+1 to SPC Task Force – 10 May 2021

W3C

SPC Task Force

10 May 2021

Attendees

Present
Adrian Hope-Bailie (Coil), Bastien Latge (EMVCo), Christian Aabye (Visa), Clinton Allen (American Express), Doug Fisher (Visa), Gerhard Oosthuizen (Entersekt), Gustavo Kok (Netflix), Ian Jacobs (W3C), Michel Weksler (Airbnb), Praveena Subrahmany (Airbnb), Rolf Lindemann (Nok Nok), Sameer Tare (Mastercard), Stephen McGruer (Google), Tomasz Blachowicz (Mastercard), Werner Bruinings (American Express)
Chair
Ian
Scribe
Ian

Meeting minutes

Scope document edits

Some questions:

* Benefits v. features

* Ecommerce?

Ian: Should we focus on Ecommerce?

Gerhard: I would include bill pay. For me the split is more B2C v. B2B

smcgruer_[EST]: +1 to "B2C"

<mweksler> +1

smcgruer_[EST]: Ok for future considerations including P2P or B2B

<Christian> +1

<AdrianHB> +1

Action: Ian to clarify B2C use cases in the scope document

Ian: (Unique) Benefits v. Features?

Gerhard: Whichever way we go, the thing that is different is:

- Built in browser support for payments

- Cross-domain
… FIDO already gives us cryptogram.
… I think there are "primary" and "secondary" benefits / features

<smcgruer_[EST]> +1 to those being the useful things (for now)

Ian: What does "cross-domain" mean to you?

Gerhard: "Party calling it is not the RP"

Tomasz: If we are talking about cross-domain capability, I think this is a key feature.
… even if the cryptogram captures additional details, it's the cross-domain bit which is a key feature
… it is not just about scalability, it is an enabler for a new user experience

Action: Gerhard and Ian to work on teasing out BOTH features (e.g., cross-origin) and benefits (e.g., scalability)

Gerhard: I think we should have some additional discussion on requirements for browsers v. innovation in UX

Work plan

https://github.com/w3c/secure-payment-confirmation/wiki/Plan-2021

Tomasz: Do we have other browser vendors engaged (in this time frame or other)?

Ian: WG can share deliverables ... please have your companies ask for engagement on this topic!

Tomasz: What about Edge?

smcgruer_[EST]: If we (Chrome team) were ship code, we will contact all the other browser vendors and solicit input.
… we will want an explainer that states what we plan to ship
… once we have an explainer that looks like something we have in a spec, we'll socialize that with other browser vendors.
... One comment: I am excited by the plan.
… regarding FPWD, we don't need "confirmed" FPWD, but at least a spec that I'm satisfied would be pretty much an FPWD

Ian: Any editing volunteers?

* Stephen

* AdrianHB

* Gerhard

* Ian

* Rolf

<Ian> Next meeting: 17 May

Summary of action items

  1. Ian to clarify B2C use cases in the scope document
  2. Gerhard and Ian to work on teasing out BOTH features (e.g., cross-origin) and benefits (e.g., scalability)
Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 131 (Sat Apr 24 15:23:43 2021 UTC).