Meeting minutes
PRs
PR 431
<kaz> PR 431 - Oct 2022 - Update TD results to latest version of playground
McCool: going to merge
done
PR 432
<kaz> PR 432 - [TD] Add text direction to mqtt example
PR is merged
PR 433
<kaz> PR 433 - Manual test results for WoTWebThing
McCool: PR updates readme, csv, and TDs files
Lagally: I had no time to validate the TDs
Ege: it seems that a curl bracket is missing
Lagally: I will fix the issue
PR 434
- Add Architecture implementation report for saywot!
Ege: waiting for Felix to get feedback
McCool: going to merge, another PR can update the content
PR is merged
PR 435
<kaz> PR 435 - Delete template.csv
McCool: file not used in testing
… going to delete this
merged
PR 437
<kaz> PR 437 - Update TD editdor manual csv
McCool: it seems not all assertion showing up in the csv files since the extracting tool missed some
… we need to check
PR 433 - revisited
<kaz> PR 433 - Manual Profile test results for WoTWebThing
<kaz> validation still fails
Ege: I need to check the log
McCool: forms seems to be a object and not an array
Lagally: I will check it again
Ege: found the problem. There is an extra forms defined in the TD.
Review Implementation Report
TD
<kaz> wot-thing-description PR 1706 - Oct 2022 Testfest Updates to Implementation Report
<kaz> latest draft Implementation Report
McCool: it seems still the old manual assertations results are in there
… I will check
Discovery
<kaz> wot-discovery PR 421 - Oct 2022 Testfest Updates to Implementation Report
<kaz> latest draft Implementation
McCool: Discovery automatic tests passed. Few things have to be done such as manual inputs issues have to be fixed
McCool: to be finalized on Monday during the Discovery call
Profile
wot-profile PR 298 - Oct 2022 Testfest Updates to Implementation Report
latest draft Implementation Report
PR 433 for Profile - revisited
PR 433 - Manual Profile test results for WoTWebThing
Lagally: fixed the problem. PR can be merged
merged
Profile Implementation Report - revisited
<kaz> Profile/Results/webthings-gateway.csv
<MM visit PR 430>
<kaz> PR 430 - Assertions split for Consumer and Thing - Excel and CSV cersions
Lagally: the excel has colored markup, nicer to read
… lets not merge
<MM closes PR 430>
McCool: there is still an error in https://
Wrapup and next steps
McCool: I will generate the new reports based on the new inputs
Ege: I created a PR a to fix the 'span' problem
wot-thing-description PR 1716 - Assertion span fix
Sebastian is ok to merge this PR
Kaz: how to proceed?
McCool: I'm going to clean up today
… I will have new PRs begin of next week
… in Discovery meeting will review the results and finalize the list of at risk items
… same should be done for TD on Wednesday
… and Architecture on Thursday
… on Wednesday we should also decide on Profile
Lagally: probably the specification is not mature enough. However, we should not slow down.
… I think, it is ready in 1 or 2 months
McCool: we should also decide to publish the Profile as Note or keep as Working Draft
Lagally: I believe before we go in CR another review of all specs would be good
Kaz: we need to see how many features from TD and Architecture to be identified as "features at risk" before CR publication, so there is a possibility we need to wait until Oct 19 to make the final resolution. If needed, we can make the resolution by email before 19th, though./
[adjourned]