See also: IRC log
dale, where are you?
<monica> good morning
<dmoberg> at an omg meeting. sorry looked away for a second
<cferris> scribe: charlton
minutes adopted
paulc: not meeting next week
... Dublin F2F Jul 17-19
... PR schedule
... sent draft transition to PR request to WG
paulc: prasad reporting for editors
prasad: implemented resolution for issue
4672
... PR drafts refreshed by Felix
... only 2 other guidelines issues, one pending open issue
... action item 319 - done
... action item 318 - discussed on last editors telcon
... resulted in open issues
... to resolve in order to make progress
... as soon as resolved, editors to implement
... as such AIs 318, 319 are done
AI 318 and 319 are done
paulc: 304, 306 outstanding on Chris Ferris
... 318, 319, 320, 321 and 324 are all done
... all others are open
paulc: minor changes to dashboard as more
results are reported
... thank you felix for your due diligence on reflecting this data
... looking for vendors to public results of round 5 results
... Axway and Layer7 have published round 5 results in addition to IBM
cferris: thanks to those who have continued to endeavour on this
<fsasaki> +1 to cferris!
paulc: Action-320 - leave for WG to respond to
Sergey
... Issue 4762 - Felix recommends to treat as PR issue
<abbie> +abbie
paulc: thought we'd handle media types issue in
CR
... thanks for remembering that felix
... as soon as get to PR, mark 4762 as PR issue
<cferris> ACTION: Chris to change 4762 to PR issue once transition to PR has occurred [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/06/27-ws-policy-minutes.html#action01]
<trackbot> Created ACTION-327 - Change 4762 to PR issue once transition to PR has occurred [on Christopher Ferris - due 2007-07-04].
<paulc> Namespace="http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing" />
monica: two examples concerning this
... with this link
<Fabian> section 4.5
monica: the namespace s/b ...
<Fabian> a more complete quote:
<Fabian> (14) <sp:Header
<Fabian> Namespace="http://www.w3.org/2005/08/addressing" />
paulc: link is valid
monica: reference (in Framework, both examples and references) for WSP
<paulc> xmlns:sp="http://docs.oasis-open.org/ws-sx/ws-securitypolicy/200702
monica: reference to WS-Security Policy
... have the right link, but the reference mis-describe this
fsasaki: December 2005 should be April 2007
<monica> 8 December 2005.
change to 30 April 2007
paulc: i think we can deal with this in the
PR
... makes sense not to change this - WSP is out for OASIS ratification,
ballot still open for three more days
<paulc> [WS-SecurityPolicy] WS-SecurityPolicy v1.0, A. Nadalin, M. Gudgin, A. Barbir, and H. Granqvist, Editors. Organization for the Advancement of Structured Information Standards, 8 December 2005. Available at http://docs.oasis-open.org/ws-sx/ws-securitypolicy/200702.
paulc: any objection to making the edits
now?
... actually, other problem is if you change the dates, you need to change
them for WS-Security Policy 1.2
... changing this w/o due diligence is the wrong thing to do
monica: make it a PR issue then?
paulc: yes
<fsasaki> agree with proposal to have this as an PR issue
paulc: update WS-Security Policy reference to most recent OASIS version
<cferris> ACTION: Monica to open PR issue regarding the security policy reference [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/06/27-ws-policy-minutes.html#action02]
<trackbot> Created ACTION-328 - Open PR issue regarding the security policy reference [on Monica Martin - due 2007-07-04].
<prasad> This applies to both Framework, Attachment, Primer and Guidelines BTW
paulc: any other comments?
cferris: acknowledge written items of support for transition to PR
<dmoberg> yes here
<dmoberg> but on mute
Tom Rutt (Fujitsu), William Henry (IONA), Abbie Barbir (Nortel), Dale Moberg (Axway)
and Frederick Hirsch (Nokia)
<cferris> Frederick (Nokia)
written items of support for transition to PR
companies present on the telcon
cferris: abbie barbir (nortel), charlton
barreto (adobe), sergey b (iona), paul cotton (microsoft), chris ferris
(ibm), dave orchard (bea), glen daniels (sonic), mark little (jboss), monica
martin (sun), dale moberg (axway), dan roth (microsoft), felix sasaki (w3c),
fabian ritzmann (sun), prasad yendluri (webMethods), yakov sverdlov (ca)
... don't see wso2, oracle on the telcon
paulc: do the members on the telcon, and given the support from those who wrote in, does anyone object from requesting the director to transition to PR for the framework and attachments specs?
no objections
<cferris> RESOLUTION: no objections to requesting transition to PR for framework and attachments specs
<fsasaki> applause!
<dmoberg> clap clap
<jeffm> hi
<jeffm> no objection
hear hear
<jeffm> no objection to transitioning
all members present (except wso2) have agreed to the transition
oracle represented by Jeff Mischkinsky
wso2 and fujitsu not present
issue 4376 to be addressed at Dublin F2F
paulc: monica and asir took their comments and
assigned them across individual issues opened by MaryAnn
... w/o asir or maryann here, uncertain if we can process these issues
... in particular maryann''s issues 322, 323 and 325
... did have action on bug 4566
... asir and toufic made progress on this, and it is done, but neither asir
nor toufic are here today
... can i propose that we adjourn today's meeting and carry over these AIs to
the next meeting?
cferris: no suggestions w.r.t. this proposal
no objection
paulc: chris to chair on July11th
<cferris> http://www.w3.org/2002/ws/policy/participation/attendance.html
paulc: will hold meeting with director on
monday
... will convey results to WG as soon as possible
happy canada day paul, abbie, daveo