Working draft releases

scribenick: mlagally

Kaz: almost done, but need to finalize check today. Will try publication this week or during weekend using the automatic publishing system

Dev meetup

McCool: demo time is 1 hour starting at 6:30
... we have 2 tables (150*200 (300?))
... please register if you plan to attend
... will upload registration link to wiki later

Kaz: need to bring display or projector for dev meetup?

scribenick: kaz

McCool: probably we should bring our own ones...

Online plugfest

scribenick: mlagally

McCool: we need to capture results
... need to verify results template: does it match to preparation document?
... plug fest was useful, but I did not accomplish what I planned
... we need to use the remaining time until Lyon
... get our results done quickly

Kaz: Fujitsu has already provided a report

McCool: diagram shows Fujitsu's view - we need a common view

Kaz: consider spread sheet suggestion again

McCool: tabular form of results would be good
... perhaps google doc would be good. I will ask Matthias for a template

Lagally: we also need an overview diagram as we had before

Koster: spreadsheet is a good idea

Kaz: start with a diagram and start with generation based on a spreadsheet

Koster: google docs may have an API to generate a graph

Kaz: Matsukura.san's diagram could be a starting point

Koster: do we still continue on the remote setup with a VLAN

McCool: VLAN is really useful for IoT testing

Koster: will provide a note for Federico

McCool: we need an expert to sort out VLAN

Kaz: concrete guideline based on plugfest experience would be useful (VLAN, proxy, network configuration). Perhaps a group note.

McCool: I should capture my configuration setup, however still need to finalize it
... post Lyon we might consider another online plug fest
... I want to have VLAN operational by Lyon

Koster: OCF has some parts of this, if we don't consider security
... new organisations do CoAP interops, Zigbee, LWM2M

McCool: VPN is an interesting mechanism to extend the region

scribenick: kaz

Lagally: we do a lot of conversation on VLAN, etc.
... difference between open Internet and closed secure network
... pretty unlikely VLAN would be really used by people
... so we should not forget that

Koster: what we need to work on includes proxy
... inter-proxy tunnel, etc.
... let's work on that for Lyon and every plugfest

McCool: ok
... a lot of people working on the open Internet with security setting
... we got experience with bearer token, etc.

Lagally: need to have control for both sides
... we should not make assumption

scribenick: mlagally

Lagally: we should not assume that we control the consumer and the producer of data

scribenick: kaz

Koster: we use TD

McCool: there is an issue with TD re-write

scribenick: mlagally

McCool: proxy subgroup could talk about that
... API for standardized thing directories would help

Koster: we had TDs in a thing directory at an earlier plug fest

McCool: I want persistence managed by a directory
... state caching

Koster: inter proxy tunnel has to manage how to do state caching
... need to focus on balance between testing and system design
... directories and semantic lookup
... what's the balance for Lyon plug fest?

McCool: Lyon plug fest folder is currently empty
... consider preparations and results document from online plug fest

<kaz> readme.md

Kaz: main readme.md can be categorized into several services like (1) authentication, (2) directory, (3) proxy, (4) validation, (5) simulator, (6) OCF gateway and (7) network configuration, e.g., VPN

McCool: we need preparation.md, templates, results.csv
... next meeting: all results done, will create a template based on the current one

Kaz: are you moderating the Lyon plug fest as well? I'm asking because it might be a bit tough.

McCool: I can chair both meetings, but if somebody else wants to step forward I'm also good
... will discuss with Matthias and Matsukura on Lyon preparation and results documents
... please register for Lyon, if you have not already done

<kaz> Lyon PlugFest registration results

Kaz: 13 people registered so far

scribenick: kaz

Kaz: btw, Matsukura-san and Sano-san have just joined
... we can ask them if they can give their report during this call
... or the following PF call

scribenick: mlagally

McCool: we need to do a lot more work on scenarios
... compelling application scenarios

scribenick: kaz

Lagally: another proposal from Michael for industry scenario
... also something like Panasonic light automatically turned on/off
... maybe a dry-run before Lyon?
... some sync-up point

Koster: focus on Thing Directory

scribenick: mlagally_

McCool: TD did not work
... Koster and Lagally drive the scenarios

Kaz: we already have working modules and possible scenarios, everybody should contribute

Koster: looking for consistent semantic integration

Task force reports

Koster: we were just publishing the documents

<kaz> [main call adjourned; plugfest call will start in 10 mins]