– DRAFT –
Dataset Exchange Working Group Teleconference

can we reconvene in your evening?

its now 11pm here with summer time - so switching to the same time slot as the plenary on a thursday (for you) - friday for us works..

We can maybe call you via skype?

confirm agenda

+1

<ncar> +1

<LarsG> +1

Minutes from last meeting

<LarsG> https://‌www.w3.org/‌2019/‌09/‌12-dxwgcneg-minutes

+1

<ncar> +1

<LarsG> +1

Resolved: Approve minutes from last meeting

Open Action Items

<LarsG> https://‌www.w3.org/‌2017/‌dxwg/‌track/‌products/‌4

<LarsG> action-193

<trackbot> action-193: Rob Atkinson to Move jmeter test suite to within w3c systems -- due 2018-09-05 -- OPEN

<LarsG> <roba> leave open

<LarsG> action-358

<trackbot> action-358: Rob Atkinson to to convene working session to co-develop common model to match link header data and alternates view requirements. -- due 2019-08-08 -- OPEN

<LarsG> can be closed since we have that data model in the spec

<LarsG> close action-358

<trackbot> Closed action-358.

<LarsG> action-362

<trackbot> action-362: Lars G. Svensson to Propose generalising syntax for the ietf doc to bypass hard requriement for token indicator -- due 2019-09-05 -- OPEN

<LarsG> This has been solved through https://‌github.com/‌w3c/‌dxwg/‌issues/‌290#issuecomment-530328470

<LarsG> close action-362

<trackbot> Closed action-362.

<LarsG> action-371?

<trackbot> action-371: Lars G. Svensson to Mark http implementation as "feature-at-risk" since we don't know what ietf will say about it -- due 2019-09-19 -- OPEN

<LarsG> has been done in the doc

done - can be closed

<LarsG> close action-371

<trackbot> Closed action-371.

<LarsG> action-372?

<trackbot> action-372: Lars G. Svensson to Ping karen and tomb regarding the answer listed in https://github.com/w3c/dxwg/issues/1017#issuecomment-526164813 -- due 2019-09-19 -- OPEN

<LarsG> ping has been done

<LarsG> close action-372

<trackbot> Closed action-372.

<LarsG> action-373?

<trackbot> action-373: Rob Atkinson to Provide text for order of precedence (#505) -- due 2019-09-19 -- PENDINGREVIEW

<LarsG> PR has been actioned

<LarsG> close action-373

<trackbot> Closed action-373.

ncar: issue has been dealt with - ongoing discussion is about implementation in specific platforms

<LarsG> action-374?

<trackbot> action-374: Rob Atkinson to Perform final editorial changes from #575 (https://github.com/w3c/dxwg/issues/575#issuecomment-530362099) -- due 2019-09-19 -- PENDINGREVIEW

ncar: so will put a comment and mark it due for closing

+1

<ncar> +1

<LarsG> +1

<LarsG> Issue #575 has been closed, so we can close here, too

<LarsG> close action-374

<trackbot> Closed action-374.

<LarsG> action-375?

<trackbot> action-375: Lars G. Svensson to Update changelog in ed -- due 2019-09-19 -- OPEN

<LarsG> PR has been merged, so we can close the action

<LarsG> close action-375

<trackbot> Closed action-375.

<LarsG> action-376?

<trackbot> action-376: Rob Atkinson to Create pr to resolve #1042 by showing how data and functional profiles work together -- due 2019-09-19 -- OPEN

<LarsG> https://‌github.com/‌w3c/‌dxwg/‌issues/‌1042

<LarsG> leave open

roba: is this useful?

ncar: yes - i need it for ckan

roba: i will generate a PR for it now pressure is off

Open Pull Requests

<LarsG> https://‌github.com/‌w3c/‌dxwg/‌pulls?utf8=%E2%9C%93&q=is%3Apr+is%3Aopen+label%3Aprofile-negotiation

<LarsG> none open

i dealt with last one this morning

Discussion about state of document v. recent WG mailing list requests

state of document

ncar: comments from riccardo - need to update document status to CR

ncar: changes requested have all been editorial in nature - no substantive issues open
… havent heard back from antoine - does model conflict with PROF? - Can now show with implementation.

Action: ncar: communicate with aisaac and/or WG to show implementation

<trackbot> Created ACTION-379 - Communicate with aisaac and/or wg to show implementation [on Nicholas Car - due 2019-10-24].

LarsG: we seem to be still aiming for Rec?

ncar: yes

LarsG: schedule-wise to aim for Rec needs to be on charter for next WG

ncar: its on the draft charter

roba: from agendas of plenary its not yet finalised

update on IETF

LarsG: no progress - will see Reuben today to see what can be done - draft is in submittable state from my perspective

ncar: has the draft been enhanced?

LarsG: little impact

roba: recent syntax catch is an improvement however.

outbound communications:

ncar: little to report.

implementations

<ncar> the pyLDAPI-based implementation is demonstrated online (incomplete) at https://‌conneg.info/‌mediatypes/‌connegp

<ncar> the implementation's code is https://‌github.com/‌nicholascar/‌mediatypes-dataset

<ncar> the interesting code is pyLDAPI: https://‌pypi.org/‌project/‌pyldapi/

<ncar> connegp utility functions: https://‌pypi.org/‌project/‌connegp/

ncar: the implementation calls out normative text and shows how they are addressed with live links

<ncar> here is the Alt Reps model in action: https://‌conneg.info/‌mediatypes?_profile=all&_mediatype=application/‌ld+json

ncar: the issue have struck - in the alt views data model - need review for the representation that avoids factorial explosiom

<ncar> does this view faithfull use the Alt Reps Data Model: https://‌conneg.info/‌mediatypes/‌object?uri=https:%2F%2Fw3id.org%2Fmediatype%2Ftext%2Fn3&_view=alternates

roba: given the HTML is not machine readable - it conveys the information validly without listing every combination separately
… too much detail to review on the fly - can you provide an email with a targetted review request

ncar: will do
… take home is it all looks implementable

roba: contract renewed at OGC so easier to find time to complete implement.

AOB

proposed: move meeting time two hours earlier

+1

<LarsG> +1

<ncar> +1

Resolved: move meeting time two hours earlier

LarsG: apologies for next week

start new time in 2 weeks