W3C

– DRAFT –
Silver Errors Subgroup

03 February 2021

Attendees

Present
Crispy, deanhamack, sarahhorton, Sukriti, Todd
Regrets
-
Chair
sarahhorton
Scribe
Sukriti

Meeting minutes

Update team on presentation to Silver Taskforce of Errors User Needs Worksheet and Errors User Needs Summary

sarah: everyone really happy about the approach
… in the larger group

Review Scope and Timeline; discuss next steps

<sarahhorton> Scope: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KrDoB4wNJGKwhQ7MhXSQzj1vhamt-WaQFR4D0i3QNOA/edit#heading=h.1c6d9fdd68lf

Sarah: timeline

Review February Tasks; assign tasks

tasks for the month divided up into individually assignable pieces

https://www.w3.org/WAI/GL/task-forces/silver/wiki/Main_Page#Sub_Groups

<sarahhorton> https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1DBP8ujOs6HeZ1dYQWBbSOAssATCNDEcLYMF3VYRCAZk/edit#gid=526717162

Sarah: guidelines from the first public working draft
… that and the guidelines worksheet to model out guidelines

sukriti: are errors a subtopic of other guidelines or guidelines of their own?

Sarah: Can be either depending on the scenario
… came up in call last week
… contrasts
… should there be a different error contrast than general
… there could be a case where that is the requirement
… our scope is for error related guidelines for now

chris: related guidelines in the summary sheet
… cross mapping between different groups
… there are things in the user needs data such as persistent data
… thinking about the language of the guidelines and applicability

Todd: also for the timed guideline
… is there a non text contrast section as well?

chris: error icons for additional understanding

Sarah: subgroups that currently exist
… asking or compiling a list of things we're looking at
… content resources to use for developing guidelines

chris: need to be w3c or external?

sarah: need to stick with silver resources

chris: I can do that

sarah: next thing would be to go through the worksheet and add a column that is yes/no
… errors/ guideline?
… yes this is an errors guideline

yes/no/maybe

sarah: one way to do it would be to have 2 of us to do that
… get together and do it together

Sukriti: I can do it
… two columns and discuss where there is a disagreement

todd: can do that

sarah: content category, and other content to put in the guidelines outline for the end of the month
… come up with a template

<sarahhorton> https://w3c.github.io/silver/guidelines/

sarah: structured content description

sarah: working meeting not scheduled at the moment

chris: throwing a whole section in and seeing where the gaps are

sarah: if someone wants to host it, would work

todd: can host
… don't mind getting on the collaborative call

chris: doesn't have to be every week

sarah: do one on Friday?

chris: that works

sarah: 11 ET

todd: can do Fridays

sarah: can use the w3c room

sarah: Janina was explaining iOT error flows

Discuss ways to collect input and feedback, e.g., additional error flows

sarah: deliberate about getting feedback
… helpful to catch edge cases Janina mentioned

Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by scribe.perl version 127 (Wed Dec 30 17:39:58 2020 UTC).

Diagnostics

Succeeded: s/Chrispy/Crispy

Maybe present: chris, sarah