Comments
From SPARQL Working Group
Contents
Comments to SPARQL documents
- Key to columns
- Owner: WG member who is addressing issues and/or drafting response email
- Response: links to response email and to subsequent acknowledgment from commenter
- Status: should be "open", "Response sent", "ACK", "ACK - OK", or "ACK - NOT OK".
Current policy is to write proposed response in the wiki (below), send to WG mailing list, wait 2-3 business days, get some +1s from the WG, then reply.
Comments after decision Oct-2012 for CR/PR
| Comment | Date | What | Author | Wiki Page | Owner | Status | Response/ack | Affected Documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| JL-6 | 2012-11-28 | application/x-www-url-form-urlencoded | James Leigh | draft response | Greg | Response sent | response | Protocol |
| TH-1 | 2012-11-28 | Sparql protocol WSDL | Tomas Hudec | draft response | LeeF | only needs clarification, no formal response | response | Protocol |
| JS-1 | 2012-11-07 | ORDER BY and literals | John Snelson | response response2 | Greg | only needs clarification, no formal response | response, partial ack, | Query |
| JW-1, JW-2 | 2012-10-23 | Test without data? | Jan Wielemaker | draft response | Axel | Open? (Axel: checking back whether another formal response is expected) | response ack | Query/Test suite |
Comments for query 3LC
| Comment | Date | What | Author | Wiki Page | Owner | Status | Response/ack | Affected Documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RV-9, RV-10 | 2012-09-13 | Property Path usage query | Rob Vesse | draft response | Axel | ACK - OK | informal response to RV-9 response ack | Update |
| NH-5 | 2012-08-13 | Property Path usage query | Nicholas Humfrey | Axel (informally replied by Steve) | ACK - OK | response; ack | Query | |
| NH-4 | 2012-08-13 | 9.1 Property Path Syntax | Nicholas Humfrey | draft response | Andy | Finished | response; ack | Query |
| HK-4 , JC-6 | 2012-08-12 | BIND semantics , BIND semantics (2) | Holger Knublauch / Jeremy Carroll | draft response | Andy | Response sent | response; ack | Query |
| BB-1 | 2012-08-08 | Querying only the default graph from the data store | Barry Bishop | draft response | Axel | ACK - OK | response; ack | Query |
| DB-32 | 2012-07-30 | Question about duplicate triples | David Booth | Andy | General question. | answer; ack | No specific comment. |
Comments received after 2012-05-29 Consolidation
| Comment | Date | What | Author | Wiki Page | Owner | Status | Response/ack | Affected Documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DB-31 | 2012-07-20 | CONSTRUCTing illegal triples should be optional | David Booth | draft response | Andy | Finished | response -- ack | Query |
| JA-1 | 2012-08-01 | Re: SPARQL 1.1 Update - Comments | james anderson | Axel | No reaction needed | Update? (is more on future work item CompositeDatasets) | ||
| DB-30 | 2012-07-20 | Serializing datetime | David Booth | draft response | Andy | Finished | response | Query |
| DB-29 | 2012-07-20 | Serializing xsd:decimal, xsd:float, xsd:double | David Booth | draft response | Andy | Finished | response - ack | Query |
| JL-5 | 2012-07-06 | SPARQL BINDING/VALUES Keyword | James Leigh | draft response | Andy | Done | response - ack | Query |
| PW-2 | 2012-06-30 | Inconsistancy between documentation and conformance tests with respect to STRBEFORE() & STRAFTER() | Peter Waher | Andy | answered | response | Query | |
| DB-28 | 2012-06-02 | FROM and FROM NAMED: To fetch or not to fetch? | David Booth | comment response | Greg | Response sent | response | Query |
| DB-27 | 2012-06-27 | Editorial: small clarification of LOAD | David Booth | response | Paul | Done | ack | Update |
| DB-26 | 2012-06-26 | Ambiguity about whether graphs are created or deleted | David Booth | response | Paul | ACK - OK | ack | Update |
| RV-8 | 2012-06-19 | Comment on SPARQL 1.1 Test Cases | Rob Vesse | Lee | answered | response | Tests | |
| PW-1 | 2012-06-03 | Default and named datasets in federated queries | Peter Waher | response draft response2 | Carlos Buil | ACK-OK | response Peter's reply ... ack | Federated Query |
| BD-3 | 2012-06-02 | small erratum for SPARQL UPDATE 1.1 | Bob DuCharme | Axel | ACK - OK | response ack | Update (editorial) | |
| JL-4 (cont. from JL-2, JL-3) | 2012-05-08 | Indirect Graph Identification | James Leigh | Sandro | ACK-OK | Last msg (ACK), resp. editorial change | Graph Store Protocol |
Consolidation of 2012-05-29
This section is all the comments in the following sections that are marked "Open" as of 2012-05-29.
| Comment | Date | What | Author | Wiki Page | Owner | Status | Response/ack | Affected Documents |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| KK-15 | 2012-05-17 | "Fresh" blank nodes vs. RDF Merge in Update | Kjetil Kjernsmo | Comment Response KK-15 | Axel | ACK - OK | response ack | Update |
| SA-3 | 2012-04-17 | BindingClause for Subqueries | Stephen Allen | Comment Response SA-3 | Andy | Response sent | response - ack | Query |
| AH-1 | 2012-03-28 | SPARQL 1.1 comments relating to BINDINGS (also minor editorial comments) | Aidan Hogan | Comment Response AH-1 | Andy | Response sent | response | Query |
| AD-1 | 2012-03-13 | Multiple BINDING clauses in SPARQL queries | Alexander Dutton | Comment Response AD-1 | Andy | Response sent | response - ack | Query |
| DRD-1 | 2012-02-17 | Comment on Path / PName clash and Turtle impact | David Robillard | Comment Response DRD-1 | Andy | Response sent | response | Query |
| PF-1 | 2012-01-23 | Direct Graph Identification | Philip Fennell | Comment Response PF-1 | chime | ACK - OK | response ack | Graph Store Protocol |
| DW-1 | 2011-12-08 | SPARQL, PATCH and IE's XMLHttpRequest Object | David Wood | Comment Response DW-1 | Chime | ACK - OK | response ack | Protocol? Graph Store? |
| DB-5 | 2011-07-29 | SPARQL 1.1 Update - Comments | David Booth | Comment response DB-5 | Paul | Done | ack | Update |
| SA-1 | 2011-07-15 | SPARQL XML to HTML XSL Performance Bug | Stephen Allen | Lee | Open | ?? | ||
| RC-1 | 2010-09-29 | SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: HTTP status code for QueryRequestRefused | Richard Cyganiak | Lee | ACK OK ( | Protocol 1.1 | ||
| KK-6, GR-3 | 2011-01-14 (first message in thread) | HTTP DELETE operation | Kjetil Kjernsmo, Gregg Reynolds | Chime? | Response ack | SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol | ||
| RC-2 | 2010-09-29 | SPARQL 1.1 Protocol: Format of fault messages | Richard Cyganiak | Lee | ACK - OK | response ack | Protocol 1.1 | |
| GR-4 | 2011-01-26 | Dataset, Graph Store, etc. | Gregg Reynolds | Draft response | Chime | Response | ? | |
| KK-8, KK-9 | 2011-02-02,07 | Re: Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol Working Draft 14 October 2010 | Kjetil Kjernsmo | Chime | ACKs Greg, Kjetil ("referred to older comments") | SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol | ||
| JC-4 JC-5 | 2011-02-16,17 | s/URI/IRI/ in http://www.w3.org/TR/sparql11-http-rdf-update/#indirect-graph-identification | Jeremy Carroll | Chime | JC-4 addressed as per 22 Oct 2012 (CVS) Editors' Draft | SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol | ||
| KK-13 | 2011-03-25 | Comment on "Dataset HTTP Protocol": Uses of "indirect" | Kjetil Kjernsmo | Draft response: CommentResponse:KK-13 | Chime | Response sent ACK | SPARQL 1.1 Graph Store HTTP Protocol | |
| MLR-1 | 2011-04-01 | HTTP status codes when no result is responded | Markus Luczak-Rösch | Lee | ACK OK | SPARQL 1.1 Protocol | ||
| Demairy-1 | 2011-05-04 | File not found: http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-sparql-XMLres/result2.xsd | Erwan Demairy | Lee | Open | SPARQL 1.1 Protocol | ||
| DBeckett-1 | 2010-12-05 | Aggregates, Bindings and other comments | David Becket | Draft response DBeckett-1 | SteveH | Response sent | response | SPARQL 1.1 query and Fed extension |
| KK-8, KK-9 | 2011-02-02,07 | Re: Comments on SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol Working Draft 14 October 2010 | Kjetil Kjernsmo | Chime | Duplicate of entry above | SPARQL 1.1 Uniform HTTP Protocol | ||
| FS-1 | 2011-06-27 | Syntax problem in Fed document | Fernando Silva | Draft response | Carlos Buil | Response sent | response | SPARQL 1.1 Federation Extension |
See Comments_2012-05-29 for all comments in the consolidation.
