W3C

– DRAFT –
WoT Architecture

31 March 2022

Attendees

Present
Ege_Korkan, Kaz_Ashimura, Kunihiko_Toumura, Michael_Lagally, Michael_McCool, Tomoaki_Mizushima
Regrets
-
Chair
Lagally
Scribe
kaz

Meeting minutes

Minutes

Mar-24

approved

Publication timeline

Extension plan

Lagally: would like to extend the deadline by 2-mo

McCool: OK with changing the date
… but need to be aware of the deadline for CR transition
… 2-mo should be OK
… you can generate a PR to apply the proposed changes

Lagally: (generates a PR)

McCool: CR transition at end of June?

PR 1017 - Update wg-2021-extension-plan.md for Architecture 1.1

Lagally: can we merge it?

McCool: yeah
… and let people know during the main call

(merged)

Testing

PR 707 - WIP: Implementation Report

McCool: (shares his screen)
… have fixed the script
… also the report itself has been updated
… wondering about the Editors of the Implementation Report

Ege: would like to be included

McCool: Panasonic to be removed
… Matsukura-san can be included
… what about Mizushima-san?

tm: please include me
… Tomoaki Mizushima, Internet Research Institute, Inc.

McCool: would like to just say "Intel" as my affiliation

Kaz: note that we should be clear about the role
… Editors are people who edits the whole document
… each contributors and section authors should be called "Contributors" and "Authors" respectively

McCool: yeah, need to check that
… would like to list Toumura-san as well

Kaz: btw, the copyright year should be 2022

McCool: probably

htmlpreview for the draft implementation report

McCool: would like to merge the current PR so that we can add further edits

related Issue 725 - Implementation report - remaining tasks

Lagally: are you merging PR 707? I can merge it

McCool: ok

(merged)

PR 727

PR 727 - Draft of explainer for architecture 1.1

Lagally: generated an updated explainer

McCool: ok
… you could go ahead and merge this
… could add a chunk of updates after that

Lagally: ok

(merged)

PR 669

PR 669 - Producer definition

Lagally: Producer definition

Kaz: I'm OK with the text itself
… but are we clear enough about the relationship among "Thing", "Device" and "Servient" as background?

McCool: should be ok
… "Producer" is more mechanical
… could add some more cleaning up later

(merged)

Issues

remaining issues

Lagally: (visits section 7.1 WoT Thing Description)

7.1 WoT Thing Description

Lagally: let me search for "JSON"...

Issue 687

Issue 687 - Inconsistencies in 7.1.2.1 Thing Descriptions

(closed)

Issue 684

Issue 684 - Introduction misses WoT Discovery

McCool: maybe already fixed?

Lagally: visits the Introduction section

1. Introduction

Lagally: still need to fix

McCool: ok

Issue 676

Issue 676 - Move "orphaned" annex B.1 from "binding templates" to architecture

Ege: have not reviewed this yet
… should migrate the binding text with the Architecture spec

Kaz: in that case, the document consistency check between Architecture and Binding Template is not completely done yet. right?

Ege: right

Binding Templates B.1 Forms Element

Issue 675

Issue 675 - Move Media Types in Section 8.7.3 to a higher level (8.8)

6.7.3 Media Types

Kaz: maybe the section number has been updated but would be better to say "6.7.3"

Lagally: yes

Lagally's updated comments

Issue 617

Issue 617 - Review Chapter 6.7 in relation to Binding Templates 4.1

Lagally: need to see

Issue 673

Issue 673 - Review Discovery Spec, ensure consistency of architecture and discovery

McCool: to be fixed in consistency with the Intro section (to add description on Discovery)

[adjourned]

Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 185 (Thu Dec 2 18:51:55 2021 UTC).