– DRAFT –
WoT Architecture

Agenda

<ML presents the agenda>

We should check the issue about the Profile normative section in Arch11 spec. Should be informative. I provided a PR to solve this issue

Minutes

WoT Arch

https://www.w3.org/2022/10/13-wot-arch-minutes.html

<mlagally> decision: revisit in next charter period (issue 815)

<mlagally> anecdotal

Lagally: any objections?

McCool: looks good

approved

WoT Profile

https://www.w3.org/2022/10/19-wot-profile-minutes.html

<mlagally> there was no consensus - we agreed to cancel the previous resolution

McCool: is ok

<mlagally> (ran out of time) - AOB

<kaz> (Architecture part is approved)

Lagally: we will keep the minutes open, will be approved in the next Profile call

Issues to close

Issue 841 Link

<mlagally> https://github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/841

<mlagally> /github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/841/Issue 814 - Compatibility in the ecosystem [TAG feedback]

Lagally: will close

<mlagally> -> /github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/814 -> close/

Issue 814

<kaz> rrsagent make log public

<kaz> rrsagent draft minutes

<kaz> Issue 814 - Compatibility in the ecosystem [TAG feedback]

Lagally: close this issue

Issue 587

<mlagally> https://github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/561

https://github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/587

Lagally: close issue

<mlagally> https://github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/558

Issue 561

Issue 561 - Lifecycle simplification

<kaz> Issue 841 - Update Security Link

Lagally: will close

Issue 558

Issue 558 - Cross reference FPWD drafts of Discovery, TD, ...

Lagally: will be not closed. Defered to next Arch version

Issue 555

<mlagally> Issue 555 - system lifecycle with registration

<mlagally> deferred to 2.0

Issue 548

<mlagally> Issue 548 - Align language: use case vs. application domains

Lagally: close this issue

Issue 412

Issue 412 - Property affordances claimed to always readable

<ML shows the text in Arch section 6.5.1>

Lagally: Issue is addressed, we can close this issue

Issues with label "close next week"

Issue 553

<mlagally> https://github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/553

McCool: Prefer to defer it to next charter
… relates to registration

<mlagally> Issue 553 - Information lifecycle

Lagally: ok, defer it

Issue 538

Issue 538 - Lifecycle section needs to take peer to peer discovery into account

Lagally: lets also defer it

Issue 536

Issue 536 - Relationship to Project Connected Home over IP

McCool: CHIP is now called Matter

Sebastian: I'm wondering why achitecture should address this. Maybe more relevant for use case discussion.

Kaz: Ok with moving to Use Case doc. New smart home standards should be also mention in the new charter.

<ML adds "use case" and "charter discussion" labels to the issue>

issue will be not closed

<mlagally> https://github.com/w3c/wot-architecture/issues/530

Issue 530

Issue 530 - Incorporate Discovery terminology into terminology section

Lagally: Issue seems to be solved
… going to close

Issue 524

Issue 524 - Sequence diagram for TD lookup in a directory service

Lagally: Will keep it open

Issue 417

Issue 417 - [question] Is the servient a hypervisor or single application vm?

Lagally: Question was answeard in the issue
… going to close this issue

<mlagally> proposal: Architecture TF agrees to close issues that are marked as "question" after they had been sufficiently "answered"

RESOLUTION: Architecture TF agrees to close issues that are marked as "question" after they had been sufficiently "answered"

Issue 374

Issue 374 - Where did w3c-wot-td-context.jsonld and w3c-wot-common-context.jsonld go?

Lagally: close

Issue 365

Issue 365 - Define gateway

Lagally: close it

Issue 364

Issue 364 - How does one connect "directly to the cloud"?

Lagally: close it

Issue 48

Issue 48 - Thing Discovery

Lagally: also close it

Issues to close or defer

Issue 508

<kaz> Issue 508 - Create a terminology definition for "system user data"

Sebastian: Oliver is not active anymore. We should involve Jiye

Lagally: let keep it open

Issue 455

Issue 455 - Cross check terminology of stakeholders with DID

Lagally: close it

Issue 430

Issue 430 - Give basic definition of "End-to-End Security"

Lagally: close it

Issue 429

Issue 429 - More clearly define "Thing Authentication"

McCool: keep it open

Issue 208

Issue 208 - Need deployment example for Cloud Server with Client devices

Lagally: keep it open and defer it

Issues to resolve by PR transition

Issue 859

Issue 859 - Prepare PR publication

Lagally: It seems that APA did not review yet

McCool: I will check

PR

PR 862

PR 862 - Switch Profile to non-normative section

<kaz> related Issue 850 - Contradiction with the WoT Profile spec on protocol bindings

<there is too less time for detail disussion>

<kaz> (to be discussed during the Profile call next Wednesday)

Lagally: let's continue in Profile call

<kaz> [adjourned]