W3C

– DRAFT –
WoT Testfest - Day 4

15 December 2022

Attendees

Present
David_Ezell, Kaz_Ashimura, Kunihiko_Toumura, Michael_Lagally, Michael_McCool, Ryuichi_Matsukura, Tomoaki_Mizushima
Regrets
-
Chair
McCool
Scribe
kaz

Meeting minutes

Agenda

McCool: minutes review to be done next week

Quick updates

Lagally: need to leave soon...

McCool: was not able to work on implementations so far
… but have some time tomorrow
… don't want to merge the update PRs for implementation reports right now

Lagally: if we have devices available...

McCool: let's have follow-up next week
… Siemens is not here today

Lagally: Ben's implementation is also to be updated
… asking him for TDs

McCool: ok
… so the work is ongoing in general
… let's review PRs quickly

PRs

McCool: Ege has updated the Playground

PR 516 - Update Playground.csv

Kaz: why we're still updating the tools?

McCool: not updating the tool itself, but there are still bugs with the tools...
… so there is another concern

PR 522 - Move language direction guess to pass

McCool: on the other hand, this is change with tool

PR 523 - Add oauth2 client flow Thing to WoT Experimental

McCool: changes for manual.csv
… added data to TD directory

Kaz: that's actually adding a TD, isn't it?

McCool: ah, right

Kaz: I'm kind of confused about the goal of the Testfest
… we're still adding data

McCool: gathering the data is the main purpose

Kaz: have been expecting we could see the results today
… if we still need to merge all these updates, we should change our plan and see the results next Wednesday

McCool: ok

PR 524

PR 524 - Updated TD results for Playground, editdor, wot-experimental

McCool: adding new results

merged

Implementation Reports

TD

<McCool> wot-thing-description PR 1755 - Implementation Report Update - Dec 2022

rendered version

McCool: this is the final output from the Testfest
… there are 18 features at-risk there
… but that's weird...

Kaz: what's wrong???

McCool: (looks into the data)
… some with the Playground...
… e.g., with td-security-oauth2-client-flow
… let me check with Ege

McCool: another point, "293: privacy-immutable-id-as-property" to be taken care of
… but should be easy
… no changes from yesterday

Kaz: let's simply merge this PR 1755

McCool: I'm OK with merging this
… (adds comments to the PR)

McCool's comments

merged

Discovery

wot-discovery PR 447 - Update Implementation Report - Dec 2022 Testfest

McCool: some SPARQL results to be clarified
… seems we lost automatic results for wothive.csv
… so let me not merge this now but let me fix the problem first
… (adding comments to the PR)

McCool's comments

Profile

wot-profile PR 343 - Implementation Report Update - Dec 2022

rendered version

McCool: including new updates from Fujitsu, etc.
… don't see the results from Oracle...
… TDs are there but no CSV
… would like to wait until we get the CSV file from Oracle as well

McCool's comment

Architecture

wot-architecture PR 887 - Implementation Report Update - Dec 2022

rendered version

McCool: a lot of updates here
… no new results other than Fujitsu's proxy

Kaz: contributes to the features at risk?

McCool: yes
… would like to merge this PR

McCool: CR draft includes more features at risk due to this update

merged

Next steps

McCool: the issue with wot-profile requires talking with Lagally

Kaz: and you need to talk with Ege about Playground bug

McCool: yes
… the next step is finalizing all the Implementation Reports
… will bring them to the next Testing call on Dec 21
… will work on my own implementation as well

Kaz: thanks a lot, all the contributors!

McCool: yeah, Matsukura-san, Toumura-san, etc.

AOB

McCool: ah, some remaining PRs on wot-testing

Kaz: yeah, 5 there

PR 521

PR 521 - Add write permission to the GitHub action workflow

Toumura: the script didn't have necessary permission

McCool: I'm OK with merging this

merged

PR 517

PR 517 - TD manualcsv changelog - Wednesday

Kaz: this doesn't impact the test results themselves. right?

McCool: right

merged

PR 518

PR 518 - Add manualcsv changelog for arch

merged

PR 519

PR 519 - Add discovery manualcsv changelog results

merged

PR 520

PR 520 - Add manualcsv changelog for profile

merged

McCool: we're actually done now
… aob?

(none)

[adjourned]

Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 196 (Thu Oct 27 17:06:44 2022 UTC).