Meeting minutes
Previous minutes https://
Previous minutes about today's agenda https://
Data Entities categories and sub-classes
In previous meeting(s), we agreed to include only those categories that are relevant and important e.g. mentioned by a legal obligation so as to include in core DPV instead of an extension
julian: this list will not be comprehensive, and is dynamic and industry-specific in real-world
georg: so in cases of e.g. ROPA, there would DataSubject as the field and an open text field to specify information about what data subject categories
julian: these labels are not formalised in the sense that their interpretation is not clear, unambigious, or uniform across use-cases. For example, 'WebsiteVisitors' is applicable to a visitor to a website, but if there is embedded Twitter content on that website then are they also visitors?
julian: some of these categories are subclasses of LegalEntity but not DataSubject, why so?
georg: In some cases, e.g. GDPR A.9(2-d), where members may not be data subjects until certain conditions are met
julian: in this case, `Member` should be in dpv-gdpr rather than dpv
georg: we can think in terms of legal entities, so as to see which groups of data subjects are associated with each legal entity ; then we can think of what categories to model
Everyone agrees to the proposal. Georg will be sharing a preliminary categorisation on the mailing list.
Personal Data Categories ambiguity and resolution
Proposal earlier talked about prefixing concept IRIs (e.g. Location) with `pd_` to make it `pd_Location` so as to disambiguate it from other uses of Location e.g. StorageLocation as adopters are incorrectly using Location (which is personal data) to denote other forms of non-personal-data locations e.g. company location
julian: prefer modular approach i.e. extract personal data to separate module and use as dpv-pd:Location
paul: like the concepts all being in one place, but okay to go with consensus
harsh: Piero denoted preference for modular approach as well
harsh: I prefer modular approach as well
Harsh will enquire with Georg and the group will make a decision in next week's meeting
Next Meeting
We will meet again on WED 15-DEC 13:00 WET / 14:00 CET