13 Jan 2020



Kaz_Ashimura, Michael_McCool, Elena_Reshetova, Tomoaki_Mizushima, Zoltan_Kis


Review minutes

McCool: given we're making all the TF minutes public and some of the TFs would like to have some review periods, we should be consistent
... e.g., two-day review period like the Scripting TF
... (going through the previous minutes)

Previous minutes

McCool: bunch of stuff for todo list
... should clarify that we still need to discuss IETF Anima
... other than that, OK to accept the minutes?

(no objections)

McCool: the minutes accepted


Elena: to have discussion with Zoltan

McCool: are we ready to delete lifecycle portion from the Security note?

Elena: still need to have some more discussion
... some discussion done during the Architecture call last week, though

McCool: can join the Architecture first call this week?

Elena: trying to provide input

McCool: please input our proposal
... and wait until the Architecture draft is done


McCool: next item is discovery
... privacy and security considerations

<McCool> https://github.com/w3c/wot/blob/master/proposals/wot-discovery.md

McCool: the above is the draft Discovery considerations
... use cases to be added
... number of things to be done
... probably need to discuss guidelines first
... that is a heads-up
... need to go back to GoDaddy guys and IETF guys
... also need to see IETF Anima
... by the end of March, would have clearer view
... questions?



PR 150

McCool: still leave it out


Issue 151

McCool: Elena is working on this
... could you make a comment here?
... or a pointer to another issue?

Elena: ok

Issue 149

McCool: still pending

Issue 147

McCool: covered by a PR (150)

Issue 148

McCool: need to sort out terminology
... wondering about the profile discussion
... still done within the Architecture call?

Kaz: yes

McCool: it seems we have security roles, and other roles to be defined within the Architecture
... mapping with specific protocols as well
... still pending

Issue 142

McCool: syntactic change
... "HTTP over TLS" and "CoAP over DTLS"
... "HTTPS" => "HTTP-over-TLS"
... "CoAPS" => "CoAP-over-DTLS"

Issue 143

McCool: assigned myself to this issue
... should ask the PING for a definition or a reference

Issue 125

Elena: can close it

McCool: has been done and the Architecture doc has been published
... consider this closed

CR2 version of WoT Architecture

McCool: close Issue 125

Issue 136

McCool: issue of lifecycle is included in the new WoT WG Charter
... security and privacy sections of the TD and Architecture documents were updated as part of the CR2/PR review cycle
... information lifecycle (and the device lifecycle) are now part of the WoT WG Charter renewal and are being discussed in Architecture
... so this can be closed for now
... questions?


McCool: closes Issue 136
... AOB for today?


McCool: let's think about the other issues next week


Summary of Action Items

Summary of Resolutions

[End of minutes]

Minutes manually created (not a transcript), formatted by David Booth's scribe.perl version 1.154 (CVS log)
$Date: 2020/01/15 11:42:16 $