Meeting minutes
Preliminary
McCool: last day today
PRs
PR 177
Add converted SDF models as a submodule #177
McCool: Jan is not here...
… we can validate TMs as TDs
… and I can check the tests
… a few issues with composition
… need discussions
McCool: (look into the changes)
… let's merge this and see what would happen
(merged)
McCool: (and then sees /tools)
… tools not actually changed...
… effects on submodules
https://
McCool: good to have link to the original OneDM
Koster: where it came from
McCool: gravity and orientation, etc.
(Jan joins)
McCool: good to have relation type on the original data
… e.g., SDF model
… should have some standard way
Koster: e.g., for accelerometer
McCool: what's interesting is having accelerometer_X_Value and Accelerometer_Y_Value
… should be a vector value
Koster: like color value
… individual definition to be done, e.g., by OneDM
Kaz: why don't we create an issue about those points?
McCool: yeah
… do we have an issue for this project yet?
Jan: not yet...
McCool: (creates a project for SDF Conversion)
… (adds comments to that issue)
Koster: we provide SDF model for components
… but not data schema itself
… how to construct the data schema?
… SDF has, e.g., RED/GREEN/BLUE components for color
… same question about TM
… how to describe the element of the vector data
Sebastian: good question
Project (2021-09) Plugfest: SDF Conversion #183
McCool: also might want to think about timestamps
… possible discussion on Wednesday
Kaz: you mean a main call on Oct 6?
McCool: any conflicts?
Kaz: no, we can have discussion there if we want
… should clarify what to do today and what to do on Oct 6
McCool: would wrap up the discussion today
PR 178
McCool: diagram updates
(merged)
McCool: (check the devices/apps within the diagram)
McCool: there are several devices with "?"
… need a bit more information
… should clarify which devices are available for what
Kaz: we need to add related information in addition to the TD itself
… README.md description, Project Issue, Project description, ip.csv, active.csv
McCool: yeah
Matsuda: ECHONET provides devices using 30.110
… others from ECHONET should be removed
Pham: +1
McCool: what about NHK?
… probably we should remove all the unknown devices with "?"
Toumura: ok
McCool: any other devices showing up here?
(none)
McCool: what about RIoT implementations?
Philipp: RIoT OS itself uses IPv6 so can be globally addressed
… but Arduino uses IPv4
Kaz: what about the mobile connection?
Philipp: didn't work well
McCool: maybe the question is not VPN itself
… but bridge connection
Kaz: given it's the last day today
… we should once give up to connect to RIoT OS Arduino
… and need to think about the setting separately
McCool: let's discuss that later
Philipp: having been working on tutorials
… and they're already available online
PR 179
McCool: some problem from Toumura-san?
Project (2021-09 Plugfest): Siemens / Logilab TDD #168
Farshid: caused by synchronization problem?
McCool: automatically allocated ids
… each run of crawling script assigns a new id
Christian: working on the issue
McCool: let's merge PR 179 itself
(merged)
PR 180
Toumura: NHK says all their (virtual) devices exposes their address as "Android-2.local"
McCool: general mDNS should work for that
… but using concrete value for the Plugfest is fine
(merged)
PR 181
McCool: includes sensors
Matsukura: you can see the diagram within another file
… sensor unit exposed via the proxy
Fujitsu's readme.md under /TDs
McCool: let's merge this PR itself
(merged)
Kaz: please note that we should have made sure all the participants should have provided not only TDs but also (1) brief description on the main README, (2) a Project Issue, (3) Detailed description on the Project, and (4) available IP addresses for the devices so that other participants can tell how to connect with each other and put the results on the Interop Testing Issue.
McCool: let's add description to the interop issue
Matsuda: question
… this proxy can be connected to the devices provided by ECHONET as well?
… note that we provide WoT interface within the VPN this time
Matsukura: ECHONET Lite connection bridged via the WoT connection within the VPN
Matsuda: ok
McCool: let's generate a consolidated information about the available devices and the results of connection
PR 182
Provide TDs of composed TM definitions #182
McCool: some issue with validation again
… maybe Ege can help
Next steps
McCool: we need documentation
… I'll update the implementation document
… need (automatic) assertion tests and (manual) CSV tests
PR 182 - revisited
Kaz: Sebastian has just merged PR 182
Next steps - revisited
McCool: anybody planning to add yet another TDs?
(none)
McCool: let's see the results next week
… vF2F will starts
Kaz: Tuesday, Oct 5 and Thursday, Oct 7
McCool: ok
… let's have discussion on Wednesday during the main call and the Plugfest call
Kaz: meanwhile, I'd like to ask again all the participants to provide not only TDs but also (1) brief description on the main README, (2) a Project Issue, (3) Detailed description on the Project, and (4) available IP addresses for the devices so that other participants can tell how to connect with each other and put the results on the Interop Testing Issue.
McCool: also description about the implementations (for the implementation report)
… Plugfest report out is not yet on the agenda...
… let me add it to Oct 28
… so that we have enough time for organization
… meanwhile, please make sure you docuement your projects!!!
[adjourned]