-27 2005-07-18
1066 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Section 2.2.5 Semantics, working towards solidifying two items 2005-01-31 2010-10-12
1067 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Section 2.4.2 Be specific about when the information is available 2005-01-31 2005-08-02
1068 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE How are the blocking guard condition semantics would be projected to BPEL? 2005-01-31 2005-09-28
1074 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS DUPL Language Extensibility and Binding - suggested change to an Extensions rule 2005-02-07 2005-05-10
1075 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Channel Types - attribute "usage" should be made an Element 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1076 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Information Exchange Capturing Variables Definition 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1077 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Add enforcement level to the silent action specification 2005-02-07 2005-05-26
1078 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Marking the Absence of Actions - reword section to better relate to what actions are not performed 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1079 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Interaction Syntax - successul-sending and properly-received are not clearly defined 2005-02-07 2005-12-12
1084 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE State the relationship between WS-CDL and the UN/CEFACT Modeling Methodology 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1086 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Clarify which role ref/refs is/are valid in XML schema 2005-02-07 2005-08-03
1088 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Clarify Variable and Token Information Type usage 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1092 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE State relationship between WS-CDL and ebBP 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1093 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS DUPL How would the blocking guard condition semantics would be projected to BPEL? 2005-02-07 2005-08-03
1094 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE 2.3.4. Overall. (editorial) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1095 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE 2.3.4. Para "The value of Variables:". (editorial) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1096 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS INVA 2.3.4. The last two paragraphs, about "roleType" attribute. (needs clarification) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1097 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE 2.4.4. The first para. (editorial) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1098 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE 2.4.5. The second para, last sentence. (editorial) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1099 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Specify that the evaluation of the guard expression is done in a fixed order 2005-02-07 2005-09-28
1100 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT Decompose workunit construct into "loop", "conditional" and "workunit" 2005-02-07 2005-05-12
1101 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT The operational behaviour involving "complete condition" is not clear 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1102 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Combine Finalizer blocks etc. in their corresponding workunits 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1103 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE 2.5.2.1. Interaction Based Information Alignment (editorial) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1104 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE 2.5.2.3, Interaction Syntax, exchange element. (editorial) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1105 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE 2.5.2.3. Interaction Syntax, record element. (editorial / clarification) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1106 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE 2.5.4. Assigning Variables, the second para. (editorial) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1107 WS Chore Last Cal gritzinger CLOS FIXE Mapping of roles and binding of variables (needs clarification) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1108 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Isolated sub-choreography terminates unsuccessfully (needs clarification) 2005-02-07 2005-09-28
1109 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Remote reads with cdL:getVariable (clarification) 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1110 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE When a copy expression references a variable that has not been set, what should happen? 2005-02-07 2005-08-02
1126 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS WONT usage of 'time' within CDL 2005-02-14 2005-08-02
1128 WS Chore Last Cal steve CLOS WONT Accessing and modifying members of lists and arrays 2005-02-22 2005-09-28
1129 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Extending Choreographies 2005-02-22 2005-05-17
1166 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS LATE Handling an arbitrary number of concurrent flows 2005-03-09 2005-08-03
1175 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT Mandatory reference token in channels 2005-03-21 2005-06-20
1176 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Workunit inside an exception handler 2005-03-21 2005-07-26
1177 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO WONT Mandatory reference token in channels 2005-03-22 2005-12-12
1178 WS Chore Spec martin.chapman RESO DUPL Workunit inside an exception handler 2005-03-22 2005-07-14
1455 WS Chore Primer steve ASSI --- Interaction Syntax - successul-sending and properly-received are not clearly defined 2005-05-17 2005-12-12
1456 WS Chore Primer steve ASSI --- Accessing and modifying members of lists and arrays 2005-05-17 2005-12-12
1457 WS Chore Primer steve ASSI --- Question on constraint - Section 2.3.4, 2nd last paragraph, 1st sentence 2005-05-17 2011-08-16
1459 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE We should clearly state in the spec that nested isolation choreographies are not permitted 2005-05-17 2005-08-02
1486 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Use of rns: and tns: namespace prefixes in example 2005-05-27 2005-08-02
1493 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Ordering of activities in finalization 2005-06-13 2005-08-02
1496 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman CLOS FIXE Making explicit the session mechanism 2005-06-14 2005-09-28
1503 WS Chore Primer steve ASSI --- Accessing and modifying members of lists and arrays 2005-06-20 2005-12-12
1831 WS Chore Last Cal martin.chapman RESO WONT Use of "capturing" to describe certain variables 2005-08-03 2005-09-28
2360 WS Chore Primer martin.chapman ASSI --- Section 4.2 says: A relationshipType identifies the roleTypes and behaviors, where mutual commitments between two parties MUST be made for collaborations to be successful. However, you indicate in Section 3.1 that relationshipType MAY only be used in ... 2005-10-18 2005-12-12
3101 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE hasChoreographyCompleted 2006-04-11 2006-07-18
3102 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE Perform bind variable types 2006-04-11 2006-07-18
3103 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE Choice 2006-04-11 2006-07-18
3104 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE Exchange type 2006-04-11 2006-07-18
3105 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE Service endpoint projection 2006-04-11 2006-08-08
3106 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO REMI Channel Passing 2006-04-11 2006-08-01
3107 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE Multipart variable with single part 2006-04-11 2006-08-01
3108 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE Activity names 2006-04-11 2006-08-01
3109 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO REMI hasExchangeOccurred 2006-04-11 2006-08-01
3110 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE description element 2006-04-11 2006-08-01
3111 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE Recursive performs 2006-04-11 2006-08-01
3484 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO WONT working mode of enclosed choreography while finalizing 2006-07-18 2008-12-02
3568 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO REMI Participants without roles, roles without behaviour 2006-08-01 2008-12-02
3569 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO WONT It is impossible to compare QNames 2006-08-01 2006-08-08
3570 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE add optional name to token locator 2006-08-01 2006-08-01
3571 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO WONT optional query for TokenLocator 2006-08-01 2006-08-08
3588 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO WONT channel passing example 2006-08-08 2007-03-20
3843 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO FIXE Redundant 'initiate' flag on interaction 2006-10-17 2008-12-02
3901 WS Chore Implemen martin.chapman RESO WONT Notification Message Exchange Type 2006-10-31 2007-03-06
24472 WS Chore Spec: Ne martin.chapman NEW --- bdsm toilet pain slave 2014-02-02 2014-02-02
334 bugs found.