There are 4 comments (sorted by their types, and the section they are about).
substantive comments
Comment LC-2590
Commenter: John Simpson <john@consumerwatchdog.org> on behalf of Do-Not-Track Community Group (archived message ) Context: Document as a whole
Status: open
proposal
pending
resolved_yes
resolved_no
resolved_partial
other
assigned to Nobody
Auerbach, Dan
Bateman, Adrian
Berkower, Elise
Bian, Chao
Bielova, Nataliia
Bos, Bert
Bowman, Neil
Brioche, Rudy
Caprio, Dan
Cargill, Carl
Chao, Qu
Chester, Jeffrey
Colando, Amy
Cunche, Mathieu
Doty, Nick
Fette, Ian
Fielding, Roy
Gao, Hanrui
Glueck, Sue
Gombert, Alanna
Grant, Euan
Hall, Joseph
Harvey, Sean
Heffernan, Ronan
Hu, Bin
Israel, Susan
Jaffe, Daniel
Jaffe, Jeff
Krauss, Simon
Kulick, Brad
Kwong, Kennie
Li, Jessica
McDonald, Aleecia
Min, Yue
Neuenschwander, Erik
O'Connor, Theresa
O'Neill, Mike
Riordan-Butterworth, Brendan
Scarborough, Keith
Schauf, Thomas
Schunter, Matthias
Seltzer, Wendy
Sherman, Rob
Singer, David
Smith, Kevin
Smith, Michael[tm]
Sullivan, Bryan
Tao, Weihua
tian, caten
Tien, Lee
Toner, Alan
Toubiana, Vincent
Turransky, Alan
van Eijk, Rob
van Holst, Walter
Wagner, Frank
West, Heather
West, Heather
Wiley, Shane
Wu, Jing
Yan, Xuemei
Zhang, Yuanzhou
Zhao, Yangguang
Zhou, Horace
Type: substantive
editorial
typo
question
general comment
undefined
Comment :Third, the document frequently uses the term “cross-site tracking,†and we think it should simply refer to “tracking.â€
Related issues: (space separated ids)
WG Notes:
Resolution: (Please make sure the resolution is adapted for public consumption)
Comment LC-2591
Commenter: John Simpson <john@consumerwatchdog.org> on behalf of Do-Not-Track Community Group (archived message ) Context: Closed Issues ISSUE-2: What is the meaning of DNT (Do Not T...
Status: open
proposal
pending
resolved_yes
resolved_no
resolved_partial
other
assigned to Nobody
Auerbach, Dan
Bateman, Adrian
Berkower, Elise
Bian, Chao
Bielova, Nataliia
Bos, Bert
Bowman, Neil
Brioche, Rudy
Caprio, Dan
Cargill, Carl
Chao, Qu
Chester, Jeffrey
Colando, Amy
Cunche, Mathieu
Doty, Nick
Fette, Ian
Fielding, Roy
Gao, Hanrui
Glueck, Sue
Gombert, Alanna
Grant, Euan
Hall, Joseph
Harvey, Sean
Heffernan, Ronan
Hu, Bin
Israel, Susan
Jaffe, Daniel
Jaffe, Jeff
Krauss, Simon
Kulick, Brad
Kwong, Kennie
Li, Jessica
McDonald, Aleecia
Min, Yue
Neuenschwander, Erik
O'Connor, Theresa
O'Neill, Mike
Riordan-Butterworth, Brendan
Scarborough, Keith
Schauf, Thomas
Schunter, Matthias
Seltzer, Wendy
Sherman, Rob
Singer, David
Smith, Kevin
Smith, Michael[tm]
Sullivan, Bryan
Tao, Weihua
tian, caten
Tien, Lee
Toner, Alan
Toubiana, Vincent
Turransky, Alan
van Eijk, Rob
van Holst, Walter
Wagner, Frank
West, Heather
West, Heather
Wiley, Shane
Wu, Jing
Yan, Xuemei
Zhang, Yuanzhou
Zhao, Yangguang
Zhou, Horace
Type: substantive
editorial
typo
question
general comment
undefined
Comment :As noted earlier, we do not wish to prevent user-agent vendors from shipping with a default of DNT: 1, and we have some concern that the current language may do so. We believe that the current statement of ISSUE-4 permits user-agents to ship with DNT enabled. We equally believe that user-agents should not ship with a default of DNT:0.
Related issues: (space separated ids)
WG Notes:
Resolution: (Please make sure the resolution is adapted for public consumption)
Comment LC-2593
Commenter: John Simpson <john@consumerwatchdog.org> on behalf of Do-Not-Track Community Group (archived message ) Context: Closed Issues ISSUE-2: What is the meaning of DNT (Do Not T... (Resolution of ISSUE-40 in particular)
Status: open
proposal
pending
resolved_yes
resolved_no
resolved_partial
other
assigned to Nobody
Auerbach, Dan
Bateman, Adrian
Berkower, Elise
Bian, Chao
Bielova, Nataliia
Bos, Bert
Bowman, Neil
Brioche, Rudy
Caprio, Dan
Cargill, Carl
Chao, Qu
Chester, Jeffrey
Colando, Amy
Cunche, Mathieu
Doty, Nick
Fette, Ian
Fielding, Roy
Gao, Hanrui
Glueck, Sue
Gombert, Alanna
Grant, Euan
Hall, Joseph
Harvey, Sean
Heffernan, Ronan
Hu, Bin
Israel, Susan
Jaffe, Daniel
Jaffe, Jeff
Krauss, Simon
Kulick, Brad
Kwong, Kennie
Li, Jessica
McDonald, Aleecia
Min, Yue
Neuenschwander, Erik
O'Connor, Theresa
O'Neill, Mike
Riordan-Butterworth, Brendan
Scarborough, Keith
Schauf, Thomas
Schunter, Matthias
Seltzer, Wendy
Sherman, Rob
Singer, David
Smith, Kevin
Smith, Michael[tm]
Sullivan, Bryan
Tao, Weihua
tian, caten
Tien, Lee
Toner, Alan
Toubiana, Vincent
Turransky, Alan
van Eijk, Rob
van Holst, Walter
Wagner, Frank
West, Heather
West, Heather
Wiley, Shane
Wu, Jing
Yan, Xuemei
Zhang, Yuanzhou
Zhao, Yangguang
Zhou, Horace
Type: substantive
editorial
typo
question
general comment
undefined
Comment :These issues appear related. We strongly prefer that DNT settings persist across sessions until modified by the user. We do not object to the standard’s permissiveness here as a technical matter—when the DNT header is sent, servers need not “remember†previous sessions—but DNT will be significantly more valuable to users, and will better meet users’ expectations, if DNT need not reset each time users visit a website. A non-normative reference about the value of persistence may be appropriate here.
Related issues: (space separated ids)
WG Notes:
Resolution: (Please make sure the resolution is adapted for public consumption)
Add a comment .