W3C

– DRAFT –
WoT Testfest - Day 2

13 December 2022

Attendees

Present
Daniel_Peintner, Ege_Korkan, Fady_Salama, Kaz_Ashimura, Kunihiko_Toumura, Michael_Lagally, Michael_McCool, Ryuichi_Matsukura, Tomoaki_Mizushima
Regrets
-
Chair
McCool
Scribe
Ege, kaz

Meeting minutes

Quick Updates

Ege: I have done an API Key in the body implementation

McCool: to be reviewed later

Active Devices

<kaz> 2020.09.Online/active.csv

McCool: we have an active.csv from an old event
… we need to point to the TD as well

Lagally: pointing to the TD would be very good here

Ege: putting the td path more front would be nice

<kaz> (McCool and all see the active devices for node-wot)

McCool: let's put an example

Ege: you can put the node wot devices

Daniel: you can take node-wot ones like counter

<kaz> (then next for Oracle)

<kaz> 2022.12.Online/active.csv

Daniel: can we put links to the hosted TDs or the github link

McCool: you can maybe even use html markup to make them clickable

Kaz: so we want people to add information on their device to this active.csv file. right?

McCool: you can make a PR to the active.csv and I will merge them if they dont break anything
… use the current format

PR Review

PR 492

<kaz> PR 492 - Add fujitsu test results

McCool: should we remove the Fujitsu folder? It seems a duplicate

rm: yes please remove that folder

McCool: I think it will not influence any at risk results

McCool: There were also some fixes to the batchvalidation file

<kaz> (McCool checks batchValidation.sh)

<kaz> batchValidation.sh

PR 494

<kaz> PR 494 - Manualcsv changelog for each implementation

McCool: Ege has reverted the namechanges
… there was one but it was for my implementation

PR 497

<kaz> PR 497 - refactor: add quotes around node-wot results and add comment column

McCool: this fixes are about the quotes on node-wot
… it would be also good to have correct assertion text, I can help with it
… I have a regex that can help

Kaz: so is daniel using an old version?

McCool: I think daniel fixed the csv that was available already

Kaz: Ege, Daniel and Fady, please clarify what was the problem, which PR fixed which part of the problem and what to be still need to be fixed

subotpic: PR 1754 of TD

<McCool> wot-thing-description PR 1754 - Sync manual csv with playground and new titles

McCool: I will include my fixes there

PR 482

<kaz> PR 482 - Update processed results

McCool: some results of Ditto went back to not impl

Ege: it is weird that ditto has gone back, not normal

McCool: please have a look what is the cause, maybe something within playground

PR 499

<kaz> PR 499 - Add Fujitsu test results for Profile

McCool: there are sometimes single quotes within the assertion text. Matsukura-san, could you fix the quotes? Maybe you can leave the first line "Assertion", but should remove the assertion text on and after the second line.

https://github.com/w3c/wot-testing/tree/main/events/2022.12.Online#contributions

Ege: you can follow the instructions linked to make sure that you have quotes exported

Lagally: Are Fujitsu devices online?

rm: sadly not

McCool: Ege, please fix the GitHub action so that deleted TDs are not tested

PR 1755 in TD

<McCool> wot-thing-description PR 1755 - Implementation Report Update - Dec 2022|

McCool: Toumura-san has noted that we have 25 at-risk features

McCool: we can see that multiple assertion get resolved

<kaz> rendered version of the draft TD Implementation Report

<kaz> (question about "102: td-security-uri-variables-distinct"'s having no pass)

<McCool> https://w3c.github.io/wot-thing-description#td-security-uri-variables-distinct

Ege: I think that the distinct assertion is not passing since that implementation is not passing the uri variable is not used

McCool: Ege, can you fix the test?

Architecture Results

<McCool> wot-architecture PR 887 - Implementation Report Update - Dec 2022

<kaz> rendered version of the draft Architecture Implementation Report

McCool: we have many security assertions that are not passing

Ege: anything not security?

McCool: no, all security

Profile Results

<kaz> wot-profile PR 343 - Implementation Report Update - Dec 2022

<kaz> rendered version of the draft Profile Implementation Report

McCool: I did not get any new results

McCool: there are maybe missing implementations or maybe the fujitsu results will help

Lagally: It would be nice to have some inputs from nodewot in the consumer side

Daniel: I had some problems understanding which ones are consumer and which are thing

Kaz: note that this PR 887 adds updates on TLS 1.2 to be "SHOULD" instead of "MAY" already

McCool: sorry but seems I used a wrong version as the basis; will fix it

Lagally: let's not change the files right now

McCool: aob?

<kaz> (none)

<kaz> [adjourned]

Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 196 (Thu Oct 27 17:06:44 2022 UTC).