Meeting minutes
agenda
McCool: found a bug, created a fix PR
… other prs and discussion about pubblication
minutes
McCool: minutes look ok
… issue 86 was closed by PR
… I updated implementation report
… finally we took some time discussing todo
… but no substantial updates about that after it
… smaller typos
… any other comments?
… propose publishing this
… no objections
… minutes accepted
PRs
353
<kaz> PR 353 - Update Privacy Considerations
McCool: reviewed in the security call this morning
… coming from privacy review
… got some feedback
… made few changes
… using GDPR definition of profiling
… also fixed some consistency issue with TD spec
… no new assertions
… just updated
… it was already accepted by security
… propose to merge it
… after typo fixes
… never mind, it wasn't a typo
… hearing no objections PR merged
PR 355
<kaz> PR 355 - add a link to rendered Implementation Report
McCool: quite handy
… no objections
… merged
PR 351
McCool: farshid complained that I didn't captured all the changes
… I've resolved his concerns
<kaz> PR 351 - Update Change Log
Farshid: correct
Farshid: one note, we didn't update the API but the TD
McCool: however a TD consumer would see this as an API change
… better than nothing
… merged
PR 360
<kaz> PR 360 - Update assertions list for manual testing
McCool: this should fix serveral issue with the implementation report
… looks ok
… merged
PR 361
<kaz> PR 361 - Update wothive.csv report
McCool: I usually copy things over from wot testing
… andrea did you check it from wot-testing?
Andrea: I will update wot-testing too
McCool: ok merged
… all PR merged
PR 358 (closed)
<kaz> PR 358 - Fix Duplicate IDs
McCool: there was an id duplicated
… the PR fixes it
Publication
McCool: I've been working on the files that should be generated for the WD
PR 357
<kaz> PR 357 - WIP Create CR Candidate Working Draft for publication
McCool: anyway I fix a bunch of html issues
… and broken links
… this all goes under publication/3-cr but I will than change to 3-wd
… I would merge it cause my workflow requires the changes to be published in the main branch
… so that I can take them from github.io
… so I'd merge it just to run the link checker
… the changes does not touch files outside publication/3-cr
… ok
… the other thing that I did is to inline the TM
… merged
implementation report
<kaz> PR 362 - 27 June 2022 impl report update
<michael updating the implementation report and fixing minor issues>
McCool: I'm seeing a duplication of assertions
… they should be fixed
… we still have some notification thing to be done
Farshid: we just submitted the reports
McCool: ok
… about the manual ones: pretty easy
… however some of them are related to consumers
… which are tricky
… no implementation for coap
… I will update the impl report right now
Farshid: I have some concerns about the fact that duplicates were already fixed
McCool: yeah I know, but now they should be fixed
… ok merging the update
… merged
todo.csv
<kaz> PR 364 - Update todo.csv
McCool: did anybody work on their todos?
… I didn't have time
<michael fixing duplicates in todos.csv>
McCool: new pr created
… merging
McCool: farshid fixed some old entries in 363
<kaz> PR 363 - Remove duplicates and obsolete entries from manual.csv
McCool: there is still work to do to clean up the wd
… I will spend some time to fixing smaller issues
issues
McCool: quick glance
issue 348
<kaz> Issue 348 - Missing assertion markup in 7.3.2?
Farshid: I think it can be closed
McCool: the text looks to much assertion like
… we should at least try to rephrase it
… any objections?
… ok closing
issue 354
<kaz> Issue 354 - Clarification about diff parameter in events
Cristiano: the text was a little bit open
… servers may choose to not fire errors
Farshid: the problem is that the assertions are too far away
… probably a note should be sufficient
Cristiano: not sure it solves it
McCool: I would prefer not major changes
issue 341
<kaz> Issue 341 - Improve service-http-resp-content-type assertion
McCool: this is on me, but we should first the coap problem first
… there is a misalignment with the content types in coap and http
… we'll track it in a new issue
McCool: ok created
[adjourned ]