Meeting minutes
review minutes
https://
any objections?
no
TD roadmap
https://
there some update for point 0 and added a comment for the review phase which may be take longer then 6month
tomorrow in the Arch call we will decide if we do a 12 month extension of current WG charter
Kaz: I'm OK with the proposed timeline
… but that means we need to check our progress based on this updated timeline every week
Sebastian: right
… we should do so at the beginning of the TD calls
… note that we'll keep the 6-month deadline itself
(latter 6 months of the extended period to be kept as our margin)
PR
PR 1239
PR 1239 - Update impl.csv for 2021.10 Plugfest results
do some discussion about the "impl-" prefix. It seems that all other companies have also to remove it
Kaz: Michael will give some new introduction how to update the implementation result
decided to merge this PR
PR 1250
PR 1250 - Fix JSON Schema issues
its about some fixes in the JSON Schema
PR 1260
PR 1260 - update definition for forms
decide to merge
PR 1261
<kaz> PR 1260 - Additional recommendation about the unit usage
going to be merged
PR 1262
PR 1262 - fix default value link for op
will be merged
PR 1250
<kaz> PR 1250 - Fix JSON Schema issues
going to merge
PR 1263
<kaz> PR 1263 - additional text about TM versioning
<kaz> VC 1.1 REC appendix B
Kaz: regarding the discussion on "versioning" for TM vs TD, the above spec might be helpful
… our approach is different, though
<kaz> (mergded)
PR 1264
<kaz> PR 1264 - Fix 948
<kaz> sk: would check with McCool before merging this
PR 1270
<kaz> PR 1270 - add tm:submodel entry in relation typ table
<kaz> (merged)
PR 1271
<kaz> PR 1271 - fix iri to iri-reference and add further instructions
<kaz> (merged)
Issues
Issue 1258
<kaz> Issue 1258 - Good Practice for observe property flow
Kaz: so we'll continue to discuss how to deal with the concrete behavior. right?
Sebastian: yes, I'll create a PR for that purpose
Bindings
binding prefixes
<kaz> PR 129 - General improvements to the modbus ontology and spec files
Ege: Cristiano used modbus prefix
… for http we are using htv
… because some people would confuse http prefix as an URI scheme
… why did Cristiano use modbus and not mdv?
… 120 issue is also reletated
Cristiano: v at the end is weird
… http prefix is it really a problem?
… but I would go for a consistent approach
Ege: we can't change htv
… is in the TD spec
Daniel: you can choose any prefix
… not sure how we can solve, but there's definitely confusion around
Ege: we can deprecate htv in TD 2.0
… so at the end with the modbus should we go with the full name?
Daniel: I would keep htv
PR 131
<kaz> PR 131 - Create orphaned sections
Ege: I move some orphaned sections to the appendix
Ege: it is a temporary fix
… objections?
PR 138
<kaz> PR 138 - Fix broken links
Ege: fixing broken links with w3c link checker tool
… now pointing to the architecture document
Kaz: sadly we have to manually fix links right before the publication
Ege: btw also td doc has broken links
… created issues on td repo
Kaz: ok for merging
<kaz> guide page
Kaz: editors please head to the page above for guidelines about writing spec documents
Ege: merging 138
Issue 135
<kaz> Issue 135 - Consider removing section 2.2 HTTP Default Vocabulary Terms
Ege: duplicated terms about http
… it is both in binding and TD
… at least there's no conflicts
Cristiano: ok for moving to TD, but maybe change TD table to be equal to our current table
… what do we loose if we remove http binding section on the TD
Ege: I'm not sure
Daniel: is an introduction text
Ege: I'm going to open an issue on the TD about binding http section
… and link
Ege: aob?
Ege: adjourned